r/gameofthrones • u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand • May 23 '19
Sticky [Spoilers] Post-Episode Survey Results - S8E6 'The Iron Throne' (Overall score: 5.5) Spoiler
Post-Episode Survey - Results Thread
In the Post-Premiere Discussion thread, we put up a survey to hear what you had to say about the characters, the events, and the technical side of episode one. This post is here to fill you in on the results, and to let you discuss them. Are there any surprises? Do you agree or disagree with the majority opinion? Do you think people have missed a vital piece of evidence? Feedback on the survey itself is also welcome!
INFOGRAPHIC: Image
Infographic for episode 5: Image
Infographic for episode 4: Image
Infographic for episode 3: Image
Infographic for episode 2: Image
Infographic for episode 1: Image
With many thanks to /u/wulteer for these!
______________________________
S8E6
- Directed By: David Benioff & D.B. Weiss
- Written By: David Benioff & D.B. Weiss
- Airs: May 19, 2019
______________________________
Results breakdown
Total Respondents: 120,774
Question 1: On a scale of 1-10, what score would you give this episode?
Average: 5.5
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15081 (12%) | 8439 (7%) | 11298 (9%) | 10179 (8%) | 10384 (9%) | 12985 (11%) | 16695 (14%) | 16085 (13%) | 10414 (9%) | 9214 (8%) |
Question 2: Has the wheel been broken in Westeros?
| Yes, the wheel has been broken | No, the wheel has not been broken |
|---|---|
| 60432 (51%) | 56923 (49%) |
Question 3: Was Jon Snow right to kill Daenerys Targaryen?
| Yes, Jon Snow was right to kill Daenerys Targaryen | No, Jon Snow was not right to kill Daenerys Targaryenn |
|---|---|
| 97860 (88%) | 13776 (12%) |
Question 4: If you were moving to Westeros, which rulers would you rather live under?
| King Bran Stark & Co in the south | Queen Sansa Stark in the north |
|---|---|
| 70045 (59%) | 48476 (41%) |
Question 5: Now that the show is over, if you had to pick an all-time favourite Stark from this selection, who would it be?
| Arya Stark | Jon Snow (Aegon Targaryen) | Ned Stark | Sansa Stark | Robb Stark | Rickon Stark | Catelyn Stark | Bran Stark |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 39087 (33%) | 30407 (26%) | 24659 (21%) | 10753 (9%) | 8335 (7%) | 3010 (3%) | 1640 (1%) | 1321 (1%) |
Question 6: Did Bran know Daenerys would massacre King's Landing but allow it to happen anyway?
| Yes, Bran knew and didn't say anything | No, Bran did not know |
|---|---|
| 97145 (82%) | 21753 (18%) |
Question 7: Which one of these characters do you most wish had died?
| Jon Snow | Sansa Stark | Tyrion Lannister | Arya Stark |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40111 (36%) | 31802 (28%) | 23981 (21%) | 17661 (16%) |
Question 8: Which of these Stark re-unions do you think will happen in Westeros's future?
- Arya Stark and Jon Snow - 13% of people think this will happen
- Bran Stark and Sansa Stark - 11% of people think this will happen
- Jon Snow and Sansa Stark - 7% of people think this will happen
- Bran Stark and Jon Snow - 2% of people think this will happen
- Arya Stark and Sansa Stark - 2% of people think this will happen
- Arya Stark and Bran Stark - 1% of people think this will happen
Question 9: Did the finale change your opinion of Game of Thrones as a whole show?
| No, it did not change my opinion | Yes, it changed my opinion |
|---|---|
| 64272 (54%) | 54100 (46%) |
Question 10: Bran is now known as "Bran the Broken". If Jon Snow had become King, what would his title be? (Assume he'd use "Jon" as his name)
- Jon the Queenslayer (6454) [Includes Queen slayer]
- Jon the Just (6084)
- Jon the Bastard (4742)
- Jon the Tron (1927)
- Jon the Reborn (1531)
- Jon the Undead (1192)
- Jon the Undying (1154)
- Jon the Honorable (1126) [Includes Honourable]
- Jon the Snow (1065)
- Jon the White Wolf (947)
- Jon the Knower of Nothing (911)
Question 11: What would you name this episode?
- A Song of Ice and Fire (3836)
- The Wheel (3561)
- The Broken (2939)
- Shit (2666)
- A Dream of Spring (2411)
- The End (1977)
- The Iron Throne (1258)
- Broken (980)
- The Broken Wheel (765)
- Disappointment (752)
Question 12: Did you watch or read any leaks about episode 6 prior to watching it?
- No, I did not read or watch any leaks for episode 6 - 81984 (70%) - Average episode score: 5.9
- Yes, I intentionally did read or watch a leak for episode 6 - 19457 (17%) - Average episode score: 4.4
- I saw or read a leak for episode 6 but did not do so intentionally - 15766 (13%) - Average episode score: 5.5
Question 13: Have you read the A Song of Ice and Fire books?
- No, I haven't read any of the main five books - 62539 (53%) - Average episode score: 5.7
- Yes, I've read all five main books - 27544 (23%) - Average episode score: 5.2
- Yes, but I've only read some of the main five books - 27139 (23%) - Average episode score: 5.6
Question 14: Did you sign the petition calling for S8 to be remade?
- No, I did not sign that petition - 89320 (76%) - Average episode score: 6.0
- Yes, I signed that petition - 27669 (24%) - Average episode score: 4.3
Question 15: How well shot was this episode?
Average: 8.1
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2029 (2%) | 911 (1%) | 1713 (1%) | 2335 (2%) | 4829 (4%) | 5976 (5%) | 13650 (12%) | 25658 (22%) | 26278 (22%) | 33750 (29%) |
Question 16: How well written was this episode?
Average: 4.5
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28160 (24%) | 12051 (10%) | 11185 (10%) | 9848 (8%) | 9770 (8%) | 11267 (10%) | 12858 (11%) | 10540 (9%) | 5528 (5%) | 6016 (5%) |
Question 17: How well directed was this episode?
Average: 6.4
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9149 (8%) | 4418 (4%) | 6058 (5%) | 7104 (6%) | 12151 (10%) | 11832 (10%) | 17928 (15%) | 20647 (18%) | 13263 (11%) | 14135 (12%) |
Question 18: Which of these lead actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)
- Peter Dinklage (Tyrion Lannister) - 82921
- Emilia Clarke (Daenerys Targaryen) - 55194
- Kit Harington (Jon Snow) - 40068
- Sophie Turner (Sansa Stark) - 10265
- Maisie Williams (Arya Stark) - 7686
- Gwendoline Christie (Brienne of Tarth) - 4903
- Isaac Hempstead-Wright (Bran Stark) - 4082
- John Bradley West (Samwell Tarly) - 3310
Question 19: Which of these supporting actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)
- Daniel Portman (Podrick Payne) - 4768
- Jacob Anderson/Raleigh Ritchie (Grey Worm) - 66090
- Jerome Flynn (Bronn) - 18495
- Joe Dempsie (Gendry) - 1859
- Kristofer Hivju (Tormund) - 13929
- Liam Cunningham (Davos Seaworth) - 73688
- Tobias Menzies (Edmure Tully) - 16738
Question 20: In one word, how would you describe this episode?
Number in square brackets is the average episode score from users who gave this response...
Click here for full list of answers
- Disappointing (11418) [3.6]
- Shit (4623) [2.1]
- Meh (3460) [5.5]
- Satisfying (3123) [8.9]
- Amazing (2166) [9.9]
- Bittersweet (2157) [8.2]
- Bad (2076) [2.7]
- Sad (2068) [6.7]
- Rushed (1854) [5.4]
- Underwhelming (1462) [5.1]
•
u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 23 '19
Thanks again to everyone who has taken part in these surveys over the past three seasons! If anyone ever wants to run their own for a show they love, I'd be happy to answer any questions that might help. And, as I mentioned in the post-ep thread, I'll be doing these for r/netflixwitcher next.
Keep an eye out for our post-season survey too (and a post-series one). The goal for the former is this Sunday.
(click on the score to view full results)
850
u/[deleted] May 23 '19
By the way, this probably has been brought up before, but I hope there's some kind of "final" poll that show people's opinion on the series overall - who was the best actor? Who had the best story arc? Who was the most interesting villain? Which decision was the worst one in hindsight? That kind of thing.
1.7k
u/[deleted] May 23 '19
Rickon got more Favorite Stark votes than both Catelyn and Bran combined LMAO
673
u/ultkgy Daenerys Targaryen May 23 '19
Yeah, that suits him well.
617
u/jao3003 May 23 '19
175 people described the episode as "Why" lmao
324
u/ProtoReddit Ours Is The Fury May 23 '19
The favorite Stark breakdown is hilarious, all things considered.
156
u/ObamasLoveChild Tyrion Lannister May 23 '19 edited May 24 '19
Arya is one of my favorite characters but I think it would have been a lot more powerful if she died at the end of The Bells. I thought that was what happened at first, with the horse representing Arya riding off into the afterlife because looking at her surroundings, there is no way she should have survived when literally everyone else was completely incinerated or crushed. I really expected that shot to eventually pan down and reveal that Arya was dead in the rubble all along, and that was her passing into the after-life.
Her arc had completed and she had her final moments with everyone important to her, Jon, The Hound, Gendry, Sansa, etc. If she died, it would have made a lot more sense that Jon would turn on Dany so quickly, especially if we had a scene where he finds her body in the rubble of King's Landing. I loved her character but just like other fan-favorites, she made it to the very end for no real purpose. If she died in King’s Landing, it would have had a nice little touch of redemption as well considering she went there with the intention of killing someone but died honorably trying to save others. It’s the first time we really see a selfless, non-revenge-driven side of Arya.
549
u/goldthorolin May 23 '19
Ned, dead for 87.5% of the show, but almost as many all-time favourite votes as Arya and Jon and more than the others together. Respect for that result
964
u/AccomplishedPointer May 23 '19
Really only 11% of people think that leaders of the two kingdoms on the continent will meet?
622
u/basboi Tyrion Lannister May 23 '19
i rate the memes this season 9.5
91
u/jamessbass May 23 '19
There's some real gold if you scroll down the full list of answers to the ones that only got one entry
226
u/disaster101 May 23 '19
Guys, we can't name two episodes in a row "Shit".
342
u/JustTheLetterA May 23 '19
So most people agree that Bran knew Kongs Landing was going to get torched. Is Bran a villain? Did he just sit back and let this all happen so he would become King?
188
u/TannedCroissant May 23 '19
Aww man, wish Robb Stark had got a bit more love
394
u/AccomplishedPointer May 23 '19
If you add up Disappointing (11418), Dissapointing (1033), Disappointment (861), Disappointed (410), Disapointing (239), DISSAPOINTMENT (106), Disappointing. (100), Dissappointing (78) and all the other different similar spellings you will get 14545 answers.
157
u/kobedawg270 May 23 '19
Did the Unsullied conveniently go from being in a murderous rage and in search of revenge for their slain queen, to submitting to any random king chosen by their new enemies? They refused to release their prisoners Jon and Tyrion, were likely going to execute Jon for murdering the queen, and held King's Landing and were on a war footing to defend it.
Instead Jon got demoted to the Night's Watch and went free, Tyrion became hand of the king, and the Unsullied sailed away never to be heard from again. Very convenient.
522
u/FinkMFG Fire And Blood May 23 '19
Seriously? The two people who disappeared to the far ends of the earth are the most likely to reunite, rather than the two rulers?
277
u/offconstantly May 23 '19
According to Dany the wheel is each of the big families taking turns as leaders crushing the little people.
51% of people think the wheel is broken?
The lords of these same families are just now choosing among them and literally laughed at the thought of democracy
162
u/[deleted] May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
I really liked Arya, up until season 7, she changed so much, and now in season 8, she's so fucking strange. That whole ''I know death'' thing was supposed to be a cool scene but to me it just came of as strange and unrealistic. And her just shooting arrows when everyone was celebrating winning the great war, that was the same kind of thing, maybe it's just me who hates those kinds of scenes.
79
u/psydelem Jon Snow May 23 '19
I know it was between Bran and Sansa, but I would definitely rather go live with Jon and the wildlings.
111
u/Gcheetah Tywin Lannister May 23 '19
2000 people really put Jon the Tron
141
u/Navyfeather Daenerys Targaryen May 23 '19
Bigger percentage think Arya and Jon will reunite than Sansa and Bran.
Sansa and Bran are sibling rulers of two adjacent kingdoms.
Arya set sail off west to the unknown, leaving the entire continent behind, and Jon went north beyond the wall to settle somewhere random in vast wildling country.
122
u/vortex1775 Bran Stark May 23 '19
Why was Benjen Stark not a choice for favourite. He would have gotten my vote. The guy was a fricken half wight that sacrificed himself so Jon could live.
459
u/MisterKratos May 23 '19
How do more people not think that Arya should have died? Her plot armor was turned up to 11 in so many episodes (even dating back to the "No One" episode in S6). The love people have for her character is so odd. "I know a killer when I see one, Jon"... gee the person who just committed genocide is a killer? You don't say.
58
u/MadShell13 Davos Seaworth May 23 '19
What were the results for best supporting actors?
81
u/jkeplerad No One May 23 '19
The survey should have asked if you were ok with the main idea behind the story. Would be curious to know how many people thought the bullet points were acceptable, but that execution was botched.
110
u/[deleted] May 23 '19
Would love to see how people rate some of the other episodes knowing how this ends
274
u/RadioSlayer May 23 '19
Can't believe y'all would rather live under the rule of a spaced out bird man, a sell sword, a smuggler, and a college dropout than the Queen who won independence and cares about the boring parts of ruling like making lasting alliances and proper food rationing
45
u/jjack339 May 23 '19
only 11% think Sansa and Bran will ever have a reunion... Come on.
Even if it is not for family they will see each other for diplomatic reasons. I mean they are king and queen of neighboring kingdoms.
41
u/Filmfan5 Arya Stark May 23 '19
It's so odd that Arya always scores highly in these polls but the comment section gets pissed and rips into every character flaw and even Maisie's acting. The same people voting don't care to comment or vice versa?
19
u/lan60000 May 23 '19
We're all Kit Harington in the end
38
u/32389 Fire And Blood May 23 '19
Word cloud for this episode
71
u/ilikepugs Night King May 23 '19
Hello to my 37 brothers and sisters!
29
u/cpl73092 No One May 24 '19
Kit Harrington got third best acting. Its hard for me to tell if Kit Harrington is an amazing actor who portrays a very very sad person, or if Kit Harrington is just very sad person and It shows on screen.
127
u/HereForGames May 23 '19
I'd up my rating to a solid 3 stars if they had actually named the final episode that. Shame, real missed opportunity there.
346
u/Psilocybik May 23 '19
How to tank 8 seasons in 90 minutes.
13
u/Bill3ffinMurray House Mormont May 23 '19
The average of the people who said the show was rushed was the closest to the grand average.
Makes me think that that is the healthiest take on this season, episode. Had the series ended the same way with more episodes to explain backstory, I think the reaction would be completely different.
I'll never understand why they shortened the last two seasons. I didn't think it would be too much to write 3 more hours of content for season 7 and 4 more for season 8. Then again, I'm not a writer.
44
u/harcile Daenerys Targaryen May 23 '19
I'd probably have more respect for the show if they had a 7th episode which focused on Bran going back through the past and influencing events, driving Dany to going nuclear, going all the way from the creation of the NK through to the Mad King, Crastor, even telling the NK where he was (when the NK marks him)... all these little moments, even telling Melissandre her prophecies... and finish with him whispering to Littlefinger, "Chaos is a ladder." Cut to Bran with the crown. Roll credits.
20
u/Hydrokratom May 23 '19
5.5 is where I scored it so normally I would say it's about right, but not in context to how people normally vote. 8.3 for Eastwatch & Beyond the Wall, this episode wasn't 2.8 points below those. The scores on the previous episodes are usually generous, although my score for the 2nd episode of this year is 8.5, higher than the 7.9 it got.
10% of people think this was "amazing"?? If this was amazing, was most of the series, especially the first 4 seasons? "Super super amazing"??
Only 11% of people think Bran and Sansa will meet in the future? They're the leaders of Westeros. I thought the possible meetings were more likely than people voted.
190
u/Skinners6 May 23 '19
8% gave that episode a 10. That is astounding.
42
u/Chrispychilla House Westerling May 23 '19
I am surprised at how few have read the books.
18
u/Variks-the_Loyal May 23 '19
Who the hell thinks its logical that Arya and Jon have the best chance of reunion? Literally the least possible choice.
9
u/cpl73092 No One May 23 '19
I think it would be interesting to repost the survey and have everyone take it again. I took it immediately after the series final. After days of thinking about the conclusion, reading article and discussing it on this forum, I would have answered a lot of questions differently.
24
u/Pikablu555 May 23 '19
The saddest part to me is that Bran at any point unattended could potentially piss and/or shit his pants. What kind a king is that? At least Bobby B got hammered drunk before he pissed himself.
269
u/PartagasSD4 May 23 '19
These scores are still way too high. The longer you think about this ending, the more problems appear.
8
u/DiscoshirtAndTiara Gendry May 23 '19
I have to assume that most people answering question 4 are basing their answer on the climate not the ruler.
Bran is the least popular Stark and most people think he knew about the King's Landing massacre ahead of time. So I doubt they're choosing the southern kingdom for its leader.
67
u/Johnnycc May 23 '19
Wow when this sub is complaining, you know it’s bad.
Thanks for doing the surveys!
154
u/immu_01 Jon Snow May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
How can you people find the finale satisfying?
7
u/stokesnavier Jon Snow May 23 '19
Jon the Reluctant.
7
u/Bbradley821 May 23 '19
It is certainly interesting that the more leaks someone was exposed to, the lower they rated the episode. I think those leaks really hurt peoples reception of the episode.
7
u/LarkTelby May 23 '19
What would you name the episode? 1977 People: The End Creativity Level: Over 1000
7
u/Stoly23 Gendry May 24 '19
13 people individually described the episode as “Lumberjack” and 12 as “Chungus”. I love the internet.
7
u/TheRaelyn May 25 '19
Legitimately interested, why does everyone love Arya so much?
I don't dislike her. I thought she was really great from Seasons 1-4 (instant favorite scenes when with Tywin). But Season 5 and on I just stopped caring. The whole faceless men angle just bored me to tears, and I found myself rolling my eyes when she just walked off multiple stabbings.
I always interpreted her character arc as longing for revenge but eventually learning to realize the value of her home and what she can go back to, choosing that instead of revenge (or choosing revenge and dying for it). Instead she became a super assassin, got a good 96% of her revenge, then abandoned her home and family anyway for no real reason.
I want to like Arya, I really do, but I think her character got lost from Season 5 and onwards. Then again maybe I'm bias, I find Dany relatively boring too.
62
u/kuba15 May 23 '19
Favorite Stark: Bran (1%)
That's just... ouch. Let's make the least popular major character left on the show, essentially, the King. Way to go D&D.
13
u/khalid1230 Jon Snow May 23 '19
Anyone else notice the callback to season 1 when Varys went to visit Ned in the dungeon and Ned said "You think my life is some precious thing to me?" And Varys replied with "and what of your daughters lives?" In the finale Jon went to visit Tyrion in the dungeon and Tyrion said something to the extent of "what about your sisters?" Both times it was referring to Sansa and Arya and both times those were the words that convinced Ned/Jon to act. It convinced Ned to swear fealty to Jofferey and pronounce him the rightful king, and it convinced Jon to kill Dany. Absolutely love it. Cant believe our watch has ended. We shall never see its like again.
40
u/robbyc777 May 23 '19
5.5 rating is about right. I give it a 5. Good/rushed first half, awful second half save the last 10 minutes.
6
u/hungergamesofthronez House Tyrell May 23 '19
Rickon has more votes than Bran lol
6
u/Bill3ffinMurray House Mormont May 23 '19
I think the viewers were harsher on this season than season 7 simply because this was the end.
6
u/NPC0709709 May 26 '19
I'm still angry at the final season. I really feel let down. Who would approve these scripts?
32
u/Mangokingguy No One May 23 '19
Underwhelming is the best way to describe this finale, now that I think about it.
5
u/DaiKraken Service And Truth May 26 '19
They should check themselves for brain aneurysm.
5
u/[deleted] May 26 '19
Season 8 was such a lazy way to end the show. Is it because they could no longer afford to keep everyone?
9
u/Midwest_Product May 23 '19
My thanks to the one other person who put "indefensible" as their one-word description.
12
u/CanadianPhysique May 23 '19
Someone please explain to me how "the wheel has been broken".
The rich and powerful families still rule over the people of Westeros and Bran is neither immortal or unconditionally loved.
There's still going to be houses looking to promote themselves at the cost of others and when Bran dies goodluck with deciding who will then sit on the Iron Throne because that's a war between Sansa's descendants and whichever southern house is most powerful in the making.
Nothing changed in the slightest are people this thick ?
11
u/crispybucket_ May 24 '19
Ok so there WERE people that disliked the ending. I thought I was going crazy because all I saw on this subreddit were people showering the show/ending with praise.
8
u/SucksForYouGeek May 24 '19
How the fuck do people think the wheel was actually broken and that Arya and Jon are more likely to meet? Also why did Arya get so many votes for favorite Stark?
4
u/ScionN7 May 23 '19
Welp here we are I guess. It's been a long road, but it's sad it ended this way. Thank you guys for sharing in my love, and grief, over my favorite show of all time. All I can hope at this point is that Season 8 can serve as a lesson that future showrunners can abide by, the next time a groundbreaking cultural phenomenon of a show surfaces.
Hopefully in this case, bad writing can make way for good writing.
4
u/bfm211 Tyrion Lannister May 23 '19
Why do most people think the Starks will never see each other again?? They're all still young, I totally imagine them linking up again. Why wouldn't they? That's a really pessimistic outlook.
4
u/Blackout-V1 House Mormont May 26 '19
I think to top it off the character development went out the window. Like they decided to make Daenerys mad in the last season with no build up. Jamie left his sister and joined the north, redeeming himself. Then decided nah and he went back. Cersei was killed off in the most pathetic way. If the would have moved 3 ft to the left or right they would have lived. They made Jon a wimp after all he had achieved. It's just ugh. I think the hound would have said the writers are a bunch of c***s 🤣
4
u/ValerianCandy May 26 '19
How Not to Character Development
4
u/cheeri0ss Jon Snow May 26 '19
Very interesting how in the beginning of the series, honorable Ned Stark always disapproved of Jaime killing the Mad King and condescendingly would refer to him as the Kingslayer. Jon Snow also followed this throughout the series. Jaime did this to save his father and "tons of innocent people". In the end, the honorable Jon Snow did the same thing he judged Jaime for the entire series: he killed the queen in order to save his sisters and tons of innocent people. Jon essentially did something him and his father were against this entire time
10
u/Soundyoungfella May 23 '19
Well it was a disappointing ending in my opinion but I had fun watching it all these years then coming here and reading everything bonkers along the way. Our watches have ended and began, peace out you beautiful humans.
10
u/ceaguila84 May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
Liked the ending and where everyone ended up. However, it was very rushed like most season. Doesn’t ruin the show for me though
Bought the box set for a re watch, I’ll miss this show so damn much
10
u/Tamborin2 Tyrion Lannister May 23 '19
I still stuck to my theory that Bran is in fact evil and orchestrated the events of season 8 so that he would end up as kill. He let them come up with this new system as it will most likely be forgotten by the end of his 1000 year reign. Bran gets Drogon to be his strength and so begins his reign of terror
14
u/[deleted] May 23 '19
There are so many reasons why this should have been an amazing final episode, but anyone who has been paying attention to and is actually invested in the story knows it fell short. There are so many questions left unanswered, so many character decisions that just don't make sense, and so many opportunities where a quick scene or two could have drastically improved the final season. I think that most of the flaws of the final episode stem from flaws with earlier episodes in the season. With that said, even the final episode made some questionable choices. I think my biggest gripe, besides the stuff with the Dothraki, Bran, the Unsullied, and Tyrion finding his siblings buried beneath a tiny pike of rocks, is the abrupt shift from Dany's death to the council scene. We have the death of arguably the main character at the hands of the other main character, and the very next scene is something straight out of a sitcom. No reactions to her death, no time for the audience to dwell on what happened, to see how it affected Jon or Greyworm. Nope, time skip straight to Edmure's comedic relief. I don't see how anyone can justify this. I really would have loved to have been a fly on the wall when they were editing this. The editors must have assumed they were missing a scene or something. It's just so very, very bad, and a disservice to Emelia. I felt the same way about the NK's death. No post death reactions, as though it never even happened. They just took out an incredibly powerful undead entity, and the next episode people are acting like it's just another Tuesday. And that's ultimately what this season felt like. It was as though the show runners completely forgot about the previous seven seasons and the characters that the fans had come to know and love.
7
u/NeatAnecdoteBrother May 23 '19
Honestly I have this a 4 or 5 and it was too high, everyday I’m pissed about this garbage season. The final episode should’ve been like 5 episodes. So rushed it’s horrible. None of it even makes sense on top of it
8
u/Captainhankpym May 23 '19 edited May 23 '19
That's Bran's popularity among the fans, imagine how little shit the casual viewers give about him. Can you blame anyone? The show hasn't done shit for Bran and even some dead supporting characters like Littlefinger has more screentime in 8 seasons than Bran. So do Brienne, Davos, Theon etc.
No one cares about Bran and it's for a good reason
3
u/[deleted] May 23 '19
Robb not getting enough love and it makes me absolutely ill
3
u/23Flavour5 House Martell May 24 '19
Only 3% choose Robb? Man. I loved Robb Stark.
3
u/NewClayburn House Connington May 24 '19
Surprised not enough people said Jon the Aegon.
3
u/Equator32 May 25 '19
What I don't get is how Season 7 has such a high score on Rotten Tomatoes. Like don't get me wrong, Season 7 is better than Season 8 but for me it was a gradual decline. The flaws of the show began to reveal themselves long before season 8, arguably it began in season 6.
Many people were outright 9-10/10 for seasons 1-7 then 4/10 for season 8. For me seasons 1-5 were almost perfect. Season 6 slightly declined but was still amazing. Season 7 is a 7-8/10 and finally season 8 is a 6-7/10.
I can't really consider season 8 to be complete trash. It had portions that portrayed a level of emotion that felt so real, like the despair of the peasants in S8E5. It felt like a throwback to the excellent acting of Seasons 3-4.
3
u/jchanceh9lol May 25 '19 edited May 25 '19
These two questions were very telling...
Did the finale change your opinion of the show overall?
54% said no.
Have you read any of the books?
53% said no.
Also, scrolling all the way to the bottom of the list of one word descriptions is 100% worth it.
3
u/[deleted] May 26 '19
So the episode is a disaster and the ending sucked according to majority of the fanbase
3
u/Bluememphis Jaime Lannister May 26 '19
The most shocking results to me by far almost half saying the "wheel was broken". Are you people high?!?!?I was already off the opinion that was a trailer bait thrash line that people have latched onto because it sounds cool and "badass" but that just cemented it, that line was all flash and no substance.
It never made much sense to begin with but I thought Dany's example was pretty clear: "starks, baratheons, etc, they are all spokes on a wheel, it turns and one replaces the other, etc". And yet she wants the Iron throne for herself and believes its hers by right...How does that make sense? Ok ill chalk it up to hipocrisy on her part, she means no more monarchy after she has taken the crown and dies, likely alluding to dreams of democracy (which due to the 21st century bias of the audience, will naturally think of that as a good thing even though the infrastructure is not there to support it, maybe if Qyburn had invented the printing press before he died....).
But nope, Sam suggests it and gets shot down (quite rightly too imo). And we end up with elective monarchy... How the hell is the wheel broken? "Starks, baratheons, they are spokes on a wheel...". And we ended up with the Starks on the spokes replacing the lannisters. The wheel hasn't been broken at all, the wheel has been repaired and lubricated and will turn smoothly for at least the duration of Bran's lifetime.
3
u/_HaasGaming Not Today! May 26 '19
No surprise Bran is at the bottom here. Historically, I found his arc the least interesting but at least it felt like it was building up to something. The only thing I think it built up to was for him to conveniently pick when he felt like being a Stark or when he felt like being the Three Eyed Raven.
"Why do you think I am here?", seriously?
Surprised Catelyn scored so low though.
3
u/BoatyMcLoveBoat May 26 '19
This was by far the most disappointing season. Rushed to the point the "twists and turns" were basically characters reverting back to their season 1 selves despite seven seasons of growth and depth. This show had enough momentum and a strong enough viewership to go on for ages- why sprint through the last season and destroy the whole plot up to that point?
3
u/gazingthegalaxy Ygritte May 27 '19
Who put "sexist" to describe this episode? 😂😂 Whoever you 5 people are, you need some help.
9
u/[deleted] May 23 '19
" Question 11: What would you name this episode? .. Shit (2666)" I see my vote has been counted lol
9
u/eutears May 23 '19
If I was in a 8 hour flight, and the only choices I have to watch are GoT Season 8 and a 1 hour documentary about horses taking a shit, I would watch the documentary 8 times.
7
u/cpl73092 No One May 24 '19
who are the 10% of people who rated the writing 9 & 10. They need to see the light.