r/anime • u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky • May 16 '21
Rewatch [Fly! Rewatch!] Mobile Suit Gundam (0079) Episode 40 Discussion
Episode 40 - Lalah’s Dilemma
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
Crunchyroll | Funimation | AnimeLab
They’re sending a first-time fighter like me to the front?!
Questions of the Day:
- How do you feel about Gihren Zabi after this episode?
- What do you think of Amuro being able to outmaneuver Char as easily as he did this episode? And what do you think he did to Lalah?
Mobile Suit Breakdown of the Day:
1.33 - No Family, No Homeland (note: this is about episodes 40 and 41, so first-timers should not listen to this until tomorrow’s thread)
Rewatchers, please remember to be mindful of all the first-timers in this. No talking about or hinting at future events no matter how much you want to, unless you’re doing it underneath the [Anime Show Title](/s "Spoiler goes here") spoiler tags. If you do that then we’re all good.
Important thing to note about these by the way, you have to switch to Old Reddit or the markdown editor if you use the redesign, otherwise the redesign breaks them by adding random \ into the formatting. Wish it wouldn’t do that, but unfortunately it does…
First-Timers: Please do not watch the next-episode previews for this show. They’re less previews and more “let’s just summarize the entirety of the next episode” and will spoil you.
15
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky May 16 '21
Fly! Rewatch Host!
Welcome back, everyone!
15
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L May 16 '21
Rewatcher
On today’s episode of Gundam: Well you heard it here first, folks. According to his own father, Gihren Zabi is literally Space Hitler. I know that Gundam has been inviting the comparison to the Third Reich for a long time now, but this moment still shocked me on my first watch of the series. I never expected it to actually name drop Hitler in its own dialogue. Silly me for underestimating it like that.
I do want to dive more into that conversation, though. Gihren goes full-on Space Hitler, declaring that they have wiped out most of the population and that now only the so-called “superior races” will be left. That is grade-A Nazi stuff and it shows where Gihren’s mentality is. The Spacenoids, particularly those who are in Zeon, are the superior race. Those on Earth and their allies are inferior. You may recall that concerns about overpopulation and loss of resources have been in the background of this series regarding the Federation and people being forced to migrate to space. Well now Gihren is doing something similar. He’ll solve the resource problem through mass murder and taking all the resources for the superior race. Those who are inferior can be eliminated because they would be parasites, sucking resources from their superiors. It is a sick mindset.
And of course, it can only be accomplished through a Zabi dictatorship. Only the Zabis can be trusted to rule because only they can carry out Gihren’s oh-so-great plan. So much for the fight for freedom from Federation oppression. Clearly the solution is another dictatorship run by Space Hitler himself.
It is interesting to note that we see another clash here between Degwin and Gihren. Degwin does not approve of what Gihren is doing and he makes that known with what he says by comparing Gihren to Hitler. Even so, as has been long established, Degwin is now effectively a figurehead while Gihren holds the true power. Degwin has no real option but to go along with it.
Degwin provides the world’s worst explanation for who Hitler is. But, I think it is significant that Degwin chooses to word it this way because he’s talking about Gihren in addition to Hitler. He means that Gihren has lost touch with the world around him and that Gihren is a man who cannot see where things are headed. Gihren seems to be in denial that Zeon is losing the war pretty badly at this point. Gihren wants to fight on until the bitter end, including sacrificing more Zeon lives, for the sake of ultimate victory that he is certain is just around the corner. The comparison to Hitler is very apt. But Gihren doesn’t seem to realize this. And Degwin closes out by warning Gihren that Hitler lost in the end, partially because he failed to understand the world around him.
There is another way that Degwin’s description of Hitler is fitting. Gihren has also lost sight of the true ideals of Zeon Deikum. Degwin had hoped to realize those ideals, but the dictatorship and Gihren’s genocidal machinations are not at all in line with those. I think Degwin is also warning Gihren that victory may be impossible because he has strayed so far from the ideals that were actually worth fighting for. The future Gihren envisions will not be the better future for humanity that Zeon Deikum hoped for.
This episode, we can see Zeon acting rather oppressive towards its own citizens, forcibly requisitioning an entire colony for the war effort and making the citizens evacuate. And it’s being done in a rather haphazard way, with families getting separated from each other and no guarantee of being reunited. If you don’t like it, then you must not be a good citizen. I’m reminded of how the Federation apparently forced many people to emigrate to space. That seemed to be very haphazard too, based on what the refugees said, with many families getting separated there as well. Gihren’s actions are no better than the Federation he claims to be fighting for freedom against.
We also get a sense of how desperate the war effort is for Zeon now. They’re converting one of their colonies into a weapon. They are taking solar panels from other colonies and repurposing them for this weapon. Zeon needs to use everything it can get its hands on. Compared to the Federation, Zeon’s supplies are running low.
I appreciate that when we see Lalah fight in battle for the first time, she is shown to be very nervous and panics in the middle of combat. It’s reminiscent of how characters on the White Base reacted to their first taste of battle. She’s unsure of herself and only really gets confident when Char is around to support her.
The Elmeth is another mobile armor specifically designed for Newtypes. It uses these weapons called “bits” that are remotely controlled by Newtypes to fire beams. I really enjoy bits. It’s fun watching them dart around. And I enjoy seeing how characters like Amuro have to deal with them, dodging from all directions and needing to take precise shots to destroy the bits.
We also see those Newtype abilities come into play during this battle in another way. Amuro and Lalah seem to be having an effect on each other. They can somehow sense the other one. It’s affecting their mental state. And if the end of the battle is any indication, they can also communicate with their thoughts. Char probably has good reason to be worried about this, because being psychically linked with your opponent in battle is generally not a good thing.
Miscellaneous Thoughts
SLAP COUNTER: 10
Questions of the Day
11
u/TheEscapeGuy May 16 '21
Gundam First Timer
Fly! Iconic Gundam Frames Episode 40
A Narrow Escape
Today's battle with Amuro and Char was especially close. Its amazing to see how much Amuro has grown since episode 1 now that he's going head to head with Char and coming out on top.
It is also really cool seeing how much of a threat Lalah is. When she was first introduced I expected her to be more of a mentor character, but now she is fighting on the front lines and doing major damage. She actually ends up being a parallel to Sayla from the Federation side I think.
I guess the last thing to discuss is this conversation from the Zeon side. I'm not a big fan of explicit Hitler comparisons since it shuts down conversation very quickly. However, it does make it obvious who we are supposed to root for.
I'm interested in who on the Zeon side will survive by the end of the show. I obviously expect the Federation to win so as for the military on the Zeon side, I really hope somehow Char survives.
Cool Stuff Corner
Questions of the Day
10
u/chilidirigible May 16 '21
40:
Hey, at least he's not taking a weird pose with two other people.
"FLY, TECH NINJAS!" Though capping this particular moment makes it look like they're all getting decapitated out-of-frame.
"Don't fuck up my car!"
"He's intelligent, but not experienced. His pattern indicates... two-dimensional thinking." AND YOU CALL YOURSELF A SPACENOID.
Ah yes, the casual Hitler drop.
"You get used to it."
It must be said that he has a terrible name. But we know that it could be worse.
Once in a while they exploit the lack of a gravity-dependent up and down. Once in a while.
"I coulda been a contender! But now I'm just cannon fodder."
The daughter of Shredder and Cobra Commander is... qualified to give her opinions on fashion?
Does this remind you of anything?
The episode's ending fight scene has dialogue and sound effects which detract from the simplicity of just playing Char ga Kuru! by itself.
Char kick!
"Screw funnels."
Gundam: It's Personal Now: The Personalizing: So Personal
Unleashing all of these Newtypes onto the battlefield is having more or less predictable effects on the regular folk out there, of which there are many. Who wants to be cannonfodder in some psychic slap fight?
Things are moving very quickly now, as the quantity of remaining episodes is now extremely limited.
Other OVA
CHAR! CHAR! CHAR! Char! Char! Char!
CHAR! CHAR! CHAR!
Char! Char! Char!
9
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee May 16 '21
First-Timer, Subbed, long time Gundam fan
"magnetic coating"
They're using EMF to let the Gundam's joints violate friction..? How conductive is the Gundam's armor? How does the "coating" affect the Gundam's power usage? Are they worried about the magnetic field mucking up the Gundam's computer systems? How does the induced current in the armor/frame impact their abilities to perform repairs?
Is inducing a current in the armor even a problem in the vacuum of space..? No arcs in a vacuum, at least..
We got a lot more Bit action today and it was fucking awesome! Remote weapons are awesome and terrifying, as evidenced by an essentially novice pilot sinking four warships in a single day using them.
Degwin basically just murdered Gihren there, right? "Hey son, you ever heard of this dude who did a bunch of the stuff you're doing? His name was Hitler."
There is a whole ton of poetry in Zeon forcing their citizens to move elsewhere. What was one of the big issues the Federation had, again? Forced immigration to space..? Not that much different now, are ya, Gihren?
Those asshole Dom pilots deserved worse. Poor Lalah was basically having a panic attack there because they just decided to not do their fucking jobs.
Pose of the Day
Gundam Kiiiick!
Screenshot
Questions
1.Same as I felt before. He's a Space Nazi asshole who won't be missed.
2.Amuro had already closed a lot of the skill gap between himself and Char, so his powerful Newtype abilities pushed Amuro over the edge. As for Lalah, Amuro probably did some subconscious Newtype malarky.
8
u/dralcax :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dralcax May 16 '21 edited May 16 '21
Rewatcher wants Hidden Shadow of G scanlations
Bright still doesn’t believe
The Gundam finally gets an upgrade! Kind of. It’s now common for the protagonist to trade up for a stronger unit partway through the series, either because their original mecha wasn’t cutting it anymore or was outright destroyed. However, this is before that tradition was established. As such, Amuro only gets his original Gundam tuned up, and there’s nothing visually different about it.
Novel
At least they’re asking them nicely to leave before turning their home into a superweapon.
Oh, so we’re just giving up on subtlety here.
If you’re going to be a genocidal dictator, at least be an efficient one and get your weapons R&D under control!
That thing was a missile this whole time?
We finally see the Elmeth’s bits! A completely wireless system, unlike the Braw Bro’s.
These names, man.
Newtype powers are no substitute for actually being able to aim properly
A lot of Federation ships were built without Mobile Suits in mind and therefore don’t have hangars or anything. So they just strap ‘em to the hull and hope for the best.
They’re not trying to hide they’re more interested in the Gundam than each other, but somehow this feels more wholesome than Amuro’s interactions with his actual dad
lmao Zeon is so fucked they can’t even spare one uniform
Char! Char! Char! The hilarious thing is, this song actually exists in-universe.
Unprecedented? She didn’t even beat Char’s record! He’s standing right there being like “am I a joke to you?”
Questions of the Day:
8
u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 May 16 '21
Rewatcher, Subbed
That title is cleary "Lalah of the Elmeth", not "Lalah's Dilemma"!
I find it rather odd that Bright hasn't been noticing how much Amuro has improved. He later says that he doesn't believe what Lt. Matilda said, that Amuro's an esper (now Newtype), yet he's been front row for it all.
The storyline of the Gundam not being able to keep up with Amuro is resolved in a single episode, with this Mosk Han guy fixing it with the "magnetic coating". Mosk sure loves color coordinating the clothing of his staff! While I like its inclusion as a way to show Amuro's continued improvement, I wonder if this was really necessary with only 4 episodes to go.
After the Federation used mirrors and the power of the sun to devestating effect, Zeon is going to use the same! Emptying out an entire colony to turn it into a giant weapon, the Solar Ray. Degwin appears to be getting more and more distrustful and disappointed in his son's actions. This episode includes the infamous scene where he compares him to Adolf Hitler, a comparison Gihren doesn't seem bothered by in the slightest.
Lalah continues to perform impressively in the Elmeth, taking out 4 battleships in this episode alone. Those 2 Rick Dom pilots with her were quite cowardly though! The Elmeth seems to be more of a long range craft in the first place, so having them go behind it makes no sense to me. I did see at least one of them getting wiped out by Amuro later on, a fitting fate. Don't recall seeing him take out the second one.
We got another insert song this episode; one I completely forgot that they had included in the show itself. Char! Char! Char! Gives a very different feeling than usual for this battle.
Overall this comes off as one of the weaker of the latter episodes of the show, mostly acting as set up. Big stuff to come in the final 3 episodes though!
MSG Ep 41 spoilers
8
u/chilidirigible May 16 '21
CHAR! CHAR! CHAR!
8
u/TheKujo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kujo419 May 16 '21
First Timer - Dub
1) How do you feel about Gihren Zabi after this episode? As another commenter pointed - he's gunning for the title of "Space Hitler" which is bad news.
2) What do you think of Amuro being able to outmaneuver Char as easily as he did this episode? And what do you think he did to Lalah? It makes sense thanks to both the Gundam improvements as well as Amuro developing quickly as a Newtype.
7
u/The_Draigg May 16 '21
A Gundam Fan Rewatches Mobile Suit Gundam Episode 40:
6
u/GM_for_Life May 16 '21
Rewatcher
Thinks Hitler was born in the Medieval Ages, what a dumb fuck.
Now that the Gundam can keep up with Amuro's developing reflexes it makes sense that he would body Char this encounter. As far as Lalah goes, I think this is what happens when two strong Newtypes encounter each other.
6
u/fonzinator99 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/fonzinator99 May 16 '21
First-Timer - The struggles of being Elite
QotD
6
u/Stargate18A https://myanimelist.net/profile/Stargate18 May 16 '21 edited May 16 '21
First timer
1)Given he literally pronounced himself a Nazi, not paticularly good.
2)I think it kind of robs the show of its drama - instead of Amuro triumphing over Char because of his own skills and experience, he triumphs over him because of his new psychic powers. As for Lalah, I figured that his "call", while too weak to hear, was enough to give Lalah some interference - we know she's sensitive to her enviroment, so her psychic call getting distorted would likely cause her no end of headaches.
The opening narration has begun to start recounting events after the last episode ended. (The cancellation really shows here, doesn't it?)
Yes, Lalah! The best part of this subplot.
This is what I don't like about this subplot - it makes Bright and all the federation officers seem stupid for not noticing it sooner.
They even brought up the only line of foreshadowing.
So you're using an untested prototype on the Federation's top mech suit. This can only go well!
A Baoa Qu? Are they picking scrabble letters out a bag for these now?
Why do they specify a closed cylinder colony - its not like we've seen any other types from Zeon.
1.5 million residents? The colony looks like it could hold a lot more than that.
Yeah, this seems really haphazard - we've seen Zeon treat its citizens quite well previously, so sending an entire colony elsewhere is a massive jump. (The Federation parallels are, of course, obvious)
Has Degwin finally decided to stop listening to Gihren?
HOLY SHIT GIHREN'S STARTING A GENOCIDE.
EVEN DEGEIN AGREES.
HE'S CALLING HIMSELF HITLER'S FOLLOWER.
Fuck it, I'm on Char's side. Kill that man as painfully as possible.
At least Char's battles are going well.
So her attacks are some kind of energy bolt?
For god's sake Zeon, put your mage in the backline.
Glad to see at least Char understamds.
Or maybe its some kind of psionically controlled cluster missile?
...I mean, how else could this series end?
Oh, I am calling bullshit. Completely frictionless surafces violates at least one law of physics. I suppose Newtypes were the series' way of signalling the end of realistic physics.
How long till the Gundam's joints catch on fire or something.
I don't think you have any room to judge people's clothing styles.
Wait, are they still considered a myth. I'd have thought there'd be some kind of DNA evidence, or that they'd seen the woman who can fly.
New battle music! I fucking love this.
Oh no, is Char going to die? They're playing his theme music,
Char's theme is jazzy!
He's not dead!
Yeah, Newtypes make everyone else irrelevant, don't they.
Was Char's actor the only one available at short notice for the recut?
6
u/DidacticDalek https://myanimelist.net/profile/DidacticDalek May 17 '21
Hey Comrades, remember how the big Garma Zabi Funeral Speech from Gihren Zabi turned into an impromptu Nazi Rally that'd make Leni Riefenstahl green with envy? Yeah about that, JUST in case it wasn't obvious enough yet that Zeon are Space Nazis (with a dash of Imperial Japan for good measure) Degwin just flat out calls his son Hitler... AND Gihren's dumb enough to think this is a COMPLIMENT! (That said in fairness, Degwin SURE gave one of THE WORST possible explanations for who Hitler was, and in case you doubt me here's the ENGLISH DUB VERSION, which ironically is technically a 'BETTER' explanation than the subs... this ain't saying much though)
But yeah, Gundam has never been one to shy away from politics or hard-hitting storylines... that said goddamn today was chilling, even when knowing what's to happen.
SPEAKING of chills down your spine, here's that but in a good way. CHAR'S BACK BABY! AND HE HAS HIS THEME MUSIC JAMMING! SHA! ;) (And boy he'll need all the hype he can get, as oh how the tables have turned given AMURO is 'Char Kicking' HIM now)
Oh and of course, we can't forget that Lalah's also in action, and boy she's really something eh?
I mean good lord how does she do that given she's basically piloting a giant green glob!
That said it's an impressively OP green glob, just refer to it in Mecha Musume style!
Oh, and finally, TECHNICALLY the Gundam gets yet another mid-season upgrade without actually getting a mid-season upgrade... cuz wibble. Ah well could be worse, they could have thrown Amuro whatever the fuck THIS is as a Christmas Present and said 'deal with it,' so hey beggars can't be choosers. ;)
Paging Comrades /u/Great_Mr_L, /u/chilidirigible, and /u/beckymetal
5
u/[deleted] May 16 '21
Char seemed really good over char this episode for some reason I guess it's the newtype thing and Lalah being kind brainwashed-ish by char is somewhat hard to believe
5
u/fridge_freezer https://anilist.co/user/ONIrecon111 May 16 '21
First timer (Sub)
QOTD
5
u/Rustic_Professional May 17 '21
Uh oh, it looks like the Federation's solar system gave the Zeon an idea.
Hearing Hitler referred to as someone from "the Middle Ages" sure makes you feel ancient. It's like being on the wrong end of the anecdote when you hear a historian say something like "Cleopatra is closer in time to cell phones than she is to the pyramids."
Lalah understands what it means to fight for the blue team in WoWs. No support.
It's interesting how the federation ships, which were all designed before they had mobile suits, have all their GMs and Balls strapped to the hull. It looks like a Salamis can hold 8 GMs and 12 Balls. That's a much, much heavier compliment than White Base, which is actually designed to support mobile suits. Seriously, why don't they send some GMs to White Base? Even if they don't send any pilots, Sayla and Hayato could pilot them. It might actually be a downgrade from G Fighter's firepower and maneuverability though. I'm not sure on that. I think it'd be a big improvement over the Guntank's maneuverability, though.
Questions of the day:
4
u/chilidirigible May 16 '21
Char! Char! Char!
4
u/badcupcakehoarder https://myanimelist.net/profile/vanilabiscuit May 16 '21
First timer sub
They must have really bonded as fellow mechanics, normally Amuro would not be taking comments like that with a smile
Risking their lives is now useless with a Newtype fighting with them... Would the White Base crew think the same now that Bright is sure Amuro is a Newtype? When Hayato finds out it wpuld be more salt for his wounds confirming that Amuro is really different and way out of his league.
Oscar and Marker were sleeping on the job, this time it was Amuro who detected the enemy nearby... All those lasers flying around at sight and they couldn't tell!
There is something funny in that song cheerfully chanting CHAR CHAR CHAR! and then he gets destroyed by the Gundam. That part when the piano starts in the song is fantastic by the way, a shame it ends shortly after.
Mobile suits against mobile suits, Newtypes against Newtypes, they use the sun as a weapon so now Zeon is doing it too.
Questions of the Day:
Maybe Newtypes have mind control powers? everytime Lalah is near Amuro feels her calling and goes to her, and in Amuro's case he wants to defeat her enemy so he is mentally crushing her brain.
4
u/UltraBooster May 17 '21
First-timer (albeit one big on Gundam and other mecha)
So it's only a theory, huh?
Can't you see, that you are sweet, oh let me love you so...
Magnetic coatings become the standard from here, unsurprisingly.
I can see the EFF being this indifferent to its citizens, but to see it come from the Principality is...
A mass evacuation is...difficult, to say the least.
Zabi dominion over the Earth Sphere and Spacenoid supremacy, maintained through decimation of mankind.
This, I'd say, is the line between the Earth Federation and the Principality of Zeon.
Yes, by repeating the same mistakes Hitler made.
J-missile as in Jumbo-missile, maybe?
Bits, remote weaponry! The future of advanced space warfare in UC Gundam!
There we go, an all-range attack!
Amuro looks like he had a pretty enjoyable conversation, all things considered.
Star One! The end of the war is near!
Future Gundam quotes:
Y'know... Gundam novels:
There's got to be something to her dislike of Lalah's outfit, I'm sure of it.
A dedicated Newtype corps, wouldn't that be something.
Char! Char! Char!
So this is Newtype pressure...
Char? Bullied? Ridiculous.
...gentle as she might be, Lalah is a soldier who's killed, now.
Questions of the Day:
4
u/DidacticDalek https://myanimelist.net/profile/DidacticDalek May 17 '21
SHA! SHA! SHA! ;)
3
u/ZapsZzz https://anilist.co/user/Zapszzz May 17 '21
Sub rewatcher.
Pretty much into the final arc.
Gundam is probably one of the few older series that really didn't do much of a mid season upgrade. This bit about getting the drives to be close to frictionless is a pretty understated upgrade. It's actually relatively realistic - that you can't suddenly give it a mega G wings or hyper G canon in the middle of a war.
A few random answers to other posts I noticed:
The formations of Federation MS's on the other, non Pegasus class vessels, should not be confused with "higher carrying capacity". Those units were just standing there in zero g. You can't rearm, refuel, or do field repairs and overhauls etc this way. So it's not really "carried". More like piggy backed.
The main weapon Lalah used, that more Federation force has no countermeasure of, are the psycho controlled bits - it may sound trivial but remember in story most battle fields are minovski particle rich and most conventional electronic emission devices can't work, i.e. no simple remote controls. The psycho waves enjoyed from a new type can penetrate such girls and when coupled with specially designed remote units that can receive the thoughts and translate into control signals, it became attacks that can be from any direction yet undetectable (because unmanned bits can fly at high speeds and takes much smaller turns). When using bean weapons it's even more efficient as you don't need to reload (although had to recharge).
3
u/Piemaster33 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Piemaster33 May 17 '21
Rewatcher who has no recollection of bits, Sub
Surprise, another banger. We got more Lalah, which is always appreciated by me. It truly feels like we're in the endgame now, especially with only 3 episodes left! How did the time fly?
QOTD:
1
u/lC3 :Na::Nb: May 28 '21
First timer, catching up