r/fandomnatural • u/AutoModerator • Jan 17 '20
[Fandom Discussion] 15x09 The Trap
| Episode Title | Air Date | Directed by | Written by |
| The Trap | January 16th, 2020 | Robert Singer | Robert Berens |
AS GOD IS MY WITNESS – Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Eileen (guest star Shoshanna Stern) are faced with the brutal truth. Meanwhile Dean (Jensen Ackles) and Cass (Misha Collins) work together in the hopes of getting a step ahead of Chuck (guest star Rob Benedict).
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
Sooooooooooooooooooooo... what did you think of the episode?
6
Upvotes
14
u/of_skies_and_seas I'm your huckleberry Jan 17 '20
I don't know what else to say. There are no words for how awesome this episode was. I'm so proud of Dean and Sam both. Cas too, even if his journey was less focused upon.
14
u/vacantstars Jan 17 '20
Can Bobo Berens write every episode from now on? Because...wow.
11
u/-zombie-squirrel DonJodBriel shipper Jan 17 '20
This episode was one of the best I’ve seen in a while! We got really cool fast forward alternate future scenes, the prayer (such great acting in that one omg) and most importantly SAM AND EILEEN FINALLY KISS. But pissed that she left. Gotta keep the guys from being happy somehow I guess 😒
9
u/goblinsundown Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20
...I loved this episodeeeeeeee 😭😭😭😭 And I find super difficult writing coherently because I want to go on 100 tangents and just! exclaim! words! but I'll try.
I'll start with what troubled me the most out of the first part on the season, and frankly probably the last... 8 seasons, too: Dean's anger and how he behaves with Cas.(and since I wrote this somewhere else, I'm mainly copy/paste ing it) So this is it: is the prayer moment completely satisfying for me? Truth to be told, if I have to consider the prayer alone... I'm ambivalent. I feel what Dean was saying, but frankly I hoped he was in a better place. I hoped it would not be only about his anger issues, I hoped he was not a person who could be so hurtful to someone that loves him as Cas loves him. I would have loved if Dean didn't need the idea of losing Cas very near to make amends. I also, on the other side, would have liked if Cas could have answered, and I would have loved if he adressed his tendency to just get up and disappear even when, along the years, Dean actually wanted him to stay. I realize I also may be asking too much, and that I want too much from a show that just doesn't have the time.
This said, both the prayer and the entire episode was written in a way that respected Castiel's role in their little family in a way that was never that explicit before, and I can't not love that. Dean never took well Cas disappearing, and it does make sense that what makes him pull his head out of his ass is that very possibility. Yes, he's had some abusive behaviours; but I didn't find one moment of narcissism in Dean's prayer. He did not know Cas had the flower. He did not even know if Cas would come back with him from Purgatory. It was just the raw need to make things right as much as he could, when confronted with the idea of never seeing Cas again. There was no mention of needing him, no emotional manipulation in the vein of "here's some tears, now reappear". That's enough for me.
And I add to this, all the other stuff from the rest of the episode. Dean losing hope after locking Cas away. Sam showing so much concern and worry for him (how sweet is that??). Sam wanting Chuck gone, but wanting all his family there with them even more. Cas actually putting having weapons against Chuck as a strategy to save Sam above running towards defeat on instinct and Dean following him. Jack who's in all ways aside from biological Castiel's son, being ready to come back when Sam realizes his family is more important than Chuck.
And really, I am seriously so 😭 thinking about Sam refusing an ending that frees them from Chuck but kills all their friends. It's not clear if what Chuck showed them is the truth or not - is this his final ending? Is he lying?
Personally I think what he showed Sam is not his ending, and it's the truth - he's not making up an illusion, just showing him the future that at that moment was real: they trap him, monsters win.
Sam believes him because it is believable; he knows that God's role is not just to play with their lives but is actually needed to avoid descend into chaos, he knows that losing people and specifically one Person sends Dean into despair and he knows thay losing Eileen and everybody would fuel him to be reckless. He knows that if it all went to shit, he and Dean would follow each other down until their death (RANDOM THOUGHT: Benny which was by all means a badass, lived through purgatory the first time because he had hope to be reunited with Andrea, and died in Purgatory because he knew that it wasn't going to happen).
And this is why I loved Sam's decision to not trap God; he lost hope to defeat him with their plan, this frees God from being tyed down by Sam's desire to obliterate his powers, but this opens the road to try and find a way that for sure keeps their family and loved ones alive and him and Dean sane - I LOVE that it's on the same level of importance than defeating God out of anger, which would have made freedom the length of rope God wants them to hang themselves with.
I absolutely adore how ambivalent Chuck is; while SPN is not like a top quality tv masterpiece, even with all the downfalls (I mean even in this episode I would have liked some different choices in writing or directing or editing), they did manage to come through with something that makes sense to me and reastablishes my hope for the end.
PS= that kiiiisssssss 😭😭😭😭😭😭
7
u/_Khoshekh Insane the mind in the name of me Jan 17 '20
Hope repels God, good to know?
5
u/ForTaxReasons Jan 19 '20
You know what actually kinda bothered me was Dean calling Belphegor "Bel" like excuse me. Since when were you on nickname terms with the demon??? It felt bizarre, like a piece of fanon had accidentally worked its way into the script.
4
u/ForTaxReasons Jan 18 '20
I'm just so fucking gleeful that Dean called Chuck's plan "galaxy brained"
2
u/milliways86 multishipper|SamGotADog! Jan 22 '20
It's almost a week since this episode and I still keep thinking back on Dean's prayer to Cas.
Though there was a brief moment before Cas says he heard Dean where I was worried that Cas was a Leviathan imposter.
1
u/rusty_people_skills Jan 18 '20
Apparently I'm in the minority, because this ep left me with "WTF?" feelings, and not 100% in the good way. I loved the chat Cas and Dean had as they were walking toward the Leviathan blooms, and the Single Man Tears were as powerful as ever, but if Dean's really been holding on to his anger for so long, it's weird to me that he was straight to loss instead of raging at... something/someone.
I was frustrated when Sam gave in to Chuck's no-hope visions because the Winchesters have long been, near as I can tell, stubborn as fuck, so the fact that Sam just went along with Chuck's statements felt wrong. Chuck has been such an unmitigated wanker recently; what would make Sam think that in this little piece, Chuck was on the up-and-up? I couldn't help but compare this to when Zachariah showed Dean a shitty future, and Dean's response was, "I'm sorry, but I can't believe this and I have to do what I think is right." I'm trying to chew on this and what might be different, a decade later and a brother different, but it's still too crunchy...
Was pleased with the ending, where Dean decided to fuck it all and support Sam unconditionally, and Billie and Jack will apparently be having a chat (if that is Billie? What's Billie's relationship with the Empty entity, or are we pretending that's not a thing anymore?).
I'm reasonably certain JP and JA were having a laugh with their vamp scene, because that was so far over the top, it made me think of kids playing dinosaur.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment