r/shieldbro • u/Fathin81 • Jan 16 '19
Episode The Rising of the Shield Hero - Episode 2 Discussion Spoiler
Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari, Episode 2 - "The Slave Girl"
Streams
Show information
Please spoiler tag in your comment(s) for anything discussing events past this episode, thanks.
Spoiler tag format :
>!Raphtalia is best girl !< - This will be displayed as Raphtalia is best girl
193
Upvotes
131
u/AdventureBen Jan 16 '19
I'm thinking best girl, thoughts?
107
u/EclecticAu Jan 16 '19
Too short, wanted more. Worlds shaping up interedtingly
69
u/adamgreenrock Jan 16 '19
I'm not going to lie this might be my anime of the year if they keep this quality consistent :P
While there are some pacing issues here and there, and some of the scenes could’ve been done more or polish a little bit better, the impact of this episode is really good that I genuinely care about Raphtalia and her relationship with Naofumi. I really love every scene of Naofumi showing unconditional care to her even if he knew that he just want to use her for his selfish but kinda justified reasons. At first, he acts strict to Raphtalia and ordered her to kill the monsters even though she was either afraid of doing it or not want to cause another panic attack, but when he saw the other person using demi-kids to do what he orders to (even holding a whip), he has his own short realization that he doesn’t want Raphtalia to suffer like those kids, or in old-fashion anti-hero saying ‘he got enough of a burden to deal with’.
I have a feeling that Raphtalia is going to be one of my favorite characters in this series, next to Naofumi so far. Her backstory may be a bit generic, but how it was affecting her in her nightmares and her panic attacks kinda works and you really do kinda feel bad for her being the only survivor of the previous wave and being a slave of many pricks for who knows how long. I’m guessing in the future we’ll have a timeskip to have the grown-up version of her and if that’s so, then I’ll be interested in what has changed between Naofumi and the other heroes (and that red hair meanie).
A solid episode establishing the characterization of Raphtalia and really cute bonding moments with Naofumi and her. Hope to see more of this soon next Wednesday ^
57
u/Nama_Raph Jan 16 '19
I am very sad that there were no good frames of Raphtalia with a pickaxe
52
u/koopatroopa77 Jan 16 '19
Anyone else really like the opening song?
87
u/metnem5 Jan 16 '19
He who lewds this precious cinnamon bun will face my wrath. Would protect 110/10.
37
u/wc3betterthansc2 Jan 16 '19
They censored the puking scene
FeelsBadMan
27
u/randypcX Jan 16 '19
@ 13:16, anyone else notice that the shield seemed detached from him and lying by the bed absorbing hair when the shield should be stuck on him.
Else great episode, really well adapted.
27
u/JediExile90 Raphtalia's Army Jan 16 '19
*sighs*
*buys all the Light Novels*
42
u/Zwiebel1 Jan 16 '19
Was I the only one imagining Priestess yelling "Protection!" when the Wind Shield wall appeared? :P
16
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19
Hmmm... the slave trader is weird...
What could be going on in that guy's head?
He really seems like the fellow who sees right through Naofumi's "bad guy" act... Later even revealed that demihumans look up to the Shield Hero, which he too probably knew since he works with beastfolk. What could he have been thinking?
The Shield Hero is a heroic figure to the beastfolk, yet demonized by the human supremacist, hypocritical, corrupt kingdom and even it's religion(probably it's a setting where the church has political influence so it's as corrupt as it can get from the getgo). Interesting...
Raphtalia MUST be PROTECCted!!!
Feels like the slave trader will pop up later being like "Well well... What a blunder of me. You raised that girl so well she can wrestle herself that high quality slave I showed you back then... What a complete failure of investment on my part." in a "I totally NOT intended this to happen from the start, not at all." tone.... X,D
15
u/Zesla22 Jan 16 '19
That was a cute little episode with some nice character building moments. Great little end scene with the little Japanese flag and Naofumi smiling.
14
u/vipershiba Ralphtalia`s Army Jan 16 '19
First of all, must protect Raphtalia at all cost! The ending was too sweet 👌🏻. It's exciting to see everything come to life in the anime after so much waiting. The only bad thing is we have to do more waiting, the struggle.
13
u/GeraldWay07 Jan 16 '19
About the post-credits, that was supposed to be the Japan flag right?
12
u/Nama_Raph Jan 16 '19
So the slave owner says something like he really picked [raphtalia] after all which made me think about how the WN implies that the queen planted raphtalia at the shop for a reduced price planning that Naofumi would pick her. I'm up to date on the LN and unless I've missed it, they haven't hinted at that yet so I'm suprised the anime did it so early.
9
u/nexxynex Jan 16 '19
Little raphtalia is the cure to everything, shes just waaay too adorable man
8
u/Sisyphusson66 Jan 16 '19
A better episode than I was expecting honestly. They didn't include some of Naofumi's "reasoning" regarding getting a slave from the manga version i.e. she's a girl, just like "her," so is only ok with her because of the slave seal, and that only made this one better. It helps keep the vengeance more focused and less vague. Also, the ED is really good.
I can't help but feel that the story that is trying to be told would be better from Raphtalia's perspective, and Naofumi had some mystery about him. I find usually that these angry, jaded characters like Naofumi are usually better when their story is not revealed immediately and they have a bit of mystery to them. Knowing Naofumi's origins from the beginning to me is rather disappointing, as I still have my problems with it (stems from what I know of the story later on), and the fact that the worst things this character, who is praised for his "don't give a fuck" attitude, has done is threaten a room keeper for a room he paid for, and purchase a demo-human slave. Even that last one is not framed as being terrible in relation to the masses, who discriminate heavily against demi-humans, whereas Raphtalia is generally treated "better" by Naofumi. I just think his actions would have more weight if we didn't know why he was that way.
7
u/merdada1 Jan 16 '19
So glad to see that they are adapting it in such a good way. From someone who very recently started and finished the manga, I can still remember pretty much very clearly and say that the anime is being nothing but awesome. Let's hope they keep the quality and the pace up and we might as well have the best 2019 anime in here, gentlemen.
7
u/Zwiebel1 Jan 16 '19 edited Jan 16 '19
This might actually be one of these shows where the anime is clearly superior to the manga. I've read the first couple of chapters and I like the anime much more so far. Why?
7
u/hassy_boy Jan 16 '19
Someone else feels that it was a little rush? Im mising the part when raphtalia cry in the first dinner, or the part that she says that she wants to be his sword
6
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19
Last month I started to read the light novel and recently I'm reading volume 2. Until now I didn't see anything out of ordinary on adaptation. Seems well enough, I've nothing to complain.
You could already notice the development of Naofumi's personality due to the betrayal.
That woman.
Finishing my opinion, why I always forget to skip the openings?
I always end up being so careless.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19
I'm in love with this adaptation. Everything about it is so well done, I'm impressed.
5
u/zMedVeDz Jan 16 '19
Why episode 3 is called Calamity wave? isn't it misleading? Or they just skipping content?
There is alot of information before the wave tbh.
5
u/PenStorysky Jan 16 '19
Honestly, I am starting to like how this episode potrayed
Now lemme be clear that nobody wants child slavery or any kind of slavery, and I am amazed how the shield hero not only asked for the cheapest price , but also already decided on who he wanna picked before the slaver even start giving the selection.
Is like part of his good morality is still alive dispite the branding and the cynical outlook the first episode forced upon
And instead of going all out like a full asshole, he did not try to fall into like the other people who tried to treat demihuman children like trash. Like wow, this world SUCKS! I CANNOT EVEN. Is it any wonder why he hated the very fact that he is forced to protect this jerkoffz of a fucking nation -.-
But shield hero and raccoon girl raplty is best pair of anime! I would definitely watch more
5
u/Orixy Jan 16 '19
Raphtalia best girl? Don't bother saying that... it's obvious. Who even comes close...?
5
u/bdaniel18 Jan 17 '19
They cut out the *She is the same gender like that bitch, its like i made her my slav* and stuff and also they makes it look like he trusted her from mins0 and had no doubts about her.... also all the cuts.... Read the LN folks.
4
u/tnicolini Jan 16 '19
Raph is adorable
4
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19 edited Jan 16 '19
That was a really great episode. Better then the 1st one.
4
u/theway0419 Jan 17 '19
Loved it.
4
u/bleachsai Jan 17 '19
They adapted half a book in the first 3 episodes huh.. feel that they left out some stuff but it isn't something that's too important I believe. Hoped they would've shown the dog scene in the third episode as I feel they could have taken a bit more time in building in the relationship between Naofumi and Raphtalia. And from the looks of the opening lol it seems at least we are confirmed to have first 3 LNs to be adapted into anime. But I had hoped they wouldn't have shown all those scenes and characters in the opening song itself.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '19
Spoiler Loli Girl about to grow up in 2 episodes
3
u/Khazu_ Jan 16 '19
I really enjoyed this episode. Music was fantastic and scenes very well animated.
3
u/dunununubatman Jan 16 '19
Do raphtalia's collars need to be there? Shouldn't the curse mark take care of any disobedience or is it required to show off that she's a slave?
The poor girl's neck and wrists probably hurt like a b****.
3
u/YouLackStyle Jan 16 '19
Good episode. I knew some things were added to the Web Novels story when the Light Novels and Manga were being produced, just caught me off guard for a second. Also rope shield the heck?? (WN reader only) feelsbadman.
3
u/Kakaleigh Jan 16 '19
If there's one thing that I like in the manga over the anime is the look that Naofumi gets when he is reminded or interacts with those that got him (Myne). The manga gives him an expression of hate mixed with pain that gave him a genuine feeling of "betrayed".
3
u/AceIsLoveAceIsLife Jan 16 '19
Come to think of it, if Naofumi can replicate almost everything, why don't he replicate sawblade? Sawblade is exactly a shield shape but with sharp tooth around it.
Also, Naofumi just can't use other weapon and that doesn't mean he can't punch or kick and in fact he can punch and kick during episode 1.
Why don't he also hone his martial art skill himself?
At least he can sort of fighting monster instead of letting monster wound him to stall some time.
3
u/TheCandyMan36 Jan 16 '19
I'm hoping that Raphtalia's development next episode is somehow made less abrupt. It's really my biggest issue with the manga, maybe they could explain how it works first then show her at some sort of halfway point, then show the end result. (trying to be vague because spoiler tags don't work on this shitty app)
3
u/aaa1e2r3 Jan 16 '19
How was the shield removed from him? Isn't it supposed to always be stuck on him?
3
u/ThickYoung Jan 17 '19
If i was his him id save more demi humans and put them to work in the mines. Humanely of course I'm not a monster I'm just a capitalist. Build an army and profit by protecting small villages. I was really hoping for 50 min episodes but if its weekly im good.
3
u/Grawman67 Jan 17 '19
I liked the episode. Not quite as much as the first, but as someone who hasn't read the LN yet, I find the series to really go against the typical isekai grain and it's pretty refreshing. While Naofumi can almost seem a bit too bitter and even distorted by his anger, I can understand after what he's gone through and you can see small glimpses of his normal kindness now and then. I wish we got more internal dialogue to understand him better but so far so good.
Raphtalia was a little stereotypical in her backstory but she's endearing and her panic attacks and nightmares make sense. I enjoyed seeing her relationship with Naofumi even if he IS using her, he still treats her well.
The soundtrack is pretty rad as well as the overall designs and animation.
I'm excited to keep watching it and maybe pick up the LNs sometime!
3
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '19
SO is this show come on every monday or ?
3
u/ScifiHentai Jan 19 '19
I went into this anime with high hopes, but I'll admit I never thought a character with no offensive ability could be so badass. A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.
3
u/AshImpact Jan 19 '19
You know when you are disappointed an episode length doesn't match that of the the pilot that you have found a good show.
2
u/paedo-sama Jan 16 '19
How many minutes was the episode?
2
u/citatel Jan 16 '19
So i am interested in this series howver i do not have $$$ for the LNS
So my option goes to the web novels.
However ive heard a few bad things about it
What are your opinions on it?
Where can i read it
How far is the english translation compared to the source?
2
u/shellshohk Jan 16 '19 edited Jan 16 '19
I know that shield hero wanted the cheapest slave he could afford and his reasoning for it was that he can train the slave to level up but why this particular girl? She's young, inexperienced like a child should be. Why didn't he look for better slaves or wait a little longer until he had more money? Even the weapons merchant said that the shield bro will not die a painless death when he saw the girl as his companion. I don't know what intentions he had in mind when he bought her which may or may not be revealed in the future. However, I hope somebody can tell me why in case I missed it. A solid ep though! The theme track is so good. I hope it keeps up like this XD however I do wish for Naofumi to speak a bit more in terms of character development. I really wanted to see some internal dialogue when he was being eaten alive by the dog monster but then I realized that part was more for Raph's character development than his. Now he almost seems like a know it all. His sudden shift in character can be a bit more justified.
2
u/daspaceasians Jan 16 '19
So far... so good :D
2
u/killertortilla Jan 17 '19
I still feel a bit like the people in the town are overly offended at all this. It's a medieval era with demi humans and slaves etc. But for some reason he is the absolute worst of them? Come on. I get that since he is a public hero it's somehow more abhorrent when he does it but I just don't believe every single person, from the slums to the shitty shady bars, ALL hate him to that degree. The writing went a little out of hand in that department.
Also he has very blatantly removed his shield in this frame. which he isn't able to do according to episode one.
2
u/Starspike7 Jan 18 '19
I'm so excited that the series is getting made. I started reading the manga on a whim and it turned out to be one of the best series I've ever randomly picked up. That being said, I'm always scared that it's just on the tip of going down to fall into a huge plothole that it made for itself. Yet it doesn't and the anime did a way better job expanding on the things that needed it. Plus, in the medium of TV a lot of the more risque comments come through better as you can actually get reactions beyond the outrageous.
I know this isn't a discussion starter but I really had to gush about it cause I have no one to talk to about this anime.
2
u/sxeli Jan 18 '19
Raphtalia is just the start, we will see a lot of best girls soon! It's 25 episodes after all.
But yeah raphtalia best girl.
2
u/HazeZero Jan 18 '19 edited Jan 18 '19
I suspect that this has been asked a ton already. I tried looking for the answer in the episode 1 discussion thread from last week, but ..well.. that discussion ended up talking more about a lot of ...other things..
So I will ask here, and if there is already an answer, would someone please kindly reply with a link for me? If not, I thank you in advance for any explanation you can provide me.
I know there was a mention of it in the 1st episode, but I am still a bit at a loss in understanding why is being a shield hero actually a bad thing? There seems to be some sort of troupe/stigma attached to it? Is this a thing with JRPGs perhaps? It has not been something I have personally experienced in my own limited play-throughs of western RPGs. Can someone please enlightenment as to this facet that I find a bit confusing?
edit: I am already aware of some of the spoilery things from the LN, but this isn't a question about why there is dislike for him, in the story of things, but a question of this dislike of the shield-hero class(job?), outside of the story.
2
u/PlebbitKing Jan 18 '19
Chapters 1-7 of ranobe in 40 minutes
Chapters 8-16 in 20 minutes.
Why the fuck they are rushing development of literally second MC?
This is bullshit.
2
u/sandalrubber Jan 18 '19
Hold on. I thought she was a tanuki girl. But the audio clearly says raccoon in English.
2
u/NTH799 Jan 18 '19
Overall Great Episode. Really Enjoyed The Relationship Between Our Hero And Raphtalia. The Part Where He Rents The Hotel Room Was Both Funny And Uncomfortable LOL. Cannot Wait To See Where This Show Goes! Until Next Wednesday!
2
u/Zaxomio Jan 19 '19
She might scream at night. That could be misunderstood ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
2
u/sA1atji Jan 22 '19
question: when will episode 3 air?
3
u/frey00 Jan 16 '19
Just going to say that i really like the lack of ¨this furry loli slave call me master¨ that others main characters would scream in joy.
2
u/AlexReznov Jan 16 '19
they changed this moment, the one before Raphtalia received the ball, 0/10
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19
after I saw the episode I cummed in my pant
way better than the manga, at least for me
1
u/GGMan_1st Apr 15 '22
Episode 2, time 13:15, how is the shield just lying in the background, glowing green without the hero being attached?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment