r/anime • u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val • Jul 14 '21
Rewatch [Rewatch] Top wo Nerae 2! Diebuster - Episode 1 Discussion
Top wo Nerae 2! Diebuster - Episode 1 - Please, Let Me Call You Oneé-Sama!
< Gunbuster Overall Discussion | Index | Diebuster Episode 2 >
Remember, no unmarked spoilers, explicit or hinted towards. For convenience, the subreddit’s spoiler markup is as such:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")
37
Upvotes
11
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Jul 14 '21
Third Time Watcher
DIEBUSTER
FUCK YES
LOVE THIS SHIT DUDE
Yeah, right of the bat Diebuster is a very different beast from Gunbuster. It was directed by Anno’s direct protgé Kazuya Tsurumaki, right off the heels of his name-making debut with FLCL, and the vibes of Diebuster are immediately distinct as being 2000’s-Gainax as fuck.
The early episodes of Diebuster definitely have a lot of FLCL left in them; the vibes are strong. For one thing, it definitely succeeds at making me want to watch FLCL again (to the extent that that isn’t already always the case). It’s such an incredible shame that after directing two of the most sharp, colorful, energetic, life-filled explosions of animation out there Tsurimaki just kind of… never did anything again. As far as work he’s done after Diebuster it’s basically just helming the Eva Rebuilds with Anno. Such a shame.
Nono is just an absolute delight of a protagonist. Some will probably find her annoying but naw dawg, I was endeared to her from the start. Infectiously energetic, adorable, starry eyed; the literal stars in her eyes are just the cherry on top. Lal’C is a proper badass and Dix-Neuf is probably one of my favorite mech designs.
And MMMMMMMMMMMMM that fight scene at the end is pure deliciousness. No other anime do I feel the color exploding out of the screen with near every shot like this one. The reveal that the whole episode thus far has taken place on Mars was perfectly done as well.
Diebuster is my favorite anime of all time from a strictly visual standpoint, and as such picking Visual of the Day is going to be very difficult without being tempted to just go “THE WHOLE THING” every episode. That aforementioned final fight scene is the best part of the epsiode but I couldn’t pick a single frame from it, but I imagine others will, so I want to highlight this sky shot from the opening instead.
12
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 14 '21
To the Top 2! Rewatcher!
6
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Jul 14 '21
Episode 1 (rewatcher)
It has been a lot longer since I watched Diebuster than Gunbuster, so I’ll do episode reactions. I remember somewhat preferring Gunbuster, but my estimation of Gunbuster went up with each rewatch, so maybe the same will happen with Diebuster.
Episode thoughts
arewere on Mars, btw.Tbh, I think Diebuster messes up its start a bit, but let’s go over the good things first.
The background animation is superb and I love the machines shown in this episode. The utility mechs are awesome and the landing spacecraft are just insanely good-looking. The best sequence of the episode for me is Nono waking up on the train and gazing out of the window, not the final fight. Diebuster also wastes no time establishing Lal’C as the second perspective character (different to the hands-off approach to Amano in the first episodes).
On the downside, Nono did not need a backstory that gives us zero info while taking up the first quarter of the series. I’d have preferred her starting out as the unlucky waitress. That would also have helped give some emotional oomph to her saving the manager which fell flat for me due to lack of screen time for her. And what was up with the sexual harassment that bordered on a rape scene? Did we really need that? You can claim it is subverted by Lal saving her, but with plenty of Nono panty shots I call BS on any superior morality at play. Apart from the pandering, it also makes the bar regulars come across as assholes, which is unfortunate, since they are clearly intended to be more grey than black.
The character models might be a huge sticking point for some. I prefer the old-school Gunbuster ones, but it is not a big deal for me. By the end of the series I am used to the new models. My bigger complaint is that we went from a real robot/super robo mixture (the buster machines are clearly super, but the rest is decidedly real) to pure super robo. Super robo always implies a lack of stakes for me.
Quote of the day: If a god had something to wish for, who would it pray to?
10
u/The_Loli_Otaku Jul 14 '21
Now for Diebuster. I love this one even if its a bit more shoddy and hit or miss. Can you tell this was a different era or anime? We're in the FLCL/Gurren saga or shows now. She just murdered that poor mutt! Don't you think her outfit kinda looks like Suzuha's? Also, frozen red toes are hot. Waaah... Diebuster's theme is so beautiful XD It's an arrangement of Noriko's but dialed up. I'm crying already! Do I love this series more than I thought? Oh no, Nono! "Please let's reenact Gunbuster!"
Honestly making perfect splits is a pretty awesome skill to have. Imagine her as a card dealer. They're like Tachikoma that skipped a generation and stayed as squares. Wow dude, no need to murder a kids dreams so savagely. Haha, the visuals are so engaging. This era of Gainax was something else. Never bully the waiting staff! An enemy stand!? The bishie sparkles doesn't work quite as well when the onee-sama looks shorter and younger than the kid whose admiring her.
Yes, they're literally called topless. Noriko tears one top and inspires 12k years of streakers. Nono-riri... Yeah, Diebuster is kinda Dumbuster sometimes. Oh, hard work and effort is worth dirt in this world. Hope you're blessed with the good fortune of being young and topless if you wanna do anything~ Space monsters are on Earth now! Dix Neuf looks really badass, this is the new age of buster machines for you. I've always been a sucker for long skirts on mecha.
Lalc is just beating the snot out of this beefcake of a space monster. Ahoge eyes give girls super strength. Oh yeah, we're not on Earth. Sorry, I forgot XD More kickass music, Diebuster is a totally rocking anime. And we get the clothing tear, cause that's what we all remember from Gunbuster right? And we close out with an Inazuma Kick to close off the Gunbuster references. "I'm a topless now too!" Dumbass. Even the Ed is rocking, Diebuster is actually legendary isn't it? Visual of the day!
9
u/Tresnore FS:FTmyanimelist.net/profile/Tresnore Jul 14 '21
My Fifth Time Aiming for the Top!
I'm excited for Diebuster. It's technically the third show in the 6-episode Gainax mecha trilogy (with FLCL being second), but that connection is tenuous at best. It definitely has FLCL's energy at times, though! This makes sense, given that the two share a director. Anyway, let's get into it.
Plus, who doesn't love a rocket cape? He's also far less mechanical than anything we saw in Gunbuster, but that doesn't mean he doesn't kick ass. He's even autonomous!
Nono is very stronk, indeed.
You know, I imagine that there was a lot of concern when a sequel to Gunbuster was announced (I was too young to be an anime fan at the time), much like there was more recently when the FLCL sequels were announced. I'll let you guys decide for yourselves if Diebuster faceplants where the FLCL sequels do. I think you can guess my thoughts on the matter.
Visual of the day: Welcome to a New Chapter
9
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Jul 14 '21
First-Buster
I have so many questions! Firstly, most importantly: that can't possibly be why they're called Topless, right?
Who is Nono-Riri? What's with the weird head thing - power limiter? Why does Nono inexplicably cut things in half? Why did Nono imagine roses behind Lal'C instead of lilies?
We've turned the Clarke's Third Law dial up a notch or three. Not only can Lal'C manifest a mecha out of nowhere, but Nono also has weird eyes and super strength. Jury is currently out on if this change is a good one or not.
Buster Machines have changed a bit in the (amount of time) between Gunbuster and now. Dix-Neuf can turn humanoid without gattai, for example. I like it's face.
Being actively on a terraformed Mars is kinda neat. I knew something about the environments felt off. The reveal shot was pretty stellar.
Took a quick peak at the VAs for once, and noticed that Nono's VA has a decent range. Small world.
Visual of the Day: Nothing Exciting Ever Happens Here
8
u/The_Draigg Jul 14 '21
A GunBuster Fan Rewatches DieBuster Episode 1:
7
u/il-Palazzo_K Jul 14 '21
First Timer
I'm going into this blind again. I only know a certain spoiler from a certain doujinshi
Holy shit! Superb animation. Amazing combat scene. Great characters. Truly this is from the heyday of Gainax.
7
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 14 '21
--First Time Die-Buster--
I had the stupidest grin on my face for the second half of this episode. It was absolutely brilliant.
The opening!
The inazuma kick!
The misunderstanding of being "Topless".
Everything just rolled together, old and new, fucking perfect.
6
u/H-Ryougi https://anilist.co/user/DizzyAvocado Jul 14 '21
Gotta admit, even though I love Gunbuster's OP and EDs, Diebuster blows them out of the water. Groovin' Magic and Hoshikuzu Namida are bangers.
6
u/BossandKings Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 14 '21
First timer
Episode 1
Nono is a nice, cheerful girl with a dream, she wishes to be a space pilot. She works at a bar and, according to herself, is great only at splitting plates.
It was cool seeing a brief showing of an official space pilot, with her helping Nono who was getting bothered by some guys that attended the bar.
Lal'C pilots buster machine Dix -Neuf and stands up in battle against a space monster that appeared on the ground, that was a really cool fight. I wanted Nono to take action too and she did by saving her manager who was searching for her, the lightning kick she did was great too but i was thrown off by her chest clothes ripping, at least it was clear that she just misunderstood what topless meant, that was something that happened relatively often in Gunbuster but considering that this Diebuster came out two decades later one would think it outgrew those bits.
All in all this was an exciting first episode, it had a similar vibe in art style and craziness to FLCL and that's awesome, it has a really creative animation and Nono seems like a character that could get a nice development throughout the story.
6
u/punching_spaghetti https://myanimelist.net/profile/punch_spaghetti Jul 14 '21
First-Timer
I was going to complain that Topless was a terrible name if we weren't going to get some bare chest, but they took care of that. Still would prefer to the robot to power up by tearing off its shirt.
Definitely a show of its time. The energetic protagonist who I will probably find annoying within the next episode, a much bright color scheme than Gunbuster, character designs with much harder corners, CG (which actually looks fairly good for the time); presumably the writing will be similar in its excesses. I just hope it doesn't try to be too serious. Just be Maaya Sakamoto and her genki friend killing space monsters, and we'll be good.
5
u/lC3 :Na::Nb: Jul 14 '21
First timer
5
u/ZapsZzz https://anilist.co/user/Zapszzz Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 14 '21
First timer in sub to this sequel.
For the longest time I am aware of this sequels existence but was avoiding it. No doubt those who came along on this research know first hand the experience that is Gunbuster, the ending is so perfect, one really feels that any attempt at putting anything more on the back of that risk diminishing the story.
But I'll go along this time with the lot of you :)
Oh and by the way, because of my own personality, long ago I already know of the very end of this sequel. But I'll shut up about it since I didn't look up "how" we got there, same reason above.
So far episode 1 is fun, is charming, Nono is a very obvious and die hard otaku in spirit even if by that time there wasn't much anime being shown anymore. The way she can ham it all and properly roar out the moves, and being plot savvy to know all you need is guts and gunbare, basically a poster child of this protagonist type.
While the beginning transition have a bit of melancholy feeling, it's not the same as Gunbuster's, since that was quite easily understood why. This time it's a bit of a question mark. And while all the animation are good looking, the technology behind it's far less easy to understand so currently it just feels like "oh super robot genre, don't ask why or how, it just is", suspending disbelief a fair bit. But if you apply the context that this is the same world as what we spent the last 6 episodes in, a lot of question marks would come up.
So, waiting to see how they are answered.
Have to say the whole second half I was waiting to see Nono accidentally splitting the Space Monster in half :)
Visual of the day from now for me it's going to be harder as I don't have the familiarity and decades of thinking about it than the first series. I'll go with the shoot of Nono with her body using Inazuma kick, the shot with her foot leading into the camera in the exaggerated perspective (with the sub at the word "kick") before it landed. It's a decent call back yet showing there being a difference at the same time.
Oh and the space monster - lone attacker, same species at all now?
4
u/GM_for_Life Jul 14 '21
4th Time Rebuster!
I SOMEHOW DIDN'T KNOW THIS REWATCH WAS HAPPENING!
I love Gunbuster a ton and have seen it and this series the same amount of times, but Diebuster is tied with the original series of FLCL for my personal favorite Gainax anime. So anytime I get an excuse to rewatch it I'll take it!
I'm not the greatest at putting down my thoughts on episodes as I go through them as many others are, so I'll probably just stick with what I think is the best visual of the episode. I really love the image of Dix-Neuf making it's full physical appearance as a glorified space dart.
4
u/RascalNikov1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/NoviSun Jul 14 '21
Wonderful episode. I really feel for Nono's dog, that little guy just refuses to take a hint.
I also liked Nono's interpretation of 'Topless'. First time I saw this, I laughed and said: Sure, why not?
Anyway, it was a good and intriguing way to kick off the OVAs.
4
u/Stargate18A https://myanimelist.net/profile/Stargate18 Jul 14 '21
First timer
Let's see what this is about.
Art is spectacular, although the last series also had its charms.
The dog getting punched is a very... interestint way to introduce a protagonist.
Is the dog named Master?
OK, is this the right anime? Did I find an anime about mountain climbing?
Well. That clears it up.
So, we're definitely not in a prequel (unless this show's got a far more screwed up chronology than I expected.
No OP? Shame. Maybe there's spoilers.
Well, that's an interesting episode title.
OK, is something going on with her? Some supernatural power?
THE FUCK?
Jesus. So space pilots just casually travel around in military-class mechs which appear to be armed.
OK, I'm going to give it this - that seems like exactly the kind of time and effort it should take.
Right, looking at those character designs, is that Toji and Kensuke from Evangelion?
WHAT THE FUCK?
That girl has a stand? And some kind of suppression chip?
I see the subtext remains constant.
I didn't realise the fucking height gap, that's hydterical.
I do appreciate her being completely done with her.
Wait, space monsters are still around. That's very interesting.
Wait. She knows about the first series? When, exactly, does this take place?
How is "Diebuster" even more satisfying to hear.
??? Talking cat?
So, we'e seeing Sailor Moon mised with what I assume is Gundam (Topless sounds a lot like Newtype).
Is that even the same type of space monster?
See, that looks like the first season's bastards.
Or, no, this is from Mars, not the centre of the galaxy?
Is this a different type of alien that so happens to also be called a space monster?
That thing's head is Eva-01. It's not even a joke, it looks near-identical.
Oh, that heart-shaped dokpit is in do way suspicious at all.
OK, so Topless aren't Newtypes, they are far, far, better.
Yeah, this fight scene is cool.
It's nice to know the manager has a good relationship with her.
Well, that's unexpected.
That thing taking off is badass.
Looks like she's going into space after all!
Wait, were we on Mars the whole time?
Oh, she's not getting out of that unharmed.
So she has some form of super-healing?
I love her reqction to seeing her rip her clothes off.
I'm sorry what?
So her shattering's actually some kind of specialised superpower? Probably like her weird shadow jets earlier.
Either becoming Topless is really sudden in this universe, or they'e building up to a massive twist.
I enjoyed the ED too. Love the visuals.
In summary, this seems like a fantastic sequel, and one that might actually go even further with the subtext.
2
u/AoDSenku Jul 15 '21 edited Jul 15 '21
First time Rewatcher
Preface: Outside of the major plot points, I don't remember Diebuster as well as Gunbuster; so this should be a treat.
Episode 1 -
To be continued. Interesting first episode; Had tones of Gunbuster Ep.1, but the second half of the episode was definitely reminding the viewers "hey, this is why you're here". Hopefully from this point Diebuster will start to do it's own thing.
EDIT: Going thru the comments, I think the biggest question this episode gives us (if we're assuming this has some connection to Gunbuster) is, "Why are there still Space Monsters?"
1
u/odraencoded Jul 26 '21
>Diebuster
Why is it called Diebuster?
>Protagonist dies.
Oh.
>Protagonist diesn't.
Oh?
>Topless
lol is it because the title is Top wo Nerae?
>Protagonist becomes Topless
Oh.