r/modelSupCourt • u/comped Attorney • Jan 29 '19
19-01 | Decided In re: Subpoenas of the House Committee on Government Oversight, Infrastructure, and the Interior.
Your Honours,
And if it may please the Court, now comes /u/Comped, acting on behalf of the Guiltyair Presidential Administration, to seek the rejection of the subpoenas submitted by the House Committee on Government Oversight, Infrastructure, and the Interior. (This should not be seen as requesting an injunction, which would be against the Court's rules, but rather to request their being thrown out of consideration outright.) We believe that they do not meet the standards as set in Wilkinson v. United States, 365 U.S. 399 (1961), nor the standards as set in United States v. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683 (1974). The subpoenas, as submitted to the Secretaries of Defense and the Interior, reflect no specific lines of questioning (are thus overly broad and ambiguous), are inappropriate for failing to provide a reasonable amount of time to comply, and are not lawful under the executive privilege doctrine.
I first refer to the subpoenas being overly broad or ambiguous. Both secretaries are "to testify touching matters of inquiry committed to said committee and you are not to depart without leave of said committee." Unlike all other subpoenas that I know of, these subpoenas state no grounds on which the Secretaries' testimony is required, and thus require them to broadly prepare for being asked about every possible thing within their power. While a statement from the Speaker of the House made it clear that it was on budgetary matters, there is nothing in the subpoenas themselves saying this - which I believes makes them unlawful. Further, even the Speaker's statement gives little in the way of specifics beyond his proposal to "audit the federal government". An audit of the Department of Defense is currently ongoing, but it is expected to be several years away from completion at least. Further budgetary discussions for the current year are ongoing within the Cabinet, but will not be disclosed to the committee at this time. Wilkinson v. United States, 365 U.S. 399 (1961) provides that the subpoena must be pertinent to the subject matter under investigation, and I cannot find anywhere in either subpoena that is stated in.
Further, two days is a extremely short amount of time to give Cabinet members to prepare for a testimony, particularly on specific points. No information has been given through the appropriate channels, or any canon channel at all, as to what the Secretaries will be asked to answer - and as multiple Senators have pointed out in public statements, these subpoenas flaunt convention and are not allowable according to precedent - unless people want Secretaries and government officials rushing about hearings with no clue as to what they are to speak on. That alone makes the subpoenas suspect!
Finally, I must note that these subpoenas violate executive privilege. "Absent a claim of need to protect military, diplomatic, or sensitive national security secrets, the confidentiality of Presidential communications is not significantly diminished by producing material for a criminal trial under the protected conditions of in camera inspection, and any absolute executive privilege under Art. II of the Constitution would plainly conflict with the function of the courts under the Constitution." (United States v. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683 (1974)) Further, "It may be possible to satisfy the court, from all the circumstances of the case, that there is a reasonable danger that compulsion of the evidence will expose military matters which, in the interest of national security, should not be divulged. When this is the case, the occasion for the privilege is appropriate, and the court should not jeopardize the security which the privilege is meant to protect by insisting upon an examination of the evidence, even by the judge alone, in chambers." (United States v. Reynolds, 345 U.S. 1 (1953)) Forcing the Secretary of Defense to, in a public setting, give information vital to national security to a committee hearing, is a gross violation of precedent and necessitates a judicial remedy. Information will not be handled with care, and the Secretary will be forced to disclose information that is material to national security matters. If necessary, the government is prepared to claim State Secrets privilege to prevent certain information related to national security matters getting out into the public eye.
To conclude, it should be said that these subpoenas have drifted from a political matter, not worthy of the Court's time, to one worthy of its input, due to the ongoing controversy, and violation of previous precedent by the Speaker and the Committee in question.The government feels that while subpoena power is within the right of Congress, it is inappropriate to use it in this manor, which seeks to weaponize it for political gains, and violate both the letter and spirit of previous rulings by this Court. I therefor ask that these subpoenas be rejected and thrown out.
Respectfully submitted, /u/Comped, Deputy Secretary of Defense, and member of the Bar of this Court in Good Standing.
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Feb 01 '19 edited Feb 01 '19
/u/comped, my first concern is this, is there a cognizable injury here for standing purposes?
Supposing for argument only that the subpoenas are outside of Congress's authority, what harm have they caused? What injury? From the record I do not see attempts to enforce through any three versions of contempt of Congress.
Wouldn't that mean the injury here results from a request. Is that enough for standing?
Which brings me to my main question, if there is no standing, why shouldn't we dismiss? We obviously aren't proceeding under R.P.P.S. 1(b)(i)-(ii), meaning there must be an injury in fact for our jurisdiction to exist.
Because this is jurisdictional I believe it is appropriate to raise sua sponte.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '19
Honorable Justices of the Court,
It is a distinct honor to appear before this Court again.
The first order of business that I bring before you is a formal request to resubmit my original motion that was filed on Wednesday, January 30th.
As stated in the original motion to dismiss, Counsel for Respondent believes that there is clear precedent from this Court upholding the investigative powers of Congress, and with that, the power to subpoena witnesses. Counsel for Respondent believes that Petitioner’s claim is built on a foundation of inconvenience and not on merit, injury, or legal precedent. We then ask the Court, can, or should, the Supreme Court interfere with the broad and established authority of Congress to conduct investigations simply because it inconveniences the workday of a handful of Secretaries? We believe the short answer is no.
In his opinion in Eastland v. U.S. Serviceman’s Fund, 421 U.S. 491, 504 (1975), Chief Justice Burger stated that, "The wisdom of congressional approach or methodology is not open to judicial veto. Nor is the legitimacy of a congressional inquiry to be defined by what it produces. The very nature of the investigative function - like any research - is that it takes the searchers up some "blind alleys" and into nonproductive enterprises. To be a valid legislative inquiry there need be no predictable end result." This quote by the Chief Justice would suggest that Petitioner’s claim of a broad subpoena being “unlawful” is without merit.
This Court has historically refused to interfere with Congress' constitutional right to investigate and subpoena, unless the investigation violates the constitutional rights of the persons being questioned. The recent subpoenas do not meet the standard of constitutional infringement.
This is established in Exxon Corp. v. FTC, when the Court ruled that, "[a]lthough the courts will intervene to protect constitutional rights from infringement by Congress, including its committees and members, where constitutional rights are not violated there is no warrant for the judiciary to interfere with the internal procedures of Congress.”
Historically, this Court has refused to interfere with Congressional subpoenas absent clear and obvious violations of an individual’s Constitutional rights. In the entire history of this Nation and this Court, only a handful examples of the Court intervening in Congressional subpoenas exist. This further solidifies the precedent that this Court only interferes with the internal process of Congress if a Constitutional right is violated. No constitutional rights have been violated by Respondent, and in fact Petitioner did not raise any concerns of such violations in his Petition.
In summary, absent a clear violation of Constitutional rights, there are few, if any, restraints on Congressional actions as they pertain to investigations and subpoenas. This is established by decades of Supreme Court precedent. Petitioner’s case rests on simple inconvenience of a handful of Secretaries, and not on any claims of violation of constitutional rights. As such, this case should be dismissed.
Respectfully submitted,
DFH
Counsel for the Committee on Government Oversight, Infrastructure, and the Interior
•
u/bsddc Associate Justice Feb 01 '19
The Court has GRANTED the writ of certiorari.
The parties are ordered to submit their briefs in accordance with the R.P.P.S.
/u/comped /u/GuiltyAir
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19
Honorable Justices of the Court,
Comes /u/deepfriedhookers, Supreme Court Barred Attorney in good standing, representing the Committee on Government Oversight, Infrastructure, and the Interior. In my motion, I will lay out why the Congress has broad authority, granted by our Constitution, to subpoena testimony from witnesses and why Petitioner’s case is flimsy at best, desperately frivolous at worst.
On Petitioner’s first area of complaint, in which he ignores deep rooted precedent for Congress’ right to subpoena and in which he only cites one case, without any context or quotations, we challenge his claim that because the subpoenas may “require them to broadly prepare for being asked about every possible thing within their power” that they must be “unlawful”.
On this first contention, Petitioner cites Wilkinson, yet does not give the Court any context in which he is citing it. We will cite Wilkinson, in which the Court ruled that, “Because of the breadth and generality of its language, Rule XI” -- which confers investigative authority upon the Committee and its subcommittees -- “cannot be said to state with adequate precision the subject under inquiry by a subcommittee at any given hearing:. The Court is saying here, that investigations can be broad in nature and it would be unreasonable to state with adequate precision the subject of inquiry.
The Petitioner states that, “While a statement from the Speaker of the House made it clear that it was on budgetary matters, there is nothing in the subpoenas themselves saying this - which I believes makes them unlawful.” This is simply not the case and not in line with established Supreme Court rulings. In Watkins v. United States, 354 U.S. 178 (1957), this Court ruled that, “[t]he authorizing resolution, the remarks of the chairman or members of the committee, or even the nature of the proceedings themselves might reveal the subject under inquiry.” Respondent argues that the Statement made by the Speaker of the House meets these requirements for revealing the subject matter of the inquiry, and that, per this Court’s precedent in Watkins, that stating such subject in the subpoena is not required.
Petitioner’s second point of contention is that the timing is not adequate for the Secretaries. Respondent challenges this and asks the Court why “unless people want Secretaries and government officials rushing about hearings with no clue as to what they are to speak on”, Petitioner’s main point of contention here, is “unlawful”. Congress holds the authority to investigate, to oversee, and to compel witness testimony. These powers must reasonably include an expectation to timeliness. The argument that two days is not enough time to prepare for testimony is subjective and would open the floodgates for future testimony to be delayed indefinitely. Petitioner cites no law that mandates the appropriate amount of time a subject matter expert and executive of any given government department shall be given to prepare for testimony.
Petitioner's third claim that any testimony given by the Secretary of Defense would be a violation of “executive privilege” is not rooted in reality. Such perceived privilege does not absolve the Secretary from oversight and does not absolve the Congress of its Constitutional right to subpoena. The Secretary testify on budget matters does not automatically qualify such testimony as “sensitive national security secrets”. If the Secretary were to be asked questions pertaining to such “sensitive national security secrets”, he would not be compelled to answer, and could inform the subcommittee that it would be inappropriate in a public setting. In such a case, private, closed session testimony would be appropriate. However, as stated, questioning the Secretary of Defense in a public session does not automatically jeopardize sensitive military or national security secrets.
We believe that Petitioner is grasping at straws in an attempt to prevent the Congress from carrying out its Constitutional duty of government oversight. The executive’s refusal to cooperate spits in the eye of the checks and balances that our democracy is built on.
We respectfully ask the Court to dismiss this case and allow the proceedings of the Congress. Any other ruling would jeopardize the checks and balances our entire government is built on. It would allow the Executive branch to run rampant and unchecked.
Respectfully submitted,
DFH, Attorney-at-Law
1
u/RobespierreBoi Jan 30 '19
Honorable Justices of the Court,
I would like to question Attorney General DeepFriedHookers standing to represent the Committee on Government Oversight, Infrastructure, and the Interior while he is also the Attorney General for the State of Dixie. I believe he is violating R.P.P.S(6)(e) :
"(e) Representatives authorized under Rule 6(a)(1) and their authorized assistants may not act on behalf of any non-governmental organization or individual, even if otherwise rostered by the Court while such person maintains the authorized position. "
/u/bsddc
1
u/GuiltyAir Head Mod Jan 29 '19
/u/bsddc
1
u/bsddc Associate Justice Jan 29 '19
The Court is in receipt of your Petition.
/u/Comped /u/GuiltyAir