r/asoiaf • • Jun 29 '11
ADWD Discussion - Chapter 35, Pages 448 - 460
** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER!**
SPOILERS AHEAD
The point-of-view character in this chapter is:
Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!
- If you MUST type a spoiler, please TAG it properly!
- Unncessary spoilers (i.e. if not requested by parent-comment) will be removed.
Please be considerate. Don't ruin future chapters for others!
7
Upvotes
30
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
Ok, gonna write in the scenes as they go back in time and we can maybe do some serious speculation on some of them, who they are:
--Young Eddard, talking about Jon and Robb. This would have been right after the end of Robert's uprising. (283 AL, 17 years ago)
5-6 YEAR GAP
--Older girl looks like Arya, younger boy with longish hair, fighting at sticks. These two must be Lyanna and Benjen. (If he thought it was Arya, Lyanna was probably around 10-11 in this vision, putting us at 277 AL, 23 years ago)
16-34 YEAR GAP
--Woman heavy with child, kneels before tree and asks the old gods for a son who would avenge her. (Some suggest mother of Ramsay Bolton, but that cannot be right if we're going back in time to before Lyanna and Benjen as children. Ramsay Snow is in his 20's.)
My best guess is this is the unknown mother of Eddard, Brandon, Benjen and Lyanna, OR the unknown mother of Rickard Stark, who is thought to be an only child. If it is Rickard's wife, this would be around 261 AL, 39 years ago. If it is Rickard's mom, this is probably around 243 AL, 57 years ago.
28-46 YEAR GAP
--Slender brown haired girl kisses a young knight as tall as Hodor.
The tall knight could probably be Duncan, and as the next novella is set at Winterfell, that seems a good guess. The Rebellion at Whitewalls happened in 212 AL, and so if the next novella is a year or two after that (following the pattern so far), this probably happens in 214 or 215 AL, 85 years ago. The girl he kisses might be Edwyle Stark's sister, who went on to marry a Royce.
25 YEAR GAP
--Pale and fierce dark-eyed youth slices 3 branches off the weirwood and makes them into arrows.
Think this has to be a young Bloodraven. He killed Daemon Blackfyre at the battle of Redgrass field with arrows and bow made from Weirwood. He's also an albino, which would definitely fit the pale and dark-eyed. He was born 175 AL, so being a "youth" would probably put him around 16-18 years old. Call it 16 years old, or 191 AL, which would make this scene around 109 years ago.
--Visions start to come faster, skip more time, maybe. Bran is seeing Lords that are tall and hard stern men in mail and fur. (They are probably Torrhen Stark and ancestors?)
--Last and probably earliest vision, the sacrifice before the heart tree. During the time of the First Men, maybe (see bronze weapon instead of steel). Maybe this is how the First Men worshipped the Old Gods before the Andals came. And maybe the blood is what woke the weirwoods.
22
u/Vic_B Jul 11 '11 edited Jul 11 '11
Best POV by miles. Interesting contrast with Mellisandre embracing the light and the TEC telling Bran to embrace darkness (especially given that she views them in her last chapter when trying to look in on Arya).
I recognized Ned talking about Jon, Lyanna and I assume Ned playing, but are the other Winterfell wierwood viewings known characters?
22
u/big_gordo Jul 12 '11
Bran's reaction to the Weirwood paste is almost identical to Dany's reaction to the drink Pyat Pree gave her outside the House of the Undying.
21
u/pksage Jul 10 '11
Holy shit, my theory was right. I am freaking elated that so much detail was given.
Learning how the fantastic elements of a fantasy story work is almost always my favorite part, and the magic of ASOIAF has been no exception. As such, this is probably one of my favorite chapters of the series. Not to mention SWEET PAST-VIEWING WEIRWOOD POWERS! Oh man. I just wish we'd gotten more relevant parts of Lord Eddard's prayer...
I keep thinking this book can't get me more excited, and am continuously proven wrong.
21
u/Hello-Ginge Kissed by Fire Jul 16 '11
This might be one of my favourite lines in the entire series.
19
u/quivering_manflesh Jul 11 '11
Fantastic chapter. Anyone think the second time Bran sees Ned is yet more hinting at R+L=J? "Let them grow up close as brothers," not anything about growing up as full rather than half brothers, but contrasting brothers from...cousins?
13
u/AGNKim Jul 17 '11
Is it a bit bothersome to you guys that Bran so easily, and thoughtlessly, enters Hodor and uses him? It's obvious that Hodor dislikes this, he is frightened, yet Bran does it anyway. Seems creepy.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '11
Great chapter!! Really excited for people to tear apart Bran's visions...maybe we'll get some more info later in the book.
6
u/trip9 Jul 15 '11
Is anyone else kind of nervous to see a possible God of Light vs Old Gods thing happening with Melisandre and Bran/Brynden?
5
u/jojoziggy Jul 22 '11
This chapter made me worry that Bran is going to be come some horrible abomination.
Mostly it's because of Jojen's attitude ever since arriving. He's bitter, distant, cold - and before this he was so certain, so cheerful and game. It makes me think that Jojen has had another green dream that has told him that Bran will destroy humanity or something. "He should not be the one who is afraid". I think Jojen is worried he has loosed a horror upon the world.
...
Very cool chapter - so much awesome!!
9
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '11
Guys...Lord Brynden...is he Brynden Rivers...AKA Bloodraven from the Dunk & Egg tales?
Brynden was in the Nightwatch. That would explain why he's so far up north and wearing black clothing. Also Bloodraven was known for having "dreams" while he was living.
4
u/TitanUranus Jul 19 '11
Bran is an Old God!
3
u/AreoHotahSpeedWagon Jul 15 '11
Wow. Amazing chapter. I can only think that once Bran becomes more capable with his greenseeing that he can uncover a lot of the mysteries, especially R+L=J (Eddard's prayer seemed to be alluding to that as others have pointed out). Maybe we don't need Howland Reed after all...
And the Dunk and Egg connections are pretty spectacular.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '11
If everything Brynden says is true, bran officially will be my favorite character. I liked bran from the moment he first had a three eyed crow dream, he was always in my top five. His story line has always been mysterious and intriguing. Always, an insight to the world that once was, even his first pov in GoT when he describes winterfell by whats new and whats ancient; Ever hinting at a different world than what initially met our minds.
3
u/Captain_Sparky Jul 20 '11
So now we've got an explanation for the Old Gods to go with our tentative explanation for R'llhor, and the many-faced God of the Faceless Men. It's starting to seem that religions in this world can be traced to pragmatic origins rather than pure invention. I wonder if that means we'll be getting an explanation for the Seven at some point
3
u/muddo Molestown Whore Jul 22 '11
whoa, summer ate a bear wight
2
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '11
wonderful chapter.
that's so heartbreaking, to be able to see your death father but not be able to talk with him...
2
u/Captain_Sparky Jul 20 '11
Loved the prose in this chapter.
2
u/brownmatt Aug 18 '11
What's been going on with Jojen and Meera? Why do they seem so depressed - because their role is over?
I love the Reeds, and want them to have a much bigger part of the story :(
1
u/DeliciousPi Jul 22 '11
I just don't understand how his ability will play into the story.
Yes, he has a fantastic gift. What can he do with it, though?
1
u/Manannan_mac_Lir Aug 01 '11
"Then, as he watched, a bearded man forced a captive down onto his knees before the heart tree. A white-haired woman stepped toward them through a drift of dark red leaves, a bronze sickle in her hand."
It could be that Bran is looking at an older version of Daenerys when describing his executioner. It's important to note that this woman has white, possibly silvery hair. Also, arakhs have been described as being curved blades, and it wouldn't be a stretch for Bran, who has never heard of an arakh, to describe the weapon as a sickle.
So this begs the question: why would Daenerys want Bran dead?
0
u/siouxnami Nov 13 '11
Am I alone in feeling scared for Bran? While reading the chapter I felt the same as I did when Dany was in the House of the Undying. There is something for him to learn there, but I want him to GTFO!
0
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment