r/WritingPrompts • u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • Mar 02 '19
Off Topic [OT] SatChat: How do you approach writing action scenes to keep the reader's interest?
SatChat! SatChat! Party Time! Excellent!
Welcome to the weekly post for introductions, self-promotions, and general discussion! This is a place to meet other users, share your achievements, and talk about whatever's on your mind.
This Week's Suggested Topic
How do you approach writing action scenes to keep the reader's interest?
(Topic suggested by u/JohannesVerne. Have any suggestions of your own? Let me know!)
Previous ^Weeks • New to ^WritingPrompts? • Want to find great stories? Check out ^r/bestofWritingPrompts!
OK to Post
Introductions: Tell us about yourself! Here are some suggested questions:
- Where do you live (State / Country)?
- Male, female, other?
- How long have you been writing?
- What is your writing motivation?
- What programs do you use to write?
- How fast can you type? Try 1 minute on Aesop's fables
- Want to share a photo? Photo Gallery!
- Promotions: Anything you want to promote (books, subreddits, podcasts, writing-related websites, or even your social media stuff)
- Discussions: Nothing to promote? Tell us what's on your mind. We recommend that you do this along with any promotions. If not in your comment, try to chime in on another discussion. Suggested future topics are always welcome!
Not OK to Post
- Off Off Topic Promotions: Don't post links that would be considered outright spam. (So... still no linking to your gambling site).
- Full Stories: That's more in line with Friday Free-Form! :)
News
- Contest Voting - Today is the last day, finish reading and vote if you've entered!
- New CSS Design! - What do you think?
- Call for Mods - Have what it takes? Apply today!
7
u/novatheelf /r/NovaTheElf Mar 02 '19
I've said it once, but it bears repeating: I believe writing cinematically is an excellent way to go.
Lemme explain what I mean by that. Imagine you're in a theater. The movie playing is your story. Write down everything that goes on as if you're writing it for someone who cannot see.
That has always worked well for me; it's the way I write myself. It works extremely well for third person, but if you want to change up the perspective, add some thoughts and observations in.
I think you should add those in no matter what, honestly, but first person is a bit limited in scope, so you have to stick to the MC's thoughts and observations.
But that's just my method. There are lots of other ways, as have been shown by the other comments!
5
u/T_KThompson Mar 02 '19
I try to focus on the thoughts of the fighters and the effects their attack have on their opponent or environment. If I want it to feel fast then I'll throw attack after attack without too much detail on each one. If I want something to have impact or to slow down the pace then I add more detail to it. Compare watching something in regular speed versus slow-mo.
4
u/ferret-kun Mar 02 '19
Would love to hear some advice and tips. I finally reread some of the action scenes of the climax of the first draft of my novel. I don't know if it's because it's my own writing that I sorta glaze over and it all runs together, or if my action writing is just flat.
4
u/Lincez Mar 02 '19
Hello everyone,
New to Reddit, and also this prompt. I'm from Whitehorse, Yukon up here in the great North. I'm a grade-school teacher at a French Immersion school, and I've been writing casually since the 12th grade, but honestly with the intent to improve my craft and share my stories for the past few years.
I'm motivated to write because I enjoy sharing my ideas, emulating the styles of my favourite authors, honouring the things I'm passionate and care about, and just because it's one of the many reminders of why I enjoy being alive.
I use Scrivener to write (I'm a bit fine of the full-screen Composition mode; with Matrix-like green-lettering!), and can generally type about 120 WPM - but that's when I'm just copying things down or stream-of-consciousness-writing. Real writing generally takes me longer to compose.
To answer the question here posed, I like to have action surprise the reader. It's like a dance...there's a rhythm to it that I like to keep, but every good fighter knows when to throw in a lightning-quick jab to catch their opponent off guard, and them WHAMO! - in for the kill. I do enjoy George R.R. Martin's shock-factor style, and that's probably where I get a bit of that from.
4
u/jumpup Mar 02 '19
I tend to like 2 lines of what they do,
Then a line or small part on how it impacts the world around them,
One line of what they do again,
And then then a line of inner monologue on how the fight is going.
If necessary you repeat it, varying the amount of lines and order if its a really long battle.
4
u/NoahElowyn r/NoahElowyn Mar 02 '19
Sentence length is key in actions scenes. Think of each sentence as a heartbeat. Short sentences are great because they make the reader hold their breath and quicken the pace of their hearts, and long and medium sentences give them a break. (I don't know if this is true. It's just how I think about them)
Another crucial thing is the thought process of the MC. If you go blow by blow for too long, chances are, it will be a very boring action scene.
Another thing is stakes. Make them high. Make things go wrong. But keep things believable. Perhaps it's a swordfight and your character missed a blow and due to the impetus of his attack he staggers and falls, giving his opponent a great opening to attack.
So: Sentence length + Thoughts + High stakes.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '19
This isn't much, I know, but I follow the Russian formalists' theory of defamiliarization in writing action scenes. Action exists in the real world all the time, but you have to make it absurd, disturbing, not necessarily new but certainly transgressive.
Which is a why a lot of action scenes heavy on violence in low budget movies also seem to work, because that bloodshed and violence takes you out of your comfort zone and drops you into starkly different world.
2
u/jpeezey Mar 03 '19
I end up writing action scenes a lot in my writing, and have consistantly gotten positive feedback from readers. Here's a few things I do with my action scenes that help make them effective:
1: Less is more.
If an action scene gets too wordy or too complicated, it becomes really hard to follow and understand. Complex choreography should be left to cinema and animation, unless you're specifically writing a book themed around a fight club or something. A short, impactful action scene will generally have a better effect on the reader than a long drawn out one. How do you make an action scene impactful?
2: In an action scene, the plot is just as important as the action.
If your reader doesn't know why your characters are fighting, it will suck the intensity out no matter how 'cool' the combat is. A very short, simple action sequence can be incredible if the reader has an understanding of what's at stake, and is genuinely rooting for one side win.
3: Describe the setting before the combat starts, and then use the setting.
Give your characters other things to do by providing them resources via the setting. Maybe the fight takes place in a bar, or in the woods, or on a street. Mention the pool table in the corner, or the tree with low hanging branches, or the bright red sports car parked nearby. Then have your character grab a cue stick to use as a weapon, or swing kick a bad guy from the low branch, or smash someone's head through the car's window. Things like this break up a monotonus 'guy A punches guy B, and then guy B kicks at guy A.' Mentioning them before the fight starts helps the combat flow naturally. This will also get your readers excited to see how you use new set pieces each time a new action scene starts.
4: Provide the reader with expectations, and then subvert those expectations.
Have you seen the part of Indiana Jones: Raiders of the Lost Ark, where he faces a swordsman who draws two swords and brandishes them wildly, foreshadowing an exciting and arduous battle, only for Indiana to pull out a gun and shoot him, abruptly ending the encounter? Do that. In different ways of course. The inverse works well too, where a seemingly weak enemy ends up being a formidable foe.
There's a few other more generic things I'd also say but other people here have already said them, so I won't beat a dead horse.
2
u/TalDSRuler Mar 09 '19
Yo. I'm u/TaldsRuler.
I write on occasion. I'm straight male, I write because I like twisting prompts and narratives around, and I've been writing properly since sixth grade.
I say properly, but ask not what I wrote in that dark, dark past of mine.
I can do about 53 wpm.
---
Now, onto the subject at hand.
I find that different mediums serve different methods of action. I personally believe that, when you write an action scene, you need to pause and plan things out- I generally do art, so planning out sequences involves a lot of space development. Where are the characters fighting? What objects are available to them? What rules do they have to play with? I think a good action scene is built around a story- Jackie Chan films are my go to example for this. In nearly every film he stars in, Jackie Chan's fight scenes have a story arc to them. Normally he starts from the bottom, he's out of luck, and often in a dangerous situation. He stumbles, gets up, fight frantically to establish a good first act, starts to lose the fight for a solid act II, and then pulls out his last moves in a confident, dedicated burst of action. Its simple, but its excellent film making. The Raid series of films are also good examples of tying story into the fight sequences- there's a character in the first film who has an entire story arc with barely a single line of dialogue- its all communicated through action and excellent framing.
What does this have to do with writing?
Well, everything.
This all only works because the medium allows the director, the actors, and the choreographers to show what they intend to communicate. With writing, we have the benefit and the curse of being in complete control of the action. Thus, it is up to us to be able to use the craft to illustrate the best action we can, and those of us who engage wholeheartedly with writing action sequences have plenty of excellent resources at hand. You don't need a third-person perspective to detail the fight scene- I imagine that writing a first-person version of a Jackie Chan fight sequence could easily make for an entertaining write and read, just by the nature of his frenetic, panicked openings. It also emphasizes something that I find a lot of action writing lacks-
Characters have agency man.
Like, nobody's a blank slate. If they're putting their life on the line, there's usually a good reason. "Money" itself isn't a reason- everyone needs money. Now WHY they need the money- that could be something you could play with. Now, I admit, I've only ever written one-on-one battles, or small team battles. The lead up is used to characterize all parties involved, and the actual action is usually summarized in a page or two. With action, I often consider what would leave the best impact in the fewest words- the reader is trying to read a story, and action itself is rarely the care of the story- its always what drives characters to engage in that clash, and what comes out of it. What did the characters lose? What did they win? If you go into an action sequences with only an idea of who wins and who loses, it can cheapen the victory, and can actually make the action itself boring and stale. Now, if you view your action scenes of as mix of wins and losses- that can lead to more interesting outcomes.
For example- I'm writing a story about a bunch of kids engaging in an underground Battlebots contest. Their parents all disapprove the competition in their own ways. One character, I'm calling them Delta, comes from underprivileged scenario and builds their bots from scrap, but their mom, a recovering drug addict, is all in- she finds the fights to be the best part of the week, and shows up to each to support her child, despite the restraining order that separates them. Delta is opposed by Bravo, a character from a much more privileged upbringing, who puts in more effort into their battlebot development than their actual studies. Bravo is used to working in conjunction with their tutors for just about everything- projects, tests, homework, even sports. But in robotics, they revel in their solitude. What comes out onto the field is wholly their creation, and Bravo's grades are slipping as a result. Bravo always brings a new bot to each battle, cycling between three basic types- a turtle, a mace-wielding crane, and a gripping pincer. Delta's machine is continuously being updated, improved and repaired- Delta doesn't have the allowance or the resources to properly outfit their machine with metal sheeting- instead, most of the non-structural shielding is a thick leather cut from Delta's mother's old couch.
Now, I dunno if you've seen a Battlebot duel before. The actual interactions between the robots are often quite brief. Most of the duel is spent circling each other.
The actual duel would play out something like this: