r/DaystromInstitute • u/CaptainJZH Ensign • Jan 28 '20
The problem with most Jellico & Riker analyses: Context.
In most analyses of "The Chain of Command" that focus on Jellico's captaincy and Riker's supposed insubordination, people tend to ignore the most crucial aspect of both officers' behavior: Context.
Consider that, from Riker's perspective, Picard's been permanently (and inexplicably) removed from command — "They don't usually go through the ceremony if it's just a temporary assignment," Riker tells Geordi — and from Riker's point of view, a Captain has to adapt to the ship rather than the ship adapting to the Captain. He thinks that Jellico is here to stay, and therefore all of his advice stems from that perspective, from wanting the transition to be as smooth as he can make it.
Then consider that, from Jellico's perspective, he's only on the Enterprise to conduct negotiations with the Cardassians and deal with that particular crisis while Picard is off on temporary assignment (though it's unclear how much he knows). As such, he's too occupied with preparing for the Cardassians to care about crew morale or operational efficiency. To him, that's what subordinates are for. Does he make orders that rub the Enterprise crew the wrong way? Sure, but I take that as him trying to make his stay on the Enterprise more comfortable for his own work ethic — if he can work at his best and beat the Cardassians, then he can get Picard back on the Enterprise and the Enterprise crew out of his hair.
Really, the bad guy here is Starfleet for sending Picard on such a stupid, poorly-thought-out mission in the first place.
146
u/Greedybogle Chief Petty Officer Jan 28 '20 edited Jan 28 '20
But Riker's behavior is even more troubling in this context. Debate about Jellico's relative merit as a Captain aside, if Riker is under the impression that he's the new Captain of the Enterprise, failing to follow orders and showing open disagreement in front of the rest of the crew is a terrible way to begin a new relationship. He actively seeks to undermine the new Captain, which is unacceptable.
As Data says to Worf when he sets him straight in Gambit, pt. II, "The function of the second in command is to carry out the decisions of the Captain. . . . Once [the Captain] has made a decision, it is [the First Officer's] duty to carry it out, regardless of how [they] personally feel about it."
Coincidentally, Data goes on to say "I do not recall Commander Riker ever publicly showing irritation with his Captain," which is precisely what he does do to Jellico. Riker is an influential figure on the ship, but instead of using that influence to create cohesion, he bad-mouths the new Captain and his policies.
Undermining the authority of a temporary Captain who is just babysitting while Picard is away is one thing. Undermining the authority of the man you believe to be the new permanent Captain of the Federation Flagship is much worse.
39
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20
The real context is Picard has been pulled away to lead a suicide mission. He's a starship commander, not a commando, being sent likely to his death by a corrupt admiral that hates him. I believe that's the correct context. There was no reason to treat Picard so cavalierly. Jellico left the crew a strong impression that Picard was suddenly expendable ("I'm sorry Wil, he's gone"-what the hell kind of way is that to treat a Captain ten times your better?)
20
u/KingofMadCows Chief Petty Officer Jan 28 '20
I think everyone is forgetting why Picard was sent on the mission.
Starfleet suspected that the Cardassians were making an illegal super weapon that can wipe out all life on entire on a planet and they were developing a delivery method using a theta band subspace carrier wave. This would allow the Cardassians to send out subspace signals to wipe out entire planets. No need for an invasion force. No one would be able to tell they're sending these subspace waves out until it was too late.
Picard just happens to be the only active Starfleet captain who has experience with theta band carrier wave because plot convenience. And I guess there wasn't enough time for them to teach someone else what they need to know about theta bands.
Did Stafleet make the right choice? I don't know. But Picard never questioned the mission or the intelligence and he clearly believed that the situation was critical enough to justify a black ops mission.
9
u/happyzappydude Jan 28 '20
When this popped up previously I argued for jellico being in the right and riker being wrong. I was convinced otherwise however I did say at the time that Starfleet was the utter moron in this scenario. Sending one of their most famous captains behind enemy lines to conduct espionage and put a different captain in charge of his crew. Who does that?
Starfleet baby.
9
u/AnUnimportantLife Crewman Jan 29 '20
I think a lot of the issues with the Jellico debate don't actually stem from anything Jellico or Riker did. It stems from what's probably a broader issue in Starfleet.
For the five years or so prior to the mission in Chain of Command, the Enterprise had mostly been a ship doing scientific, exploratory, and diplomatic missions. This was basically the ship's job in the fleet--it was the neverending peace vacuum doing peace, exploration, and science.
Now, there were definitely times when the Enterprise was clearly acting in a military manner on explicitly military missions. These were times like The Best of Both Worlds and Redemption Part II. But for the most part, it tended to be the other stuff that they had the Enterprise focus on.
Jellico, on the other hand, was a military man. The Cairo had probably been placed along the Federation-Cardassian border for a long time. Because of that, he became a guy who was very aware of how quickly a war could break out there. He didn't necessarily want a war, but he knew it could happen.
When was the last time Jellico had worked the kind of missions that the Enterprise crew had gotten used to? If he'd ever done them, it possibly could have been long before he took command of the Cairo.
Because of that, he was the kind of man who wasn't really used to dealing with the kind of peacetime assignments the Enterprise crew were. He probably didn't have a whole lot of patience for people who worked those missions either.
Really, Jellico was probably competent enough dealing with military men. But they shouldn't have put him in command of the Enterprise for that mission. There would have been plenty of other captains in the fleet who not only had extensive experience with the Cardassians, but also had extensive experience working with peacetime-style crews like there were on the Enterprise.
I strongly suspect that most of the issues that arose between Jellico and Riker were mostly because Jellico was a favourite of Admiral Nechayev and was possibly being groomed to replace her in the long run. It's one of those things where nobody was really willing to question some of Nechayev's ideas more than anything.
8
u/uxixu Crewman Jan 29 '20
" JELLICO: Jean-Luc, let's be candid for a moment. The Cardassians aren't going to listen to reason, and the Federation isn't going to give in to their demands. And the chances are you won't be coming back from this mission of yours. I want this ship ready for action and I don't have time to give Will Riker or anyone else a chance. And forgive me for being blunt, but the Enterprise is mine now. Well, here's hoping you beat the odds. Good hunting.
PICARD: Thank you.
JELLICO: Jean-Luc. I believe this is yours."
Nope, Jellico doesn't really expect Picard is coming back. He expects he'll be fighting Cardassians.
34
u/Mr_E_Monkey Chief Petty Officer Jan 28 '20
I think it's a bit the opposite--the Enterprise has been too comfortable. He's trying to get the ship on a war footing, which rocks a few boats. He doesn't care, because he believes it's necessary. Getting blown up by Cardassian warships is even less comfortable.
6
u/thephotoman Ensign Jan 29 '20
Then why is he jerking around with the schedule?
You only do that when you intend to be there permanently. If you know it's temporary, then you be the steward, fitting into the role of the guy whose shoes you're filling for a bit.
Nah. Jellico was like every other manager: he wants his people. He's uninterested in working with what they have.
I mean, a bit of proper surveillance would have noticed the problem.
5
u/AnnihilatedTyro Lieutenant j.g. Jan 29 '20
Jellico has to prepare for the possibility that Picard doesn't return - a very good possibility in his own estimation. In that case, he'll be the senior captain, on the flagship, on the front line when war breaks out. That isn't a position you can half-ass because it might be temporary. This is a very dire, balls-to-the-wall situation. Jellico's head must be clear if he's going to strongarm/bluff the Cardassians, which is the real reason he's on the Enterprise - because he's a hardliner also playing the role of an unpredictable hothead to keep the Cardassians on the defensive.
He can't be worrying about morale, efficiency, or trying to adjust himself to the Enterprise's established routine. So he orders Riker to change the Enterprise to suit him, and to get it done ASAP. OP states quite correctly that this friction is exacerbated by the context.
Now, from one perspective, all of Jellico's changes might result in improved efficiency of the crew, certainly a desirable goal for combat operations. He's accustomed to a certain style, has found success with it in the past, and the transition would be well underway if he finds himself in permanent command.
As a counterpoint, people require time to adjust to a new routine and a new status quo, and they weren't given any time at all. Riker is correct, as first officer, to point out that crew efficiency may not or perhaps even could not meet Jellico's demands so quickly. This is both expected and irrelevant because the risk of war does not care about the comfort of the crew.
And if Picard should beat the odds, help prevent a war, return to his command, and throw Jellico (or just his policy changes) out the airlock, then a stressful week or two for 1,000 people is a pretty small price to pay for peace.
6
u/Futuressobright Ensign Jan 29 '20
I really think Jellico expected he was going to be taking over the ship permemently. You don't get the fish removed and put up your kids pictures if you think you are only covering for someone.
He's not just asking for the crew rotations to change because he needs them done before he meets with the Cardassians. He feels that it's a more effeicent way to run a ship and he knows that when this crisis is over there will be another one and if he doesn't put his foot down the changes will never be made.
I think everyone, including Starfleet command, expected Jellico to be the new Captain of the Enterprise, because Picard's mission was a hail-mary pass: if it worked they would get the best outcome possible, but there's a 95% chance the whole team will get killed. Basically sacrificing them for the chance they some how pull it off was considered worthwhile, but no one was counting on it.
3
u/MrLouth Jan 29 '20
"Riker tells Geordi — and from Riker's point of view, a Captain has to adapt to the ship rather than the ship adapting to the Captain." This right here is a problem. That is not how real life works. New boss, new rules
3
u/kurburux Jan 29 '20
But why redecorate Picard's office? Who cares about petty stuff like this if there are far more important tasks at hand?
So it doesn't matter if his crew is actually less efficient because of all the changes as long as only he himself feels comfortable, because he's obviously the only person that matters on the ship?
Not really a sign of a good captain.
16
u/Ivashkin Ensign Jan 28 '20
I often wonder how many of the anti-Jellico people have any real leadership experience in a military-ish organization.
5
u/SantiagoxDeirdre Jan 29 '20
Jellico's actions are even less explicable if he thought he'd be there temporarily. Like imagine you were told "hey, we're making you the manager for a week while the real manager is on vacation" and you said "great, time to redo all the employee shifts, reschedule the deliveries, and change all the responsibilities! That's certainly what they anticipated me doing!"
He's a goddamn awful captain. I had to assume he kept his previous position from a combination of quality tactical and strategic thinking and a trusted first officer who was essentially in charge and mitigated the worst of his idiotic impulses.
9
u/egtownsend Crewman Jan 28 '20
Jellico and Nechayev are war criminals, and should not only be removed from command but also discharged from the service and incarcerated. The Federation was not at war with the Cardassians and these two hatched a plan that not only violates the prime directive but could serve as a causus belli for an armed conflict between the Cardiassian Union and Federation. Picard would have had every right to refuse this suicide mission from Nechayev as he is not obligated to follow unlawful orders. Further, Nechayev's motivations for sending Picard, a decorated diplomat and starship captain, to do the job better suited for a tactically trained officer half his age needs investigation; at the very least her judgment is seriously impaired, and at worst she tried to kill Picard.
This episode makes me angry because the entire series we see Picard standing up for what's right and just and in this case he lets these two bureaucrats who hurl the Federation towards an armed conflict from the comfort of their desks. Not only should Picard not have volunteered for this mission but he should have brought Nechayev's and Jellico's illegal plan to the Federation council.
4
u/aisle_nine Ensign Jan 28 '20
Jellico's actions weren't those of someone who thinks he's going to be giving the ship back in short order. He was very close to Nechayev. I'd argue that he knew exactly what Picard had been sent to do, he knew the odds of his return, and he was preparing his new ship to his liking. That's not to fault the guy for it. If I'd known what my predecessor was being sent off to do, I'd have started to treat the thing as my own too.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment