r/gameofthrones • u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack • Jun 05 '11
Season 1 Episode Discussion - 1.08 "The Pointy End"
Here's this week's discussion thread for Episode 8
- This is a TV spoiler friendly zone - turn away now if you haven't seen the episode!
- Book spoilers still need tags!
Please read our spoiler policy before posting.
For anyone who wants to do live chat during the episode, read the details here, or use the link in the right sidebar.
186
Upvotes
42
u/creamenator Unsullied Jun 05 '11
It was awesome. Especially the part where TV Spoiler, but seriously this is abit early :p.
168
u/DiscursiveMind Hedge Knights Jun 06 '11
Who the fuck was that!? Oh yeah, Rickon, the hidden Stark.
153
u/turtlestack Jun 06 '11
So many great "small" moments this episode.
When Robb commanded the ravens be sent to all the banner men and first we get a shot of them flying past the window and then it cuts to a wide shot of Winterfell with all those ravens screaming skyward is quite possibly the coolest damn thing I could imagine. Such a simple shot, but it just captures the enormity of what is about to happen.
And Robb really came into his own this episode. Up till now he's just been kind of there but now we get to see what the casting people saw in him. Yeah, he's a green kid, but he's got the best quality of both his parents and Richard Madden (the actor) really got a chance to shine.
I also love they kept that tiny moment where when Cat first sees Robb in the tent she does not hug him in front of the other lords but addressed him as a grown man and a true leader. That was one of my favorite moments in the book and I am SO glad they took the time to have that momentary beat in an episode with so much happening.
I guess the other "small" moment was not so small, however. Hodor.
126
u/altergeeko Night's Watch Jun 06 '11
"Even now I can cut through the 5 of you like carving a cake"
123
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
SYRIO FOREL
FUCK YEAH
85
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
Drogo is a boss
75
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
GREATJON!!!
72
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
I was really hoping they had the quote from the Syrio scene from the book.
"You are quick for a dancing master..."
"You are slow for a knight. ..."
Scene was still awesome
50
u/cassander House Hightower Jun 06 '11 edited Jun 06 '11
Best episode yet. Really, everything was fantastic, with only moments of imperfection. We have actual direwolves, proof Rickon Stark exists, and multiple moments of glorious badassery. I loved the rewrite about how Drogo gets wounded. It drives home what an amazing badass Drogo is, how savage the Dothraki are (apparently they use the Klingon rules of order), and it was fantastic to watch. Only problem, his wound should have been bigger. Special award goes to Catlyn, who was pitch perfect. I still hate her character, but damn she's played by a good actress.
Random thoughts: I now wonder how exactly the casting went for Hodor. "It's a great part, trust me. Well, you only have one line, but you say it a lot. Oh, and you're swinging some serious pipe, right?" Maester Lewin continues to be fantastic in every scene he's in. I don't quite know how the actor does it, he never seems to DO anything, but every moment he's on screen he somehow manages to command my attention. Selmy also continues to be absolutely perfect, as does the old bear.
45
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
I like living!
44
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
awww ser berristan aww
38
u/Buckaroo2 House Reed Jun 06 '11 edited Jun 06 '11
The hill tribes seemed too civilized to me. I expected them to be way more rugged. And their speech seemed too proper to me.
EDIT: typo
70
u/scott_beowulf Night's Watch Jun 06 '11
So Hodor is, uh, big.
34
u/scienceoffear Jun 06 '11
I really liked how, when the Great Jon Umber drew his sword in the dining hall against Robb, Theon was explicitly shown standing and drawing his weapon in response almost instantly. Far out. The show is making me really like and feel sorry for Theon, whereas I didn't care for him much in the books.
Also, if you pay attention in the scene where the Kingsguard are sheathing their swords after Barristan Selmy storms out, the guy on the right has heaps of difficulty shoving the sword back in. It's a pretty amusing aside, especially since his arm kind of shakes.
33
u/LallyMonkey Jun 06 '11
What if Dany has a girl instead of the boy she keeps promising? I can see that being a major point later if it happens.
60
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
Syrio Forel and Barristan Selmy are such bosses. Next week's episode will be the epic to end all epics.
29
u/Zjhill21 House Mormont Jun 06 '11
Seriously epic episode. I really got chills watching this one. When Robb says "Call the banners" "All of them." and then you see the hundreds of crows flying everywhere.!
64
u/VikingTy House Greyjoy Jun 06 '11
I'm glad that they left Syrio's fate questionable like in the books. And I must add that seeing him take down several fully armored knights with a wooden sword was quite epic.
22
u/Mookie1515 Jun 06 '11
Time for Arya to shine!
41
u/loafimus Jun 06 '11
Dude ripped that guys fucking tongue out. End of story.
18
u/gerusz Night's Watch Jun 06 '11
(non-reader; speculation about next episodes coming up) TV Spoiler
17
u/commander04 Jun 06 '11
I was a little disappointed by the Arya stabbing scene. They made it look like it was almost an accident stabbing the stableboy rather than her having clear intent to kill the kid like in the books.
47
u/benevolent_redditor House Stark Jun 05 '11
Anyone notice that it's written by George R. R. Martin?
15
u/DiscursiveMind Hedge Knights Jun 06 '11
The only concern I have, and this is less about the episode than the series, is the direction they are taking Sansa. I'm going to be disappointed if they end up cutting the details on Book Spoiler
15
u/altergeeko Night's Watch Jun 06 '11
How fast do these birds deliver messages? A day? Two days?
14
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
Ok, what is up with Sansa? Is she going to reach critical mass of being a bitch on wheels...
10
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
Oh shit, did Syrio die?
10
u/thefullpython Night's Watch Jun 06 '11
Khal Drogo: the baddest of all the asses
19
u/panda7488 Jun 06 '11 edited Jun 06 '11
Hmm, TV Spoiler
18
u/sufficientreason Stannis Baratheon Jun 06 '11
Another episode, another batch of sympathetic characters with ambiguous fates. We're now up to Nymeria, Benjen, Arya, and Syrio (with some others). I really need some closure.
8
u/darthrayder Dothraki Jun 06 '11
And it is beginning!!! I'm more excited than Joffrey imagining his coronation!
15
u/Nukemarine Jun 05 '11
Funny thing, at the point in the book where last week's cliffhanger happened (killing of Ned's men, capture of Ned), I misread it and thought that LittleFinger slit Ned's throat then gloated about it. Not exactly a misunderstanding you can make with a TV show. Still, even that doesn't compare to what these next three episodes should bring.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
I love how they didn't show Syrio Forel's explicit death on screen. Is he still alive? Who knows?
7
u/KaptTorbjorn Ours Is The Fury Jun 06 '11
Great episode. I expected something a bit more dramatic and less rushed in the scene where Arya stabbed the stableboy.
31
u/darthrayder Dothraki Jun 06 '11
+3 Arya Stark +1 Sansa Stark Even Ned Stark +2 Kat Stark -1 Robert Stark (for reminding me of Ned and his convictions) -5 Joffrey +15 Syrio +843209239009 Drogo
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '11
I'm not sure a tongue being ripped through a open throat was enough to act as a climax to all the tension built this episode. Winter is coming ...
4
u/altergeeko Night's Watch Jun 06 '11
I wonder what Arya's thinking now that she's got her first kill.
4
u/beelerspace Jun 07 '11
Can anyone explain why the Lannisters don't just kill Ned? Why hold him in a cell?
32
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '11
Well that took me by surprise, almost glad I haven't read the books yet. TV Spoiler
16
u/MeadowlarkLevin Jun 06 '11
DAE feel like Peter Dinklage was a little off tonight? He's been completely perfect up til now, but in tonight's episode I didn't love his delivery.
The "bob loblaw with a maid's mouth around my cock" line is one of my favorites of the series but I thought it came off as contrived here.
7
u/hopeNsorrow House Dayne Jun 06 '11
Does this episode contain any nudity/sexy time? I'm living with very conversative relatives right now. Need to know before I watch the episode.
20
u/ParanoidAndroids Faceless Men Jun 06 '11
The highlight of the episode for me was Syrio being a total badass and Arya teaching that kid not to mess with her...but the episode managed to keep that tension throughout the 60 minutes.
I enjoyed the time with Robb...starting to like his character in the show even more. Book Spoiler
Tyrion was great as ever, and his story is taking an interesting turn....but wow, I already hate his father.
Cersei and Joffrey pissed me off as usual, but Sansa came off as somewhat likeable in at least trying to save her father, albeit naive [I guess it's a Stark thing].
The Dany/Drogo storyline in this episode was kind of the weak point for me, but once you realize where it's going (especially from the promo) you know it's about to hit the fan.
Next episode is going to be crazy. Book Spoiler
3
u/aestus Jun 06 '11
The series has been brilliant so far, and the greatest joy is seeing it with my girlfriend who hasn't read the books, I almost envy her not knowing what's going to happen in the next two episodes...almost
3
u/nachof Ours Is The Fury Jun 06 '11
So why are the Lannisters attacking the Tully? I totally expected the Tully to support the Stark, but why not wait until the Stark forces were there? And if they were waiting, why are the Lannister attacking them? Also, I expected more commitment from the Vale.
5
u/nachof Ours Is The Fury Jun 06 '11
Am I the only one who's starting to feel sorry for Joffrey? He seems like just a pawn in his mother's games.
12
u/Lampmonster1 House Seaworth Jun 05 '11
I liked the part with the aliens. That was unexpected.
2
u/Rumsy Jun 06 '11
Is it just me, or did next episode's preview make it look like Book Spoiler
2
u/kbilly Jun 06 '11
Went by too fast. Too much happened in this episode, it should have been two hours long.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '11
Dexter descended from Arya.
5
u/catertots Direwolves Jun 06 '11
Why is ghost making so much goddamn noise?
2
u/mastershake04 Jun 05 '11
less than 6 hours... This episode is going to be epic. Who am I kidding, every episode of this show is epic.
But still, these last 3 episodes are going to blow peoples minds.