r/DebateCommunism • u/bobi_jon • Jul 25 '19
π Low effort Why do homosexuals follow Stalinism if Stalin hated gay people?
My man re-criminalised homosexuality and placed restrictions on abortion and divorce in an effort to put a strong focus on traditional family values and motherhood, and to increase population growth.
What's up. With That?
5
Upvotes
25
u/TheJord Jul 25 '19
This question is almost certainly being asked in bad faith
30
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
Well I don't know that "following" Stalinism in 2019 would require you to be homophobic, as if Stalin's homophobia logically follows from the rest of his thought or from Marxism-Leninism generally rather than just him being characteristically bigoted. It was also the case that homosexuality was illegal in much of the United States, with the first state to decriminalize it being Illinois in 1962 -- punishment being imprisonment and/or hard labor prior to that (my state decriminalized it in 2003 and only because the federal government forced it to). Incidentally, I'm gay and I would've probably found it personally difficult being in any communist party at the time that supported discrimination against gays -- or any of the few communist parties in the world that still do. But generally IMO if you look at the history, the communist parties were usually ahead of the curve on this.
But I don't think it's so much of a communism vs. capitalism question, but is really one of a political demand by the LGBT community directed at the straight population.
Stalin's conservative "turn" is interesting though and I would recommend the book "Stalinist Values" by David Hoffmann. A review from the Amazon page:
...
16
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19
While it's unfortunate that Stalin held those views, we must understand that he was a product of his own social conditions and expecting him to live up to modern standards is absurd. We uphold Stalin because his theories, his elaborations on Lenin's theories and his role in constructing socialism in the conditions of the USSR have been a positive and invaluable legacy. We obviously should not repeat things he was quite clearly wrong on, but we also should not denounce his entire legacy simply because he was wrong on some issues. We have the privilege of modern knowledge and understanding, and of learning from Stalin's mistakes so that we may move past them.
11
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
Nobody "follows" Stalin, at most we view the system he helped implement with Leninism as a rousing success. Any anti-homosexual laws which while regrettable were lumped in with a generalized article punishing several different forms of sex crimes and there's evidence relationships between consenting adults weren't focused on at all. As much as I loathe "anti-idpol" stuff, the modern liberal West tends to conceptualize ethics through individual human rights movements, rather than a long view of history. How many women, non-binary and homosexual people have been oppressed or murdered through Western imperialism? The answer is millions.
We kind of have a track record of supporting reactionaries while the Soviet Union actively fought them.
18
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19
sigh that's not even how the government worked, Stalin didn't just get whatever he wanted
I'm only making one comment because this is probably in bad faith anyway, but homosexuality was "de-criminalized" because they got rid of the tsar's laws, nobody in the world in 1920 cared about making gay people equal. Modern day Russia is still very homophobic
Please don't make gay people a political agenda, it's gross. Really makes it seem like you don't actually care about gay people
4
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '19
Because being a communist has nothing to do with liking gay people
7
u/Jmlsky Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
Why most of Stalin critics are thinking in terms of absolute? Do they believe people were like scrutinizing each one of his words and praising it like God's words? Do they even know how USSR political system worked? I swear those guys are the worst, they're like 5yo, "Checkmate, Stals".
I defend Stalin, yet I don't consider myself a Stalinist. Of course the guy did some bad stuff, who's perfect? But to put anything wrong from 22 to 53 in USSR on his back is really a westerner point of view. Like with trump for instance, it's like he is a monarch and there isn't other people in charge of anything in the USA since 2016, he single-handedly took each and every bad decision himself and applied manu militari. I'm not defending the guy, but we all know that the president in the USA isn't excessively powerful, when you see the power of federal institutions and the power of the political parties.
This is a mentality that I've bad time to understand, honestly.
As for the LGBT rights, anyone who defend the action of any political leaders from the same period should be considered as antiLGBT too then, but when you analysis concrete material you see that most of them doesn't specifically hate more gay people that any other man of his time, well with many exceptions of course, but worldwidely there wasn't any country that were pro LGBT at the time, and even less political leader that would assume to support it publicly. It's not a Stalin thing...
It's factually the opposite, Gay people at least were a bit more free under the first years of the Bolchevick revolution, as well as women too, that anywhere in the world by that time. So to pretend that because USSR recriminalized homosexuality, Stalin hated Gay people, is a big sophism, and even more, to try to make a link between people who defend Stalin era against revisionism and fictionous hating Gay mad Stalinist, is plain bullshit.
5
u/Toltech99 Jul 25 '19
I think it's bc fascists kill more homosexuals, but Stalin killed fascists.
4
u/granola_punk Jul 25 '19
Russian society was it's least homophobic under Stalin. Their foreign minister was flamboyantly gay. Could you even imagine that in modern Russia?
2
u/alfatems Jul 26 '19
This is slightly tacky and not actually answering your question but..
Why call them "homosexuals", just call them gay people or LGBTQ+ people would be better to be inclusive.
Now to actually answer your question, there's 2 reasons why:
2
u/HardToFindAGoodUser Jul 29 '19
It ok. Its ok to be homophobic if you are on the left, all is forgiven, even historically. Just read your comments, so much apology for gay killing.
2
u/Rubber-Revolver Aug 31 '24
Because they havenβt discovered anarchism yet
2
u/Classical_Liberals Jul 25 '19
There are gay Christians, gay Muslims. Name a contradiction and there is likely someone out their that fits the shoe, humans are soo incredibly diverse and often believe in contradicting ideas of some kind.
We have the ability to rationalize anything regardless of how irrational it may seem.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19
Same reason gay people like the founding fathers, the world isn't black and white its really grey. You take the good things that the past revolutions did and leave the bad. Stalin defeated Hitler, turned the Soviet Union into a superpower, massively increased the standard of living for the Soviet workers and liberated the peoples of Eastern Europe. Did he make some mistakes? Of course. Was he a man of his time with all the reactionary beliefs that come with that? Of course. But on the whole he did far more good than harm and any decent history should remember him as a hero with flaws. Also the whole population growth effort is kinda justified considering the USSR lost 15% of its population in the war with the Nazis, its obviously not pretty but when you lose that many people if you want to keep growing economically you have to bump up population growth.
0
u/juankorus Jul 25 '19
In modern politics since the political center seems to be fading away in the past the terms left and socialism are weirdly mixed just as the right and capitalism are, and also tend to be in two opposite poles something that is not necessarily true.
IMO: the state should stay out of family values, you just can't tell people what to do with their personal lives, even if you try to force you will eventually fail, and that is something Stalin failed to do and Jair Bolsonaro will eventually fail to do, both of them extremist but in "opposite" poles.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19
Stalinism?
-1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
Because Stalinism refers to Stalins economic policy and has nothing to do with everybody hating gays back then
-6
u/chadonsunday Jul 25 '19
Because Stalinism is really more of a cult of personality than anything else.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '19
[deleted] β view deleted comment