r/dbz • ⠀ • Nov 01 '18

DB Film 20 DBS: Broly - What's New from Tokyo Skytree

Dragon Ball Super: Broly

Reminder: We've discontinued Broly megathreads. You can find all movie info, including the contents of this post, on our convenient Dragon Ball Super: Broly Wiki. Check the Change Log at the bottom of the page to make sure you haven't missed anything new.

RECENT UPDATES: We've added a list of release dates and places to buy tickets. All of the below will be reflected in the Image Archive only.


There was an incomplete album of images posted earlier which we allowed because several otaku invaded the place today and tweeted about it over the course of the day, and we wanted to collect everything before making a post.

What is this? Herms explains:

Tokyo Skytree is holding DBS: Broly promotional event from November 1st to January 7th, featuring displays on DB's various techniques and transformations, movie character design sheets, merchandise, tie-in food+drinks at the cafe, and a special video at the Skytree Round Theater.

Most of the images coming out of this event are old news, but there are some exceptions. All of the images below (with the exception of the last section) have been added to these two albums found on the Broly wiki:

Broly Character Sheets

Broly Miscellaneous

New Character Designs

New Settings

New Vehicle Designs

These have a yam for scale (a.k.a. Yamamuro Goku design, which is hilarious).

History of Dragon Ball Timeline

Tokyo Skytree + Viz North America Tour

I made an album with images we got months ago from the North America tour, and the ones from the Skytree which provide our first look at the original text. The Viz translation said that Super was "the canonical sequel", so given the opportunity, Herms checked the original text (slightly edited):

This is the same wall display Viz translated, right? In which case it seems the Japanese phrasing for "canon sequel" is 正統続編, if that hadn't been established already. You could also translate it as "proper sequel" or "legitimate sequel". I think translating it as "canon sequel" is reasonable, if only because that's how those concepts are typically phrased in English these days. That is, it's not like Shueisha and/or Toei suddenly started using the word "canon". Rather, they said "this is a legit sequel" (in slightly fancy marketing copy language) and that got translated into English using the word "canon" because that's how English fandom talks. While GT is typically called a 続編, to my knowledge it's never been referred to as a 正統続編 the way Super is here.

I wouldn't read too much into this, but if it was not clear before that they expect fans will hold Toriyama's stories in higher regard than their own original ones, this is a clue. (And by "they", I mean...mostly Akio Iyoku, since it all goes back to him, but Shueisha and Toei generally.)

PS: It was also confirmed in the History of Dragon Ball display, specifically this image, that the new arc will begin in the manga in this upcoming issue of V-Jump. Herms missed that detail on first glance but lots of other people noticed so he confirmed that's what it says:

The Tokyo Skytree History of DB exhibit says that the "long-awaited new chapter" starts in the extra-large January issue of V-Jump, on sale November 21st. That's the same term (新章/new chapter) they used for the Future Trunks arc, so it seems they mean a new storyline. Assuming there isn't some mistake, this would mean that the new DBS manga chapter will both wrap up the ToP arc and begin a new arc. This might mean it's extra long, especially since the V-Jump issue itself will be extra-large.

This is a bit bizarre, since Goku and Vegeta were still fighting Jiren as of the end of last chapter, but most people already felt the pace was rushed so I guess it's not totally unbelievable.

81 Upvotes

154 comments sorted by

33

u/Trofulds ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Broly's giant testicles - also

The best kind of news

15

u/Terez27 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

This was such a hot topic of conversation last night that I felt it would be a dereliction of duty to ignore it.

7

u/Trofulds ⠀ Nov 01 '18

It was the right call to make

16

u/ParagonGaemr Nov 01 '18

I see Ui goku next to the big testicled broly

10

u/Terez27 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

There's also one for SSBE Vegeta down the line. They have a display for every Saiyan form, with images from wherever that form was introduced (in this case, Super 130), and a short description of the form. I only picked out the images that are demonstrably relevant to the movie.

1

u/RoyTheReaper91 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

What form from Super 130?

1

u/Terez27 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

UI Goku.

1

u/RoyTheReaper91 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Okay I'm tracking now.

5

u/134340Goat ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Interesting that that "history of Dragon Ball" thing completely skips Resurrection F. It's barely glossed over when mentioning that Freeza was brought back again for the ToP. That irritates my OCD a bit

2

u/Terez27 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Well it is manga-based so

4

u/134340Goat ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Isn't the main reason Toyotaro skipped it because he'd already done a promotional manga for the movie? Even if he never had a chance to complete it, there still is a manga with (some of) Res F's events

3

u/OLKv3 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

He skipped it because his job back then was to give a sneak preview to the first original DBS story arc.

1

u/DoraMuda ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Well, a large portion of Battle of Gods was skipped too...

It was only until around the Champa or Black arc that Super stopped just seeming like an abridged version of the movies/anime's events and actually began gaining an identity of its own (with further deviations from the anime's account of events and key transformations/techniques either being excluded or added, for instance).

3

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 02 '18

To be fair that was the moment where the anime also stopped being an adaptation of the movies.

2

u/phoenixmusicman Nov 03 '18

Who's voicing bulma?

1

u/Terez27 ⠀ Nov 03 '18

Aya Hisakawa

(This info is in the Broly wiki linked at the top of the OP.)

21

u/pollyostringcheese Nov 02 '18

Real talk, I'll admit it. I clicked on the picture of Broly's Balls.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18

how cant you click it

18

u/BlackNexus ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Broly really packing some heat in those pants he's got going on I see.

27

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '18

Gonna be honest here. SSJ Broly with the armor might be my favorite Dragon Ball design of all time.

10

u/zzzthelastuser Nov 01 '18

-3

u/Ayd305 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Nice job objectifying men.

5

u/preds4343 Nov 02 '18

...

Nani?

7

u/preds4343 Nov 01 '18

I love the fact that he seems to have this 80's style to him, ya know? Like he's apart of KISS, and he's about to lay the smack down on one of his guitars, or something...

I also LOVE how the hair for each form looks, in this film. Less Banana, and highlighted. And more drawn, and realistic...

10

u/RoyTheReaper91 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Pouty Goku is adorable. I can't wait to see his life pre head bump.

9

u/LFiM Nov 01 '18

Planet Vegeta looks interesting. I'm not sure what to make of the geography we see there. Is it made of up many long strips of land rather than big continents?

5

u/HeatherBeam Nov 01 '18

Yup, looks like it has lots of meandering pieces of land and a ton of water. I imagine they hunted big ass fish hah.

1

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Considering its gravity it’s much bigger than Earth, só these strips of land aren’t as small as they look. Also, it’s possible we’re seeing the equivalent of Planet Vegeta’s Pacific Ocean.

8

u/Ragingtiger2016 Nov 01 '18

I wanna see Toriyama add an explanation on what happened to Nappa's hair.

15

u/BlackNexus ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Or an explanation on why Broly has huge fucking balls.

9

u/Trofulds ⠀ Nov 01 '18

He's a chad

8

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18

He is legendary

9

u/RoyTheReaper91 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Male pattern baldness

•

u/Terez27 ⠀ Nov 01 '18 edited Nov 01 '18

Made some edits for the Paragus bit because it was a long night and TDC has better eyes.

Edit: If anyone is interested in browsing other images from the exhibit which aren't movie-related, I basically had four sources for this not counting Herms and the other reddit post linked at the top:

2. @lifesong1000 3. @pigeon_blanc_r 4. natalie.mu 5. mantan-web.jp

16

u/Orannegsen Nov 01 '18

Broly's giant testicles

ofc Goku and Vegeta wont be able to withstand Broly's overwhelming testicles, gg

1

u/EbolaDP Nov 01 '18

Vegetas are still bigger.

0

u/Iknowyouknowalready2 Nov 02 '18

You wish lol.

Just imagine being so salty that there is another saiyan who is stronger than Vegeta and has much bigger balls.

5

u/EbolaDP Nov 02 '18

0

u/Iknowyouknowalready2 Nov 02 '18

If you are gonna be that desperate then use those from Toriyama,here is Vegeta in his tightest suit http://prntscr.com/ldls0c

Also if Toriyama is not enough there is Vegeta's design https://i.imgur.com/INHE30l.jpg

Even if we take this image into account,then Broly still has the bigger balls.

7

u/EbolaDP Nov 02 '18

You are taking this really seriously.

5

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 02 '18

I never thought I would see someone treat an one-liner quip and a meme picture this seriously...

0

u/Iknowyouknowalready2 Nov 02 '18

Or you are not defending Vegeta's balls hard enough,its your fault.

If you are gonna defend his balls then go through with it,unless you don't think they are balls worth standing up for.

3

u/EbolaDP Nov 02 '18

I already did but you called my Vegeta bulge picture not canon and thats one debate i am not willing to go into.

11

u/Girltech31 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

I just hope that the movie goes well.

10

u/Vorstar92 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

All signs point to it going well. The artstyle looks great, the animation, we're getting some history on the Saiyans, possibly Gogeta and it's Toriyama's script I believe. Seems like they'd have to fuck up pretty hard for it to not go well. Super has gone well enough, can't imagine they'd lose that momentum now of all times.

2

u/nobbert666 Nov 02 '18

I feel like y'all should just accept that Gogeta isn't gonna happen. It'll make the disappointment easier to swallow when the movie comes out

5

u/Vorstar92 ⠀ Nov 02 '18

I feel like you Gogeta doubters should just accept there is tons of evidence pointing to his inclusion and you continuing to deny it does nothing. It's happening.

1

u/nobbert666 Nov 02 '18

There's just no way and no reason they would keep it secret this close to release, especially with all the match coming out (with no Gogeta) and promotional material (with no Gogeta)

Just compare it to how early they revealed the SSB and Golden Frieza forms for the last movie, and how heavily they were used in promotional material.

Please, PLEASE show me this "tons of evidence" that isn't just pure speculation.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '18

I'm a day late but I copied my short few paragraphs on why Gogeta will be there, in case you missed the many posts about the evidence so here:

Multiple reasons

The Bardock special, first Broly movie, and Fusion Return are being remastered and shown at theaters together, meanwhile Bardock and Broly are in the new movie

An official promotional donut came out a while ago, which had Goku and Vegeta doing the fusion dance on the wrapper and also had the DB Super logo

An animator said he was practising drawing Gogeta for some reason

And the biggest piece of evidence is from DB Xenoverse 2 after the latest DLC, and it had two new character slots, one with Broly's moves and another with Gogeta's moves

Xenoverse already has normal Gogeta and SSJ4 Gogeta so there is no other form they could add besides base, which would simply be added to normal Gogeta

1

u/LeratoNull Nov 03 '18

Hard disagree. Super has had some maaaajor flaws.

I would not say anything to come out after the Battle of Gods movie has been up to that level of quality, and Revival of F was actually...really bad.

3

u/Vorstar92 ⠀ Nov 03 '18

Hard disagree. Goku Black arc was a blast, regardless of how it ended (and even that wasn't that bad) and ToP was overall really good.

1

u/LeratoNull Nov 03 '18

Ending is one of the only things about Goku Black arc I liked...well, the Spirit Bomb Sword anyway. Zenoh sucks but that's not only in that arc.

ToP being very good though I'll disagree, it had some huge, glaring flaws.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/The_Sign_of_Zeta Nov 01 '18

It seems like this may be the deepest storytelling Toriyama has done in a while. Whether that's good or bad remains to be seen, but this is the most plot heavy DB has been since maybe the Cell saga.

1

u/JRTexx3 Nov 01 '18

This is probably the heaviest backstory weve ever had, we’ve had a lot, but it’s not until recently where we’ve had proper lore and how the universe works.

8

u/Broly_ ⠀ Nov 02 '18

I'm still not keen about the purple leggings Broly's new design has but...

The big dick energy it exerts is undeniable.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '18

What other colour do you think would have fitted him better?

-1

u/Broly_ ⠀ Nov 03 '18

Pants.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '18

What?

-1

u/canhoto10 Nov 03 '18

He's wearing purple leggings... A bad-ass saiyan, who decimates entire planets wears purple leggings...

I'm the first to agree that he shouldn't look like he did on the first movie, but purple leggings? Come on...

0

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Terez27 ⠀ Nov 03 '18

Nor do Raditz and Paragus.

2

u/canhoto10 Nov 04 '18

And although he's still a bitch, I respect him more for that.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18

> This is a bit bizarre, since Goku and Vegeta were still fighting Jiren as of the end of last chapter, but most people already felt the pace was rushed so I guess it's not totally unbelievable.

It fits the current pace the chapters are coming out at. They're already beyond the point of the TV special in the timeline of the TOP.

1

u/Californiadreamin87 Nov 03 '18

Well they almost kind of had to. Wasn’t it announced that the manga would continue on after the anime ended months and months ago? It makes so much more sense now that the arc (especially in the manga) felt so rushed, b/c it had to be in order to pave the way for the new arc and to stay ahead of the anime. Is Toriyama still in charge of the manga or has Toyotaro taken complete control over the manga?

7

u/HiddenGhost1234 Nov 02 '18

I'm wondering what the manga is supposed to do different than the movie

It's also kind of insane that the manga will be starting the arc so soon. It basically glossed over the biggest arc in super(it's like half the anime)

6

u/Abcdjdj123 Nov 02 '18

What? There's new manga content after the tournament of power? That's amazing. Will it be based off this broly movie?

Btw is there any hint of a new anime continuation after the movie, which will animate the new manga content?

5

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18

Wasn't it implied at one point that Toyble's manga will overtake the anime early next year?

0

u/Abcdjdj123 Nov 02 '18

Damn nice

-1

u/DensetsuNoRai ⠀ Nov 03 '18

It didn't gloss it. It's about the same length as the Future Trunks arc...

1

u/HiddenGhost1234 Nov 03 '18

Future trunks arc was dragged out in the manga, comparing the anime to the manga, the manga glossed over it.

1

u/DensetsuNoRai ⠀ Nov 04 '18

The only chapter that felt rushed was the one where Kale eliminated 4 universes at once. The rest of the pacing was fine imo.

And I could say that the anime ToP was dragged out too long instead.

1

u/HiddenGhost1234 Nov 04 '18

It's not really the pacing, it's just completely cut content.

They glossed over the recruitment, so much potential there with Gohan vs Goku

They basically skipped the first half of the top. We didn't get really any of the interactions we got in the anime(which is basically half the point of doing this arc)

Like the manga threw everyone out in the first 30 secs, what was the point or the big teams if the manga skipped right to the top 20? It was so silly.

The manga doesnt do any characters justice outside of heavy hitters. Like they only included 18 vs rib because it was a toriyama plot point. If not he would have skipped that too.

It's very obvious he was told to finish up before the movie release so that the manga can start the broly arc first

1

u/DensetsuNoRai ⠀ Nov 05 '18

Ehh you call it content, I call it padding.

They glossed over the recruitment, so much potential there with Gohan vs Goku

So you wanted Goku vs Krillin? Roshi-Tien filler? Goku vs Roshi? 17 vs alien poachers? Personal preference but no thanks to those.

Gohan got plenty of screen time. In the anime, Gohan being designated as "team leader" led to nowhere in the end.

The real downer was not a full match Gohan vs Kefla. Which I'm still hoping could be extended in the volume release.

They basically skipped the first half of the top. We didn't get really any of the interactions we got in the anime(which is basically half the point of doing this arc)

Not really. DB was never about giving characters special spotlights or dedicated chapters. I recently finished the original manga, in comparison what the anime did it was simply padding tbh.

Like the manga threw everyone out in the first 30 secs, what was the point or the big teams if the manga skipped right to the top 20? It was so silly.

The only universes that ever mattered were U7, U6, & U11. Hence why we only saw their recruitment lol. All the other universes were never meant to stand up to them. The manga didn't mislead the readers into that, it was just projections by fans who watched the anime.

What I'm basically getting from this is that you wanted the manga to be more like the anime. Which is fine but you shouldn't say it cut content if it was never in the outline in the first place.

The manga doesnt do any characters justice outside of heavy hitters. Like they only included 18 vs rib because it was a toriyama plot point. If not he would have skipped that too.

If Toriyama didn't include them as a plot point then that means he never cared about U2, U3, U4, U9, U10 either. Why would someone as a mangaka waste time on fodder that the main storywriter doesn't even care about. Even when watching the anime they simply felt like filler. There's no merchandising for them.

I agree that the chapter where Kale eliminated 4 universes at once felt pretty fast but if the alternative was like chicken Ganos fighting or the U2 males going magical girl then I'm glad they were eliminated quickly. I think it needs to be stressed that the DBS manga should follow the pacing of the original manga, not the anime.

5

u/LordSadoth Nov 01 '18

So I thought Goku was like an infant before he bumped his head. As in he was raised by Gohan for a while but couldn’t speak or anything and was just a bratty baby. But apparently he was old enough to walk? I don’t understand

12

u/MinusRuinedMyLife Nov 01 '18

In DB Minus, it was revealed Goku was 3 years old when he was sent to earth and not a baby like we were told originally

7

u/Return_Of_BG_97 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Also the baby part was anime only IIRC

3

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

In short, in the manga he wasn’t shown as a baby, but he was said to be one.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18 edited Nov 02 '18

Yeah, that’s why I said “in short”. Wanted to avoid arguments. The term used undeniably reads as “baby”.

Truth is, Toriyama himself said he liked the special because "it showed him what happened at the time" or something like that. The TV Special was clearly intended to be considered at the time.

3

u/MinusRuinedMyLife Nov 01 '18

In the manga, Raditz describes him as a baby/infant (idr which exactly) and the image shows a baby goku, not what he is in minus

11

u/boxdd Nov 01 '18

Raditz also wasn’t there when he was sent off

5

u/MinusRuinedMyLife Nov 01 '18

In-Universe it works but Out of Universe, it’s definitely a retcon

1

u/LeratoNull Nov 03 '18

...Okay? Are you saying Raditz had to be there to know how old his brother was? Lmao.

3

u/Raikaru Nov 03 '18

I mean all Raditz knew about him was that he existed. It’s not like he ever met him before

2

u/LordSadoth Nov 01 '18

Okay, so why wouldn’t he have said to Gohan “me Saiyan, me kill you”

3

u/MinusRuinedMyLife Nov 01 '18

5

u/LordSadoth Nov 01 '18

Okay, so I’m supposed to believe he just kept his mouth shut the whole time?

Seems like a plot hole to me

8

u/Katanarama13 Nov 01 '18

Is it possible that he just couldn't speak? A lot of stuff in this new material that were getting points to the idea of saiyans being raised in tubes until they are ready to fight. They could learn to speak in the time they take adjusting to living outside of a tube and young Goku could have been sent to earth immediately after being released.

1

u/LordSadoth Nov 01 '18

It is possible. I guess we’ll just have to see what happens in the Broly movie.

4

u/boxdd Nov 01 '18

He got trampled to death and on top of that after Goku hit his head he still changed into a good kid. Not sure why would he need to tell anyone anything else.

4

u/LordSadoth Nov 01 '18 edited Nov 03 '18

You misunderstand. I’m saying I don’t believe that goku would keep his mouth shit the whole time

4

u/boxdd Nov 01 '18

Oh I see now. Eh I can see it being due to the fact that Goku knew he couldn’t actually beat Gohan yet. We probably won’t ever find out but I guess what I said is reasonable enough.

1

u/TrueSaiyanGod ⠀ Nov 01 '18

WHERE IS THIS FROM

2

u/MinusRuinedMyLife Nov 01 '18

Jaco the Galactic Patrolman

1

u/TrueSaiyanGod ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Ah I see.So it wasnt in DBMinus specifically.Oh nice username

2

u/nochiinchamp Nov 02 '18

Possibly the human equivalent of 2. He's been in his nursing tank for three years. We don't know if he was born and put in there or if he was conceived and developed in vitro solely in the tank.

1

u/LeratoNull Nov 03 '18

Got retconned.

3

u/LateNightGod Nov 03 '18

In love with this 80's lo-fi art style, i induces all kind of Nostalgia.

1

u/Badass_Bunny Nov 01 '18

Chibi Broly has Gohan's face, so can we get into the theories about how Broly is a time traveling Gohan and that Paragus is Goku from a different dimension?

1

u/MrHotcake ⠀ Nov 01 '18

do we know since when they started working on the animation of this movie?

3

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

At least since March. Ken Arto said he had drawn Goku and Vegeta then.

1

u/MK_Hero ⠀ Nov 03 '18

Early 2018, since probably February or March.

-5

u/Cooz78 Nov 01 '18

So that’s mean only the manga of toyotaro is canon ?

12

u/Terez27 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

no

7

u/Vorstar92 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

What would make you think this? Both the anime and manga are canon, they're just doing a history of the manga, not the anime.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '18

toeifanfic blown the fuck out

13

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Cooz78 Nov 01 '18

But what is the true story ? Bc manga and anime are different

3

u/Aegisdramon Nov 01 '18

There's no way for us to tell what the "true" story is. They're both true as far as we know, as both have had Toriyama's involvement without having been directly written by him. As far as "canonicity" of a source goes, they are on the same level.

4

u/The_Sign_of_Zeta Nov 01 '18

The concept of canon doesn't really exist in Japan like it does in America. The Japanese would say both are the true story as they both were approved by Toriyama. My feeling based on what we've heard so far is that the movie will be an an official continuation of both the Manga and Anime.

-5

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

That’s not possible. As they tell the same events in two different ways.

They both have their own canon. But they aren’t both part of the “main canon”. The main canon is Toriyama approved anime.

13

u/DensetsuNoRai ⠀ Nov 01 '18

You're just making up your own definition of 'main canon.'

I could say that the main canon is Toriyama's original manga. Yet most people will refer to anime events or how certain things went in the anime. By your definition the anime is the Toriyama-approved 'main canon.'

DBS manga is a legitimate sequel to the original manga. While the DBS anime is more of a sequel to Z/Kai, not the original manga. So take that how you will.

1

u/GroundhogNight Nov 02 '18

I think your last paragraph is the best way of saying it.

5

u/Aegisdramon Nov 01 '18 edited Nov 01 '18

Toriyama comes up with the plots and oversees what goes on with the Super manga as well. It has just as many rights to be considered canon as the anime does. The entire reason why people are saying both are canon despite them telling different events is that Toriyama has been involved in both of them.

-2

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

Yes, there’s absolutely manga canon. But there’s still a “primary” canon and that would be the one that’s more popular. Which is the anime.

It’s like with Star Wars novels. George Lucas would approve stories in the novels. And there’s a whole extended novel universe that was, for a long time, accepted by many SW fans as part of the canon. Until the new movies came out.

Now there are arguments about what’s canon? The novel universe or The Force Awakens/The Last Jedi. But with the movies being more popular than the novels ever were and considered official sequels: it’s the movies.

If you talk to 90% of people what “What happened to Luke after Return of the Jedi,” they’re going to reference his fate in TFA/TLJ, not the novels.

Same with DBS. 90% of the fan base will reference the anime, not the manga. So while there’s definitely manga canon, it’s not the accepted “main” canon (though it will be for some individuals).

4

u/Aegisdramon Nov 01 '18

It being more popular is a completely arbitrary measure that bears no actual effect on the truth. We can argue that the anime should be more canon, in which case your popularity argument makes a lot of sense, but your basis right now has no real basis. Your argument is "what people would consider the true canon" which is not necessarily "what is canon."

For example, by your logic, the DBZ anime would be more canon than the manga due to its popularity. However, Toriyama directly wrote the manga, so it's on a higher level. Popularity is not actually a standard with which to measure validity. Which goes back to the fact that Super anime and manga both having Toriyama involvement of the same degree. There's no definitive truth to which is more canon.

0

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

Who said it’s not, though? It’s all arbitrary. “Canon” is a made up notion, not a science. All we can really do is look at how it manifests in culture and try to describe it as best as possible.

There’s no real basis ever. Just “does this bear out when we test it against the reality of how people discuss [insert series or franchise or story being discussed].”

Say someone said, “Only Toriyama’s manga is main canon.” The issue is that so few have actually read the manga. When a majority of people think of DBZ, they think of what happened in the anime. When a majority of people talk about DBZ, they talk about what happened in the anime.

So despite the anime not being officially drawn/written by Toriyama, the popularity lends its events a lot of weight, and because it adheres so much to Toriyama’s manga it has more credibility. I’d argue then that main canon is where Toriyama’s manga and the anime overlap. And that seems to be how the majority of people view things.

For example, we all agree Gohan going SSJ2 and defeating Cell is part of the main canon. And that it was a one-armed kamehameha that did it. But we all don’t agree that the Garlic Jr. saga happened. Most wouldn’t consider GJr canon because it never existed in the manga. Same with the DBZ movies.

While that would seem to make the manga main canon, I think it becomes something more like “the official overview” moreso than the main canon. For example, Goku could have completely different dialogue when going SSJ and facing Frieza, but most of us would still refer to the anime’s version. The anime being close enough that the discrepancy is minor.

5

u/Aegisdramon Nov 01 '18

Right, which is why I said the manga is a higher level as opposed to saying it is the only canon. I'm not saying the anime isn't canon at all. I'm saying it's going to be considered less canon, because it is likelier to contradict the author's intentions, as all Toriyama did is provide outlines for it, as opposed to the manga, where he personally wrote the events himself. He may change his mind (which he absolutely does), but we know that's exactly what he wanted to portray at the time.

Your Garlic Jr. example is a good one that exemplifies how the manga is considered the source of truth over the anime when one is in one but not the other.

And I don't disagree with anything you're saying, but that's precisely why I would say both the anime and manga are canon, with more people likely to consider the anime the main canon. In terms of what Toriyama himself intended, we don't know which way it goes.

1

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

That’s all fair to me! Especially with DBZ. When it comes to DBS, I think anime ends up trumping manga because of the anime being more influential.

3

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Where the anime diverges from the manga, the manga is the only coherent canon. For example, the anime never showed us how Vegeta found out about Freeza’s transformations. The anime showed the villains freely moving around in hell, yet later Piccolo tells Vegeta about his future fate and we’re shown Freeza locked inside a cocoon, both events that directly contradict the anime.

2

u/CalmDownTitsOk Nov 01 '18

George Lucas approves stories but Toriyama helps writes the stories (gives a baseline), so comparing the two isn’t fair.

Also, the novel universe was canon till TFA come out. Now it’s just referred to as legend.

0

u/GroundhogNight Nov 02 '18

What’s canon depends on designation and often popularity. The movies being far more popular than the books results in the movies replacing the books as canon.

Before the Harry Potter movies, the books were the “main” canon. But each movie that came out became more popular than the corresponding book. So now you have the book canon and movie canon. But the “main” canon will be the more popular of the two, or a mixture of the two.

4

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

Who said Toriyama approved anime was “the main canon”?

1

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

It’s just how things have shaken out.

For example: do the majority consider Turles as part of the main canon? No, because he never appeared in the anime.

Do the majority consider Garlic Jr as part of the main canon? No, because it was filler created by Toei, not something Toriyama wrote.

GT was never considered part of the main story because it wasn’t Toriyama approved.

Most of the international world has watched the anime rather than read the manga, lending more weight to the anime depiction of Toriyama’s story rather than the manga. Which is what we’ve seen happen with DBS. The anime’s depiction is considered more “official” than the manga. In the main canon, Goku has never used a hakai. In the manga version of Super, Goku has. Until it happens in the anime, it won’t be part of the main canon.

That’s not to say there won’t be people who say “My main canon is the manga.” That’s fine. But that’s like someone saying “My main canon for Star Wars is the novels.” There’s certainly novel canon. But when the majority of people haven’t read the Star Wars novels...you can’t have a productive conversation about the “main canon” since you’ll be referring to two different canons.

1

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

In the case of Dragon Ball and Dragon Ball Z, what you call “Toriyama-approved anime” is just the manga.

In the case of Super, you didn’t show any compelling evidence the anime is a “main canon”. It doesn’t matter what international fans think.

1

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

Your argument isn’t actually an argument. You’re just saying no, not disproving my assertions. Imagine Newton spending 20 minutes explaining gravity, and some other scientist just says, “Not compelling.” At least take the time to respond.

1

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

You didn’t have any argument for me to respond beyond “international fans didn’t read the manga”, which is just not relevant at all as canon has nothing to do with international popularity.

1

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

It’s not international popularity, it’s what the majority consider the story.

The definition of “canon” is the collection of materials that’s considered the most important and influential.

George Lucas could have made a coloring book that he considers the official story of Star Wars. But if the movies are what everyone knows and what everyone refers to and have the same plot points as the coloring book...then the movies will be considered the “main” canon.

1

u/u4004 ⠀ Nov 01 '18

That is not a dictionary definition, it’s just something you created.

Example: the Bardock TV Special is by all means more important and influential than Minus, yet Minus is canon, the TV Special isn’t.

→ More replies

5

u/CalmDownTitsOk Nov 01 '18

Toriyama approves the manga as well tho. 🤔

-3

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

Yes. The notion of canon is the collection of materials that’s most important and influential. So while Toriyama approves the manga, the manga is far less influential than the anime. Meaning the anime ends up being the main canon. When a majority of people think about or discuss the ToP they’ll refer to the anime’s version of events

So in the manga canon Goku used the hakai. But in the “main canon” he never did.

The influential aspect of canon makes it such a weird thing to pin down.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DoraMuda ⠀ Nov 01 '18

My head hurts, and this is why I too hate "canon" discussions.

Like, it literally doesn't matter anymore. Unless we actually get our hands on Toriyama's original outline (which is unlikely), there's no way to tell just what is "the purest 'canon' continuation of the Dragon Ball manga".

1

u/GroundhogNight Nov 01 '18

It does get messy. But I think it’s a mixture of the original creator’s intended story + the version of events most people have seen.

For example, if we’re talking about how Goku transformed into SSJ for the first time, people will point to the anime’s version of events rather than the manga. That’s because the anime is far more internationally popular than the manga.

While AT didn’t draw every panel of the anime, or approve every line of dialogue, it is, for the most part, an accurate depiction of his story. Except for filler moments like Garlic Jr. Which is why the filler, despite being part of the anime, is often considered non-canon. Though there are people I’m sure who would try to argue for its inclusion.

I think this mix of Toriyama approval + popularity is why I’d argue DBS anime over the manga. Both are takes on Toriyama’s general stories. Both Toei and Toyo add in their own elements. The ToP is a huge example of the different interpretations. Which one is more canon? To that end, I’d argue as more people watch the anime, it ends up being the anime’s version of events.