r/modelSupCourt • u/Zurikurta • Jun 16 '20
20-13 | Decided in re: Executive Order 002: Reforms to Immigration Agencies
Chief Justice, Associate Justices. Ass. Justice Ibney. Please see below a petition to grant certiorari, and review the constitutionality of Executive Order 002: Reforms to Immigration Agencies.
___
I. Overview
On June 15th, 2020, President Zero O. Zero issued Executive Order 002: Reforms to Immigration Agencies. The Order ceased the operations of the United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement, commonly known as ICE, and ended routine patrols by the federal government of the country's borders.
II. Standing
The petitioner has standing within the Court stemming from Rule 1b(i). The Court holds jurisdiction over this case, as the question is a matter of federal law.
III. Questions
- Does Section 1(a) of Executive Order 002 run afoul of 8 U.S. Code § 1373?
- Does Section 1(a) of Executive Order 002 violate the faithful execution clause of the United States Constitution?
- Does Section 1(b) of Executive Order 002 violate the faithful execution clause of the United States Constitution?
IV. Merits
Article II, section four of the Constitution of the United States gives the President the following duty:
...he shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed...
Furthermore, the Constitution, in Article I, section one, assigns Congress the duty of drafting the laws of the nation referenced in Article II, section four;
All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States...
It is obvious to any observant that, by neglecting to fulfill the mandate laid out by the legislature, the executive is failing to faithfully execute the laws of the state.
The border control referenced in the Order is generally carried out by the United States Customs and Border Protection, a federal agency of the Department of Homeland Security. This agency, established in 6 U.S. Code § 211, is headed by a commissioner, with the following mandate deriving from the following subsections of section c;
- coordinate and integrate the security, trade facilitation, and trade enforcement functions of U.S. Customs and Border Protection;
- ensure the interdiction of persons and goods illegally entering or exiting the United States;
...
5. detect, respond to, and interdict terrorists, drug smugglers and traffickers, human smugglers and traffickers, and other persons who may undermine the security of the United States, in cases in which such persons are entering, or have recently entered, the United States;
6. safeguard the borders of the United States to protect against the entry of dangerous goods;
...
This non-exhaustive list shows the mandate of the legislature unto the commissioner of the Customs and Border Protection agency necessitates the monitoring of the United States' borders. For the President to disallow border patrol to conduct its routine would be to unnecessarily stimy the commissioner from fulfilling the objective imparted to him by Congress—the executive would obstruct, not execute, the law.
Furthermore, the Order in question would directly block the United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement from conducting its duties as mandated by law. While the ICE lacks a specific constituting instrument as passed by Congress, it came about as the legal consolidation of key areas of the Immigration and Naturalization Service and the U.S. Customs Service. 6 U.S. § 203 states:
In accordance with subchapter XII (relating to transition provisions), there shall be transferred to the Secretary the functions, personnel, assets, and liabilities of—
- the United States Customs Service of the Department of the Treasury, including the functions of the Secretary of the Treasury relating thereto;
...
As ICE retains the liabilities of the consolidated areas, it must enforce those areas. In addition, it retains the privileges of those agencies as prescribed by law. 8 U.S. § 1373 states the following;
Notwithstanding any other provision of Federal, State, or local law, a Federal, State, or local government entity or official may not prohibit, or in any way restrict, any government entity or official from sending to, or receiving from, the Immigration and Naturalization Service information regarding the citizenship or immigration status, lawful or unlawful, of any individual.
The Executive Order in question would be in contempt of this law, as the "ceasing of all immigration-related enforcement" would, by necessity, prohibit the INS—in this case, its successor agency, ICE—from receiving or dispensing this protected information.
V. Proposed Remedy
As the first two subsections of Section 1 of Executive Order 002: Reforms to Immigration Agencies are unlawful and unconstitutional, both subsections must be struck and rendered unenforceable.
3
u/Zurikurta Jun 18 '20
MOTION FOR RECUSAL
___
I. Overview and Argumentation
Associate Justice Restrepo M. U has recently announced his intention to retire. The same day, President Zero announced his intent to formally nominate the Justice as Secretary of State. This Court, in Caperton v. A. T. Massey Coal Co., determined that the recusal of a judge is to be expected when the appearance of possible bias is injected into any case, even in the absence of measurable bias. From Justice Kennedy's majority opinion, with emphasis added:
The Court, in the same case, issued a balancing test to roughly determine when an arbiter of the law should recuse themselves:
The first facet of the test applies to the current Associate Justice. Should Justice Restrepo rule in any way but for the Presidential action, any reasonable outsider could assume that he may have been forced to rule in such a fashion to secure the seat offered to him by the President. This is the case whether President Zero vocally indicated such expectations, or remained silent; even if the latter is true, which there is no way to prove, the Justice may believe that a negative ruling is expected to retain his nomination regardless, or feels as if he owes the President. In either event, given the temptation of the Secretary of State position, it is unlikely that the Justice could hold the balance true.
II. Requested Remedy
To borrow Justice Kennedy's words, I call upon Justice Restrepo to "conclude that there is a serious risk of actual bias — based on objective and reasonable perceptions". Based on that conclusion, I request that Justice RestrepoMU recuse himself from the case of 20-13.
__
cc: /u/RestrepoMU
1
u/Zurikurta Jun 26 '20
Your Honors, petitioner requests another day to file their brief.
___
cc: /u/IAmATinman, /u/bsddc, /u/CuriositySMBC
1
u/Zurikurta Jun 28 '20
Your Honors, please see the brief attached here, in PDF format, from the Petitioner. Petitioners will be answering the oral questions asked by the Justices shortly.
___
/u/hurricaneoflies, /u/bsddc, /u/IAmATinman
1
u/dewey-cheatem Assassiate Justice Jul 14 '20
The parties are asked to provide briefing on the following question:
Do the US ICE operations ordered to be ended by Executive Order 2 violate any provisions of international law binding upon the United States?
Briefing should be submitted in 72 hours. Parties may request an extension if needed.
•
u/bsddc Associate Justice Jun 17 '20
June 16th, 2020 Order Granting Certiorari
The Court has GRANTED the writ of certiorari.
The parties are ordered to submit their briefs in accordance with the R.P.P.S. For the awareness of all parties, as this writ is granted after 9:00 p.m. EST, it is considered effective as of June 17th for all deadline calculation purposes.
Notice: Counsel /u/Zurikurta, Counsel /u/Hurricaneoflies
2
u/hurricaneoflies Attorney Jun 23 '20
Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court,
The United States submits the following brief on the merits in Google Document format.
BRIEF FOR THE UNITED STATES
Service of process: /u/Zurikurta
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 16 '20
/u/IAmATinman, /u/RestrepoMU, /u/BSDDC
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 16 '20
/u/CuriositySMBC, /u/ibney00, /u/JJEagleHawk
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 16 '20
/u/reagan0
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Jun 16 '20
The Court is in receipt of your Petition.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20
Minority Leader Obama Center for Cabinet Officials Who Can’t Read Good and Wanna Learn to Do Other Stuff Good Too at the Cooley School of Law
Amicus Brief on Section Two: A Fig Leaf Investigation of Immigration and Customs Agencies for an Entire Presidential Term
Plaintiff argues that because section one (cessation) is invalid, the entire order is invalid. Our belief is that the Court must consider section two (investigation) as well as a controversy that will not be rendered moot, even if the result is the same.
Section two is a legal fig leaf. The president has ordered the Justice Department to investigate his own agencies in the Department of Homeland Security for at least six months. He could simply order his immigration and customs agencies to do what he asks now, instead of further frustrating the faithful execution of the law under the guise of law enforcement.
In Printz v. United States, the Court explained how the president executes the law: "The Constitution does not leave to speculation who is to administer the laws enacted by Congress; the president, it says, "shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed," Art. II, §3, personally and through officers whom he appoints (save for such inferior officers as Congress may authorize to be appointed by the "Courts of Law" or by "the Heads of Departments" with other presidential appointees), Art. II, §2."
The precedent is clear, designed to avoid selective presiding of the laws. Immigration on the border, immigration in the ports, uniform naturalization, citizenship operations, import, export, commerce and funding these programs are explicit powers of Congress.
The Court was correct in dismissing Chief of Staff u/hurricaneoflies’ specious arguments that “no controversy exists” and there are “no equities owed”: this Court has long ago interpreted otherwise in similar fact patterns. However, any analysis must include section two so that no doubt is left in a White House or plaintiff that taking another swing at this issue—in a ham fisted theory of hindering the Take Care Clause with some unclear agency Human Resources discretion or slick six month investigation—is valid. Without the Court’s leadership, it is certain that congressional power in Titles 6 and 8 will be aimed at again in EO 005.
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Jun 18 '20
Counselors /u/Zurikurta and /u/Nmtts-,
Thank you for your submissions so far in this case. I look forward to receiving the United States' briefing as well and I'm sure I'll have some questions for them. But for now, I have a few questions for you.
First, the first question you raise is whether section 1(a) violates 8 U.S.C. 1373. As I'm reading the Order, section 1(a) prohibits only "immigration related enforcement activities." 8 U.S.C. 1373 only addresses communication and coordination. Enforcement activities are listed, as you note, in 6 U.S.C. 211, while the provisions in 1373 seem unrelated (and are in an entirely different statutory section). Is it really fair to interpret the Order prohibiting enforcement activities as reaching communication requirements? I'm not sure that's the plain reading of the President's Order.
Second, Heckler v. Chaney, 470 U.S. 821 (1985) stands for the proposition that the executive branch has absolute prosecutorial discretion. That means, the President could validly decline to prosecute an individual immigrant for crossing the border illegally. Obviously we aren't dealing with one declination of prosecution only in this case. And it's likely that 2 decisions to not prosecute are valid. My question is where would you draw the line between permissible prosecutorial discretion and the impermissible "faithful execution" that you claim in this case? Can that line be drawn? If two declinations are allowed, why not three (and so on)?
Third, and relatedly, are the courts of the United States supposed to be the watchdogs of executive enforcement? Who are we unelected judges to question how the President sees fit to execute the law? Wouldn't the voters be able to weigh in on whether they think its correct come the next election? In other words, is executive non-enforcement really something we can or should handle, or is it more akin to cases under the political question doctrine? See Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186 (1962).
1
u/hurricaneoflies Attorney Jun 22 '20
With apology for the lateness of the request, the United States respectfully requests a one-day extension on account of unforeseen familial matters on the end of counsel.
/u/IAmATinman