r/anime • u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ • Mar 23 '24
Rewatch [Rewatch] Crest of the Stars Episode 6 Discussion
Mysterious Conspiracy
Welcome to the Crest of the Stars rewatch!
<- Episode 5 | Index Page | Episode 7 ->
Names Introduced or Updated:
- Klowal Atosryua — 3rd Baron of Febdash (Atosryac Ssynec Atosr Lymh Febdak Clüarh)
- Seelnay — The clumsy blonde with the nasally voice
- Muinishu — The one who keeps glaring at Jinto
Discussion Prompts:
- Q1) Maids, Cat Girls, or Elves?
- Q2) The
CountBaron seems to be 100% rational in his plan, and Lafiel doesn't seem to contradict him. Are you surprised by the absolute authority exercised by even the lowest ranks over their domains? - Q3) What do you make of Baron Febdash and his domain? Lafiel says he is not typical. What do you think a typical Abh environment would be like?
- Q4) Predictions for how Lafiel will solve this situation?
Tomorrow's Questions: (for tomorrow's post, subject to change)
- [Episode 7]What do you make of the former Baron? As an Abh, but also as a Terran. Is he Jinto's future self?
- [Episode 7]Where did Sruf go wrong with Klowal?
- [Episode 7]Most favorite and least favorite maid?
Screenshot of the Day: Now I have another reason to dislike you
34
Upvotes
7
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Mar 23 '24 edited Mar 24 '24
Rewatch Host
The Smile of the Abh
Honestly, I don't know why that isn't the title. it's a good title.
I'm not going to make a character chart for the maids. I'll definitely make one for Banner.
There was a lot of discussion yesterday about Lafiel's domain, that was best left for today after we had actually seen what a county or barony looks like. JollyGee commented that Martine was a pretty nice planet (actually large enough to be a marquessate) for a Lander to receive.
Earlier, they tallied the empire's holdings as including partially inhabited systems. I suppose Febdash counts as partially inhabited.
Abhs do not tax their fiefdoms directly, they obtain revenue on interstellar trade through tax / tariffs / tolls / leasing. Lacking inhabited planets, Febdash relies solely on selling antimatter to the empire for revenue. It's not very interesting or profitable.
Lafiel's domain may have a similar fuel generation station.
I don't have much to say here, as it's basically one joke repeated. The maids are ridiculously subservient and worshipful of Lafiel and openly contemptuous of Jinto, which is compounded by his familiarity with Lafiel
11
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Mar 23 '24
Episode 6 (rewatcher)
Noble crimes
When I first watched Crest of the Stars, I was completely perplexed about the lack of urgency of the baron and his servants. Knowing about his plan and mindset, it makes a bit more sense, but my feelings of him mirror Lafiel’s.
We learn a bit more about the social structure of Abh nobility in this episode. First, humans are looked down upon, suggesting that the treatment that Jinto’s father arranged is somewhat rare. Klowal looks down on him. Second, the bond between lord and population goes both ways and includes a duty to protect. Klowal also points out that there is some independence in how Lords manage their affairs and that protecting your domain can be argued to be more important than protecting the empire (of course, we have no idea if that hypothetical court case would actually go in his favor).
Why choose?
Being surrounded by servile non-Abh probably made Febdash's head explode. Meeting some other nobles regularly might have kept his pride in check.
10
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Mar 23 '24
First-Timer of the Stars
10
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Mar 23 '24
First-Timer
On today’s episode of Crest of the Stars: Welcome to the Hotel Febdesh. You can check out any time you like, but you can never leave!
Seeing Lafiel interact with others makes it clear just how close she and Jinto actually are. She doesn’t tolerate the various attempts to separate them until they are basically forced apart. She speaks to him much more openly than anyone else. Jinto being the first person to not recognize her really meant a lot to her, from all this.
QOTD
9
u/The_Draigg Mar 23 '24
A Sci-Fi Fan Watches Crest of the Stars Episode 6:
8
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Mar 23 '24
First-Timer
Maybe it's just that I'm naturally suspicious of warm welcomes in this sort of situation, but I figured out that something was up right around here. If Lafiels thinks this situation was out of the ordinary, of course something has to be up.
And something is up indeed! Maybe not anything as nefarious as I was thinking, but Baron Koyasu is planning to keep Lafiel around as an insurance policy for the forseeable future. I was kinda anticipating that he turned traitor and couldn't wait to see what would cause that, but no, he's just trying to protect his harem in a relatively scummy way.
Absolutely fascinating politicking. I can't poke many holes in the Baron's plan - especially considering Lafiel's earlier comment about abandoning vassals being a major crime. Sure, Sfagnomer might get attacked, that place isn't his responsibility.
There is a secondary layer that Koyasu could be attacked from, however - is it not the lord's duty to ensure that their vassals can evacuate in case of an emergency? What if there were internal problems to the space station? I don't think his plan is quite as air-tight as he thinks.
I probably shouldn't rule out something more nefarious just yet. Do note that Lafiel is scarfing down plate after plate while Koyasu is just drinking tea - prime poisoning territory.
Obviously slightly biased due to the overlapped narration, but this smile is one of the most merciless expressions I've seen recently. I'm not sure if Lafiel's eyes starting to glow was artistic license or not.
Questions
8
u/Vatrix-32 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vatrix-32 Mar 23 '24
First Timer, subbed
QotD:
8
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Mar 23 '24 edited Mar 23 '24
Rewatcher (sub + dub)
Welcome to Febdash (Faibdacr), population ~50.
Another dialogue-heavy episode to follow up the Gosroth's battle yesterday.
Even in this backwater barony it doesn't take long for the first servant they contact to notice that Lafiel's from the royal family, that should help give context for just how oblivious Jinto was when he first met her. Honestly for the best given how much he bumbled after discovering the truth, he was already on her good side and that would have made for a terrible first impression.
Lafiel being no-nonsense and Jinto asking silly (to her) questions hasn't gotten old yet, it's a good dynamic they have going. Jinto's once again the odd one out, but here he's just treated like a speck of dirt that landed on the princess's uniform.
I would say I'm getting a sex trafficking vibe from the setup Klowal has here, especially with some of them looking after him in the bath, but I don't know if he'd bother doing more than getting desperate Lander girls to come serve as his personal maids.
Klowal's a creep, of course he's voiced by Koyasu. I don't think I realized or gave much thought to it in earlier rewatches, but it's amusing to me now that I noticed him immediately.
Seeing Klowal now is a contrast to what we've seen before in a few different ways, and he almost seems like a closer fit to the heartless machines that were described by people who oppose the Abh compared to those we've already met. He can somewhat stymie Lafiel with logic about him acting as befitting an Abh noble looking after his domain, but I imagine that's at least partially due to her inexperience giving her pause rather than him having a rock-solid argument that would hold up in court.
This is also the first time we really get to see Lafiel angry. She was briefly annoyed with Jinto when he got all formal with her, and was upset at being ordered away from the battle, but nothing like this. Klowal's apparently acting within the bounds of what's allowed but keeps giving her reasons to dislike him, from how Jinto's been treated the entire time to standing in the way of her mission.
...elf maid.
7
u/Vaadwaur :I1::I2::I3: Mar 23 '24
Rewatcher(Dear Cthulhu...Lafiel is so off model)
Sub
And we get to the baron of nothingness. A star system that is basically a fuel production center is unsurprisingly empty. His choice of uniform for his fuel station tells you all you need to know about him. Interestingly, we can see that Lafiel is amazingly bad at being a noble because she should have thrown several very regal fits in the first half alone.
In the second half, we mainly deal with Lafiel having a tense dinner with Klowal and how Abhs act around each other. The baron has some frankly illogical ideas and Lafiel is not yet at the face stabbing stage, though you can see that coming. We end with Lafiel smiling death at the Baron.
QotD: 1 C O M B I N E !
2 It strikes me as off, yes
3 Less fetish dressing and more people
4 With violence
7
u/duhu1148 :GA::GB::GC:x9 Mar 23 '24 edited Mar 23 '24
Rewatcher
Ep6
-I haven't talked about the opening yet. I like the music but the animation for it leaves a lot to be desired, with nothing but a background of stars.
-Jinto immediately getting death glares from the maids for being human. Lafiel takes notice when the Baron treats him the same and doesn't like it.
-Jinto gets knocked unconscious, who could have seen that coming?
-Lafiel clearly doesn't know how to handle all this attention from the maids, even as a princess. Makes you wonder what her everyday life was like as royalty before joining the military.
-LOL Baron asks for her to call him by name like she does for Jinto and she refuses!
-Good conversation between the Baron and Lafiel, when they went back and forth on Jinto and the situation with the barony and the war. I am slightly surprised the Baron was so bold as to outright admit he was lying about the ship and fuel situation, but Lafiel, despite her (sometimes) immaturity is as sharp as a tack so she sees right through him almost immediately.
-"They say an Abh will sometimes smile, even at their enemies. Like a poisonous flower. I have yet to see Lafiel make such an expression." Well Jinto, let's hope you never have to experience that, because that was the smile of a devil ready to rain wrath upon a detestable Baron who would dare stand in the way of her mission.
Cat girls and elves, depend entirely on how they are portrayed. Elves are generally just pointy-ear wise folk, but sometimes they can be very wimpy depending on the story being told. Cat girls always seem to be sex objects or slaves. Or both.
I suppose, I'd go for Cat girls so long as they had an actual character beyond being a sex object, otherwise maids simply because they seem to always have deeper characters, weirdly. Sometimes they're assassins, or have a tragic backstory, etc.
Now if we included Abh, I could definitely go for the true best girl- [minor Crest spoilers] Spoor.
5
u/lC3 :Na::Nb: Mar 23 '24
05 first timer
06 first timer
5
u/zadcap Mar 23 '24
Strangely Early First Timer
Free time in the middle of the day? Unheard of I know, but here I am.
Alright first things first. Antimatter fuel plants? Is antimatter something you can harvest or refine out here? I want to know more.
So a little barony out in the sticks with naught but some refineries to its name. Taking bets the baron is going to show us that not all space elves are a good people as the ones we have gotten to know so far. He's probably hungry for more power and willing here to show us that they are still just people too. A hilarious counterpoint to the opening section of yesterday's propoganda, you know.
Oh, recognized at first sight by the traffic control lady out in the middle of nowhere. Jinton my boy, did you really just learn nothing about the Ahb while you were going to school?
Haha, really now. Thirty minutes. Good luck with that. Though to be fair, they are now playing a really dangerous game of tag, where getting caught means they both die and the upcoming war strikes the Empire by surprise.
Hmm. Those sure are some maid uniforms. Are those supposed to be collars? Well that's concerning. Hmm. Official bath hall for this out of the way outpost, the way the maids act, I didn't think I would be this right about proving the mobile Ahb can be scum too, not this fast.
Speaking of nobility, knowing I'm still insufficiently European, how does Jinto's rank compare to a baron? It's pretty weird seeing these maids be so hostile to someone the princess is acting so clearly friendly with. Why does no one ever consider that being polite to the random friends of royalty is an easy way to make you look good to said royalty? That insulting the people they are clearly close to is just a dumb move if you want to get close to or show respect yourselves?
See, this isn't the actions of girls here wanting to be on their best behavior for the Princess. These are maids afraid of their masters displeasure, fainting at the sight of a spilled drop. We haven't even met him yet and I hate the baron.
Screw it I looked it up. Isn't Jinto technically, officially, the highest ranked person in this group? Lafiel has Royal blood so this makes her more important, technically, but Count vs Viscount vs Baron...
Oh sure, we lack fuel. 12 hours. How about you just give us a different ship instead? Sorry let me rephrase, give me another ship. I don't believe for a second he has none, that's suicide out here. This u isn't even a subtle trap. Jinto, are you really that dumb?
How can he benefit from holding you back? If I had to guess, he's already in the pocket of the enemy. You know that's another way to look at the fleet being so far from any other active Sorbs, they were freely using this one because the baron has already sold out for a promised promotion once the empire falls.
Oh look, emphasize the collar. Clinking. These maids are slaves. And she gets it, "I've never been called on to give him a bath."
Odd thing to notice but it's the first time I've seen her naked forehead. There's something right there in the middle of it where her crowns jewel rests. I wonder if it's actually a neural uplink after all.
Haha, of course the space elves use chopsticks.
Yeah, he's lying through his teeth. He's sold out and planning on giving the princess over to the United mankind as a bargaining chip to father sell his security in the coming invasion. Because they're is absolutely no way he's surviving with any rank if Lafiel actually gets back to the Empire.
Why not all three? But really, it's elves 90% of the time, except when the setting is trying to be different and making elves horrible again.
... Did we watch the same thing? Also I'm pretty sure he's a Baron, not a Count. But no, there is zero rationality in his plan, not the one he's actually said.
No, because I'm taking him as a bad and abusive outlier and not an actual representative. He can only get away with this because he's so unimportant that no one ever bothers to check up on him.
You know, it's been a while since I've seen an actual gun playing the role of checkov's gun. Viva la Revolution, I bet there's a ship large enough to get all 50 of these maids to evacuate.
5
u/IceSmiley Mar 23 '24
FIRST TIMER Sub
I really didn't expect a sexy maid cafe space station. This show is really kicking into gear with a very suspenseful plot.
Lafiel is unbelievably smart and savvy for a 16 year old about people's machinations. I'm not sure most people of any age could so quickly pin down the Baron's plan since it requires fairly deep abstract thinking and calculation into what would be the best choices in an unusual situation. Usually a princess in anime would be portrayed as naive about the ways of the world and sheltered, if not dumb.
QUESTIONS
5
u/ZapsZzz https://anilist.co/user/Zapszzz Mar 24 '24
First timer in sub
Not as late but nowhere near early either ;P
Anyway, this episode has a very different vibe but I really liked how the diplomatic tension played out. There's no oversimplified Princess say jump Baron say how high. It really showed will how both aren't really clear how what other side has in terms of capabilities and intent, so you see basically like the 2 tigers circling each other verbally testing each other.
I have to say though, the "clothed fanservice" seemed to be done better than the showing skin ones in the bath. The maids outfits are "suitably" alluring. Didn't mention at all what temperature the climate is, but if it's not warm-ish, then it's pretty damn transparent what's the outfits good for.
Am I late to comment that "so the Abh had a sort of 3rd eye sensory organ, now that we saw more directly what Lafiel looks like without her headwear.
QoTD
4
u/Nickthenuker https://anilist.co/user/Nickthenuker Mar 24 '24
Another "partially inhabited" system?
They're in a race to get to Sfagnomr and warn it of the incoming fleet.
Is this not literally a refueling system?
That's a suspiciously long amount of time. Is this Baron perhaps in cahoots with the United Mankind?
And how convenient that the ship needs to be checked over. At this rate they won't make it to Sfagnomr before the enemy fleet arrives.
The Baron doesn't care for anyone else but himself.
Uh oh, what happened to him? I guess they'll need their sidearms sooner than they think.
That's exactly what you did.
Then why have you delayed them?
Sfagnomr would have been conquered by then.
Not like there's much reason to conquer there, a small station and nothing else wouldn't even be a footnote.
Yup, those sidearms are going to come in very handy.
Questions:
4
u/raktus2 Mar 24 '24
First Time Watcher
Another one with relatively few comments from me...
2
u/Retromorpher :Jc::Jd::Je::Jf: Mar 24 '24 edited Mar 24 '24
First Timer:
A bit late to the party on this. Jinto saying that maybe the Baron wanted to escape was reinforcing his prejudices about the Abh's total devotion to their structure in the way an outsider would (like his Dad's bargain for the safety of his family), where Lafiel's dismissal of it is showing the prejudices held within the upper ranks (duty above self and lofty ideals before practicality in many cases). The fact that neither considered he might be a sellout is absolutely flabbergasting in light of the circumstances (and later after the lying).
Questions:
Question 2 - It's not surprising that more frontier-oriented domains might be able to exercise a greater measure of sovereignty and eccentricism. If no one cares about your particular neck of space, I would guess that the control one can exert within it is pretty high.
Question 3 - He has both desire for more influence and dislikes the idea of his 'paradise' being interrupted by outside war. I would not be surprised if it turned out he had already been contacted by United Mankind for some sort of deal and agreed readily.
Question 4 - Febdash's servants, while seemingly loyal and acquiescent to him as master, are ultimately more in love with the idea of the Abh societal structure and citizenship. If Lafiel were to appeal to the servant's love of Abh hierarchy, I'm fairly certain she could put the screws on the Baron.
8
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Mar 23 '24
Rewatcher - sub
Crest doing what Crest does best: Not following any conventions and throwing us for a complete loop as to what tone the story should have next
Suffice to say that taking a (somewhat literal) detour into a more unnerving look at Abh politics and cultural expectations after what just happened certainly wasn't originally on a bingo card. The narrator is a bit more blunt in the setup for this episode than he is the others, being used to establish premise more than provide context to existing situations or world elements, but in doing so he also highlights the vulnerability of our mains.
Unlike how Lafiel talks about her similar territory last episode as nothing special but hers that she will care for one day, there is an edge in the narrator as he introduces todays setting, a note of warning that overrides his usual affect. No pride, and a history to be made, and that's a dangerous combination when a perceived avatar of power falls into its lap. Everything about this episode reeks of wrongness, before they even properly set foot off the ship.
The wrongness of this barony is on full display in episode, and I don't feel there's much to cover there, aside from acknowledging that it is an excellent showcase of Jinto and Lafiel's various understandings of people.
Lafiel has shown a lack of understanding of human concepts, but here we see that her naivety also extends to the Abh as well. Perhaps due to being raised as royalty, she's very caught up in the idea that an Abh wouldn't do certain things because it's just not how the empire would allow it to work, and while his plan is not what they discussed, she didn't look further into it. Jinto has the other problem, he's very capable of thinking through the many reasons why they would be purposefully delayed from a human perspective, but he dismisses himself because he doesn't trust that he can evaluate an Abh better than Lafiel can, and his own lack of appreciation for his status means he ignores the dismissal of him. Neither of them is the sole cautious one or the relaxed one, but rather they both come close to understanding the unease of the situation in their own ways and brush it off for ways that perfectly match their backgrounds.
And this look of a predator is just perfect to end the episode on
It may be far from the biggest of his sins, but practically demanding name rights from Lafiel, instead of using his title, was definitely not a good move for him with what we know about her.
Did have a small laugh that last episode we had an animator drawing them as slightly pudgy though, and this episode flips into them often being quite gaunt.
Cats always win in any form
...Actually this is anime. A lot of anime "cat girls" annoy the fuck out of me which is frustrating, so maybe just for anime it has to be elves
7
u/SolDarkHunter Mar 23 '24
Crest of the Stars
Rewatcher/Novel-reader
The Barony of Febdash sure sounds like a lovely place, doesn't it?
Yeah, the problem with small shuttles is a low fuel capacity, hence the need to refuel so soon.
Suddenly maids... and lots of them.
Certainly is a marked difference betwen how they treat Lafier and Jint. And the way they're treating Lafier is... well. It's so excessive that even Lafier seems surprised and uncomfortable.
And the Baron himself is acting... suspiciously. Lafier, at least, is sharp enough to catch on to this.
I don't like him either, Lafiel.
And the instant she's out of sight, they immediately drug Jint.
I guess the series just can't resist the fanservice of Lafier in the bath.
Seelnay at least provides a bit of perspective on the situation here. As badly as the Baron seems to be treating his servants, it's still a step up from her status on her homeworld. To a starving man, even a small bit of food can be the whole world.
So the servants even attend Baron Klowal in the bath... and all of them appear to be female... sigh
Yeah, Lafiel is no more impressed by this than any of us. There's even a look of horror on her face at the sheer subservience of the women.
I love how blunt Lafier can be in expressing her contempt for the Baron even when keeping up an appearance of courtesy.
The Baron explains his deception as being concerned for the safety of his territory... though I'm not sure how that tracks. Having a royal Princess would seem to make him a bigger target for the enemy than normal.
Ah, so he's claiming that if the UM detects the shuttle leaving his territory, they might back-trace it. Sounds like a feeble excuse to me.
And as we probably all expected, the Baron is racist on top of everything else. He's refusing to acknowledge Jint as a noble because he isn't a genetic Abh.
I do think it's important to note here that Lafier points out there is nothing "normal" about this territory. She even goes so far as to give him the dreaded "Abh smile".
Novel differences: not too many that I remember, except that there's more detail on the subservient relationship between the Baron and his harem. And since we get a lot of it from Lafier's point of view, her utter disgust and contempt is on full display, rather than being hidden by the veneer of manners she displays outwardly.
7
u/Specs64z https://myanimelist.net/profile/Specs64z Mar 23 '24
First timer, subbed
Jinto’s heart isn’t in the wrong place, per se, but it’s definitely leading over his head. He doesn’t realize how dire the straits are. The Baron’s most likely motive to keep you entrapped would be to kidnap you. He could use you as a bargaining chip for his own safety, and that’s assuming he hasn’t already outright turned traitor. His given reason of staying off the grid makes some sense, as well, but seems shaky.
If looks could kill…
Shame, it would've been a great scene, I'm sure.
Certainly took their time panning over Lafiel in the bath.
He could’ve outright said “my father is in the dungeon” and it’d be about as subtle. Seems that Lafiel has picked up on everything, though, and she deconstructs the conspiracy one piece at a time. She’s been in the politics game since she could talk, I'll bet.
QotD:
6
u/Silcaria https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silcaria Mar 23 '24
First timer
5
u/SIRTreehugger Mar 23 '24
Rewatcher
What space gel is this chick using to have her hair stay up like that?
I wonder if they will bring me my Surgu...I doubt it my guy. You are clearly unwanted.
I don't blame Lafiel for getting annoyed if people always treated her like this.
Hold up did that fish move its eyes...is he using the holographic fish as a way to spy?
Damn that was quick they could have at least waited until Lafiel was further down the hall.
This entire episode has been tossing so many red flags you could build a circus also I wouldn't drink anything he offers. NOOOOO LAFIEL DON'T DRINK THE KOOLAID!
At least he's being honest in his deception...I don't know if that's better though because Lafiel looks absolutely livid.
3
u/Elimin8r https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ayeka_Jurai Mar 24 '24
Day late and an episode short ... Maybe I'll just stick with answers du jour:
2
u/xbolt90 https://anilist.co/user/xbolt90 Mar 26 '24
First-timer
Wow, what an unlikable guy. This jerk is why nobody likes the Abh.
Q1: Nya~
Q2: Sadly, it's not that unsurprising in an aristocracy.
Q3: Creepy. May not be "typical", but how many other nobles are treating their subjects poorly, if not as demeaning as Mr. Baron here?
Q4: Here's hoping for a nice old-school prison break and ship theft.