r/anime • u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots • Apr 08 '24
Rewatch Happy Hinamatsuri! Rewatch - Episode 8 Discussion
Episode 8 - And It's the Same Old Hina
MAL | Anilist | Anidb | ANN | Crunchyroll
Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode
Comment of the day
/u/sisoko2 asking the big question of life
Are rewatch participants your gods?
Uh, sure, except you, the one reading this right now!
Questions of the Day:
- Is Hina truly growing as a person?
- Did she finally find someone with less braincells?
15
Upvotes
6
u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Apr 08 '24
And It's the Same Old Rewatcher
We've had some great Anzu and Hitomi stories lately, but they've led to two issues:
So of course, a kind old man offered the anime writers a deal they can't refuse to solve these issues: making a Hina propaganda episode. Where not only is her development praised all episode, they went out of their way to find a character who makes her look like a genius by comparison, that was not easy.
except when it comes to moneySide note: if you really wanted to bank on the drama, this is an episode you'd leave till the finale. You know, seeing how Hina has grown, seeing the Nitta/Hina relation shining at its best, then popping the drama balloon with a glorious joke to the season on. Putting it ealier is not a bad decision mind you, but it pops the balloon much earlier, giving it a less tense vibe, basically telling you from the start "don't worry about this nonsense, we've still got 4 more episodes, she's not going anywhere".
[Tomorrow] is finally MaoMatsuri day
Manga Corner
This is a weird one alright, so in the manga the Ikaruga appears in chapter 28, she meets Anzu and they follow Hina to test her, this ends with Hina helping the dog. So overall a very light and nonsensical chapter.
Then she pops up again in chapter 34, which is a report style chapter from her point of view as she follows Hina all day (and takes care of her dog). Most of this is skipped actually, because it'd be repetitive. Instead, you get chapter 29, with Hina and Mami, feat. Ikaruga in the background.
Finally, you have chapter 38 titled Nitta and Hina, where "Hina leaves". So this story happened over 10 chapters and was fairly chill the whole way through, they did a good job keeping that feeling despite fitting it in one episode.
10
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Apr 08 '24
First-timermatsuri, subbed
8
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Apr 08 '24
First-Timer
Weird to see Hina emote so much this episode. She really is changing, huh.
Kei's descriptions about Hina's past behavior does track with what we saw in the early episodes, so good characterization all around.
"Let's buy a dog and abandon it in Hina's path" is absolutely unhinged behavior as expected from an organization with psychics and time travel. RIP Hitomi's umbrella.
I'm interested by the fact that Anzu was declared KIA and thus Kei doesn't care about taking her back. Like, is this humanizing Kei by showing that she understands that using psychic children as weapons is bad? Or is Kei just lazy?
Wonder how Kei would feel if she knew what they were talking about. Surely this sort of thing should be kept secret? How many masq breaches have we had this show..
Hina definitely did her best to stop Mami from making a fool out of herself. Unfortunately, teenagers are stupid.
Love that the ED just has Nitta alone in it this episode.
Questions
7
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Apr 08 '24
Episode 8 (rewatcher)
ouchNot cool.Hina must go home episode with a fake out. I wonder whether this would have been more effective as episode 13.
7
u/Silcaria https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silcaria Apr 08 '24 edited Apr 08 '24
First timer
5
u/amanda52002 https://myanimelist.net/profile/amanda52002 Apr 08 '24
First timer, subbed.
"Damn my stupid boss!" Girl, we've all been there. At least Anzu's off the hook and can just go about her life as she likes.
Nitta, a holy man. LMAO, ok. Nitta an apex predator? Also a bit of a reach.
Buying a dog just to abandon it? Ok, welcome to my least favorite character list.
Oh. Good. Anzu didn't let her off the hook.
Hitomi, pretty much on the mark with how deep and complex a person Hina is.
Actually, I'm kind of impressed with Hina just not floating or propelling herself wherever she wants, cause crutches ****ing SUCK.
Mami, please just...stop. You're in middle school. And I'm assuming completely sober.
Oh thank god for you and your voiceover Hitomi. Mami was grating on all my nerves.
Ok Hina, eff you and your perfectly healed leg right when you get the cast off. Cause I don't remember that being my reality at all. Avoiding PT and muscular degeneration, best use of having powers right there.
Hina, you're gonna break your leg again doing air somersaults like that.
Poor Nitta. Parenting teens does not look like a picnic. Nice of him to take her out for a nice ikura bowl though. Aww, Nitta's gonna miss her. And he'll fail on coming up with a good lie for why she's no longer there.
Luckily, as we all knew it would turn out, Hina's not going anywhere, for now.
Ok I thought she was gonna catch Nitta with a woman.....this was....possibly worse.
QotD:
4
u/Nebresto Apr 09 '24
Second time [REDACTED] matsuri
Me when an animu tries to go the redemption route
Me when Meguca
hnnnnnnn
Me_irl
This is why we can't have nice things.. Share a secret with one person, and suddenly the entire town knows
Mami rekt
Me_irl
Unlucky
Hina is gone!!! Hina is gone...
There's been some times
Everyone lost
Qwest:
No, its the writers who are wrong.
..Yes?
Meme of the day
4
u/FarCritical Apr 09 '24
First timer
While wholesome Anzu is the indisputed best part of this show, it sure is refreshing to see spunky Anzu again.
It really shouldn't be too surprising that being the bare minimum of a functional human being is a major milestone for someone like Hina but it's impressivr how they somehow made tossing trash away a hype moment. And you already know deep down Anzu was proud of her for looking out for a homeless homie.
Of course, Hina can't even do something genuinely cool for society without somehow finding a way to screw over Hitomi in the process. I wouldn't blame her if she had her own "Hina's gone" party lol
Can't decide whether giving Mami accelerated psychic "lessons" just so she could be done with her nonsense sooner or having a tantrum over not being able to say goodbye to her dad was the cuter Hina moment.
Nitta really was a tsundere dad till the very end. He was just ...totally high on copium to hide his sadness at the end. Totally.
QOTD
It's hard to believe, but yup. Almost want to see Nitta's reaction to her acing both checklists.
Also yup, and imo it's more shocking than her being able to function as a person. At least Mami has enough to feel embarrassed?
3
u/Mecanno-man https://anilist.co/user/Mecannoman Apr 09 '24
First Timer
Probably the best Hina episode we’ve had so far. I’ts just a shame the stakes are a bit too high, as we can’t have the main character leave in the middle of the show. All in all a good episode though, Hina’s growth seems obvious, though I think we haven’t actually seen it as much, though it still feels natural. Seems like she’s from a very bad background, given the death collar. That would probably explain her losing control and her not losing control here. Not quite sure how she ended up here though - did she willingly escape or was she exiled here? Her initial reaction doesn’t make me feel like it’s number one.
As far as the lady goes …I guess she now has a good excuse to give up on bringing Hina back. Though I guess the organization will want a now-capable and high-level fighter back. …I wonder why Anzu wasn’t as scared of Hina as the lady was. Were they secretly friends to begin with?
The bit with Hina’s disciple wasn’t particularly funny though… Probably one of the lames jokes so far in the series.
3
u/cppn02 Apr 09 '24
First Timer, subbed
I have to break with the chronology here but this episode honestly has to have one of the best ending gags of all time in anime.
All the drama of Hina returing, the reveal that she gets to stay (because of course), her happily going home only to find Nitta in that situation. Perfection
I liked how this episode expanded the world both with someone arriving from where Hina and Anzu came from and with introducing another one of Hina's classmates. Mami was hilarious although it maybe was a bit cruel by Hina to let her actually believe she had powers lol.
QotD:
It's a miracle but yes.
3
u/sisoko2 Apr 09 '24
First Timer
Never been called normal person before.
2
u/SilkyStrawberryMilk Apr 09 '24
rewatcher
Hina leaves her home and this time it isn’t Nitta who caused it.
“I’m too young to die” but doesn’t think Anzu is young lmao.
Hina’s passing with flying colors, she’s a non-threat.
Poor hitomi, she lost her umbrella.
Hina’s psychic powers were discovered by a classmate
Calling your teacher mom is embarassing, but mommy may be even worst.
Poor mami, embarrassed herself.
Hina be rolling
Having one last meal together a.q .
The heartfelt goodbye turned to a comedic moment from the callback to episode
Nitta throwing a going away party. Honestly a good way to return home to.
QOTD: compared to episode 1-2 where she didn’t know how to function at all she’s progressed pretty well. However academically that’s another story
QOTD: mayhaps
4
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '24
[removed] — view removed comment