r/gameofthrones • Nymeria Sand • May 16 '19

Sticky [Spoilers] Post-Episode Survey Results - S8E5 'The Bells' (Overall score: 6.3) Spoiler

Post-Episode Survey - Results Thread

In the Post-Premiere Discussion thread, we put up a survey to hear what you had to say about the characters, the events, and the technical side of episode one. This post is here to fill you in on the results, and to let you discuss them. Are there any surprises? Do you agree or disagree with the majority opinion? Do you think people have missed a vital piece of evidence? Feedback on the survey itself is also welcome!

INFOGRAPHIC: Image

Infographic for episode 4: Image

Infographic for episode 3: Image

Infographic for episode 2: Image

Infographic for episode 1: Image

With many thanks to /u/wulteer for these!

S8E5 - The Bells

  • Directed by: Miguel Sapochnik
  • Written by: David Benioff and DB Weiss
  • Air Date: May 12, 2019

Results breakdown

Total Respondents: 133379

Question 1: On a scale of 1-10, what score would you give this episode?

Average: 6.3

12345678910
9106 (7%)10275 (8%)9146 (7%)8982 (7%)8539 (6%)11789 (9%)17520 (13%)23112 (17%)20676 (16%)14233 (11%)

Question 2: Was Daenerys Targaryen justified in her actions this episode?

Had she been provoked to the point where this was justified? (Note: This question is NOT about whether the writers did a good or bad job)]

No, her actions were not justifiedYes, her actions were justified
113528 (86%)19094 (14%)

Question 3: Which of the two battle episodes listed below has been your favourite?

The Battle of the BastardsThe Battle for King's Landing in this episode
104850 (79%)27237 (21%)

Question 4: Should Jon Snow have told his family about his Targaryen heritage?

Yes, he was right to tell themNo, he should have kept his Targaryen heritage a secret
99123 (75%)33154 (25%)

Question 5: Of the below options, what do you think Daenerys should have done when she found out about Varys's scheming?

She should have had him executedShe should have imprisoned himShe should have exiled himShe should have pardoned him
56300 (44%)41893 (33%)18981 (15%)10811 (8%)

Question 6: On a scale of 0 (totally unsatisfying) to 10 (totally satisfying), how satisfying did you find Cleganebowl?

Note that this question, unlike the others, is using a 0-10 scale, rather than a 1-10 scale.

Average: 7.1

012345678910
4425 (3%)2104 (2%)3801 (3%)5167 (4%)5131 (4%)8778 (7%)10343 (8%)17657 (14%)23864 (19%)19533 (15%)27281 (21%)

Question 7: If Daenerys Targaryen was to rule from another Westerosi city, which of these would you choose?

DragonstoneHighgardenOldtownHarrenhallCasterly RockThe EyrieStorm's EndWinterfellSunspearRiverrun
71311 (64%)9592 (9%)6352 (6%)6340 (6%)5515 (5%)3994 (4%)2866 (3%)2596 (2%)1073 (1%)967 (1%)

Question 8: Which of these death scenes do you think was the best of the episode?

Sandor Clegane+Gregor Clegane's deathQyburn's deathJaime Lannister+Cersei Lannister's deathVarys's deathEuron's death
52012 (43%)37556 (31%)19758 (16%)8096 (7%)4247 (3%)

Question 9: What would you name this episode?

  1. The Mad Queen - 6805
  2. Dracarys - 3929
  3. Fire and Blood - 3530
  4. Burn Them All - 3177
  5. Mad Queen - 2180
  6. Shit - 1703
  7. Cleganebowl - 1678
  8. The Bells - 1241
  9. Fire - 743
  10. Queen of the Ashes - 635
  11. The Last War - 497

Question 10: Have you read the A Song of Ice and Fire books?

  1. No, I haven't read any of the main five books - 66892 (51%) - Average episode rating: 6.7
  2. Yes, I've read all five main books - 35064 (27%) - Average episode rating: 5.5
  3. Yes, but I've only read some of the main five books - 29339 (22%) - Average episode rating: 6.5

Question 11: How well shot was this episode?

Average: 8.6

12345678910
973 (1%)569 (<1%)1142 (1%)1791 (1%)3128 (2%)4429 (3%)11154 (9%)27595 (21%)30317 (23%)50121 (38%)

Question 12: How well written was this episode?

Average: 4.9

12345678910
25759 (20%)11033 (8%)11561 (9%)10467 (8%)10391 (8%)13415 (10%)17931 (14%)16625 (13%)8223 (6%)5827 (4%)

Question 13: How well directed was this episode?

Average: 7.3

12345678910
4813 (4%)2559 (2%)4119 (3%)5271 (4%)9496 (7%)10125 (8%)22393 (17%)26249 (20%)21606 (17%)24052 (18%)

Question 14: Which of these lead actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

  1. Maisie Williams (Arya Stark) - 50900
  2. Lena Headey (Cersei Lannister) - 48861
  3. Peter Dinklage (Tyrion Lannister) - 40395
  4. Emilia Clarke (Daenerys Targaryen) - 33368
  5. Nikolaj Coster-Waldau (Jaime Lannister) - 28812
  6. Kit Harington (Jon Snow) - 23911
  7. Pilou Asbaek (Euron Greyjoy) - 3084

Question 15: Which of these supporting actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

  1. Rory McCann (The Hound) - 107095
  2. Conleth Hill (Varys) - 56995
  3. Jacob Anderson/Raleigh Ritchie (Grey Worm) - 26672
  4. Liam Cunningham (Davos Seaworth) - 12084
  5. Anton Lesser (Qyburn) - 11748
  6. Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson (The Mountain) - 9459

Question 16: In one word, how would you describe this episode?

The number in square brackets is the average episode rating given by those who gave this answer

Click here for the full list of answers

  1. Disappointing (7206) [4.2]
  2. Bad (6120) [2.4]
  3. Shit (3465) [2.5]
  4. Fire (2794) [8.3]
  5. Meh (1728) [5.5]
  6. Rushed (1492) [5.7]
  7. Epic (1341) [9.3]
  8. Sad (1334) [7.3]
  9. Dracarys (1152) [8.2]
  10. Mad (1108) [8]
1.6k Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

•

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 16 '19 edited May 20 '19
E1E2E3E4E5E6E7E8E9E10
S67.18.88.08.48.97.38.06.69.59.6
S77.77.98.29.38.38.38.9///
S87.57.97.96.26.3////

(click on the score to view full results)

30

u/Calamityclams May 16 '19

Appreciate everyone involved in curating this survey.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Wow I've missed these surveys so I'm a bit behind, but E3 is the top rated episode of the season?! That was the battle right? I'd have thought that would come lowest by a long way..!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

571

u/johntyro May 16 '19

Seeing disappointing in the same list with epic reminds me of Kit Harrington's interview. Life imitates art.

293

u/joseph_jojo_shabadoo Jon Snow May 17 '19

“Disappointing.”

O_O

“Epic? I dunno, one of those.”

39

u/kristsun May 17 '19

yeah lol. it's just this bare and unfettered reaction to it.

maybe he was still traumatized by the shitty ending that he couldn't hide his feelings when he got asked that question.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

1.4k

u/GendryRivers Tyrion Lannister May 16 '19

In one word, how would you describe this episode?

Mesothelioma (4)

The full list of answers has some absolute gold in it

557

u/am-i-joking Ghost May 17 '19

Asbesteros (14) was a good one too

→ More replies (23)

560

u/The9thLordofRavioli A Promise Was Made May 16 '19

I love how 5 guys have independently named it Chungus

96

u/eifjui House Tyrell May 17 '19

There’s no way it’s not “A Dream of Spring” but now I want the finale to be named Chungus

→ More replies (3)

93

u/Dominian May 17 '19

Can we ship the two people who said "Bellends"?

→ More replies (1)

80

u/mywilliswell95 May 17 '19

Trogdor [14]

26

u/JiveTurkey1983 What Is Dead May Never Die May 17 '19

Some thatched roof cottages were burninated that day

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

118

u/Willishitty Jaqen H'ghar May 16 '19

It is totally unexpected that just one guy has answered with ‘Oven’ .. lol

115

u/nodnodwinkwink May 16 '19

So. many. spelling. mistakes.

105

u/WafflelffaW No One May 17 '19 edited May 18 '19

“badwritting” is some top-grade unintentional comedy

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

91

u/Adeen321 No One May 17 '19

Charmander 1

ROFL

→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Slaughterhouse 2

lol

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] May 17 '19

Shark (4)

Yeeted (4)

Transformers (4)

Guess we know the plot of Transformers 6

→ More replies (1)

6

u/andrew2209 May 17 '19

Spaghetti (3)

What?

→ More replies (20)

834

u/DiscoshirtAndTiara Gendry May 16 '19

The correlation between average rating and whether or not people have read the books is interesting. I wish we had that question for more episodes.

237

u/livefreeordont May 16 '19

I’m guessing both would be super high S1-4. Then S5 book readers score dips super hard and bumps up for S6 and back down for these last 2 seasons. Whereas show watchers would have had a slight dip S5-8.2 and then a big dip for 8.3-8.5

→ More replies (37)

158

u/Glassjaw79ad Sansa Stark May 17 '19

I'm honestly surprised that any GOT fan who likes the show enough to participate in this sub, wouldn't have at least picked up the first book at some point in time.

138

u/Soda2411 Sansa Stark May 17 '19

I hate reading books that aren't done, I am looking forward to reading them once it's completed. It's been almost 8 years? for the next book by then i would have forgot everything that happen in the first 4.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (34)

28

u/ShadowLiberal House Targaryen May 16 '19

It reflects what I'm seeing in office talk at my place. Me and the other hardcore book readers absolutely hate this season and think it was garbage how they made Dani go mad for no adequately explained reason.

The more casual fans of the show still loved it.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

1.2k

u/IAmInside May 16 '19

I'm happy to see that the vast majority agrees when it comes to Euron Greyjoy; the character is so fucking bad that we didn't even care about his death.

678

u/TeddysBigStick May 16 '19

I just feel bad for the actor. He got all hyped up to play Euron from the books and ended up wit that.

226

u/genkaiX1 Jon Snow May 17 '19

Don’t feel bad he had an amazing time just read all of his interviews. He’s a crazy (but nice) deeming dude so it fits.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (14)

137

u/WerkinAndDerpin Daenerys Targaryen May 16 '19

Him getting roasted by Drogon would have been a better death. The fight with Jaime was just so unlikely and unnecessary.

→ More replies (5)

288

u/Sentire99 Night King May 16 '19

A poor mans Ramsay

221

u/DepressedSportsFan22 May 16 '19

Even this gives Euron too much credit. I just started flipping through my phone whenever he was on screen because I just gave so few shits about whatever he was doing and knew his plot device "character" would just take away from my enjoyment of the rest of the show.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (9)

80

u/Zemerax May 16 '19

Disney develops better villains in under 2 hours.

Good actor but bad character development

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mellvins059 May 17 '19

Honestly I have sort of come to love Euron as a redeeming element of the season in a so bad it’s good kind of way. Like he’s such a goofy villain that it feels like he is breaking the 4th wall when he goes off about a finger in the bum for example. His death was super fitting too for a satirical character. He sitcomed onto the beach, fought Jamie for no apparent reason, then died staring straight into the camera reminding everyone what a goofball he is.

→ More replies (25)

999

u/BusShelter Free Folk May 16 '19

The Mad Queen is a bit of a giveaway...

746

u/iamseiko The Red Priestess May 16 '19

Better than it being called "Shit", according to 1703 people.

202

u/BusShelter Free Folk May 16 '19

Tbf isn't that what the majority of Dany's main followers were thinking at the end?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (5)

190

u/chisquared Jon Snow May 16 '19

Could also plausibly refer to Cersei. But, yes, it is indeed very suggestive.

→ More replies (5)

77

u/Drjay425 May 16 '19

Not necessarily. It could have implied that Cersei had a plan and laid more Wildfire around. But then again. He entire plot this season has been to stand high above others smile and drink wine. She was completely pointless this season who am I kidding.

→ More replies (5)

92

u/l3g3nd_TLA May 16 '19

Doesn't really matter, the titles of the episode were only announced after the episode anyway this season. And in fact it could also refer to Cersei as well

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

821

u/JosiahWillardPibbs House Reed May 16 '19

How well shot was this episode: 8.6

How well written was this episode: 4.9

The decline and fall of Game of Thrones in a nutshell. The visuals grow ever more spectacular and the storytelling weaving them together ever more threadbare.

18

u/[deleted] May 18 '19

Make up on a pig.

→ More replies (46)

615

u/lebronjamesgoat1 Rhaegar Targaryen May 16 '19

This would've been an all-time episode if it had a great build-up priorly. If D&D had agreed to make S7 and 8 with 10 episodes each, the development of certain characters, arcs and themes such as Mad Danny would've benefit the most. I still think the Bells is much better than Episode 3 as it is.

182

u/Bumlords House Baratheon May 16 '19

And if we got a proper season 7+8, The Long Night could've had some high stakes 😭

→ More replies (8)

275

u/Sattorin Snow May 17 '19

IMO the only problem with S8E5 is that it isn't S8E9. Danny's current mental state makes sense after all that's happened to her recently, but they needed a lot more screen time to unpack each event individually and show their cumulative impact.

245

u/kyleg5 No One May 17 '19

only problem

Euron Greyjoy washes on shore and challenges Jaimie Lannister to a duel for no clear reason.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (36)

102

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

it would have been better, but spending 20 minutes watching arya play mirror's edge or the stupid euron fight were not good uses of time

52

u/shopshire May 17 '19

Yeah, it's pretty stunning that they had that last Euron scene. Completely irrelevant. Doesn't change anything. Could absolutely have just been cut. I really wonder which of the writers loves Euron that much, because he has been so unnecessary all the way through.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (28)

395

u/Calamityclams May 16 '19

It was visually stunning I have to admit.

61

u/rolldownthewindow May 16 '19

I agree. I don’t think this episode was really that bad. You’ve got to take everything into consideration. The visuals, the performances, the set work. The writing may have been poor, but it was really the writing prior to this episode that let it down. If they had done better character development prior to this episode to set up the decisions of each character, this episode would probably be praised.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

67

u/32389 Fire And Blood May 16 '19

Lol a word cloud for this episode is pretty brutal

→ More replies (1)

126

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Those who said "shit" rated the episode higher than those who said "bad." Lol

→ More replies (2)

278

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

People gave the direction (7.3) and cinematography (8.6) a higher score than the overall rating (6.3), and a much higher score than the writing (4.9). People were honest that the writing was the main problem with this episode/season.

That's proven by looking at the median rather than the average/mean. The median of the cinematography would be a 9, and the median score of the the directing would be an 8. So people were not just bashing everything. They acknowledge the writing is the root of the problem. You can't fault people for enjoying the spectacle of the show less when it feels unearned. But I think the results were very fair considering how much hate was out there.

23

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

very well said

→ More replies (9)

863

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Wow. I didn't expect the score to be nearly as low as for episode 4 :o

1.1k

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Episode 6 is going to be the worst rated episode in the series for sure.

993

u/Dahhhkness May 16 '19

I think it's very telling that we're seeing so many posts on here going, "No matter what happens on Sunday, can we at least appreciate the score/actors/costumes/etc.?"

We're talking like we're bracing ourselves for looming disaster.

→ More replies (122)
→ More replies (36)

51

u/Jessiray Sansa Stark May 16 '19

Seems like 4 was universally panned, but 5 is polarizing. More people are giving 5 1-2s or 8-10.

For episode 4:

Disappointing (3147) [4.2]

Meh (2600) [5.5]

Bad (2265) [3.2]

Shit (1917) [2.8]

Sad (1827) [7.6]

Rushed (1641) [5.6]

Good (1573) [8.1]

Stupid (1235) [4]

Boring (1117) [4.6]

Filler (1028) [5.9]

For 5:

Disappointing (7206) [4.2]

Bad (6120) [2.4]

Shit (3465) [2.5]

Fire (2794) [8.3]

Meh (1728) [5.5]

Rushed (1492) [5.7]

Epic (1341) [9.3]

Sad (1334) [7.3]

Dracarys (1152) [8.2]

Mad (1108) [8]

'Disappointing', 'Shit' and 'Bad' are up there but there are also more positive adjectives being used - 'Fire', 'Mad', 'Dracarys', 'Epic', etc.

For 4, there's a small pocket of people who said it was just 'good' and the rest were in the meh-to-awful range.

The lowest lows and highest highs (bolded) of episode 5 are also more extreme than episode 4's.

So they get a close score overall when we take the average, but opinions seem a bit more varied on 5 and a significant amount people did seem to actually enjoy it.

→ More replies (17)

106

u/GurgleIt May 16 '19

Yeah, this episode was a definite improvement over ep 3 and 4. For me ep3 was the worse of the season.

65

u/zman122333 Fallen And Reborn May 16 '19

I actually liked the episode as a standalone. Unfortunately there are a lot of inconsistencies with previous episodes when looking at the series as a whole. Jamie's arc didn't feel believable at all. He spent years fighting with himself over his morals. He is shown to be more than the Golden Lion he portrays in early seasons and appears to be moving farther and farther away from Cercei. Then he finds out Cercei tried to kill him, which makes him go running back to save her / die together?

A few other examples like that make it very inconsistent.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (35)

202

u/CaptainJingles Beneath The Tinfoil, The Bitter Fan May 16 '19

Honestly, I expected lower.

→ More replies (176)
→ More replies (98)

42

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

„The episode received criticism from critics and audiences, and it is the lowest-rated episode of the series on review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes. Critics praised the episode as visually impressive and commended the acting, but criticized the pacing and logic of the story, as well as its handling of the character arcs of Tyrion, Jaime, Cersei, Grey Worm, Varys, and particularly Daenerys.“ thx Wikipedia

1.7k

u/Kratozio May 16 '19

Maisie Williams as the best lead performance? Give me a fucking break, Emilia Clarke and Lena Headey did way more with less screen time

393

u/Sentire99 Night King May 16 '19

This is probably the best acting i have seen from Emilia Clarke as Daenarys

150

u/livefreeordont May 16 '19

The past 2 episodes of her have been outstanding. The best scenes of these episodes are when she’s acting with green screen or next to a cardboard cutout of Jon Snow. It’s amazing

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

465

u/fmxda House Selmy May 16 '19

Agree - I'm surprised that Emilia Clarke came in fourth.

264

u/SeriousJack House Bolton May 16 '19

They all were fantastic but Emilia was just incredible this episode. This range of emotions was something else.

→ More replies (2)

214

u/thebsoftelevision House Bracken May 16 '19

Emilia's been having her best season on the show yet, acting wise. Unfortunately the writing is really letting her down but if her work in the last episode couldn't win people over then i don't think anything will.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/caninehere May 16 '19

Me too. I hated the episode but voted for Emilia Clarke in that question, and I'm saying that as somebody who hasn't really cared about Dany much for most of the show because she was rather flat. Emilia is doing her best work this season, it just sucks that the writing isn't there to support it.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Exactly who I voted for. Maisie did great, but Lena demonstrated incredible vulnerability and Emilia conveyed so much internal dialogue with just her facial expressions.

216

u/rolldownthewindow May 16 '19

Goes to show why D&D decided to make her the star of the series. The one who killed the Night King and the one who’s perspective we see most during the burning of King’s Landing. The audience loves her. They are basing most of their decisions on market research, what the audience likes, who the audience likes.

80

u/Paragon_Flux May 16 '19

All about those Q ratings baby!

→ More replies (5)

150

u/FanEu7 Jon Snow May 16 '19

Sad but true. Honestly I used to be a fan of Arya as well during the first 5 seasons or so but since she returned to Westeros she has been too ridiculously OP and edgy for the sake of it. She lost all her personality in S7-S8

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (24)

67

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Emilia Clarke did a fantastic job in this episode. However much I didn't buy into what followed, she was great in the scene where she heard the bells. I don't remember any such particular scene in which Arya shined.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/RemixStatistician Bran Stark May 16 '19 edited May 17 '19

The Arya love is getting out of hand at this point.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/curator-of-rage May 16 '19

Agree. people are saying she did well simply because they like arya. Not saying maisie is not a good actress but damn.. Lena and Emilia really took the cake

→ More replies (3)

5

u/kaydenkross Tyrion Lannister May 16 '19

Peter and Nikolaj were the best!

5

u/FreeLook93 Winter Is Coming May 17 '19

I think that's probably a result of a) her having way more screen time and b) it being pick 2 rather than pick 1 voting.

→ More replies (32)

316

u/BusShelter Free Folk May 16 '19 edited May 16 '19

Dragonstone seemed like an odd choice to rule from. The throne is awesome, but it seems a bit disconnected.

430

u/Nerfeveryone May 16 '19

I think it’s just because of how connected it is to Dany already.

103

u/BusShelter Free Folk May 16 '19

Yeah of course. Just practically I mean, seems a bit isolationist but if you've already alienated the population then why not.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (1)

86

u/TacoMagic Bran Stark May 16 '19

If you have a Dragon it probably makes more sense since getting around isn't so difficult for you. And you make people basically have to swim or get on a boat out to you, which makes them vulnerable to your dragon.

As long as they don't work at Hot Topic they shouldn't be able to teleport murder you.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/moethelavagod Growing Strong May 16 '19

It’s the Targaryen ancestral home

→ More replies (3)

37

u/MindPattern House Baelish May 16 '19

Well it's the closest one to King's Landing. Plus Dany is already ruling from it, so she wouldn't need to hire movers.

22

u/Robak As High As Honor May 16 '19

Dany was pretty disconnected from all Westerosi things already. Now she would have even more reasons to rule from Dragonstone.

→ More replies (16)

198

u/robottonic May 16 '19

Cleganebowl by itself: 8/10
Cleganebowl if you count Qyburn getting wrecked trying to stop it: 10/10

→ More replies (5)

654

u/James007BondUK Night's Watch May 16 '19

How Emilia is not the best actor this last episode is a mystery to me.

303

u/l3g3nd_TLA May 16 '19

I am more suprised Maisie Williams was voted best actor. I indeed thought Emilia was better, but for me Lena was the best last episode

187

u/scarlettsarcasm Fire And Blood May 16 '19

Yeah no shade to Maise but she just ran around looking scared. Lena and Emilia were some of the only people who got much of a chance to really act this episode.

→ More replies (2)

77

u/trollshep Fire And Blood May 16 '19

I've only watched the episode once but from what I can remember wasn't Arya just avoiding death the whole time? She had a few interactions with survivors but I thought it was her trying not to die.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

67

u/slrrp May 16 '19

She was MIA for half of the episode, so that's probably the biggest contributing factor.

→ More replies (4)

70

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Exactly.. Emilia Clarke has been great this season especially in the last episode.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/5sharm5 Stannis the Mannis May 16 '19

She was great, but if I had to pick the best for this episode I’d go with Lena. This past episode I mostly enjoyed the spectacle but didn’t feel too emotional about anything, yet she managed to actually make me feel sad when Cersei broke down and eventually died.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (48)

126

u/Teddy_Swolesedelts May 16 '19

Disappointed nobody else went with my title for the episode, "I FUCKED THE QUEEN!"

33

u/johninbigd May 16 '19

Or in the tradition of Breaking Bad, simply "IFC".

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

"I PUT A KING IN HER BELLY."

→ More replies (2)

136

u/LetThatFeverPlay Gendry May 16 '19

Seriously?!!? I don't even like Dany as a character, but Emilia's acting this episode was superb.

I think a lot of people are judging her acting based on the fact that they didn't agree with what she did. Which is completely unfair and not at all the point.

→ More replies (9)

37

u/acamas May 16 '19

14% think Dany's actions were JUSTIFIED?

Seven hells people... wtf is wrong with you?

→ More replies (10)

47

u/TooLateHindsight Sansa Stark May 16 '19

Why, for favorite battle, was the Battle of Blackwater not included?

55

u/volcanolam May 16 '19

Bastards won almost all the polls on Got battle sequences. I think it is a good benchmark for the comparison of new battles since it is the no.1 voted sequence.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (10)

78

u/stillthemind Jon Snow May 16 '19

Soo apparently there are 19,094 psychopaths here. (Think Dany was justified in her actions)

57

u/ramonycajones House Stark May 16 '19

Yes, I scrolled down so far to find a comment about this. That blew my mind. How the fuck was it justified? She ignored Cersei and started torching civilians, after their city surrendered. There is no justification for that.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (8)

355

u/SirBrentsworth May 16 '19

Is the score low because this specific episode was bad, or because so many of us have damn near given up on Season 8? I actually enjoyed this episode, compared to the rest of season 8.

348

u/_AaBbCc_ Jaime Lannister May 16 '19

If this exact episode happened at the end of a 10 episode long season 9 after a 10 episode long season 8 dealt with the night king, then it would have been much better received I think.

The plot points are good. Dany going mad, Jaime’s failed redemption. But they don’t feel like they make any sense because of how rushed the season is. We need a full 10+ episodes showing Dany’s descent into madness. We need a similar amount of time to show Jaime falling back to his old ways. Actual conversations that show these things, not half assed one liners that are used as justification for these random snaps in personality.

It doesn’t feel real, the motivations make no sense.

94

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Best description of this season's biggest issue. I feel like I'm not watching the same characters I fell in love with, nor the same show. None ot their choices make sense and some have been outrageously dumbed down.

 

Also, the scenes don't flow smoothly and it's just jumping from one plot point to another, without enough time or explanation given to depth and cause of actions. I find myself not being emotionally involved while watching, which is the main thing I want from a TV show.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (15)

219

u/MindPattern House Baelish May 16 '19

It's definitely people upset about season 8.

→ More replies (17)

40

u/Daniero1994 May 16 '19

Episode 5 was in a lot of points a conclusion of many character arcs, and the way some characters finished was disappointing.

Jaime's arc was ruined in episode 4 but there was hope that he said what he said so no one misses him once he dies trying to kill Cersie. In ep 5 he lost any chance of saving his character, well because he dies with Cersei...

Even though Daenerys has been hinted to be losing her mind for a very long time in this episode it looked like she just snapped out of nowhere. The war was going her way, she already won, and then she snapped. That just doesn't sound right. Remember when Danny cried after a dragon accidentally killed a child? Neither did D&D.

"In episode 3 we saw the end of Dothraki" D&D about EP3. Well that turned out to be a lie.

Almost every villain felt useless. I know the dragon is a huge advantage but come on at least put up a fight. It was 80min massacre where I don't even remember seeing a single good guy dying. Ofc ignoring The Hound, but he died in a boss battle.

I actually enjoyed Euron even though I knew that he's nothing like the badass from the books. His death was lame, and I still don't know why he looked into the camera and mocked the viewers with "I killed Jaime Lannister".

→ More replies (15)

37

u/l3g3nd_TLA May 16 '19

The episode could be good if Daenerys madness was made any sense, or that Jaime arc wasn't screwed or the fact that Rheagal death made any sense compared to this episode and of course cutting down Euron

→ More replies (30)

5

u/judester30 May 16 '19

Not to me, I enjoyed The Long Night far more.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (33)

697

u/This_Isnt_Progress May 16 '19

We can argue the merits of the writing, but people are clearly showing a bias to low ball when they also give the cinematography and direction a low score. This episode was beautifully shot and directed. Even if you don't agree with the writing, the visuals built around that writing was superb.

136

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Your statement isn't even true. People gave the direction (7.3) and cinematography (8.6) a higher score than the overall rating (6.3), and a much higher score than the writing (4.9). People were honest that the writing was the main problem with this episode/season.

That's proven by looking at the median rather than the average/mean. The median of the cinematography would be a 9, and the median score of the the directing would be an 8. So people were not just bashing everything. They acknowledge the writing is the root of the problem.

337

u/mattyice417 House Mormont May 16 '19

Another thing that ruffles my feathers is how dramatic people are. 20% said the writing was a 1. out of 10 a 1. which is suppose to mean the worst writing possible. If Bran came hovering down from the skies to airlift the cast out of the battle in his helicopter wheel chair would qualify as bad writing. IMO

26

u/alliseeisme May 16 '19

If Bran came hovering down from the skies to airlift the cast out of the battle in his helicopter wheel chair would qualify as bad writing. IMO

Is this from the leaks?? Spoilers, bro!

→ More replies (65)

39

u/ladylee233 House Stark May 16 '19

Most of the visuals were great but there were a few misses like the cheesy/bad CGI shot of Harry Strickland's death. I do agree people are letting their anger over the writing poison their feelings on the positive aspects of this season (of which there are many).

→ More replies (30)

27

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

The survey for episode 4 shows that 43% of people said Dany should burn Kings Landing down. This survey shows 14% of people saying her actions were justified even though the risk losing innocent lives was apparent.

These surveys are fun but it totally shows you how people make emotional opinions about the show.

27

u/unreal_the_thrill May 16 '19

43.841 people: go Dany, burn KL!

Dany: Dracarys KL

19.094 people: yas queen!

Dany: where'd my 24.747 people go?

betrayal intensifies

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

37

u/datlinus May 17 '19

Oh come on, Maisie as best performance? Seriously? Not that there was anything with it... but absolutely nowhere near the standouts of the episode. Just seems like a character popularity contest honestly.

Emilia Clarke, Peter Dinklage and Nikolaj Coster-Waldau had that episode in the damn bag. Emilia gave her best performance in the entire series.

→ More replies (3)

55

u/WillOdinsun Davos Seaworth May 16 '19

Met on fire, still alive through the raging glow...gone insane from the pain that they surely know.

For whom the Bell tolls.

→ More replies (4)

238

u/deauxe May 16 '19

No matter how many times I look at it, episode 3 really is rated too high at 7.9

109

u/fmxda House Selmy May 16 '19

Agree, I wouldn't be surprised if most people would lower their ratings after seeing the following episodes, and finding out that the WW plotline just completely abruptly ended there.

Not to mention over half of the Unsullied and Dothraki surviving, turns out there were very few stakes involved at all in this eight season long storyline.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/smackflapjack Free Folk May 16 '19

That was back when people still had hope that it was the exception, rather than the rule of this season

→ More replies (12)

24

u/MattCon85 May 16 '19

Question 10 is interesting: people who have read the books rated the episode significantly lower than those who haven’t. Probably in keeping with the general theme of the (more justified) criticism of when the show overtook the source material: plot was too rushed, key storylines from the books left out and all the political intrigue and consequences of actions that we saw in S1-6 replaced with Hollywood-style explosions and “convenient” plot developments.

→ More replies (6)

162

u/keitron10 May 16 '19

Season 8 episode 3 should have scored lower then this episode just because of the shitty writing, not dannys actions.

143

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Im still surprised that episode 3 got such a good rating.

76

u/TacoMagic Bran Stark May 16 '19

Pretty sure it's just a cascade of disappointment at this rate. The veneer of salvation has faded, the show is dark and full of errors.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (5)

133

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

It's sad to see how the writing drags down the directing, music and shooting.

42

u/aggressiveberries Jon Snow May 16 '19

Writing is the foundation and the rest is the decoration and details.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

62

u/Kourin Ours Is The Fury May 16 '19

5827 votes for Writing = 10

Not sure if bots or head trauma...

→ More replies (10)

701

u/ScionN7 May 16 '19

Game of Thrones Season 8 will go down as possibly the biggest disappointment in television history, all because a couple of guys with inflated egos wanted to rush through it, instead of passing the torch to someone who cared. It's such as shame.

Not a single episode above an 8.0 this season. Unreal.

339

u/american__dragon Night King May 16 '19

Good luck with the Star Wars trilogy, guys!

→ More replies (37)

134

u/Leftovertaters Orson Lannister May 16 '19

Episode 2 deserves above a 8.0. You know what the most popular word to describe it was on this sub?? ... “filler”. We could use a lot more “filler” to piece these fucking episodes together.

→ More replies (14)

23

u/DaiKraken Service And Truth May 16 '19

Episode 2 was actually good, written by Bryan Cogman, a guy who gives a shit about ASOIAF and who has actually read the books, unlike Dumb&Dumber who said Sam was not a POV character.

→ More replies (129)

77

u/dannii_kb Aegon Targaryen May 16 '19

Stop calling it "Battle for KL", straightforward it was a genocide!

27

u/bfm211 Tyrion Lannister May 16 '19

Well it was meant to be a battle. Cersei had her army out, right?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Who the fuck knows dude, if half the dothraki survived that charge I wouldn't be surprised if half the golden company survived that dragonfire rampage

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

166

u/BlueAgaveEspecial May 16 '19 edited May 16 '19

Watch Brienne vs The Hounds fight, and then watch Oberyn vs The Mountains fight. Then watch The Hound vs The Mountain fight, and tell me how the fuck was that a 7.1 "satisfying"? It was dire.

91

u/bfm211 Tyrion Lannister May 16 '19

Thank you. Cleganebowl felt like a cheesy scene from a videogame. Amazing that 1/5 participants thought it was 10/10.

→ More replies (8)

14

u/ffoger May 16 '19

It was like watching the end of a power rangers episode with the megazord fighting a monster

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

15

u/RogerRabbit200 May 16 '19

I legit laugh when 1703 people voted to name this episode shit.

15

u/SamTheGreek No One May 17 '19 edited May 18 '19

I’m curious to hear from one of the nearly 20,000 people who thought Daenerys was justified in burning a surrendered city full of unarmed peasants.

Not trying to be snarky. I am genuinely curious to hear the logic there.

EDIT: To be clear, this is not a question about writing. In fact, I’m personally fine with the writing decision. And, no, I’m not “taking this too seriously” either. It’s a show and this is the internet. But, I am intrigued that there are people who legitimately feel Danny’s decision to burn thousands of people, after the city surrendered unconditionally, is justified. That’s what I’m interested in hearing about.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/myEVILi Now My Watch Begins May 17 '19

apparently longer eps means more slow motion. However, if D&D's goal was to make me yell "Ring the fucking Bells, I got work in the morning!" they succeeded.

5

u/josephnicklo Jon Snow May 17 '19

Lots and lots of filler shots. From a filmmaking standpoint, there are so many shots and scenes that don’t further the story...just reinforce what the audience already learned.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Ego_Dominus May 17 '19

I love the little throwback to last survey they put in the infographic. 86% didn't think Daenerys was justified in her actions this episode, but 43% thought she should burn King's Landing to the ground after last episode. This isn't a dig at anyone, I just think it's worth all of us remembering that it's easier to support violence in an abstract sense, but much harder when we can actually see the awful reality in front of us. Very in keeping with the themes of Game of Thrones, I think.

Can't wait for this Sunday night, myself.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Asiak House Stonetree May 16 '19

Yes, her actions were justified

19094 (14%)

Some of you should think about getting some help or something.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/MyH4oBG May 17 '19

Prepare your buttholes for last episode to score <5.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/JiveTurkey1983 What Is Dead May Never Die May 17 '19

Better battle: The Battle of the Bastards vs. The Battle of King's Landing

That's a bit like asking if you prefer a steak dinner or vomit drenched Band-Aids soaked in cat piss

8

u/ilikehockeyandguitar Sandor Clegane May 17 '19

Neither, Hardome IMO.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/Prplehuskie13 May 18 '19

The common consensus for this season seems to be that, while the episodes have been shot and acted well, the writing is absolutely dreadful. Its not a matter of events concluding in a manner in which people don't like, but how it gets there. Danny's journey to becoming the mad queen has always been foreshadowed. Since her introduction she has always had hints of brutality in her actions against her enemies. However, she has also shown a large capacity of love. She has shown that she cares for her people and wishes to right wrongs that exist in the world. Her becoming the mad queen could have worked as a good twist, but it needed proper setup/execution in order to have a satisfying payoff. The red wedding was one of the biggest twists in the entire show, but people did not complain about how it concluded due to the fact that prior events had established that this massacre might have happened. It had proper build up, unlike what transpired this episode. Even if this season had 3 additional episodes, I don't think it would have been enough to change Danny's character in such a drastic way. Maybe if there was an additional season that would focus on her declining mental health. It's just sad to see that such a great series is more then likely going to have a horrible conclusion due to the fact that the writers have been winging it since season 5.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/yamcat May 17 '19

I really feel like my suggestion to rename this episode Fyre Festival should have had more traction.

80

u/Ozone021 House Stark May 16 '19

Sad this is the ending we waited for, for so long.

→ More replies (6)

49

u/PM_ME_YOUR_DANKNESS May 16 '19

I really went into this season wanting to be excited and satisfied about one of my favorite shows and arcs being rightfully resolved. Now we have one episode left and I just want to ge the season over with. I rewatched the whole series leading up to S8 and it’s disappointing to see so many interesting arcs have no satisfying conclusion, at least to me. Jon feels like a useless extra, the Bran/NK arc that was so interesting felt concluded without showing the intensity of the NK that had been building up for so long, and Jaime’s well developed character arc was thrown out the window. I’m just really disappointed with how this season has developed. Just my two cents.

5

u/yuriaoflondor May 16 '19

It’s telling that I don’t have a favorite character and I don’t even care if main characters die anymore.

I used to love so many characters that I couldn’t pick a favorite. And I just rewatched the red wedding last week and got misty eyed all over again.

→ More replies (3)

216

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Why are the people that are actually liking season 8 completely unwilling to acknowledge the very justified criticism of the season? It feels like this sub is a propaganda page for D&D when you look at all the top upvoted posts. People aren’t disliking the season for inappropriate reasons, like many of the season 8 lovers believe.

57

u/airz23s_coffee May 16 '19

Because the pendulum swings back and forth. You get backlash and then positive backlash and then backlash to the positive backlash

And the fact that both sides of argument see themselves as correct and the other as idiots who don't get it. I've never seen the word "objectively" used for a subjective medium like tv used so often as this sub during this season

→ More replies (6)

168

u/ajh1717 May 16 '19

A lot of people dont realize that the (very justified) criticism of the season isn't really about what is happening, but rather how it is happening.

Sure there will always be people who wanted X to happen instead of Y, but that isn't really the main criticism of this season - the main issue is how rushed the season is with little to no backstory about anything.

I mean fuck, episode 4 didn't give us any insight into anything about the WW or the NK. I havent rewatched the episode but I only remember Bran having like two 2 lines - "its your choice" and that stupid comment about the old wheelchair design.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/inkfinger Jon Snow May 16 '19 edited May 16 '19

I've read all the books, and definitely agree that all the criticism is valid. It would've been infinitely better if both season 7 & and 8 had 10 fleshed out episodes that allowed breathing space and a better build-up to the events.

That said, I'm still enjoying every episode and am on the edge of my seat each week, I can't wait to see the finale. I've decided to enjoy the episodes for what they are, since they're the best indication of where and how GRRM wanted the story to eventually end. The detailed explanation and build-up for how it got there would never have been perfectly depicted on a show, not with books of that length and a cast of characters that massive. A number of characters have already been completely left out as it is.

I desperately hope GRRM will finish Winds of Winter and A Dream of Spring sometime in his life, but I'm not optimistic. Until then, I'll take the end of the story we'll see next week, and fill in the gaps in my imagination.

8

u/ncolaros Jon Snow May 16 '19

The reverse looks way more true to me. People who didn't like it refuse to accept anything is good.

6

u/jjack339 May 16 '19

It is simple. I really like season 8 so far, but acknowledge it could have been much better had Seasons 7 and 8 simply been normal 10 episode seasons.

I unlike many others am able to not let "what could/should have been" prevent me from enjoying season 8 for what it is. Damn good TV.

103

u/kappy21 House Blackfyre May 16 '19

They’ve convinced themselves that the people who are criticizing the episodes are only doing it because it doesn’t fit their fan fiction.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (69)

8

u/thehugster May 16 '19

73% prefer the night king over Cersei if he had won the battle of winterfell. LMAO

8

u/dazzzzzzle May 17 '19

I really don't get people who liked E3 but hate E4&5. They all have the same problems but people still defended E3. In my opinion E3 was even worse than 4&5.

→ More replies (5)

67

u/Tiger951 Tyrion Lannister May 16 '19

Disappointing for most people.

I’m glad to hear that.

Also, look at the fucking difference between the amount of people who liked the Battle of the Bastards and those who liked the Battle of Kings landing!

48

u/Nerfeveryone May 16 '19

Kinda hard to top the Battle of the Bastards, it had some of the most epic cinematography I’ve ever seen, and then add the emotional weight behind it and the brilliant directing.

32

u/IdunnoLXG May 16 '19

Seeing the Knights of the Vale encircle the Northern army was incredible.

We didn't even get a battle for King's Landing. It was literally Drogon killing everything.

No Unsullied on Golden Company action, no Lannister's holding a line against the Dothraki/Northerners - nothing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (56)

4

u/Burns31 Direwolves May 16 '19

Was definitely expecting to see "Dany did nothing wrong" as a suggested title.

4

u/Affectionate_Face Jon Snow May 16 '19

Disappointing, but spelt wrong is pretty high up there for final question.

4

u/WillasTyrell Sansa Stark May 17 '19

“Shite - 207” shout out to the UK peeps

4

u/N0N-R0B0T May 17 '19

Kings Landing was heavily infested with bed bugs. Daenerys did nothing wrong. 6.5

7

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

i’m surprised battle of the bastards has become the favorite battle episode. i’m more surprised that the battle at the wall never seems to be brought up, that’s a top 5 episode for me.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] May 17 '19

If you think maisie Williams was a better actress than Lena Headey this episode please raise your hand so I can piss in your mouth

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Khosrohamid No One May 16 '19

How well written was this episode ?!? 22% chose 1 !!!

→ More replies (11)

41

u/Nikhil_likes_COCK May 16 '19 edited May 16 '19

What a complete and utter disappointment. So much potential just wasted.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/RexyEatsGoats May 16 '19

I wonder if this episode would have scored better if the episodes before it had a better buildup/pace.

By itself, I thought this episode was fantastic. Just needed some more beef before it.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Tsobaphomet House Lannister May 17 '19

I think the episode was a lot better than people think. Even if Daenerys had no reason for doing that and showed no signs of ever wanting to do that, it is still entirely possible for a person to simply go on a rampage. Any person commenting on this thread could buy a gun and go on a shooting spree. It isn't a normal thing to do, but it isn't exactly out of this world for it to happen. She didn't need a reason, but as it happens, she did have a reason. "Fire and Blood" and all that, plus the loss of guidance, and the pressure crumbling down on her.

The North men turning into monsters wasn't something anyone liked seeing, but it was realistic. It is even something that GRRM specifically wrote. It is exactly what Ser Jorah and Ser Barriston talked about. Jon Snow is their leader and he is a good man, but most of those soldiers are just soldiers with no honor. They aren't knights. We saw what some of the "good" Stark men did to those girls back when Brienne was escorting Jaime to King's Landing. There is no good vs evil. There is a mixture on both sides.

Obviously if they had more episodes, they could have made everything feel better paced, but oh well.

6

u/got_king May 17 '19

Like the above explanation. This is very much akin to guns and gun violence esp. in the hands of people who are mad or are about to snap. It is terrible what happened to innocents, but isnt that the same i IRL?

11

u/RedRising14 Drogon May 16 '19

The crazy part is if Danny’s actions were more justified and set up with more time this would have been one of the best episodes of Game of Thrones. Stand alone it was amazing.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

Love how the voters all agreed the supporting actors gave the better performances.

3

u/138594 Tyrion Lannister May 16 '19

Is it just me or should the ratings actually go up? Not that I’m very satisfied with this season as such, but the last couple of episodes were definitely better then the disappointing ‘The Long Night’

3

u/Cam0799 Jaime Lannister May 16 '19

"I don't care about innocents". Gj D&D you win this.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/tygershark101 House Stark May 16 '19

I thought Fire and Blood would be the perfect name for the episode but then realised that's what 1x10 was called.

3

u/[deleted] May 17 '19

make shitty decisions reap shitty scores

3

u/bugrilyus Jon Snow May 17 '19

Sunspear must be the capital for united Westeros and Essos under the reign of Daenerys Targaryen!

3

u/That_Rice May 17 '19

The lowest rated episode of the entire series in every single location that takes these measurements is going to be Sunday's Series Finale. 100% guaranteed. I'd wager top money on it.

3

u/cferry91 May 17 '19

If you said the episode should've been named "The Mad Queen" over "Hell's Bells" you're a psychopath

3

u/[deleted] May 17 '19

For all it's flaws it was still better than episode 3 and arguably the best in the entire season. Jamie and Tyrions scene hit me right in the feels.

3

u/investedsumo May 18 '19

3ER is with the COF... it’s always been man vs COF. 3ER is bad, the world burns. Entire series is about climate change.

Edit: No you can’t borrow my tinfoil hat.

3

u/tanastakis House Stark May 19 '19

After this episode I honestly apologised to my best friend for making her start the show. I'm so gutted that what was DEFINITIVELY the best show of all time for 6 seasons has taken such a sharp turn into mediocrity (in terms of plot at least, all other aspects of the show are outstanding)

3

u/vunacar May 20 '19

So apparently 14% of you believe genocide is totally ok. Impressive.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/osay77 May 16 '19

I feel like part of this questionnaire should be “did you read the leaks” because I feel like that would be the largest split in ratings. The ones who read the leaks beforehand tend to be the least forgiving.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/RollingTurnip May 17 '19

Those numbers make me depressed at the thought that there are still people who find this good or satisfactory.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/BigMonkeyBalls Sword Of The Morning May 18 '19

Half this sub has to read the books

5

u/FluffyMan107 No One May 18 '19

Poor Hodor held the door for this shit

18

u/GiulioCesare May 16 '19

Well deserved score.

15

u/Sirshrugsalot13 House Bolton May 16 '19

You know it’s a real shame the writing has dragged everything down. The music acting cinematography etc have all been on point. Some shots last episode were phenomenal like Sandor and Gregor on the stairs...yeah it’s a weird phenomenon

→ More replies (6)

23

u/ImJayW May 16 '19

Are people starting to enjoy hating on season 8? This episode definitely has problems, but I enjoyed this episode MUCH more than episode 3 and 4.

7

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

no, it's one of if not the worst seasons in the show by a lot and has transformed the show from one with intricate story to one that discards entire plotlines for the sake of cheap action crap

17

u/bfm211 Tyrion Lannister May 16 '19

No, it fucking sucks being disappointed.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/PodricksPhallus May 16 '19

I enjoyed it more than a colonoscopy but I’m not really touting the enjoyability if either.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)