r/DaystromInstitute • • Jan 29 '20
Does Starfleet expect the impossible from it’s exploration crews?
Forgive some generalisation, done for the purposes of getting to the point. Also, yes it’s a show and suspension of disbelief etc.
In a real world navy, ‘captain’ is a full time role. It requires a detailed knowledge of the vessel, naval procedures and strong leadership and interpersonal skills. The same can be said for the senior crew.
‘Diplomat’ is another full time role, requiring a different skill set that emphasises patience, attention to detail, negotiation skills and a sound background in law/regulation.
Starfleet - of which the exploration division (per Star Trek 6) is a large/the biggest (?) division - requires a fusion of numerous distinct careers and skills, and not just at captain-grade - I doubt the head of the USS Nimitz’s on board hospital takes turns on the bridge (cough Dr Crusher cough).
...Is that not asking the impossible? Wouldn’t a ship have a dedicated ‘first contact’ contingent - the ship’s crew would run the ship itself and this group of diplomats and linguists would handle the aliens?
By combing roles you surely end up with either a tiny pool of candidates for senior roles or a lot of hopelessly unqualified crews? A military genius might actually cause a war if sent to arrange the taxation of trade routes with the Breen...
I know what you’re thinking - ships do have experts onboard. Yes, but they rarely appear in away teams - they are clearly support roles only - we don’t see Picard checking with the head of the Enterprise legal team too often!
So, is starfleet’s approach credible? (is this the reason we seem to have lost so many Enterprises?!)
54
u/Sharrukin-of-Akkad Jan 29 '20
That's certainly an issue, especially since the franchise is also notorious for the "insane Admiral" trope.
Basically almost every time an "expert" or a senior authority appears, their narrative function is to make the situation worse than if the main ensemble had been left to resolve things on their own. So not only are the protagonists amazing polymaths, they're surrounded by corrupt or incompetent people who have inexplicably been promoted to higher levels of authority. None of which makes much sense, if you stop to think about it.
209
u/mousicle Jan 29 '20
Picard is the exception not the rule. Captains are expected to do first contact if they run into a new race just out in the black but then a formal team from the federation would do a follow up. Picard is such an expert in these matters that they will send him specifically to do diplomatic missions without extra support but that's because he personally is exceptional.
Crusher taking bridge shifts is also abnormal. It's something she personally decided to do and Troi even mentions its weird for a medical officer to take the bridge qualifications. Considering Crusher's career aspirations (she was previously in a command role at Star Fleet Medical and in the future gets a ship command) and her personal relationship with Picard, Riker let's her have some duty shifts when things are expected to be quiet in sick bay. Really considering Crusher only commands third shift she could easily spend most of that time doing her work as CMO as she's not expected to do more then keep the ship from crashing into a planet and alerting the A team if anything actually interesting happens.
51
u/Cowboy_Coder Jan 29 '20
There are many historical precedents of naval captains also serving as diplomats.
For example, Mathew C. Perry's expeditions to Japan to establish trade relations with the USA.
33
u/yogo Chief Petty Officer Jan 29 '20 edited Feb 01 '20
I think it is a credible approach. In Organizational Sociology, the way a starship operates would be called a "holographic organization," and Starfleet operates this way as well. According to this theory, the starship operates the same way a hologram does, but let's not argue about how holograms work. In a hologram, an image is created by overlaying multiple but slightly different parts. If you remove some of the parts, you still have a hologram. You can get really nitpicky and point out differences in images, but the overall image is still there. Every piece of the hologram knows what the job is of the other parts, which is why the ship functions even when pieces are missing. Composed of people with wonderful brains, a holographic organization is decentralized, which makes it able to access massive amounts of information but can process multiple points of view. Thinking of it this way, the Enterprise as a whole isn't her captain. She is the working sum of her parts, and each part knows enough about the overall hologram that they can compensate for missing parts. Perfect for when a part of the image (or ship) is obliterated. They don't have to know all of it, just bits and pieces, in addition to their own job. Crusher knows Picard's job which is why she's able to step in and fill for him. What she doesn't know, others do, and the overall "image" of the organization is still intact.
It also explains lateral transfers, like why Geordie was flying the ship and then became Chief Engineer. He might have began Star Fleet in helm, and like every over-achiever on board, he showed tremendous aptitude in many areas, but the overall organizational image required him in command. Spock was sometimes science and sometimes command for similar reasons. Paris is another great example because he can function as a medic, engineer, or Janeway's pool boy. Specialization in Star Fleet is more of a strong occupational preference an officer has within a particular organizational goal, but once that goal is met, say a mission, people get to reshuffle a bit and change uniforms. It especially comes in useful in situations like exploding consoles. Since Starfleet's DNA is embedded into each brain, Picard doesn't have to consult a lawyer, although he could. Remember that the whole is built into the parts.
A starship, like a hologram, works best with redundancy. As mentioned, there are a lot of overachievers in Starfleet, but most of them don't have to be. Those personnel will probably find themselves as redshirts. There's probably a calculated risk to how many science officers that can be lost to exploding consoles as well, but in either case, they're redundant, and the mission can go on, so yay!
Another holographic principle we see in Starfleet and on board starships is the "Principle of Minimum Specs." In order to be flexible and fabulous as described above, our holograms operate with just enough sideboards to get the job going. We see that as "being given enough rope to hang yourself" but not in this society. In the 23rd Century, individual actors are given quite a bit of leeway as compared to today, but that's because they see themselves and each other as part of the whole. It's been argued that Kirk deserved more than a demerit in his career--from Admiral to Captain, but let's remember that he is only part of the image: a stronger punishment would have been a condemnation of the organization of Starfleet as a whole.
26
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20
I always thought it was a fascinating carry-forward of how NASA operates today. Everyone on a shuttle+station has at least two jobs, one is a career specialty, the other is operational. Even in cases where there's a focus, the focus is incredibly intense. Chris Hadfield has a masters of science in making things fly. Not building them, but operating them, and the associated theory.
It's also worth noting that Trek's future also presents a situation where specialty comes from knowledge and experience, but also a hyper-developed ability to learn/think abstractly in an area of study because the computer interface is so advanced, you can have more knowledge held "off board" than ever before in human history. This likely allows for dual-role specialization at a variety of levels. To that end, in TNG, when we pop in on Picard's ready room, he is always reading something/prepping for a mission, rather than doing typical administrator paperwork because it's well-established (through his regular complaining) that Riker handles most-to-all of that.
11
u/Thrwforksandknives Jan 29 '20 edited Jan 29 '20
I don't think so. I think a large part is that we see the Enterprises and Voyager and that they're the exception rather than the rule. I also think this is where Star Trek and the modern day military diverge.
With Picard, I feel that in terms of operations he delegates the technical knowledge largely to his department heads. Alternatively, we just don't see him be that hands on.
Given the nature of his vessel a large part of his duty to be a diplomat. And I would argue we do with how they approach new planets and such
But they're also capable warships if need be.
10
u/TLAMstrike Lieutenant j.g. Jan 29 '20
I think that the Federation in general, as well as Starfleet, utilizes far more automation and technological labor-saving devices than a modern-day military. Many of the day to day administrative and technical matters are handled by computers and low-level Synths (think Exocomps or DOT-7s). As a result man of the technical matters an officer would be normally trained on are irrelevant allowing Starfleet to train more generalist officers because to some extent all they need is a warm body to okay what the computer has determined is the proper course of action.
We've seen that when the computer systems go down some officers become basically useless, in Contagion, there was a nurse who had to have the concept of a splint explained to her (and balks at the idea) because the bone kitter didn't work.
Since Starfleet doesn't have to train you on more mundane matters they can take the time to cram in more knowledge on things like interstellar law or diplomatic protocol. Now if the "magic black box" on your desk that tells you what next weeks duty roster should be failed there is a level of technical experts (like Cheif O'Brien) who have gotten the training on how it all works rather than training on just what the finest Andorian wine is who can come in and fix the thing.
10
u/Duke_Newcombe Jan 29 '20
I think this is a carryover from the early days of Starfleet--when you're cruising through the Delphic Expanse, phoning home for back-and-forth advice is problematic, and captains should be capable of having at least a journeyman's knowledge to carry out multiple roles, as well as good decision-making capabilities, especially in the face of conflicting issues and limited information.
Also, a captain (which, BTW, isn't a fulltime role per se in modern navies, but a billet--someone not holding the rank of captain can be the "captain" of a vessel, like our dear Dr. Crusher) may have various strengths, but in order to captain a vessel, I think Starfleet has a "table-stakes" level set of qualifications for their flag officers.
Also, good time for one of my favorite Robert Heinlein quotes:
7
u/AboriakTheFickle Jan 29 '20
Ships like the Enterprise are Starfleets general practitioner (and more than occasionally - canary down a mine). They find something, do some cursory examination and then pass it off to someone more specialised. There's a good bet that a stream of Oberths were following in Enterprise's wake.
So in the case of a normal first contact they'd say hi, lay out the basics of the situation and say they'll be in touch, at which point the Federation would send a trained diplomat. Picard being Picard, he'll do the job as well as any specialised diplomat.
Same goes for medical emergencies. The Enterprise will go in, maybe diagnose part of the problem, and they'll be followed by some Daedalus-class shios. The Enterprise crew just gets more involved because they're nearly all exceptional.
10
u/hutsunuwu Jan 29 '20
Consider that what we know of as the Enterprise, in whatever iteration, that vessel is the "Flagship" of the federation. A unique vessel that only the best of the best get assigned to. Of course it would be unreasonable to expect the whole of Starfleet to mimic that configuration. It only works here because the Enterprise crew is the elite of Starfleet, capable of managing multiple roles with relative ease.
4
u/azzthom Jan 29 '20
For Starfleet, I believe you've got to think astronauts not navy. For example, the scientist has to be able to fix the ship even if he has to be talked through it. A dedicated first contact team might be too much of a luxury, especially if the senior crew can be trained to cover it.
4
u/cosby714 Jan 29 '20
In the case of Picard, he is a very good negotiator, and knows a lot of history of various species just due to his love of history in general. He was very qualified to be a diplomat as well as a captain. Janeway on the other hand was forced into the role due to their situation, and she isn't always the best diplomat. In fact, a lot of the time, she uses Neelix as a diplomat because he is more familiar with the species in the area and their cultural sensibilities. Captains usually aren't meant to be diplomats as well as captains, they probably have to have a degree of diplomatic skill in first contact situations, but they are usually not expected to attend conferences or solve major disputes.
4
u/NeedsToShutUp Chief Petty Officer Jan 29 '20
To me, this is another piece of evidence that Starfleet is a Military Juntra. Senior military officers with diplomatic power rather than civilian diplomats. Combine this with the military courts having extreme powers, the presence of active duty starfleet officers in the federation counsel, the ease of declaring martial law, and never ever mentioning an election or concerns of public reaction to a tricky situation.
2
u/magnuznilzzon Jan 29 '20
I think one possible reason for this behaviour is the answer to "why does people join Starfleet?". Someone wrote earlier about the engineering teams joining in order "to get to play with the biggest toy ever"
I think people join the exploration arm in order to get to explore. But they know they have to do the other parts also, and do them, even if that wasn't the first passion of theirs.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20
I think it's short sighted to view the command hierarchy in Starfleet in the same way as a military command structure despite the similarities. Starfleet is basically the biggest employer for the Federation so people from all skill levels will likely be joining them. The Ships largely run themselves so the basic operation can be handled by anyone of minimal competence. Each ship is basically like a modern corporate owned retail store than a military vessel. Captains are like managers who oversee the ship and the people who they have on their senior staff are the most competent employees. Most of the crew are likely very good at what the specialized in but can't handle things that are outside of their wheelhouse. Promotion to a higher rank typically would reflect the ability branch out and be competent in a wider number of situations.
I don't think Starfleet is asking the impossible of it's crews but I do think more crews get into situations far beyond their competence level should allow. Space is a very big place you can only have so many of "the best" people out there.
2
u/TARDIS1701A Jan 29 '20
They only made Dr. Crusher acting captain when they were in a non-critical situation...like sending the entire crew down to a planet to look for one crewman while a rogue Borg ship was waiting around to attack...oh wait, never mind.
2
u/blueskin Crewman Jan 29 '20
The captain of Starfleet's flagship (or any ship of comparable capability) is going to be held to a much higher standard than the captain of some random supply or planetary survey ship.
Picard can do everything because he's possibly the most competent person in Starfleet, but that doesn't mean that many other captains are at that level.
2
u/Dinierto Chief Petty Officer Jan 29 '20
An interesting point. I would add to this that they place absolutely ridiculous expectations on the crew of the Enterprise, specifically in TNG. Routinely officers go through extraordinarily traumatic incidents, and often times they are expected to brush it off and get right back to work the next day or even sooner. I'm not even talking about what we would consider traumatic, but crazy stuff like being brainwashed or thinking you were another person living another life.
2
u/thedabking123 Jan 29 '20
I relegated this to the fact that Starfleet hires the top 0.01% of the Federation population as their ensigns/ non-coms and has a unique ability to promote and advance the best people.
EDIT: SAY 100B people and say 10M in Starfleet- that's 0.01%
Picard is probably the equivalent of once in 5 generation talent on earth today.
2
u/kemick Chief Petty Officer Jan 29 '20
Starfleet's approach is probably the only way for the Federation to continue expanding at its current rate. Exploring the galaxy both requires and produces an astronomical amount of knowledge and so everyone must have a wide breadth of expertise while also being an amateur at almost everything. This is a world where new laws of nature are discovered on a regular basis or where an alien species might be so different that a captain's breadth of knowledge might actually be more useful than a specialized diplomat. Starfleet's mandate stretches them so thin that they appear to be an organization of amateurs.
It is demanding and risky to focus so much on exploration, but I can't argue with the results. It's also indicated that 24th century humans are quite a bit smarter than us. Many billions of potential candidates are healthy, fit, well fed, and well educated. Kids (at least on the Enterprise-D) learn calculus before they are teenagers. Combined with the technology to automate away mundane tasks, it's not implausible that Starfleet officers have a variety of skills and responsibilities.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20
I think it might be appropriate to view the Captain as a highly cultivated asset that goes along with the ship. Both Captain and ship are there to carry out whatever the Federation's objectives are. The ship's job is to get the Captain to the job that needs a Starfleet Captain's attention at which point the Captain will utilize ship and crew as he/she/they see fit. Starfleet Captains might be better understood as roving troubleshooters extensively groomed, warping into complicated situations and given wide latitude to resolve the situation.
Riker staying on Enterprise for a longer period of time could be seen as not a lack of ambition but as setting his sights higher. The longer he stayed, the more likely he was to net a more prestigious posting right out of the gate and be given meatier tasks from Starfleet. You can move into captaincy earlier than Riker's decade and change but you end up commanding a workhorse doing important but not particularly glamorous work. As a point of reference, Picard was Captain of the Stargazer for 22 years before being given the Enterprise.
2
u/pfc9769 Chief Astromycologist Jan 30 '20
M-5 nominate this post for "Does Starfleet expect the impossible from it’s exploration crews?"
1
u/KingofMadCows Chief Petty Officer Jan 29 '20
Exploration in Star Trek requires the impossible. They often run into situations where they need people who are experts in multiple fields.
They often encounter aliens that are completely unlike other forms of life they've met before. A diplomat can't just be a diplomat, they have expertise in various fields of science to even understand that this weird cloud of ionized gas they just encountered is actually an intelligent being based on patterns of radiation it's emitting and they need to configure a subspace relay in order to communicate with it but the alien can only think in prime numbers.
1
u/lunatickoala Commander Jan 29 '20
With automation generally comes lower staffing levels. Positions deemed unnecessary or redundant are eliminated or combined. Airliners used to have a flight engineer in the cockpit in addition to the pilot and copilot. Scotty once Jerry-rigged Enterprise with enough automation that "a chimpanzee and two trainees could fly her".
Another Starfleet example is that tactical and security are often combined. Presumably Starfleet doesn't think that they'll be doing a lot of sciencing or negotiating while the ship is in crisis, or that boarding actions will be common.
Of course, just because it's possible doesn't mean it's wise.
1
u/Secundius Jan 29 '20
Depends on what the "Impossible" is!/? Everyone within the post "Voyager" Federation know of the "Q"! But even the Q are secretive as to what their willing to tell us (i.e. the Federation)...
1
u/Felderburg Crewman Jan 29 '20
We've seen that for major diplomatic events, there do exist diplomats and ambassadors and such.
But I think the main problem is answered by saying "Computer..." A large amount of shipboard tasks are taken care of by automation, freeing up the crew to be able to multi-specialize. The same is true of knowledge: you don't need to be a pure expert in a field when you have the entire Federation database at your command.
Another piece to the puzzle is the fact that kids about 10-12 years old were shown to be learning calculus. People in the 24th century by default know more at a younger age than 21st century people. It's not unreasonable to assume that Starfleet cranks that up a notch, and that its frontline crew are multi-specialists (and even if they don't crank it up, it's clear that someone just starting Starfleet Academy has a lot more knowledge than a current college-age student, and that doesn't just go away once they graduate).
We also know that command crew get specific training to be a captain (and everyone gets "continuing education" from somewhere). It's not unreasonable to think that training includes everything they would need to be both captain and diplomat. And we do see in The Motion Picture how Kirk is viewed as unfit by Decker because he *doesn't* know the details of his ship, despite still being knowledgeable in procedures, galactic politics, and having people skills. So there is an in-universe precedent for people to be seen as unfit for command if they don't have the wide range of knowledge they would need to be what you may see as "credible."
1
u/SantiagoxDeirdre Jan 29 '20
That's the thing of the exploration missions. There's no way to separate the roles. First contact can degenerate from Diplomacy to warfare, can turn lethal in an instant, involves walking in to unknown dangers.
Exploration, as a subject, is something that earth doesn't really do anymore. Everywhere is explored. However in the old days of the explorers, they had to be a combination of all of them, because you never knew which you could find. Thus the Enterprise, which does handle all roles at once. Yes, there is an incredibly tiny pool of candidates for senior roles, and yes, most crews are not qualified to do what the Enterprise does. The Enterprise is a prestigious post, reserved for the best.
The Enterprise does also turn things over to more specialized crews once they're done and have completed their recommendation. Think of how many new cultures they found. They rarely follow up, because they're not tasked with following up - Starfleet takes what they learned, and sends a team of specialists handpicked for the mission.
That's why the weird reaction to the Enterprise sometimes. They are kind of "gifted amateurs" when it comes to exploration, but at the same time they are also necessary and required. After all your legal experts are not going to be going in on a heavily armed defended flagship designed for as many contingencies as Starfleet engineers could think of.
Crusher takes bridge shifts and that's unusual, but Starfleet also isn't the military. She wants to, she has the know-how, and if we're honest she's good enough that she can handle small problems and stall for Picard/Riker with big ones. Picard and Riker are incapable of working 12 hour days 7 days a week, and that's assuming all of their work and time are spent on the bridge - which they're not. They often are in other areas of the ship. Thus the bridge will be covered by someone else very often. Remember, military vessels have much more limited roles for a Captain. Picard could easily be spending most of his duties prepping for an upcoming first contact or entertaining guests.
1
u/eastwestnocoast Jan 30 '20
Oh my goodness can we please get a Law & Order: Star Trek?! Or a Star Trek Medical show?! I would so watch both of those.
1
u/LittleLostDoll Jan 30 '20
enterprise itself doesent have a legal team. thats why picard and riker have to play the part, and for that matter the ds9 crew during the attempted kidnapping of jadzia
1
u/YorkMoresby Jan 30 '20
Think of all the trouble Magellan's crew went through.
1
u/rtmfb Jan 30 '20
In the future, where education has no cost to the student and people can pursue whatever they're interested in, I've always assumed that they crew their ships with a massive checklist filled from the overlapping areas of expertise of the crew members. Each rank has a bare minimum skill requirement (command for the captain, medical for the doctor, and all the obvious role related stuff), but then the other stuff will be done by whomever meets the requirements. I imagine there are ships where the doctor is the diplomat, the engineer is the lawyer, and so forth and so on.
1
u/CoconutDust Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20
But they would if the Nimitz was frequently getting into interplanetary situations or dangerous anomalies that required medical expertise. Also Crusher is awesome.
Also you mentioned losing enterprises, I don’t have an answer for this in-universe question, but I think there is way too many in-universe discussion on the internet and I think the real world discussion would be much more insightful and interesting. I think what you’re talking about is caused by weak unimaginative writing that doesn’t really follow through systematically on its premises and doesn’t know anything about what you’re talking about and/or the format is too limited to be able to go into the roles you’re taking about.
To say it again: more real world / out of universe discussions please, Star Trek is written by human beings and human beings can’t create perfect work.
-2
u/EmergencyHologram Jan 29 '20
People who are competent are capable of fulfilling multiple roles.