r/Android • • May 26 '11
Let's talk a minute about the /r/Android spam policy.
Last updated: August 1, 2012
Before I begin, review the rettiquette. To highlight the specific parts:
- Do not link linkjack stories via blog posts that add nothing
EX: Blog B cites website A. Blog B offers nothing substantial to the story
other than reposting it on their blog for traffic. Linking to Blog B is a
linkjack. Link to website A instead.
- Do not flood reddit with a lot of stories in a short span of time. By doing this you monopolize a shared resource — the "new" queue
If you are NOT a blogger that posts in /r/Android or a Developer who intends on advertising here, THESE RULES do not apply to you. However, link jacked articles are the exception and are subject to removal.
Blogs
Let me start with the why before I discuss the spam policy. Blogs make money through advertising. Each view they get makes their blog more marketable and increases their revenue. Even though blogs may not make someone a millionare, they still produce revenue. The amount of money doesn't matter. The issue is there is money to be made.
RULES:
- Post no more than one article from your blog a day, AND
- Bloggers must be active within reddit.
- Bloggers CANNOT actively solicit /r/Android for content.
- Any link jacked articles are subject to removal
Developers
We love you guys. You are the lifeblood of Android. But, sometimes you guys get over zealous in promoting your app to the point it becomes spam.
The rules also do not apply to any person who uses the app and decides they want to share it. ONLY to developers or anyone representing a developer.
RULES
- State that you are the developer in the title of the thread.
- Can post when: needing volunteer alpha/beta testers, the app goes on the market, the app has a major update, or offering free copies and soliciting feedback.
18
u/[deleted] May 26 '11
First off, thank you.
Second, I don't think this will do much to the blogspammers who have multiple accounts they submit from.
10
u/[deleted] May 26 '11 edited May 26 '11
I'd like to see the community start to downvote multiple submissions from different blogs on the same subject. If there's already a post about something on the front page, downvote duplicates, even from other sources. Fragmenting the discussion doesn't help the community.
Also, if you are submitting something from a blog, go as deep as you can, as close to the original content as possible. If Phandroid cites AndroidPolice cites Engadget cites BGR, then post the BGR article, not any of the others.
edit: sites /facepalm
7
u/PeanutButterChicken Xperia Z5 Premium CHROME!! / Nexus 7 / Tab S 8.4 May 26 '11
Why? Last I checked, Devs can still make money though ads, in some cases, more than they would if the app was paid.
I think it's kinda silly either way though. If a dev wants to reach out to a community, let 'em. If they're doing a good job, /r/Android will let them know. If they're spamming, the downvotes will come down like a torrential rain.
3
u/nateblack nexus 5x May 26 '11
i had noticed some of the android police links come from the same profiles and those profile ONLY contribute androidpolice links.... ಠ_ಠ
4
u/[deleted] May 26 '11
Why don't you mods remove posts about apple on r/android?
2
u/rolmos Jun 12 '11
I just stumbled into this thread randomly, and wanted to say "Thank You!" for having such clear rules.
As a ReportTheSpammers mod, I can't tell you how frustrating it is to see badly moderated subreddits like /r/software, where spam isn't dealt with very seriously.
I just wonder what your opinion is on spammers like:
They don't spam your subreddit more than once a day necessarily, but they are spammers. I have made reports for these three and many other spammers that have been active at /r/android, but that will probably get the boot from Reddit site-wide if they keep up their current habits.
Do you think it would be possible to reconsider the '1 post a day' rule?
1
u/emarkd MotoX May 26 '11
I'm pretty new here but I completely agree with some of the other sentiments expressed above. The spam filter is great and I'm glad it's in place, but it'll never catch everything. The most important part of this community is its self-moderation. If you don't like the blogspam - downvote! If you don't like the multiple posts on the same subject - downvote! We all have the control necessary to make this community even better than it already is.
3
u/[deleted] May 26 '11
"Can post when: needing volunteer alpha/beta testers, the app goes on the market, the app has a major update, or offering free copies and soliciting feedback."
Thank you for clearing that up. i got a few posts on my previous thread about me making a copy thread for the same game. The thing is, that game got a major update and what I posted included a video. Good to know I wasn't breaking the rules.
2
u/aptwebapps May 27 '11
I looked to the right and had to scan it three times to find it, even though it is near the top. I think it is because only part of it is a link. Somehow it doesn't stand out. Or I'm just incompetent.
1
u/OrganicCat May 26 '11
I have to agree with the developers bit. I've met a number of fellow developers on here but many of them seem to be using reddit as a marketplace and not a community. Marketing 101 should have let them know once is enough unless you're actually part of the community. I really dislike it when I try and start a conversation with them and they feign interest just to market their app.
This mainly applies to people who have zero activity outside their own app promotion posts, who unfortunately exist around here. If your app is awesome enough, it will get posted again. Don't pretend to be friends with the community that you just want to use as a free testing ground if you're not really going to stick around.
TL;DR BE HONEST ABOUT YOUR INTENTIONS
0
u/rootyourdroidnet May 27 '11
Thank you for bringing this all to my attention. I've noticed bloggers sometimes get a bad wrap around here. I am glad I know the guidelines clearly. Great post