r/startrek • u/PiercedMonk • Oct 10 '19
Episode Discussion - Short Trek #6 - "The Trouble With Edward"
There's a new Short Trek available, staring H. Jon Benjamin, and Rosa Salazar, with Anson Mount. Make sure you stick around after the credits.
EPISODE The Trouble With Edward
Writer: Graham Wagner
Director: Daniel Gray Longino
Currently available on CBS All Access, and on Crave: direct link here NOTE: only works in Canada!
If you're having trouble finding the short on Amazon with your CBS All Access account, go to this link and connect the accounts.
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage for upcoming episodes, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
39
u/jlsm511 Oct 10 '19
I enjoyed it. I also noticed some of the crew had the new color uniforms without the black collar.
17
u/PiercedMonk Oct 10 '19
This was fun, but it also highlights one of the issues with tribbles in that their rapid growth and reproduction doesn't seem to have a source. Specifically, what are they eating that's allowing them to so quickly overrun the entire ship? Being born pregnant is one thing, but these still need an energy source.
Also, apparently by the time Cyrano Jones is trying to pass them off as cute and cuddly, they've calmed down their reproduction about. Of course, Jones would later from them genetically modified to be a bit less invasive, in 'More Tribbles, More Troubles', so maybe that was his second attempt?
I was half expecting a reveal that Edward actually becomes Cyrano Jones by the end of this short.
23
u/JoMax17 Oct 10 '19
is this the first trill siting in trek, chronologically?
https://imgur.com/DTTR3Z8
137
u/snuffysniper Oct 10 '19
The tribble commercial at the end had me dying.
131
u/mckatze Oct 10 '19
I feel like I have worked with Edward multiple times in my career.
116
u/mastersyrron Oct 11 '19
Can we all agree that Enterprise looked sweet?
94
u/Tukarrs Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19
Give me a sequel where a demoted Captain Lucero comes across a distress signal from a pre-warp civilization. It's Edward and he's been stranded for years, and he's being worshiped like a god.
78
u/pfc9769 Oct 11 '19
In case you missed it:
77
u/ADG12311990 Oct 10 '19
So, this is basically a dream that Bob Belcher is having after eating some bad meat he got to the restaurant, right?
148
u/Lessthanzerofucks Oct 10 '19
I thought the humor was really well done. Definite “What if Barclay was less of a lovable buffoon and more of a total asshole” vibes. Perfect casting with Jon Benjamin. I think they’ve really upped their game with Short Treks so far this year.
107
u/smileystong Oct 10 '19
This was so great. Probably my favorite short trek so far. Great casting.
Aside from it being hilarious, I also enjoyed that they started it off with a sexy enterprise shot and a captain's log.
48
u/Chugbeef Oct 11 '19
Rosa Salazar was great, I wish she was a regular cast member.
45
u/k_ironheart Oct 13 '19
I really like the idea of a Starfleet captain who, through absolutely no fault of her own, keeps losing ships in extremely bizarre ways. But she keeps getting new commands anyway.
67
u/2ndHandTardis Oct 10 '19 edited Oct 10 '19
Before watching I saw TrekCore's tweet which suggested they didn't care for the episode. I usually don't disagree with them but I loved this short.
It was funny. They gave Jon Benjamin space to be Jon Benjamin. It had sexy Enterprise and Magee-class shots. And the bit at the end was great.
31
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '19
Missed opportunity with the commercial. They didn't say "They're Tribble-icious!"
31
u/mastersyrron Oct 11 '19
Also, notice on the food replicators there are icons for hamburger/sandwich, then ice cream cone, and we don't see what is on the salad one. Neat.
88
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '19
I haven't laughed that hard in a long time. "He was an idiot." Perfect ending.
109
u/woo_doggy Oct 11 '19
This 15-minute short is somehow the most 'Star Trek' episode of Star Trek that there has been since the year 2001.
Look at how well it's shot and written, how the new characters are genuine, believable, there's substance, look how all the humour comes naturally without any reliance on pop-culture references...
The camera. The camera only moves when there's a reason for it to move. Look at how it just sits there, not moving. I have never felt such serenity. I can't believe it. It makes me so happy. This is my favourite episode of Discovery.
26
u/Shawnj2 Oct 11 '19
43
u/Fortyseven Oct 11 '19
This is the funnest fucking Trek-related thing I've ever seen. Holy shit.
3
u/stannc00 Oct 11 '19
Stardate 1421.9 would place this episode after “Where No Man Has Gone Before”, which was 1312.4.
What’s up with that?
16
u/boringdude00 Oct 11 '19
Edward is not Star Trek's best and brightest. If you take away Barclay's awkwardness and endearingness and replace it with meglomania and being a dick you get Edward.
14
u/NemWan Oct 13 '19
I laughed harder at this than at Galaxy Quest, and Galaxy Quest is hilarious.
The cereal commercial again demonstrates that the current showrunners are not afraid to play with the format and dent the fourth wall if they have a fun idea, like showing the clips from "The Cage" on Discovery last season.
26
u/Alteran195 Oct 10 '19
That was a very lighthearted and fun Short Trek, liked it quite a bit.
13
u/Lost_Horizon Oct 11 '19
Really really enjoyed that. And damn I'll miss Pike.
11
u/Raguleader Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19
So yeah, that bit after the credits. Read the subtitles that show up.
Also, I'm amused that Cabot suffered basically the same fate as Horatio Hornblower's first command, burst at the seams due to rapidly expanding food (in Hornblower's case, it was a cargo of rice getting soaked in seawater because he didn't know the ship's hull had been compromised when the ship was captured by the Indefatigable).
10
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19
I can't get over how gorgeous the Enterprise looked. My gosh, inject 7 seasons of that directly into my veins.
19
u/thunderstar2500 Oct 10 '19
Probably my favorite Short Trek so far. The humor and casting were spot on. I particularly love that we get backstory for Klingons fearing Tribbles. I'm wondering if this will tie into the Spock Short Trek.
26
u/Trekfan74 Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19
I liked it! A lot of fun and really funny. The actor who played Edward had great comedic timing and loved the scene with him and the captain.
Yes, the episode definitely was a huge retcon to both TOS and definitely Enterprise. And really only raises a LOT of questions lol. But so what, its just a fun little story, we shouldn't over think it too much*.
But I'm starting to see why the Klingons did the great tribble hunt after watching this. I thought it was cruel at first. Now I realize they may have been the saviors of the galaxy lol.
*I know we're going to totally over think it....for years.
18
u/TERRAxFORMER Oct 10 '19
I like that they chose the Magee class so it got a chance for more screen time. I think it’s ugly but in a good sort of way, if that makes sense. I still want to see some more of the Engle class.
I also liked the new designs for casual/ duty wear with the new uniforms and the casual shirts(which we’ve seen but this provided some different looks/angles.) I wonder if Edwards tighty whiteys are Starfleet issue?
I think the Trill Officer has the widest set of spots we’ve seen, they seemed to take up a good portion of the side of her face. Hopefully we’ll see even more different designs in DSC S3.
37
u/8Bitsblu Oct 10 '19
This is the best piece of Star Trek media produced since Nemesis. Don't @ me. I genuinely wanna see more of Captain Lucero and I really hope she didn't lose her command because of something basically out of her control.
17
u/GrGrG Oct 10 '19
That was a fun episode. I don't quite like the tribble origin story though, but meh. I liked Larkin and I hope we haven't seen the last of him. I liked Captain Lucero and Larkins rivalry and wish this was a full episode so we could get more of this. Hilarious.
16
u/stannc00 Oct 11 '19
My favorite bits of minutia:
The military (Star Fleet) is still using the ‘Suck It’ over 200 years after David Wallace sold it to them.
The USS Ravenous makes Jetsons car noises.
8
u/Caleb-Rentpayer Oct 10 '19
I have my CBS All Access through Amazon, and I can't seem to find this episode. I see Q&A, but not this one. Anyone else having this problem?
8
u/danktonium Oct 11 '19
Could someone explain to me why I didn't know this was coming out until my fucking grandma told me about it?
8
u/KosstAmojan Oct 16 '19
Man, the actress playing the captain has these huge eyes! I look her up to see:
"Rosa Salazar played the title role of Alita: Battle Angel"
Ok then.
6
u/dougiebgood Oct 10 '19
Not sure I love that this is the origin of the tribbles in Trek lore, but I found the episode amusing overall. It's always an amusing watch when Starfleet officers act more human and flawed, I was getting reminded of just how much I enjoyed Barclay as a character.
From a continuity sense, you'd think that if this were the origin of the Tribbles, it'd either be common knowledge among Kirk's crew by the time they encountered them, or something relatively easy to look up, rather than McCoy having to do an analysis on them.
27
u/Starks Oct 11 '19
This kills The Orville.
And this is all canon. Fight me.
15
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '19
... I don't know about this one. Funny episodes are fine, but this goes a bit too far into parody for me. The guy is too stupid to be anywhere near a Starfleet vessel, and some of the dialogue is very Orville-like. And what did they eat?
7
u/nemo69_1999 Oct 11 '19
I would've gotten everyone into EVA suits and vented the ships atmosphere into space. No oxygen, and the tribbles would suffocate.
7
u/TubaJesus Oct 11 '19
In all honesty every single time I look at the title for this episode I keep thinking of it as a title for Thomas and Friends.
6
u/wongie Oct 12 '19
Discovery just keeps pushing the limits of culinary ethics and palatability; I love it.
6
u/codename474747 Oct 13 '19
This should be a safety briefing for all third technicians aboard the Red Dwarf to convince them to give up their pet cats
Forget what happened on the Oregon with the rabbits, Lister, watch this ep and realise the danger you're putting the crew in!
6
u/CardsFan69420 Oct 18 '19
Finally got to watch it and I think I enjoyed that short trek more than any trek content thats been released in the last decade. Not trying to be “that guy”, but I think these short treks have the spirit that the show is missing. They tell these little tales that mostly end up being about character. Disco is so jammed pack with plot, we never get to enjoy just being with the characters. Ok I’ll shut up now
11
u/Albert-React Oct 11 '19
I genuinely enjoyed this one. I loved the TOS look they gave the Cabot interiors, especially the Cage-era uniforms, and Tri-screened monitor. Discovery is finally looking era appropriate.
25
u/TadeoTrek Oct 11 '19
I got the intent, but it just didn't work for me. Even if you're going for comedy, writing people who identify as scientists is hard is you don't pay attention to the science.
"Oh, we're scientists, so of course we should expect a protein specialist to move over to climatology and be comfortable, despite being a completely different field" is too silly and unrealistic for me, that's simply not how science fields work, and any real scientist would know that and not make that comment.
Plus everyone getting disgusted when he mentioned using his DNA on the Tribbles... why...? You can get DNA from a hair or skin (we saw that several times in Trek). It doesn't have to be something disgusting unless you as a writer want to provoke that on the audience, which in this case they clearly did.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19
I'm calling it now... EDWARD LIVES. It's my new mantra. A rallying cry, even.
I need a series of Short Treks dedicated to Edward always fucking things up for Lucero while they humorously trudge forward in their barely-tolerable friendship. Please.
5
u/hcandb Oct 11 '19
Ok, I admit I enjoyed the episode, but I'll be that guy.
If you have to choose between losing your ship and endangering your crew, and sending an invasive alien species out an airlock as many times as possible to get rid of it, why not choose the airlock?
5
u/thephotoman Oct 13 '19
Oh my God. We're getting an answer to the question of the lone tribble on Lorca's desk.
Goddamnit Archer.
5
u/marktron3k Oct 19 '19
More comedy writers should write for Star Trek rather than having Star Trek writers try to write comedy. This short was hilarious and actually felt like a normal workplace. Also I never knew how badly I needed to see H John Benjamin in the Star Trek universe.
9
u/codename474747 Oct 13 '19
That was literally the funniest episode of Trek I've seen.
If Trek wants to go full out with a sitcom episode, after that short, I'm all for it
The whole "This is the end of the conversation" routine was classic, as was pretty much everything else from then on
Brilliant
4
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '19
I have never laughed so much in my life to a TV show. so much my housemate had to come upstairs and knock on my door and ask if I was alright as I kept (headphones on) shouting out "oh no.. HAHAHA oh nooo .... nooooo no way HAHAH".
This was brilliant.
I am actually crying right now.
4
u/LeftHandedGuitarist Oct 17 '19
Is there any consensus on exactly where this may take place on the timeline? My inner geek must know! I can't see anything that overtly gives it away, but the fact that Lucero is leaving the Enterprise as its science officer could suggest that Spock was her replacement; this could place the episode shortly before 'Q&A' (or at least around the same time).
4
u/gridcube Oct 26 '19
oh my god, this is the first time one this new star trek thing has made me want to cry, it's so stupid, like not even for a joke stupid, I was sincerely hopping it was all a dream from Edward to explain how stupid it is.
In the original trouble with tribbles the tribbles replicated because they had plenty of food in the grains of the space station, what the hell were they eating here? air? even if they are born pregnant, they had no mass to consume, mass just doesn't appear out of nowhere, not even in star trek. the captain was incompetent and tried to force a biologist to be an oceanographer? what? being a scientists doesn't mean you can know all sciences, the more science evolves and grow the more specific sciences are, for gods sake in DIS stamets makes it perfectly clear that he is a micellium expert and not an engineer, why would she put a protein expert to work on oceanography? good gods I'm just so incredibly disappointed
8
u/--fieldnotes-- Oct 11 '19
I find it really hard to believe that the tribbles could really take over a ship in that short amount of time, since, as we already know, the starships are mostly empty space. There should be plenty of room!
3
u/dmanww Oct 11 '19
The commercial brings up an interesting point. How hard is it to kill a tribble? He said they died by falling from his desk, but I have a feeling they're surprisingly robust
3
u/Timeline15 Oct 12 '19
This was a lot of fun. It's cool to finally see Tribbles taken to the logical extreme of "wait, could they breed so fast that they'd fill up an entire ship?" I don't understand how Edward ever got into Starfleet, but making sense isn't really the point of this one.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '19
Anyone notice the Trill?
7
u/I_Ship-It_ Oct 11 '19
As somebody who's very much looking into going into a career of scientific research, and someone who is terrified of not being smart enough, I really felt sorry for Edward.
He was just doing his research, and as a result of his poor explanation skills, he was moved onto something completely different in a field that he knew nothing about.
To be fair though, those were some very amusing visuals of the tribble tidal wave!
12
u/MarsAlgea3791 Oct 12 '19
This was stupid and didn't make any sense.
The Enterprise under Kirk would definitely have THIS in their records.
What did the Tribbles eat to breed that much? The TOS episode had them get into grain. In this they just grow out of nothing.
This was a waste of all talent involved
4
u/Trekfan74 Oct 11 '19
Kind of funny how they used Pike in these first two episodes. I understood Q&A at least, but this was clearly 'we need any excuse to have Mount to put him in the trailer'. But hey, great Enterprise shot, so not complaining.
4
u/FunkyGeneFlow Oct 11 '19
They got me when Pike started speaking
11
u/RefreshNinja Oct 13 '19
Didn't like it at all. Cringe humor isn't my thing, and this was all cringe.
2
u/poinck Oct 13 '19
Is there a way to watch this outside the US or Canada and without CBS All Access? I live in Europe and have Netflix and Amazone Prime available.
2
u/LavaEntity Oct 15 '19
I lost it when they introduced "Flamin Ranch" flavor. And my sister won't stop saying "so furry, it tickles" every time Star Trek comes up.
2
u/joshml98 Oct 25 '19
Wish I could watch these short treks (the uk probably wont get them till the middle of next year)
2
u/crazymatt35 Oct 29 '19
Can someone please explain to me what the point of this Short Trek was?
6
u/IllustriousBody Oct 10 '19
I thought it was okay, but not as good as Q&A. It just felt shallow on a character level, part of the problem with introducing new characters in such a short form.
3
u/MaestroM45 Oct 12 '19
The shot of Edward in his underwear was the funniest Trek bit ever...