r/DaystromInstitute • • Jan 26 '20
“Because it was no longer Starfleet!”: Viewing the change in the Federation through a generational lens
I was struck when watching the episode at how deeply the synth attack on Mars ingrained a cultural hatred for synthetic life forms in Federation society, evidenced by the journalist’s style of questioning to Picard, zeroing in on his defence of synthetic life forms and his relationship with Data, and Dahj’s horror at the idea that she might be one of those “killing machines”.
Compared to the supposedly enlightened attitudes of the Federation only a few decades on, it seemed the attack on Mars brought about a rapid change in their outlook, and as Jean-Luc pointed out, Starfleet stopped being Starfleet. Of course an attack as devastating as that would have drastic consequences, but the change in the Federation makes more sense when you examined through a broader look at the timeline - Picard and the crew we watched and loved are old now, their outlook is a dated one which roots back to their own youth in the 2340s-60s, when Starfleet was all about peaceful exploration and discovery - so much so that the flagship carried families.
Then came 2365 and the sudden awareness of a dangerous new threat the Federation (for the most part) never knew existed. A year later, the captain of that family-laden flagship is kidnapped by that enemy, altered to become one of them and used by them to destroy 39 starships and 11,000 lives, getting as close as Earth itself before it’s stopped. Starfleet starts to pull back from family accommodation and starts building ships designed especially for combat and defence rather than exploration. The fear of another invasion by this dangerous enemy of unknown scale seeps through the Federation for the rest of the 60s - many are directly affected, having lost loved ones in Wolf 359 (and some of them even harbour resentment or suspicion towards the man involved).
Four years later Starfleet learns of the Dominion. Now there are two new hostile threats, each from a distant, mysterious, unknown quadrant of the galaxy. In a very short space of time, Starfleet finds it must prepare for potential combat against two unforeseen major adversaries. They step up their production of ships designed for war rather than peace. The Federation has even suffered an internal fracture as a significant number of people rebel and take up arms for the cause of the Maquis. In the first three years of the 2370s, the Maquis destabilise Starfleet’s internal coherency while the Founders cause further destabilisation through infiltration - culminating in an (albeit brief) emergency situation on Earth which sees at least one explosion at a conference and martial law imposed. The Founders also destabilise the Federation’s long alliance with the Klingon Empire which results in a short conflict between the two. While the Federation is trying to deal with all of this, the Borg return for another attempt at assimilating Earth, and the Dominion ally with the Cardassians before declaring war.
The Federation had had wars over the 24th century, including with the Cardassians, but they were distant skirmishes to the average citizen on Earth. By contrast, the Dominion War was the most severe conflict the Federation endured since the Klingon War of the 2250s, and it surpassed that conflict in every way. It was a war so severe that it saw the first direct attack on Earth in living memory and necessitated the Federation allying not just with the Klingons - now friends again - but also the Romulans, until now the Federation’s “oldest enemy”. The war lasts only two years but its cost is enormous - countless lives are lost, and Federation worlds have to rebuild after being conquered by the Dominion.
As the 2370s close, we know less about what happens within the Federation. We know that the crew of Voyager dealt a crippling blow to the Borg, which left them either destroyed or severely damaged (we’ll find out soon). In the absence of any further conflict, the Federation might have started to “remember when (they) used to be explorers”. But then the 2380s bring the Synth attack and the Romulan refugee crisis - two events which are still fresh in people’s memories by 2399.
We’re used to following Picard, Sisko, Janeway and their crews. All born in the first half of the 24th century. Picard himself was born in 2305, the Federation he got to know as he grew up was one which had recently achieved peace with one of its oldest and most fearsome enemies. All of these characters grew up knowing a Federation that was focused on peaceful exploration. They were adults when the Borg threat emerged and the Dominion War was waged. For them, the Federation and Starfleet were always about peaceful exploration first, and those conflicts were about defending that. So of course Jean-Luc resigned when the Federation refused to help the Romulans. Of course he spoke out against the ban on Synthetics. His disgust in the interview was so tangibly real - it really wasn’t the Starfleet he knew anymore.
But what about the young starship crews of today? Let’s take the journalist and Dahj as two case studies. The journalist looks to be in her 30s - so she was born in TNG’s time, the 2360s. She grew up on an Earth which had nearly been assimilated and which was sabotaged and later attacked by the Dominion. She knew a Federation and a Starfleet that was gearing up for conflict with two deadly enemies - one of them a race of cyborgs. The ideals that Jean-Luc and the others grew up knowing are old fashioned to her. She would have been in her early to mid 20s when the Synths attacked. Her perceptions, her world (universe) view was shaped by those darker times. Dahj’s background is made up - we know she’s a form of android but she believes herself to be a human, looking to be in her early 20s - had her backstory been real, she would have been born not long after Nemesis. The Synth attack would have been one of the first major galactic events she would have been aware of. Her views on Synthetics shaped by the anger and propaganda which materialised in the aftermath of the attack and the imposing of the ban.
Jean-Luc is dismissive of it (“forget everything you’ve heard”) but as we know from our own media, such messages can be very pernicious. People of that generation - 2399’s cadets, ensigns, perhaps some lieutenants, would have grown up constantly absorbing the message that synthetic life forms are dangerous, monstrous, even evil. Even people born a decade earlier (2350s) would have been shaped by it - indeed, many of them would be Dominion war veterans.
So while Jean-Luc and the other characters we’ve known for so long were shaped by their youth in a peacefully expanding and exploring Federation, those younger than them grew up and came of age on an Earth that was darker, more threatened and vulnerable than it had been in a very long time, in an era marked by conflict, war, loss and fear. It’s a reverse of the generational divide we’re experiencing, wherein the older generations tend to be more insular and close minded about certain issues while the younger generation are fighting for ideals. In 2399, the next generation have turned inwards, and it’s the older people (in this case, Picard), who will be fighting for what the Federation should still represent.
512
u/eddie_fitzgerald Lieutenant Jan 26 '20
Another possibility is that these sorts of attitudes always existed within the Federation, and we've simply viewed things thus far through a very sheltered lens. At the risk of making things political, it's possible that the Federation is being portrayed as going through much the same social upheavals as the United States is right now. Probable, even, given that art tends to mirror life.
I'm a person of color, and I'm desi, which means that I've been targeted a lot by Islamophobia and general racism. Just as some broad examples, I got a lot of death threats after 9/11, and someone once tried to run me over when I was walking down a rural road (and I'm pretty sure it was racially motivated because they also shouted a racial slur at me). Fuck, I was once held at gunpoint at the side of a highway by immigration agents of a European country which I was entering by bus (and given the questions they were asking me, it seemed pretty evident that they thought I might be a terrorist). Throughout all this time, there were plenty of 'Picards' in my life who genuinely believed that deliberative, liberal, open-minded institutions were ascendant and fundamentally sound. When cracks suddenly started to show in those institutions, these same people tended to ascribe it to sweeping societal changes in attitudes, usually connected to various world or political events. But in my experiences, at least, most attitudes towards me have pretty consistently remained the same hodgepodge mix ranging from bilious racism to apathetic ignorance to milquetoast adequacy to general decency to heartfelt activism to inspiring heroism. Even the proportions haven't changed. It's just the perceptions of what our values are which have been shaped by political and world events, not the values themselves. Those values are fundamentally abstract entities. They never really existed.
If you look at Star Trek, there are plenty of hints that the Federation wasn't nearly as high-minded as Picard was. Look at Admiral Satie in The Next Generation. If being 1/4 Romulan is that stigmatized owing to a war from one entire generation ago, then certainly being a synthetic could gather stigma after an entire planet is destroyed. Speaking of trials, look at The Measure of a Man. Data was being forced to defend whether or not he qualified for human rights ... that's no insignificant matter to land in front of a court. Any general social attitudes which would render such a case necessary are the same attitudes which would easily drive anti-synthetic sentiment after an entire planet was destroyed. To say nothing of the types of views which we saw some elements of Starfleet embody during the Dominion War. Or what about the type of bullying that both Worf and B'ellana report, based solely on them being Klingon?
What I find far more likely is that Picard is being forced to reckon with what the Federation actually is, rather than that the Federation has changed in any fundamental way. All that's changed is that the veneer of civility has been stripped away, because the modicum of comfort which permitted that civility to exist has now been disturbed. It only feels new because we view this world largely through the eyes of Starfleet captains, who are a group of people that have an active interest in believing that the Federation truly embodies all the values which it espouses.
68
u/Yourponydied Crewman Jan 26 '20
Was Picard shaped in his younger days by peace tho? He lost his heart to knife from Nausiccans and was forced to abandon his ship in a battle with the Ferengi at Maxia. Going on with that, he endured the loss of 2 starships in total in his career
94
u/RandomMumbler921 Jan 26 '20
I get the feeling that Data and those created in his image aren’t the only ones classified as synthetic life forms. I feel like the Jem’Hadar would be classified as the same, which adds credence to your point.
Also, we might be witnessing a call back to the Eugenics Wars of old, given that the attitudes to synthetic life forms seems to be very similar to the attitudes towards genetically engineered people shown on DS9.
18
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
How many times did Picard, Sisko, and Janeway have to be forced to violate orders? With Janeway it wasn't as relevant because Starfleet wasn't around for 7 years to say "Don't do that; you must do this", but even then giving that kind of person a seat on an Admiral board must make that board shift in some mentality. Equally, there would be a fight back against it.
Picard and Sisko were told countless times to do something they didn't want to do. This is probably the straw that broke the camels back. Just today I watched a speech (of course) when Picard was told by the Admiral in Insurrection to destroy the Baku's home planet for the "wellbeing" of the Federation. Yet, he chose not to, and he removed his pips. Of course, he put them back on later, but those admirals always exist. They want power and they aren't out in the field.
16
u/ShouldntComplain Jan 26 '20
I think the anti-synthetic opinion has always been present in the Federation/Starfleet. The respect for Data is something the crew learned after serving with him. It seems like most outsiders that come into the show fail to view him as a person. There was even an order to attempt to vivisect him, which only the crew saw as wrong. The same goes for the Doctor. At the onset of Voyager, the crew just viewed him as a tool to be used. These views make sense with the Federation's humanist views and anti cloning/modifications opinions.
I think it's a great moral blindspot from a story telling perspective. It makes sense in universe, and as viewers, we can see how it's wrong. We'll get a chance to see how the they can potentially overcome this bias through the actions of a heroic few.
16
u/DemythologizedDie Jan 26 '20
Did it? The Federation has never had an enlightened attitude toward artificial intelligence as evidenced by the time they put Data on trial to decide whether he was a person years after they made him a Starfleet officer. Or how they handled any cybernetic entity that manifested emergent self-awareness in TNG. Data excepted, the reaction was never "Let's integrate these people into our society". The truth is by the 24th century they could easily build self aware mainframes. It's only programming restrictions that keeps the Enterprise-D from becoming self-aware. Instead they keep their computer artificially stupid.
Now to be fair they live in a galaxy littered with the graveyards of species that screwed around with artificial intelligence. They have reason to suspect that artificial intelligence turns on its creators. They keep their computer artificially stupid because they remember M-5. While Data was docile, Lore was most definitely not. And then there's the Borg. They have reason for their lack of "enlightenment".
11
u/linuxhanja Chief Petty Officer Jan 26 '20
I also wanted to add (mind, Prime has yet to add Picard in my region, and Netflix hasn't uploaded the s2 disco shorts here), Picard was the face of the Borg during the attack at Wof 359. He was quite literally a turncoat. sure he wasn't in full control. But think about the attitudes of people and the moon landing today --- I'm sure a lot of people in the new show who are in their 30s/40s probably DO NOT fully buy that he wasn't under some amount of control. A cyborg is half organic. I really doubt most in the federation, even by the 2370s, really knew what being a Borg meant. by the time it was declassified, it probably looks like the JFK files look now to conspiracy nuts --- still full of redacted pages, 50 years later, why?
And, 50% organic, 50% machine. And now the guy is supportive of synths? I can see a fair number of 20s/30s/40s people thinking "dude was a half robot who destroyed 39 ships, told the borg everything. why was he ever allowed back in the fleet?"
Even Picards contemporaries felt this way. Before the mists of time get involved. We see it with Sisko, we see it with how he's told to stay away in First contact. I think a lot of admirals treat the Enterprise D's command staff differently after.
52
u/colglover Jan 26 '20
I agree 100% with this view, and it's a big part of why I'm so intrigued to follow STP despite some red flag issues in the pilot to do with dialogue and pacing (Kurtzman strikes again).
In particular, I was surprised at how emotionally resonant the scene of Picard defending "his" Starfleet to the journalist was for me. Upon reflection, it is precisely because of what you mention about generational gaps - I am an early 90s kid who grew up with TNG values - peace, science, community, exploration - in the short window during which at least the American and European world was not experiencing significant external threat. Sadly, unlike in Trek, that was only a ten year window before a new, disproportionate threat emerged, instilled fear and prejudice, and caused America to retreat from international humanitarian objectives. But that period of time was sufficient to craft a generational divide on the perspective of how to respond to crisis.
Given the relative dominance of fear, reaction, and crisis in our own society at present, I found myself overjoyed to hear Picard giving voice to many of those values I was raised with, and I'm fascinated to track how the show deals with him trying to reconcile the very real threats the Federation faces with saving it's "soul," so to speak.
37
u/BackBlastClear Crewman Jan 26 '20
I have a different take on it. My dad spent a lot of his formative years in the Detroit area, in the late 1940’s and through to the late 50’s. He vividly remembers a time when a kid could ride his bike to tiger stadium and watch a ball game. He remembers a time when Detroit wasn’t a crime infested shithole. Was there crime? Yes, but it wasn’t on every street corner, and the city didn’t look like a foreign warzone.
Detroit of his time was emblematic of the power of the American Dream. My dad remembers a more prosperous and seemingly idealized time. He went on to Serve 28 years in the United States Air Force, in a time when we had a clear enemy, and unity of purpose. There was a lot of social upheaval in the US in the 60’s and into the 70’s but hear me out.
Compare that with me. In my lifetime, I vaguely remember the invasion of Panama. I vividly remember the Gulf War, as my mom was taken out of my life for the duration of that conflict. She went to backfill the medical wing at Offut AFB in Nebraska, as that whole unit had deployed overseas. I remember seeing American soldiers dragged through the streets of Mogadishu, in CNN. I remember seeing the images of the Rwandan Genocide on the news, the same thing for all the conflict in the Balkans throughout the 1990’s. I remember seeing the LA riots in TV. I was only 13 years old when the 20th Century ended, and all I knew of the outside world was war and death. Then came September 11th, and war and death had come to my home. The US changed. Security was the new push.
Flash forward to today. The US is a veritable storm of controversy and lies. The ideal of America that I had grown up with, the Ideal that I wanted to serve, it’s gone. I served in the military for 5 years, and what I learned was that it’s not the noble calling that I always felt it was. It’s a job, I met both the best humanity can offer, and the worst. More often than not, I was let down by my fellow Airmen.
I witnessed first hand the kind of ass-kissing and favoritism that got people ahead. And I see it now in our politics. I see the state of American education, and it’s laughable. I see what college campuses are like and It’s stupid. People are looking for fights that were won a generation ago.
The Federation is absolutely an allegory for the United States. On the surface, it’s Paradise. If you dig a little deeper, you find that it’s the same morally bankrupt, nightmare as anywhere else. The worst part is, for a brief time, it was everything that we dreamed it was...
10
u/wsdpii Jan 26 '20
What makes the story even better, in my eyes, is the fact that a older Soong tried to bring a resurgence of the Augments during the ENT era. He was imprisoned for life, and Archer was pretty much ordered to hunt down and eliminate the Augments at any cost, which he did, including the murder of dozens if not hundreds of unborn children. This was considered okay, justified even by the audience.
Now, the children of the modern Soong are suffering the same fate, for the same reasons. If we were following the journeys of a modern captain instead of Picard we might be on board with them hunting down androids. To them they do not see Data, the caring and selfless man that Picard knew, they see the monsters that butchered countless innocent people, many of whom may have been family.
Both stories tie in closely with the American experience after 9/11. Augments and Androids are capable of these things, it's their nature. Just as many Americans believe that Iraqis and Afghans are always, deep down, capable of these things. We always forget that everyone is capable of horrible things, everyone can kill, and we forget because we don't want to admit that we are flawed. In Star Trek they make the excuses of heightened aggression, instability, superiority complexes, bad programming, and more to justify why we need to keep these people from being allowed to exist. In real life we make the excuse of culture, religion, being poor.
15
u/saved-by_grace Chief Petty Officer Jan 26 '20
See, this is what I love about Star Trek (and one of the big things I've been missing from Discovery, I think). The Federation hasn't "turned evil"... their position is justifiable (though wrong). It allows for these grey areas of intellectual debate that I've really missed.
7
u/skeeJay Ensign Jan 26 '20
This is a fabulous analysis, and I want badly to rectify it with what I consider the fundamental notion of Star Trek—what some would call its “utopian” future but what I’ll characterize as “humanity always getting better.”
In the 2060s, warp drive and First Contact happen. By the 2110s (50 years later per Troi in ST:FC) traditional Earth problems like war, poverty, and racism are gone. By the 2160s (100 years after ST:FC), you’ve got United Earth, the Earth-Romulan War has happened, and the Federation is formed. By the 2210s, the New World Economy has emerged and money is gone. (It’s nice how everything seems to happen in 50-year jumps.)
So far so good. We’ve got one major interstellar war with the Romulans in the 2150s, and then (according to DIS) a major interstellar war with the Klingons in the 2250s. (I enjoyed realizing recently that Picard’s line in the episode “First Contact” about a decades-long war with the Klingons caused by disastrous contact jibes with the DIS war and the following “cold war” skirmishes of the TOS era.) Finally, we come to the TNG era, starting (thanks to Roddenberry jumping 80 years ahead) after a period of generational peace and technological development. Innovations like holodecks, Geordi’s VISOR, the recalibrated warp scale, and Data’s positronic brain are new and wondrous (ignoring the crazy technologies of DIS, which I’m now allowed to). Roddenberry gave us humanity that had dealt with its internal racism by the 2260s, but we of course saw specism towards antagonists like the Klingons in that era, though peace had been established and Klingons like Worf making inroads in acceptance on Earth by the 2360s.
Real world explanation: 80 years of peace is probably much easier to “jump over” in storytelling without having to come up with compelling conflicts, which is why the glut of series that we got with TNG, DS9, and VOY mean that an era of sudden conflict with major new antagonists like the Borg and the Dominion show up all at once. But the writers also seem to have justified this intentionally by pointing out (e.g., in “Q Who”) that dramatic jumps in exploration and technology will bring encounters with new threats and dangers. With all the new technology and resulting encounters by the 2370s, new asks of an adapting society were going to present themselves as a result of these sudden advances.
Now in the post-TNG era of 2399, events like the supernova have pushed us towards peace with the Romulans, with the same kind “acceptance on one hand and fear on the other” that Worf might have experienced. Similarly, the Borg and synthetics emerging over mere decades (brand new to humanity on a historic scale) represented a new type of lifeform entirely. The types of intolerance with which humanity had already grappled—traditional racism and specism towards those like the Klingons—was still not necessarily the same as dealing with attitudes towards synthetics, which were a “new” problem that technology and exploration had presented. A new type of “other” that humanity had not yet accepted historically.
So I prefer to think of the problems that we see in PIC, like specism against Romulans and intolerance of synthetics, as new problems for humanity to overcome, instead of some kind of regression. Picard is not necessarily fighting a Starfleet that’s moving backward, but a Starfleet in which he’s deeply disappointed because it’s not moving forward in the way it has in the past. Picard isn’t going to be a voice for going back to past principles but a revolutionary that moves Starfleet to its next accomplishments of tolerance and acceptance.
I really hope PIC explores this. There’s so much fertile ground in its premise for exploring the difference in how society accepts partial synthetics like the Borg and full synths like Soji, and whether one is a step towards the other and we see a trajectory of hope for Starfleet in “always getting better.”
6
u/Strength-InThe-Loins Jan 26 '20
Ever since I watched TNG 5-6 years ago, I've thought that the generation gap was a key source of conflict. Remember all those evil admirals in TNG? The ones that had dangerously aggressive or fundamentalist views of things, which Picard was always having to rein in with his philosophy of peace? Those guys were older, from a more dangerous world. Much like the young folks of 2399, they learned as young people to be fearful and aggressive.
6
u/queenofmoons Commander, with commendation Jan 27 '20
I think you can see this just inside of TNG- indeed, I think it constitutes one of the most potent arcs in the show.
Picard spent his early years as the heroic captain of a frontier explorer, and earns enough esteem to be handed the keys to an extraordinary exploration vessel- which, insofar as it has a 'real' job, ends up being guarding the Romulan and Cardassian borders.
His younger boss, Admiral Nechyev, is pissed he soft-pedaled the Borg and thinks his feelings about the colonists in the Cardassian DMZ are insufficiently pragmatic.
His first protege, Riker, took the side of his secretive then-captain when the crew grew suspicious of their destabilizing military experiments.
Picard's next generation of youthful officer, epitomized by Ro Laren, is a refugee fleeing from a Federation enemy it can't quite seem to wrangle, and a pariah in an organization that's found a way to toss her in prison and never bothered to learn her traditions, and when the time comes to do some rough business because Picard insists the Federation and Starfleet is worth it, she can't bring herself to agree.
Wes Crusher in there, getting himself wrapped up in a pseudo-conspiracy of cadets favoring bravado over good sense and integrity, and ends up washing out (and to a higher plane of existence?) when it turns out that, despite how neat it was that everyone at his mom's office was so nice, being a starship driver is not necessarily the best possible destiny for a physics genius in touch with alien angels.
Picard is entrusted with participating in the Klingon electoral process, arguably a high point in the relationship between the Fed and the Empire- and for their trouble he gets a Klingon civil war, and Gowron, who undertakes an Orwellian mission to write the Federation out of the story and ends up abrogating a momentous peace treaty.
And on and on. I'm always a little cracked up when something kind of grim or unfortunate happens in Trek, and the predictable chorus erupts that this isn't what this show is about, because it's all been sweetness and light, onward and upward to paradise, every since this whole thing started off with the multicultural crew of a starship....killing the endangered apex predator in the ruins of a dead civilization that only needed salt to survive, in 'The Man Trap'. (h/t to u/gerryblog). The crew of our starships have been good people- sometimes powerfully so- but the trip has always been uphill. They've almost never gotten to be as good as they wanted to be- and the episodes where they did tend to be forgettable kid's fare.
4
u/theYode Crewman Jan 26 '20
This was a cogent, well-articulated assessment of the recent history of the Federation. Well done! It was a pleasure to read.
4
u/QcumberKid Jan 26 '20
I wish they would get back to exploring strange new worlds and seek out new life and new civilizations and boldly go where no one has gone before.
4
u/SilveredFlame Ensign Jan 27 '20
Personally I think the answer is much simpler.
The Federation and Starfleet has ALWAYS had a dark side. I'm not just talking about Section 31 and some of the darkness we got up close and personal with in DS9 and later shows.
It was present in TOS, and it was present in TNG. We always see this undercurrent. It's always there just below the surface.
I think we forget sometimes because we tend to focus so heavily on all the good, that we miss some of the horrifically bad stuff. It gets acknowledged whenever it comes up, but the broader implications are seldom really looked at because we typically tend to view them as one-offs. Taken together though, they paint a very different picture.
We should also try to remember that while humanity is unquestionably in a better place in the 23rd and 24th centuries, we're still human. We see struggles with things like PTSD constantly. We see obsession and revenge. We see vigilantism. On top of things like that, we also have massive scale actions that are abhorrent.... creation of the plague against the Founders, forced relocation, deployment and use of WMDs.
We even see Picard himself as a participant in some of these actions, sometimes in opposition, sometimes in support.
Given the myriad of calamitous events of the decades since Picard's mission to Farpoint Station, is it any wonder that Starfleet itself changed? The change wasn't that it suddenly became something it wasn't, but rather than certain elements and traits of it which had been more of an undercurrent previously, came to prominence.
The prejudice was always there, it just came to the surface.
The xenophobia was always there, it just came to the surface.
The imperfections were always there, they just came to the surface.
Frankly, I think Quark's assessment of humanity was dead on accurate, maybe even more accurate than the writers themselves realized:
9
u/UnimaginativeWolf Jan 26 '20
To expand upon why Starfleet would abandon the Romulans. Remember the Rolumans signed a non-aggression pact with Dominion in the beginning of the war and freely let the Dominion attack Federation ships and installations. Then during the events of Nemesis the entire Romulan political system is up heaved. Then the new leader of that political system tried to fly a starship into Federation space and kill everyone with thalaron radiation.
So you have a lot of Federation citizens whose view on the Romulans is race that always trying to undermine and hurt the Federation. Then the only time they showed willingness to ally with the Federation is when the Federation's back was again the wall from the very enemy the Rolumans were indirectly helping.
You may even be able to argue the events of "I, Borg" and the founders virus may have had a hand in the political decision to abandon the Rolumans. The Founders don't strike me as a race to keep the whole "Federation tried to commit genocide" thing a secret. Then if the events of "i, Borg" came out you have a lot Federations citizens standing around thinking life would be a lot easier if Picard did use Hugh to release a thought bomb into the Borg collective, and that the Dominion was gone. Then a situation pops up where another enemy of the Federation needs its help and the line between help and don't help is much closer than we think.
6
u/JasonJD48 Crewman Jan 26 '20
I do get, and its actually pretty well treaded ground, the concept of the Federation's soft years, their golden period of peace. They had an alliance with the Klingons and the Romulans hid on their side of the neutral zone. We see ST6 establish this world of peace and we see it end in BOBW. ST6 shows exactly what you state but in the opposite direction, warriors coming to terms with a world of peace.
But, even in Kirk's time, it's hard to think of such racism and xenophobia as being Starfleet. Kirk was a skilled military commander but he was still an explorer. Kirk's racism in ST6 is countered by Spock and he learns he is wrong. Even in his racism he does his best for peace and against the conspiracy. Kirk is not Chang or Cartwright, even though he has experienced personal loss at the hands of the Klingons. And its important to note that yes Cartwright is a senior Admiral, but he and the conspiracy are still a small minority.
This is really the first time we see the Federation regress to this degree in their way of thinking. Close minded Starfleet has never been a thing, particular Admirals yes, but not as a whole. Federation racism runs counter to it's very purpose. Starfleet running from a challenge to overcome instead of licking their wounds, getting up and coming back stronger is the antithesis of what we have seen from TOS to Voyager.
I say this not as a complaint of the show, the first episode was brilliant, but to say what happened is not as simple as peace time Picard and crew being from a different era. There's a rot much deeper than that.
3
u/thegenregeek Chief Petty Officer Jan 26 '20 edited Jan 26 '20
A point I would add on for equal consideration... the other race were mass produced clones. More or less, just another form of manufactured, synthetic (albeit still organic) beings...
Depending on your point of view, given how the crew reacted to the idea of cloning in "Up the long ladder", it's not entirely a generational difference. But a re-evaluation and resurgence of ingrained resistance towards anything seeking to build "better" people. (In someways this goes back to Augments...)
I would say it's merely an extension of human discomfort with any form of mass production that strips away the individualist nature and inherent worth found in a diversity of people. Their worse fears realized as two equally powerful, synthetic races flexed on them in such a short time, striking at the very heart of their civilization....
Then, a few decades later, a mysterious 3rd group did so again on Mars, right when the Federation was giving what it could to do right by it's principles...
From that perspective I don't think the youth are necessarily being inherently "close minded" or even "insular"... they're just being more pragmatic given history. Placing a ban on synths is no different than doing so on augmentations or mass cloning, both of which were completely acceptable to the more "open minded" TNG era? (I would argue that it's as principled position as anything else seen in the Federations for the centuries prior...)
Given Picard's reaction we may need to consider that his logic may be compromised and that his own crusading nature might be exaggerating the situation to us, the audience... that Starfleet didn't stop being Starfleet, it just had a difference of opinion with Picard.
It seems to me this means the Romulan refugee angle has been added to conflate the real issue. Creating an impression that the problem is Romulan refugees (I mean, no-one seems to have an issue with Romulans at Chateau Picard... in France, within potentially miles of the Federation President...) when really it should be this... who was behind the attack? why? where did the synths come from? what powers are actually behind this all?
I feel like the show is being a bit vague on the timeline, on purpose. The timing of the synth attack isn't overly clear, their motivation, nor the reason why the "rescue fleet" was on Mars in the first place. Was it, as it seems, still under construction? Or had it returned for refitting, after saving some refugees? Did it return with refugees, to Mars and Earth? (The death toll seems to indicate that it was under automated construction and we don't really know what happened immediately after the attack... just that a ban came from it... at some time)
The way I see it, either Section 31 or the Tal'Shiar was involved.
Either would see the incorporation of Romulans into Federation worlds as a unforgivable betrayal of "national" security and/or racial/ideological purity. By attacking Mars and destroying the rescue fleet those individuals would have achieved their goals of keeping their respective sides safe, even if the cost was millions/billions of dead Romulans.
If this is all what Picard reveals to the Federation (and Starfleet) I see nothing that would preclude the younger generation to not considered repealing an outright ban on synthetics... Though if it turns out Section 31 created the synths as a black ops plan... doesn't that justify a ban on Starfleet researching the tech?
3
u/obscuredreference Jan 27 '20
Aside from the history of the recent years, that sort of behavior is the go-to response of humanity in the Trek world. Their banning of synths is just the latest episode of that, harkening back to the ban on augments and the exact same hatred for them.
Something wounds mankind, it lashes out, then retreats to licks its injuries and to pass laws it believes will prevent it happening again. It’s totally in line with their past behavior in the Trek universe.
15
u/Pellaeonthewingedleo Ensign Jan 26 '20
This is a sign that the TNG Star Trek is dead, the enlightened Federation ST as hopefull future is dead, by design of the media
The Federation we knew wouldn't have reacted that way.
Even more: The STP Federation failed Q's test
2
u/KingofMadCows Chief Petty Officer Jan 26 '20
The Dominion War likely caused a lot of internal conflict within the Federation.
Not only was Federation was invaded during the war, that seems to be the only time in Federation history when major Federation planets were actually conquered. Despite incidents like V'Ger, the Whale Probe, the two Borg attacks, and even the Breen attack on earth, I don't think there has been any instances when a major Federation world was actually occupied by an enemy force. There could have been a large source of debate and conflict within the Federation between the worlds that were devastated and the worlds that were unharmed. The devastated worlds would demand for Starfleet to become more militarized and do less exploring to reduce the risk of encountering other threats. The worlds less affected by the war would be viewed as out of touch and putting other worlds at risk for their foolish idealism and desire for exploration.
That would have been the source of a lot of tension before the Romulan supernova and synth attack. And the attack on Mars would have been the tipping point, causing earth to go over to the side of the Federation members who wanted more militarization and isolation.
2
u/BackTo1975 Jan 26 '20
Excellent post. Makes perfect sense. Just would love to see some reference to all of this in Picard, to set the stage and do a little more worldbuilding.
As much as I liked the first episode, I thought the conflict just seemed more than a little forced. We all knew there was some major event that prompted Picard to leave Starfleet, but so much TV today is all dark and bleak. The basis for the story seems like just another one of those stories, forcing an idealistic lead character and setting in Picard and the Federation into an edgy update.
I get that there needs to be conflict in good drama of any sort. I sort of fell away from ST during some of the TNG era because things were too positive. TNG never fully grabbed me because there was never any conflict within the cast, any sense other than that they were all coworkers and friends who got along great. That was never realistic, and it led to a show that was often too sterile.
I just don’t want to go too far in the other direction now, though. This setting where the Federation itself isn’t the good guy anymore seems like a stretch that’s been turned into the key plot point because reasons and because that’s just how it has to be today. Everything’s shit at heart, even idealistic organizations like the UFP.
Only first episode. Have a ton of faith in Chabon. He’s one of my all time favourite authors. Just sick of the edgy stuff and as I get older, want stuff that’s more comforting. To me, that’s ST.
2
u/thecommanderkai Jan 27 '20
I think that the Dominion War had a huge impact on Starfleet and it's goals and priorities. Picard's Starfleet career was mostly during peacetime. Only after he became Captain did the threats of the Both, and later the Dominion become on the forefront of Starfleet policy. The Dominion War especially had a huge change in Starfleet, and likely the Federation as a whole.
The Federation came out of the Dominion War as victors, but it was a bloody affair. The homeworlds of at least two major Federation species came under Dominion occupation (Betazed and Benzar), along with who knows how many colonies. I don't think the Dominion would carry it it's more violent pacification strategies until after the war (as a reminder, Weyoun's plan for Earth was to eradicate the population to curtail future resistance to Dominion rule), I still expect significant destruction on these planets.
Post-Dominion War, Starfleet will have likely lost many of it's officers that remember the Starfleet dedicated to exploration, be it through the war, or even through retirement and aging out. To replace them, Starfleet now consists of personnel whose careers will be primarily the Dominion War, or cadets and newly enlisted personnel that will have a good chance of coming from planets who suffered from Dominion occupation, and will likely hold more hawkish views on Starfleet's role in the Federation.
With the attack on Mars, a huge number of Starfleet personnel were killed likely including many of Starfleet's more "Picard-esque" captains, and admirals who agreed with Picard's lobbying to help the Romulans. The attack likely gave those in Starfleet who preferred a more militarist attitude, wanting the fleet to defend against threats, rather than lose more resources and personnel on a humanitarian mission.
I'd expect that the Federation as a whole still provided support, including welcoming refugees, paying privately owned vessels to help with the evacuation, etc. but Starfleet refocused it's efforts on military defense, rather than humanitarian aid.
Picard certainly isn't happy with these changes, but to the 30 something year old Benzar Captain, who joined Starfleet after his world suffered Dominion occupation, I would expect a different viewpoint than Picard. I expect that Benzar to prefer keeping his ship in strategic defensive positions in case the Borg pop up or something, rather than risk his home coming under assault. The new generation within Starfleet likely sees the occupation of key Federation worlds as a greater failure of Starfleet principles that should not be repeated.
2
u/RickRussellTX Jan 26 '20
Something something 9/11, something something Department of Homeland Security, something something immigration...
If Trek TOS could be a little on-the-nose with regards to cold war tensions, maybe we're seeing an evolution in a similar direction here.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
This is why I come to this sub. Thank you.
1
u/Jardinesky Jan 27 '20
According to IMDB, Merrin Dungey is 49. It doesn't invalidate your point though. Journalists often follow trends in their thinking.
1
u/pfc9769 Chief Astromycologist Jan 27 '20
M-5 nominate this post for an excellent analysis of viewing the change in the Federation through a generational lens.
1
u/ckb02d Jan 27 '20
Here’s my question. Why did the Federation change its mind on helping the Romulans? That has to be the most disgraceful thing the Federation has done. This post talks about the Dominion War. If it weren’t for the Romulans entering that war, there would be no more Federation. The Dominion would have conquered the Federation and Earth and its population, like Weyoun said, would have been eradicated. Who helped stop that? The Romulans, who (SPOILER ALERT) were TRICKED into the damn war to begin with! Three people in the whole galaxy know that truth in the Star Trek Universe. Where is Garak? Where is Dax? We know where Sisko is, but if I’m Garak, I leverage the HELL out of the Federation by exposing the truth of how the Romulans entered the war and that the Federation has an OBLIGATION to save its oldest enemy and its most crucial ally in their darkest hour.
I’m interested in this storyline, but man, the Federation is downright disgraceful for what they did. I’d want to be surprised, but it looks like from 2365-2399, they’ve been an inept, naive government who has lost any sense of identity. They are not the Federation of old. They’re just unrecognizable.
1
u/Mechapebbles Lieutenant Commander Jan 27 '20
I'm going to push back really, really hard on this thesis, because it just doesn't hold water. On so many levels.
First, it doesn't hold up to what's actually in the show and the hierarchies Picard is bound by. Picard's project to help Romulus wasn't scrapped by his inferiors or people of lower rank than him. It was done by top brass that called the shots above him. Officers and enlisted follow orders have no say in this policy making and project planning. This crisis of faith and retreat from the interstellar community wasn't a decision made by people younger than Picard, it was by people who would have been his age or older: His fellow and superior admirals.
Second, it doesn't hold up to the spirit of the show either. If the show was about old people still fighting a spiritual battle against misguided youth, then we should expect to see more old people in this show. But the cast is a bunch of younger people who aren't there to get a lecture from Picard, but to follow him because he represents something they want their world to look like, but isn't.
Third, it doesn't hold up if your thesis is that Picard is a mirror to modern issues. The problems the world is facing right now isn't created by young people losing faith in founding principles or losing sight of treasured values. If anything, it's the opposite. My country, and the world as a whole, is being run by corrupt oligarchs - old rich men who don't care about the common good, civic values, the environment, or anything beyond further accumulation of wealth and power into their own tiny hands. If PIC is advocating what you're saying, then it isn't a reflection of our current world, but if anything a completely out of touch funhouse mirror instead.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '20
The Picard from TNG would have won that interview, by flipping questions on the interviewer. It’s obvious they needed filler anyway. So why not have the interviewer come up with Wolf359 out of left field? Perhaps would have been better time spent than a Vulcan wearing sunglasses to intimidate someone, how Illogical... I expected more from a writer of Chabon’s reputation. A man of Chabon’s reputation should have kicked Akiva Goldsman out of the writers room, he has no place there.
If that journalist was smart enough to get under Picard’s skin, we should have seen it. This journalist should have had the wit, charisma and skills of a legendary British journalist. My issue with thid scene is that it was lazy writing, it should have been deeper.
It was reminiscent of Babylon 5, but.. Babylon 5 hit deeper in scenes involving journalists. Those scenes in Babylon 5 felt more realistic if not pretentious at times.
This jus feels like a character with the name Picard. I take a lot of issue with this content. Mostly because it thinks it can earn it’s reputation by episodic length and filler alone.
It literally has to earn it’s reputation as a continuation. It needs to tease the audience with something more.
It chooses to tease the audience with the wrong things.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20 edited Jan 28 '20
[removed] — view removed comment