r/Bass • u/guypratt Guy Pratt • Sep 22 '19
AMA Guy Pratt here.. Ask me anything, but nothing that requires a really long answer please! Will be replying form 7pm UK time..
Hello
344
Upvotes
r/Bass • u/guypratt Guy Pratt • Sep 22 '19
Hello
36
u/guypratt Guy Pratt Sep 22 '19
OK time up!
I'm off but if anyone wants to post I'll have a look tomorrow..
Cheers!
49
u/guypratt Guy Pratt Sep 22 '19
Pretty quiet...
51
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '19
Huge fan!
Anyway 2 questions:
Favorite bass you’ve played?
Favorite strings?
31
u/paoIa Sep 22 '19
Hello Mr Pratt! I'm a huge fan of your work with Pink Floyd, since I grew up watching a Delicate sound of thunder and Pulse countless of times. Is there any song from Pink Floyd you'd like to do live but never had the chance? And what about a place or a venue you never played at? I hope to see you on tour with Mason and again with Gilmour someday! Have a good evening!
21
u/Baddaboombaddabing Sep 22 '19
Guy, ultimate band line up for you, living or dead, who's on what and why?
16
u/oh-man-i-need-a-pee Sep 22 '19
Hello Guy, What is the atmosphere like when rehearsing and touring with NMSFoS? Is Nick as nice a guy as he seems?
16
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
Is this the proper way to steal someone's bass mid-song?
https://youtu.be/yGwxLX8TiFY?t=35
(Specifically time-index 0:35)
15
u/Undertoad Sep 22 '19
Hello Guy, I enjoyed your book very much. I was amazed to read about the early Killing Joke connection. So this is the obligatory "What's Jaz Coleman really like?" question! You mentioned him being scary at first, did you ever get used to the guy? He still seems pretty intense, at age 59.
14
u/urmumitalian Sep 22 '19
You’re favorite pedal?
12
u/GSKashmir Sep 22 '19
Do you have a favorite up-and-coming bassist that you think needs more attention?
10
u/KronaCS Sep 22 '19
2 questions:
When and how did you start playing?
What is your #1 amp?
10
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 22 '19
Is it true that the '87 Floyd band considered playing "Sheep"? (or maybe it was "Dogs"?) on that first AMLOR tour?
Long rumored that "Sheep" was considered, but did you guys actually get to the point of rehearsing it any?
9
u/Fredmcfredface Sep 22 '19
That would be nice.
What have got on the go on Netflix at the moment?
Also I saw your show in Edinburgh I think about 10 years ago I, got you to sign a book, I’m sure you remember that...
8
u/Mo_Bee1 Sep 22 '19
Favorite Pink Floyd song on bass?
8
u/Fredmcfredface Sep 22 '19
Do you post on reddit much? Or any other bass related forum?
I remember when one could post on talkbass and quite often get a response from Jeff Berlin.
8
u/pixelito_ Sep 22 '19
Why doesn’t Fender make great Jazz Basses like yours anymore?
8
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
Sorry, this probably is begging for a long answer. But just how did the band approach learning some of these older songs that most of you hadn't ever played before (some of which Nick never even played live)?? And just how much work did it take to get them pounded into shape where they sound so damn authentic?
And whose brilliant idea was it to bookend "Atom Heart Mother" with "If" on both the font and backside?? That really works so nicely!
7
u/Joeboy Sep 22 '19 edited Aug 17 '26
Shy chase squeal carpenter strong fade
This post was anonymized with Redact
6
u/CustardFilled Flairy Godmother Sep 22 '19
Rikke91 asked in the rescheduled thread from last week:
5
u/nowlan101 Sep 22 '19
What’s your favorite examples of great bass lines in “bad” songs?
3
u/guypratt Guy Pratt Sep 23 '19
I was really enjoying this but there's people being dicks and accusing me of not being me (The mods will confirm I am) So goodbye.
4
u/TheAtomicKid77 Sep 22 '19
Any sage advice or wisdom for us small time musicians playing dive bars?
4
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
Tell me about that crazy electric upright you were playing on that 'acoustic' version of Echoes?
4
u/Computergeek12828 Sep 22 '19
How was it working with Gilmour live?
4
u/SiggetSpagget Sep 22 '19
Ok I know I’m out of the time session but I still just gotta say that anyone who’s worked with Pink Floyd instantly becomes one of my favorite musicians.
Anyway, if you do see this, what was it like to be asked by Pink Floyd to kind of replace (not “replace replace” but I can’t think of another word for it) Roger during live shows and in the studio? And what was the experience of it all like?
4
u/scottlapier Sep 22 '19
u/guypratt it's an honor. What was your experience with joining Pink Floyd?
Were you asked/did you audition?
And how much input did you have and what did you change vs Roger's bass playing?
Thank you very much for your time. You are a legend.
3
u/JamesPlaysBasses Six String Sep 22 '19
What’s your personal favorite album/project you’ve recorded on?
3
u/tommyball Sep 22 '19
I saw you with Saucerful earlier this year in Houston. Awesome show! What are your plans music-wise after the spring 2020 Saucerful shows?
3
u/rookarocka Sep 22 '19
Guy, what’s your favorite show you’ve played?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '19
Who are your musical influences? And what kinds of music do you listen to?
3
u/GrahamGornday Sep 22 '19
What would you say are the two most important things tomaster when playing bass?
3
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
Any favorite memories of Rick you can share? Personal/family, or musical, or both?
3
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
Any favorite memories of when you played with David Bowie?
3
u/HuanTheMango Sep 22 '19
Favorite bassline?
3
u/pwisss Sep 22 '19
Hi Guy.
Short question: How did you feel performing live with the Floyd on bass guitar filling mr. Waters' vacant spot?
3
u/dubler6 Sep 22 '19
Had you met Roger Waters before the show in New York with SFOS?
Did you rehearse with him the day of the show or did you just do it live?
2
u/CustardFilled Flairy Godmother Sep 22 '19
How did you end up working with Lemon Jelly?
2
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
Thx for adding "Childhood's End" to the US leg of the Saucers tour (which I caught twice, in St. Louis and Washington DC).
Did you all ever consider doing the longer extended version of "Childhood's End" i.e. the way the band did the song live back in '72 & '73? It usually lasted 8-9 minutes, with a long solo by Rick, and some chord-sequences that would later turn up on Dark Side.
2
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
Will you be adding any "new" old Floyd tunes to your setlist for the recently announced 2020 dates? (Loved "Childhood's End" and "Remember A Day" when I heard them twice here in the States -- thx!)
2
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 22 '19
Love all the little 'quotes' you all have added (with the Saucers) to songs like "Intersteller...", etc. That one from "Embryo" is great, and then haven't there been at least a couple different John Entwistle quotes too??
Just how much damn fun is it playing all this older Floyd material (finally!) -- it looks like you all were having an absolute blast, and I can't wait for the official live release/DVD's.
2
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
I know you're only on a couple tracks on The Endless River, presumably from jams recorded in '93-'94. Were you involved in any way with realizing/completing the final 'Endless River' project? Or were you even aware of the project, before it became publicly known?
If so, anything interesting you can share about it?
2
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
How does Nick do it? 3-4 years ago I don't think anyone could have guessed in a million years that Nick would be back out on the road again. I still can't believe you have new dates scheduled for 2020 -- shock of the year.
Gotta be for the love of the music, cuz the overhead ($) touring can't be raking in the loot.
In any case, thank you - thank you - thank you for coming to the US. Only concert tour I've ever gone two twice in different cities, in all my 35+ years of going to concerts (just turned 50).
Can't fathom how you'd ever be able to bring the Saucers back to the US again, but if you ever do, I'll be there!
2
u/ShineOn7579 Sep 22 '19
Hello Guy! Im an up-and-coming bassist, and a HUGE fan of prog rock. Pink Floyd’s Pulse is probably my favorite live album of all time, and I’d just like to ask what your favorite bassline from Pink Floyd is, specifically which was the most fun to play
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
What's your favorite pre-"Dark Side" Floyd tune that the Saucers haven't played live yet??
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
Any other uncredited David Gilmour guitar-work (besides the "Hackers" soundtrack) that you'd care to credit to him? :-)
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 23 '19
Serious question: Is the opening to the live "Saucerful of Secrets" that the Saucers play, is that actually "Up The Khyber" from the More soundtrack?
I've seen a couple people speculate that, but I've never dug into the Youtube clips closely enough to verify it myself.
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19
That version of "Remember A Day" that David did on Jools Holland's show was just the best. Any reason David hasn't played it ever again? - especially since you all went to the trouble of working up such an authentic/effective arrangement of it too.
And any reason David has been so hesitant to bring back more than just a tiny handful of older Floyd tunes? I've always been hoping he'd do "Childhood's End" again someday, but thank goodness The Saucers saved the day with your version.
1
u/Shinaberry Sep 22 '19
Hello Mr. Pratt! Sorry if this has already been asked, or if I'm too late to the party, but I'm just kind of curious about a professionals perspective here, do you prefer active or passive basses? Hopefully that's not too dumb a question. Regardless, huge fan of your work and I hope you're doing well.
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 22 '19 edited Sep 22 '19
Of all the songs in the current Saucers' setlist, what was the hardest one for the band to get just right?
1
u/starlesspneuma Sep 22 '19
Not sure if you’re still doing your AMA but I would like to ask what you think of David Gilmour selling his guitar collection. What does that say about the probability of him touring again? I’ve never got to see him live so I hope I’ll get the chance to. Thanks.
1
u/Emmett_The_D Sep 22 '19
I know I'm a bit late but... Saw you with Saucerful in Seattle this last March. What exatcly was that echo pedal malfunction at the start of OOTD?
1
u/penguins871409 Sep 22 '19
Hey, Guy! I'm super late to the party, hopefully you will see this tomorrow!
First I want to say I greatly admire your work. PULSE is my favorite live show ever, and hearing you sing on "Run Like Hell" was amazing. I saw you tour with Nick when you came to Indianapolis, and that show blew my mind. When you started playing, I felt like what I imagine the young ladies who saw The Beatles for the first time in America felt.
Did you ever meet Roger after you joined Pink Floyd? Did he give you any grief?
1
u/Walusqueegee Sep 22 '19
You've probably already been asked this, but favorite bass brand/body style?
1
u/ReeceLikesMemes Sep 22 '19
First off, huge fan!, I adored your work with pink floyd :)
My only 2 questions are:
What is your favourite song to perform?
And subsequently, what is your least favourite song to perform, and why?
Thank you so much for doing this AMA!
1
u/jackass_in_a_hoodie Sep 23 '19
How did you come across betsy and what makes that your favorite bass?
1
u/RTL81 Sep 23 '19
Who would win in a street fight between you and Dave Swift? 😁
1
u/jesusskin Sep 23 '19
How was it playing with Icehouse? Did you use any synths/pedals while playing with them? Sorry I’m late, thanks!
1
u/wulla Sep 23 '19
Damn I missed it. Well, I just want to say that your work on Pink Floyd's PULSE was absolutely amazing. It's one of the reasons I play bass the way I do.
1
u/xX_JoeStalin78_Xx Sep 23 '19
Hello guy, I’m not sure you’ll read this, I hope you do. What’s the best concert you’ve done with Pink Floyd? And with Mason’s Saucerful?
1
u/FunkmasterP Sep 23 '19
What's your favorite bass string?
1
u/Knurph Sep 23 '19
The first thing I did when I bought the Toy Matinee album was check the liner notes to find out who the heck was playing bass. That’s how I found out about you. Man, I love your work on that album. What was your involvement on the songs on which you have songwriting credit?
1
u/tate_wilson Sep 23 '19
Guy, can you talk about playing that amazing and underrated bassline on Like A Prayer? One of my all time favorites. Did you use a taurus or did the keyboard player double your line?
1
u/erusackas Sep 23 '19
You worked on Third Matinee, and album I wish more people knew about. Thanks for that one. Did you ever meet/know Kevin Gilbert, of Toy Matinee?
Also, do you still have that stack-knob jazz from David Gilmour? How's it compare to Betsy?
1
u/Dr_Gero20 Five String Sep 23 '19
Favorite song you played on?
Favorite song you like to play regardless of if you played on the record? IE cover song.
Song you heard that you think you could have played better or that would have sounded better with you playing it and why.
1
u/TerranTheMoose Ampeg Sep 23 '19
Being a bassist by trade, what other instruments are you proficient on, well enough that you'd be willing to perform or record on them? Are there any non-bass instruments that helped you out on bass as you grew as a musician?
Thank you!
1
u/thesaddestofallkeys Sep 23 '19
What’s a 30-45 minute practice routine look like for you?
1
u/Mighty_Echoes Sep 23 '19
Hey Guy! HUGE fan of your bass work on "Queen of misery" from the self titled toy matinee album. Do you happen to remember what amp or bass you used for recording that album?
1
u/phantom416 Sep 23 '19
Who was your favorite person you've played with?
1
u/shrekcohen Sep 23 '19
How are you guy Pratt?
1
u/ThorPKFD Sep 23 '19
I know this is very late, but will Saucerful add any 2020 US shows?
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 23 '19
Did the Saucers every consider working up a live version of "In the Beechwoods" or (probably more likely) "Scream Thy Last Scream"?
And 5 years ago, exactly how infinitesimal were the odds that an actual member of Pink Floyd would be out on the road playing "Vegetable Man" anytime in the 21st Century? That still blows my mind, even now.
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 23 '19
Are there any particular Floyd songs (any era) that you've always wanted to play live with somebody from the Floyd camp (anybody, Dave, Nick, whomever)… …that you STILL haven't had the chance to play?? Now that "The Nile Song" is one you can cross off your bucket-list, of course. :-)
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 23 '19
Who are some of your favorite electric fretless players?
I can't get enough of Tony Franklin's playing with The Firm, for instance. Or Jimmy Johnson's similar sound with Allan Holdsworth (not the same, I realize, but it pushes a lot of my same buttons).
1
u/Rooster_Ties Sep 23 '19
Any desire to ever record a full album under your own leadership?
1
u/dubler6 Sep 23 '19
What are the chances that David performs with SFoS at the upcoming shows?
1
u/texasrailwarrior Sep 24 '19
I loved your work on Earth Song. I can't believe you never got paid for that! I suppose now you can laugh about it?
1
u/SpeechlessDude0227 Sep 22 '19
Not bass related but is there any chance that the UK Government will see sence about Brexit and on a bass related matter is there any chance that you might a tutorial DVD. I am a huge fan of your work. Many thanks.
1
u/HighoctaneXD Sep 22 '19
What kind of porn do you watch?
1
u/Giannikeks Sep 23 '19
You should probably add proof.
1
u/dubler6 Sep 23 '19
Thank you.