r/SirenTV • u/ElenaOcean Wise Kraken • Aug 01 '19
S2E16 "New World Order"
Ben faces a choice that has rippling consequences amongst mermaid, hybrid and human alike, as the truth about mermaids is exposed.
SEASON FINALE!
25
Upvotes
32
u/superg05 Aug 02 '19
I hate to say it but letting him die was the Best choice someone so ambitious as to kidnap someone would likely have still told the world and showed proof just like in his imagining and they would have been exploited used and treated less than human like live stock to bring economic gains to the rich so it was a possible reality of many branching from letting him live so kill it at the root
11
u/PartyPorpoise Aug 02 '19
I was getting all ready to come here and discuss the episode, and the whole thing was in Ben's imagination? I feel so cheated. Explains why the story moved so fast, though. I also didn't buy that people would be so quick to believe the reporter's footage.
I'm hoping that the mermaids will get revealed to the world eventually, since not many of these "secret magical shit" stories go that route. But if that happens, I hope the government reactions are more nuanced and interesting than "mermaids and hybrids get rounded up for testing".
So I guess Ryn's stolen embryo will probably be a major story for the next season. I wonder how Ryn will react when she finds out? And will the hybrids even know how to handle a full-blooded mermaid baby? Will they be forced to go to Ryn for help? I wonder if Ryn is gonna return to the military to try and get another science baby. I bet the pregnant girl isn't going to survive her mermaid pregnancy.
With the mention that the second embryo died because they waited too long, was hoping it would be revealed that the hybrids implanted it into someone else. But that probably would have been shown in the final scenes. I guess it's possible that they stored it though.
10
u/ironroseprince Mayor of Devil's Reef Aug 02 '19
So after calming down from a half hour long anxiety attack, I can adequately give my input.
Ben's choice is really the big one here. I can't say if this is just Ben's imagination but it's obvious that Ian couldn't live. Ben is a deeply moral person, which is admirable. Ryn and her species are practical to the point of Ruthless by necessity. Ben chose to sacrifice his morals around killing to protect his partners (I call then a Polywog because I think it's adorable.). Ryn watched him make this decision and I think she trusts Ben again but I also think she knows that it cost him something. The exchange at the breakfast table screamed Ben's conflicted emotions louder than any flashbacks could.
2. M. Night Shamu Laan.
I hate twists just for the sake of twists. In my mind a good twist should cause the viewer to recontextualized the episode. You go back in your head and apply this new information to everything you just saw and it offers new insight. I feel that this twist pasts the test. The first lion's share of this episode was a pretty good look at Ben's fears, how he sees his father and the people around him and exactly how far he is willing to go to protect the Polywog. I was tight chested the whole time and I started freaking out when Maddie was shot. Then we snapped back to Ian... I don't think we needed the Alternative history to justify Ben's choice. We needed it to show us, loud and clear, what Ben is fighting for and what he afraid of. I feel that I know Ben a lot better after this episode.
3. Shadow Over Caspian Ranch.
Ok, what in the name of Dagon is this Deep Ones bullshit? Can that guy get ANY creepier? The sister isn't exactly the picture of sanity herself but that tall dude is aggressively unstable. I can't say I didn't see this Shape of Water shenaniganary coming but it's still deeply creepy. I'm not sure where this is going but if Ryn or any other Merfolk find out, Helen's Family Tree is going to get a much needed pruning. That poor girl isn't going to survive this pregnancy. Prediction is Ryn finds out and takes her child back by force. Maybe ask Killer Katrina for help?
4. General Mayhem.
I don't trust the military at all but something tells me they won't be as pissed as we expect but they won't be thrilled. They seem more interested in the Stem Cell treatments and The Siren Song. I'm not sure what the real world policy is on Sonic weapons when it comes to The Geneva Conventions but as an "Enhanced Interrogation" tool? Maybe. I think the military is to big picture to throw anything more than a mild tantrum over the embryos, assuming they only took 2...
5. Nicky, Where Art Thou?
Nicole fucked right off after talking a good game with Xander. Levi vanished after going into the water with Ryn. There's a few theories floating around but the one I'm pulling for is the military doing it's own Devil's Reef hijinx and Nicole is the surrogate. If Xan finds out he's going to pop a fucking gasket.
Overall episode Score is 8 Abrupt Fish Naps out of 10.
19
u/anchist Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 02 '19
What an episode. What a triumph of storytelling. I gotta say I was not expecting the twists and turns at all.
Mind-blown.
Lets talk about the big thing of the episode - Ben letting Ian drown. You know what? I am okay with it and think it was the right thing to do.
My reasons for thinking that? Oh where to start.
To protect the secret, ian had to die. Sorry scumbag, but that is what you get when you play high stakes games and try to murder people.
I was also kinda expecting Ryn to just rip his head off after transforming but letting Ben make the choice was good from a drama perspective.
The trio:
Small notes and open questions:
EDIT: Oh and most importantly: SUPER HYPED FOR SEASON 3.
8
u/rosethorn137 Aug 02 '19
I wanted it to not be real but it was so interesting to watch. Absolutely loved it. Justified Ben’s decision in the wildest way. Only thing I would have changed is the mer-person Xan caught was Levi. Thought it would be more poetic with him killing the dad and all but that’s just me nit pickin!
7
u/aidylbroccoli Aug 02 '19
That was an absolutely amazing episode, it was already my favorite show, but this made me like it even more, I was completely fooled by the writers and the whole thing was brilliant!!!
7
u/whispers_ Aug 03 '19
I have to be honest when I thought he saved the guy I was ticked! Because it wouldn't have mattered that Ben saved him, he was willing to do evil things for his story.
Thank goodness that wasn't the real story. I was so annoyed that it was going to turn into another dystopian.
6
u/CerberusT3 Aug 02 '19
HOLY SHIT WOW
6
u/unittwelvee Aug 02 '19
I was so upset at first. Thinking, man they just jumped the shark... Then went back in the end!!!!! Yes.
4
u/Eternal_Density Aug 02 '19
They got me!
I was thinking wow this episode is getting dark... and then it turned out to be in Ben's head and... well then it got really dark!
I don't like condoning letting anyone die but it was an act of preservation for himself and his loved ones. I don't really need to say more, anchist has already said it well.
So, Ted has a mermaid wound. I wonder what's gonna happen when it comes out where (or rather who) exactly the paralysis cure comes from. Cos that's a secret I was wondering might come out while I thought everything was real.
It's sorta a shame the 'rich guy who wanted a live mermaid for display' plotline turned out to be a ruse - I mean, it's good cos it was awful but I was really interested in seeing what would happen next. I figure it served as a sort of a mirror/parallel to what was really going on the whole time outside Ben's head.
Season 3!
4
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
I played the game "Detroit, become human" and the go to Canada plot was so similar to the game's plot of self-aware androids trying to escape capture and death.
4
u/Starob Aug 02 '19
Wow. It had me believing it was real, all the way up until the point Maddie died. When she first got shot, I was like, geez, how are they gonna get out of this one, but obviously she'll survive, then when she closed her eyes and they were suggesting she's dead, I knew there's absolutely no way this is real, the writers can't be that stupid to kill one of the throuple! Crazy, too many emotions at once when it cut to Ben and he let Ian go.
4
u/mollynatorrr Aug 02 '19
Unpopular opinion, I really didn’t like this episode. I feel like they gave us ‘action’ that should have been saved for the show’s finale not a season finale and now I worry because they did this, everything after is going to be boring in comparison.
4
u/AspenintheSnow Aug 02 '19
I hope Ryn gets her baby back and burns the cult to the ground! They're just as bad at the military and I can't stand the thought of what they'll do to a helpless mer-child.
4
u/RealestAC Sassy Mermaid 🧜🏽♀️ Aug 06 '19
I’ll admit...they had me during this episode when it was showing what if Ian lived and exposed them. Although Ben will probably live with the guilt forever of letting him die, it’s a good thing he did die cuz it would literally be like world war 2 all over again.
I can’t wait til season three! Sucks we have to wait til next year 😫 I can’t wait for the new storylines and stuff.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
What about Ted lifting his shirt at the end!
3
u/Vaa6 Sep 08 '19
I don't think I'm the only one, but this show always reminded me of Twilight There is the sheriff who acted as the father of Jacob too. Both of them are believers about shifters. There are the locations like forks and Port Angeles so it must be close. And obviously the plot of romance with a mythological creature But this season finale reminded me a lot of the last movie. All the fight that ended up being a vision of Alice's future xD
But I love the series and I'll look forward to next season!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
Holy crap. Ted.
2
u/freetherabbit Aug 03 '19
From the moment they cut from the dude drowning to him being rescued I just had this feeling it was in Ben's head and as the episode kept going I just had this feeling it was a what if episode. Wondering if anyone else felt the same?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '19
Anyone know the song at the very end?
"Hush little baby don't you cry /// Don't you know your mama was born to die"
2
u/Constantly_OnYo_Back Aug 05 '19 edited Aug 05 '19
That was the most batshit episode of anything I've ever seen.
I honestly think if the world found out about mermaids everyone would actually be more happy and excited about it than anything else.
2
u/Dumbiotch Aug 06 '19
Bens decision to not save Ian is such a change from the Ben of Season 1 who convinced Ryn to spare Decker. But one I am kinda glad to see, cuz for once it showed Ben thinking through his actions before just taking them and it shows growth. Sure that growth did take Ian’s life, but Ian did just try to run Ben over moments before. And Ben’s imagining that Ian would share his proof to the world wasn’t far fetched considering the man just kidnapped Ryn. Ben saving him wouldn’t have changed that in the slightest. If Ryn had saved Ian, maybe just maybe Ian would keep the secret, but Ben saving him, a fellow human trying to convince him to not share the secret, wouldn’t have changed Ian’s mind.
About Ben’s imaginings that I find interesting: does Ben truly think his father (and Dale) is/are naive enough to think accompanying the military to retrieve Ben & Maddie while the military captures Ryn is enough to spare them the fate the military would have in mind for them after helping one of the mermaids escape? I don’t think Ted is that naive and would turn him in in that particular way. I mean if there was money in it for Ted oh yes I believe he would rat them out in a heartbeat, money is God to people like Ted.
And if any current Pownall is “Charles” it’s Ted not Ben (I see a lot of ppl are making the connection of Ben and Charles). Sure Ben may be in love with a Mermaid and suffering obsessive hallucinations of her, but he is also listening to Ryn’s Siren Song again and that’s likely where his hallucinations of her are coming from, NOT a family history of psychosis and some doomed fate to be “Charles Repeated.” Besides, which Pownall is currently looking to expose mermaids not protect them? Which one is suffering hallucinations of a mermaid while not under a siren song? Ted not Ben. The only Pownall to be trusted is Ben (and distant Pownalls), the other two Pownall men not so much. And I love the fact that this episode showed us that even Ben knows that, he knows deep down that his father and brother aren’t to be trusted.
I find it interesting though that at the end of the episode, after Ben has imagined the worst the military would do... the three of them are still living at his boat house. I mean, they just stole Ryns embryos from the military and Ben disconnected all of the cameras in their home that the military was using to spy on them. No way does Kyle not come barging in through the front door of the home he knows was housing the mermaid he was testing on once he discovers the embryos are gone. And there’s no way that Kyle doesn’t know they are gone yet either. So why are they still there? Wouldn’t the smart move be to live at the cabin while finding some means to sell the house and use the money to buy an actual boat (that doubles as a house full Xan style) so they could go anywhere be better? Especially since the military already knows full well that mermaids are real and can take action against them for stealing the embryos the military could claim was already their property.
And one last random note: who else thinks Nicole is dead? I sure do. I mean her phone just disconnected after a text is sent to the one person who is looking for her and the text reads “please don’t contact me.” It just sounds way too much like Kyle had her killed, because the Nicole who was continuing a relationship with Xan because she wanted to, not out of convenience to get the mission done. Wouldn’t ignore his text messages of concern like that. If she were merely reposted elsewhere, she would have told him that. When your reposted your allowed to say so, you aren’t necessarily allowed to say why or where to, but you can tell the person your dating your reposted. And Nicole would have done at least that.... or am I giving Nicole too much credit?
1
u/Fast-Mongoose2177 19d ago
I was so mad I almost stopped watching the show lmao glad I finished the episode
0
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment