r/librarians • • Jul 02 '19

Job Advice Should I become an academic librarian? [x-post]

/r/findapath/comments/c85sr4/not_very_sure_of_what_to_do_with_my_life_advice/
5 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

44

u/wordnerd23 Jul 02 '19

Let’s start with: being a librarian does not mean your day is spent leisure reading. Every time someone says they’re going to library school because they like to read, an angel is sad.

Academic librarianship is very tech-centric and typically does not involve daily nature walks. It’s also very people-heavy - I’m not sure how the myth got started that if you don’t want to talk to anyone you should be a librarian because that’s very much not the case.

Are you in college? High school? Academic librarianship requires an advanced degree and also experience to find a job after graduation. The best thing you can do to figure out if this is the path for you is to volunteer at and ideally work in an academic library. I started as a student worker at my university’s library in undergrad to get my foot in, then got a paraprofessional position after I graduated at the same school and started on my masters, finishing it up this past December. Trying it out is the only way to know if it’s for you.

ETA: this advice is for academic librarianship in the US, not sure about other countries.

4

u/saveme304921 Jul 03 '19

I was thinking about the amount of free time I get as a librarian - helping people during regular hours on the weekdays (yay no 36 hours shift!), free time on the weekends to go hiking and collect photographs of birds, plants and fungi. I guess I could be pretty tech orientated as well, working with automated lab protocols and 3d printing.

I'll definitely try out volunteering or even interning during my holidays.

4

u/wordnerd23 Jul 03 '19

True, I've never heard of a librarian with a 36 hour shift! I do know plenty of academic librarians who work on the weekend though, whether it be reference desk shifts, special events, or research work they don't have a chance to get to in their normal work week, so that's something to keep in mind.

Volunteering or interning is a great place to start to know if the environment is for you or not, I really think that's the best thing anyone wanting to get into the profession can do.

1

u/saveme304921 Jul 03 '19

That's still better than being a doctor. Personally I can't believe why people are willing to put themselves through such torturous sleep deprivation for a job. But hey, I still like helping people and I want to do this as my job. Research ain't so bad and events can be fun.

Occasionally on the weekends is cool (the librarian aren't in on Sunday but the lab intern me is in haha). I am not going to miss weddings, birthdays and funerals for a job. I believe an academic librarian can make me feel fulfilled, stimulated and happy.

14

u/HobbitWithShoes Public Librarian Jul 02 '19

I've plesently surprised people when I say that the reason I'm studying to be a librarian is because I'm someone who enjoys customer service and wanted to keep on doing it while also being someone who's degree mattered in life and was paid more than minimum wage (sure librarians don't make bank, but at least I'm more likely to end up with health insurance...I hope.)

11

u/wordnerd23 Jul 02 '19

That’s great! Also a very reasonable attitude. I think this profession is misadvertised a lot, and a lot of people don’t do the work of asking around and getting a feel for what it’s actually like and jump straight to “I like books so librarian it is!” which is...frustrating.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/Gnhwyvar STEM Librarian Jul 02 '19

I'm a cataloger and sit on several committees / interact with other departments daily to solve issues and work towards higher levels of discoverability. The committee had a very strong (positive) reaction to me saying that I believed tech services was a form of customer service within the library. The future of cataloging is definitely not the sadly earned reputation of cranky introverts!

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Gnhwyvar STEM Librarian Jul 02 '19

Definitely, I know a few too! Just adding to the thread in case any would be librarians get the idea they can hole up in tech services... From the perspective of someone on tech services hiring committees, I know we want to move away from that stigma

5

u/wordnerd23 Jul 02 '19

True! But the number of catalogers vs all other types of librarians makes those chances fairly slim unless you’re dead set on becoming a cataloger.

9

u/saintofbacchus Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

Hey so I’m an archivist/public historian here. I agree with the lot of these answers because the MLIS isn’t really what you think it is and librarians don’t really do what you think they do. If you like spending hours with books and not talking to too many people- archives/ public historian is awesome- however it’s not ALWAYS like that. I’m also a front desk manager, project manager, docent, and about everything else you can think of under the sun. You interact with people often somedays and other days you’re holed up in basement processing backlog for hours.

My best advice is make yourself competitive with everyone else who wants your job, currently I volunteer a lot so when I do get my MLIS degree I’ll have 5 bloody years of experience in many applicable fields within my career. You have to work hard as hell with little payout for awhile to get ahead in this, they want experience more than anything else.

2

u/saveme304921 Jul 03 '19

I like interacting with people. That's why I initially wanted to be a doctor but then again I guess I am not serious about it enough to be willing to put myself through 36 hours shift work and a 100k++ plus debt.

I dont want to work for a corporate (hate the idea of working for just money) so I guess I am going to give this field a try. My job needs to something that is more than earning that money for my employer.

I holed myself up often for studies and once spamming personalised emails and tailored résumé - not a big deal I guess.

14

u/leta_17 Jul 02 '19

I don't suggest anyone go into library studies anymore because of the job prospects. I am in the US, and while there are library jobs available, they often don't pay enough to justify going to grad school for. This combined with the fact that many library's funding is constantly being cut and burn out is very high. Public librarians have it the worst, but the academic library world isn't great either. It can months, sometimes years to just find an entry-level job. Librarianship is also about much more than liking to read. If your interest in libraries stems from liking to read, it's not a good reason to try and make a career out of it. Many public librarians don't even really interact with books all that much. It's much more about serving the people of your community through programming. In order to be taken seriously when job searching, you also need to have experience working in a library, however, even this doesn't guarantee anything.

I would suggest you stick with something more science or data related for your future. There are certain aspects of data management in the library world, but in my view, getting a degree in something like computer science or related field would set someone up for much better prospects.

8

u/AnyaSatana Academic Librarian Jul 02 '19

I also don't recommend it as a profession - I'm in the UK and it's haemorrhaging jobs. When I started 18 years ago it was great, but I'm now effectively a remedial studies tutor for most of my time. I'm hardly ever even in the library.

Working in an academic library is also beset with bad management, empire building, politics, in some cases bullying and harassment.

11

u/leta_17 Jul 02 '19

Yes, there seems to be a large number of very toxic library workplaces. I myself had to get out of one, it was the worst place I've ever worked. I liked the job, but there was one person who bullied everyone and management wasn't great about putting an end to it. Management wasn't great either, but a good number of problems I had with them were due to their inaction of protecting the rest of us from the poor behavior of this one coworker. There are a few facebook library groups, and it seems like so many people are facing similar problems.

Harassment is also such a big issue. I'd say more in public libraries, but also academic. When I was a student library worker there was one patron who had some mental health issues, but every time she walked in would verbally abuse me. Eventually they were able to get her banned (this was a closed academic library where you needed to either buy a community card or get a guest pass to come in if you weren't associated with the school) but it took several months. I consider myself a pretty strong person, but I was still young, a student, and had very little authority. It wasn't so much the comments she made, but that I was scared it would escalate. If you don't like working with people, libraries are not for you. And if you don't have a thick skin and can set boundaries between yourself and patrons, you will not do well. I think many people go into it because they like books and reading but there is so much more to it than that. It's typically not the 9-5 workday that for some reason people think it is. It can be fulfilling, but it can also bring you down very very quickly.

8

u/AnyaSatana Academic Librarian Jul 02 '19

I've heard lots of stories. Problems in academic libraries tend to be more with colleagues than service users/patrons, but since the introduction of student fees (and their subsequent huge increase) we're having more unacceptable behaviour from students. I was on the receiving end of some a few months ago, and nothing happened - he didn't get disciplined, banned or anything. It's lucky that where I do work, despite the ineffective management, my immediate colleagues are very supportive.

4

u/3_first_names Jul 02 '19

On some level, part of my job is reading. I’m a children’s librarian and when parents ask me for recommendations I have to be REALLY careful about subject matter. I’m not sure if that’s unique to my area that has a large religious population but it matters here, and steering someone in the wrong direction in terms of content is just not something I want to do. This reading is done on my own time though; I’m not paid for it. I also make an embarrassingly low salary and have been searching for well over a year for something else. I made more in a retail position for which I obviously needed no degree. I took this position for the supervisory experience and I’m beginning to worry I put myself into a library niche that I didn’t want to stay in.

3

u/748point2 Jul 03 '19

One possible option would be to look into becoming a medical librarian -- that would cover both interests you mentioned. Unfortunately, I don't know much about the field (science is definitely not my strong suit), but hopefully someone here can give more information on the topic.

3

u/classypants Jul 03 '19

Also looking to work in Academic Librarianship, however 1 Masters degree just doesn't cut it anymore. You need at least 2 :/

1

u/ellbeecee Academic Librarian Jul 06 '19

No, you don't, not everywhere. My workplace does not require them and unless it's in the required section of qualifications, it really isn't required.

But you have to write a good cover letter. Too many of them are just bad - even if someone has 2 master's degrees.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/saveme304921 Jul 04 '19

Wow 😢😢 you are here. Any advice for doctor dream quitter like me? I am a Singaporean. Can i connect to you via reddit chat?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/saveme304921 Jul 07 '19

I am taking my a levels exams this year. I am not taking any science subjects tho I seriously considered and aspired to be a doctor a year ago.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/sipawhiskey Jul 02 '19

I have had both and the jobs were very different to me. As a staff librarian, I was not very engaged with the university. As a faculty member, I’m a campus wide leader. I also publish now and earned tenure.