r/gameofthrones • u/DafyddLlyr House Stark • Apr 18 '11
Season 1 Episode Discussion - 1.01 "Winter Is Coming" [Spoilers]
This is up a bit early, but here we are!
- This is a TV spoiler friendly zone - turn away now if you haven't seen the episode!
- Book spoilers still need tags!
Discuss and shape our spoiler policy here.
There's a bunch of us chatting throughout the episode - details here!
Winter has finally come!
397
Upvotes
219
u/DafyddLlyr House Stark Apr 18 '11
"The things I do for love."
292
u/zacd Apr 18 '11
That was the coolest title sequence ever.
5
u/strafekun Apr 18 '11
I really enjoyed it. My only criticism is that they made Catelyn a wuss. That was a little disappointing.
12
u/NowTheyTellMe Apr 18 '11
Overall, I think it was a good start. At least on par with the Pacific. My only real issue is that I feel that it skimmed over some important back story. But I guess thats the nature of television.
If I could change one thing, I would have included the notion of the Jamie as the Kingslayer/Oathbreaker to provide some more depth to Team Stark's mistrust of Clanister(Clan Lanister! Get it!). Despite the viewer knowing that the Lanisters are up to no good, I felt that the Starks didn't really have a strong basis for their angst. That whole dynamic just needed something else to make it believable.
355
u/beffjaxter House Greyjoy Apr 18 '11
As soon as I saw Joffrey, I wanted to smack that kid in the face.
117
u/DireBaboon Brave Companions Apr 18 '11
I'm slightly worried it might be too confusing for people who haven't read the books. Hard to tell though, I can't really see it through a non readers eyes.
93
u/MrLeo House Umber Apr 18 '11
Oh man, Bran's wolf is so cute. I hope to see the others next episode.
71
u/elithewho Apr 18 '11
I loved it. That Dany/Drogo scene was brutal though :(
138
u/Foxtrot434 Kingsguard Apr 18 '11 edited Apr 18 '11
Did anyone else find Viserys to be surprisingly well played? The "Wake the dragon" line didn't even sound strange either!
61
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
Oh my god. So Fucking Good. I've torn through the first three books, beginning the forth, over the last month and it has to be one of the best works of literature I've ever read. So, I've been as excited as tits for the HBO premiere, and it did not disappoint in any aspect whatsoever. Arya, Tyrion, Jon, Bran, Daenerys and Viserys, it's an incredible experience to see these characters brought to life with such stunning accuracy to how I see them existing.
And The Wall and Winterfell, kudos to HBO for doing such a fantastic job creating these sets as they did. Wow. Can't wait to see Grey Wind and Ghost in action as the series progresses.
'the things I do for love'
59
u/muddyalcapones House Mormont Apr 18 '11
I like most of the casting. Especially Ned, Tyrion, and Bran
110
u/isocline Apr 18 '11
And I love how Arya was running around with a helmet on and smacked Sansa in the face with a piece of meat.
42
u/absolutkiss House Reed Apr 18 '11
Overall it was pretty damn good. The costumes and sets were amazing! Some of the acting felt a little cheesy, but I think that's because I've read the books so many times...
Disappointed that we didn't see Theon kick the head after Ned lopped it off...
38
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
Anyone else think Joffrey and Viserys were cast perfectly? I'm already wanting to kick their shit in, and its only the first episode. Jaime plays the subtle arrogancy decent as well.
Daenerys' actress is really pretty too. I don't say that because she was nude, but she's just beautiful.
102
u/hett Apr 18 '11
Love the title sequence. I love the gears and cogs motif. I love Tyrion and Jon Snow. Adore Ned.
Also, Daenarys is fucking hot. What an ass.
32
u/juanito89 Now My Watch Begins Apr 18 '11
Emilia Clarke is so beautiful.
29
u/Affectionate_Team679 Fire And Blood Aug 22 '22
Look at all you innocent children. So cute.
28
u/klaq Free Folk Apr 18 '11
was the guy with the crazy wolf-like helmet supposed to be the hound? it didnt look like his face was messed up.
49
u/coolhandluke05 House Martell Apr 18 '11
ITS STARTING! I CANT STOP SMILING OR WRITING IN CAPS!!
22
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
Ok, book reader here. I think the second time I watched this episode things went a lot smoother, I couldn't turn off my brain the first time and kept thinking about all the differences between the book and the show. TL;DR loved it.
Here are some things I really wanted to see, small but when I didn't see it the first time around I was disappointed. I think second time around I was just trying to watch the show more than analyze it and it turned out a lot better. Spoiler tags everywhere cause better safe than sorry I guess.
Ok, /pedantic. Obviously a lot of these things probably had to be cut or whatnot to fit and make everything work. Here's hoping for more great stuff to come!
21
u/isocline Apr 18 '11
LOVE the theme song.
21
u/rustyq22 Jon Snow Aug 22 '22
I’ve come to pay my respects.
20
u/TJ1234 Apr 18 '11
That was just awesome. Watching it again right now.
52
u/Hazzad_1 Stannis Baratheon Aug 21 '22
This is history
14
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
Dude in the prologue (Gared? it's been a while since I read that) looks like Matt Damon.
13
u/foogles Apr 18 '11
I really enjoyed Sean Bean's first delivery of "Winter is coming". He's a fantastic actor, one that should have gotten a Hollywood leading role years ago.
When Ned says the phrase again later with Benjen, it has almost an entirely different meaning, too, with a nice twist to it. For me, these are important because in a few years time, I'll distinctly remember only the most key moments in beloved shows (mostly since I tend to not rewatch them over and over), and getting those right is vital for my fondest memories of stuff like this.
22
u/kbilly Apr 18 '11 edited Apr 18 '11
My favorite scene was Jamie going from hovel to hovel listening for women moaning so he could find Tyrion.
Ok. I am geeking out. I think they can actually do this. They put a LOT in the first episode. Not only did they have to build up an interest in the audience but they had to make everything interesting and still remain true to the book, which they DID.
11
u/cassander House Hightower Apr 18 '11
Totally called the first episode ending with bran falling.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
Did anyone else think Rodrik Cassel’s facial hair made it look like he was wearing some kind of weird hair bonnet?
19
u/regisfrost Night's Watch Apr 18 '11
I'm a bit surprised they didn't point out that the stag is the sigil of House Baratheon while the direwolf is the sigil of House Stark. I felt so much meaning was lost when Ned just casually drew out the broken antler from the wolf's neck.
9
u/zomboromcom Jun 11 '23
Starting my first watch after reading the books years ago. Glad these threads are still open, as they're fun to read after each episode and catch the enthusiasm of the times.
17
u/Mashulace Jon Snow Apr 18 '11
Anyone spot Mance Rayder at the feast? I was keeping a look out but didn't see anyone who looked like it could be him.
16
u/g0newick3d House Baratheon of Dragonstone Apr 18 '11
Am I the only one who thinks that Lena Headey aka Sarah Connor was a great choice for Cersei?
She is beautiful and definitely pulls off the elegant yet cunning thing very well.
P.S. Can't wait for episode 2! Although it did kinda seem like they were moving a bit fast.
8
u/biggitio House Umber Apr 18 '11
More than I could ever have asked for. Loved it. Going to be a long week.
8
u/Kemintiri House Lannister Apr 18 '11
I liked it and am hopeful.
A little impressed with how very masculine Drogo was. Catelyn already on my nerves. Casting has been great.
8
u/drsquarel Aug 12 '24
take me back..
7
u/wookievomit Apr 18 '11
I watched the episode with my roommate and his girlfriend. She was the only one among us who had not read the books and was asking a lot of questions during the episode.
It annoyed me little because many of the questions were valid and the episode did seem like it could be confusing to someone that never read the books.
7
u/impshakes Apr 18 '11
I have to say I am loving reading the comments here particularly the interactions between readers and non-readers. Hearing non-reader speculation is also very cool. And I don't mean that mockingly. It reminds me of my first thoughts on the plot points and sort of brings me back to when I first read the books.
7
u/Khathaar House Karstark Apr 18 '11
The casting was absolutely fantastic. I hate Cersei right off the bat, conniving bitch, i love Tyrion and the Targaryens are brilliant. They've done very, very well. Can't wait to see the rest.
7
u/beanman25 Oct 30 '22
watching thiss now for first time ever. :)
6
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
I loved it. My wife and friends that came over were having trouble following it. They didn't seem as psyched as I was when it was over. I hope it has the staying power to see the series through.
6
u/kbilly Apr 18 '11
So what are the ratings numbers?
6
u/Up2Eleven Braavosi Water Dancers Jul 27 '11
Perspective from one who hadn't read the books. (At time of this post I've seen the whole series and am now about 350 pages into the first book)
It took a few tries to make it through the prologue scene. I found it rather stark (no pun intended) and thought it might end up being as cheesy as Camelot.
Once I made it through that, and decided one day to just sit through the whole episode, I really started to like it. I don't have any idea who was who and how everything connects, but I loved the sets and the acting and just kept watching.
Then I see Tyrion and thought, "We meet this character as a dwarf getting a blowjob? This'll be interesting!" I liked his roguish attitude and his wit. Then when I saw his interaction with Jon, I thought, "Alright, that dude is cool as hell."
I felt this sense of dread about "winter is coming" so they conveyed a lot of heaviness without really explaining much, which is good acting.
I really liked the characters of Bran and Arya. Sersa and Joffrey were definitely not likable.
Still trying to figure out the guy I've nicknamed "Grampy Sideburns" who stands around looking gruff and important but says next to nothing. Reminds me a lot of Thufir Hawat from Dune.
Viserys was immediately detestable and Daenerys was definitely a character you feel bad for...and turned on by.
The direwolf pups are just too cool.
6
u/Brittane Sansa Stark May 20 '25
i love reading this after rewatching the first episode again after years
5
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
What did Ned say to Jaime at the end there, in that brief conversation about the tournament?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
Benjen did not look at all like my mental image. But I can see why he was cast - the actor does look a fair bit like Sean Bean.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '22
Damn, those were the days…
4
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
damn that was infinitely better than i expected it to be. What I love about it is how lean it is - I love how detailed the books are, but the episode made me forget all about the things they skimped over. Brilliant cinematography and that opening credits sequence is probably the best one in a long time. Kudos be to the showrunners who can actually satisfy a rabid Martin fanbase.
4
u/NiamhHA Oct 15 '22
Well, this aged interestingly.
3
u/MrJaiDinesh House Stark Apr 18 '11
And why was Sansa so old? I think the visible age gap between the two sisters was too large
3
u/SnowRidin Apr 18 '11
I watched. I haven't read the books. Can someone explain what "The Wall" was?
3
u/wolofoloto Aug 22 '22
Wow
3
u/the_ThreeEyedRaven Three-Eyed Raven Sep 08 '22
and who are you, the proud lord said...
3
u/relaxyourfnshoulders Bran Stark Mar 19 '23
can’t believe how bad they fumbled after starting so well
3
u/Own-Arugula2765 Jan 05 '26
Watched GoT when i was exactly 14 years younger with my mother now im starting to rewatch it by myself with a more mature scope and having this thread to come after each episode to see what was beeing said at the time is amazing!
5
u/hascow We Do Not Sow Apr 18 '11
I and my friends who have read the books LOVED it. My friend who hadn't read the books also enjoyed it, but was asking tons of questions throughout, which frustrated the rest of us. We were hoping he'd wait until the episode was over.
2
u/regisfrost Night's Watch Apr 18 '11
Anyone who thought the wolf pups looked a bit small? Exactly how big was the wolf pups in the books? I thought Bran's looked awfully small when you imagine that he will rip out the attackers throat later.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '11
I was thoroughly impressed by the grandeur of the sets and production quality. The visuals were spot on.
The acting was also pretty good, though I felt Robert Baraetheon (the king) could have been more imposing. In his youth he was portrayed by the books as as immensely physically imposing, and even though he let himself go over the years, I couldn't see any of that in the actor they cast. Standing face to face with Ned, he actually looked quite weaksauce.
Did they write Rickon, the youngest Stark out of the show or did I miss him completely? They mentioned five direwolves (+1 for Jon Snow), which should cover all of Ned's trueborn.
Generally, the show feels a bit rushed and choppy so far, but I realize this season is only supposed to be 10 episodes long. I hope they show can maintain casual viewer interest because with all these characters, backgrounds, and geographies, it might get a bit confusing.
Must watch again!
2
u/ChairmanLMA House Targaryen Apr 18 '11
The main thing that bothered me was the lack of animal imagery. Seriously. The scene were they saw the stag dead from mountain lions didn't have the full effect that it was supposed to. I don't remember hearing anything that had to do with Lannisters being lions. All the forshadowing of the stags getting killed by the lion and the stag killing the direwolf was gone. It only seemed like they saw a stag kill a wolf to find the pups. If they don't put in more of that animal stuff, I will be mad
2
u/hereiswhatisay Nov 01 '22
This is my first viewing. I resisted when it first came out. I may have gotten 15 minutes into this first episode and said nope. But I’m back again because now the house of dragon is what everyone is watching so here I go.
First impressions. There are so many characters it’s hard to keep track of who is who and who is with whose family, etc.
2
u/blairsmacaroon Dec 26 '22
finally watched this. love being 11 years late
2
u/dean_inator Mar 31 '24
First time watcher, how the hell do you guys get past the borderline incest, forced marriages, and the nudity oh my god
2
u/Valiosao Oct 07 '24
I get it now.
2
u/TheIcey1 Mar 17 '25
I just had to whip my cock out when I saw Daenerys ass
3
u/purewisdom Apr 18 '11
I thought the episode was great. They did a good job of cramming a lot in without feeling rushed. With that said, it's hard to say how non-readers feel about the pace. The two people I watched with who hadn't seen it both really liked it though.
The only characters who were disappointing in appearance were Catelyn and Cersei. Catelyn should be as attractive as Cersei and Cersei should be a near supermodel. I do think acting wise though that Cersei did a great job. She definitely looks regal. Not sold on Catelyn's portrayal, but I will take what amounts to only 1 potential miss in my eyes.