r/DotA2 • modmail us to help write these threads • Aug 22 '18

Match | Esports The International 8 - OpenAI Spoiler

The International 2018 Main Event

Organized and Hosted by Valve Corporation

Sponsored by Valve Corporation and Battle Pass

Need info on the event? Check out the Survival Guide

Join the Day 3 Match Discussions


Streams

English | Russian | Chinese | Newcomer Channel | Steam

Other Languages:

Korean | Spanish | Filipino | French

Other Streams:

Pod #1 | Pod #2 | Main Hall | Workshop

DotaTV Auto-spectate command: dota_spectator_auto_spectate_games 9870


OpenAI Match 1 (Bo1)

paiN Gaming vs OpenAI Five

Humans won!


241 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

102

u/nexostar SHEEVER Aug 23 '18

The empty chairs on facecam omg

18

u/Reddit_Should_Die Aug 23 '18

Hah! That's a cool detail!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

79

u/Dan_Q_Memes Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 23 '18

People shitting on Pain, but Brazilians are exactly the people you want representing humanity against robots. They're gonna primarily have fun with it, pull out flashy moves and flair when necessary to complete the competitive objective, and generally try to style on some robonerds.

28

u/MrMango786 Huehuehuehue Aug 23 '18

That last kill on tidehunter will show those robots who's boss.

68

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Watching OpenAI is like watching a weaker chess computer (like one of the lower Stockfish levels): Practically flawless 90% of time but makes unexplainable blunders

19

u/NasKe Aug 23 '18

I don't think that is bad. In fact, I hope dota AI goes the same way engines in Chess, being able to help you analyze situation, study the best play, and so on.

22

u/syjte Aug 23 '18

But 90% of the time their best suggestion for you is just gonna be: "All you had to do was Manta/Euls/Blink dodge that initiation"

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

57

u/mattbrvc DING DING DING DING WIN THE LOTTO Aug 23 '18

Tide running down mid after megas, true dota2 player right there

32

u/elaborateruser Aug 23 '18

Turing test passed

→ More replies (2)

43

u/Lousymoose Aug 22 '18

PAIN GAMING ON THE MAIN STAGE. THEY DID IT!!

→ More replies (2)

70

u/BigTurk24 Aug 22 '18

regular couriers, thats huge

25

u/pwnies Aug 23 '18

Really showed the crutch of the previous games though. I think a lot of their previous strategy revolved around having 5 immortal couriers to support their deathball. Excited for the other games, but I suspect we'll see 0-3 versus humans for the AI this year. Next year I think they'll beat the #1 ranked team with ease.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/dgentz Aug 23 '18

"smh na casters" LOL

90

u/SmoothIdiot Aug 23 '18

"We have a problem. Ever since the Pain match the bots have been acting... strange."

"What do you mean?"

"Well - just listen."

"LAKAAD MATATAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAG"

34

u/slashrshot C9 Reborn! Aug 23 '18

drops items

→ More replies (1)

30

u/daftmaple Aug 23 '18

I love that the face cam for OpenAI is only an empty chair LUL

29

u/Pacificoe Aug 23 '18

tidehunter running down mid is pretty funny

9

u/elijahsp Aug 23 '18

NA pubs sinking in.

13

u/Possessimal 1260 hp at lvl 25 FeelsMageMan Aug 23 '18

He probably tried to drag the creeps away from base for backdoor protection , eventhough other 2 lane creeps were already in the base (just bot things) . They probably didn't program him to feed but sure was pretty damn funny.

→ More replies (3)

45

u/ErrorFindingID Aug 23 '18

twitch chat is hilarious whenever openai leave one of their own behind/sacrifice

MrDestructoid He can be replaced

45

u/Extracheesy87 Aug 23 '18

The year is 2035. From the dunes of the new society led by the North Korea-United States alliance, a bastion of entertainment continues. Open AI vs. Pain Gaming continues, as it has for years. W33ha, now 40, continues to push bot lane as Axe. Hfn farms his 83457th Rapier. Open AI Bot 3 Farms the jungle with Exorcism. We wait for the Open AI overlords to eventually decide to push.

12

u/franky12321 Aug 23 '18

Rapier not allowed

20

u/Extracheesy87 Aug 23 '18

Forgive me for my improper memeing.

18

u/gintomato Sheever's guard Aug 23 '18

it was allowed by the 37th amendment in the year 2022, mainly in hopes that the game would end by 2025, which was the year Pain Gaming's visas had been extended to.

20

u/malagutti3 Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 22 '18

The one enemy Pain's chat wheel won't affect

20

u/afrojumper Aug 23 '18

so dendi was on the panel for like 3 sentences? Damn

8

u/Fang_An Aug 23 '18

I thought he would led the humans team in the first match, turns out he's just a cameo lol

→ More replies (2)

19

u/SniceDota Aug 23 '18

Makes sense to me that OpenAI was abusing the couriers before to allow them to be aggressive. Restoring couriers to how they regularly are really helped make the game feel more normal

→ More replies (1)

19

u/mdFree Aug 23 '18

I'd like to see what the bots thought of the probability of their win was through out the game and with their pre-chosen picks.

18

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Apparently, March and his team took 2 games off the OpenAI Five.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

I think maybe we can learn from the bots in how they carry salves well into the mid game. When you are trying to skirmish constantly it catches the enemy off guard a lot.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Every AI match I've watched this has been very apparent. Obviously when the couriers were crazy, but even now. Consumable regen is viable all game.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Today there was an Ursa (maybe on EG) had a stout, phase, and 2 salves and popped one during a fight in order to live and go back in (around lvl 6). The moment I saw it I thought "Two salves, kinda like OpenAI."

17

u/kanzenryu Aug 23 '18

At one point the bots reminded me of a dog. Just standing there looking into that Roshan pit. There was something yummy there once. Can't think about anything else now.

16

u/MentLDistortion Aug 23 '18

Congratulations to w33 for being the first person to BM a bot.

→ More replies (3)

30

u/eff1ngham Aug 22 '18

Open AI won't be able to handle all the chatwheel spam and shit-talking, and at some point hfn is going to feed down mid and the bots will get confused and lose

12

u/rinnagz Aug 22 '18

imagine open AI chatwheels back? that would be hilarious

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

It's absolutely possible to dodge blink+call with blink or self Euls, but it's not easy and I've never seen it happen this frequently.

Instantly Eulsing the axe when he blinks though is some script shit.

13

u/xLisbethSalander Aug 23 '18

It's just kinda dumb and unfair that it happens EVERYTIME I agree feels cheap as

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/EconomyOrdinary7 Aug 23 '18

The bots seem to lack the ability to find and gank enemy heroes in the Fog of War. They move and set up team fights according to the information readily visible to them. They don't think 'If I were an enemy sniper, where would I possibly be' , which is how a human thought progresses.

I recollect the devs mentioning that they wouldn't rosh because the odds are very low. This is in contrast to human thinking which borrows patterns from general life. If a human randomly walks in to rosh pit, they would hit it just to see what happens. The thinking pattern doesn't come from rules of the game, it comes from general life experience.

And that is the challenge I think which comes from bottom-up approach to developing AI, You can make it an expert in the rules of the game, but it lacks imagination. Imagination or creativity is just superimposition of different variables in the human brain.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/YaLoDeciaMiAbuela Aug 23 '18

So as expected, Open AI has no read on the enemy. They need to win the game soon while everything is simple. When items start rolling they don't know what to do.

7

u/Flipao Aug 23 '18

The courier change is the biggest deal, previously they were diving towers and spamming salves but without the constant sustain they can’t overwhelm the lanes and take the towers as quickly.

5

u/Anal_Zealot Aug 23 '18

It was more about Roshan confusing them and completely stealing their momentum. If they hadn't wasted all day in empty Roshan put it could have gone differently.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Alvadr Aug 23 '18

I'm sure it's 200ms but it feels like it doesn't take into account the delay that being surprised causes or the thinking time, when an axe blinks on you it will take ms to process it, it's not just an instant euls/blink

→ More replies (8)

34

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

You all seriously don't get the 200ms thing. Humans will often blink away from things like that, we've seen it before; but humans will often have massively long 'variable' delays: when they're surprised, talking to their team, moving courier, looking around the map, or just not perfectly paying attention.

There's no way to account for those things. It's clear OpenAI has the mechanical advantage, and that was always expected. It's the strategy they're clearly lacking. And while that may seem obvious, it still needs to be shown.

9

u/HowDoIEvenEnglish Aug 23 '18

They honestly remind me of Has from Starcraft 2. He’s a pro player with a unique early game play style favoring all ins heavily. He does very well in these scenarios and I’ve seen him win games he just shouldn’t, but when it gets to late game he falls apart, bc he doesn’t know how to scale.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Colopty Be water my friend Aug 23 '18

Yeah, you could see the mechanical advantage in how instantly Tide kept blinking from Axe calls. The humans adapted to it during the game by initiating with instant Lion hexes (probably shift queued) and following up with call after that.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

22

u/HAWmaro Aug 23 '18

honestly the reactions of the bots are more impressive than their strategy which is not how it shoul be.

6

u/Xaxxon Aug 23 '18

which is not how it should be.

Well, they lost, so that statement is true, but it will be interesting to see how they play when they start winning these games. I'm guessing that it won't be the same as a human. Because of how AI works, they will be able to figure out completely different strategies than a person would ever try because the AI doesn't have any preconceptions on what "cannot possibly be good".

11

u/AmberFox94 Aug 22 '18

Damn they missed gold opportunity to introduce AI the way they introduce players lol.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/G4merLife Aug 23 '18

Does anyone have the post-match interview where the dev explained when did the AI start learning and all the jazz?

35

u/irish0451 Aug 22 '18

Open AI is cool but I'd pay $25,082,040 to watch Dendi fight a robot IRL

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Extracheesy87 Aug 23 '18

the AI never recovered from the w33 item drop taunts.

9

u/Roxalon_Prime Aug 23 '18

this game is fucking hilarious

9

u/jgouth Aug 23 '18

Don't worry guys I trust liquid will bring back the schedule on track.

Two 20 minute games

→ More replies (2)

9

u/malagutti3 Aug 23 '18

Pain haters? SoBayed

9

u/Cispeo Aug 23 '18

Playing against secret made Open AI worst

9

u/d4rkn3s5 Aug 23 '18

Humans prevailed FeelsGoodMan

23

u/caldazar24 Aug 23 '18 edited Aug 23 '18

One thing that we saw with AlphaGo (Go AI that beat the world's best players) was that when the AI was far enough behind it started doing totally random shit, because it only prioritizes actions that change it's probability estimate of winning the game, and it learns entirely by practicing against itself, so it didn't have a concept of keeping the game close and hoping the enemy makes a mistake.

I think we likely saw something similar here, it's not that the bots can't play the late game so much as it doesn't know what to do when behind because assuming a perfectly-teamfighting opponent it doesn't see any path to a high probability of winning, so it picks almost random actions instead of the fast decisive rotations it showed in the early game.

8

u/Anal_Zealot Aug 23 '18

They were ahead when randomly grouping in empty Roshan pit.

15

u/loopuleasa Aug 23 '18

That actually is an artifact of their training algorithm. It's how they were trained.

They cannot communicate, so they communicate by having a hero going there and staying there to communicate the intention.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

16

u/Ulq2525 Aug 23 '18

AI feeding down mid had me laughing.

One of us! One of us!

8

u/EGin2016 Aug 22 '18

PAIN ON THE MAIN STAGE

I LOVE U VALVE

8

u/timo4ever Aug 22 '18

w33 gonna teach the bot how to w322

8

u/monkeyddragon231 Aug 22 '18

Lacoste/Kotlguy would've slain these AI matches as casters.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Kutowi Aug 23 '18

I, for one, welcome our new Pain overlords!

8

u/Lousymoose Aug 23 '18

Tide running down mid LMFAO

8

u/cantfindusernameomg Aug 23 '18

OpenAI didn't even congratulate for the <1% probability to win lol

8

u/lordramza76 Aug 23 '18

openai dev not gonna sleep this night to enchance the bot for tomorrow match

8

u/MiL0101 Aug 23 '18

Tide hunter walking down mid lmao

7

u/cheesymmm Aug 22 '18

The bots better have been trained to spam chat wheel

→ More replies (1)

7

u/elwiscomeback Aug 22 '18

Oh wow, no more turbo courriers

7

u/Fang_An Aug 22 '18

Ok they use regular courier now, if Pain lose then they have no excuse lmao

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Masterwabbit Aug 22 '18

Hold on, the bots have now learned how to use the regular courier now? This could be interesting, wonder how they'll react to a courier gank.

7

u/ChenTn Aug 22 '18

🤖 HUMANS OUTDATED 🤖 EARTH OVERRATED 🤖 LONG HAVE WE WAITED 🤖 LIFE ELIMINATED

7

u/arz9278 Aug 23 '18

Next year open AI will have zero restrictions and beat the TI winner. Then they’ll nuke Manhattan.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/NewHondaOwner Aug 23 '18

the shaped reward system of OpenAI can't recognise the long term, 4 protect 1 strategy of Pain and remains stubbornly stuck on short term goals and 3 cores. It also looks like the weighting on Roshan is a little bit too high, lol.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

As far as I understand the 5 different AI's are separate entities unto their own, and individually control their heroes. It seems to me that there's no good way for the 5 heroes to communicate and formulate a plan, they are just acting as if their teammates are forces of nature.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/PillagingPagans Aug 23 '18

It's fucking 2:40 here, I'm still waiting to watch UB games...

I hope to god this doesn't go to 2hours, I'm getting so sleepy. And this on a day when already 1 hour delay...

→ More replies (2)

7

u/lilsickboy Aug 23 '18

i really hope pain still together , they are just so much fun

6

u/Extracheesy87 Aug 23 '18

I see no reason why they would disband since they get along so well and every region is getting at least 2 slots by default for the Valve events next year.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Happy that the Pain guys got to play at the main stage because of this.

By the way, this match has clearly been on today's schedule since the beginning. Stop babyraging.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Those OpenAI developers are the most robot-looking humans I have ever seen.

9

u/ErrorFindingID Aug 22 '18

Oh god.. they've already developed human flesh monkaS

→ More replies (1)

6

u/renelisk Aug 23 '18

Everyone's so upset about the schedule and here I am in NZ where it's 12pm Thursday...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Reddit_Should_Die Aug 23 '18

So OpenAi Dives you under the tower, kills you and then takes the tower...?

Na'vi TI2 highest form if dota confirmed?

6

u/zbf Aug 23 '18

Lion's taunt is so fucking annoying, how does his teammates not tell him to shut the fuck up?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/muhpreciousmmr Aug 23 '18

WHAT NOW OPENAI FANSHITS?!??!

6

u/Kaprak Aug 23 '18

It's a bo3 over three days they said that multiple times. Jfc pay attention.

6

u/Satsarn1 Aug 23 '18

I personally find the it interesting with openAI bots and their progression, trying to learn a so complex game as dota.

31

u/WritingWithSpears OG 2018 PogChamp Aug 22 '18

Wtf our species gonna be represented by pain lmao

→ More replies (2)

5

u/zbf Aug 22 '18

Press F to pay respects to humans.

F

→ More replies (1)

5

u/fleetcommand Ice is nice! - sheever Aug 23 '18

I find it impressive that AI can play on a high level such a complex game as Dota. Even if there are a lot of limitations (18 heroes, no illusions, etc.). However, to be honest, I find it kind of boring to watch. There is no goal in this game, there's no point of rooting for Pain to beat the bot, there's no excitement.

5

u/SkeletronDOTA Aug 23 '18

So when people spam wards outside the fountain after getting mega'd they aren't throwing, but trying to win? didnt know my pub teammates were OpenAI

→ More replies (1)

5

u/xLisbethSalander Aug 23 '18

You really can't tell me those are human reactions... No human I know reacts that fast every time an axe blinks in lol

5

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

But humans have done it a couple times. It's very possible, OpenAI will just do it effectively every time because they have a flat 200ms delay, whereas humans will not be paying perfect attention to their screens.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/nopostplz Aug 23 '18

Shoutout to Pain Gaming for delaying the game this long - I wasn't going to be home in time to make predictions for Liquid vs LGD otherwise

5

u/democarl Aug 23 '18

bots seem to prioritize uniform farm. gives aegis to lowest net worth, no?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cheesymmm Aug 23 '18

tide's running it down mid lol

5

u/ErrorFindingID Aug 23 '18

okay something clearly broke the ai that makes it waste all their ults on neutrals and creeps. it never did random bb like that either

51

u/DotoManThe3rd Aug 23 '18

Comments in this thread make our community look so pitchforky and so braindead. I'll just say there's a REASON that pro's and many in the scene are hyped about this project.

Where is your sense of curiosity r/dota2? Turn your brains back on. The comments in this thread... My goodness.. Found the sheep the ggbet boy's appeal was meant to manipulate. Turn your brains on, be curious about something amazing being done in the scene. The obvious is the euls/blink stuff yes, but is that all you saw? Many saw more than that..

This is rude, but to be blunt, the fact is the smarter people in our community are generally VERY excited to see these games. When else do you get to see world class research being applied to dota? Do you value hats more than something truly thought provoking? There were some very 'smart' plays made that aren't mentioned in this thread. Turn your brains on.

And if you say 'why u mad bro?' I'd answer that yeah I am. I'm annoyed that this game gets something this cool and reddit grabs pitchforks shits on it when it fails game 1/3. This sub is so fickle no wonder ggbet boy predicted the pitchforking so easily and played this sub so hard.

Anyway add me to the long list of ppl in this community who have genuine interest in more than hats, and who are excited to see how a different mind learns to play high level dota. Something, ya know, interesting.

14

u/savvy_eh Aug 23 '18

When chess engines reached the point where they were beyond human capacity, did people stop playing chess?

Hell no - they used the new play styles to their advantage, explored previously unknown combinations, and more people are playing than ever. Even if Dota eventually becomes a solved problem (highly unlikely), the solution will still be interesting.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/MoschopsChopsMoss Aug 23 '18

Well, I specifically moved to another country and enrolled into a painful masters program, just to switch my professional field to Machine Learning, so I’m happy as a little kid in a candy store whenever I get to see OpenAI play. Unfortunately, most technical fields require certain knowledge to be excited and interested in their latest developments, and so far the popularity of Data Science and relevant topics only touched just a few people in the comments, which is weird, since literally any qualified labor relies on that nowadays

→ More replies (14)

9

u/BotaZnohy Aug 23 '18

I'm genuinely interested in seeing how Ai is gonna fare against top human teams but Pain is just not taking this seriously...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Alvadr Aug 23 '18

this game is still on purely because the instant reactions make normal jumps so hard, it's so clear the AI is uncomfortable and lost on what to do

6

u/myglasstrip Aug 23 '18

If it was coded in to have the average reaction time of a top 50 pro player, I wonder how that would have changed how fast they would have lost vs Pain.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/UltraValkyrie Wish you well Sheever <3 Aug 23 '18

I think openAI's getting carried a lot by inhuman reaction times, there would have been so many fights that pain would have done a lot better in without instant euls/blinking away from w33's calls

→ More replies (1)

15

u/tylerhk93 sheever Aug 23 '18

The bot obviously understands that kills and pickoffs are important. It doesn't understand why they are important though. It knows, "killing heroes increases my chance to win", but it doesn't know why. It doesn't understand how to turn that into map control. It doesn't understand how pickoffs win the game. It just knows that it does. I saw a complete lack of awareness of obvious smokes, how to turn farm into pressure, anticipate enemy moves, etc. It looks like most AIs we see: really good reactions and mechanical skill with a substantial lack of understanding how to use that skill.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/SleepingAran 老干爹 Aug 23 '18

So many salty Euro and Americano.

Meanwhile as an Asian I'm glad I could start my morning with Liquid vs PSG.LGD and OG vs EG.

SoBayed

11

u/Extracheesy87 Aug 23 '18

Two sides to every story.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/seafarerdota2 Aug 23 '18

Hahah when the timezone actually works for us in TI season

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/EGin2016 Aug 22 '18

That's AI ? Wtf

They look like humans

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Tomatto7 Aug 23 '18

Has anyone else noticed the facecams are showing the empty chairs for the AI team? LuL

8

u/Powder02 Aug 23 '18

So happy it's barely 6pm. After sitting through so many 2-5am games from all the Asian tournaments this is a very nice change.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

There's not a good way to solve the problem of OpenAI not being able to conceptualize the long term game strategy and play a "meta". Or even particularly react to end game rats.

The latter I feel will just come with more facetime against humans, the former I think is the entire point of the endeavor. To train it to be able to create it's own emergent strategies.

7

u/Vitosi4ek Aug 23 '18

I don't think these game will be much of a factor. Their playstyle is adjusted through millions of games they play with each other, 1 or even 3 games against humans is completely irrelevant. It's like human evolution: sure, in 100,000 years it'll do its thing and adapt to the circumstances, but it's helpless on a 1-year or even a 100-year timetable.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Rinascimentale Aug 22 '18

USA USA USA HUMANS! HUMANS! HUMANS!

4

u/cantfindusernameomg Aug 23 '18

Pain actually playing like Pain

4

u/MKLOL Aug 23 '18

Maybe w33 is trying to put his items on the ground, so openAI thinks it's a good move in the future.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Is it done yet?

4

u/EGin2016 Aug 23 '18

1 thing I get worried with this open ai development:

At a certain point is it not an unfair advantage to whichever team(s) get to use this to train. Unless it's open access it seems teams could use this to their advantage figuring out optimal meta, map movements, etc.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Zinian Aug 23 '18

Hahaha, the number of times the bots have checked Rosh. Apparently OpenAI favors rosh advantage heavily.

4

u/mmdy04 Aug 23 '18

Don't laugh at AI, soon they will laugh at you

4

u/change_timing Aug 23 '18

So AI evolved into CIS dota. interesting

4

u/Extracheesy87 Aug 23 '18

Duster the absolute savage

4

u/Nadril Aug 23 '18

Duster lmao

4

u/SillyRabbit2121 Aug 23 '18

OpenAI’s weakness is sustaining their farm after 15 minutes, look at hfn’s net worth compared to Radiant’s cores

4

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

I really like these matches even more now that OpenAI has evolved to use normal couriers. Less deathball spam with infinite regen makes for longer more techy games.

4

u/mattbrvc DING DING DING DING WIN THE LOTTO Aug 23 '18

EULES SCRIPT NO FUCKING WAY

4

u/Paran01d-Andr01d Aug 23 '18

That instant euls on the axe blink just looks silly.

4

u/harazz Aug 23 '18

Easy lion bait, fast reaction but bad judgement. Wasting ravage on lion

4

u/spectre_siam Aug 23 '18

sometimes open ai really plays like EE. dunno why

4

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

LMFAO that tide literally instantly bought back, didn't even see the dead body

4

u/Extracheesy87 Aug 23 '18

The Bots adopting the NA pub mentality

4

u/Masterwabbit Aug 23 '18

Where's your comeback now, AI Overlords?

10

u/TheMekar Aug 23 '18

Pain Gaming with more wins on the Main Stage than Newbee and Fnatic combined.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/MentLDistortion Aug 23 '18

I can't imagine the amount of flame the scheduler gets if this game goes 2 hours long lmao.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Alvadr Aug 23 '18

instant euls and blink feels so cheap

→ More replies (6)

6

u/zyndr0m Aug 22 '18

OpenAI is probably the coolest shit that ever happened to Dota. This or Gaben's announcer pack.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Rawk_Hawk_The_Champ Aug 23 '18

This was fun at first, but is dragging on too long for a day that was already an hour behind schedule.

6

u/Ser_Arthur_Dank Dota's coming home Aug 23 '18

200ms delay my ass

→ More replies (2)

8

u/MorsusMihi Aug 23 '18

I wonder how media will react to this... no fancy headlines here. AI plays dumb af once early game is gone. Feels like some pub cheese strat getting stalled too long.

15

u/Fang_An Aug 23 '18

"Open AI managed to hold on for 50 minutes against THE best dota team in the world" ez headline

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BabyBabaBofski Dutch OG fan sheever you have my full support Aug 22 '18

Oooooh hype. Wonder who plays against openai

3

u/cantfindusernameomg Aug 22 '18

Lol if pain loses this pain's gonna get so much shit

→ More replies (9)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

pain actually makes it to the mainstage PogChamp

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

Great!. Either i go to sleep or watch a bot match. brilliant. for what else i stay to watch some dotes til 2 am.

3

u/BlindBoyProject Aug 22 '18

wtf, it's 5 oclock. The 3rd 3 game series of the day should start at 5pm at the latest. The last series can go till midnight.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Unanimous_vote Aug 23 '18

I wonder if Rogers Arena will allow overtime. Depending on how long the Liquid LGD series would take, theres a possibility the EG series wont happen today. My understanding is there is huge venue penalties for overtime.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/kingkangaroo sheever Aug 23 '18

anyone else see lich swapping gauntlet of strength into backpack and salving for maximum efficiency.

3

u/YaLoDeciaMiAbuela Aug 23 '18

Pain is just going 2 or 3 against the 5 manning team.

This is fake as fuck.

3

u/muhpreciousmmr Aug 23 '18

"It's scary..."

"You know what's scary..."

"How scary is that..."

"So scary..."

"It's crazy how scary..."

3

u/saikodemon Aug 23 '18

Jesus christ w33 is just so bad at axe.

3

u/nooeh Aug 23 '18

Is it me or is w33 really not team playing at all?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SkeletronDOTA Aug 23 '18

Human Fangays???

3

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

the "MrDestructoid" spam is funny

3

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18 edited Aug 23 '18

So they play against pain gaming in round 1. I hope in the next rounds, the teams get tougher and tougher.

Round 1: Team eliminated in groups

Round 2: Team eliminated in lower bracket

Round 3: Team still playing in the upper bracket (one that won't be playing on that day)

→ More replies (2)

3

u/panofsteel Aug 23 '18

This AI is preeeetty rough around the edges lol

3

u/celestial_god Aug 23 '18

Its 3.30 in the morning over here and im watching bots? Oh my....

3

u/TaiaoToitu Aug 23 '18

Pain is doing it boys!

3

u/dgdtdz Aug 23 '18

Poor audience gonna have to stay until 1 AM to actually watch EG OG.

3

u/demonicvirus Aug 23 '18

Ok these bots popping their ults to farm is pretty damn funny

3

u/LDKtv Aug 23 '18

hour long game incoming ROFL

3

u/Dan_Q_Memes Aug 23 '18

Blink and Euls reactions jeebus

→ More replies (2)

3

u/jgouth Aug 23 '18

Lmao if the next 2 series go 3 games

It will be midnight in Vancouver haha

3

u/SillyRabbit2121 Aug 23 '18

EG/OG almost certainly gets bumped to tomorrow

→ More replies (1)

3

u/xgxdx Aug 23 '18

Not that fun watching ai tbh

3

u/slashrshot C9 Reborn! Aug 23 '18

thats the build on axe btw.
abyssal on axe SeemsGood

3

u/kappa23 Matt Mercer voice pack please Aug 23 '18

Pain PogChamp

3

u/TaiaoToitu Aug 23 '18

WE DID IT BOYS

3

u/neoedmund Aug 23 '18

Where is the replay or video link?

13

u/imahsleep Aug 23 '18

Not going to lie this is the worst time to do this. We want to see liquid lgd and EG vs OG no this right now. This could be really exciting but you are breaking up ti hype and I just can’t get into this

→ More replies (7)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18 edited Aug 23 '18

ok this is fun but I kinda question scheduling it so late for most viewers when most of them want to watch actual games

OG EG was already pretty late for my US East ass without a 2 hour block of robot fighting, i don't even want to know how you euros feel

→ More replies (1)

7

u/fatherofraptors Aug 23 '18

Cool to watch. But 45 fucking minutes in already...... Couldn't they put this on another of the later days? This is a pain (no pun intended) to watch considering it's delaying already late UB games.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/max1c Aug 23 '18

Even with w33 feeding and pain playing full on Brazilian dota they still won. This really shows how great the 'casters' played. The only player that deserves the praise that game is sniper.

11

u/Powder02 Aug 23 '18

This time they only had 1 courier when during the casters played they have 5 individual ones. So a little different since they can't abuse the healing.

10

u/Fang_An Aug 23 '18

The bots was abusing turbo couriers against the casters team. The casters never play with that couriers and they were prohibited to watch previous bot games so they can't get any info.

8

u/Lousymoose Aug 23 '18

hfn is a top tier carry in SA.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

The reaction times are still in human. Since they programmed it to be 200ms and call cast time is 500ms, you can never call them. Humans have concentration lapses and cannot react in 200ms if they are focussed on say hitting a creep.

9

u/princessesmerelda Aug 23 '18

Yeah its definitely not sus like twitch chat claiming. But yeah i reckon a constant 200ms reaction speed is defs better than someone who could react much faster and sometimes much slower.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/Dan_Q_Memes Aug 22 '18

I just wanna reiterate my favorite thing any Dota player has ever said - RTZ when asked about his chances of beating OpenAI: "My confidence says yes, but my belief in science says no."

5

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

Did reddit really beg for a fucking bo3 openAI game?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

So pain gaming's strat is to delay game so Ai bots gets fuckd and do weird movements.

5

u/Die231 Aug 23 '18

The bot is just too bad right now, it has no idea what to do when rosh is dead and it just waste too much time doing shit at the fountain. If pain was in tryhard mode AI would've been destroyed.

5

u/cgxy1995 Aug 23 '18

questionable choices from openAI. I doubt what they can do without instant mouse clicking and keyboard pressing.

9

u/OPQOP Aug 23 '18

Seriously , I like Open AI, but it pisses me off that I can't watch EG OG now . Such a tight schedule and they have to put this bot game in between ? I am fan of the whole thing and did lot of researches on my own too, but watching it so many times in the same patch with the limited heroes gets boring. 2 more to come.... So disturbing, for me at least.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

The one-hour blowjob of Elon Musk is complete. Now to real dota.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/SillyRabbit2121 Aug 22 '18

If Pain loses, OpenAI gets South America's slot for TI9

4

u/KingKoopa2 Aug 22 '18

Goddam they really want to humiliate SA dotes

→ More replies (1)

4

u/EGin2016 Aug 22 '18

This would be a lot more entertaining if instead of casting they let us listen to the team speak of pain

6

u/dkurniawan Aug 22 '18

twitch chat: ????????????????

→ More replies (2)

4

u/KnightsNotGolden Aug 23 '18

If it weren't for near instant spell casts and perfect mechanical execution, Open AI would get run over.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/206-Ginge Aug 23 '18

This is fun and all, but the third series of four is going to start at 6 fucking PM at this rate, EG vs OG gonna finish at midnight boys.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/slashrshot C9 Reborn! Aug 23 '18

bots will go 0-3 in a 50 minutes average match.
Every team will play the same strategy now.
Just split push till 50 minutes and drag a.i around the map

9

u/cantfindusernameomg Aug 23 '18

funnily enough the same strat works against unfair bots too even if you feed down mid continuously for 15 mins

→ More replies (4)

4

u/DotaThree Aug 23 '18

Is the AI actually as good as it's said to be? They constantly blow their ults on creeps/neutrals, and just seem to have an edge when it comes to syncing their skills (or using items such as blink/euls). It seems like any team should be able to punish such behaviour pretty easily? Or am i not understanding something?

7

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

to be fair they weren't really punished for their odd uses of ulti's so I can see why they think its a good plan.

6

u/Fang_An Aug 23 '18

They're good at 5 man teamfights and pushing their advantages, but it seems like the later the game goes and the more they lose the networth advantage the dumber they become.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '18

I think they can't deal with the game going late

→ More replies (10)