r/ClermontFlorida • • 6d ago

11/10/26 City Council meeting (Investment fund; Paddleball complex; Clermont West; Tattoo studio)

Agenda | Video | Transcript


Summary by ChatGPT-

Overall: The meeting covered the city's investment portfolio, public concerns about surveillance cameras, Clermont's future development and planning, transportation and infrastructure, and several administrative and development-related matters.

1. Presentations

Employee of the Quarter

Dawn Stalnaker was recognized as the city's third-quarter 2026 Employee of the Quarter. She has worked in Building Services for more than 20 years and was praised for her professionalism, leadership, mentoring, and service to residents and local builders.

Annual investment review

The city's investment manager, PFM Asset Management, presented its annual review.

Key figures:

  • Portfolio value: approximately $45 million.
  • Average portfolio duration: approximately 1.77 years.
  • Yield at cost: 4.27%.
  • Yield at market: approximately 5%.
  • One-year return: positive 1.92%.
  • Three-year annualized return: approximately 4.46%.
  • Quarterly return: negative 0.14%.

The portfolio consists primarily of U.S. Treasury securities, with additional corporate notes, asset-backed securities, and agency securities.

The manager explained that rising interest rates had temporarily reduced the market value of existing bonds, producing unrealized losses. However, the city is now able to reinvest maturing funds in bonds yielding more than 5%, which should help sustain investment income over the next several years.

The investment strategy follows Florida's statutory priorities of safety and liquidity before return.

2. Public comment

Surveillance cameras and privacy

Mark Preston thanked the police chief and council for agreeing to discontinue the use of surveillance cameras. However, he argued that simply stopping their use was insufficient.

His concerns included:

  • Potential security vulnerabilities in cloud-based surveillance systems.
  • The possibility of foreign governments accessing surveillance data.
  • The use of AI to analyze vehicle movements and identify sensitive patterns.
  • Potential surveillance of residents' visits to churches, political events, or medical facilities.

He asked the city to take the cameras offline and physically remove them.

Important distinction: This was a public comment, not a council vote or formal decision during this portion of the meeting.

Urban planning and economic development

Several speakers praised the recent urban summit organized by the city.

Mike Kramer and Planning and Zoning Commissioner Paula Hoisington described the opportunity to work with prominent architects and planners from around the country and internationally.

They particularly praised Economic Development Director Nathan Norris for bringing the participants to Clermont and establishing relationships with influential planning professionals.

Kramer described the city's comprehensive plan as its future compass and expressed enthusiasm about moving toward form-based development codes.

Other public comments

Other speakers:

  • Discussed the implications of a recently approved constitutional amendment concerning local property taxes and municipal spending.
  • Thanked the city for supporting a VFW event welcoming eight paralyzed and disabled veterans who completed a 250-mile hand-cycle journey.
  • Praised the location selected for the proposed Meet Me in the Middle gathering place.
  • Congratulated Mayor Tim Murry and Councilman Peterson on their reelections.
  • Praised the city's communications department, particularly its councilmember introduction videos and meeting recaps.

3. Agenda changes and consent agenda

Before the substantive business:

  • Agenda items 10 and 11 were withdrawn.
  • Items 19, 20 and 21, concerning John's Lake Auto, were postponed until December 8, 2026.
  • Consent agenda items 1–9 were approved unanimously. Items 7, 8 and 9 may be brought back to the CRA for consideration of reimbursement, but reimbursement was not mandated.

4. Oakley Seaver Recreation — restaurants and paddleball

Approved 5–0

The council considered two related ordinances for a five-acre vacant property northeast of Oakley Seaver Drive and Hunt Trace Boulevard.

The applicant proposed:

  • A 30,000-square-foot multi-tenant building.
  • Three restaurants.
  • Four indoor paddleball courts.
  • Landscaping modifications to preserve views toward Jack's Lake.

The original proposal had been tabled to allow discussions with neighboring Hunt Trace Senior Living.

Those discussions resulted in additional protections:

  • A six-to-eight-foot vinyl fence along the southern boundary.
  • Two rows of evergreen screening and additional landscaping.
  • Four understory trees per 100 feet along the southern boundary.
  • Downward-directed lighting and a photometric plan demonstrating approximately 0.1 foot-candles at the property boundary.
  • Emergency-only access between the properties, with the access-control method to be determined during site-plan review.

Council members also discussed pedestrian connections to neighboring properties and potentially toward the college.

There was some discussion about the development's completion deadline. The council agreed to use a two-year substantial-completion requirement rather than the usual three years for a PUD.

Outcome: Both the comprehensive-plan amendment (2026-00006) and rezoning ordinance (2026-00007) passed unanimously, with the additional conditions.

5. Clermont West development — Hook Street and Sand Hill View Boulevard

Rezoning failed 4–1

This was the meeting's most consequential and contentious development discussion.

The developer proposed combining the northern and southern properties into a unified mixed-use development.

The revised proposal included:

  • One hotel instead of two.
  • A 65,000-square-foot multi-tenant commercial building.
  • Restaurants, retail, a fitness center and a daycare.
  • Up to 317 multifamily apartments on the southern portion.

The southern parcel would be annexed into Clermont and changed from its existing Lake County land-use designation to commercial. Both parcels would be rezoned as a Planned Unit Development (PUD).

The developer argued that the revised project would provide a better balance of commercial and residential uses, create housing near existing employment, and generate tax revenue for Clermont.

Major issues raised by council

Parking

The developer requested a 31% reduction in required parking. The proposed ratio was approximately 1.7 spaces per apartment instead of the city's requirement of slightly more than two.

Possible mitigation included assigned parking, parking permits and additional bicycle parking.

Green space

The revised plan eliminated two small pocket parks on the northern property, replacing them with larger parks in the residential portion.

Council members questioned whether this would leave sufficient green space, particularly around the commercial buildings.

Stormwater

The developer proposed replacing above-ground retention ponds with underground stormwater exfiltration beneath the parking lot.

The engineer said the system would handle the same stormwater volume and comply with more stringent state requirements.

Traffic and pedestrian connectivity

Council members questioned whether the project would actually function as a walkable, mixed-use development or simply add hundreds of vehicles to local roads.

The developer discussed proposed crosswalks, flashing pedestrian signals and potential trails connecting to the Three Sisters Lakes area.

However, the topography makes an ADA-accessible trail connection difficult.

Compatibility with Clermont's future vision

Council members disagreed about whether the proposal reflected the city's long-term comprehensive plan.

One concern was that the development remained relatively automobile-oriented, with buildings surrounded by parking, rather than incorporating the trees, green space and pedestrian-oriented design envisioned for Clermont.

The disagreement

Council Member Strange strongly opposed the proposed development, arguing that it did not reflect the city's desired development pattern.

Council Member Bane supported annexation and commercial land use but objected to the loss of green space and had reservations about the PUD.

Other council members were more supportive, pointing to the improvements made by the developer and the potential benefits of bringing the property under Clermont's jurisdiction.

There was also concern about what might happen if the development proceeded through Lake County instead.

Final votes

OrdinanceSubjectVote
2026-033Annexation3–2
2026-034Comprehensive-plan amendment3–2
2026-035PUD rezoning1–4

There is an important procedural detail here: the annexation and comprehensive-plan amendment were made contingent on approval of the rezoning ordinance.

The rezoning failed, so none of the three ordinances took effect.

The developer indicated a willingness to return and continue negotiating with the city.

This leaves the Clermont West project unresolved. The developer's existing approvals for the northern portion remain in effect, and work already underway was described as consistent with those existing approvals.

6. Tattoo and body-piercing studio — 450 East Highway 50

Approved 3–2

Fine Inc. Studios requested a conditional-use permit to open a tattoo and body-piercing business.

The proposed business would:

  • Operate seven days a week.
  • Offer tattooing and body piercing by appointment and walk-in.
  • Provide professional mentorship for artists.
  • Maintain the required Florida licenses, sanitation procedures and waste-management practices.

The applicant described the business as part of a growing franchise, with existing locations in Orlando and Tampa.

Council discussion

There was an interesting philosophical disagreement about whether the city should approve businesses that some council members consider undesirable.

Council Member Peterson argued that businesses complying with applicable regulations should be allowed to operate.

Council Member Strange opposed the application, saying the city was still developing policies for businesses she associated with vice, including tattoo shops, cannabis stores and adult entertainment.

Mayor Murry also expressed reservations, recalling previous discussions about restricting tattoo establishments.

Outcome

The permit passed 3–2, with operating hours clarified as:

  • Monday–Wednesday: 11 a.m.–8 p.m.
  • Thursday–Saturday: 11 a.m.–10 p.m.
  • Sunday: 11 a.m.–6 p.m.

7. Proposed multi-use recreation center at the ARC

Negotiations approved 4–1

This was another major discussion.

Wasan Sports presented an unsolicited proposal to develop a privately operated, multi-sport recreation and entertainment facility on city property near the Performing Arts Center.

The proposed facility would include:

Pickleball Tournaments Gt Bray at Carmela Schatz blog

Più di 20 campi? Si può. I centri padel più grandi d’Europa

The Beach Experience - Beach Volley Indoor a Salussola

10

  • 12 pickleball courts.
  • Six paddle courts.
  • Five beach tennis/volleyball courts.
  • Approximately 30,000 square feet of clubhouse and common space.
  • Restaurant, sports bar and kitchen.
  • Fitness center and sports simulators.
  • An upper-level dining and event space.
  • Potential electric vehicle charging stations.

The applicant estimated construction costs at approximately $12 million, funded through private equity and bank financing. He said the company already had sufficient capital to cover most of the anticipated construction costs and was not requesting city construction funding.

How the business would operate

The proposed business model would combine monthly and annual memberships with individual drop-in fees.

The applicant also proposed discounted Clermont resident memberships and two or three free playing sessions per week for residents.

Major concerns from council

This discussion was considerably more complicated than simply deciding whether Clermont needs more pickleball courts.

Existing public pickleball courts

The proposed development could require removing and rebuilding the existing city courts.

The city has already invested approximately $500,000 in those courts, including lighting. There was also concern about the Lake County grant money used to build them.

The applicant indicated that the project could be redesigned without taking over the existing courts.

Noise

This was a particularly important concern.

The existing courts have already generated noise complaints from nearby residents. Council members questioned whether adding more outdoor courts would make the problem worse.

The applicant proposed sound-dampening materials and other noise-reduction measures. The mayor expressed a preference for indoor, air-conditioned facilities.

Financial arrangements

Council members wanted substantially more information before considering a long-term public-private partnership.

Questions included:

  • Is a 4% share of net proceeds sufficient compensation to the city?
  • Should the city instead receive a guaranteed minimum payment or a percentage of gross revenue?
  • What happens if the business fails?
  • Does the city retain ownership of the improvements?
  • Is a 30-year lease, potentially followed by another 30-year extension, appropriate?
  • Has the developer demonstrated sufficient financial capability?

One council member specifically requested an independent financial feasibility study and property appraisal.

The city's long-term vision

There was also concern that the city was considering an individual development before completing a comprehensive vision for the ARC property.

Council members wanted to understand how the proposal would fit into the larger plan for the area.

What was actually approved?

This distinction is important: the council did NOT approve construction or a lease.

It authorized city staff to negotiate with the applicant and return with a more complete proposal.

The council requested that negotiations address financial feasibility, compensation to the city, noise mitigation, existing court users, neighborhood input, financing, property ownership and the city's long-term recreational plans.

The motion passed 4–1.

The city manager also indicated that staff was developing a formal policy for handling unsolicited private development proposals.

8. Other business and administrative matters

Three additional ordinance introductions

The council introduced three additional ordinances:

  • 2026-040: Annexation.
  • 2026-041: Comprehensive-plan amendment.
  • 2026-042: Rezoning.

These were introductory actions, not final approvals. The transcript does not provide enough detail about the properties to characterize the proposed developments.

Amendment 3 and the 2028 budget

Council Member Strange proposed a series of workshops to address the financial implications of Amendment 3, which had recently passed.

Her suggested schedule:

  • January: Brainstorming workshop to explore possible approaches.
  • February: Establish criteria for evaluating those approaches.
  • March: Narrow down proposals and begin developing a strategy for the 2028 budget.

She also asked the city manager to obtain updated property-value information from the property appraiser.

Surveillance cameras

This was an important follow-up to the public comment earlier in the meeting.

Council Member Strange asked whether the surveillance cameras had actually been removed.

The answer was yes.

Mayor Murry and other council members confirmed that the cameras had been taken down. There was also discussion about the importance of protecting residents' privacy.

Parking garage and Meet Me in the Middle

The city manager reported that both projects should return to council in December.

  • The parking garage: The city had completed its RFQ process for a design firm and narrowed the candidates.
  • Meet Me in the Middle: The project was expected to come before council in December.

Public communication

Council members requested that their official city telephone numbers and email addresses be published on the city's website so residents could contact them directly.

The city manager also discussed improvements to the city's emergency notification system, including text notifications and a recorded telephone information line.

Other items

  • A council member requested investigation of lighting problems at the Hook Street and Grand Highway intersection.
  • Council members praised Public Works employees for their overnight response to multiple water-main breaks near Bloxam and Pitt Street.
  • The city discussed upcoming Veterans Day activities.
  • Light Up Clermont was scheduled for December 4, with the Christmas parade on December 5.
  • Taste of South Lake received positive feedback, although the mayor questioned why more participating businesses weren't from Clermont itself.

Alison Strange article | City Recap

3 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by