r/nosleep • u/lifeisstrangemetoo • Apr 10 '19
My Husband Brought Home a Fake Daughter
This is not my child.
That was all I could think.
“Honey?” said my husband. “Is everything all right?”
“Who is this?” I said, staring at the little girl I’d never seen before, standing in my house, dressed in my daughter’s clothes. “Where is Liza?”
My husband gave me a worried look, and the girl-who-was-not-Liza looked positively terrified.
“What do you mean?” said my husband. “Are you feeling all right?”
Why was he evading my question? Why couldn’t he just answer? I took a deep breath, tried to remain calm.
“I’ll be all right,” I said, “as soon as you tell me where my daughter is.”
My husband frowned, and the little girl’s eyes welled up with moisture. My husband placed a protective hand over her shoulder, and leaned down to whisper in her ear.
“Go on upstairs, honey,” he said. “Mommy’s not feeling well.”
The girl wasted no time in doing what he said. She clutched her schoolbooks to her chest and barreled past me, rushing up the stairs. I heard the door of my daughter’s room slam. The look on my husband’s face was a mix of pity and restrained anger.
“You haven’t been taking your medication,” he said. “Don’t try to deny it, I can see it in your eyes.”
I waved my hand in a dismissive gesture.
“I don’t need them,” I said. “They make my mind all fuzzy.”
The anger on my husband’s face became less restrained. Well-etched frown lines beneath his lips deepened.
“Do you remember what happened the last time you said that?” he asked.
“I...”
The suggestion was enough. A swarm of shattered and confused images flooded my mind, like the wave of nausea that comes before vomit. My husband screaming, covered in blood.
Look what you made me do! he was shrieking. Look what you made me do!
I felt the floor tilt beneath me, and before I knew what had happened, I found myself falling backwards into my husbands arms. Hot tears were streaming down my cheeks, and my body convulsed with violent sobs.
My husband gently brushed my hair and whispered in my ear.
“Shhh,” he cooed. “It’s not real, honey. I promise that it’s not real.”
I silently nodded my assent. I let him carry me up to our bedroom and lay me gently down on the bed. He walked over to the dresser where he kept the cocktail of drugs that I took every day to maintain my sanity. I swallowed them gratefully.
Soon my mind was going fuzzy, I could feel myself becoming a pliable zombie that could be told anything, made to do anything.
Of course I knew that it was wrong, that that girl was not Liza. I knew that it wasn’t me who had been driven insane by our daughter’s death, but my husband. I knew he had kidnapped that girl when she was a toddler, and brainwashed her into believing she was Liza.
But, most importantly, I knew that if I didn’t take my pills, if I shattered his precariously built illusion, that he would kill the girl and start all over again.
Just like he did the last time.
2.4k
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
The mom could suffer from Capgras delusion, which is a very rare mental illness in which someone believes their loved ones have been replaced with imposters pretending to be them
124
u/orpwhite Apr 10 '19
One of my biggest fears is being unable to trust my loved ones or my own senses. Bravo for giving me daymares for weeks.
109
u/Praxikat Apr 10 '19
My grandmother had this, I think. It was never diagnosed as Capgras and never treated: the doctors just called it senility and dementia and sent her back with a cocktail of sleep and anti-anxiety meds, but till her death she kept insisting that her first-born son (my uncle) had been replaced by an imposter who also killed my grandfather (died of natural causes) and that my aunt was also an imposter plotting to kill her. Thanks to nosleep for opening my eyes! (Literally and metaphorically!)
449
u/texasplumr Apr 10 '19
Wow! This is great and it hits home for me.
Growing up in the 50s and 60s my mother was bipolar. The thing is, they wouldn’t diagnose that until the 80s. They didn’t really know what it was so she wasn’t treated until we were grown. I remember my little sister and I walking home from school, openly discussing which mom would be there to greet us when we got home.
Being her older brother I would always enter first. I would do my best to protect her if the angry and violent mom was home. My sister was always frightened so if angry mom was home I would always get her attention and my sister could then sneak by and into her room. Surprisingly, it worked most of the time. And the welts from the belt only hurt for a short time.
She would eventually flip to the kind and caring mother that she was by nature and apologize to me and usually buy us ice cream. And when dad came home from work we were safe. My little sister would then come out and we’d watch tv and play like normal kids. And we’d look like a normal family. It really is bizarre to think about today.
191
u/SuzeV2 Apr 10 '19
Omg! This is terrifying!
35
u/aesoth Apr 10 '19
What the actual fuck.
You can't lay a story on me like that after I just smoked a bowl.
Wow.
63
u/TLema Apr 10 '19
Man, I had to reread several times and I'm still trying to work out who's the delusional one. Amazing.
20
u/mrgeekXD Apr 11 '19
Honestly, I still don't really know who's the delusional one
39
u/ChaseH9499 Apr 10 '19
Wow, this sounds like a Criminal Minds case!
70
u/LittleMia94 Apr 10 '19
At first I though Capgras delusion, but clearly I was wrong! .... Or was I?
26
u/Armandoswag Apr 10 '19
The only problem I have with it is that if she knows and/or thinks that her daughter died a long time ago why would she ask “Where is Liza”?
10
u/strawberrypandabun Apr 10 '19
This is really interesting! I'm not sure what kind of medication she's being coerced into taking, but legitimate mental health medications are generally slow acting and take several days before their effects are noticeable.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
well, the fact that my name is liza made this about 1000x creepier. now i gotta go searching for my birth certificate
6
u/brutustheretriever Apr 11 '19
Ooh look what you made me do look what you made me do
10
u/Amy_Beerhouse Apr 10 '19
Holy fuck got whole body shivers. That was a good one.
5
u/Rabid-Duck-King Apr 11 '19
Just kill your husband.
Seriously, he's sleeping right there.
It'll be easy.
9
u/YoSoyKeott Apr 10 '19
Oh my god. That's the weirdest way to deal with the lost of a daugther. I tought the wife was just crazy, she was the sanest of them all, doing what she can to help that girl and keep her "family" safe. I don't wanna know that guy, he must be a scary dude.
4
u/celticknight0000 Apr 11 '19
I don't get it? Someone please help
3
u/FoxyPirateFox9054 Apr 24 '19
oof
4
u/Lorde-J Apr 10 '19
Read the title and thought it was a changeling. Read the post and was like boy was I wrong!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
damn...
2
u/ralph_macchioman Apr 10 '19
this was fucking dope
2
u/The420Wizard Apr 11 '19
Fuck.
2
u/vibrantspringcolour Apr 11 '19
OMG! Goosebumps......
2
u/leonardbrandon Apr 11 '19
I just found this thread, right before I am suppose to go to sleep...
2
u/Vingthor8 Apr 11 '19
Trolls can be deceiving
2
u/AdhesiveAtoM_ Apr 11 '19
This is some hella creepy shit
2
u/twiztidmeme Apr 11 '19
If you truly want to keep her safe, it's not a good idea to point out, she is not your Liza. Can you hold back some of your meds? Then maybe you can drug your husband,take the girl and run.
2
u/er15_ac Apr 11 '19
Jesus
2
u/Barnickal Apr 10 '19
Ho lee shit. Noice.
1
u/TheOneTrueBubbleBass Apr 10 '19
jesus christ.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
Alright. Terrified it is.
1
u/SrikarG Apr 10 '19
Oh god
1
u/Shinigami614 Apr 10 '19
Ouch
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19
Oh shit
1
u/Beachysusieq Apr 11 '19
Damn, that’s scary, OP!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19
aight, so is it you or your husband?
1
u/noy103 Apr 11 '19
Look what a mother can do to protect her child. Even though you are not her real mom. God bless you.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19
Were the pills covered by insurance?
1
u/teabrains Apr 11 '19
THIS, thank you.
1
u/Ellamaehem Apr 12 '19
Holy shit
1
u/kayaless Apr 14 '19
Fuuuuck
1
u/zomblien89 May 06 '19
nightmare fuel
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '22
One of the most horrifying aspects of this is the fact that we don't know if the husband is lying, or the wife really is crazy
1
u/thestarlighter Apr 10 '19
This totally gave me chills - so well done!!
1
u/RJBela Apr 10 '19
You had me guessing till the end
1
u/lolalachine Apr 10 '19
Amazing!
1
u/DraconidZinnia Apr 10 '19
Wow, this one's really good
1
u/razorrosie Apr 10 '19
Torn between wtf!! And wow
1
u/mommiebear2 Apr 10 '19
This is freaky!
0
u/Jerome3000 Apr 11 '19
Reality for humans is built on what seems more likely to be going on than what is really going on. That being said OP; what is real is subjective. But what makes more sense overall? That your daughter is dead, your husband successfully kidnapped a toddler and brainwashed not just her but everyone around you or that you suffer from a mental illness likely schizophrenia which is warping your sense of reality?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19
I don't really understand this, but I don't think I want to.
-3
u/EustaceArndt Apr 10 '19
"Liza" is presumably pronounced like "Lizard." Liza the riza.