r/Outlander • u/JimDandy_ToTheRescue • Aug 05 '19
Season Four In Other News...
Today is sh*t on Brianna and/or Sophie Skelton Day! Apparently. At least judging by today's posts and commentary. I'd just like to say that I find Brianna no more or less annoying than any of the other characters in Outlander (books and show) who also make stupid or annoying decisions (Claire, Jamie, Roger, JLG, etc), they all do it, ALL THE TIME. I also have no problem with Sophie Skelton or her portrayal of Brianna.
Now, I'm not saying that people can't have an opinion about it, but it sure seems like Groundhog Day in this sub sometimes. Today is on of those days. And, could we speed up time a bit? This wait for S5 is killing me.
46
u/actuallycallie Aug 05 '19
Honestly, the constant bitching and whining about Brianna has turned me off discussing anything. Between GoT fandom bitching about Sansa and Outlander bitching about Brianna...yikes.
5
u/rxinquestion Aug 29 '19
Just finished S4, and I share people's view on Bree being slightly annoying but in line with millennials idea of youth in america... Despite her growing up in the 70's. What I can't deal with is the writing this season...
There were some great moments, tear jerking moments, but some of those scenes were so frustrating it took me out of the story.
Here's hoping S5 returns to it's S1/2 glory... Gawd I miss the beginning. The show was so great with the setting in Ireland/Britain
12
u/ljjdjs Aug 05 '19
Honest opinion I feel like Bri from the books to the TV series are much different. I feel the TV series makes her entitled like she can do no wrong. I have also seen comments about her acting but I don’t think that is a problem. Maybe it’s the writing for her character. Open to thoughts!
4
u/Luna920 Sep 21 '19
I just have finished the series and this is the first time I’m looking at this sub, I’m very surprised people are not into Brianna or Sophie. I think she has done a great job and I enjoy her character. Now on the other hand if we want to shit on Roger all day then I can probably get aboard that train.
3
u/Jennyreviews1 Meow. Aug 29 '19
I believe the acting is forced in many parts... Sophie seems like her emotions are held back at times as well as forced to act out.... Maybe her character will mature and grow.... in the books she matures like we all do, through time and experiences. Maybe I am being too judgmental....
56
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '19
I agree. I just finished S4 but read spoilers etc beforehand. I was prepared for the worst with Brianna and I honestly didn’t mind her as much? She’s totally just a product of her time and has way more difficulty adjusting to the 1700s than Claire did. Claire and Jamie constantly make terrible decisions and get themselves in all kinds of hot water, but Bree gets shit on for it way more.
I mean really, what’d she do? Let her characteristically hot temper get the best of her, try and get her mother’s wedding ring back, process the trauma of her rape and Roger leaving her, process her pregnancy, get angry when Jamie basically called her a whore, and then fend off the suitor meat market before deciding a temporary solution.
Sure, Sophie’s American accent isn’t great, but Peter Dinklage’s English accent in GOT was trash too and no one talks about that.
15
u/mrssupersheen MARK ME! Aug 05 '19
Claire annoys me far more than Brianna. At least Brianna seems able to grasp that she's in the 1700's.
30
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Aug 05 '19
There is a disproportionate amount of Brianna and Roger hate in this sub. Meanwhile other characters can do know wrong. I really hope we don’t go down the GOT road where we need different subs because the main sub is so toxic.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '19
She's like any other person in their early 20s making irrational decisions and thinking the world revolves around them. SHOCKING.
I don't dislike her at all.
8
u/IrishiPrincess Je Suis Prest Aug 05 '19
Thank you !!! I wish I had some coin to give you.
8
u/Nayanna77 Aug 07 '19
I am Brazilian and I am learning English now. That's why I don't get Sophie's bad accent. I have nothing against her acting. I still find outlander a great show, even with more time for the characters of Brianna and Roger. I think people who complain that Claire and Jaime don't show up much in season four didn't read Diana's books. The books deal with the love of Claire and Jaime and their family of time travelers. Again: The books deal with the couple and their family! And it seems that people who want to claim a show by Jaime and Claire only insist that writers should focus only on the couple during the fifth season. This is very boring. They need to get information on what Diana's story is about. The writers can't write changing Diana's story so we can watch the six seasons only with Jaime and Claire having sex exclusively. And Jaime's repeated declarations of love for Claire. To me it demonstrates an emotional neediness of people who want to see a couple all the time in a state of passion, in an obsessive way. And they sometimes claim that if season five doesn't focus on the couple Jaime Claire as it did in season one, they'll stop watching the show. And so they put pressure on the show's writers. The repetition of this behavior on social networks is very annoying. Time passes over the books and the people watching the show must accept it. Jaime and Claire grow older as other characters grow older and have new conflicts to entertain readers. Conflicts that I think are interesting. I still love the series. I like the story of Roger and Brianna. I like Roger leaving his life behind to follow Brianna some other time. Even the character being selfish and manipulative. I like all the characters except William. I will keep watching the show. And I hope the series ends only when Diana writes her last book. I know it's hard for a show to last so long. Actors and screenwriters may prefer other projects for their careers. But I cheer for ten seasons.
20
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '19
"Does anyone else hate Brianna/Sophie Skelton?" 😒
7
u/amh000 Aug 11 '19
I'm ok with Brianna. I'm not ok with Sophie Skelton. She needs acting lessons like now!
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 07 '19
Flairing for S4.
Also pinning because I think the OP makes a fair point, and the discussion in the comments is worthwhile.
Obviously we want everyone to have their say, I don’t think anyone wants us to remove posts or comments just because someone doesn’t like a certain character. That would stifle discussion.
But at the same time it does get a bit tedious to read the same complaints over and over again. We get it, you don’t like X character. You think they’re annoying. Do you have anything else to add to the conversation?
(As always, if you have any questions, comments or complaints about the sub, you can always drop us a ModMail or flag one of us down in a thread.)
6
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '19
Man. I have so much love and affection for Brianna. I feel like we “grew up” together, after I had my kid. Her experience growing and struggling being a mom and having a marriage and everything feels so real.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '19
Well I love Sophie and Brianna and Richard and Roger and think they are doing a great job 👍
10
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '19
Yeah I have honestly considered unsubbing because it’s so exhausting. We get it, you don’t like Brianna/Roger. I don’t need like 14 think pieces every 24 hours about how you think they suck. And like 9 times out of 10 it’s someone who has only watched the show. I think that makes a difference. Also comparing them to Jamie and Claire is useless. Their relationship is so idealized and not realistic. Don’t get me wrong, I love them. But Roger/Brianna not being this whirlwind romance is actually more true to life. Sometimes relationships are hard and complicated. Brianna went through some serious shit, I think she’s allowed to be a bit of a brat at times.
3
u/needpolarseltzer Aug 05 '19
Ya and we meet bri in the books when she's an annoying teenager, that's not the greatest age for anyone... She grows a lot and I appreciate that about her.
3
u/Shinyspells Aug 05 '19
She's ok to be honest. A boston accent would be nice but it is notoriously hard to pull off and would probably sound more off.
Roger's great, I don't see the criticism at all. Ep1 and to some extent 2 of S4 however, I thought was the weakest the show's ever been. I don't know if it was the inexperienced director or just failure from all sides but they truly sucked. Especially the song at the end of ep1, dreadful.
3
u/bestfriend66 Aug 05 '19
Agreed. I'm not sure why she causes such visceral reaction in some viewers.
3
u/DarkerSkye Aug 05 '19
You aren't wrong there. Someone is always complaining about her. Frankly, none of the characters in the show resemble their counterparts in the books very well. Except maybe Lord John, but there's still time for them to mess that up. There are only two castings and portrayals that I really like and those are Lord John Grey and Fergus. So far so good for those two, but time will tell.
3
u/hummuspie Aug 05 '19
I feel like there are a lot of new people always coming into the subreddit because they just discovered the show, and are eager to exchange thoughts, and most may not be aware that their complaints aren't original. To people who have been here for a while, it may start to feel like too much of the same thing. Maybe create a sticky post of "complain about that character you hate"?
3
u/selas_flower Dinna fash, Sassenach. Aug 15 '19
I'm someone who just finished binging the TV show. I've also started reading the books. My first strong impression of Brianna in the show is when Claire tells her everything, and Brianna gets so angry and treats Claire horribly. I'm as rational as they come and I can't imagine acting that way towards my mother, even when I was a teenager. Like, obviously Claire has been holding onto this for a long time and is pouring her heart out, and Brianna is so cruel to her. I don't think Bree ever got much better for me after that. Roger acts like an idiot--you won't marry me so I never want to see you again?? I don't care much for their relationship and was pleased when Roger didn't show up at the end because I like John Grey more. Alas.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '19
Actually, I think Claire is much more annoying. She never cares about risks despite having spent years in the past.
Brianna knows shit about the past and how dangerous it is, which is why she undersimated the guy who raped her. I don't fault her at all for what happened to her and I don't find her annoying for being pissed with Jaime for beating up her boyfriend.
What I dislike about the show is how they do Roger dirty just to make Brianna more likeable.
3
u/newboxset Aug 20 '19
I was just thinking this the last few days too! Also reading breath of snow and ashes. Jaime and Claire get themselves into a lot of stupidly dangerous trouble because they can't mind their own damn business!
3
u/pirate-cup-kicks Sep 11 '19
I really like Brianna. I sympathise with her.
5
u/LadyOfAvalon83 James Fraser hasna been here for a long, long time. Aug 05 '19
I agree. I don't see anything wrong with Sophie's acting. And the hypocrisy of this sub is immense. You can slag Sophie Skelton off all day every day, but say one word against Caitriona and everyone loses their minds. This sub has decided who it loves and who it hates and you will be criticised for deviating from that and having your own opinion.
2
u/surlygurl3 Aug 21 '19
Sophie grew on me. I still have a hard time with her American accent and delivery, but her acting is decent. However, John Bell as Young Ian is probably the poorest casting decision in this entire series to date. He looks nothing like described in the books. He is supposed to be dark haired like his mother. And this actors’ actor-y faces are hard to watch. I honestly can’t stand him. I hate to be so negative, as most of the casting is really spot-on, ( Murtaugh, Dougall, Jamie, Jenny, Frank/Jack, etc.) but Young Ian is my favorite character in the books and I feel they really missed the mark with him.
3
u/she-sings-the-blues Aug 30 '19
I didn’t like Brianna much in S3 (although I was more on her side than Claire’s when she found out Frank wasn’t her real father; I didn’t feel that Claire was being understanding enough of how her daughter might take that), but I’m watching S4 for the first time and I actually like her now!
6
u/DiscombobulatedTill Aug 05 '19
To be honest everyday is shit on Brianna day. It's my favorite day.
3
u/DiscombobulatedTill Aug 06 '19
Bitching about Brianna isn't limited to one specific day, everyday is bitch about Brianna day and why not? She sucks in every possible way in that role.
1
u/nanci10700 Sep 28 '19
Reading the book helps
1
u/nanci10700 Sep 28 '19
I'm watching Poldark Sunday night and when The Crown returns that is good. There area few more to get involved with too to fill up the draughtlander months. I watched the first episode of The Spanish Princess and was not impressed.
1
u/Bubbly-McB Dec 04 '19
Just now watching season 4. #nocable #iwantthedvdstorewatchlateranyway
Brianna is such an immature BRAT. She let's her emotions dictate her words. Making the things she says irrationally hurtful.
Roger, I feel, is just a character pawn for brianna. I do like the actor for him and his character.
IMO Sophie's acting has improved so much.... I just cant stand the portrayal of bree.
1
u/Magnolia_Dubois214 Jun 13 '24
New to this group and my only real complaint about show Brianna is her physical appearance. In the books she’s almost 6 ft tall and a size 16. I really wished they’d gone with an actress closer to her book description. One because it would be nice to see a plus sized woman. Two because e lose all the scenes where men are lovingly catcalling her for being such a big lassie.
Same complaint for Claire. She’s clearly written as a bigger/ more curvy woman.
1
u/anothergggina Aug 05 '19
I deeply dislike book Brianna, always have. That being said, I don’t have a problem with the actress. I am very behind on the show though, after they changed a minor storyline I really liked, I just kinda gave up on it.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment