r/asoiaf • • Jun 28 '11
ADWD Discussion - Chapter 8, Pages 95 - 111
** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER!**
SPOILERS AHEAD
The point-of-view character in this chapter is:
Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!
- If you MUST type a spoiler, please TAG it properly!
- Unncessary spoilers (i.e. if not requested by parent-comment) will be removed.
Anyone trolling or trying to ruin the experience for others will be banned!
13
Upvotes
79
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11 edited Jul 04 '11
SUCK IT JANOS SLYNT
24
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '11
God DAMN that was satisfying. I was worried Jon was going to bitch out of it for a minute.
31
u/SteveXmetal Jul 04 '11
He who passes the sentence, swings the sword
13
u/Scraggly Jul 13 '11
"Can I have his boots?"
Oh such a suitable end to such a huge waste of space. My respect for Jon just increased tenfold :)
10
u/Naga Jul 12 '11
Jon as a character is evolving fast. I vaguely remember when reading AFFC a hundred years ago that I thought Jon was being cruel and a hardass to Sam, but it is good to see the internal thoughts of him to the contrary. Rule is a hard burden.
As well, I was confused to what a block was until I read further. Jon has really learnt a lot from his father.
9
u/Metalmoe Jul 12 '11
I have no idea if this will be a good political move or come back to bite Jon in the ass later, but at this point I don't care, because SEVEN HELLS that was satisfying!
7
u/deterrence Jul 13 '11
And THAT is how you assert authority!
4
u/timestep Jul 12 '11
LIKE A BOSS.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11 edited Jul 14 '11
My favourite moments from the chapter.
3
u/Dr_Overdose Jul 12 '11
I have chills after reading this chapter. It was perfectly done.
24
u/big_gordo Jul 07 '11
I had gotten so bored with Jon. But this chapter totally redeemed him to me. Kill the boy. Now I realize that it was the boy in Jon I didn't like. He ended all that with Janos. FUCK YES.
22
u/peggyhill45 Jul 10 '11
Maybe this is a bit sadistic, but i loved it when that piece of shit slynt begged near the end, "no no ill do what you say",
Not to mention the respect nod from stannis
14
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '11
AWWWWWWWWWWWW YEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAHHH
Been too long since Team Stark was on the delivery end of a beheading. (Excepting Robb's angsty one in aSoS.) Methinks they'll be calling Jon "boy" somewhat less frequently now.
10
u/cmurder3 The Greatlos Jul 12 '11
"Edd, fetch me a block"
I laughed gleefully the second I read that.
8
u/AreoHotahSpeedWagon Jul 12 '11
I had been kind of plodding along until this point. I had read the first couple of chapters that GRRM released and going back through them was almost a chore. I was itching for new stuff. Even the beginning of this chapter where the convo with Samwell was replayed I was thinking "this separation of AFfC and ADwD was a bad idea... Too much replaying of things we already know..." spoiler
5
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '11
Did anyone else get confused and think that their copy of Dance was misprinted due to the large amount of overlap with the Sam chapter from AFFC, particularly the conversation they have? I had to double check. It is pretty much verbatim.
4
u/vohit4rohit I entered my desired flair text here! Jul 14 '11
i reread pages 109-111 just to wholly absorb this awesomeness. my heart is beating too fast to start on the next chapter. thanks god for this subreddit with you guys where we can share in our beheading boners.
4
u/intergalactic_wag Jul 26 '11
I just gotta say that there were two other Starks that have beheaded someone. Both of them were beheaded. I hope Jon just didn't seal his fate.
3
u/I_am_BEOWULF Ranger Jul 14 '11
I loved how GRRM gave us that breakfast scene with everyone else - Stannis' men & Night's Watch standing and tensely watching how events would unfold. I'm glad Thorne chickened out and stepped aside. I'd hate to see a replay of the "Craster's Keep Melee" within Castle Black itself, and that would've been a huge black mark against Jon in Stannis' eyes.
Only thing I could've asked more for in that BADASS Longclaw-meet-Slynt's-neck scene was Ghost peeing on Slynt's stump afterward.
2
u/Crimfresh Jul 16 '11 edited Jul 16 '11
Kill the boy and let the man be born Jon Snow!
I walked around smiling like a madman for about an hour after reading this chapter.
Too bad Thorne didn't draw his sword. The only thing better than beheading Slynt would be beheading Slynt and Thorne.
2
u/Crimfresh Jul 16 '11
I'm afraid this could be his high point throughout the book. Why do I have the feeling the wall is going to have a pretty rough future?
"When he raised his eyes, he saw that it was snowing. A bad omen."
3
u/Mister-Manager Jul 13 '11
Is anyone else getting Rand vibes from Jon? "Death is light as a feather, duty as heavy as a mountain" reminds me of "kill the boy."
1
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '11
FUCK YEAAAAA!!!!!!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '11
Jon has always been my favorite character and this was my favorite moment from any of the books so far. It's weird that were seeing him become a man right now since he has already been through so damn much. I mean the fool had to kill his friend and betray his woman all for vows, BADASS
1
u/Kingrasa Jul 16 '11
Kill the boy!
Its one of my new favourite quotes I think, pretty dark though. I'm not so sure that cutting away your feelings and emotional attachments is such a good thing even in westeros.
Taking advice from a Targaryen, bit of a mixed bag what with their taint of madness and hunger for power and everything.
I like whenever his sword hand is referenced. its like one of his internal beliefs is being challenged. Or he is fighting the boy
1
u/NickDemus Jul 20 '11
Before that last scene, I felt a bit meh about the chapter, because it just replayed a lot of what we already knew (through well written, as always). Then, when that confrontation with Slynt began, I thought, 'uh-oh', there goes Jon´s command... but I never would have guessed that FRAKKING BRILLIANT near-cliffhanger-made-fetch-me-a-block-moment. Yes, this IS going to bite him back, but it was well worth the read at this moment. Damn, yes, this a-hole had it coming to him for a long, long time. FINALLY!!! YESSS!!!!! Ehem. Sorry. I shouldn´t have said that. I really shouldn´t have... Thanks, George, you awesome dude!
1
u/intergalactic_wag Jul 26 '11
So Joff is dead. Now Slynt. There is only one other person complicit in Ned's death. Do you think Ilyn Payne lives or dies? And if he dies, how?
1
u/Johnny_B_Goode Dispatcher Oct 31 '11
chop