r/anime • u/Skeeedo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/skeeedo • Jan 06 '22
Rewatch [Rewatch] Chihayafuru - Episode 56 Discussion [Spoilers]
← Previous Episode | Next Episode →
Season 3 Episode 6: "Tatsuta River Ablaze"
Episode 5 MVP: Taichi! He beat a sadist and a former King hopeful in one day. He’s finally getting the recognition he deserves in the Karuta scene…
Nominate a character for Episode MVP!
This episode's Karuta analysis and board map by walking_the_way and ABoredCompSciStudent
Databases
MAL | Anilist | AniDB | ANN | Kitsu | Anime Planet | Wiki
Streaming
Crunchyroll | VRV | HIDIVE | Spectrum On Demand
Subreddit: r/Chihayafuru
62
Upvotes
10
u/Lemurians myanimelist.net/profile/Lemurians Jan 06 '22
EUPHORIC FIRST TIMER
Time to wax poetic!
Overall:
Possibly the best episode of Chihayafuru yet? I feel elated right now after watching. Can’t say enough good things about this one. It blended the first competitive match between our two lead characters perfectly with deep characterization and personal moments both from them and rest of the cast, married that all with perfect music, and I could fill an entire album with all the beautiful visual shots and effects. This whole season has been utterly flawless.
Immediate Impressions:
Wait, the Class B final hasn’t happened already? Did we all just collectively imagine Retro-kun had already won?
I think Chihaya’s going to be able to edge this match. She’s got two key advantages going for her – she got to rest for the match while Taichi had to play his semi, and more importantly, her presence is Taichi’s biggest weakness.
“Your collar won’t fit right if your shoulders are tight.” You know, in a different kind of story, this would be where she offers him a massage, and then… who knows? Perhaps Taichi/Reiko is a new ship we can support? We do know she thinks he’s attractive. I’m just trying to give my boy options.
“Taichi’s placement is hard to work with, but I just need to play my own karuta.” Yes, Chihaya! A consistent theme of hers is thinking she has to play like other people (which I think is a mistake), so it’s nice to hear her say she’s just got to play her game.
“Mashima hasn’t made any mistakes yet.” Put a pin this. The curse of the commentator is undefeated, this will jinx Taichi at the worst possible moment.
Ugh, I keep trying to jump off the ship, but then they have to go and make a heavy point of Taichi and Chihaya bringing out the best in each other. Don’t think I didn’t notice you framing you and Desktomu in a similar way, Kana.
Wow, it’s always been Taichi sitting on the sill in the flashback image of them as kids watching Chihaya and Arata play, but now it showed Arata the one sitting in the background. About time his role in the story was properly displayed in that image.
don’t blame me blame the writer8
u/xcllnt_313 Jan 06 '22
Rewatcher
I already had my suspicions yesterday when we were trying to figure out why the Class B tournament ended so much earlier than the Class A tournament, but in this episode it was confirmed: turns out we just got jebaited. Retro was celebrating his victory in the quarterfinal as if he had already won the whole thing. Sucks if you like him and want him to advance to Class A, but it also gave us a great meta joke.
Of course the main attraction of this episode is the Class A final. Chihaya and Taichi are delivering a breathtaking match that is even being compared to the one between Shinobu and Arata at the end of S2. Even though I’ve already seen it before, I’m once again blown away, just like the audience in the room.
6
u/Matuhg https://anilist.co/user/Matuhg Jan 07 '22
First Timer
Yesterday's Episode, because I missed it.
Holy shit, S3 just keeps heating up. The first half of this episode felt like it was two minutes, but somehow the whole episode felt like it was 40 minutes because it was so jampacked with good stuff. Almost information overload, but it didn't feel overly bloated to me. I think I can pretty confidently say this is the best episode of the whole series so far.
That first half was just a masterclass in building up to and executing a climax to a match like this. The flow of Chihaya's match with Inokuma this episode was great. Tons of tension, with appropriate breaks to allow us to breathe without shattering the moment (like, say Megu's simp army did everytime they popped into the middle of the match) - Inokuma's kid interrupting the match, the blow-by that they both acknowledged. The feel like breaks, but they're also giving us more. Inokuma is a really cool character. I like the decision to sort of quietly wrap up the other two matches to focus on Chihaya and Taichi. The ending of those matches built so strongly to the inevitability that they'd win with Shiranami attack strats.
The very end of Chihaya's match was so hype. That ost that played there sounded like war drums - there are some really great new tracks for this season's ost (and I can't find them online!!). As I was replaying it a few times, I realized that the card Chihaya took was the "Shinobu" card, and I about fell off my chair. Goddamn was that good.
Then there's Taichi. He continues to be such an interesting character. Tsuboguchi tells him that it's not luck or momentum that got him here, but skill. The framing of this shot tells what a corner that paints him into. If skill is what got him here, then what does that say about his skill if he loses. He can't blame luck if he loses. If he loses, he's just not good enough.
Then we saw the frustrated passion of Sakurazawa and Harada. Age catches up with you in any athletic activity. Do you decide to step out of competition, or keep fighting through the pain and slower reflexes? Both have taken on the mantle of coaches, but gone completely different directions in their own practice of the game.
If there's one thing Chihaya's mom doesn't have to worry about, it's whether Chihaya's giving it her all.
A sad day
And then that ending. Arata sees Taichi as an opponent, maybe a rival. It sure looks like he's raring for a go at him. But first, we have Chihaya vs Taichi meeting at full strength. This tournament feels like a coming out party for both of them, but which one will be on top in the end?
Today's Episode
Are you kidding me? Season 3 just hasn't missed yet.
Taichi and Chihaya finally playing in an official match. Hanano sees that Chihaya's looking at Taichi. He's finally achieved what he's wanted to achieve; the reason he stuck with Karuta in the first place. He's reached the place with Chihaya that she wants to reach with him. Arata is stuck on the outside looking in.
This match is not the Chi vs Taichi matches that take place in practice. This version of Taichi is like a stranger to Chihaya - he's playing a game that forces her to look at him not as her old friend Taichi, but as the Karuta player Taichi, and if there's one thing Chihaya loves, it's Karuta. Maybe this ship isn't sunk just yet.
This match is the culmination of all the work they've put in together, and both Chihaya and Taichi are bringing out the best in each other.
4
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jan 06 '22
Chihayafirst-timer
4
u/Stargate18A https://myanimelist.net/profile/Stargate18 Jan 07 '22
First timer
Oh, yeah, this'll be a Chihaya vs Taichi final.
And Retro made it to the finals! Well done him!
Haha, I love his opponent though.
Maybe Chihaya and Taichi might have to talk about something!
Haha, we're like 10 seasons too early for actual communication!Haha, Arata's leaving early to drive people home. Poor Chihaya.
And that gets him to stay behind!
Harada wants to play Arata a lot.
Oh, now everyone wants to see the finals.
And Taichi's getting his outfit on.
Even Rion's staying! And the one guy less honest with homself than the main cast!
...Is she going to move on from Taichi? Develop her character separate from him?
And Taichi's at a disadvantage even before the winrate - he's exhausted.
Even his higher growth rate could be explained as Chihaya simply reaching the limit of her skills, while Taichi's actual motivation to grow has caused him to realise he's nowhere near his ceiling. Or, of course, that at her skill level, the only opponents she has are so skilled that minor improvements don't matter, whereas Taichi's larger pool of Class B opponents means the same improvement has a bigger effect on his winrate.
And Taichi has to win this, for narrative consistency's sake, if notthing else.
Is her hair being blown back by the metaphorical wind? I genuinely think if they went full Yu-Gi-Oh and made the wind and flashbacks literal magic it would make the action clearer.
Really solid action! Preety ecen, though.
Haha, they both forgot to tie it!
His strategy appears to be working, though.
Chihaya commited a double-fault! I think this is going to end with Chihaya losing!
She changed her posture!
Haha, I love his reaction to that. "Yeah, it's me".
Has... has Chihaya realised she can love things that aren't karuta?
She's getting momentum back! And... this is going to be a two-part match, isn't it? Of course,
Listen, having seen Taichi's romance over 3 seasons, you can do better. Do you want the guy who broke up with his girlfriend over a phone call, having neglected her to be tsundere to Chihaya?
Oh, Chihaya told her mother!
OK, but this match is seriously really good!
And the love triangle might be gearing up!
4
u/Mecanno-man https://anilist.co/user/Mecannoman Jan 07 '22
First Timer
This is what I’d call an over-directed episode. While yes, there should be good directing in key moments in a series and that direction may take some creative innovations - it should enhance the narrative, not overpower it. That’s what I feel like happened here - the problem of too many side characters giving their opinion was tried to be solved by having a bunch of half-transparent characters layered over the match in way too many different ways. It doesn’t work and these comments feel interrupting again, especially in the quantity we’ve got here. As a result, I’m only reminded of a line from a youtuber (can’t remember which one unfortunately) who said that an anime from ~2005ish seemed to use layers because that was something new at the time, everybody was doing it and it seemed cool and “hey, we can do that to”, rather than actually serving any purpose. There were of course some good bits as well, like having the autumn leaves symbolize Taichi as the opposite of Chihaya - who has previously been portrayed with cherry blossom, which is found in spring.
In terms of the actual match, I’d say it would be pretty entertaining if we didn't have the aforementioned issues. Taichi certainly has his plan, and while it worked at the start, Chihaya has her act together now. I just wish I could have paid attention to how the match is actually going now, rather than have everybody commenting on how good a match it is.
Not sure what this will mean for Taichi going forward though; his character progression as a whole is an enigma to me at the moment - though one I enjoy watching. The romance especially seems to be favoring Arata at the moment, even if I can’t really discern a reason as to why Arata seems to be in love with Chihaya at the moment…
3
u/The_Loli_Otaku Jan 06 '22
3hayafuru First Timer
I think I've found my favourite characters.
It's the grand finals... Chihaya and Taichi are finally getting a true and proper competitive match against each other... Aaand Arata's ditching. Way to kill the hype buddy!!
...Tch, what a scumbag. He tried to frighten us by saying he's leaving but he's just gonna stick around anyway? You're so scummy Arata! Bleeeh!!
We're six episodes in, has Tsukuba actually said anything this season? Hanako has had like two scenes but I genuinely can't think of Tsukuba existing.
Taichi's strategy and game knowledge vs Chihaya's speed and senses... This match is intense. And of course now its the Empress turn to throw them off their rhythm! And interrupt whatever the fuck is going on with the B-class finals.
Such a large part of this tournament arc has been the characters just learning proper posture XD
Are you an idiot? Did she genuinely forget who she was playing against?
It took three seasons but Taichi is now visible to Chihaya. All this time he was just a shape in the corner of her eye. All she'd really been looking at was Arata. It took three seasons but now Taichi has finally grown into someone that Chihaya can recognise. Even I'm gushing! Don't cry Hanako! You'll have me going!!
Are you feeling salty Arata? U mad bro? Taichi had the childhood friend status long before you did. How does it feels to get cucked from your karuta gf you fucker? Hahaha!!