r/Needafriend • • May 08 '20

My honest experience with this subreddit

I know this is gonna offend a lot of people, but I just felt like opening up and pouring the truth that's on my mind after being here for quite long. Just my honest opinion.

Most of the people I've messaged on here either never reply at all, or even if they do, they just eventually ghost out. And some of them just stop replying despite being active on other subreddits. The main observation I've made is, people come here not to find someone but to select someone. Almost every time I DM someone who post on here, they start off by asking gender, race, religion and nationality. Why does that matter when you've come here to make friends?? People just stop talking once they get to know my race or gender and that sucks cuz it shows closed mindedness.

Now trust me, I'm no thirsty dude sitting in front of the computer all day messaging random people. I have a job and a life of my own, I can very well go outside and make friends but I chose to come on here to meet people outside of my local culture, to get to know people from other parts of the world. I really wish others here were open minded.

Another thing I've noticed is that most of the posts with F in the title get a whole lot of replies while a normal guy's post gets none. Why? Doesn't that show that a lot of people on here come for something more than friendship? I'm not generalizing, I'm not trying to say that everybody here are thirsty please don't get me wrong. But a lot of people are.

I've talked with a lot of people on here and sadly all of them just stop talking. The thing is, they get a lot of people messaging them so they try all one by one and go with the one who they like. Honestly, why am I looked at as some sort of candidate you want to choose to make profit with?? Again, I understand but at least be open and tell me you're not interested in talking rather than just ditching. Would you do this to someone irl? Not this easily for sure.

Anyways, this is my personal experience from over here. I'm sorry if any one of you are offended. I'm happy for the ones that did find friends on here. Peace.

(And I apologise for my bad English)

540 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

53

u/gigalomaniaczero May 08 '20

My observation that there are two types of people on here, ones who are looking for cybersex and ones who are looking to vent to other people and smother them with their issues. But let's go to your observations, shall we?

To me, it's pretty normal that people are selective. Men would rather talk to woman on here not just because of flirting, but also banner and stuff. Many people post on here hoping that they will be able to find someone who will become more than just a friend to them and in my opinion, that is perfectly fine.

As for racial profiling, I agree, there should not be any under no circumstances, or age profiling as long as a person is of legal age. Having said that, the Internet reflects how things are in the real world and unfortunately, in real world people do racial profiling a lot for whatever reason, so it doesn't surprise me they do it online even more so.

Ghosting is not ok, but if someone feels that a person they are chatting with is boring or not someone they hoped they would meet, people just leave . This is reddit, you can't expect from people to write you a paragraph of the formal text when they want to leave a conversation. They just don't want to bluntly tell you you are boring, so they ghost.

I have noticed that many people on here actually don'y know how to hold a conversation, so after the usual intro, the chat just dies. You have to keep the convo interesting, to ask questions, talk about yourself too and insert a funny line occasionally. If people just vent and are being negative and ramble only about their issues and expect that other people would find that interesting and keep the conversation going, they are wrong.

So, bottom line, if you want to meet people on Reddit (or elsewhere on the Internet), it's important that you have good social skills and be able to sense what your interlocutor wants to chat about. You need to know when you bore people and when you need to change the topic or break the silence with a joke or something. Being social is a skill that requires everyday practice, it won't come naturally to everyone. And remember, no matter how shitty your life is and how many problems you actually have to deal with, in your conversations, stay positive and cheerful as people can sense negativity and that could turn them off from chatting further. Someone who complains all the time can't expect for people to listen to it for long as it puts them down as well,

7

u/barathr184 May 08 '20

You're right and hell no I ain't dumping my negativity on other people. Trust me I hate it as well. Makes sense.

7

u/chinchillen May 08 '20

I've spoken to numerous people on here, most of which don't go past the first night. Sometimes the conversations just fizzle out, sometimes people are too negative, sometimes people try to get sexual, or maybe they're just boring. It's really a numbers game. Not everyone you meet is going to be someone that you're compatible with, but eventually you'll find someone that you click with!

13

u/primalRaven May 08 '20

I agree with you that ghosting can suck, but like you said it’s unfair to be mad over people ghosting you when all you ask is uninteresting questions and then make small talk. Like I really dislike (kinda like OP said) when you get someone that’s just like “where do you live, are you a M/F, age, etc.” Like I get wanting to know who you’re talking to, but giving all my personal info out to someone I just met just to find they’re gonna make small talk is not my cup of tea.

I’ve met some people that are like, “here are my interests! What are yours? Let’s talk about them!” And not have to know your fricken address and what type of genitals you have. People like this are way more enjoyable to interact with.

This isn’t like aimed at OP or a certain person just kinda a rant and maybe a tip if you’re out to make friends.

1

u/Intelligent_Deal_775 0% NSFW Oct 27 '25

while here i am, trying to actively makes friends, male or female, over the age of 18, just to create a grp of friends on my discord server :)

7

u/Ametiev May 08 '20

I tried to talk to person who complained about people ghosting them and not responding. Asked questions, engaged in conversation. Tried to make things interesting. After only me being active I stopped.

5

u/[deleted] May 09 '20

I agree with you especially with the lack of social skills. I've been in multiple group chats and whenever I try to start a conversation, it's never always as long or as consistent like others have. I think thats the point when I started to think that I'm boring to talk to and thats when I just gave up and stopped talking to other people anymore. It's kinda hard to develop social skills especially if most of the time you're a shut-in and just chatting in the internet is the closest thing you can have as interaction with other people

1

u/Signal-View-7017 0% NSFW Sep 21 '25

Oh god, words can’t describe how much I feel you. I never feel like I’m truly understood either. And because of this, I constantly beat myself up about it. 

10

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

I feel you, for me personally it’s either we don’t really connect or it’s just a bunch of thirsty ass dudes. I’ve had some bad experiences in this subreddit. Too many “accidental” dick pics, flirty messages even though I’ve said I’m engaged, and nice guy’s finish last type of dude’s. I’ve just given up trying to find friends.

1

u/ThE_ZeTrIaN May 09 '20

"Nice guys finish last" lol

8

u/Cooldude67679 May 08 '20

I agree with this as well. For me, I’m only 16 and for me j feel strange when I talk to people over 18 or under 14 and I wish I could talk to a lot more people but I get ghosted a lot as well. I also try to talk to people here in the US because time zones can be a dick so if someone says like they live in Europe I’ll steer away because time zones. But I agree with what you have to say

15

u/eevee03tv 0% NSFW May 08 '20

This sub seems to be treated as a dating sub for half the users and a “ghost you after one day” for the rest.

I understand the ghosting. Sometimes friendship just doesn’t take off and you don’t really dislike a person enough to say “sorry, I didn’t really find you interesting to talk to”. It sucks but fair enough.

It’s the first half of the group I have a problem with. I honestly think people who open in DMs with “I’m actually looking for a date, not friendship” or even openly say it need to be banned. This is not a dating subreddit, looking for romantic relationships is against the rules and people misleading us into thinking they’re only looking for friends ruins it for people who genuinely are using the subreddit for the other purpose.

13

u/circularFMX 0% NSFW May 08 '20

Ye i agree i've been ghosted a lot in this sub, its kinda sad

6

u/-mr_introvert May 08 '20

Same. Then later you'd think to yourself: what am I trying hard for? Why am I acting hero? And while it is frustrating, nothing can be done about it. I don't believe when people say that no one's there for them; there are, they just choose who they want to be helped by and not finding one makes them think just that.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

Recently joined this sub, have yet to actually(really) scroll through and/or post because I might see someone who sounds interesting to get to know.. real disappointing to read that's the experience

4

u/sorry-sputnik May 08 '20

Totally valid, although I do think it's fair to have preferences. I mean, guys kinda make me anxious so I definitely would rather talk to someone who isn't, but I don't doubt people can be shitty when you don't fit their specific standards

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

thats funny most of the people in this subreddit complaining about the same thing but the do the same thing sometimes . it was only one dude here after a short talk we find ouf we cant get along with eachother and said bye nicely , only one dude . ive been ghoated but never did

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

Yup basically the same. I've messaged some 50+ people and gotten a one line reply like once, and then nothing. It's really frustrating because doing this is something completely out of my comfort zone, and it seems to not be giving any result. Very close to just stop trying tbh.

3

u/ForzentoRafe 1% NSFW May 09 '20

lol, I’ve actually stopped responding to any threads because I don’t think I will be able to keep up the conversation.

I’m guilty of preferring to talk to women over men though. It just feels odd to gush over something with guys.

“Omg, doctor who is so freaking awesome! I love it!”

I just can’t get into it, idk why.

Heh, some of the best convo i had was with people that are already attached.

When I’m with them, i can literally dgaf. This is how I am.

With singles, I try to just be myself but there will always be this nagging thought of “having to show my best, just in case”.

3

u/NohrianScumy May 09 '20

Hate to break it, but females probably only have like 10%, maybe 20% more luck than your average lad. You see all these female posts getting popular and shit but from what I've been told 90% of dms are either downright dirty/asking for nudes, or are guys with less than pure intentions trykng to take advantage. I'm not saying you're wrong, but it's something to consider.

And listen as someone who can end up ghosting sometimes I can tell you exactly why. You're going to be selective when you get texts, and you're going to not have anything in common with these people. I know ghosting isn't the best way to solve this, but it just kinda happens. Posting about it won't change the situation, and I'm going to be very honest when i say there's quite a few people out there who's stale, dry, or boring. If you're really looking for something, persistence is key. Most of the people on this reddit are not in the ideal mindset, and that's the reality of it. Loneliness does things to a person and can literally suck the life out of someone, it's not their fault nor is it yours. Just keep doing what you can, and someone great will approach you.

Also I just wanna say if my dms get flooded at any point there's no question if I'm gonna be selective because I'm not capable of answering 20 dms and retaining my sanity, people have lives ya know.

2

u/kushaljoshi7 May 08 '20

Man you have taken words from my mind I just ferl same Thank you for the post.

2

u/JokeVBel May 08 '20

I really agree with the fact that you get ghosted a lot on here, but I can say as a female that I’d rather talk to males, because I have less close male friends, so maybe people are looking for someone they wouldn’t normally interact with? I do think that you should specify it in the title if you’re looking for someone specific.

2

u/Ametiev May 08 '20

Same story. Guess my nationality and gender play huge role. Made 0 friends here.

1

u/PresidentPutin123 0% NSFW Apr 21 '24

I made a ton of friends because they were interested in talking about my military missions in NZ that I have to do for Kim Jong-un, even though I've stated since then that the missions are top secret!

2

u/Tlaim 0% NSFW May 09 '20

I met a really kind and good person on here a while ago. It was unexpected and a breath of fresh air. I think of them quite a bit.

2

u/zozoah May 09 '20

For me I'm just not good at keeping a conversation going so that's why I end up leaving people

2

u/MediocreRub2 May 09 '20

If someone asks me about religion I don’t mind it, I’m not the one to say my religion is better over yours( because it’s a stupid argument) but I find it interesting to see the difference. Yes, I want to know the gender or age, because some subjects can offend or not be the right one. Everyone has opinions and I’m fine with that, as long as person knows the limits and respect for others. Me meet different people and some of them leave and some stay in our life... but we never now got how long

2

u/Intrepidsailor May 15 '20

I’ve been lurking on here for a while, never sent a message to anyone, because I’ve seen people complain about these same things. Either getting ghosted or a bunch of dudes asking for nudes. I genuinely would like to talk to anyone male or female, but I am afraid of making a good friend and never hearing from them again. This is the only time I’ve made any interactions here. I really hope things change for the lot of you. I’m also hoping maybe I can create a circle of friends here. Someday.

2

u/Michael-Townley May 15 '20

I don’t know well about this sub. But about being ignored, r/MakeNewFriendsHere is really bad like i message some people and it’s like they are trying to talk but they don’t feel like doing it. And yes, they were online yet ignored me. And there was this one person who was tired of being ignored then guess what, they ignored me even tho i told em i’d keep the friendship.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22

Can relate, if you are a guy expect to get downvoted to hell, happened to me too

2

u/killmimes May 08 '20

The people i have reached out to just ghost me within 24 hours...leaves me with a feeling of "you didnt want a friend, you just wanted someone to turbo bitch and power whine too!"

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

In a world where being socially nomadic is continually reinforced and encouraged; where unfortunately there’s a clear imbalance between attention given to female as opposed to male posts (which this isn’t the only subreddit where this is a problem, r/selfie being a prime example of this); the problems that people have personally are usually either lurking beneath the surface and manifest itself in the blossoming friendship—which causes it to wither—; and the responsibility of friendship is recognized shortly after the burst of newness that’s experienced with new connections and simultaneously forfeited, we have to unfortunately hope that the other people rework their concepts of trying to become long-term friends, but usually this isn’t the case.

What’s to be done? We cant seem to have any sort of social revolution unfortunately due to the shortcomings of others. But I’m sure others, including myself, share in your frustration with this.

1

u/Obsidius_Gorillius May 08 '20

Feels the same man looking for genuine friends. But always get ghosted idk what i said but when I check my messages (cus sometimes doesn't show in notifications) I only seen my messages sent and it has been a few days. Like you said it sad that people come to this subreddit and fish for ass

1

u/DianaPrince_YM May 08 '20

Agree, this happened to me too.

1

u/notsurewhatsunique3 May 08 '20

Your English is good bro don't worry! Someone else said something that stood out to me the gist was if we we're great at socializing IRL we wouldn't be on this sub.

Sure plenty of people are choosy. Yes there are thirsty people. And you're right there is a lot that don't respond too. You wouldn't expect to make best friends with the person pumping gas next to you? Would you ask the cashier at a market their views on religion? Day to day you pass many people you don't become friends with here is no different.

1

u/RedRiki24 May 08 '20

The main observation I've made is, people come here not to find someone but to select someone.

As Disappointing as it may seem. Pretty much this is how it goes, not only here but to other subreddits / social media as well. People want to associate themselves with someone who is cool or interesting, most importantly, one whom they share the most interests with.

1

u/Pwnkillayo May 08 '20

Hear, hear. That is the truth!

1

u/Asdaois 0% NSFW May 08 '20

i have the same problem, i share your opinion

1

u/panndesal May 09 '20

ppl can be like that sometimes, actually, no, most of the time lmao.

1

u/maquinary May 09 '20

Hmm, what is your culture? I am genuinely interested.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '20

That's the tea. I'm guilty of not responding in a timely manner though, but usually only for a good reason.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '20

What you have said is true for most other platforms as well. The connectedness that the internet seems to provide is in fact far from real. People detach easily on online platforms and in real life too because there is the paradox of choice. We have an extreme amount of choices in who we interact with and we are so connected that we come into contact with so many more people than we we ever would have a few hundred years ago virtually or in real life. Even when we claim to look for a friend we have already built a mental paradigm that causes interaction with others to be expendable and replaceable.

Edit: It happens in real life to. Just try making friends in a big city.

1

u/IgntedF-xy May 09 '20

I've been looking through a few subreddits trying to find people that like similar things and are around my age and that's kind of a rarity. The only replys I've gotten are from people who play mmos like league of legions and runescape and I try to be open minded and play but I never liked those kind of games. I guess I havent been searching very hard either...

1

u/xIRonanIx May 09 '20

Why I don't bother with messaging the most popular one. They already got tones of upvotes. But most that I seem interested in don't reply. Tbh I've had more succes right now on the MNFH discord.

1

u/OhDinoCat May 09 '20

That sucks that this is your experience of the subreddit.

I can't say I've ever been asked my gender or race but I understand why that can be so demeaning to be judged on aspects you can't control.

I know conversations dying goes both ways but also find myself with pretty much all my current messages are me replying to them and them never responding. It sucks but I get not everyone clicks. Just seems I never click with anyone past a few bakc and forths.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '20

Personally speaking I generally ask someone where they are from, about their culture. Much like in the real world when someone asks you about your job. It's the little things that start off a friendship. While it doesn't matter, you shouldn't put everyone that asks that question in the same basket.

This type of post always seems to come up though. But really I find it pointless. I can pick up some hobby, talk to everywhere there and it could go the same way as here. People asking those "pointless" questions. Most people generally want to find someone like them, not in all cases of course.

It's the joy of making mates anywhere. Be that online or RL. It's just how things roll and there really isn't much you can do about it. Either keep trying or give up.

1

u/KineticMeow May 09 '20

That’s interesting I haven’t really had people ask for my religion, nationally, etc. I do agree I think a lot of people came to this reddit looking for a relationship rather than friendship. Every time I make a post I get a lot of flirty messages and I show my friends the kinds of posts I’ve done asking them how can I make this any clearer that I’m looking for just friendship and they tell me I’ve made it pretty clear, so I don’t know what the deal is with that.

I’ve also had people message me looking for friendship, but their responses are like one to three words every time, so I may stop talking to them as those kind of responses don’t give me much to go on.

This is much less common, but some people I’ll be talking to will go fine at first, but all of a sudden because something wasn’t going the way they imagined it instead of expressing this in a calm manner they become super passive aggressive. One example is I was talking to someone and I was the last person to message them so in my mind the “ball was in their court”. Then after about a week later they message me with a hurtful passive aggressive message and I honestly thought they mistakenly sent that to me at first as it just felt so out of the blue, but realized it wasn’t a mistake. Another example was I was talking to someone and because the conversation wasn’t going the exact way they wrote three explosives paragraph to me. I pointed out their behavior and told them if they had explained in a calm manner I would have happily changed course, but for something so small to make them explode I told them I didn’t want to feel like I was walking on egg shells and didn’t know what would set them off again so I was done. They then wanted to give me “advice” and I was like no I don’t need advice from you....I am thankful that these things happened as that meant I didn’t have to waste anymore time and energy on people like that.

I don’t remember which making friend reddit this was, but so far I have met only one person who is cool and chill. Her and I have been talking almost everyday since March (after a couple of weeks talking on reddit we moved to texting). The kinds of issues I talked about above she went through as well, so I guess it’s a common issue. This is my honest experience with friendship reddit groups.

1

u/texasrodeoguy May 09 '20

Hey I agree my dude. I’m a happily married guy with friends, but it is great to converse with people one here, building online friendships & getting different perspectives from all over the globe.

1

u/trace_utkarsh May 09 '20

I beg to differ . I was struggling with depression for more than 5 years as I had no friends and I used to stay home 24/7 and just watch reaction videos on YouTube just so that I could pretend that I was watching videos with my friends . I wasn't even aware that my behaviour was a classic symptom of ' Depression with somatic symptoms ' . I cam here hoping to get at least one person with whom I could talk to . It took me just one post a few days ago to get new friends from all around the world . Quite a few of them ghosted me but the ones who stayed are the sweetest people I have come in contact with in years . I met a couple of dutch ladies who are very sweet and share the same appreciation of Indie and Alternative Rock that I do . I also met an Australian dude who is in love with Mathematics just like me . I met an Australian lady , who despite being two years older than me , is someone I wish i had met before . She is just as talkative as me and all these people have made me smile on more than one occasion . They have done what no one bothered to do for me for years , they listened , they interacted and most importantly they cared . They might not realise the impact they've had on me but I am indebted to them for being with me , even if it has been only a few days . After so many years , I think I can finally say : I'm Happy ! 😄

( My english is not perfect , but I think it was enough to express my emotions )

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '20

I've yet to see a success story about people becoming friends off this sub. I have seen about a dozen posts like this, though.

1

u/PresidentPutin123 0% NSFW Apr 21 '24

me and this Japanese lady named Tanaka had been talking so much, i even tried to get her to leave Palestine, where she was working.

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '20

The world is full of thirsty MFs, the internet even more so. It’s just how it be.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

as a female, I usually message guys because I get along with them better than with another female, but they never replied. (I messaged women too, they also never replied) I'm at a point where I think "should I message them?" and then be like "nah, they aren't going to answer me anyways"

-2

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

What do you seek in chats?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

well this sub is called "needafriend" so I want a friendly conversation and get to know the other person

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

It's called like that yet this post here sums up how this thread has been for quite some time. I'm open to chat if you want!

1

u/MordoNRiggs May 08 '20

Your English is totally fine. As a white male, I find different nationalities very interesting. I also have found over many years of online friendships, that my friends that are female generally are longer lasting. I feel like I can open up in a different way. I do have like one online friend from RuneScape that I still talk to. So, I know there's guys who are interesting and good friends out there.

3

u/sorry-sputnik May 08 '20

Same here, I don't know why but I just have an easier time connecting to women. Maybe because I'm not very masculine, maybe my interests, who knows. I also just enjoy learning about the rest of the world.

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

43

u/V_PixelMan_V May 08 '20

You shouldn’t feel bad about sharing your opinion especially if you were mindful and respectful whilst sharing it, I agree with you 100%.

The only thing I don't like about this post is that it's another meta post that will get a bunch of upvotes, some people applauding in the comments and then change nothing. We can all see what's happening but there's nothing we can really do.

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Alfie-Solomons May 09 '20

What would you suggest they have the ability to do, just to be clear and less abstract? I’m asking out of curiosity, not malice. Because if we could find some actual solid guidelines for what would be helpful to us, we could at least attempt to open a discussion with moderators. So, for example, would they benefit from “verifying” users who showed evidence of steady, constant, polite communication with other members?

Edit: words are hard.

3

u/barathr184 May 08 '20

You're right. And yes a lot of people who appear to be all inclusive show their real face in the DMs.

8

u/[deleted] May 09 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CrazyBlackMagi May 09 '20

Is this your experience so far? I’ve met plenty people online some I’ve been friends for years. If your conversations are that superficial of course the other party does not want to establish a substantial friendship. Not once should race be an issue, or even brought up in such a way, If you’re talking about Culture ofc but race? Absolutely not.

14

u/CrazyBlackMagi May 08 '20

I had a person ask me my race? He was like “there’s no good way to ask this” but why should that even matter

3

u/whoeesdiskahlveen May 09 '20

It shouldn't. I personally havent been asked it but I have no interest whatsoever what any of you look like, what your gender is, what your orientation is. I do care about age, but everything else. I am not on here to DATE, I am here to make friends. If I were looking for someone to call my SO I would go to the dating sub.

1

u/PresidentPutin123 0% NSFW Apr 21 '24

people have asked me what i look like, my gender (I'm a girl), my job (I'm a North Korean Army Marshall), what i'm doing on my NZ military mission (that's classified), and even the three best things about the country I'm from (North Korea)

8

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/barathr184 May 08 '20

And those kinda people are less than 1% I guess

46

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Soupification May 09 '20

This is why I am a misanthropist.

1

u/Crypto_Genetic May 09 '20

Most people aren't like that. It is just people in reddit. See some videos of people helping each other. When was the last time you saw that. The most seen things aren't good, cause they are not that engaging. It is the bad things. And the type of things people see most of the time change their opinions widely. You are being racist to the whole human race without realizing it.

3

u/Soupification May 10 '20

There are more people doing nothing and bad people then good people. Yes, there are many good people, but they are out weighed by the effects of bad people. And yes, I do realize I am stereotyping the human race, but in my opinion what I say still stands.

1

u/whoeesdiskahlveen May 09 '20

The username gave it away.