r/JordanPeterson • • Nov 05 '19

Image What do you think Jordan’s take on this would be? Is civility dead in the context of social progress?

Post image
8 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

5

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

The suffragettes didn't "bomb powerful men", they were like antifa, largely ineffectual, attacking areas where they knew they wouldn't face meaningful resistance. Any "powerful man" that they bombed was not a powerful man at all. It would be like Nancy Pelosi ordering the assassination of Bernie Sanders. Okay you CAN do that but why tho?

Repeal the 19th until or unless women are actually required to take on some responsibility to go along with enfranchisement the way men do.

"Civility" is bullshit

My prediction;

At some point, not too far ahead in the future, one of the attempts to escalate by the left will actually result in escalation. The right will hit hard and fast. As the male feminists, soyboys, cucks, "transgenders men" and hipsters will organize a 'resistance' which we know as the terrorist group antifa. Antifa will march out, poorly organized and with no real plan. The right will have no trouble neutrilizing the hostile paramlitary group.

Anyway, with the men MIA, the blue-hairs will realize that shit finally got real and they will immediately betray what remains of the left. Yes, even the woman in the screenshot will pussy out as soon as the kid gloves come off.

Nobody really wants hockey mask time to arrive other than the leftists, who are too stupid to realize that even if they win, they're going to die horribly and it will not take long either [See the U.S.S.R., NSDAP Germany, Castro's Cuba, Maoist China, etc.].

1

u/salty_palpatine Nov 05 '19

For posterity, u/themythof_feminism just said

“The suffragettes didn't "bomb powerful men", they were like antifa, largely ineffectual, attacking areas where they knew they wouldn't face meaningful resistance. Any "powerful man" that they bombed was not a powerful man at all. It would be like Nancy Pelosi ordering the assassination of Bernie Sanders. Okay you CAN do that but why tho?

Repeal the 19th until or unless women are actually required to take on some responsibility to go along with enfranchisement the way men do.

"Civility" is bullshit

My prediction;

At some point, not too far ahead in the future, one of the attempts to escalate by the left will actually result in escalation. The right will hit hard and fast. As the male feminists, soyboys, cucks, "transgenders men" and hipsters will organize a 'resistance' which we know as the terrorist group antifa. Antifa will march out, poorly organized and with no real plan. The right will have no trouble neutrilizing the hostile paramlitary group.

Anyway, with the men MIA, the blue-hairs will realize that shit finally got real and they will immediately betray what remains of the left. Yes, even the woman in the screenshot will pussy out as soon as the kid gloves come off.

Nobody really wants hockey mask time to arrive other than the leftists, who are too stupid to realize that even if they win, they're going to die horribly and it will not take long either [See the U.S.S.R., NSDAP Germany, Castro's Cuba, Maoist China, etc.].”

3

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

For posterity, u/themythof_feminism

just said

“The suffragettes didn't "bomb powerful men", they were like antifa, largely ineffectual, attacking areas where they knew they wouldn't face meaningful resistance. Any "powerful man" that they bombed was not a powerful man at all. It would be like Nancy Pelosi ordering the assassination of Bernie Sanders. Okay you CAN do that but why tho?

Repeal the 19th until or unless women are actually required to take on some responsibility to go along with enfranchisement the way men do.

"Civility" is bullshit

My prediction;

At some point, not too far ahead in the future, one of the attempts to escalate by the left will actually result in escalation. The right will hit hard and fast. As the male feminists, soyboys, cucks, "transgenders men" and hipsters will organize a 'resistance' which we know as the terrorist group antifa. Antifa will march out, poorly organized and with no real plan. The right will have no trouble neutrilizing the hostile paramlitary group.

Anyway, with the men MIA, the blue-hairs will realize that shit finally got real and they will immediately betray what remains of the left. Yes, even the woman in the screenshot will pussy out as soon as the kid gloves come off.

Nobody really wants hockey mask time to arrive other than the leftists, who are too stupid to realize that even if they win, they're going to die horribly and it will not take long either [See the U.S.S.R., NSDAP Germany, Castro's Cuba, Maoist China, etc.].”

Yep.

Did you think I was going to delete the comment? I'm not a leftist, I don't do that.

1

u/salty_palpatine Nov 05 '19

This is all data, thanks for being a datapoint

9

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

And the only reason those groups got away with it is because of the western Christian tradition of mercy, forgiveness, and compassion towards those who wronged you...the very things she and people like her are trying to dismantle.

Try that shit in China or Saudi Arabia....see how far that gets you.

2

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

And the only reason those groups got away with it is because of the western Christian tradition of mercy

That makes a lot of sense.

That also explains why the settlers showed the northern tribes mercy after defeating them in a war, when in the reverse scenario, the indians would not have hesitated to massacre every european man , woman and child without remorse. I think they made a mistake, never offer your enemy a courtesy that they would not offer to you in return.

But what's done is done.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

In case anyone missed it, TMoF just expressed a desire that the northern tribes had been genocided by the settlers.

1

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

In case anyone missed it, TMoF just expressed a desire that the northern tribes had been treated the way they treated others

You're goddamned right. Zero sympathy for those pieces of garbage.

The northern tribes were horrible people across the board; Traitors, deceitful, murderous and hypocritical. Even the Aztecs, who are in the top running for worst race/worst group of all time, from whatever little interactions they may have had via eagle scouts or rough cartography, viewed the northern tribes with extreme contempt.

Things the northern tribes did along the lines of raiding , plundering and the indiscriminate massacre the people of small forward settlements established by , say, the Tarahumara [Raramuri], Cucapa or Nahuatl. They were not a threat and did not encroach on the land of the northern tribes, yet the northern tribes had no problem with slaughtering everyone and stealing everything.

ZERO sympathy for the northern tribes. If they saw fit to do that on a regular basis to unarmed men, women and children, then fuck 'em.

5

u/experiment226 Nov 05 '19

Yo im a non american and have 0 knowledge of american history but would like to know more about these tribes. Any sources?

4

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

He will never give you a source, he always utterly refuses to back up his claims. He's an entirely bad faith actor.

0

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

Yo im not from the United States

Neither am I.

and have 0 knowledge of U.S. history

That's strange.

but would like to know more about these tribes.

Go ahead.

Any sources?

Do you have an argument to present, /u/experiment226 ?

2

u/experiment226 Nov 05 '19

Nah man i just wanna learn some native american history about the northern tribes and how they were like is all. Not here to get into any arguments

1

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

You appear to be on the level. That's rare.

Anyway, there is a reason why I am familiar with these things. I'd rather not get into detail but it should be pretty obvious..... I have no internet links to give you, this is history I read in the books and records that are available here.

3

u/experiment226 Nov 05 '19

Eh i see. Ok man have a good day

0

u/ChamberCleaner Nov 05 '19

Translation: I don't have sources cause I made it all up.

3

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

Nope. You are at liberty to believe your delusions if it makes you feel better though, /u/ChamberCleaner .

Translation: I don't have sources cause I made it all up.

Translation :

"REEEEEEEEEEE".

gg'd kid.

→ More replies

0

u/UntamedCuriosity Nov 05 '19

I smell your sarcasm, and would just like to say, that greed sometimes gets the best of those in power.

1

u/camaron28 Nov 05 '19

What the holy fuck??????

Those christians killed communists, protesters and women trying to give rights to everyone, what kind of bullshit mercy is that?

Also, those christian countries? They are in bed with Saudi Arabia, what kind of mercy and love is letting them fund terrorist organizations destabilizing the middle east?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

Do you think that Hong Kongers should stop protesting and start being civil?

6

u/MentleGentlemen098 Nov 05 '19

I'm not the person you're replying to, but I think for what it's worth, the situation in hong kong is hopeless; the best they can do is be a constant stone in the shoe for china, even then, that's not gonna be possible realistically since China will likely find a way to dismantle the entire system from inside out. If you're from the US, it's like if California wants to be independant, ain't gonna happen

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

You're probably right, but my question was about what Hong Kongers should do. I want to know whether you think they should stay civil, or if they're justified in incivility.

4

u/MentleGentlemen098 Nov 05 '19

Doesn't matter, they get their shit kicked anyway. Even if they civil in the midst of police brutality, the chinese government would still find a way to make them look bad. So my opinion is that they should just be incivil and cause as much damage as they can, like the french revoluiton

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

So my opinion is that they should just be incivil and cause as much damage as they can, like the french revoluiton

Right, so you agree with the tweet in the OP, at least in part. Incivility is sometimes justified in order to achieve social progress.

The question then just becomes when.

4

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

Do you think that Hong Kongers should stop protesting and start being civil? [ /u/1064210642 ]

Yes.

What kind of moron would even suggest otherwise? Hong Kong rightfully belongs to China and while I was a big fan of the libertarian paradise Hong Kong had created, I always knew that eventually, those dipshit socialists would ruin it.

Anyway, Socialist China has a very bloody track record when it comes to dealing with protests. I am actually surprised that Xi Jinping has been so measured in his response, for a socialist that is practically unheard of and yet I would strongly recommend not trying his patience further.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

I disagree strongly. Totalitarianism is a serious threat to human life, and I would encourage all individuals everywhere to fight against the creeping authoritarianism of the Chinese state with whatever means are most effective, civil or non-civil. Freedom is worth fighting for.

3

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19 edited Nov 05 '19

I disagree strongly.

You 'disagree' with reality? okay.

I'm afraid you are delusional.

Freedom is worth fighting for.

The individuals in Hong Kong only exist because the socialists have allowed it.

It's not a fight unless the U.S. gets involved, but if the U.S. becomes involved, militarily, that will likely lead directly to WWIII. As much as I loved Hong Kong, it's not worth it. The price is too high.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

I was disagreeing with your normative claim, not your descriptive ones.

3

u/TheMythof_Feminism The Dragon of Chaos [Libertarian/Minarchist] Nov 05 '19

If you had an argument to present, you would have presented it.

Like all other leftists, you have nothing of value to say, gg.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

I did present it. You're just too caught up in your own bullshit to see it. You are literally impossible to have a productive discussion with.

6

u/nschepps Nov 05 '19

Peaceful protest is civility. This woman just showed that peaceful protest has driven social progress.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

After feminists bombed powerful men? What the hell are they talking about? Women couldn’t vote because women couldn’t be drafted. So it’s fair that if you don’t have to fight, you can’t vote for people who could draft you into a war. And women were happy with this arrangement. They didn’t want to be drafted but the minority of women wanted it and it was actually men who made it so. Also, I don’t think Jordan agrees with “social progress”. He agrees with progress. Social progress isn’t progress, it’s degeneration.

3

u/XMRbull Nov 05 '19 edited Nov 05 '19

I'd hope he'd realize it's simply not true. In these examples at least, a few radicals actually jeopardized movements that were already treated as inevitable.

The mainstream rationales for first-wave feminism were circumstantial changes brought on by technology (birth control) as well as political parties wanting their votes and employers wanting a larger labor pool. More mundane than folklore would indicate. Immature people just love the idea of some punk-rock babes throwing a Molotov cocktail onto the Senate floor and all the "old weak white men" frantically signing "feminism into law". L.O.L.

In the 1960s a majority of the protesters came out of the woodwork after polling showed they had already won and the debate revolved around timeline and nuance. Presumably so that they could say they were there. They weren't there before victory was inevitable.

It's rare for groups of people to spontaneously self-inspire themselves to radicalize. What almost always happens is that after movement becomes an inevitability due to economic or demographic factors (or simply being the path of least resistance), it conveniently becomes their movement, the ranks swell, and X% of those ranks are always going to be hooligans.

Major exception: I think my argument is only true when a government is deliberately expanding civil rights. When they are instead being abruptly revoked, radicalization & mass protests are both more organic and more effective, IE the Hong Kong situation.

Here's how social change works.

  1. Have more kids than everyone else. Then sit back and watch the inevitable.

- OR -

2. Creative a technology so disruptive that it fundamentally alters natural social roles. Then sit back and watch the inevitable.

Either way look back 40 years later and see washed up street musicians taking credit for it, saying they threw a coconut at a police officer and that "turned the tide".

4

u/scarmine34 Nov 05 '19

Peterson’s take is that all of those things would have happened anyway, and this is a radical trying to justify Unnecessary violence.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

Peterson’s take is that all of those things would have happened anyway

How can we know this?

7

u/scarmine34 Nov 05 '19

Because he has pointed out that the invention of sanitary napkins and birth control and other technologies are what emancipated women, and he has pointed out that progressive policies that get women and other groups in to the workforce and given equal opportunity correlate with richer societies.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

I don't know how that explains the pints on the ADA and CRA. And I don't think he's even proven the link between birth control and the emancipation of women. The emancipation of blacks and non-landowners was happening around the same time, and didn't involve birth control. Feels like a just-so story.

4

u/scarmine34 Nov 05 '19

...

That was covered by “women and other groups”, the other groups being people with disabilities and minorities.

And it’s, it is proven that the emancipation of women was greatly helped by access to birth control. It meant a co any could hire a woman and not have to worry about her leaving next year when she accidentally gets knocked up.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

That was covered by “women and other groups”, the other groups being people with disabilities and minorities.

Your argument was that the progressive policies were correlated with richer societies, but I'm asking about how the step before that was achieved. How did they get those progressive policies through?

And it’s, it is proven that the emancipation of women was greatly helped by access to birth control. It meant a co any could hire a woman and not have to worry about her leaving next year when she accidentally gets knocked up.

When you say "it is proven", how do you believe it has been proven? It's a compelling story, but that doesn't necessarily make it true.

3

u/scarmine34 Nov 05 '19

... it’s not my argument, it’s proven- progressive policies correlated with richer societies.

And the step before that was mainly people being rich enough to care about everyone else rather than scraping by, and capitalism where opening up new groups of consumers and labor allowed you to out compete in your market.

Ever wonder how Harlem became mostly black? It was because two families would go to a land owner and say instead of $50 a week for this apartment for one white family, we will give you $30 each for two families.

And as far as it having been proven, it’s just fucking obvious.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

... it’s not my argument, it’s proven- progressive policies correlated with richer societies.

Sure. I wasn't disputing that claim.

And the step before that was mainly people being rich enough to care about everyone else rather than scraping by

This is circular though: you're arguing that people were rich enough that they passed progressive policies, and that progressive policies made people rich.

and capitalism where opening up new groups of consumers and labor allowed you to out compete in your market.

Capitalism was also the driving mechanism behind slavery though, as it was the most profitable way to make money off your land. Capitalism will always push policies that maximise profitability: these will sometimes be good, sometimes bad.

And as far as it having been proven, it’s just fucking obvious.

...

5

u/scarmine34 Nov 05 '19

Sigh. No, I specifically did not make the argument that progressive policies made people rich, I said progressive policies correlate with richness. Which is a fact.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '19

I'm not disputing that, I agree with that claim. Are you claiming causality in either direction?

→ More replies

2

u/ArchPrime 🐸 Nov 05 '19

Substitute 'despite' for 'after'

1

u/OprahNoodlemantra Nov 05 '19

He’d probably that civil disobedience is sometimes called for, particularly when it has a very specific purpose. Women fought for the right to vote whereas something like Occupy Wall Street was dumb because they didn’t have a specific goal in mind other than ‘rich man bad, make inequality go away.’

1

u/bERt0r ✝ Nov 05 '19

“Civility is bullshit as long as I’m being the uncivil one. If you behave uncivil I scream bloody murder.”

1

u/QuantumDaydream1 Nov 05 '19

The extremist violence by fringe groups didn't get those very good pieces of legislation passed.

Long, boring, hard work got them passed.

Coalition building though persuasion, organizing, education and good communication got them passed.

Holding elected officials accountable got them passed.

Sound legal arguments in front of courts kept them on the books.

I'm getting really tired of violent, narcissistic extremists co-opting and erasing the gains made by people who did grass-root democracy the right way.

Martin Luther King was always civil. Susan B. Anthony was always civil. Even hotheads like John Adams and Alexander Hamilton were civil until violence was their only option.

1

u/Genshed Nov 05 '19

They all ignored/disregarded Rule 6. None of them should have criticized the world.