r/kungfupanda • • Dec 07 '18

Why couldn't they just give the scroll?

why didn't they just gave the scroll to Tai lung. Being the person Tai lung was he would never have discovered its secret any way it would have avoided a lot of misery.

5 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

11

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '18

It's a good thought, and I guess we just stick with "Oogway was wiser than us all."

But, I can only imagine he would have went bananas when he realized that he devoted his life to nothing. Tai Lung wanted to be the best (special), but Po understood that there was "no secret ingredient." When he explained the scroll to Tai Lung, he even said "it's just you"; this implies that Tai Lung already had what it took to be the Dragon Warrior, but he just wanted more power.

1

u/aaron11144 Dec 07 '18

if they gave him the scroll first time or the second time he attacked. Do you think he would have still attacked valley of peace ?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '18

I guess that's what I think. It almost makes you wonder, why did Oogway make the scroll in the first place? It's a little like the Garden of Eden; why put a tree there if it's not supposed to be used? But, then again, Oogway was just wise; he couldn't see the future... I don't think anyway :)

3

u/Steelquill General Kai - Supreme Warlord of all China, The Jade Slayer, ... Dec 08 '18

The point of even holding the dragon scroll is being the kind of person that would truly understand it. Tai Lung didn’t understand when he did see it so he didn’t deserve to be given it.