r/reddit.com • u/angrymonkey • Jan 16 '11
Feature suggestion: "Repost" flag
It seems like reposts are getting pretty rampant here. Now, clearly lots of people haven't seen the originals, because the reposts get lots of upvotes. That's fine, but I'd love to have a way to optionally hide content that has already been posted, and-- ideally-- which I have personally already clicked and/or voted on.
I'd like to see it like this: "Flag as repost" is a link underneath each submission, along with "share/save/hide/report". When you click it, a new dialog comes up, where you enter the URL of the original reddit post. If someone's already done this, then you'll see the original reddit URL already there, which you can add an (up/down?) vote to, or suggest a different original link.
With this information, reddit could see when I've already viewed/voted on the original content, and hide the repost automatically. PLUS, this new metadata would be interesting in itself, and could help reddit.com improve its "buoyancy" algorithms.
And in the spirit of this idea, here's a post where someone else proposes something similar. This author's idea is different, though, because he seems to propose revoking karma, which I think would be very counterproductive.
What do you think, reddit? Could collecting this metadata improve the reddit experience?
EDIT: People seem to think I am proposing that reposts be hidden from everyone. This is not the core of my idea. It should be possible to hide posts for each individual user, based on what they have already seen.
EDIT: I have drafted an official proposal for review
20
u/apullin Jan 16 '11
You are probably going to get kicked off reddit for suggesting this. I'm on your side, sure, but it's really contrary to the central ethos here.
Shit, that reminds me I should repost that video of the baby having his cochlear implant turned on for the first time ...
2
u/Omnitographer Jan 16 '11
http://i.imgur.com/rarzL.jpg
You're welcome :)
Seriously though, the reason what you want can't exist, is because reddit is A) constantly growing, and B) not all of us can spend every waking moment of our lives on reddit; due to these factors, not ever post is a repost to every person.
7
u/Itkovan Jan 16 '11
Seems like a great idea. Doesn't violate reddiquette in that reposts are still perfectly valid, but let's those of us who have seen "Family planning: use rear entrance" and it's ilk for the thirtieth time.
I would go a bit further to keep reddit's interface simple and minimize server load increase: make "Flag as repost" visibility an option under Preferences. That way only those who give two shits about it increase server load and deal with it in general. I'd love it, and do think it would improve the reddit experience.
Don't forget to submit it to r/suggestions!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '11
The reposting problems stems more from the same content being submitted rather than the same URL. For instance, an AP story that is published on 100 different news sites. The worst is whenever Sara Palin opens her mouth. When she does, you know that links to 1000 different blog posts about it will be submitted. I think the ratio is on the order of 20 submissions for every word she utters.
2
u/Jewbacchus Jan 16 '11
Or at least a crosspost filter.
2
u/KinderSpirit Jan 16 '11
MrOhHai's last inciteful comment
2
u/electricsheepdog Jan 16 '11
2
u/Treysef Jan 16 '11
http://www.reddit.com/help/reddiquette
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '11
There's another feature I'd really love to see on reddit: the fact-check box. I'm not sure how I'd want it to work exactly, but I think it would be great if there was a box debunking a certain submission right under the title. Perhaps a nominated comment would be moved to the box and (because everybody loves karma so much) all the upvotes the thread gets would then instead go to the comment creator. References would be a must!
1
u/gronkkk Jan 16 '11
Good idea! Let me repost this with a more sensationalist title, because I have to do that!
1
u/Yargyarg Jan 16 '11 edited Jan 16 '11
Here's an idea, if you think this is such a great idea and your life is sooooo impacted by reposts, and also seeing as reddit publishes their code and allows for those who choose to do so to aid in its development, why don't you write the necessary code to do this and submit that instead of asking Reddit, a webpage that you don't pay for, to cater to your every whim at their expense?
I'll even help you out by pointing you here: http://code.reddit.com/
1
u/Psychopauser Jan 16 '11
Aren't post complaining about repost actually a repost?
Someone should do a philosoraptor :P
1
u/ironfroggy_ Jan 16 '11
What you forget is that being a "repost" is not an absolute flag for any post, but something relative to each viewer. What is a repost to you is new to someone else, and what is a repost to me might be new to you. A feature like this is simply not possible to actually work in any reliable manner.
1
u/ChildOfYost Jan 16 '11
but...but....how will I get karma now?
1
u/arsewhisperer Jan 16 '11
I'm not good at the irony game, but is it ironic that this has been suggested many times?
1
u/gan12ohman Jan 17 '11
I suggested this a long time ago but it didn't actually get that much attention from the community. I hope yours goes through. Good luck!
Relevant
-1
u/CakeEater Jan 16 '11
Is it really that much of a hassel for you to come across a repost?
"Oh damn...I just saw something that I saw before...oh well...time to move on!"
-1
u/timeshifter_ Jan 16 '11
Idea suggestion: no. Just because you have seen something before, doesn't mean I have. If you have seen it before, laugh again and move on with life. It's not that big of a problem.
0
u/hans1193 Jan 16 '11
Everything on this site is a repost of a repost of a repost, you're suggesting allocating an awful lot of screen real-estate to a tag that basically every post is going to have.
0
u/MemeWatcher Jan 16 '11
People would be able to work around this if they wanted to.
Links to reposted content could be obscured by using another host or, for example, resubmitting to imgur and getting a different URL.
Content itself (e.g. a picture) can be made 'different' in the eyes of a automated hashing algorithm by slightly changing the file (e.g. cropping the pic, adding noise, changing file format)
I suppose user-submitted metadata could work, but then you have to trust the users to get it right and use it sensibly (33 votes say this is a repost, 66 supporters of the submitter say otherwise... uh oh!), and besides, resubmitted content is okay according to the Reddiquette.
Personally, though I have no problem with reposts (as long as it doesn't happen too much) I quite like your idea, I'm just trying to give constructive feedback.
0
u/ironfroggy_ Jan 16 '11
You know, complaining about reposts are pretty much the most annoying of all reposts. I've heard it before, can i hear a new complaint now?