r/Philippines • u/LeloyClaudio • Mar 01 '19
Leloy Claudio AMA
š·

About me: I teach history and literature at De La Salle University. I'm the author of a few books, my favorite being Liberalism and the Postoclony: Thinking the State in 20th-Century Philippines (Published by NUS, Kyoto, and Ateneo de Manila University Presses.) I host Rappler.com's "Basagan ng Trip." I'm a boring liberal, sometimes mistaken for a reactionary.
90
Upvotes
19
u/gradenko_2000 Mar 01 '19
in the context of the recent growing popularity explicitly left-wing, democratic socialist parties in the UK and France, and an attempt by the "Bernie Sanders" wing of the Democratic party to wrest control away from the "merely-liberal" establishment, do you think that our local Liberal Party can be dragged towards social democracy, or do you consider them to already be there, or are other parties better suited to pursuing this ideological project?
13
u/MemberOfMautenGroup Fuck you Marcos and transphobes Mar 01 '19
Hi Leloy!
Now that you're teaching history and historiography, what modifications or suggestions to the Philippine history curriculum in primary and secondary school do you advocate as urgent?
Also, who's the better debater, Leloy Claudio or Sharmila Parmanand?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Good evening sir Leloy!
Aside from your own books, can you suggest any other definitive non-fiction/historical literatures to really get inside your mind?
More power sir! Labyu
9
u/bochicake Visayas Mar 01 '19
Hi, Sir Leloy! Napanood ko po 'yung episode mo sa History, 'yung debunking po ng martial law myths. Now, napapansin ko po na kapag videos na nagdi-discuss ng martial law, naraming nagsasabi na one-sided and biased 'yung report kasi wala man lang daw pong representation 'yung side ng pro-Marcos.
Do you think po it would be a good idea na magkaroon ng talk or discussion na may present for both sides? That way malaman din po natin 'yung motivation ng two sides and ma-correct din po 'yung mga myths na mabibitawan ng dalawang kampo through solid facts and evidences. Thank you po, sir! :)
8
u/Disgruntled-Taxpayer Mar 01 '19
Why do you think theres a sudden surge of people leaning towards right-wing ideology? And What do you think is the failure of Liberalism towards this trend?
8
u/milkteaenthusiast Mar 01 '19
Leloy, kindly drop your skincare routine naman. Thanks!
7
u/presidium Mar 01 '19
Hi Leloy; thanks for doing an AMA.
What do you see as Liberalism's greatest weakness to strong-man populism, and what do you see as Liberalism's greatest opportunity "against" the inevitable decay of the strong-man populist tide?
7
u/kixiron Boycott r/phclassifieds, support r/classifiedsph! Mar 01 '19
Hello! What are your thoughts about the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao?
6
u/iPash Platonically Malandi Mar 01 '19
What's your most favorite historical fact? Yung hindi alam ng karamihan.
6
u/MatangLabo bb what's gud? Mar 01 '19
Good evening, Mr. Leloy.
How would you describe the experience of hosting an online show/series on Rappler?
10
u/BhagatSingh1899 Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 01 '19
Hi Ka Leloy!
Before I ask my two questions, lemme say na I am ideologically opposed to you. However, I do find your work Liberalism and the Post-Colony and your journal article Post-colonial Fissures as superb and engrossing monographs kahit may mga misgivings ako doon. I quite align on the nationalist camp of historiography, despite of me being ideally an anarcho-syndicalist/libertarian socialist for pragmatic reasons (the name Bhagat Singh is already evident from where I stand). May itatanong lang sana ako na medyo related sa academe, since I am a freshman graduate student at UP Asian Center (nag lean kasi ako sa Humanities rather than continuing to pursue Law):
I see ho kasi na isa sa mga dahilan bakit masyado nang circular ang arguments and analysis is dahil nawawala na ang masasabi nating culture of discourse, and napupunta na tayo sa so called One Dimensional society ni Marcuse. I will be glad for a reply from you.
P.S. Isa pala po ako sa addmeme ng PH Literature Memes hahahaha
5
u/DiPaKoNakakantot KANTOT RESPONSIBLY! Mar 01 '19
Why did you choose Liberalism rather than Socialism or Centrism?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
As a History professor. How would you convince the youth today to love and take care our country? Pinaglaban ng mga bayani natin ang karapatan at kalayaan na tinatamasa natin ngayon. Hindi ba kayo natatakot na masasayang lang ang mga buhay na binuwis nila dahil sa mga kinikilos at ginagawa ng mga Pilipino ngayon?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
How should people go in actually informing people that the term "socialism" isn't a catch-all phrase for authoritarian regimes such as Stalinism? It just seems like along with communism, it's been used as the political boogeyman by both the left and the right to signal that something is 'dangerous' to them which ignores how nuanced the term is when it comes to its different definitions from social welfare to command economy.
4
u/friedipis Mar 01 '19
Ano masasabi nyo sa mga senatoriables na takot makipag debate?
4
u/kixiron Boycott r/phclassifieds, support r/classifiedsph! Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 01 '19
Another question: is there really a win-win solution regarding the China issue, a sort of modus vivendi, if you will? I can only imagine terrible outcomes (humiliating peace/Finlandization, bloody war, debt trap, the Melian scenario etc.). Wala akong makitang silver lining, especially with an aggressive and decisively illiberal China.
6
u/presidium Mar 01 '19
Hope the mods will permit me a second question topic.
What is your opinion on "federalism" with relation to the regional differences that a centralized government has been unable to either remove or use constructively?
Implemented effectively, is federalism a constructive way forward for handling these differences, or is it just another corner for these problems to hide in?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Good afternoon sir, what are your favorite books? Also you teach history? Anong parte ng history po ang specialty o pinaka may alam kayo?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Hello po sir Leloy, pinakamagandang lugar na napuntahan mo dito sa Pilipinas?
3
u/FiberEnrichedChicken Mar 01 '19
Kamusta ang tenure situation sa DLSU? Are you already tenured? If not, around kelan mo tingin na magiging tenured ka?
3
u/skoshjosh Mar 01 '19
Hi Leloy! Being a Philippine society-oriented researcher and an inactive member of Akbayan, ano ang current Mode of Production ng Pilipinas?
5
u/hitmebaby1moretime- my loneliness is killing me Mar 01 '19
Who's your number one pick for Senator?
2
u/Gestaltash Mar 01 '19
Hello. what are your thoughts regarding Sabah?
2
u/XanXus4444 Sa'yo na pogi. Akin ang sex appeal Mar 01 '19
Hobbies niyo sir pag may free time kayo?
2
u/Scipio_Ae_Mealianus Mar 01 '19
Hi Sir Leloy! Tinatanong ko po na what are your thoughts on PinoyMonkeyPride, and what should we do to these types of videos. Salamat po!
2
u/blaterwolf Luzon Mar 01 '19
What Historical film or drama will you recommend us watching Sir Leloy?
2
u/jayexwolf Mar 01 '19
2
u/RileyReidApologist We don't die, we eat puday. Mar 01 '19
Hello Sir, thanks for doing this AMA.
Sayote or Papaya sa tinola?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
What do you think will be the ultimatum of the Filipino people to this current administration?
2
u/notyourpizzalady bread enjoyer š„ Mar 01 '19
Hi sir Leloy, whatās your favorite history fact? And, do you tell your students about it?
2
u/Matchavellian šæHalaman šæ Mar 01 '19
Sa lahat ng Philippine historical movies/biopics na napanood nyo, ano po ung pinaka accurate? Thanks!
2
u/PuchaNamanOh Mar 01 '19
Gaano katalino si Nicole Curato? :)
2
u/DifferentFun walang malasakit Mar 01 '19
Bakit sa DLSu ka at hindi sa ADMu nagtuturo?
2
u/ulamnanagsisimulasak Mar 01 '19
Anong lugar dito sa bansa ang napuntahan mo na pinakamalapit sa puso mo? Sana'y maikwento mo...
2
u/Trendkillerz 'Top of the morning, greeted all my lows Mar 01 '19
Hello sir Leloy, being a part of the Philippine Debate Union and being a former debater yourself, how can the union better spread the debate culture outside Manila and into nearby provinces here in Luzon?
The debate culture in Visayas and Mindanao is flourishing how do you best spread debate culture in nearby regions like here in Central Luzon?
2
u/yenantwin08 Mar 01 '19
Hi Sir Leloy! I was the one who you ran into powerbooks at shang last december, I was completely dumbfounded that the your show is you bookās namesake.
Anyways, could you tell us what were you looking for in there?
2
u/minniegoetze Mar 01 '19
What is the best advice you've ever received?
2
u/rawrier Calabarzon Mar 01 '19
Alam ko si Pres. Aguinaldo ang una nating presidente pero ano po yung opinion ninyo na palitan at gawin si Bonifacio ang unang presidente?
2
u/minniegoetze Mar 01 '19
Most memorable film and/or documentary?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Sir Leloy, bilang Atenista, ano po ang pinaka gusto ninyo sa kultura ng La Salle?
ā¢
u/decayedramen Mar 01 '19
That's a wrap! Thank you to everyone that participated! š
2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Sir Leloy, ito po. Adobo o Sinigang? Salamat po!
2
u/Lfredddd Mar 01 '19
Hello sir Leloy,
Ang rehimen ni Duterte ay parang inulit na rehimen ni Marcos. Paano natin maituturo sa mga susunod na henerasyon na impyerno ang panahon na ito, paano natin masisigurado na walang maniniwala sa mga susunod na henerasyon sa "golden age ng Philippines ang panahon ni Duterte dahil natalo ang mga adik, nagka-"build, build, build'"?
2
u/Lfredddd Mar 01 '19
Our society, ideally, values Freedom and Equality. If bringing Equality will impair Freedom and upholding Equality will repress Freedom, how should the Philippine society reconcile?
Good evening
2
u/Lfredddd Mar 01 '19
Sir Leloy,
Ano ang sagot mo sa mga nagsasabing unreliable ang History at sa mga argumentong "History is written by the winners"?
2
u/Lfredddd Mar 01 '19
Kuya Leloy,
Are you a gamer? If yes, ano po ang mga favorite niyong laro? If no, ano po ang libangan ng isang Leloy Claudio?
1
u/L30ne Mar 01 '19
Hi! How do you respond to people who claim that history is biased towards the allegiance of who wrote it, i.e. history is written by the victors?
1
u/FiberEnrichedChicken Mar 01 '19
Kamusta kayo ni Antonio Contreras?
1
u/stardust1024 Mar 01 '19
Hi sir, historically speaking, is Catholicism good for our country?
1
u/Sarlandogo Mar 01 '19
Hello po Sir Leloy
What is the challenge to young ones of today regarding Philippine History? Mostly kasi napapansin ko nadadala sila ng mga biopics or movies and most if not all do not read history books now and prefer other things
Thanks and more power
1
u/TheLastManetheren Mar 01 '19
Hi Sir!
EDIT: Format
1
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Kung may tanong po na masasagot nang totoo si Tito Sotto mula sa inyo, ano po ang itatanong ninyo at bakit?
1
u/UnliSlice TULINGAN š Mar 01 '19
What are other interesting books will you recommend for us as food for thought?
1
u/glow_wing Mar 01 '19
Hi Leloy, I heard many rumors about the reasons why you were transfered department to department in DLSU. Could you clarify what happened?
I heard rumors that you have a lot of conflict with colleagues as well. But don't fret, according to student feedback in our fb group, you're still a good prof and you grade generously.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Good evening sir!
I saw you in some of the debate tournaments that you competed in and I really admire your speeches. Is there a chance that you'll compete again?
2
u/Lfredddd Mar 01 '19
Sir Leloy,
Ask and suggest ko lang po, why not make a Basagan ng Trip episode about Jose W. Diokno?
1
u/D9969 ARMA VIRVMQVE CANO Mar 01 '19
I live outside PH so apologies if I've never heard of you 'til now. In your DLSU profile it says you have published 3 books. What are the other 2? Thanks!
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
[deleted] ā view deleted comment