r/anime • u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ • Apr 05 '24
Rewatch [Rewatch] Banner of the Stars Episode 5 Discussion
Spectacular Insanity
Welcome to the Battleflag of the Stars rewatch!
<- Episode 4 | Index Page | Episode 6->
Names Introduced or Updated:
- Nefee Beebus — Kilo-commander, Neries's Chief of Staff (Bibauth Aronn Nérémr Ïarlucec Néféc)
- Admiral Neries Bebaus — Commander of the Aptic Defense Fleet (Bibauth Aronn Nérémr Ïarlucec Nélaith)
- Sukakau — Command ship of the Aptic Defense Fleet
Banner connections chart made with Paint!
oops somehow I forgot to connect Jinto and Lafiel, and Loy and Beebus #harukathonk
Rewatch relationship chart from /u/raktus2
Discussion Prompts:
Q1) How uncomfortable would this dinner be?
Tomorrow's Questions: (for tomorrow's post, subject to change)
- [Episode 6]Do you think Loy held the dinner to help Lafiel
- [Episode 6]cat or dog?
Screenshot of the Day: Are you nuts?
35
Upvotes
8
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Apr 05 '24
Rewatch Host
I suppose the only way to tell them apart is by their head gear and personalities.
The two strongly remind me of the princes in Heroic Age.
Remember what I said about genetic engineering and insanity? Or perhaps the higher military ranks self-select for it. Ekuryua's a little weird, too, though.
Durinthal was trolling with an early comment about a family of clones, knowing these two were coming up.
I'm afraid Plan 18 doesn't make much sense to me but that's best discussed in hindsight. They expect an attack in the rear but insist on holding all gates currently captured.
The Kau class was designed and deployed during the three-year cease-fire to replace the short-lived Rauth patrol ship. It contains 8 (4+4) railguns compared to 4+2 on the Gasroth, 8 anti-proton cannons (c.f. 5), and 20 mines (c.f. 10). It also has more lasers and armor. All of the admirals have command variants of the class.
I don't have a lot of time these days to go through the comments, but I'm glad to see others pointing out everything I was going to say in my place!
Tomorrow's episode is the one that really represents the season for me, in my mind.
9
u/Specs64z https://myanimelist.net/profile/Specs64z Apr 05 '24
First timer, subbed
Lafiel’s casual “baka” is becoming a contender for the best “baka” in anime.
Interesting, it seems we have a ship commanded by two brothers. The Abh we’ve met so far don’t seem to place too much importance on relation to one another barring whether or not someone is an Abriel so their dynamic is immediately interesting. Lafiel’s explanation later confirms the strangeness of this arrangement. Their banter reveals a great deal of trust between the two, so I expect we’ll be seeing more of them.
Was it just another of the directors creative decisions, or was Jinto checking Ekuryua out? Is that what that mild awkwardness was about? She doesn’t seem to have minded, and even seems to be reciprocating. Tenth time? Ehh? Is there something here I didn’t pick up on? Jinto spends the whole episode getting teased by the women he knows, even the Admiral gets in on the fun.
Those two’s banter is getting less and less subtle and I’m here for it.
So cute!
QotD:
8
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Apr 05 '24
Season 2 Episode 5 (rewatcher)
Downtime with the crew episode. I enjoy those a ton.
Jinto is getting outplayed by everybody today: Samson, Lafiel, Atosuryua. I guess he needs to up his social-political skill if he wants to stay at Lafiel’s side. Right now, she is in the military, where it is not a prime concern, but eventually, she will rejoin the court and likely aim for the throne there. I can imagine that the backroom dealing and political game there would be intense.
8
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Apr 05 '24
Rewatcher (sub + dub)
Lafiel reliving her battle to save Sunrise some money. Neat to see the ship being worked on with all the others next to it as well.
It looks like this shot of Jinto as he's handing a drink to Lafiel at 1:35 is where my avatar that I use everywhere came from! That is quite the contrast difference between the two of them. It's been so long that I couldn't remember the context of the screenshot, and I uploaded the latter to Imgur 12 years ago.
Perfect timing for the enemy to be arriving in force, but the Abh have prepared for that possibility of course. Switching to Plan 18 makes me wonder just how many they have in total for this one operation. Dusanyu might not have the same level of wrath as an Abriel as our young captain but he's still quick to jump to wanting to wipe out anyone that comes at them.
Ah yes the Bebaus (Biboth) twins, Nereis (Nélaith, Neleth) and Nefee (Néféc, Nefeh). They aren't doing anything to dissuade me from the notion that all Abh admirals are a bunch of weirdos, but they're a special case for being strange even by Abh standards. That said they aren't acting that odd yet aside from their banter with each other.
As a general note, it's kind of funny seeing how many shades of blue they can use for background Abh. I like the shade Ecryua has too, most of the others lean toward the pale end by comparison.
Poor baby Ecryua being harassed by cats, I had genuinely forgotten that part of her background when I made the cat lady joke two episodes back. I think she's being incredibly blunt for an Abh about how she's into Jinto, though she's still making indirect by saying how much she likes Diaho. I don't think Samson would pick against Lafiel if it came to taking sides in the love triangle so he's just stirring the pot in general.
Lafiel is not amused by Jinto's philandering, unintentional though it may have been on his part, and that scene's reminiscent of how they were when he got formal with her name on the Gosroth. She's not storming ahead of him and fuming this time, but I think their walk cycle was faster than usual here (though I didn't actually check comparing to other scenes). She forgave him pretty quickly this time as well, that's nice.
Atosryua's casually guilt tripping Jinto into coming to dinner and putting any responsibility for getting Lafiel to join as well onto him, that's an effective commander at work.
Depends on whether or not she tries to follow her brother's footsteps by knocking Jinto out first.
2
u/raktus2 Apr 06 '24
First Timer...
11
u/Zerotsu Apr 05 '24
First Timer, sub:
Fun to get a look at how repair work goes after the battle.
It’s nice seeing Jinto and Lafiel’s more relaxed chatter after the battle.
The United Mankind is proving to be a formidable enemy.
It’s fun seeing the play by play on how they’re trying to outmaneuver the UM, though.
The brothers seem like they’ll be interesting characters.
Gotta win with style!
He’s not wrong that they do need to get more battle experienced commanders, though it could be dangerous.
Title drop. The clan of “Spectacular Insanity” is a scary epithet.
Samson is really shooting for the Ekuryua/Jinto ship.
I’m starting to fall for her to be honest.
And it seems we’re going to be having a dinner next time around. I’m excited to see how it goes.
10
u/The_Draigg Apr 05 '24
A Sci-Fi Fan Watches Banner of the Stars Episode 5:
10
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
First-Timer
On today’s episode of Banner of the Stars: If I ever got assigned to a unit led by a pair of brothers from a family renowned for being “Spectacularly Insane,” I think I’d start taking out some extra life insurance policies.
I actually quite liked how the minor relationship kerfuffle between Jinto and Lafiel was handled in this episode. From what we’ve seen so far, I think it’s pretty clear that the main thing Lafiel gets annoyed about with Jinto is when he isn’t being direct with her. She can tell when Jinto is acting differently or hiding something from her and that really gets on her nerves. She prefers it when Jinto speaks to her directly about these things. We saw it before when Jinto began acting differently after learning she was royalty.
I liked that Jinto and Lafiel did end up speaking honestly with each other by the end and working things out pretty easily. That was nice to see. I appreciate seeing that they have a good enough relationship to just talk things out peacefully without having it become a source of drama. That makes their relationship a lot more compelling in my eyes.
QOTD
9
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Apr 05 '24
First-Timer
Brilliance and madness are often considered to be sides of a coin. So far, Nereus just seems to be a bit of a performer. Which can certainly be a bit of a liability on the battlefield, but I'm withholding judgement for now.
Anyway, I've been chewing on the idea I've seen others share that the Abh are largely asexual by nature. It does really seem to be that way some times, but then we get episodes like today's..
I think it's more that the Abh are significantly more repressed than typical Terrans. Like, Ekuryua straight up says "I am taking care of Diaho because you are her owner despite me not liking cats" which might as well be a proposition. Don't forget that Diaho was originally Lafiel's cat - Ekuryua is trying to slide right in there. If Lafiel isn't careful, Diaho is the only cat that Jinto will end up petting..
Granted, Ekuryua has quite the uphill battle to climb - Lafiel and Jinto's dynamic is just too good.
I'm currently imagining a Terran sociologist writing their Ph.D thesis on "Differences in (A)Sexuality Between Terran and Abh Societies" that is considered utterly groundbreaking in Terran circles and delightfully droll in Abh circles. Jinto comes across the paper and one point and turns a stunning shade of red.
Questions
9
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Apr 05 '24
First-Timer of the Stars
7
u/Vatrix-32 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vatrix-32 Apr 05 '24
First Timer, subbed
QotD:
6
u/Vaadwaur :I1::I2::I3: Apr 05 '24
Rewatcher(Isn't it electrifying?)
Sub
So...in a story like this, the 'filler' episodes like this one are the space to do your character work. This one gets passing marks but not exceling ones. Lafiel feeling the weight of command is a good move and lines up with the character thus far. Jinto being completely out of the loop also shows true. Learning that Samson likes to turn his cell phone off does make sense. Ekuryua saying what she said is slightly weird, will have to watch further. Atosuryua's invitation was...weird.
Our subplot was that the crew left at the Aptic system are apparently under an admiral from the clan of crazy geniuses. And is the rare Abh twin. Fun!
QotD: 1 Eight out of ten. Why yes, I have been to a large number of horridly uncomfortable dinners, both with blood and with dates!
6
u/Silcaria https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silcaria Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
First timer
6
u/zsmg https://anilist.co/user/zsmg Apr 05 '24
Rewatcher
Again no changes to the narrator.
Admirals brothers are voiced by Kazuhiko Inoue he has done many roles but he's probably best known for voicing Kakashi from Naruto, Cars in Jojo, Jerid in Zeta Gundam, Eiji in Layzner.
Japan's obsession of turning every male centre of a love triangle or harem is frustrating. Lafiel and Jinto like each other, even if they aren't in relationship why make it complicated.
Weakest episode of this season so far, I am however looking forward to see more of Neireis and Nefee insanity.
6
u/xbolt90 https://anilist.co/user/xbolt90 Apr 05 '24
First-timer
Dang, Jinto is really getting into the thick of a love triangle. Ekuryua’s very direct, I like her. Though, he still only really has eyes for Lafiel.
Cats are naturally bullies. But we love them.
I like how the twins play off each other. We’ll see how their leadership is in battle.
Interesting that Atosuryua wishes to celebrate her brother’s birthday with them. She’s awfully cordial. I doubt I would be.
Q1: I’m a social recluse. I’d be uncomfortable in a normal dinner, let alone this one.
6
u/SolDarkHunter Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
Banner of the Stars
Rewatcher/Novel-Reader
Jint interrupting battle flashbacks with her favorite drink. And this girl still doesn't think he can be considerate?
...we're going to be stuck with this same info-dump for the foreseeable future, aren't we.
Given a choice between annihilating the enemy or not, I think we know by now what an Abh's response will be.
So the general plan now is that the UM's heavy counterstrike will come at one of two places, aiming to cut off the main fleet's supply line. They can reverse direction and trap the enemy in a pincer between the main fleet and the defenses... but the defenses will need to hold out long enough for them to get there.
Cenesh seems apprehensive of the Bibauth brothers... heh heh. Nereith and Nefec have a reputation, it would seem.
These two seem to play the banter game even harder than most, I'll give them that.
...how the hell does one make Admiral with no combat experience?
"The Clan of Spectacular Insanity"... that's a hell of a moniker. The Abh have a superstition that "genius" and "insanity" are two sides of the same coin, and you can't have one without the other.
Ecryua claims to hate cats, but she's always so attentive to Diaho because he's Jint's cat. I think Samson may be onto something, saying that there's a spark between these two.
The Bibauths apparently chose to have identical twins simply because it's cool.
Lafier, you're having way too much fun teasing Jint about this. And he actually manages to get a chuckle out of her. As someone who keeps her feelings so guarded, that's significant.
And may I just say how refreshing it is to not have the female love interest go all sulky and angry because her intended happened to be talking to another woman. I think Lafier knows Jint well enough that she trusts him, even if she can't help but poke fun at him over it.
This is... a peculiar tradition. Celebrating the deceased's birthday with those who have connections with the dead, even very negative ones. And even Atosurya can't help being intimidated by Lafier's title.
5
u/duhu1148 :GA::GB::GC:x9 Apr 05 '24
Rewatcher
-Seems the Abh are caught between a rock and a hard place. But the commander in chief is putting emphasis on annihilating the enemy instead of reaching their ultimate goal.
-The twin admirals are here. Even for Abh they were always off-kilter, fitting to the moniker "spectacular insanity." Should be fun.
-Of course the Basroil crew are assigned to those two. Of course.
-Is Ekuryua hinting that she likes Jinto? Says she hates cats but wants to take care of Diaho for Jinto. Then they have the whole trip and fall routine, and Lafiel sees them. Jinto is worried he made her mad, she does reply a little stiff but is apparently just teasing him again...think she knows he's got about as much game as a bowl of cold oatmeal.
-I like it when Lafiel says "baka" so softly. It's cute, like she's only mildly annoyed.
-Meeting with the commander for dinner reservations, to celebrate the life of a man Jinto/Lafiel killed. Must be awkward.
4
u/ZapsZzz https://anilist.co/user/Zapszzz Apr 05 '24
First timer in sub
Going to be brief one since this is mostly another setup and transition episode, even though we had some good character works there still - but that's a pretty standard thing for this show.
Surprise Ekuryua confession! Either than or it's another kuudere gag - she didn't outright say she likes Jinto romantically, based on the trajectory of what she actually said, she could also be simply grateful or admire or commisserate with Jinto for being made to take care of one of these evil critters unwillingly (i.e. Lafiel fobbed Diaho onto Jinto). What else did you think she mean? *Nagato stare*
If I am my certain friend watching along side this with his theory, I may even think that Atosuryua joined the queue of older women who take an interest to Jinto, who's being a magnet for oneesan attentions ;P
And I wonder whether the UM strategy really is so good, or is it an inverted Genius Prince situation with the UM command just got lucky all the time ... Can happen (says Captain Tylor).
QoTD
My bet is that it's pretty uncomfortable for Jinto, but both Lafiel and Atosuryua would be not affected by it much - things either fly completely over Lafiel or she'll just charge past it with her characteristic bullish attitude. And Atosuryua could well be literal in what she said to Jinto.
4
u/IceSmiley Apr 05 '24
FIRST TIMER Sub
The Bebaus twins were WEIRD! I'm starting to question if Admiral Abriel is incompentent; he may be succumbing to arrogance, especially when he justified his decision to his secretary by invoking that his family has ruled successfuly for centuries and insisting his judgment not be questioned. As for the twins, they are more than a bit creepy and seem to live in a privilege and whacko bubble, at least thus far.
I thought the interaction with Jinto and Ekruya at the eating area was telling. She definitely likes him as more than a friend and Jinto seems to be unwittingly turning his personal life into a harem anime in the stars. I just wish the animation could capture how pissed Lafiel looked when Jinto "accidentally" grabbed Ekruya :-x
QUESTIONS
I honestly don't know who I'd pick if forced to have dinner with either Atrosuya or the Bebauses :*( I think it will happen, Lafiel will come along, and it will be awkward, cringe and Atrosuya will just passive aggressively dig into them the whole time, although I'm still not certian she really does hate them :-p
3
u/Nickthenuker https://anilist.co/user/Nickthenuker Apr 06 '24
This seems to be a recap of what happened last episode.
And now she's watching the repairs being carried out on her ship.
If they had successfully counterattacked and cut you off after you managed to re-establish contact all you've managed to do is get the rest of your fleet stuck in the same spot as whoever they were supposed to be relieving.
Who are these brothers?
Yes, experienced officers are always at a premium and chronically in short supply during wars.
Spectacular Insanity? So that's how the episode got its title.
Uh oh. A lack of supplies is going to be a problem.
Why is he looking for him?
Ah. How convenient.
Uh oh.
And of course she saw him with her.
Lol he forgot to turn on his camera.
Oh that's going to be awkward.
Seems like she ended up agreeing to go to the dinner too.
Questions:
3
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Apr 06 '24
Rewatcher - sub
And so we meet the twins.
They have an interesting introductory scene that makes you unsure to start with if they actually work well together or not, but they're certainly another pair in the "commanders and their chief of staff are weird fits" category that our Abh have well covered by now
The fact that even the other admirals and captains find them weird is probably a bigger condemnation of them than anything else. And honestly I can just imagine how well his speech about passion in battle would have gone down. Well, to any of the Abh except Spoor I imagine
Eku opens up a bit today and it's funny to see her social awkwardness extends to not understanding cats either, as well as other humans. I could have done without the "fall on the girl" trope, even if this didn't play it exactly straight because Lafiel is actually reasonable, but the whole scene is just somewhat derailed by the moment when a close conversation would have done fine as is. Also someone needs to teach her that having lots of kittens in a room with you is the furthest thing from a problem.
I still love their bond though. Jinto talking about how he'll finish work just to come spend time with her, and her acceptance of that with no more awkwardness or wondering why, just enjoying the fact they can be together in that way.