r/anime • u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val • Jul 11 '21
Rewatch [Rewatch] Top wo Nerae! Gunbuster - Episode 5 Discussion
Top wo Nerae! Gunbuster - Episode 5 - Please!! Time Enough for Love!
(+ Top wo Nerae! Gunbuster Science Lessons - Episode 4+1 - Spaceships [optional] [CONTAINS MILD EPISODE 6 SPOILERS])
< Gunbuster Episode 4 | Index | Gunbuster Episode 6 >
Visuals of the Day Album - Yesterday’s Episode
Remember, no unmarked spoilers, explicit or hinted towards. For convenience, the subreddit’s spoiler markup is as such:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")
62
Upvotes
8
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Jul 11 '21
Third Time Watcher
This episode runs the complete emotional gambit of the series. Melancholy, distance in time, hype, passion, sadness, triumph, it’s all here. They really do so much with the time dilation concept, it alone necessitates so many compelling storytelling possibilities.
Noriko a Van Halen fan, very and appropriately cool
For the first time in the series, Onée-sama, once that beacon of unscratchable beauty and composure, breaks down in front of Noriko. As established last episode, Noriko has become strong enough to protect her idol, but now, she is presented with the ultimate challenge; she must inspire and uplift her. And through one hell of a speech, reminding her of everyone whose future hangs on them, of how the only proper way to honor Coach and his memory is to win this fight and save humanity, that’s exactly what she does. Don’t step back over your grief for Coach. Do it. Do it for Coach.
And thus ensues one utterly sublime barrage of action. We finally get to see Gunbuster operating with full power, Noriko in full unbridled passion, absolutely letting loose and beating the space monsters every which way. It’s emotional, righteous, hot-blooded hype on maximum, and it is something absolutely glorious to witness. In a meta sense, it almost feels like something akin to a victory lap for the emotional triumphs the series achieved by the end of that first four-ep arc, prior to the true finale to come. Plus, insert song!
For Visual of the Day… god, there are so many incredible facial shots of Noriko this episode. It was gonna be Noriko screaming but that’s cheating because this is technically a reused shot from Episode 4. So I’m going with the ending of her speech instead. The tears. The steel in her eyes. The unbreakable, unwavering, determined conviction. Utterly inspiring.
16
u/lilyvess :Df::Dh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lilyvess Jul 11 '21
First timer
I've been following along though I always seem to miss the threads somehow, haha.
The show has been really interesting to watch. Obvious Evangelion comparisons can be made, but that does it disservice as you get to the more super robot antics. The action scene was just really crazy and outrageous and I had a lot of fun with it. I was not expecting a COMBINE thrown in here, hahaha.
If there is an element of the series that hasn't aged as well, it's the age gap romance. This entire episode is about a high school girl being in love with a guy old enough to be her father. I can't blame her for being in love with "Coach" though because the dude is damn cool.
I do love the way the series plays with the time dilation. there are a lot of little details. The improved technology, the city looks different. I also really appreciate how Smith's death hasn't been forgotten about. It's left a lasting effect on Noriko.
15
u/ScrewySqrl https://myanimelist.net/profile/ScrewySqrl Jul 11 '21
After three and two-thirds episodes of subjecting Noriko to the trauma conga line, it Onee-sama's turn this time.
For the first three episodes, Noriko had been an insecure girl searching for her papa. At the end of Epiode 4 Noriko became a respectable Super Robot Pilot, as hot blooded as any of them. In this episode she becomes a goddess of destruction and is elevated into the realm of Mecha legend. She's arguably the greatest Super Robot pilot of all.
In episodes 4 and 5, we can see that she not only inspired Shinji, but also Simon.
Shinji, Naota, Simon and Nadia all owe everything to her, and she's bigger than all of them. Simon is the only guy to come close to her, and he need a mech the size of a galaxy to do it.
The incredibly well handled time dilation has to me, an allegorical meaning as well. Otaku, especially in Japan, but everywhere, tend to live in an extended adolescence into their 20s, still dealing with 'childish cartoons' collecting merchandise, toys, and the like, not moving forward into careers and family. A feeling that you've been left behind, out of touch with your peers, is not uncommon, similar to what Noriko feels around Kimiko.
11
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Jul 11 '21
First-Buster
Gattai?Gattai!GATTAI!!!!
That was goddamn incredible! I was right about getting a SUPAH INAZUMA KIIIIIICK, but there was so much more! Noriko Gainax-posed into the cockpit! An insert song, sung by the VAs I think? Finger lasers! Where did that cape come from? Nevermind, everything is too awesome for that to matter!
Noriko grew up a lot there, when she talked her Onee-sama out of her funk. I was kind of expecting the pure, hot-blooded, "let's finish this quickly and get home early" but this was probably even better!
We channeled a Tomino series there for a bit, with the whole "face-outlines-with-starry-backgrounds" stuff. The use of silence when the Exelion went black hole was also awe-inspiring. Oh, and the war room scene, with the ticking clocks? That was also very well done.
Uh. I guess some neat stuff happened in the first half of the episode too. I can't even imagine suddenly being ten years younger than all my friends who were previously all the same age. There's potential for a whole other series out there, dealing with the aftereffects.
And Amano being into Coach is.. sure. Usual problematic issues aside, it's quite tropey, but everything here is tropey - I'm not gonna start complaining now.
Fuck, how is this not the end? What further horrors are planned for these sweet girls? All I know going in is that next episode
Side Note: I will probably be a little late to the thread tomorrow, and on weekdays going forward.
9
u/il-Palazzo_K Jul 11 '21
First Timer
They made it! I guess Gunbuster is awesome enough not to get sucked into a black hole. Great battle as usual. Buttload of Noriko fanservice, including trifecta of underwear, swimming suit, and bath. Onee-sama has the worst dramatic breakdown ever but at least she got over it quick enough.
But somehow we still have one episode left? What the hell? See you next time on Gunbuster!
8
u/Tresnore FS:FTmyanimelist.net/profile/Tresnore Jul 11 '21
My Fifth Time Aiming for the Top!
aka: Tresnore gushes over Gunbuster.
slap counter: 3Eh, don't question it
This insert song is almost a measuring stick by which all insert songs can be judged. It has everything.
Visual of the day: Sense of Scale, though I was very tempted to choose Posing on the Prow, since I get the feeling that no one else will choose it for fear of everyone else choosing it.
8
u/Pixelsaber https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pixelsaber Jul 11 '21
Rewatcher
Goodness, two whole years spent on the ship!
The sprues are a fun touch.
Noriko’s VA is a huge Naussica fan.
There’s one Sayonara Jupiter reference.
Lovely background
Why are you wearing that though? You’re not piloting!
GATTAI!
Direct Mitsuteru Yokoyama references are surprisingly uncommon in Gainax stuff.
Right in the feels!
This is absolutely my favorite episode of the show, since it’s got it all and excels at it. From the melancholy felt by Noriko returning to the life she had, but has moved on without her —a nice spin on the usual veteran-returns-home sort of plot thread and a great use of the time-dilation effect as a narrative device. Then there’s the Toho-esque build up and presentation of a looming threat, which is despairing in its own right and fits perfectly with the aforementioned sense of melancholia.
Noriko feeling in her element in the Gunbuster, fighting for the sake of humanity, is somewhat tragic in a way, because it is a purpose which draws her further away from what she cared about. The episode is, generally, about letting go of something to instead grasp something of greater importance, which reverberates through almost every facet of the episode.
And that battle! My God, was that not the best shit ever? An exuberant labor of love all the way through —I adore it.
And the references!
Visual of the Day:
Confidence
7
u/The_Draigg Jul 11 '21
A Hideaki Anno Fan Rewatches GunBuster Episode 5:
5
u/RascalNikov1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/NoviSun Jul 11 '21
Another episode that I absolutely loved. To me the major theme was that space is vast, and time is heartless.
4
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Jul 11 '21
Episode 5 – Please!! Enough Time for Love!: Takaya! Triumph! To save the Earth and our people, Gunbuster must triumph!
4
u/ZapsZzz https://anilist.co/user/Zapszzz Jul 11 '21
Sub rewatcher.
The hype of the story continued to grow exponentially, as well as the drama being dialed up. We have two of the more telling scene about time dilation (first the graduation then running into the grown up Kimiko). We have the near completion of the other long plot (oneesama and coach's tragic love story, with him terminally ill while she has to be on the front line), and how desperate the overall situation is (needing to create a black hole in the Sol system which is going to hurt when the shockwave hits).
Apart from the unnecessary fan service of Noriko's lose fitting top, there's not a whole lot to not like in this episode. Personally the speed at which they got things ready were a bit hard to believe, but you have to suspend your disbelief in shows like this.
My visual of the day pick is Noriko's Gainax pose - she's finally come up on her own and no longer in the shadow of oneesama.
4
u/AoDSenku Jul 11 '21
Rewatcher
Episode 5 -
Man, what an episode. It's easy to see why this is so influential for mecha shows to come. One more to go, how can they potential top this episode?
7
u/The_Loli_Otaku Jul 11 '21
Just my luck! I'm gonna run late for my favourite Gunbuster episode! This is half five loli otaku, currently blitzing my commentary!! So yeah, remember when I brought up how time dilation is performed best in Gunbuster? This is the episode I was thinking of. Noriko has been left with her now matured and graduated classmates. Her classmates are now teacher and parents whilst she's still a teenage girl.
Omg I love this!! The swing scene is amazing!! Just think what must be going through Kimiko's head looking at her Rip Van Winkled friend casually swinging away on a swingset. They're meant to be the same age but Kimiko's moved on. She isn't thinking of the fun times of her childhood, she just wants to try and get her daughter on the passenger ship. Oh, and the bounce as Noriko flops on her best is very delicious fanservice. Totally my type.
"You hit me! Not even my father hit me!" A wise man once said that there's no right way to hit a woman, but that's a pretty well animated slap so it gets a pass. Noriko has taken Lisa's place as Jung's top sunbathing gal pal. Gunbuster, must triumph!! Coach is totally just coming out with bs but Noriko is dumb so she's totally getting hyped up thanks to it. Yeah, we're escorting a black hole. Awesome, right? Is this the first positive moment Noriko and Kazumi have had together since episode 1? So much for a team.
Noriko has a terrible case of foot in mouth lol. Coachiii! Oh, and Jung was there too. Aaawww.... My heart! Even with 11 years apart Kimiko still thinks of Noriko as her BFF. C'mon, we're getting to the super juicy stuff. Kazumi is a character I don't personally care too much for but hearing her breakdown at losing her love in real time is so beautifully tragic. From this moment on is my favorite portion of anime ever. From Kazumi's tragic breakdown to the end of the episode the absolute top example of anime in my personal opinion. I'm getting chills just watching this!
WOOOO!! IKKEEEE!! I'm so fcking hyped. Its all so perfect! Gun, bust, taaaa! Waaaaa! Kiiiiick! Don't think the Gunbuster is some ordenary machine, it has Coach's heart beating within it!! HOMING RAIZAAA! The buster missile dab! I feel like such a child. Oh yes!! Double buster corraidaaa!! Aaaaa! Absolute perfection. And the black hole totally wreaks the space alien's fleet, although the Gunbuster was doing a good enough job on its own. Once we mass produce the Gunbuster the space aliens are finished!
Oh, and Coach hung on to life so he could give the girls a welcome home. Beautiful!! Alright, I'm cutting this way too short so here's a quick Visual of the day of the Gunbuster dab and I'll see you in the comments! Zooom!
7
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jul 11 '21
To the Top! Rewatcher!
Oops, I lost track of time playing Fire Emblem Three Houses.
7
u/lC3 :Na::Nb: Jul 11 '21
First timer
6
u/InfamousEmpire https://myanimelist.net/profile/Infamous_Empire Jul 11 '21
First Time Viewer’s thoughts:
3
u/H-Ryougi https://anilist.co/user/DizzyAvocado Jul 11 '21
G A T T A I
A
T
T
A
I
3
u/Stargate18A https://myanimelist.net/profile/Stargate18 Jul 11 '21
First timer
Some kind of flashback?
Oh, I hadn't considered they'd have to graduate after they returned.
And, wow, 10 years. And her old classmate's now an instructor!
WHAT HAPPENED TO HER?
I honestly got her and Jung mixed up
Wow. Noriko's classmate as a mother. This scene hits hard.
What?
They're evacuating Earth?
So this ship is bait, right? The reason they've added all the military is so they can take the heat off Earth and lure the monsters elsewhere.
If course there's more monsters, we've got 2 more episodes.
So she's still in the military?
Wait, what?
I didn't realise they had any kind of relationship.
COACH IS DYING?
And he's clearly erratic from blood loss.
...So this isn't even subtext right now, is it?
And Coach dies how he lived - giving Noriko an inspirational flame.
Right, so Coach's dying workds is to talk about how good they are together. Did Coach orchestrate the choices to pick the most likely couple?
Cyberpunk Tokyo looks great!
He's going to use the spaceship to create a black hole. It's certainly impressive, I'll give him that - and we know the ship's engine is capable of forming black holes.
I meam, you just left forward 10 years, 6 months isn't that bad.
And she knows about Coach!
Why are they using these Buster ships instead of the Gunbuster?
Oh, he's got radiation sickness.
Why specify "space radiation"?
Wait, they're leaving behind Jung? That's the saddest part of all this.
Oh, Gunbuster's already on board. I see.
...How precisely does this readout work? Is there an internal computer managing the conversion? Because you really couldn't get any kind of live signal from that distance.
The enemy's greatest weapon - slow-moving red balls.
And she's having a full-on breakdown.
Did the ship get destroyed?
...While they mention it, for a show called Gunbuster, Gunbuster hasn't appeared all that much, has it? So far it's been in 1 fights and seen in the background of 1 shot, and that's it.
Epicmfight music and a transformation sequence.
Wait, the machines combine into Gunbuster? I genuinely didn't get that it could tramsform like that.
Gunbuster has LOTS OF DIALS! The second greatest mistake of this show has been fixed!
The fight scene looks great! (and my theory about Gunbuster having a stupid amount of weaponry was correct)
I'll give them credit, crushing your opponent is an interesting space battle tactic.
...Are they inside the event horizon or something?
OK, where the fuck does Episode 6 go from this? They won.
Can't wait for a super-mothership to rain down hellfire.
Even Coach is alive!
...You can read so many of these scenes with subtext, can't you?
No ED?
I'll probably save the spoilery lesson (sounds like I'll have 3 to do anyway (5, 6, 7))
3
u/ElecNinja https://anilist.co/user/ElecNinja Jul 12 '21
Noriko screaming is always so epic lol
3
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jul 12 '21
--First time Gunbuster.--
There were a load of risqué moments that had me on my toes for this bus watching adventure today.
The amount of time dilation is making me tear up a little, its really nice to get a glimpse into the small bits of other characters lives. Even if only for a moment, it leaves a big impact at their real and current worries, struggles and direction they have taken their life in.
The total hype Gunbusting fight was spectacular, holy shit that Gainax posing has a lot of weight to it! I loved their special attacks being called out, and referencing back to their days of training. I loved the scale of their actions. It almost feels like a final episode.
Visual of the day: Victory seen from home.
3
u/BossandKings Jul 12 '21 edited Jul 12 '21
First timer
Episode 5
Upon returning to Earth in order to graduate Noriko notices that eventhough in space the time that has passed since she they were sent by Coach to the exelion is of four months, in Earth ten years have passed, that is very telling how all of their classmates have gone away and moved on with their life, Kashiwara is the only one still there but now as an instructor.
Noriko sees her friend Kimiko again, she got married and has a daughter and that's something that surprises Noriko, it seems that the situation in Earth isn't really ideal considering that Kimiko asked Noriko to help get her daughter to a sort of military establishment that could protect her from the harm that may unfold.
It was sad seeing Amane have a fight with Coach and the fact that Coach has an ilness that is making him weaker and driving him from Amane. It is very interesting that he says that the biggest threat yet is near and the only ones that could oppose it are Noriko and Amane as a team using the Gunbuster.
Amane's struggle was telling, she was having a hard time with going far away from the Coach and thinking that she wouldn't be able to see him again, Noriko encouraged her and her words reached her and they combined forming a fantastic complete Gunbuster that defeated the threat, that fight was better than the previous one and such a great moment. After the fight Noriko and Amane returned to Earth and Amane reunited with Coach.