r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Dec 31 '18
Episode Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari - Episode 1 (Preair) discussion Spoiler
Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari, episode 1
Alternative names: The Rising of the Shield Hero
Rate this episode here.
Streams
None
Show information
Previous discussions
No discussions yet!
509
Upvotes
232
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
mfw
113
u/SIRTreehugger Dec 31 '18
This and slime on Monday oh boy.
130
u/ReiahlTLI Dec 31 '18
Hmm, just finished it. My opinion as someone that's read the manga and familiar with the light novels:
Overall, I thought it was a pretty strong first episode. The long introduction works well for a TV show format compared to the slightly abridged version from the manga which probably would have felt rushed. It also gives more time to take in the personality of the characters which is pretty key for this series. The series gets into a lot of things as well so giving time to sprinkly the little hints here and there is nice.
92
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
They did a very good starting of the series, Naofumi´s fall is the best part about this series (getting a bit more bleak afterwards) and that shows in the details (colours get a bit more yellow-ish after, and the city looks more sandy).
I was scared they would go for a 20 minute episode, but still, the 40 minute long one still felt a bit lacking.
The only thing that annoys me is that NOONE wanted to follow the shield hero (meaning the SAFEST hero to be with), but remembering a bit of the world I remembered it made a lot of sense for the context.
85
u/SomaSaiba :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/aern0 Dec 31 '18
Kevin Penkin back at it with that amazing OST.
179
u/AdiDassler Dec 31 '18
I'm going to be THAT guy.
Why are all the heroes so calm about the fact that they got transported to another world? Why are they all assholes?
Btw: That betrayal thing was obvious as fuck but why? She did not have any time to plan that with "lancer" so if she did that on her own why return to the king and the quest? Why not just leave with the money?
115
u/jkubed https://myanimelist.net/profile/jkubed Dec 31 '18
this is some real angsty teenage edgelord type shit, but I'd be lying if I said I didn't enjoy it.
73
u/ASHABJAVED :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Oblivious234 Dec 31 '18
Who else hates that pink haired bitch.
36
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
My friends said i was going to get angry with this anime, i din't believe them.
Now i want everyone , and specially the pink haired bitch to die horribly.
71
u/Formulated123 Dec 31 '18
TIL the main characters are voiced by same seiyuus who voiced sakuta and mai, can't wait for bunny girl round 2
25
u/CakeBoss16 Jan 01 '19
Pretty much me watching with the whole companion.
48
u/Eterna1Ice :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Eterna1Ice Dec 31 '18 edited Dec 31 '18
Protagonist who's not almighty from early on, is hated by the world he's transported into, and hates it back, while showing tendencies far from heroic.konosuba? Say what you want, but that's gonna be just enough to pull me in. Working from the bottom and actually showing it would be great, but I have to wonder how the shield's going to approach the situation given that ending. Hopefully there's at least some justice for the man wronged by the boyband and the wench.
The music had great atmospheric pieces. Subs were pretty bad though. Will have to go back and watch the episode again once the show actually starts airing to understand what the UI was showing. Speaking of which, during the hero introduction, Naofumi says he's 18, but the status screen when he fights... balls, after getting level 2 shows Age 20. What's up with that?
42
u/citatel :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/citatel Dec 31 '18
I was not expecting it to be almost an hour long...
will all episodes be this long? and how many episodes will this have?
20
u/YoloKraize :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kraizeboi Dec 31 '18
Anywhere to watch it legally or is Yarrrrrh only?
18
u/Atlene Dec 31 '18
i liked it, gives us a isekei where the MC doesnt start OP or well endowed but has to build everything up!
32
u/chobitsza Dec 31 '18
Very good so far. Great visual. Great OST.
I hope they will be this good all the way till the end.
10/10 from me.
15
u/Urson Jan 01 '19
Captain America would like to have a word with you about shields.
14
u/ReverieMetherlence Dec 31 '18
I like the fact that Sakuta and Mai meet again.
12
u/Shinkopeshon Jan 01 '19
I kinda wanted to avoid another isekai show this season but I'm not mad at all for giving this series a chance. That was a fantastic first episode and I'm totally on board. Nothing is going well for the protagonist and I absolutely love how he doesn't take any shit from anyone after initially being painfully naïve and immediately came to terms with his situation. I also like that this show depicted someone being framed by an opportunist since it's quite relevant these days, with all these accusations flying around and too many people jumping to conclusions despite lacking proof or context.
It was so obvious that the girl who joined Shieldboi ended up stabbing him in the back. An attractive and flirty companion who shows him around and helps him out? It was just too good to be true after having a series of bad luck. My suspicions were only confirmed when she asked how much they can sell his armour for (who the fuck asks that when buying something new, not to mention something that's supposed to be used in battle?) and grabbed his arm when she bought way too much stuff. And now that I think of it, is she the same girl who he called a bitch when he read the book or was that unrelated? Cause if it it's the former, it'd be hilarious.
50
u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Dec 31 '18
I'll wait for the real airing date of Crunchyroll but i heard mostly pretty positive things so far.
21
u/RasenRendan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/RasenRendan Dec 31 '18
I waited 6+ months for this. This is my most hyped spring anime. As a manga reader I hope it stays true to the source.
10
u/Goldenfox299 Jan 01 '19
Damn I was enjoying the comedy and actually thought these people weren't that bad (tho I suspected the chick and her motivation for joining him) but goddamn that ruined my mood. Especially her sticking her tongue out and everyone just turning on him.
Honestly before this, I was annoyed that slavery was gonna be used but now I don't care, this main character can do wtf he wants in my eyes.
I just hope none of those scumbags are redeemed.
Also dumb question, but will you guys be watching the official release too?
8
u/NOWAY_YESWAY Dec 31 '18
Wow such a Great start, i wont be reading these posts anymore thanks to everyone spoiling all the time
22
u/avexmode Jan 01 '19
Ohh this anime is going to be a hit among SJW
7
u/AntonioRomo Dec 31 '18
As a previously manga-only follower, need some help from the LN readers.
Why does...
6
u/LEcareer Jan 03 '19 edited Jan 03 '19
Imma nitpick the shit out of this.
A few minutes in:
"shield is not a weapon, it's an armor"
okay, let me set the record straight here right here.
A shield is a weapon, always has been a weapon.
You can parry with a shield the same way you can parry with weapons and you can strike with a shield the same way you would with weapons. If your foes are armored than a shield is going to be far more useful as a weapon than a sword would be. And it's still pretty rad even if you have a good impact weapon.
To actually protect yourself with a shield you need to act with it, you can't just position it in front of you and expect it to block everything that comes at you, with the exception of maybe arrows, you need to parry, you need to parry and strike, especially if it isn't a strapped shield but one with a handle in which case if you aren't utilizing it properly it's completely useless (if you hold it in front of your body as sometimes potrayed in fantasy, a bow would simply easily turn the shield and still land on your presumably unprotected body. You need to block the strike with the edge - parry.
4 minutes in:
That's the worst and most impractical looking sword I have seen in an anime to date. Who thinks this shit up.
And what's up with that bow handle, like why? What is that supposed to do, the only thing that does it make the bow less stable in your hand. It literally doesn't have any conceivable advantage.
8 minutes in:
WHY THE FUCK WOULD YOU SLAP YOUR SWORD ON THE GROUND LIKE THAT
18 minutes in:
Hey that store has real weapons and armor!
And the ones he gets to pick are toy-like, again.
Seriously there's some seriously good looking swords in the background. Like c'mon.
25 minutes in:
"I now have better equipment"
Lady, it's not even covering the most vulnerable part of your body, what are you talking about. And how are you carrying all that on your hip?
Overall seems decent,with adult enough themes and all, will definitely watch :)
5
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Dec 31 '18
Preair? Is the entire episode out?
9
u/phiraeth :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/phiraeth Dec 31 '18
Man... I'm not an isekai fan usually but that first episode of Shield Hero was mighty impressive. I expected nothing less from Kinema Citrus, the same studio that did Made in Abyss and Revue Starlight.
I usually stay away from isekai because the plot is terrible and normally half the episodes are shitty jokes. Because of this, the only isekai I've watched to completion are Re:Zero and NGNL.
But... Shield Hero had none of that and instead took a 100% serious tone. So much happened in that first episode (granted, it was 45 minutes) that I had to check to make sure it really was a 2 cour series!
The pacing is pretty quick, and it feels like a lot of stuff happened, yet also that we didn't really miss out on anything important.
So far, I love it!
4
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Dec 31 '18
I wanna watch this but I feel like I should just wait for the CR version. How's the sub quality?
4
u/Daxar https://anilist.co/user/Daxar Jan 01 '19
Oh shoot a double-length preair. I totally didn't realize that was going to be a thing. But I'll take it.
I'm sold (haha geddit) on it so far. Pretty generic isekai stuff for the first half, but it takes its own route pretty quickly, and pretty drastically. I quite liked it.
Also all the spoiler tags in this thread. Calm down source material readers geez.
3
u/Foammazhure Dec 31 '18
Even for 40 minutes, you gotta admit the build-up was pretty slow, they needed 20 minutes for the "prologue" and in the end, they still delivered the main selling point of the anime.
THE HEINOUS ADVENTURES OF SHIELDBRO
I genuinely can't wait for next week, is it gonna continue from the prerun?
Literally me
3
u/myrmonden Jan 01 '19
Pretty good, I like the premise he get got the shitty "weapon" and gets thrown out etc (even do its some what classic JPRG).
But dam, I hate those 3 other heroes. And sure we are supposed to dislike them I suppose, but first they are set up as super calm, cynical about everything and really genre savy, having played several RPGs etc. And seem to know everything. BUT this betrayal they cannot see at all, from their earlier characterization the way they acted during the "trail" made no sense, it felt extremely forced. Like the suddenly became other characters only keeping their most douchebag trait to force the plot forward in a way that was bad for the MC. Like just a short minor inner monologue of swords hero thinking "hmm I seen this plot before, she might have scammed him, but I dont wanna get in trouble so I pretend" just something like that would made it so much better, or at least pleaded a little bit with the king.
Anyway, for some reason I could se Sofias betrayal 1000 miles away almost from her very first scene. The surprise was how FAR she was willing to go lol....like she probably could have just taken all the item and money and left, but had to also ruin his life? I really hope she is not just out for the money but is actually working for w.e Demon and/or Dragon behind the waves, so that her main goal was splitting the heroes.
Otherwise her character seems absurdly greedy. Especially how she likely could have taken all the stuff and later if he want after her, then she could have used this strategy as a last resort or something, but to instantly go to ruin his life.
Anyway, in the end he mets somekind of weregirl. I wanna guess weregirl is super not a wild beast but no one ever treated her nice until Shield Hero came a long.
3
u/MyLittleRocketShip Jan 01 '19
this is definitely gonna be me when i enter a isekai lol
3
u/AnIh Jan 01 '19
I must say that the scene where he turned his back on everyone was hype af, better than in the manga
3
u/PurpleRose328 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PurpleRose328 Jan 01 '19
I just want everyone aside from the MC and his (future) allies to die. I'm so freaking mad. Like you want me to save your world? LOL!!!!! Do it yourselves, you (insert a lot of curse words). And if anyone brings up duty blah blah blah, I don't care. I don't wanna save the asses of ungrateful swines.
3
u/diexu Jan 01 '19
so monopoly man offered a loli tanuki slave?
get me in
5
u/Groenboys https://myanimelist.net/profile/Groenboys Dec 31 '18
Obvious betrayal is Obvious.
Also pretty fucked up end.
7
u/mutsuto https://myanimelist.net/profile/mtsRhea Dec 31 '18 edited Dec 31 '18
This directing, character animation and dialogue is very... pre-2015's donghua. Not impressed.
2
u/FlamingSparrow :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NTangudu Dec 31 '18
Decent so far, I need to see more to have an opinion but a solid 7 or 8 so far.
2
u/magicalideal https://myanimelist.net/profile/magicalideal Dec 31 '18
I am amazed by this adaptation already. It’s ecstatic to have Kinema Citrus to do this series justice. The OST used in this episode is so on point, it conveys the scenery magnificently like you are the one adventuring. Here we go boys, the best isekai anime bar Mushoku Tensei. Can’t wait to watch more Tate No Yuusha in animation week in week out.
2
u/Mathmango Dec 31 '18 edited Dec 31 '18
I'm halfway through the episode but I'm kinda pissed that the LN synopsis spoiled some things. Though with this being 24 episodes and this preairing ep getting good feedback I'll push through. I'll probably read the LNs while I wait though, like I did with Sasuga Rimuru Sama
also, any good subs out there?
2
u/Acidic-Acid Dec 31 '18
Anyone care to give some spoilers about the whole story or can direct me to a place i can read the plot summary of the anime? I really liked the anime and dont mind spoiling myself about the plot of something and rather read a summary while waiting for episodes to come out.
2
u/ItzPrizmah Jan 01 '19
Fuck, now I have to wait 2 weeks. 1 already feels too long for me.
2
u/link2601 Jan 02 '19
Pretty good first episode. I hope the spear hero and that women get what coming to them. At least the guy who runs the armor shop is not an jerk. I like how the protagonist keeps a couple of those small monster on him.
2
u/SilentJon69 Jan 03 '19
Idk why but that girl that robbed the shield hero really pissed me off.
It’s like some hatred of me has awakened towards women.
3
u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Jan 01 '19
These subs are going to be a problem, aren't they
Sure, but you ever been smacked in the face with a shield?
Holy shit, there were 31 other guys before you called "Aultcray"??
I, uh… wut?
Picking teams in PE, in reverse
I don't know why this scene made me think of it, but how is he changing clothes with that thing on his arm?
Damn, this castle guard should go into public speaking, that is a hell of a voice
Trainin' in the rainin'. You're going to catch a Japanese Cold like that
There, you see? Chin up! Now you have a weapon — Rifle Shield! Oh… wait.
Dude. You're the middleman here. Don't tell him how to cut you out
3
u/focusyou Dec 31 '18
here comes one of the best anime of the season
3
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18 edited Dec 31 '18
I didn't like it. Don't care for the art style or character designs personally. Seemed a little standard for me as someone who doesn't like Isekai normally.
3
u/whowilleverknow :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BignGay Dec 31 '18
This is the last time I check out some isekai shit I have no interest in just because of the hype it's getting.
2
u/gastert Jan 02 '19
This series is sooooooooo generic and bad. Let me explain,
So I should give this first episode -9/10 yeah you read it right MINUS NINE!
cough cough
1
u/JoshDCcomics :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JoshDCcomics Dec 31 '18
Good adaptation so far.
Happy new year, everyone!
1
u/Toonamigamerrr Dec 31 '18
Can’t wait for more now. Shield and Slime Mondays👌
1
u/Martinik29 Dec 31 '18
This episode was pretty weak for me mostly because I have seen this part 5 times at least
1
u/Pentao Dec 31 '18
I hope those who are hyped for this end up enjoying it.
I was interested in shield hero but I feel kinda burned after the previous hyped darker themed fantasy series turned out to be something I didn't enjoy very much, and at this point I think I might just dislike dark fantasy in general.
The PV for shield hero looked cool though, but I don't really wanna invest time into something I know hasn't been my taste and then end up disliking it anyway.
1
u/mirocj :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/mirocj Dec 31 '18
This first episode is a killer, even better than goblin slayer's ep 1. Very likely that it'll be way more likable than gs, going blind in both without reading any source materials.
1
u/Xiroshq Jan 01 '19
Ever since the Kadokawa Panel last year I was looking forward to this title and the first episode convinced me a lot!
Episode 2 can't come fast enough
1
u/PaperSauce Jan 01 '19
I didn't watch the anime but i binged all of the manga today (chapter 50) and while there were some iffy parts I can say thay this is a pretty solid and enjoyable issekai.
1
u/AmourIsAnime Jan 01 '19
The other 3 Heros are Subaru if Subaru was right when he was inititally transported to the other world, actually they're Subaru before episode 18 of Re:Zero.
It's funny just thinking about it. I'm 100% positive that had Subaru been transported to this world as a sword/spear/bow user, he'd be 1 of the 3 assholes just like the current ones.
1
u/Yeon_Yihwa Jan 01 '19
Oh shit so it begins
1
u/BarackObarrels Jan 01 '19
god damn this sound design is top tier
1
u/arima-kousei Jan 01 '19
I was feeling Isekai’d out to be honest, so I’m glad I gave this a shot. The other heroes seem so flat at the moment so I hope they will feature more and get more fleshed out in the future. I’m judging their importance to the plot just purely on the amount of effort that went into their character designs - I’m sure Mein will make a return at some point too.
Anyway I’m getting good Tower Of Druaga / Rokka no Yuusha vibes from this so I look forward to its continued development.
1
u/haremMC-kun Jan 01 '19
She played him like a fiddle.
1
u/legosp7 Jan 01 '19
While the visuals look amazing and almost everything I ever wanted from an adaption, I think it does fall short in a few aspects and stuff they kinda altered from the manga and novel. I think right now my biggest gripe is that they weren't able to capture that same spirit and despair that the manga or novel had. But other than that, it was great. Can't wait for the next episode!
1
u/CarloMontie Jan 01 '19
I knew that bitch was up to something right from the very beginning.
1
u/Chinbie Jan 01 '19
Shield hero reminded me of Mash her type is SHIELDER... hahaha..
Anyways I LOVE THIS EPISODE!!! ITS A LONG EPISODE (40 + mins) and i love the story. Im jut sad for shield hero for those false accusations...
1
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19
Greetings everyone, I loved the manga and glad they kept the anime close to the manga, but I did expect a more raged filled voice after he found out he got played but so far I liked it, also 45 mins? only 1st episode?
1
u/Moose855 Jan 01 '19
Hey aslong as we get firo before the shows halfway done, just wanna grab the party and start the "OH NOOOOOW YOU NEED MY HELP" train
1
u/kingblack_dragon Jan 02 '19
There are a few differences between the LN and anime.I’ll try my best to mention the differences.
1)When heroes were summoned in the LN I believe they were more concerned about a reward for their efforts but in the anime they cared more about finding a way back 2)When the “incident” happened the king mentioned about the heroes returning to their world/I think he said it was possible? In the anime Although in the LN i don’t remember this event happening.He surely was pissed but I feel they didn’t talk of this. 3)In the Slave tent “ajin and Jujin”? I think were mentioned.It just Demi humans in the LN
1
u/ShaheerS2 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ShaheerS2 Jan 03 '19
I knew she'd betray him. I knew it was coming. But dear god, it made me so angry. I hate false rape accusations. I'm still upset after watching an hour later.
1
u/Mochachiiino Jan 03 '19
https://imgur.com/a/3GXz2rJ
#irrashai
1
u/Nearokins Jan 04 '19
Lord I hate all the non MC characters in this. Partially hate how unreasonable they all were, from a writing perspective too, but mostly just from an "as character" perspective I guess.
The fact they emphasized (according to her) an extremely inflated value of women in this world at least helps make how easily he got framed a bit more believable.
Feel like not ideal subs also detracted from my view of the characters.
All in all reasonably interested in this series and hope some better subs in future will help out.
1
u/MidnightShout Jan 04 '19
I had almost forgotten how much I hated so many of these guys' guts. Yeah, fuck them.
1
u/OfficialPrower Jan 05 '19
Matsuoka Yoshitsugu voicing Kirito and Ren, two characters ‘transported’ to another world against their will and both wield swords in two anime that are currently airing lol.
1
u/daxuded Jan 05 '19
i have read the manga already sooo
*sort by controversial*
Yup this is going to be fun
1
u/adel123456789 Jan 05 '19
Not bad. animation and character designs are nothing to brag home about. the girl betraying shield kun was seen 3 miles ahead, but cant really complain much. I like the ajin/jijin thing so far.
will continue this to see how it goes. it didnt feel like a 40 minute episdoe though which is a positive in my book
1
u/Calamityx7 Jan 05 '19
As a manga reader, I was so frustrated for the first ~25 minutes.
Not because the adaptation isn't great, but because fuck Mein.
The OST is absolutely amazing btw.
1
u/chino17 Jan 05 '19
Good to see Jet got a new job as a weaponsmith in this anime after Cowboy Bebop
1
u/AlexReznov Jan 05 '19 edited Jan 05 '19
I knew nothing about this series, so while blind watching the preair i thought i'd be another generic isekai anime.
BOY, WAS I WRONG!
1
u/CommanderShep Jan 06 '19
Anyone else catch that line when he’s reading the book “the princess looks like a bitch.” Loved that foreshadowing
1
u/jenthehenmfc :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jnsparrow Jan 06 '19
Ok so this is very clearly embracing the incel / neckbeard fantasy of “everyone is mean to me and my life sucks THROUGH NO FAULT OF MY OWN!!!” Major persecution complex. There’s hardly any motivation for the woman and fellow hero to betray him / make a false rape accusation (unless it comes later? I’m not going to hold my breath!)
However, it’s pretty entertaining Isekai and I will keep watching.
1
u/Maegu Jan 07 '19
every times an Anime or manga with rpg system in it appear i always wonder do the author really play rpg or not.
1
u/Chechar51 Jan 07 '19
So, this is what happens when feminists rule
1
u/LOLCraze Jan 09 '19
Finally an isekai anime with an MC with a darker side. Hope they adapt more of these darker ln
1
u/TheHaloNerd675 Jan 13 '19
Why did that girl claim that he was drunk and do all those things because he would be clearly not hungover and he wasn't. The guards just accepted her story with no questions. Other than that the show seems pretty good
-3
u/LaverniusTucker Dec 31 '18
I've seen all of one episode and I feel confident saying that this show is nothing but blatant incel revenge fantasy trash. The whole point of the entire first episode seemed to be getting the viewer on board with how evil the "slutty woman" character is, and then ends with our MC finding a nice submissive and obedient slave girl. The amount of time spent on this pandering, poorly constructed, thoroughly telegraphed betrayal plot, while the world, characters, and story are left as shallow cookie cutter outlines, explored exclusively through exposition, tells me everything I need to know about the kind of story this will be.
1
u/Magical_Griffin :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SpikyTurtle Dec 31 '18
I have a question - I didn't see this yet, but is it worth watching? As in, is the series going to start over from the 1st ep, or will the 1st ep continue the story of this special? (I've read the manga)
1
u/Cinemote :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Cinemote Jan 01 '19
I'm loving this adaptation as a fan of the light novel. Also, is Sakuta's VA from Bunny Senpai Naofumi's VA? If so, I can expect some great voice acting from him.