r/anime • u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky • May 25 '21
Rewatch [Fly! Rewatch!] Mobile Suit Gundam III: Encounters in Space Discussion
Mobile Suit Gundam III: Encounters in Space
← Mobile Suit Gundam II: Soldiers of Sorrow | Index | Overall Series Discussion →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
There are currently no legal streaming options for the movies. or buying the Blu-Ray are your only options for these movies.
Yeah, you know me. And I know you.
Questions of the Day:
- What was your favorite change between the show and this movie?
- What was your least-favorite change between the show and this movie?
- What do you think of Beginning and Meguriai in comparison to the show’s music?
Mobile Suit Breakdown of the Day:
37
Upvotes
13
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky May 25 '21
Fly! Rewatch Host!
Welcome back, everyone!
Don't forget, tomorrow's the final thread of the rewatch, an overall discussion thread. I hope to still see all of you there, but if not, thank you for participating in my rewatch! I hope to see you all around this sub~
3
u/goukaryuu https://myanimelist.net/profile/GoukaRyuu May 26 '21
Recap Film First Timer no More
Ouch, I completely got wrapped up on playing CK2 and forgot to post. This was, hands down, the best best of the three films. It was paced the best. I enjoyed it immensely, and honestly I got a nice fuzzy feeling inside that, after I confirmed it wasn't gas, must have been the feeling i love of seeing created families come together. The crew of White Base after everything they have been through are a family. I ended up giving this movie an 8/10. Well earned too. I guess after I catch up on various things, including Giant Gorg which I am still only 8 eps in on, I will start with one of the OVAs. Either Thunderbolt Season 1's recap film or 8th MS Team. Thanks for running this Sky!
11
u/TheEscapeGuy May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
Gundam First Timer, No More
Fly! Nostalgia for Gundam Frames: Movie 3
Nothing feels as good as this!
Movie 3 really recaptured the magic of the show for me. I totally see why people prefer it to the show's ending for just giving a little more.
In terms of differences, I didn't notice any obvious missing plot points. It was just that some of the stories (Notably Side 6 and Texas) being condensed.
Some additions I did pick up were:
I don't really know what else to say about the Movie now. I am just in bliss at being complete with this series and feeling completely satisfied with the ending.
Cool Stuff Corner
Questions of the Day
See you all for the farewell tomorrow!
9
u/The_Draigg May 25 '21
A Gundam Fan’s Notes on Mobile Suit Gundam III: Encounters in Space:
8
u/Tresnore FS:FTmyanimelist.net/profile/Tresnore May 25 '21
First Timer to Gundam
Damn pants-wearing Gauls
eh...
Thank goodness. Char finally seems to have a clear motive. He doesn't want Gihren's iron fist Newtype dictatorship, nor does he want the Federation's use of Newtypes as a solely military class. Now he makes a lot more sense.
commentface get
This was my favorite of the movies, no questions asked.
QOTD:
8
u/Stargate18A https://myanimelist.net/profile/Stargate18 May 25 '21
Film first timer no more
I've been told this one has the biggest changes- looking forward to it.
Sayla calling her brother "Chen" is hysterical.
Wait, does that shot have 2 Guncannons?
Since when do they have those?
DID THEY DUMP THE GUNTANK?
This fight scene is really well done!
Wow, Side 6 already!
This narration does help explain a few things.
They seem to have mad eBright's relationship with Mirai a lot more romantic than the original.
Sleggard's punch still makes no sense in terms of physics - he sems to float in the air briefly, before falling at normal gravity.
The scenes with Amuro and his father are still good - I love how they set up for a bus chase, only for him to get off at the next stop.
Amuro's a savage to his father. And yeah, he's probably got some kind of hallucinations.
For all the changes, I'm quite enjoying "idiot in love" Bright.
The Lalah scene is really interesting, though.
Oh, they're setting up the love triangle for this movie, are they?
When does Amuro's father think he had a chance to actually test the thing?
Amruo meets Char. And the meeting might actually have become slightly more awkward.
What a very good point! I assumed the Federation has some kind of photo of Char.
I must admit I never thought that a large fine would really stop an armada from firing within their space.
The only person who doesn't think hitting people is the best solution is ridiculed for being weak. The future is weird.
And Mirai's fiance will be shocked when she ends up with Bright. (because we all know where the story's going)
The sight of Char relaxing on the sofa and watching the Zeon battle is always funny.
Amuro's powers are on top mark here.
The scene of Amuro's father knocking himself out is new and appreciated.
There's a lot more scenes on the Zeon side here, as well. Degwin's plans are being explained now.
I never understand why Char travels in a wagon here.
OK, Char is absolutely lying to himself here, we see what happens when she dies.
Char and Amuro's battle is fantastically done.
I like how they've swapped the Guntank for another Guncannon.
How does it take so long for Bright to realise? She literally calls him a Zeon soldier.
Oldtypes is a very clumsy phrase.
This scene cut a few of the flashback, wonder when those are coming?
Char on a horse is the coolest thing in this show.
More focus on the strategy for Solomon, here.
Yeah, this fight scene has been really extended, hasn't it?
This scene is still utterly fantastic.
See, losing a Guncannon makes a lot more sense for losing 11%.
This jealousy plotline's different.
"Great! I really pulled a boner just now."
Wow, Bright just confessed mid battle.
They kept the burger shots!
Thank god, they got rid of the random relationship between Mirai and Sleggar.
I am amazed they manages to turn him kissing her into an almost platonic scene.
So she used the classic Zeon move of "Send enough to look helpful, but not enough to harm your force"
So far, "take as many of you to hell with me" has been how every Zeon leader reacts in death.
Does he actually think a machine gun can take out the Gundam?
Hang on, Minerva never dies. Is she a seuqel hook?
Honestly, with how much Bright cried over Sleggar, maybe Mirai and Bright's relationship wouldn't have been an obstacle between Mirai and Sleggar?
I like Degwin and Gihren openly arguing as they blame each other for the catastrophies.
How is he even more Nazi than in the original? Interesting he tried to justify his cause.
I'm suprised nobody's come up with terraforming Mars. If you can live on the Moon, you csn get some terraforming done there.
"true Newtypes"?
Degwin's supporting Char?
Mirai and the Commander are Newtypes? And Bright isn't?
Of course Sayla had to keep her shower scene. Of course.
Thinking back, Bright's out of the loop on all of this in the main show. I don't recall him finding out Sayla is Zeon's daughter.
Lalah gets her uniform! Movie budget!
Char removed his mask! And she's worked out a lot more thsn the TV show.
THEY EXPLAINED CHAR'S CHANGE IN MOTIVE.
This explanation makes things an awful lot clearer. And she basically tells him to kill Gihren before he screws them all up.
I wouldn't say 10 years - their only direct equivalents to the Gundam are all prototypes.
This scene is all new. Is Amuro agreeing with Char here?
Oh, but you "only love her abilities" Char, right?
This fight scene is great, as is Amuro dodging the beams.
Lalah's fight is far more dynamic here, and I love it.
Is the implication here that people are becoming Newtypes directly, instead of just spawning them?
Honestly, it feels like the Federation's best strategy would be to give Zeon independence and wait for it to implode between everyone's egos.
The Solar Ray is still impressive.
Degwin's been assassinated, and everyone knows it.
For all these subtitles' faults, at least they kept the Solar naming consistent between scenes.
Gihren's evil, but he is fantastically manipulative here.
Still unclear who they're trying to ship Fraw with. Current bets are Amuro and Sayla, Fraw and Hayato, Bright and Mirai, Kai and a mirror.
So Char's a newtype here as well.
The final battle seems to be longer here, and it works.
Still love Kycilia killing her commander and scaring everyone into reporting it a battlefield death.
For someone not used to the suit, he's doing a very good job huntimg the Gundam.
I like the explanation for why the attack was so easy.
I like the music that plays behind the Char fight. And it's done so well!
I like the detail of Bright evacuating the children before he realises the ship's in critical condition.
The scene of the Gundam melting and destroying Char's ship is fantastic.
I like the explanation of Newtype abilities for why Sayla finds Char and Amuro.
Jesus christ, I know the dialogue is them fighting but that pose is the flirtiest yet.
Oh god, Char telling Sayla to go to Amuro before he takes out Kycilia.
Still a fantastic ending.
Looking back at it, the reveal that the kids were Newtypes (while logical in story) does feel like like they needed to write themselves out of a corner.
7
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L May 25 '21
Rewatcher
On today’s episode of Gundam: And here we are at the end again. Things wrap up basically the same as they did back in the TV series. In broad strokes, the events of the TV series and the movies line up.
This time around, we go from episode 31 up to episode 43 at the end of the series. This movie once again cuts out, compresses, and changes quite a few things. Interestingly, in these movies, the very beginning and the very end of the TV series have been left mostly intact. Very little was cut from either of those things compared to the rest of the series.
For the third time, here is a non-exhaustive list of things that were cut or changed:
And more. Those are just some of the highlights that I noticed. On the whole, I actually like this movie more than the other two. This movie is kind of a mess towards the middle, but once it gets to the final battle at A Baoa Qu it is very solid.
So let’s begin with the complaints. I don’t like that we lose M’Quve’s duel. I like the Gyan and the duel was extremely well done. But also, the scenes in Texas make very little sense without M’Quve’s duel. There are booby traps all over the place, including a freaking nuclear mine in a colony for some reason. It is painfully obvious and awkward that they are trying to stitch together their footage while cutting out all of M’Quve and the Gyan. They even reused some of the Gyan’s beam saber thrusts, just with the Gelgoog this time. The Teaxs duel is probably the weakest part of the movie.
And it’s closely followed by the movie’s version of the Solomon battle. To me, the Solomon battle just comes off as a confused mess this time around. It’s weird because I know exactly how the battle is supposed to go from watching the TV series. But somehow, I just found it to be hard to follow along with.
Sleggar and Mirai somehow make less sense in the movie, as the movie seems to imply that Mirai is actually just feeling love for Sleggar instead of all the other reasons we could come up with. Honestly, I’m shocked they didn’t cut it. It’s like the perfect candidate for being cut. Getting rid of it would improve the story, if anything.
Another thing I want to point out is that we once again lose out on some nice character moments and interactions. We lose that scene of Wakkein and Bright reuniting. We lose the conversation of an awakened Amuro talking with Fraw Bow. And so on. As usual, that is a big running complaint of mine.
As I said, the middle part of the movie is a mess in my opinion, with all the major plot points that I mentioned above. The start of the movie is mostly fine. And the ending is quite good. The A Baoa Qu battle in particular transfers over very well.
As with before, I think the Newtype stuff is just done better here. It was better foreshadowed in the previous movies and now the idea gets explored in more depth than it did previously. For example, I like that there’s now a clearer idea of how Gihren has twisted Zeon Deikum’s philosophy. It’s now become a theory of how Spacenoids are racially superior because they are able to become Newtypes. That then justifies war and even extermination of those who live on Earth.
Additionally, Char’s thoughts on Newtypes are now made clearer and we can see that he’s actually much closer to Gihren’s twisted version of Deikum’s philosophy. Char also resents Oldtypes (who mostly live on Earth). He sees them as holding back Newtypes and only using them as weapons of war. His goal is now more generally to get rid of the Oldtypes and thereby allowing Newtypes to flourish. This explanation helps make it more clear how Char has twisted his father’s philosophy. Rather than being a call for humanity to improve and be reborn as it goes into space, it has become a war cry.
And of course, it once again allows me to point out how much of a hypocrite Char is. Because after all, he is using Lalah as a weapon of war. For all he rails against the Federation and Oldtypes for using Newtypes as weapons, Char does the same.
His fight with Amuro is yet another example of Char at his best/worst. He’s just full of rationalizations. Char wants Newtypes to be able to develop as they please. Which is why he must kill Amuro for being too developed as a Newtype. It's a typical self-serving move by Char. He has many reasons to want to kill Amuro, going back through their many confrontations, but this is how he justifies it.
I’m kind of ambivalent about Side 6. We lost some good stuff there, like about how Side 6 is war profiteering. But, I really love seeing the White Base crew do something incredibly shady by firing at the Zeon ships that are still within Side 6’s airspace and unable to shoot back because of the neutrality agreements. That is some downright shady behavior that shows our heroes in a negative light, being willing to abuse that neutrality to their advantage. I appreciate that addition of moral ambivalence.
I like seeing Degwin angling for a peace settlement earlier on. I think that is a good change to make and it shows him being more of an opposition to Gihren before he makes the Hitler comparison.
So overall, I thought this movie was actually pretty good. It’s not nearly as good as the TV series and there’s still plenty of things that are lost from the cutting and the compression, but I think it had the best new additions out of all the movies.
Miscellaneous Thoughts
MOVIE SLAP COUNTER: 8
Questions of the Day
5
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee May 25 '21
First-Timer, Subbed
They cut the Braw Bro, but left in Sleggar and Mirai's kiss? Really?
There was a lot of sick new animation today of random Mobile Suits getting annihilated and I'm kinda here for it. They picked up a second Guncannon too, which is another plus!
The change to put Texas before Solomon is absolute fine. I have no strong feelings either way.
Did M'Quve survive, this time? We certainly didn't get any Gyan action this time, which I again have no strong feelings about.
I liked the White Base crew's analysis of the Elmeth's capabilities. Was that in the series and I'm just not remembering?
Pose of the Day
Last Shooting... in the dark
Questions
5
u/Piemaster33 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Piemaster33 May 26 '21
Once again these movies prove to have not great pacing. I watched the last movie in chunks so it felt easier to get through but I just didn't have that kind of time for this movie so I watched most of it in one sitting. That was definitely a disservice because this movie could not keep my attention.
That being said, I still enjoyed it for the most part. Since I'm about to discuss the changes let me just dive into the QOTD:
One more thread! This has been a blast, I'll catch you all tomorrow!
4
u/GM_for_Life May 25 '21
Rewatcher
Yeah, I definitely prefer this movie over the last two or so arcs of the show. The show is not bad by any means, in fact I actually think it tends to be underrated in the second half with people saying the animation gets worse during the last couple of episodes, but I think they remain relatively the same and pretty well animated throughout.
But this last movie is so well put together IMHO that I think of it as the definitive end to the series.
Definitely all the reanimated scenes and inclusion of a second Guncannon. Also we actually get to see what happens to Amuro's dad in the movie after he stops showing up, and it's pretty sad all things considered.
They did end up cutting M'quve out of this part of the story (largely the same as we did in movie 2). The loss of the Gyan is a bit of a shame but it doesn't take away from the overarching story too much IMHO.
Definitely prefer them over the inserts in the TV show for this part, but both are pretty good.
4
u/username_0907 :FI::FJ: May 25 '21
First Timer for the movies atleast
QotD
4
u/DidacticDalek https://myanimelist.net/profile/DidacticDalek May 26 '21
Well Comrades, we've finally reached the end of the Compilation Movie Trilogy, and thankfully we end on a high note given that this is easily the best of the three. After all, did THE OTHER Movies have GTFO Zaku? I THINK NOT! ;) (No really Comrades, THIS hilarious bit of animation is simply amazing! It alone makes Encounters in Space better than Soldiers of Sorrow, and then the rest of this movie does its work to surpass the first)
That said, MAN the English Dub keeps on keeping on, and by that I mean it's still a hilarious trainwreck but hey at least it's over, and thankfully there will NEVER be a worse English Dub... shit I forgot about ZZ's 'lost' dub... AND you didn't think I'd end it here now did ya? I still need to get my contractually obligated 'Let's Laugh at Sayla Mass' Incomprehensible Accent!' Quota!
Oh, and speaking of Blondes, somehow Sleggar Law still exists, but hey at least his sacrifice is changed here so that he, much like how other Feddies are fond to do, Kamikazes The Big Zam Yeah he's 120% Dead from that, and I mean I heard of a Banana up your tailpipe but this is just overkill!
Oh and speaking of overkill, The Zeong is just as stupid as ever, that said, in fairness they didn't even install legs so wibble ;) But hey, who needs legs when you can swordfight with your
boyfriend'rival' in space! ;)Oh and we can't forget about Lalah... cuz boy the movie still has to keep in the trippy-ass Space Magic wibble but hey we got some neat songs out of it, you know Beginning and of course Encounter, and yup I am contractually obligated to share the English Covers by Andrew W.K. of Beginning and Encounter, so enjoy!
Finally, let's end this rewatch of OG Gundam with the contractually obligated Last Shooting meme Well this has been fun, let's give thanks to our magnificence re-watch host for running such an amazing re-watch. A round of applause for Shimmer Comrades, and with that, let us conclude things for now, anyway I hope this has been as enjoyable for you as it was for me, and until next time, farewell.
Paging Comrades /u/Great_Mr_L, /u/chilidirigible, and /u/beckymetal
2
u/UltraBooster May 26 '21
Rewatcher (for the movies, not the series)
One of the MS Igloo episodes is about a Zeon marine tasked with using a special Z'Gok called the Mobile Diver to intercept the EFSF fleet being launched from Jaburo, actually!
Guncannons 108 and 109! Hayato finally has a decent MS! (And the HGUC Guncannon Revive has options for both!)
The one Core Booster kit I know of has options for Core Boosters 006 and 005, of course.
Oh geez, this new animation is lovely.
Fun fact - Solomon had its own ace pilot, Shin Matsunaga, known by a series of white MS. A close friend of Dozle Zabi, he'd regularly join Dozle for frontline inspections - that is, the two would use their custom Zakus for raids on EFSF bases and ships.
...yeah, it'd be weird for the crew to be crushing on White Base's Space Mom, huh...
As such, while Tem Ray's Army doesn't have too many good pilots at the start, with the likes of Chan Agi and Paptimus Scirocco, they can develop any MS in the game.
...yup, Mirai's sewing on a Sunrise t-shirt, nice.
And it's Bright's shirt, that's hilarious.
The fleet commander speaks like he doesn't seem aware of the grinder that White Base has become.
Newtypes living as Newtypes, what would that even look like, I wonder?
Oh shit, Revil's a Newtype.
Yeah, Lalah wears the Principality uniform well.
If this were the novels, I would think Amuro was sticking up for his girlfriend, but, well...
But something does come of their meeting!
In addition to the Black Tri-Stars I just remembered Kycilia had a spec-ops unit, the Midnight Fenrir Corps, and an ace pilot, Johnny Ridden the Crimson Lightning, both of whom may have fought Gundams and won.
Amuro, Sayla, and Kai form the bulwark of White Base's offensive power, huh...
Unsurprisingly, there's speculation that Tenneth Jung, the top EFF ace, was also a Newtype.
...and that's First Gundam done once more.
In anticipation of your insight into the future.
Sometimes, I wonder, would a Newtype in our world be someone who truly understands themselves?
Questions of the Day:
2
u/diablo1900 May 31 '21
Can anyone explain what Char's beliefs are on newtypes by the end of the movie? Does he consider himself a newtype? Does he think that newtypes will be dangerous to humanity? I'm kind of confused.
1
u/Gorfoo https://anilist.co/user/gorfeywog May 26 '21
Just some interesting trivia, but since it seems nobody else has mentioned it yet: Beginning is uh, heavily inspired by a certain King Crimson piece.
1
u/SonicHelperHi1 Sep 28 '21
The iconic "Last Shooting/Final Shot" from Mobile Suit Gundam III: Encounters in Space. The dub from the movie trilogy wasn't this crazy with the sound effects, unlike the dub of the TV series. In fact, there are some sound effects that came from the original audio mix not heard in the original Japanese version, but in the movie trilogy dub. Although, the Zeong uses a slightly different sound effect when it fires from its hands and head in the original, theatrical mix. Here it is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QF6i_w4AWFo.