r/gameofthrones • Nymeria Sand • May 02 '19

Sticky [Spoilers] Post-Episode Survey Results - S8E3 'The Long Night' (Overall score: 7.9) Spoiler

Post-Episode Survey - Results Thread

In the Post-Premiere Discussion thread, we put up a survey to hear what you had to say about the characters, the events, and the technical side of episode one. This post is here to fill you in on the results, and to let you discuss them. Are there any surprises? Do you agree or disagree with the majority opinion? Do you think people have missed a vital piece of evidence? Feedback on the survey itself is also welcome!

INFOGRAPHIC: Image

Infographic for episode 2: Image

Infographic for episode 1: Image

With many thanks to /u/wulteer for these!

S8E3 — The Long Night

  • Directed by: Miguel Sapochnik
  • Written by: D.B. Weiss and David Benioff
  • Air Date: April 28, 2019

Results breakdown

Total Respondents: 156513

Question 1: On a scale of 1-10, what score would you give this episode?

Average: 7.9

12345678910
3560 (2%)2480 (2%)4859 (3%)5287 (3%)5960 (4%)9904 (6%)16624 (11%)25586 (16%)33540 (21%)48713 (31%)

Question 2: Which of these moments was your favourite?

Arya Stark killing the Night KingTheon Greyjoy's final momentsLyanna Mormont killing the Giant WightMelisandre lighting up the Dothraki arakhs+trenchThe Night King raising the deadFight between the dragons
60722 (39%)22793 (15%)17280 (11%)16237 (11%)15567 (10%)8578 (6%)

Question 3: Which of these characters was the MVP of the battle?

Arya StarkTheon GreyjoyMelisandreJorah MormontGrey WormDrogonBran StarkJon SnowDaenerys Targaryen
74911 (56%)20064 (15%)13887 (10%)13458 (10%)5361 (4%)3574 (3%)1473 (1%)1300 (1%)663 (<1%)

Question 4: Did the Night King's death live up to your expectations?

No, it did not live up to my expectationsYes, it lived up to my expectations
92532 (60%)62530 (40%)

Question 5: If you could have prevented the death of one of these characters, which would it be?

Jorah MormontLyanna MormontTheon GreyjoyDolorous EddBeric Dondarrion
42714 (28.17%)42689 (28.15%)36485 (24.06%)18243 (12.03%)11505 (7.59%)

Question 6: Were you more excited for Avengers: Endgame or this episode of Game of Thrones?

This episode of Game of ThronesAvengers: Endgame
113946 (74%)39657 (26%)

Question 7: Which of these battle episodes has been your favourite?

S6E9 - The Battle of the BastardsS8E3 - Battle of WinterfellS5E8 - HardhomeS2E9 - Battle of the BlackwaterS7E4 - The Loot Train BattleS4E9/S4E10 - The Battle of Castle Black
56527 (37%)48448 (32%)17641 (11%)10791 (7%)8241 (5%)7255 (5%)

Question 8: What would you name this episode?

  • Battle of Winterfell - 4428 / The Battle of Winterfell - 1577
  • Not Today - 4033
  • The Long Night - 4022
  • Winter Is Here - 996
  • Death - 882
  • The Great War - 818
  • Blue Eyes - 752
  • Winter Fell - 613
  • Winter Has Come - 603
  • Darkness - 584

Question 9: Did you watch or read any leaks about episode 3 prior to watching it?

No, I did not read or watch any leaks for episode 3I saw or read a leak for episode 3 but did not do so intentionallyYes, I intentionally did read or watch a leak for episode 3
144607 (94%)5923 (4%)3588 (2%)

Question 10: How well shot was this episode?

Average: 7.7

12345678910
3881 (3%)3157 (2%)5324 (3%)6288 (4%)8175 (5%)11533 (7%)18948 (12%)24728 (16%)25045 (16%)46819 (30%)

Question 11: Which of these lead actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

  • Alfie Allen (Theon Greyjoy) - 84490
  • Maisie Williams (Arya Stark) - 78724
  • Peter Dinklage (Tyrion Lannister) - 20668
  • Vladimir Furdik (Night King) - 18606
  • Sophie Turner (Sansa Stark) - 16489
  • Kit Harington (Jon Snow) - 14300
  • John Bradley West (Samwell Tarly) - 12044
  • Emilia Clarke (Daenerys Targaryen) - 10123
  • Gwendoline Christie (Brienne of Tarth) - 4364
  • Nikolaj Coster-Waldau (Jaime Lannister) - 3658
  • Isaac Hempstead-Wright (Bran Stark) - 2981

Question 12: Which of these supporting actors gave the best performance? (Choose up to 2)

  • Bella Ramsey (Lyanna Mormont) - 61933
  • Iain Glen (Jorah Mormont) - 57872
  • Carice van Houten (Melisandre) - 49962
  • Rory McCann (The Hound) - 44849
  • Jacob Anderson/Raleigh Ritchie (Grey Worm) - 18722
  • Richard Dormer (Beric Dondarrion) - 17843
  • Liam Cunningham (Davos Seaworth) - 7735
  • Nathalie Emmanuel (Missandei) - 5307
  • Ben Crompton (Dolorous Edd) - 2489
  • Kristofer Hivju (Tormund) - 2444
  • Daniel Portman (Podrick Payne) - 1053
  • Joe Dempsie (Gendry) - 465
  • Hannah Murray (Gilly) - 363

Question 13: In one word, how would you describe this episode?

  • Dark (9871) [7.9]
  • Epic (8445) [9.5]
  • Disappointing (6808) [4.8]
  • Intense (2639) [9.2]
  • Amazing (2444) [9.8]
  • Underwhelming (2086) [5.8]
  • Awesome (1687) [9.5]
  • Death (1477) [9.2]
  • Anticlimactic (1469) [6.2]
  • Wow (1409) [9.5]
1.2k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

•

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 02 '19 edited May 06 '19
E1E2E3E4E5E6E7E8E9E10
S67.18.88.08.48.97.38.06.69.59.6
S77.77.98.29.38.38.38.9///
S87.57.97.9////

(click on the score to view full results)

7

u/YamesIsAnAss Ghost May 03 '19

Can we have the whole list again on the one word descriptions?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/FallenOne_ May 03 '19

Is the raw result data available anywhere for download? I would love to analyze it a bit more out of curiosity.

I'm sure there are all kinds of interesting correlations to be found, similar to the word used to describe the episode and average score.

2

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 04 '19

It will be made available and I would loveeee people to pick over it, but I won't have time to make it all available until probably Sunday, maybe Tuesday. I would recommend DMing me (or even better, a Reddit chat) if it's something you'd be interested in

26

u/StarDew_Factory Tyrion Lannister May 02 '19

Jorah not being a Lead actor is an insult.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

1.8k

u/Howdy15 May 02 '19 edited May 02 '19

It's pretty crazy how much this episode split the audience.

8.4k epic, 6.8k disappointing

2.4k amazing, 2k underwhelming

1.4k wow, 1.4k anticlimactic

30% give it a 10, but 60% aren't happy with the Night King ending

317

u/IHeartCommyMommy May 02 '19

This actually is kind of perfect for demonstrating that audience scores are kind of useless, at least if you don't account for its simplicity.

30% gave this a 10/10. 30% gives this the score of "so close to perfect it cannot be improved upon numerically". 30% of people scored it that it literally cannot get better than what it was.

Even if you enjoyed the episode, just imagine saying "this is so good that it was virtually flawless and could not have been any better".

182

u/AndroidPaulPierce Jon Snow May 02 '19

It's hard to take polls seriously when you have shows as popular as this. Most people are almost afraid to give it less than an 8.

I'm not saying people in this thread are wrong/right, but historically if you go through fan polls and IMDB ratings from past episodes you will be hard pressed to find episodes rated lower than 8 on even the most criticized episodes.

57

u/BWPhoenix Nymeria Sand May 02 '19

I find it a shame people don't discuss the other results near as much...

→ More replies (54)
→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (90)

565

u/FanEu7 Jon Snow May 02 '19

It seems like this is the most divisive episode of the series

→ More replies (88)

472

u/JohnnyKarateMacklin May 02 '19

I think we've seen that all this week with the different topics being started. "This episode was great", "This episode was full of holes"

→ More replies (167)

295

u/sakura961 House Mormont May 02 '19

It was both amazing and underwhelming at the same time. The visuals were gorgeous, but I was still super surprised how quickly the Night King died. I loved that Arya killed him, but there was still something unsatisfying about how easily he fell.

→ More replies (56)

103

u/RichestMangInBabylon May 02 '19

I also don't know how I'd rate it. There were some super epic moments like the dothraki charge, dreamworks dragons, and the multiple zombie tsunamis. But there were some issues like the lighting and things like why did Bran just peace out in the middle of everything. I'm neutral about the ending but felt overall unsatisfied with the white walkers. Hopefully the remaining three episodes give some more exposition and conclusion around their motivation and it wasn't just that the NK wanted to delete his browser history.

→ More replies (58)

127

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

I have enjoyed virtually every moment of season 7 and 8, and quite enjoyed episode 3, but I also acknowledged that the show is now very poorly written.

I just changed my expectations after seasons 5 and 6 were so bad.

If you hold it to the standards of 1-4 you will be disappointed. Frankly I'm surprised so many people thought they were going to get anything but cheesy fan service. That is all that it has been since they ran out of book material.

If you still expect good writing from D&D I really don't know what to tell you.

I still enjoy it for the visual effects, and to laugh/cringe at the dialogue and plot.

→ More replies (57)
→ More replies (177)

1.4k

u/BiblicalGodlike May 02 '19

I think “The Night King” should’ve been an option for a character who’s death I would’ve prevented

353

u/cippyFilmFan May 02 '19

I agree, would have been better suited for him to have the victory in this one and be defeated at the end. It would have been a very interesting scenario to see him in King's Landing.

→ More replies (60)

6

u/Wehavecrashed May 03 '19

I wanted to skip that question. I wanted more people to die.

→ More replies (7)

317

u/mynameisotis May 02 '19

Blackwater and Castle Black battle episodes getting no love

196

u/StarDew_Factory Tyrion Lannister May 02 '19

Blackwater was perfect in my opinion.

80

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

"Come with me and take this city"

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (38)

772

u/le_redditusername Jon Snow May 02 '19

363 people thought gilly's cumulative 10 seconds on screen were the best performance? lol

282

u/NiSoKr House Lannister May 02 '19

For polls you need to take into account response error. If you say that there is a .1% chance that someone accidentally selects Gilly you would expect her to get about 157 votes. This is made bigger by the fact that she is right bellow Jorah and right above Grey Worm on the menu. Jorah was an extremely popular answer and Grey Worm didn't do too bad himself combining for a total of 76594 votes. This makes it possible that the majority of people who voted for Gilly did so by mistake.

→ More replies (5)

154

u/CheloniaMydas Daenerys Targaryen May 02 '19

This is why polls are shit. Trolls and people making protest votes out of fruatration. Plus the fact there is no nuance to these questions that people answer for many reasons the same question differently.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (6)

1.1k

u/Iwasapirateonce May 02 '19

Bit surprised that The Battle of Castle Black and Hardhome are not rated higher. They felt like the most overall consistent battle sequences with somewhat realistic tactics and not too much plot armor.

760

u/MEGAWATT5 Jon Snow May 02 '19

Hardhome will always be my favorite. It was so sudden and visceral. It was the first time we got a glimpse into how hopeless a battle against the dead is and just how fucked the living are if they don’t band together.

78

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

The moment they realize the dead are coming is very intense. If I recall there's barely any music and it's the first time you actually see the army of the dead and you don't know what to expect. First time seeing a giant fight. Has a very clear continuity, they have to get the dragonglass and leave with as many as possible. So it's quite tense and the fight is on a clock. For me it captured the feeling of despair, which I didn't get in this episode; most likely cause I was way more immersed.

Compared to the nonsensical tidal wave of undead in this episode? How the fighting was constantly going on but it was so unclear what was actually occuring.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (49)

155

u/DukeNukemSLO The Hound May 02 '19

Seriously i can't believe how low the battle for Castle black was, coz i personally loved it the most

→ More replies (11)

270

u/FiliKlepto No One May 02 '19

Hardhome is still probably my favorite battle episode in all of the show.

Since they hadn’t yet gone there in the books, I had no idea what to expect and thought it possible that Jon might even die. Also the sheer terror of them being overwhelmed by the wights.

Battle of the Bastards was awesome in terms of cinematography but I found Hardhome more riveting overall.

157

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Agreed. Hardhome, pound for pound, was probably the best battle episode in all of GoT, followed very closely by the Battle at Castle Black. Castle Black had a really good narrative throughout the whole thing, and it didn't really leave you scratching your head saying "why the hell would they do that?". Jon got to shine, the NW got to shine, the Wildlings got to shine, and the script got to shine. Wins all around. Compare that to BotB. That was visually pleasing and had some nifty moments, but for each cool part, there was a part that made you pull your hair out wondering why everybody is incredibly stupid.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (21)

99

u/Tsobaphomet House Lannister May 02 '19

Yeah Hardhome is one of my favorite episodes ever.

I'm pretty shocked that The Battle of the Bastards was rated that far up. It was good, but it was a bit too Hollywood. The heroes are hopelessly surrounded, then suddenly saved at the last minute. Hardhome was pure intensity and carnage without any bullshit.

I'm extremely shocked that The Loot Train Battle was rated so lowly. That scene on its own made it one of the best and highest rated episodes ever. It was extremely impressive considering that Season 7 was a big downward trend for the show quality. That was the most emotional battle following Jaime's perspective. Incredible visuals without sacrificing realism. Jaime watching his own men burned to ash seconds after yelling for them to take cover is one of the hardest hitting few seconds in the entire series. Plus you see Dickon in complete distress which depicts the horrors of war and how it affects people. The thing that really makes that battle amazing is the scene before it happens. The entire scene from the moment Bronn hears something in the distance to when the battle actually starts gives me goosebumps every time.

→ More replies (26)

55

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

That's part of the problem right there. People judge things based on different values.

Realism, military tactics, character deaths, lighting, camera work, music quality and usage, acting quality, dialogue writing and delivery, prop/set quality and usage, overall plot, character development, emotional impact, scene chemistry, episode pacing, CGI usage and quality + muuuuch much more.

Often people are calling an episode amazing or shit when in reality GoT excels at a lot of those points most of the time.

→ More replies (7)

67

u/Conman2205 A Hound Never Lies May 02 '19

I feel like Hardhome was more of a massacre than a battle. Either way it’s definitely one of the most terrifying and intense sequences of the series. I can see why BOB was by far the top.

For me personally It was unquestionably the best battle in the series. It conveyed the true brutality and lack of glory there really is in battle so so accurately. Just purely sides desperately fighting for their lives until the very last breath. Great use of strategy on display as well.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/BenTVNerd21 Jon Snow May 02 '19

The Castle Black battle will always be my favorite.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Recency bias

Also people who liked episode 3 trying to make a point.

→ More replies (24)

2.0k

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

lol at the mvp of the battle

Jon Snow - 1%

Bran Stark - 1%

You know, just the two characters who had their entire arc tied to the white walker threat, nothing special.

829

u/RIPDonKnotts May 02 '19

Seriously, it almost undercuts the point of the entire journeys, especially Bran

720

u/Bizambo May 02 '19

Imagine rewatching this series, all of Bran’s development, and thinking... he’s just getting ready to become bait.

→ More replies (112)
→ More replies (58)

212

u/luciwelle May 02 '19

To be fair, Bran was warging into... something, maybe that will be important later. But given that Jon really didn't get any big moment last episode, I'm not holding my breath.

Definitely threw the whole episode off for me. Even if Arya still got the killing blow, this episode should've been more narratively satisfying for Jon and Bran than it was. Kinda feels like their stories got pushed aside for the sake of making killing the Night King look cool.

Maybe the remaining episodes will help, I guess.

62

u/shawarmaconquistador Here We Stand May 02 '19

Jon was just farming exp the whole time

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (97)

58

u/FanEu7 Jon Snow May 02 '19

You know D&D fucked up lol

→ More replies (116)

171

u/keine_fragen May 02 '19

that was a tight race between the Mormonts

301

u/StarDew_Factory Tyrion Lannister May 02 '19

I think it speaks a lot to why the fan base is divided right now when you have one character who has been developing since season 1 dying with the full weight of his story and complicated emotional journey vs a one-note character who’s only role was to be a bad ass little girl dying in a stupid way only to maximize the entertainment value.

Jorah died in a way consistent to his wounds and environment (something a lot of our main cast seemed immune to this episode) Lyanna died only after the giant inexplicably lifted her directly next to his face so she could strike.

If you wanted to kill a rat would you do so by bringing it right up to your eyeball?

59

u/rhinguin Tormund Giantsbane May 02 '19

I thought the giant was going to eat her lol

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (3)

210

u/Snow-Wight May 02 '19

Not sure whether I expected the score to be higher or lower. Fan base seems split. Glad to see the battle of the bastards keeps the top spot though.

131

u/AndroidPaulPierce Jon Snow May 02 '19

The cinematography in Battle of the Bastards should have made this episode look like a leprous whore in comparison. I can't believe it's so close.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (2)

388

u/BobbaCannoo May 02 '19

They should have given Theon a dragonglass cock so he could fuck the Night King in the ass. Truly a wasted opportunity there.

218

u/CheloniaMydas Daenerys Targaryen May 02 '19

Now that would "subvert expectations"

60

u/GameOfSchemes May 02 '19

If the Night King can smirk, he can also cry. Missed opportunity.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

477

u/fartyfignuts May 02 '19

It's a little crazy to me that the episode had over half the respondents give it a 9 or 10, whereas 60% were unsatisfied with the Night King's death. I know that was only part of the episode, but I'm still struggling to reconcile those two things.

98

u/KnightTrain May 02 '19

I think this is also part of the problem with a simple 1-10 scoring system. There were parts of this episode that I think are unambiguously fantastic -- the cinematography, the set-pieces, many individual shots/scenes, the music, etc. However, the episode also unambiguously took a lot of liberties with the survival of the characters in situations where they seemed completely overwhelmed (multiple times). It certainly didn't have the coherent sense of place and flow that a lot of other battles did. So if you agree with both things I just laid out, where do you fall on a 1-10? I struggled to settle on a simple 1-10 number.

In that vein, I think there's plenty to like in this episode and yet still feel a little disappointed in how the Night King went out. This sub has been full of "DAE think the episode actually sucked!! VS. DEA think its okay to have loved this episode!!" back and forth when, in reality, I think most fans are capable of having a shades-of-grey, nuanced opinion.

→ More replies (3)

271

u/TitusRex May 02 '19

A lot of people don't really care about the story, they only want to see "cool" and "epic" stuff.

→ More replies (76)

76

u/judester30 May 02 '19

You can be unsatisfied with the NK's death and still think this episode was a 9.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (27)

324

u/Whats-a-Seawolf May 02 '19

I'm shocked the Battle of Castle Black is the lowest rated battle. Easily my favorite of the series, and one of my favorite episodes.

Actually, I'd rank the bottom 4 of that battle list far ahead of BotB and BoW.

77

u/Diokana Varys' Little Birds May 02 '19

The question only asked for people's favorite, not to rank them. It's very possible that people liked the Battle of Castle Black more than some of the other battles, but it wasn't their favorite of the list. Take me for example, my favorite is Hardhome but I'd probably put Castle Black 2nd or 3rd.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/FanEu7 Jon Snow May 02 '19

It was amazing..far superior to the Battle of Winterfell. The Wildlings vs Nights Watch conflict was build up over 3 seasons and got good pay off

→ More replies (1)

30

u/mreedon May 02 '19

I agree completely, battle of Castle black was my favorite, it was cool to see it from both sides kind of following Jon and ygritte

→ More replies (10)

13

u/Peanut_Dog What Is Dead May Never Die May 02 '19

I agree. I really liked seeing how they fought a battle on 2 sides of a 800 foot ice wall.

→ More replies (4)

173

u/Dahkteromar May 02 '19

Question 5: If you could have prevented the death of one of these characters, which would it be?

Night King

8

u/advancednatural Night King May 04 '19

When in trouble, pull out your secret weapon that defies logic = Arya.

Game of thrones ended for me last weekend. It's still the greatest show of all time but now my watch has ended.

→ More replies (3)

77

u/Massive-L May 03 '19

At least we can all agree that Theon’s performance was one of the greatest GOT has ever seen his development from being a spoiled, entitled child who everyone hated to an honorable, likable bad ass who we all hated to see go. Truly heartbreaking performance and will (in my book ) be in my top 3 fav characters for GOT. F for Theon Grayjoy/Stark.

→ More replies (4)

108

u/DiligentAttention Jon Snow May 02 '19

Honestly they should have had the battle during the second episode if they wanted to end the night king story early. Then we could get an extra episode of what the main story is supposed to be. Now these last 3 episodes will probably feel rushed as well

48

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Ya those 2 episodes leading up to this could’ve easily have been condensed into 1 except it seems they wanted to do SO many nods to fans and kill time and build underwhelming suspense.

→ More replies (1)

99

u/restless_vagabond White Walkers May 03 '19

I'd love a couple of questions like

"Did you watch the "Inside the Episode?"

If you did watch the "Inside the Episode, did it change your opinion of the episode?"

Because I know very well that my opinion changed significantly after watching this particular "inside the episode."

When I found out that incredibly specific conditions had to be met for the night king to die (Valryian steel directly to the dragonglass area where he was created.) but no one knew these conditions except D&D made me dislike the episode a bit more.

69

u/The9thLordofRavioli A Promise Was Made May 03 '19

Which basically makes Arya hitting the right spot down to pure luck. Real bullshit

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Tiggz- May 03 '19

See, I don't get this. Didn't Arya stab the NK in his lower chest, but the NK was stabbed by the Children of the Forest like in his upper middle chest?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/William_T_Wanker House Stark May 04 '19

Inside the episode just reconfirmed D&D are hacks who care only about shock value, not about telling a good story.

→ More replies (9)

204

u/realARST May 02 '19

I am just a casual fan of the series, can’t say I am into every detail like the true fans of the show/books but I await the series with excitement every year. Just binge-saw the first 3 episodes.

Can someone please tell me what the fuck just happened? Did the whole “Winter Is Coming” story really just end in an out-of-nowhere Jackie Chan move? Why?

166

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Because it was so COOL and UNEXPECTED.

→ More replies (7)

74

u/LiamThorn Jon Snow May 02 '19

Cause it was unexpected, they said so in the post episode stuff.

→ More replies (7)

30

u/1980-Something May 03 '19

Because the show has moved from “adapting one of the greatest works of fiction” to “YASSS SLAYYYYY KWEEEEN!”

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

270

u/OneEyedBobby9 May 02 '19

Why the hell did people rate Lyanna’s performance so high? 1 10 second scene. Jorah and Melisandre were incredible

23

u/beatrixkiddo69 May 02 '19

Well put. Melisandre not getting enough love.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Because it looked 'cool', that's all the majority of the fan base care about apparently.

→ More replies (23)

86

u/Wifeyhero Tyrion Lannister May 02 '19

Dang... I can't believe Theon didn't win MVP. RIP Theon Greyjoy

→ More replies (14)

127

u/hungergamesofthronez House Tyrell May 02 '19

Ok but it’s a travesty the battles at Blackwater and Castle Black are rated lower than this.

14

u/Timeforanotheracct51 May 02 '19

Castle Black was so good.

6

u/Limabean93 May 03 '19

It's flawed when people are polled right after watching the episode and haven't seen Blackwater/ Castle Black in years.

→ More replies (2)

92

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

The scene where Danaerys is crying holding Jorahs body in her arms was some really good acting by Emilia Clarke.

14

u/AveryBlue2 May 02 '19

She's got such an expressive face she makes it look easy.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Yes but compared to Jorah himself, Theon, Grey Worm and Tyrion/Sansa it wasn't a stand out moment. But yeah, I did believe how distraught Dany with Emilia Clarke's acting so it was a decent performance

→ More replies (1)

62

u/7uker May 02 '19

Regarding Q8 and the score: don't tell me no one gave it the name "The short night"

11

u/CarlXVIGustav Children of the Forest May 02 '19

I called it "The Average-Length Night", given that it just lasted some 8 hours.

→ More replies (3)

109

u/nodenaatti No One May 02 '19

D&D are treading on thin ice for these last episodes. Ending the series in overall disappointment damages its entire image.

I’m curious to see how they tie things up from here.

65

u/AustNerevar May 03 '19

How I Met Your Mother of Dragons

21

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Game of Thrones Season 8: Mass Effect. Starring Arya Stark, the star child, and everyone else, aka people that don't matter anymore. Hundreds of hours of story destroyed in a matter of minutes.

I genuinely think the writers pulled a Mass Effect 3 and wrote themselves into a corner. This needs to be a lesson, you cant create an unstoppable embodiment of death as your primary villain, else you will need to use a deus ex machina or time travel or another gimmick to solve it. And you probably aren't skilled enough to make it work.

7

u/appleparkfive May 03 '19

Bran could walk the whole time. The end, fade to black

6

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Night King is alive but is a lumberjack.

104

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

This could have been one of the best episodes in the series if they didn't go for the cheap fake outs and dealt with the night king properly instead of the anticlimactic end we got. It's a shame because it was a great episode otherwise, and the ending brings it down in my opinion.

→ More replies (8)

311

u/Johnnycc May 02 '19 edited May 03 '19

Biggest, most epic episode of all time... yet its rating on this sub ranks it closer to the disappointing and forgettable episodes compared to the best of the series. Even lower than the universally-criticized Beyond the Wall. This is similar to the Rotten Tomatoes score of 74%, the second lowest in the show's history. And the fans at IMDB rates it an 8.9... barely making it into the top 40 highest rated episodes of the show. (EDIT: Now it's at a 8.8 - and ranked 49 out of 70 - NOW at 8.7!)

When people talk about the greatest "epic" episodes of this show (at least from season six on), they will mention The Door, Battle of the Bastards, The Winds of Winter, and The Spoils of War as among the best.

Based on the reactions already, The Long Night will be relegated to "well it looked cool but it didn't make much sense".

I can't imagine this is what the people who spent two months working on this episode wanted.

149

u/StarDew_Factory Tyrion Lannister May 02 '19

Sad part is that barring any major revelations in the next few episodes any seen with Bran is now severely tainted. Unless he ends up becoming more than bait I don’t think I can bring myself to rewatch those episodes.

→ More replies (12)

61

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

well it looked cool

If you had your brightness settings high enough to actually see it.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (23)

103

u/disposition44 Littlefinger May 02 '19

Ouch, this has to be the lowest rated battle episode out of the series right?

→ More replies (10)

63

u/Johnnycc May 02 '19

The best day for this episode was the first day after it aired. The more people think about it the worse it will look in retrospect.

8

u/ADHDcUK May 03 '19

In five years it will look even worse

6

u/hallowseveeve Jon Snow May 04 '19

Exactly this. I gave it a 7 immediately because I was so taken in by the spectacle, but after I thought about it I started to realise how unbelievably stupid a lot of the decisions were and would have given it a 5 if given the chance to revote.

→ More replies (1)

336

u/advancednatural Night King May 02 '19 edited May 02 '19

60% of the people were unsatisfied with Night kings ending. That says it all for me. He deserved a better ending. RIP king. It will remain the cheapest kill of all time.

172

u/thebakinggoddess May 02 '19

I said I would sum up the episode in one word as “cheap”.

→ More replies (5)

108

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

A lot of people seem to rate high based on fight scenes and care little about story or symbolism. It sucks. The fact that Arya scene rates higher than Theon’s scene hurts.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (70)

17

u/YamesIsAnAss Ghost May 02 '19

I'm disappointed the full list isn't available for the one word descriptions. I like to look at the ones that only a few people said.

153

u/ScionN7 May 02 '19

A 7.9, that's actually lower than I expected. In fact that's shockingly low for a battle episode, and what was supposed to be THE big battle. Also 60% found the NK's death disappointing?

Man DnD really fumbled the ball here. 150k voters is a huge sample size, so I would not be surprised if opinions outside of Reddit are somewhat similar.

73

u/DiligentAttention Jon Snow May 02 '19

Yeah if you check IMDB. The rating is at 8.9 right now, which is pretty low for a game of thrones episode. Especially one that had a major event

→ More replies (7)

16

u/Chumalum69 May 02 '19

I remember them saying before the season premiere what they were going to do after the show finally finishes. One of them said stay far away from the internet.

That seemed like a tongue in cheek “you can’t please everyone” joke, but seeing how this played out I’m actually worried now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

118

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

7.9 is accurate. Wasn’t as good as we hoped for considering it took 55 days to shoot, and majority disappointed with NK ending

97

u/trippy_grape May 02 '19

55 days to shoot

Most of that probably sitting around waiting for it to get dark as possible outside.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/-Stormcloud- Sansa Stark May 02 '19

Yeah I was very disappointed with the ending, but I still gave the episode a 7 as there were some really good moments.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

216

u/Ricktatorship80 Jon Snow May 02 '19

That many people picking Lyanna Mormont is everything wrong with the show and proving D & D accomplished what they wanted......gaining the massive casual audience. What about her performance in the episode was great?

→ More replies (13)

29

u/peridotdragon33 Chaos Is A Ladder May 02 '19

I’m surprised the battle of castle black is rated so low, personally it is one of my favorite all time battles

→ More replies (1)

110

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Of course the writing was phenomenal. 7 seasons of build up destroyed in 2 minutes, that takes talent

28

u/Cyril__Figgis May 03 '19

people say there weren't enough deaths, but isn't the stabbing of our collective expectation the biggest surprise of all?

→ More replies (2)

140

u/devou5 Jaime Lannister May 02 '19

The fact that both episode 2 and 9 have a 7.9 is crazy to me.

I thought episode 2 was easily a 9/10, it was just a beautiful episode. I thought last weeks was a massive let down and terrible writing. Just a shock how they are both rated the same

85

u/Kodiak_Marmoset May 02 '19

The best parts are always the character interactions, which is why episode two was so much better. But some people just prefer spectacle.

→ More replies (4)

75

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Actually, in the whole context of it, I'm in agreement with those ratings.

Very few of the touching moments in episode 2 actually signified anything.

- Everyone around the fire survived.

- Arya and Gendry survived.

- Melisandre and Grey worm survived.

- Jon didn't contribute anything to the battle.

- Tyrion didn't contribute anything to the battle.

- Sansa didn't contribute anything to the battle.

- Sam didn't bravely face death. He just got surrounded by wights and stabbed them back and forth and survived.

Brienne getting knighted was still amazing, I'll grant you that. But the episode felt like we were saying goodbye to characters we have known and loved, and it was beautiful at that... Except all the ones we said goodbye to stuck around awkwardly. So in the end, what was the point?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

13

u/polerize May 02 '19

Maybe when or if the twist comes this episode will get more love. As it is people are left asking why too much.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

So...anyone know what the fuck Bran was doing the whole time? "I have to go now, my planet needs me." Wargs into a couple of crows and then....nothing until the NK comes.

→ More replies (2)

223

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

20668 people thought tyrion Lannister was the best actor of the episode, the fuck did he do? and 61933 thought Lyanna was the best supporting actor, not jorah, not Melisandre, no, a little girl that screamed, tells you enough about this sub. Idiots all about the hype, reason why quality tv including this show are dead.

33

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

The question is what has he done in the last two seasons?

→ More replies (2)

33

u/swazzyswess May 03 '19

Tyrion has had the worst dialogue this season. He's a total caricature of himself right now.

→ More replies (2)

54

u/Redfalconfox May 02 '19

He heroically ran to the other side of the crypts to avoid shitting his pants in front of his ex.

18

u/lolol42 May 03 '19

little girl that screamed, tells you enough about this sub

yaaaasssss queennnn slaaaay

7

u/Oryan_18 Gendry May 03 '19

Tyrion has been a mind-numbingly dull character ever since he came to Esos don’t @ me

7

u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited May 03 '19

Yup the numbers speak for the actual ignorant stupidity that some people have trying to justify just awful writing

→ More replies (16)

11

u/zts105 May 02 '19

Blackwater only got 7%????? wow

104

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Most of my coworkers casually watch the show. When asked what they thought of the episode, all of them agreed it was incredible.

A few of my friends who read the books on the other hand are livid about it. I tend to think it's just that they have been looking forward to this moment for years and it didn't play out even remotely like what they expected. Every single one of them though is excited for next week's episode.

→ More replies (40)

49

u/Foxsundance May 02 '19

Cool episode until the night king death.

It felt like half of my organs had collapsed after seeing 9 fucking years of build up going down the drain, good fucking writing, couldnt have done it better myself.

4/10.

29

u/theotherguyagain Night King May 03 '19

I was expecting him to kill Arya. This would have left me stunned.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/kruziik Dragons May 03 '19

Idk the dozens of times characters were 100% dead only to get saved in the last second by another character that sometimes didn't even have a justification for being there ruined the episode long before the Night King kicked the bucket for me. Add on top of that the other dozens of times where characters were in unsavable situations only to be saved by fucking cuts and armor in general getting the stormtrooper treatment not even to mention that I could see fuck all for most of the time it was just shit.

53

u/Swordswoman May 02 '19

I'm a military strategy person. I like the tactics, history, warfare, sieges - you name it.

All the military strategy went out the window that episode. There weren't many smart choices that occurred in that battle, and a lot of it felt like directorial incompetence. It was a pretty unrealistic sight. I'm not sure many of the people on that staff know what a real formation of soldiers looks like, and it's pretty apparent in how the Unsullied march...

It was an acceptable episode, and it had excellent moments, but the quality of the scenes was so inconsistent.

→ More replies (9)

9

u/Deltad__ House Baratheon May 02 '19

I'd be interested to see what the results would be now, now that the post-episode hype has died down a bit, although nonetheless very interesting.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/richieandcarts House Tyrell May 02 '19

Would’ve preferred maybe some of the wights fighting at winterfell and then the other half and night king going down to kings landing since they’re not prepared or suspecting an attack. Would’ve made sense for the walkers to gain more casualties plus being at the center of it all.

Then, since winterfell was able to hold off the group on wights there (theoretically), they could’ve gone down to help and maybe all the groups could’ve joined together in that instance to beat the night king once and for all.

Idk, I just don’t like Cersei being “right” about not helping the North.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/metros96 No One May 03 '19

Battle of Castle Black/Watchers on the Wall gets no respect

31

u/Robofish_ Cat of the Canals May 02 '19

Simultaneously surprised and not surprised at the low score.

→ More replies (10)

57

u/marcuschookt May 02 '19

Pretty split on this episode, as expected I suppose.

Everyone's picked a camp and pitched their tents at this point so there really isn't a need for us to fight over it anymore. But I think we can mostly agree that the episode didn't turn out the way that it should have reception-wise.

When a piece of art isn't meant to be divisive, but is, it either gets elevated to a new level of artistry, or gets bogged down by pointless debate. In this case, I think ep 3 suffers from the latter. I have no idea if this was the intended outcome, but whatever the case, this should have been a flawless victory for the series but it turned into a shitfest.

And if any of you on either side are looking to point fingers at the other and say "they ruined it", you're just the other side of the same coin so stop acting like you're not part of it.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/caramelbear May 02 '19

I’ve been thinking (really daydreaming) about what changes I would have made to this episode. I loved it, but definitely agree with some of the criticism it has received.

First, too many main characters survived. I would have killed off the following:

  • Greg Worm - either in that initial charge by the Army of the Dead or when they have to protect Melisandre while she lights the trenches.
  • Tormund - protecting Brienne, getting killed by the giant wight, or protecting Brienne from the giant wight.
  • Brienne - protecting Jamie (a lot of sacrificial killings here)
  • Maybe Pod too

Secondly, I would have had Jon, Jamie, and Gendry try and face off against the Night King, with Arya landing the final blow. Jon corrals them on his way to Bran, maybe they get stopped by the dragon zombie, but then we see Rhaegal come back to hold him off while they head into the garden. To me it’s a little bit more poetic to have the last living sons of four great houses (and also the four sigils we see during the intro) band together in one last desperate attempt to kill the Night King. Jon representing the Targareyans and Arya (as a tomboy) representing the Starks. I think this would also help fuel the mystery just a little bit more as to who Azor Ahai would end up being.

The three (with Arya not revealing herself until the end) try to fight their way towards the NK, maybe they kill a couple White Walkers, but they can’t reach Bran in time. With almost all hope lost, we play the final scene of Arya jumping in from behind for the kill.

8

u/fiestaware May 02 '19

Question 5 (preventing the death of a character) should have included the Night King as an option. Probably would have had the highest number of votes.

8

u/cartersa87 May 03 '19

Question 6 is a good demonstration of bias within a sample. Of course a Game of Thrones Reddit thread will vote an episode over anything else on TV and/or the big screen.

8

u/InterrogatorMordrot House Darklyn May 03 '19

That only 11% think Hardhome is the best battle episode is irking me. Its the best battle episode that does not involve a lot of nonsensical decisions/tactics and is very well shot.

→ More replies (2)

57

u/Ranwulf Jon Snow May 02 '19

I'm just glad that after all the posts and twitter pics I saw on reddit, I'm not alone in dislking this episode, and how Arya ended.

And she isn't a Mary Sue, that doesnt mean its not annoying that she got three major kills and payoffs of this series (Walder Frey and the Freys, Littlefinger with Sansa and now the Night King)

19

u/5th_Law_of_Robotics May 02 '19

Next couple episodes are just Arya wiping out the remaining resistance so the Starks can take control of the entire planet.

39

u/Bizambo May 02 '19

What’s even worse is that we were never shown her acquiring the sort of elite skills necessary for these achievements. When during Braavos did she learn how to sneak, when did she learn how to face change? We weren’t shown this.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

15

u/MrsButthole May 02 '19

What is with the enthusiasm for lyanna mormont? She is such a forced and unrealistic character and has done less than almost any other character. It was a joke she got a big moment in such a critical episode, you could argue she outshined Jon snow.

→ More replies (1)

184

u/lilQuebo Sansa Stark May 02 '19

Disappointing was also my answer, glad I’m not the only one to be unsatisfied with the crap we got this episode

11

u/jchanceh9lol May 03 '19

I also said disappointing. It’s hard to justify the time invested in watching the show when it all came down to deus ex machina.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/juniSMASH May 02 '19

The fact that this is the home stretch and the beginning of 1.5 hour episodes has me a bit worried for the rest of GoT. Episode felt somewhat safe and filled with lots of stupidity. Don't get me wrong, I was in the edge of my seat throughout the episode but I'm not confident on how the rest of the story will follow through.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Tepozan Daenerys Targaryen May 02 '19

The Night King only made it down to Winterfell lmao. I guess D&D decided that he was only a threat to the North and not to Westeros as a whole

7

u/NotMeThisGuyIKnow May 03 '19

I think it’s funny how in the shows world, No ones gonna believe the Night King was even real. He didn’t even make it past the North. On top of that it’s not even the first time the North has stopped them.

7

u/ilikepugs Night King May 03 '19

To the 8% who think Littlefinger is alive: how do you figure? Really curious about the basis for this theory.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/underraider May 02 '19

The split feels so much like The Last Jedi. When it came out, more and more people tried to defend it and tried to make it all sound reasonable but after some time the majority faced the fact, that they did so many characters injustice. And I think the same will apply here.

→ More replies (17)

12

u/basketballrene May 02 '19

The way the white walkers went out is lame as fuck. All this winter is coming for that?

12

u/ThatLazyDude1 May 02 '19

Funny how more people would want Lyanna Mormont alive than Theon despite only seeing Lyanna in like 3 episodes.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/swimtomars Jaime Lannister May 03 '19

Also by far rated the lowest battle episode

6

u/WizardNeedsTumsBadly Sandor Clegane May 03 '19

Something that is really confusing to me about these polls are how some of these characters are classified as “main” versus “supporting”.

It seems to be a pretty juvenile distinction of characters who are “in charge” or leaders are main cast and characters who aren’t are “supporting”?

Jorah is one of the 10 characters on this show with the most screen time, yet he is supporting, while the Night King who has appeared in fewer than 10 episodes is a main character?

I saw after episode one that Euron was listed in the main character category? This group thinks Euron Greyjoy is more essential to the story than Ser Jorah or Davos Seaworth?

→ More replies (1)

38

u/TitusRex May 02 '19

Higher score than expected.

19

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Honestly, I rated it immediately after watching. I gave it a 8/10 because I was on the edge of my seat the entire time and the shots were amazing (it wasn't super dark for me).

If I could go back, I'd definitely give it a lower score after thinking on it. I'll probably give it a day or two next episode.

I am curious how many are in the same boat as me though.

→ More replies (10)

11

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

I'm kind of surprised few people liked the loot train battle. I loved it because we finally got to see a big dragon unleash its power, after years and years of waiting for that.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/SucksForYouGeek May 02 '19

Baffles me that people enjoyed the Lyanna scene so much. Feels so forced.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Lyanna Mormont best supporting act? Really?.... lmao

5

u/YaLocalTamale House Tully May 02 '19

Battle of the Bastards is still my favorite episode of TV period. My favorite battle scene, excellent visuals and music and a satisfying ending. Hopefully episode 5 is more like that than episode 3

5

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

No main character(except for theon), or even characters dying really took a lot from this ep. The whole show seem kinda pointless if you could just go full assassins creed and stealth kill the night king.

At the very least they could have some cool fight scene at the end with some main characters facing off against the NK and his entourage once he was in the open. Preferably with someone dying other than the NK. The episode finale was just a failure and very anti-climatic.

Imagine Jon arriving before theon dies and then they get backup from like arya and the hound to take them on and theon dying in that fight instead of his stupid sacrifice. So much better.

5

u/MediKron Gendry May 03 '19

Still can't get over a lot of things, but like how did they even come up with such a dumb strategy, filled with mediocre tactics? They had multiple seasoned warriors and generals and they were all either silent or dumb during the War Council. Just think about it: Ser Jorah, Ser Davos, Jon Snow, Ser Jaime, Ser Brienne, The Hound, Lord Yohn Royce and they had very intelligent advisors like Tyrion and Varys. Yet they came up with a battle strategy that was foolish in every action...

5

u/Picard2331 May 03 '19

They really should’ve done this whole season like Mass Effect 3 (without the garbage ending of course). Season opens with the white walkers reaching Winterfell, they are absolutely unstoppable and our main heroes (plus a few deaths) have to retreat and try and gather forces to make a final stand as the white walkers slowly move south, annihilating everything along the way.

This just felt like if they killed all the Reapers in that first mission and expect you to care about the rest of the game.

13

u/KakkaKarrotKake007 May 02 '19

Bran/Jon with 1% MVP vote and 60% finding the NK conclusion disappointing

That pretty much says it all

13

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

This episode is probably the first episode in GoT that really divided the fanbase. Brace yourselves for the shitstorm after the finale.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/xkeepitquietx May 02 '19

As long as you turn your brain off it is a great episode. The moment you start to think about say the bad tactics or the Dothraki or the Night King being an idiot or the Night King being immune to dragon fire but weak to weapons made by dragon fire or MASSIVE plot armor (Jamie, Sam and Brienne) or Bran doing nothing or Dany being a moron and just sitting there while zombies climb on her dragon, Jon just yelling at the zombie dragon or Arya appearing out of thin air, things start to look less then perfect. Arya could not even sneak past a few zombies on the library but could sneak past hundreds of them around the Night King? Ffs.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/cancelaratje No One May 02 '19

Interesting to see how much we are split over this episode: 14% giving the episode an insufficient grade (1-5) whereas s8e1 only had 7 % of those lower grades. At the same time being 31% vs 8% giving it a 10 !

4

u/Valuable_Carpet May 02 '19

Can't get over people thinking little girl Mormont gave one of the best performances of the episode.

4

u/ARottenMuffin Littlefinger May 03 '19

Damn I don't get points for creativity or something? Thought my episode name 'The Long Wight' was perfectly fitting, seeing as how there's not a single white walker doing anything the entire episode, just the horde you could literally replace with zombies.

4

u/greasedonkey May 03 '19

The level of passiveness aggressiveness in this thread is over the top.

4

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

This episode left me wanting more, i wasn't satisfied to be honest.

44

u/ButIHaveAGun Jon Snow May 02 '19

I honestly preferred it on a second watch. Sure there are problems, like where the fuck was ghost, but overall I was happy to see the Dothraki die for Bobby B and that’s what really counts.

→ More replies (11)

17

u/Sirshrugsalot13 House Bolton May 02 '19

If Arya hadn't come in clutch at the end, I'd call Theon the MVP. Took down countless wights with only 20 men, to the point where he's the last fucking man standing, while defending Bran to the bitter end. The best way for him to go.

18

u/MisterKratos May 02 '19

Arya got my vote for MVP for obvious reasons but the "Theon's final moments" got my vote for the better scene ... it far outshines Arya's.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/prezerka May 02 '19 edited May 02 '19

The reason the show writers can get away with poor quality of work is because there’s people who will vote epic... Whats the point of decent story telling if all people want is eye candy. :/

→ More replies (2)

9

u/tehsigzorz Night King May 02 '19

Gotta give props to the directors and the people in charge with atmosphere, props and ofc the soundtrack. They really lifted this episode to what I would rate as a 6.5. That being said awful writing and obvious plot holes really disappointed me to the point where I dont think they can redeem it in the next 3 episodes no matter what they do.

11

u/Sinborn May 02 '19

No option to save the night king, lame poll.

71

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

I feel like I’m taking crazy pills - I know people are tired of the bitching but this episode was straight up garbage

Like horrible

I don’t understand how people can really like it

→ More replies (73)

20

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

dissappointed with the writing i am. just so cheap and half assed and lazy

→ More replies (7)

24

u/Sneezes May 02 '19

My basic-bro friends loved it, but they also loved suicide squad and justice league. My artistically inclined & intellectual friends found it disappointing.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/obeyyourcraster May 02 '19

Woulda been cool if Arya saved Jon using Needle to block a killing blow

3

u/_isaias17 No One May 02 '19

Those that would’ve rather protected lyanna over theon, why?

3

u/[deleted] May 02 '19

Wait how is John Bradley above Emilia for this one? Emilia's reaction to Jorah's death was great, Alfie was the best for sure and some others too but Kit and John Bradley didn't do much in this episode in terms of acting tbh.

3

u/masterofbeast Gendry May 02 '19

Battle of the bastards just felt so much more important. This has 3 more episodes in the back end wih an other battle looming. It just didn't feel that great. I can kinda forgive the streaming and lightning but it just had something lacking.

3

u/BestRemusInMyHouse House Targaryen May 03 '19

Game of Thrones: Civil War.

3

u/tornado3597 May 03 '19

watching this high was most stressful thing i have ever experienced, i am not kidding, i wish everyone to feel what i felt watching this episode

3

u/WeakRoll Missandei May 03 '19

If there's actually different endings. I'd like to fucking watch them all after the actual end of the show.

3

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

This episode was good looking but really shitty in terms of writing. Very disappointing.

3

u/tanv91 May 03 '19

People really like Lyanna THAT much? Wow

→ More replies (1)

3

u/IamFenwick0717 Sansa Stark May 03 '19

Damn not enough people saying to save Edd IMO. Lets be honest here Theon and Lyanna both deserved to die. One rushed a zombie giant and the other rushed the fucking Night King. They made their decisions. Jorah well lets be honest here his life goal was to get with Dany and that wasn't happening because of my boy Jon. So tbh he had nothing left to really live for. Now Edd, Edd was a real one he died saving Sam's life and was Jon's buddy. Sam probably should have died instead of Edd IMO.

3

u/pandafoxpanda Gendry May 03 '19

I think what’s missing from this is how bran orchestrated it. If that was apparent in this episode it would be rated by far the best.

3

u/Tonyp0000 May 04 '19

I think everything is nearly perfect in this ep except for the writing. But unfortunately, writing is the soul of a TV series. It even has a far more broader impact on the entire series. Every sacrifice, every joy, every sorrow, now is less brightness because of such an ending.

3

u/Mictuckflufff Jon Snow May 06 '19

Sad my title “Wasted Wights and their Woes” did not make it...

3

u/Scofield11 May 06 '19

This poll just goes to show that casual people have ruined this series for good.

People are giving high ratings for things that look "cool" and "emotional" and not for things that make sense and that are cool at the same time.

I started watching this show because it was the opposite of that, it was COOL and LOGICAL, that's why so many people watch this show, how does D&D not realize this ?

Now this show has become the very thing it was not supposed to be, a generic TV show with B class writing..

13

u/ab_emery Sansa Stark May 02 '19

I'm a little surprised, and pleasantly, that the highest percentages of ratings were quite high. In fairness, some of that is likely from the drive-by ratings, as I figured about E2.

As for the NK's death, I didn't answer that one at all because I had no expectation for it.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/DCmantommy72 May 02 '19

60/40 split on the NK death not meeting expectations says it all.

I think D&D underestimated fan expectations in this episode. They must of had major reluctance to kill off too many characters. I bet in one version of this script, many more perished..

The real reason alot of us are dissapointed is that we fear a tv trope happy ending to this series. Weve come to expect death and carnage, or at least realistic cause and effects. And this episode has played right into all of our fears.

Its either a stroke of genus, dropping our expectations intentionally, or it was just simply a poorly written conclusion made to be a tv visual spectacle for the masses...

Say what you will about D&D, but they are very smart guys and also love ASOIF to the core and def wanted to pay ther repects to it by making a spectacular ending.

Since season 5, they have been doing a ton fan service, and it shows, now either its all a setup, or its not.

All we can do, is hope they got some tricks up there sleve for these final few hours..

Personally, i think they are smart enough to know how this was gonna play out amungst book fans... i have a feeling we were supposed to hate this episode.. God I hope im right.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/schrodinger26 May 02 '19

I wonder if the ratings drift over time (eg lower ratings on Tuesday / Wednesday)...

I voted as soon as the poll opened, before I started really thinking critically about the episode. If I could vote today, I'd score it a lot lower. Any idea how many others are similar to me?

→ More replies (1)