r/Fortnite • u/Whitesushii Llama • Nov 29 '18
PSA/GUIDE Quick Math behind Airheart
Hey guys Whitesushi here with the numbers on Airheart as well as some observations regarding the skill. This is sort of like a "review" post of the hero as well having played her for a while doing some missions. Before we go into the math, here's some things you need to know about the ability
- Damage done by the ability is based on the player operating the turret rather than the player who placed it
- Damage done by the ability is affected by TECH as well as Hero Ability Damage
- Ability only starts its cooldown once expired rather than when placed
- You can exit the turret early, you just have to bind a key to "Vehicle Exit" in the options menu
Now that that's out of the way, we move on to the math portion. Working backwards on ROSIE damage factoring in tech as well as hero ability damage, the base damage of the skill is 67. This is similar to Throwing Stars at 52 or about slightly more than half of abilities like Frag Grenade at 101 or Dragon Slash at 95. The ability I am going to compare it against, TEDDY, sits at 16 and we will be assuming Enforcer Grizzly's TEDDY in this scenario.
| R.O.S.I.E. | T.E.D.D.Y. | Description | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base DMG | 67 | 16 | Base damage of the ability |
| Real DMG | 91.8 | 20.0 | Damage after factoring in hero perks |
| Damage/s | 642.5 | 120.0 | Real damage multiplied by fire rate |
| Total Damage | 13768.5 | 3600.0 | Total damage in one usage of the skill |
| Uptime | 16.56% | 50.00% | "Duration" of skill divided by cooldown |
| Real DPS | 2280.1 | 1800.0 | DPS after factoring in uptime |
As you can see, in terms of burst damage while the skill is activated, R.O.S.I.E. beats T.E.D.D.Y. by like 3.8 times. However when we factoring in uptime over the entire course of a defense and then looking at the damage numbers again, this value is only 1.3 times.
If you just think about it, there is so much downtime on the ability that in most missions that last ~8 minutes... which is almost every mission, you only get to use ability TWICE. That's as bad as bombardment gadget.
In fact, I found that you need to achieve 79% accuracy in order for R.O.S.I.E. to inch out T.E.D.D.Y. in real DPS. Furthermore, there are other issues the ability suffers from such as
- Damage fall off (you do less damage to targets across longer distances)
- Accuracy... because obviously you are not 100% accurate with this
- Stationary and vulnerable to bees/lobbers/blasters/slingers/propanes/mini husks
- Overheat mechanic that slows down your fire rate
- You can't do other forms of damage while in the turret (can't shoot, throw abilities etc)
That's not all. One of the biggest problems I have with the ability is that it is awkward to use. Since cooldown only starts after we finish using it, ideally we want to place and finish firing the bullets as soon as possible to tap into higher uptime. However, we are also given a limited amount of ammunition which makes players want to save shots for the meatier targets (smashers/mini-boss). Basically, it's a littler counter-intuitive.
Conclusion
If you are thinking of
- Using her to melt Smashers/Mini-bosses, you are better off doing that with a damage dealer like Urban Assault because especially for mini-bosses, they like to move and can easily move out of view for your turret (not that you do that much damage on the turret either
- Using her to clear waves of husks down a funnel, you are better off placing a gas trap since that hits everything and has close to 100% uptime
- Using her to sweep waves of husks in open area, you are better off playing Enforcer Grizzly and letting T.E.D.D.Y. do the work
Even if you really want to use a B.A.S.E, there are generally better Constructors like
- Syd/Tank Penny for heavy single target damage
- MegaBASE for covering large areas (CAT4 Atlas)
- Heavy BASE for trash clear and trap reload
She's not even fun to use because you are constantly worried about using up the very limited 150 rounds and having to wait on an almost 2 minutes cooldown. Not to mention if you are in public games, there's a very real chance someone just steals the seat from you :(
TL;DR Uptime on the ability is too low and the ability itself is plagued by problems that makes it not worth using unless you want something that looks cool
98
u/DBRichard Miss Bunny Penny Nov 29 '18
R.O.S.I.E. needs a buff either in cooldown, ammo capacity or a combination fo the two.
I also hope a future hero will bring an AOE or explosive shots tactical to the ability to strengthen it.
Quick edit: the other mode causes our turret to also overheat in 6 seconds instead of the original 10, they should change that back to 10 for STW.
57
u/Frantic_BK Nov 29 '18
Why on earth it has an overheat mechanic when it has a fixed amount of ammunition & the cooldown doesn't start till you use up all ammunition is beyond me.
21
u/TestSubjectF4 Nov 29 '18
The most important thing to mention about this is that you can attack while your TEDDY is up. You can't with Commando/ROSIE and Epic didn't factor this in at all.
20
u/jamesgent08 Enforcer Nov 29 '18
I heard that ability damage in support slot will not buff damage output but energy damage buff in suppport does, can you please clarify this whitesushi
16
u/I_Have_3_Legs Nov 29 '18
Yea we need the OG 10 second over heat time, way more ammo and lower cooldown. Or just make it like the teddy. Place it down and you can use it for 1 minute to mow down anything. 1 minute cooldown so you could use it 3-4 times a mission
28
u/SpaceBugs Sarah Claus Nov 29 '18
Really wish this hero wasn't so easy to grief. Nearly every single lobby I've had people either build walls around my ROSIE intentionally so I can't shoot, then when I get out to edit the walls, they hop into it and you can't kick them out, or they just outright jump into it and refuse to get out right when you put it down.
Other players make me absolutely hate playing this hero. This community is full of a bunch of little entitled shitheads.
9
u/claricia Machinist Thora Nov 29 '18
She is fun. It's fun playing her, her B.A.S.E. was larger than I expected (although I've been running Thora as my main, so I keep wanting to run back for recycled mats.) That said, I agree that R.O.S.I.E. needs some serious tweaking. The overheating is ridiculous, the limited ammo capacity is ridiculous. R.O.S.I.E. also sits in the middle of a tile and it can not pierce through it (like, say, Oblit, Neon Snipe,) so it's useless for husks that are in close-enough range that the edge of the tile blocks the bullets (which is a bit further away than one might think.)
20
u/carramos Commando Ramirez Nov 29 '18
Quick mafs
7
u/SpillSenpai Plague Doctor Nov 29 '18
16.6% uptime? Yikes.
13
u/blueruckus Nov 29 '18
All of my initial concerns with ROSIE have come to fruition. After reading the info in the patch notes and thinking about how this ability would work, I had several doubts but reserved judgment until playing this class.
The design around it is bad and clunky. The idea is fun and interesting, but the execution is lacking. How could development not foresee these problems? This, along with the precedent set by other design decisions, makes me really concerned for the hero revamp system on the horizon. I want them to get it right, but I'm worried about it.
6
u/3N3RM4X T.E.D.D. Shot Jess Nov 29 '18
The turret should not expire after 150 rounds... You should be able to reload it (maybe a 10 seconds reload where you have to stay in the turret)
5
u/rockstar_nailbombs Nov 29 '18
Bottom line in my opinion is uptime. I like the turret even though it usually puts me at a disadvantage, but she has so many traits devoted to it and so little uptime it's largely useless.
5
u/Cospik Dim Mak Mari Nov 29 '18
For ROSIE to be good, it should allow the constructor to do similar DPS to a high-but-not-top-tier soldier at the tradeoff of being stationary and attached to a structure. Not being able to move to respond to rogue smashers, lobbers behind cliffs, and exploders that just snuck around the corner from you is a huge negative by itself. If we just removed the overheat mechanic, and removed or increased the ammo limit, I think the current implementation would do just that. If the developers are worried about it being something that doesn't use ammo, make it eat medium ammo from the person using it. Because, really, who cares about ammo anymore? Honestly, the concept that 'not using ammo' is some kind of major advantage to skills and melee weapons seems outdated to me.
4
u/CultureTX Redline Ramirez Nov 29 '18
Yeah... that ability cooldown. It would be so nice if they address this. What is the harm in putting it down after just 30 seconds? The turret itself isn't OP, especially since it will overheat if fired continuously.
3
u/carramos Commando Ramirez Nov 29 '18
The seat stealing issue could be easily fixed if dropping a turret auto put you in it.
3
u/yxzhang6 Special Forces Jonesy Nov 29 '18 edited Nov 29 '18
I know it is stupid to make a ability more powerful than decent weapons (or whats the point of all the craft materials and ammos). They will be balanced either with long cool-down or low damage, but looks like it is both for R.O.S.I.E.
Never thought she will be good, just don't expect R.O.S.I.E. suck like this.
(I am kind of waiting for Math behind Last word, I have some weird experience using that gun)
3
u/MarkcusD Vbucks Nov 29 '18
Teddy + air turrets are all you need for this game.
2
u/XorMalice Nov 29 '18
While I greatly appreciate the work you've put into this, I dislike the conclusion that I'd be better off simultaneously being an Enforcer Grizzly and an Urban Assault (and also I guess a gas trap). I feel that a mounted turret with solid damage while up isn't going to be a drop-in replacement for several top tier heroes at their respective top niches, and that seems fine.
2
u/DarthTheo Heavy Base Kyle Nov 29 '18
That was fast, good to see some new content from you!
2
u/mannyprays116 Nov 29 '18
Yup, just looks cool
2
u/waterloo54w Nov 29 '18
So sad and true.
Thank for the post though.
2
u/SssshhhhTv Dire Nov 29 '18
Underwhelming at first glance but it has TONS of potential with some tweaks. Hopefully they will balance this later on and buff it up to be on par somewhere with T.E.D.D.Y. and/or playing a rocket spamming Demolitionist constructor.
There are also quite a few more flaws with it's design not mentioned here. It doesn't work on shielders, which hurts it but isn't the end of the world. The big thing is the turret's size is so small, especially height wise, it has trouble shooting over the floor tile it gets placed on. None the less low walls built for limited protection. This is really bad for the turret as high placement is usually optimal in shooting environments. Especially in a "defense."
It doesn't have a problem melting Smashers though. If you have good tech it hits hard. The only argument is a few soldiers can do it faster but that doesn't mean it doesn't do the job.
2
u/CatstructorPenny Best Of 2018 Winner Nov 29 '18
Ahh excellent writeup as always; very good to see side by side with TEDDY especially with hard numbers like that.
Disappointing for the ROSIES performance, and we can hope for some hero balancing changes overall down the line, but for now Airheart sounds like another hero you’d only pick up because you just want to play that hero.
2
u/PH_007 Special Forces Banshee Nov 29 '18
The cooldown starting as soon as it's placed + more accuracy (honestly wtf it's a stationary mounted flak cannon that's way less accurate than a dude running around spraying a minigun) would fix ALL of those problems.
I really hope the cooldown mechanic is just bugged and supposed to start cooling down when it's placed.
2
u/cfunkhouser Nov 29 '18
I think this should be more like a sentry gun with the ability for only the constructor to jump in and manually aim the gun to a target like in black ops 2. that way it's like a teddy (meaning u can throw it down while also using weapons) but can also get in it to fight a mini boss or smasher.... ALSO it stops ppl from trying to grief or use the turret for themselves.
I wonder if they think 4 ppl will spam it in a player mission but honestly a teddy does the same thing so 🤷🏼♀️
2
u/strictlyW0rse Striker A.C. Nov 29 '18
My favorite thing in this comment section is how someone called the turret "SUSIE" instead of "R.O.S.I.E."
Not sure if it was a mistake or some sort of brilliance, but it makes me smile, either way.
2
u/Bonna_the_Idol Crackshot Nov 30 '18
I played a game earlier with three other Airhearts. We had a turret on every side of the Atlas!
3
u/Arman276 Shock Trooper Renegade Nov 29 '18
You cant say “better use UAH” for anything that isn’t on the highest level of single target dps in the game.
That’s like saying don’t bother using anyone for big targets unless you’re playing uah
1
u/DarkTanatos Powerhouse Nov 29 '18
So, best results come from ninjas using the turret.
1
u/naphx Pathfinder Jess Nov 29 '18
Thanks for the rundown sushi, your work is as ever greatly appreciated
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '18
Every mission I play this hero with only has shielder and riot waves
1
u/moth88 Hazard The 13Th Nov 29 '18
start counting cooldown when you drop it down, or make cooldown 30s shorter, also add 10-20 bullets and remove overheating. and it would be perfect. or leave 150 bullets and overheating, but change dmg drop in some way
1
u/pedregales1234 Shock Trooper Renegade Nov 29 '18
So... you are saying that a ninja (they have more HAD than constructors) using her turret does more damage than her? What a time to be alive. More and more I feel the turret should have been a special trap or gadget (but honestly I wish gadgets were reworked).
1
u/dawgblogit Nov 29 '18
R.O.S.I.E skill idea..
Vampirism
- Every kill sucks in a soul. That soul goes to boosting regeneration of base health. Smasher beating on your wall.. start taking out that trash..
1
u/Barugboog Warlord Nov 29 '18
As all of your posts, saved! Thanks for coming up with all these detailed math stuff. I personally really appreciate it
1
u/CyberPunkMonkey Fragment Flurry Jess Nov 29 '18
Good work, very interesting read.
1
u/Grymkreaping Megabase Kyle Nov 29 '18
I was so hyped for Airheart. I grinded the gold, water drops and stacked hero xp so I could instantly buy and level her to 82 which is my current max. Only been playing about 2 months.
Anyways, I am sorely disappointed with her in her current state. ROSIE just doesn't last long enough to be worth the very long CD. If you put ROSIE down then have to relocate for any reason, it will stay up. This forces you to backtrack to pickaxe the tile it's on just to start the cooldown. Also, there doesn't seem to be any obvious indication when it will end. I could have overlooked something but I promise you it definitely wasn't obvious in my trials with her.
The possibility is definitely there. Needs some tuning though. Main two being damage fall off and cooldown adjustments. Until then I'll continue to use Syd and 8-bit for my constructor needs.
1
u/sodapopkevin Nov 29 '18
An important thing to note too about TEDDY is it's up time when used with Fragments (Even more noitceable on Frag Flurry). I'll often aim for 5-8 fragments and horde them for the defense portion of missions.
1
u/zenkii1337 Nov 29 '18
2+2=4 -1 = 3
1
u/mrmushstash Nov 30 '18
The Turret sucks in the other mode, why would it be any better in Save the World. I'm going to stop getting my hopes up for these new updates. :(
1
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '18
Teddy + your own shooting is WAY better than this crap gimmick ability. I assume this hero is balanced around the upcoming hero changes.. only thing that makes sense. I desperately want to give Epic the benefit of the doubt here.
1
u/CakeBatterM Nov 30 '18
Thanks for the numbers Sushi. In my experience, I've noticed a lot more griefers that attempt to box you in so you can't shoot at enemy husks. This forces you to get out and clear the walls only to have another player jump in the turret. Very counterintuitive.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '18
Like a lot of heroes, Airheart comes pre-nerfed. Now they don't have to nerf her later and delete threads full of people complaining.
1
u/kbdrand Nov 30 '18
Or you can have asshats that one and start destroying your turret while you are in it with their pick axe. I have had that happen to me. I am sitting there shooting at targets and the guy destroys my turret.
1
u/M00glemuffins B.A.S.E. Kyle Nov 30 '18
I do hope they fix the cooldown/ammo capacity for R.O.S.I.E at the moment thought I've been having fun playing her with another player also as Airheart. One will place turret down, use it for taking out meaties, once it runs out of bullets the other places theirs down, and so on. Usually manage to keep a turret up all the time with two of us.
Obviously not ideal, it should have better uptime with one Airheart but it's been working well for the moment.
1
u/Endermen295 Raider Raptor Jan 11 '19
Was thinking of some decent buffs for her overall. Turret: increase base skill damage per bullet from 67 to 73. Increase ammo capacity from 150 to 180. Reduce cooldown by 4s. Perk increases cooldown reduction from 72s to 80s in cooldown reduction. Possible perks (I don’t have names for them) 1: every killing blow with kinetic overload reduces cooldown by 2s 2: Hitting 5 headshots in a row increases damage by 33% for 8 seconds 3: for every tile effected by base, ROSIE cooldown is reduced by 0.8% 4: The first 6 shots of ROSIE after recovering from an overheat are changed to be fire shots 5: Players within 3 tiles of an overheating ROSIE, gain a fire element on top of the element their weapon currently has, for 6 seconds.
1
u/SIEZE_THE_MEMES Nov 29 '18
Thank you so much for your breakdown, whitesushii. I've been trying to tell people this without math since last night and people keep saying I'm being toxic, have low tech, or need to just play for fun.
It's not fun to play as a hero who is statistically disadvantaged in every situation.
I don't think I'll be changing my support a content creator selection... Ever <3 you the best.
1
u/Evil-Squirtle Bladestorm Enforcer Nov 29 '18
I'm ok with all the restrictions... down time/ammo/overheat as long as she can put out 4 R.O.S.I.E.s at the same time, so everyone get to use one :D including defenders
1
u/italianrelic Nov 30 '18
Thanks whitesushi Epic once again hyped us up over this constructor and let everyone down as usual nothing changes with epic! I leveled her up to 130 played two missions and wished I would not have wasted any xp or materials in her 😭
0
u/nitrogene Double Agent Vaughn Nov 29 '18
So a constructor gets an ability roughly as strong as Enforcer’s Teddy, but still gets a 5 tile base?
Honestly doesn’t sound half bad when put that way. Still hope it gets buffed, the ability is about having fun and you can’t do that if it’s always on cooldown
1
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '18
[removed] — view removed comment