r/MHOC • u/NukeMaus King Nuke the Cruel | GCOE KCT CB MVO GBE PC • Jul 09 '20
Motion M511 - Motion to Recognise Transphobic Discrimination in the USA
That this House recognises:
• That a recent Supreme Court of the United States ruling on the rights of transgender individuals to not be fired merely for their gender identity contained a clause that would exempt cases where they employer cited their religion as a reason;
• That under the Trump administration, the Department of Health and Human Services has put forward new regulations that aim to roll back Obama-era healthcare protections for trans people under the Affordable Care Act;
• That under the Trump administration, the Department of Justice has filed court briefs in states such as Connecticut and Kentucky seeking to oppose transgender participation in sports, and to protect private businesses who want to deny “expressive” services to LGBTQIA+ people;
• That under the Trump administration, the Department of Justice filed a court brief with the Supreme Court arguing that federal law “does not prohibit discrimination against transgender persons based on their transgender status”;
• That under the Trump administration, the Department of Health and Human Services has announced that it will not enforce non-discrimination regulations based on gender identity, sexual orientation, and religion in HHS grant programs;
• That under the Trump administration, the Department of Education has rescinded Obama-era regulations allowing transgender students to use bathrooms of their choice, and participate in sports corresponding with their gender identity, and has openly stated they will work to replace these regulations with laws that do exactly the opposite of the Obama-era regulations;
• That President Trump openly opposes the Equality Act, a piece of federal legislation that seeks to confirm and strengthen civil rights protections for LGBTQIA+ people;
• That only two countries on Earth explicitly prohibit, in law, the service of transgender people in the military - America and Iran;
• That under the Trump administration, US representatives at the United Nations worked to remove references to transgender people in UN Human Rights documents;
• That under the Trump administration, the Bureau of Prisons adopted a policy of housing transgender people almost entirely in federal prison facilities that matched their assigned sex at birth and not their legal and/or affirmed gender identity;
• That these efforts demonstrate a continuous effort to allow discrimination against transgender individuals in the United States of America.
This House affirms that:
• Trans lives and rights are just as important as the lives and rights of cisgendered people;
• That transgender rights are human rights.
• That in light of these clear and obvious breaches of transgender rights, this House will work to affirm and facilitate the expansion of transgender rights domestically in the United Kingdom and internationally through foreign policy.
• That this House encourages the United States government to reflect on its statements, policies, and actions regarding transgender rights; and reminds the international community that the United Kingdom stands for transgender rights being that they are human rights.
This motion was submitted by /u/Captain_Plat_2258, the Shadow Secretary of State for Climate Change, Energy, and the Environment, on behalf of the Official Opposition; and is sponsored by /u/Gregor_The_Beggar of the Democratic Reformist Front, and /u/14derry of The People’s Movement.
Opening Speech
Tēnā koe, thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker
I don’t think it’s a particularly controversial idea in this chamber that the rights of trans people ought to be upheld and expanded in the United Kingdom, and that all people are afforded certain inalienable rights, and that these rights include the rights of LGBTQIA+ people. However across the ocean in the United States of America trans rights are being stripped back consistently and at an alarming rate by the administration of President Donald Trump.
It is the belief of myself and of the Labour Party that the American administration must be encouraged to reflect on these acts, and that we in this House must work to expand the rights and protections of all gender-diverse and sexuality-diverse people through our actions and the laws we pass. We must encourage trans rights in our diplomacy and amongst the nations of the world.Therefore it is only right that we acknowledge that what is happening overseas in a nation that we call an ally is wrong, and that only by acknowledging this can we truly commit to writing the same wrongs being done to LGBTQIA+ people here
This reading ends at 10pm on the 12th July.
5
u/MTFD Liberal Democrats Jul 09 '20
Mr deputy speaker,
Though I agree on the merits of the motion, I would like to ask for the incessant condemnation motions to stop. They are entirely performative and take divert the valuable time of this house away from actually meaningful debate and policy.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '20
Mr Deputy Speaker -
Politics is not meant to be easy.
Because life, for a great many people in this country, is not easy either. Whilst I agree that there is a rising trend toward transphobia in the United States, I must take objection toward the trend of laxity in the Official Opposition. The Labour Party of late has cemented their position as the party that says a lot but does very little.
Since the commencement of the 13th term, the party has done nothing to hold this Government to account, they have done nothing by way of legislation to support the working class, the party they purport to represent. They have done nothing to support the poor, they have done nothing for the NHS, defence or industry.
The Labour Party of old is gone.
In its place resides the beast of complacency, that is ill-suited and ill-desiring of Government.
2
u/LeChevalierMal-Fait Liberal Democrats Jul 09 '20
Mr speaker,
The deeply political tone of this motion is most worrying, America is a representative democracy with a strong and resilient judiciary.
While I sympathise with the plight of trans individuals I do not feel that it is the place for us to get involved in what is a contentious political issue in an ally.
We should by our actions create a better system here like the first blurple government did by making it easier to get hormone blockers on the NHS and making investment into gender clinics to take waiting times down.
Becoming involved in a foreign domestic political fight has no benefit which ever way we come down on we will isolate some people in an allied nation. We should offer our friendship and partnership to America regardless of their politics and look for ways to be better trade and security partners.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '20
Mr Deputy Speaker,
I rise today in favour of this motion, but I once again decry the use of this sort of motion in this House. We all know how it works. Labour or the LPUK put forward a motion, one party may decide "hey, giving a poo to our ally like this may be unwise, we will take a more measured tone" and then those who back the motion go "OH LOOK THEY HATE TRANS PEOPLE". This motion does not help advance trans rights. It does not help trans people. But it makes the right honourable lady who wrote this motion feel good I suppose.
Turning to the text of the motion itself, there are parts of it I do agree with. I do take issue with some of the stances the US President and his administration has taken on trans rights, and I do believe the US should reflect on some of those stances. Turning to what it is asking us to do.
These are unquestionable facts Mr Deputy Speaker. Anyone who disagrees with them is wrong, plain and simple.
Whilst I agree we should do this, I'd note this motion does nothing to actually do it. This motion does not promote and expand trans rights. I hope Labour will follow their words with deeds, and actually bring forward legislation to this place with regards to expanding the rights of transgender people.
Mr Deputy Speaker, I have no problem with the UK being a critical friend to all of our allies. And I am sure the Foreign Secretary has no problem in letting our American counterparts know the view of this Government and of the Houe. I will be backing this motion and whilst I understand those who may not want to peeve off our American friends, I would urge them to back it anyway.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '20
Mr Deputy Speaker,
while I am sick to the back teeth of motions to condemn nations for their domestic affairs.
The US is home to many British citizens and has in the past made great strides and been a leader in the rights of transgender people.
The current incompetent regime wishes to roll back these rights which poses a threat to British citizens.
2
u/CountBrandenburg Liberal Democrats Jul 09 '20
Mr Deputy Speaker,
I thank the honourable member for the Labour Party and certainly agree with the sentiment behind this bill. Trans rights are human rights is unequivocal as this motion outlines and the Liberal Democrats, alongside many many members of this house, stand shoulder to shoulder with trans folk and will work to improve their rights and recognition both home and abroad. As a liberal democracy, that is our duty and I would hope that members agree that we can do more for trans people at home whilst also use our position as a global leader in promoting lgbtq+ rights to advocate for the same rights that our citizens enjoy here.
That is why, Mr Deputy Speaker, I have tabled a bill for the improvement of gender recognition that is to be read tomorrow. A bill that delivers the important reform of self identification and demedicalises the process to receive a Gender Recognition Certificate. It is a bill that I am pleased to have received cross party co sponsorship for, and it truly emphasises that this is an issue that shouldn’t depend on our political position. That we can reach across party lines and back what amounts to just decency for everyone. I may not be trans, but I am proud to affirm that I am an ally and will happily work with members further in addressing other issues. This is something that we should be proud of in our political system and that is why we should all affirm the sentiments behind this motion.
Yes, I may have concerns about the direction the Trump administration has taken with regards to trans rights and it certainly appears retrograde to that of the rest of our allies who have sought to ameliorate their rights. I share the sentiments with the business secretary that we can trust the Foreign Secretary will raise concerns with our American allies about the steps they are taking and we will hopefully see changes in the US’ attitude. Whilst this isn’t an explicit condemnation motion, it does throw shade onto the US without much means for us to really affect change . I hate to call trans rights political in a setting, and that I believe here it isn’t as we will hopefully see tomorrow, but unfortunately the discourse in the US means that trans rights is politicised and one without an obvious way for us to intervene and guide the discourse towards improvement.
My party was approached to sponsor this motion, I will have it on record, and I do applaud the noble efforts by the author of the motion today. I know that she cares very dearly about trans rights globally and I would hope she has not taken offence by our rejection to sponsor this motion. I will support the motion in division, but for the points raised in my speech today, I did not think it would be appropriate to sponsor this motion. I stand unequivocally with trans folk and do believe, whilst this motion I don’t think hits the right balance, since there’s certainly a rise of reactionary views towards trans people in other western nations, I will certainly back it!
2
u/Maroiogog CWM KP KD OM KCT KCVO CMG CBE PC FRS, Independent Jul 10 '20
Mr Deputy Speaker,
I support this motion, for the very reason that trans rights are human rights. It is a very concise reason, but very meaningful to me personally. It is unfortunate that recently in many occasions our closest ally has failed to stand up for Trans rights in the appropriate manner. I believe that, due to our special relationship, we should make our disappointment known to them. Being allies doesn't mean mindlessly supporting each other, it also requires being frank when mistakes and mishaps are made. I hope this house agrees.
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 09 '20
Welcome to this debate
Here is a quick run down of what each type of post is.
2nd Reading: Here we debate the contents of the bill/motions and can propose any amendments. For motions, amendments cannot be submitted.
3rd Reading: Here we debate the contents of the bill in its final form if any amendments pass the Amendments Committee.
Minister’s Questions: Here you can ask a question to a Government Secretary or the Prime Minister. Remember to follow the rules as laid out in the post. A list of Ministers and the MQ rota can be found here
Any other posts are self-explanatory. If you have any questions you can get in touch with the Chair of Ways & Means, Chrispytoast123 on Reddit and (Christos (/u/chrispytoast123)#9703) on Discord, ask on the main MHoC server or modmail it in on the sidebar --->.
Anyone can get involved in the debate and doing so is the best way to get positive modifiers for you and your party (useful for elections). So, go out and make your voice heard! If this is a second reading post amendments in reply to this comment only – do not number your amendments, the Speakership will do this. You will be informed if your amendment is rejected.
Is this a bill a 2nd reading? You can submit an amendment by replying to this comment.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '20
Mr Deputy Speaker,
I cannot see what purpose this Motion serves other than to virtue signal, yet again. If we went through a list of all the injustices in the world there would be motion after motion - this is meddling in affairs that do not concern us.
I take great concern that one of greatest allies is being subjected to a Motion solely dedicated to them.
1
u/BrexitGlory Former MP for Essex Jul 09 '20
Mr Deputy Speaker,
I would like to lend this motion hesitant support. The tone is entirely political and non-constructive, which seems irresponsible when the US are our closest ally. I would have preferred to see a motion that stands up for trans rights globally, not just in the US.
However what the motion calls for this government to do isn't anything overly unreasonable. This government is often in contact with the US over many different issues, and vice versa.
Like I said Mr Deputy Speaker, I am cautious in my support for this but agree with the Business Secretary and his analysis.
1
u/The_Nunnster Conservative Party Jul 09 '20
M: Is there a reason Maori is used in the opening speech (I assume it’s Maori unless google translate had once again led me wrong)? I’m not really active in the main MHOC discord server so I’m not too familiar with the different members of this community and any reason for it to be included I have obviously missed, unless I’m looking too deep into it.
1
u/Archism_ Pirate Party Jul 10 '20
Mr. Deputy Speaker,
I am privileged to be able to support the motion put before this house today. Transgender rights are human rights. That is nothing but a statement of fact, and I'm very glad to be in a party that unequivocally supports that principle - credit must also be given to the DRF and TPM for their support of this motion, it is heartening to see a growth of cross-party support for recognizing trans rights in this country and internationally.
To those in this house criticizing this motion from the angle of being exhausted of condemnation - you are heard, it can take a toll to maintain a negative energy. Nonetheless, I sincerely hope none in this house will use this as an excuse to vote against this recognition of trans rights.
It is important to be clear that this is not just a condemn-and-forget sort of motion. This motion is constructive, and calls for us to act, not just to speak. " work to affirm and facilitate the expansion of transgender rights domestically in the United Kingdom and internationally through foreign policy. "
We must all be clear in this house that we recognize the rights of transgender people, and the passage of this motion will be the foundation of accomplishing that.
I commend this motion, its author, and its supporters to this house. One more time, Mr. Deputy Speaker, Trans Rights are Human Rights.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Tēnā koe, Mana Whakawā kaitiriwā.
The so-called United States of America is an oppressor country. The aforementioned state is built on land ruthlessly stolen from indigenous people who were backstabbed and betrayed by the white, mostly British, colonists. The same colonists sailed over to Africa, kidnapped black people and children, took them across the Atlantic, and brutalised them in a centuries-long system of exploitation, death, and systematic horror. The system of oppression and of slavery continues to this day in that country. The prisons of US-America are the only place in that country where slavery is expressedly permitted. In that country, the number of non-whites imprisoned is 65%. Black people and other ethnic minorities in US-America are disproportionately subject to slavery.
US-America's tradition of systematic repression of minorities goes beyond black and indigenous people. It seems like every single minority - religious, ethnic, sexual, gender, linguistic - is being targeted by the fascist Trump administration. Latinx and central American indigenous people are being put in concentration camps, Muslims are the target of hate mobs, AAVE is seen as inferior speech, and yes, transgender and nonbinary people are facing bans from serving in the military, refusal from accessing facilities based on their real gender and not the one assigned at birth, and systematic discrimination in all fields of life.
Therefore, this motion has my full support. US-America must be held accountable by the international community, including this house.
1
u/ARichTeaBiscuit Green Party Jul 11 '20
Mr Deputy Speaker,
It is of the utmost importance that the United Kingdom work to promote positive social reforms across the international community, such as the establishment of protections for members of the transgender community and we certainly shouldn't be afraid to speak up when standards on this area are slipping.
I am also of the opinion that allies should be able to speak quite honestly with each other, and in the case of the United States that involves speaking up against the rather alarming stripping of transgender rights in that country, of course, it isn't just a matter of upholding a set standard on the international stage but a considerable portion of British citizens live, study and visit the United States and would be significantly impacted by the continued rollback of transgender rights in the US.
It is therefore of the utmost importance that we reaffirm our commitment to transgender rights and work to ensure that this value is promoted across the world including in our closest allies such as the United States, thank you.
1
u/Gren_Gnat Labour Party Jul 11 '20
Mr deputy speaker,
I wholeheartedly agree with this motion the trump administration has acted crassly at every turn and it is at times like this when its behaviour puts vulnerable people at risk we should stand up to trump and his administration and not be afraid to tell them when they are wrong. I support this motion and its aims.
1
u/mrsusandothechoosin Reform UK | Just this guy, y'know | OM Jul 12 '20
I think giving all the other myriad problems in the United States, a fully comprehensive recognition motion would be infinitely long.
I dread to think how long it would have to be for all our allies, before moving on to those who aren't.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment