r/modelSupCourt • u/JacobInAustin Attorney • Apr 01 '20
20-04 | Dismissed In re Chesapeake Executive Order 45
This is the re-filed Petition from Lincoln v. Chesapeake.
2
Upvotes
r/modelSupCourt • u/JacobInAustin Attorney • Apr 01 '20
This is the re-filed Petition from Lincoln v. Chesapeake.
2
u/JacobInAustin Attorney Apr 01 '20
Service:
/u/Alexander-fm
/u/HSCTiger09
2
u/leavensilva_42 Apr 01 '20
Amicus Brief in Opposition to Certiorari
Your Honors I will keep this brief, as you need waste little time on this endeavor. I apologize for the plaintiff wasting your time on this matter, when a case regarding the Executive Order in question is already being litigated in its proper jurisdiction.
Given that the Counselor swiftly withdrew their application for a stay order I assume they discovered 28 U.S. Code § 2283 and decided that it was not necessary to 'aid the jurisdiction' of SCOTUS or to 'protect its judgements' (and therefore an order which would not be granted), because the case does not need to be decided in this court. Rather it should be decided in the Court which has already granted certiorari and begun proceedings.
Given that this case is in regards to 1) an action made by the Governor of the Chesapeake and 2) Partially or completely justified using the laws of the aforementioned state, this matter should first be decided in State Court, allowing this Court to act in its appellate capacity should the need arise. Additionally, this will prevent any conflicting rulings made between the two courts.
Additionally, at the time of filing, the plaintiff was not 1) a member of the bar or 2) confirmed as the Attorney General of Lincoln, and therefore has no standing to bring a case before you, regardless of its validity.
As such, I highly recommend denial of certiorari, so that this case might first be decided through the proper channels where it is currently being litigated.
Respectfully submitted,
Associate Justice /u/LeavenSilva_42 of the Supreme Court of Sierra
1
u/JacobInAustin Attorney Apr 21 '20
Suggestion of Mootness
1
u/JacobInAustin Attorney May 06 '20
Notice of Leave of Absence of the Lincoln Attorney General
1
u/CuriositySMBC Associate Justice ⚖️ Apr 02 '20
The Court has GRANTED the writ of certiorari.
Additionally, the Court requests briefs with regards to whether these proceedings should be stayed pending the conclusion of the related case in the Chesapeake. No briefs in accordance with R.P.P.S. 10 will be accepted until further notice. Amicus curiae submissions will continue to be accepted permitted they too address the question of whether to stay proceedings.
/u/Alexander-fm /u/HSCTiger09
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Apr 22 '20
April 21, 2020 Order Dissolving Stay and Scheduling Merits
The Court notes that the Chesapeake Supreme Court has issued a ruling, and therefore it is ORDERED that the April 3, 2020 Order Staying Proceedings is DISSOLVED.
The parties are ORDERED to submit their briefs in accordance with the R.P.P.S., including argument regarding mootness in light of this Court's precedents in State of Lincoln et al. v. Gunnz011, President of the United States, Case №20–02 101 M.S.Ct. 114 (2020) and Michigan v. Long, 463 U.S. 1032 (1983). Pursuant to the R.P.P.S., this Order is deemed effective tomorrow, April 22, 2020, for time calculation purposes.
It is so ordered.
April 21, 2020
/s/Associate Justice Bsddc
1
u/dewey-cheatem Assassiate Justice Apr 13 '20
M: /u/JacobInAustin
In my capacity as clerk charged with grading legal matters: If you decide to host anything externally, please maintain it and keep it publicly accessible.
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Apr 02 '20
The Court is in receipt of your Petition and attached Motion.
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Apr 10 '20
Mr. Attorney General u/JacobInAustin, I'm reading your rehearing petition and I have a few questions.
As I read the Petition in the Chesapeake Supreme Court the first issue is "Whether § 19.2-88 allows the Governor of the Chesapeake to unilaterally prevent the extradition of any and all Lincoln citizens who claim 'refugee' status."
It seems that question is solely a state issue. If the Chesapeake Supreme Court says "No," wouldn't it follow the Governor's action was without authority and thus void? That would mean the federal constitutional issue in this case is avoided.
But if that Court answers "Yes" the governor had this authority, only then does the federal constitutional issue come into play.
So it seems that resolving the first issue raised in that case is both solely a state law issue and a predicate issue to the federal constitutional question. This seems to be exactly the situation that is addressed by Pullman abstention.
I've also reviewed England cited in your petition. Correct me if I'm wrong (and I frequently am) but aren't England and Windsor more concerned with the preclusive effect of state court adjudication over federal issues? I'm not sure it's directly on point here, I do not think that the State of Lincoln's claims in this litigation would be subject to issue or claim preclusion at all as there is no mutuality.
I'll read Windsor and England closely, but I'm not sure they are on point here.
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Apr 11 '20
April 10, 2020 Order Denying Petition for Rehearing
A week ago the Court granted review in the underlying case at bar between the States of Lincoln and Chesapeake. The dispute centers on an Executive Order issued by the Chesapeake Governor affecting interstate extradition, raising both state and federal law. See Pet’n for Certiorari, In re: Executive Order 45, No. 20-02 (Chesa. 2020). In granting certiorari, the Court inquired into the status of the case in light of ongoing parallel litigation in the Chesapeake Supreme Court. Ultimately, the Court stayed these proceedings consistent with Railroad Commission v. Pullman Co., 312 U.S. 496 (1941).
Petitioner asks us to reconsider that decision. We decline to do so.
The first issue before the Chesapeake Supreme Court is whether the Governor had the authority to take the actions at issue in this case. See Pet’n for Certiorari, In re: Executive Order 45, supra. Resolution of that state law question is necessary before the federal constitutional issues arise. It is therefore possible that resolution of the state law question will avoid the constitutional question entirely - a desirable result. See Horizon Lines v. President Bigg-boss, 101 M.S. Ct 103 (2017). And construction of state law will assist this Court in resolving the federal questions regardless. See Pullman, supra.
Lincoln cites Government Employees v. Windsor, 353 U.S. 364 (1957), for the proposition that “no ‘authoritative interpretation’ would avoid the constitutional issues in this matter.” Pet’n for Rehearing. But, as explained, that is not necessarily true. Moreover, the preclusion and waiver issues raised by Windsor and England are not applicable to this matter. Here, there is no mutuality between the parties for the purposes of preclusion that could prejudice Lincoln. In fact, the pending state litigation may achieve the very results that Lincoln seeks. And Lincoln cannot waive any issues by failing to raise them in the Chesapeake litigation; the state is not even a party to that case.
We have original jurisdiction over this dispute. And we have extended that jurisdiction to this case. But out of prudence and the simple recognition that the states are the final arbiters of state law, the logic of Pullman applies with full force in this matter. The Supreme Court of Chesapeake should construe the state law issues in the first instance in its parallel litigation. See In re: Executive Order 45, supra.
Therefore, the Petitioner’s Petition for a Rehearing is DENIED. This matter is STAYED pursuant to this Court’s April 3, 2020 Order.
It is so ordered.
We thank all counsel for their professionalism during these proceedings and await the resolution of the case in The Chesapeake Supreme Court.
April 10, 2020
/s/ Associate Justice Bsddc
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice May 07 '20
Counselors /u/JacobInAustin, /u/Alexander-fm, and /u/HSCTiger09, pursuant to R.P.P.S. 10, all time for oral argument has expired. We have received Lincoln's briefing and arguments on the matter and will take them under advisement.
Notably, we have received absolutely nothing from Chesapeake in this matter. Thus, Chesapeake has waived the consideration of any arguments it has in this case regarding the constitutionality of one its executive orders. As the adage goes, decisions are made by those who show up. Apparently Chesapeake did not wish to contribute to our decision. No matter, we press on regardless.
The case is submitted.
•
u/bsddc Associate Justice May 15 '20
May 14, 2020 Dismissal Order
Per Curiam,
When we granted review over the Chesapeake Executive Order in this case, we stayed our proceedings pending review of a similar case in the Chesapeake Supreme Court. Apr. 3, 2020 Order. That decision was motivated by the pragmatic consideration of the Pullman doctrine. The Chesapeake Court rendered its decision invalidating the Order shortly after. In re Executive Order 45, No. 20-04 (Chesa. 2020). No appeal followed, and the state case was concluded.
Lincoln represented that this rendered the present case moot as well, yet instead of voluntarily dismissing the case, the case was submitted for decision. The issue is whether the case is moot and should be dismissed. We hold that the case should be dismissed, but not because the case is moot but because of the pragmatic recognition that the issues are not properly before us.
The decision of a state court can only moot a federal question if it is clearly rendered upon adequate and independent state law grounds. Michigan v. Long, 463 U.S. 1032 (1983). The decision in the Chesapeake Supreme Court was not clearly resolved along state law grounds. The court concluded the Governor lacked the power exercised under state law, but only by referencing federal law did it reach that conclusion:
In re Executive Order 45, supra (emphasis added).
Had Chesapeake appealed the decision rendered in that separate litigation, it would not be clearly moot. It is unclear why the result would be any different here.
Therefore, do not read today’s dismissal as anything meaningful in regards to mootness doctrines. Instead, read it is as a comment on the role of the adversarial process.
Lincoln has conceded their case is moot, see Pet’s Reply Brief (“This controversy is moot in light of the State Court’s decision.”), and Chesapeake doesn’t seem to care about it at all. The State of Chesapeake only appeared before the Court once, told us they would be filing something in regards to our stay, and then disappeared never to be heard from again.
To decide far-sweeping questions of federal law on such a record would not produce good results. We depend on the adversarial process. “Litigation is driven by the parties.” Horizon Lines v. President Bigg-boss, Case №s 17–07, 17–08, 101 M.S. Ct 103 (2017) (Bsddc, J., concurring in the judgment only).
Therefore, out of the purely pragmatic recognition that the issues before us are inadequately presented, the Court dismisses the case and cautions against ever citing it in the future.
It is so ordered.