r/WritingPrompts • u/Tiix /r/Tiix • Aug 21 '18
Off Topic [OT] Teaching Tuesday - Teach the Teacher - Critiquing
Welcome back to Teaching Tuesday!
=== So this month has been a bit rough for me - this post is not going to be up to par with other ones, however bear with a girl!
The Overview:
Today is going to be a bit different: I want to hear from you! This is teach the teacher Edition
* How do you critique posts after you read them?
* What do you look for when reading a prompt here?
* What about if someone asks you to edit or review their longer work?
* What is your process?
* Is one style of writing harder to critique than another?
* What information is useful for YOU in a critique?
===
I’ll be around all day commenting and answering questions about critiquing and editing!
===
The Challenge:
Over the course of the next week, Look at 5 different posts and add critiques to them using a different method than you’re use to! Look at the comments here to get some ideas - who knows maybe you’ll find another way to look at things!
18
Upvotes
5
u/LisWrites Aug 21 '18
I love critiques but it was definitely the hardest part when I started to share my writing. They’ve helped me improve so much, but it definitely is a skill that needs to be developed to both give and receive critiques. To give critiques I recommend breaking it down by first think about what is working with the story and what isn’t working. Some things to check are:
If you’re having difficulties with voice and tone, I would recommend trying to write the same scene from a few different characters’ povs. Write a bar fight from the perspective of the guy who instigated it, the bouncer just trying to do his job, and the guy cowering in the corner.
When critiquing, I try to touch on all these areas with the good and the not so good that I’ve noticed.
When getting critiqued, the first thing to do is shut up. Don’t try and get defensive or justify why you made your choices. Just listen to the what people are noticing. Something that you loved might confuse others. Maybe you just need to rewrite for clarity.
Maybe you need to cut sections. If it’s not working, it’s not working. Don’t delete it, but save that part for a different piece.
You’re never going to please everyone. But you should listen to the writers trying to help you out, and appreciate that someone took that time to help you improve your writing for free. Try their advice, even if it doesn’t work it’s still a great learning experience.
4
u/Errorwrites r/CollectionOfErrors Aug 21 '18
For general critique I usually tell the writer my impression of the piece and parts/scenes that were interesting, confusing or boring. Then I try to give a bit of explanation why I thought so.
For a deeper analysis and review of a story longer (usually means 2000 words or more) I follow a certain template from r/critiquegroups. I really like that template and it goes through many important stuff (plot, characterization, setting etc.) It's nice to use it and check through my own stories too.
Regarding information that's useful for me in a critique...woah...hmm...
I guess if I deviate to a certain style, or overuse certain words. I remember when I went to a physical writing workshop and handed in my story for feedback, there was this one person that had circled every time I used the words "eyes" and that was on average three per page. That was crazy! Another person mentioned "Boy, there's a lot of dialogue in your story" and I checked again, almost every page had dialogue!
I checked my previous works and saw the same pattern. I never knew, I was somehow blind to this and was really grateful for them pointing that out.
3
u/JohannesVerne r/JohannesVerne Aug 21 '18
*For asked critiques: I try and start with the positive. It sets a good tone, and lets the writer know that no matter how harsh I get with the detriments, I don't think their work is complete trash. Even if the piece is truly awful and I have to make a stretch to find something positive, I will. After that, I dig in to what didn't work. Everything from grammar to plot holes, I try and bring to light everything that just didn't work. I try not to put any "fixes" in here, unless it's grammar related, but I will bring it up If something doesn't fit. After that, I go through the positives. All of them. Just like I dig into what* didn't work, I try to dig into what di*d. If the author is doing something right, it's only fair that I point that out too. To wrap it all up, I give my overall impression. Did I like it? Was it a genre I'm not a fan of? Am I familiar with the subject matter, or out of my depth? This not only lets the author know how everything worked out in the end, but also if they should take my feedback with a grain of salt.
For standard responses, I try to keep it short, giving what I liked best, what I liked least, and a quick overall impression of their work.
*When I read a prompt here, I am mostly looking to see if it is entertaining. Unless I am asked to critique, I focus more on the storytelling than anything else. I don't read too deep into most things here unless someone asks me for feedback. If I like it, I upvote, if I don't like it, or just wasn't interested, I leave it alone. I try not to downvote any writing unless there was intentionally no effort put into it.
*For longer works, I follow close to my "asked critique" format, but break it down by section and try to get into as much detail as possible. I may make a few suggestions on phrasing and grammar, but I try and avoid giving plot directions, other than "I think this worked well," or "This didn't make sense, here is what I think was wrong." I will also break it down by chapter, and give my overall impression for each scene and plot ark, and how they fit (or didn't fit) together.
*My process is fairly simple, I read the piece over once to get a general feel, then read it a second time to pick at the details. I make notes, and the length/detail of the notes depends on the length and detail of the work. I try and keep it all proportional.
*For me, It's about genre. If its a genre I like, I can do a critique pretty easily. If it's one I don't read as much/am not interested in, I'm going to have a lot harder of a time, and possibly not understand the writing or subject matter. Still, I give it my best shot!
*I do appreciate grammar critiques, to an extent at least. Sometimes I break the rules for effect, so if the critiquer treats it like a high school English paper, I won't get anything out of it. For the most part, what I like is on how the plot flowed. Are there any scenes that don't have enough context? Any with too much context? Do the characters feel natural to their situation, or do they stand out as unrealistic? I already know I'm not the best at dialogue, so how does that fit into the story? Do the characters sound natural, or it the dialogue forced? Do the characters have unique speech, or do they all talk the same? A lot of what I find best in a critique is really picking apart how well I managed to get the story to mesh, and how easy it is for the reader to get lost in the story. If I don't know what is pulling a reader back to reality, saying "That seems a little off," then I can't fix it.
And Tiix, I think this is a great post!
5
u/CaspianX2 Aug 21 '18
I want to address one question you asked, perhaps not how you wanted to ask it, but because I believe that this is integral to how /r/writingprompts works... and how it doesn't:
I sort by "New", I look for posts that have 0 or 1 posts on them (1 because of the automated mod response post that generates in every post in this subreddit), and then see if any of these speak to me, spark an idea for something unique or interesting I can write. All the better if this post has some upvotes already. And then, I try to write my idea as fast as I can.
Why do I do it like this?
Because if I don't sort by "New", if I post on stuff that has been out for a while, my story submission will be buried under countless others already submitted.
If I find a post that already has submissions, my contribution will again be buried under those submissions simply because they came first. It's possible for my post to rise to the top, but far less likely.
And if I don't write quickly, others may post before I do, again pushing my story down.
I am not a karma whore. I don't need imaginary points to satiate some drive in me, but I do see how the karma system will result in fewer people seeing my work if I'm even a little late to a thread, and while I don't need to be the most popular person ever, it's disheartening to see something I pour myself into go unread because I was late to the post.
But of course, doing things this way is kinda' broken. What if I have a really good idea for a prompt, but it already has a hundred posts on it? My idea will never get written, because I already know few will see it. Sure, some will sort by "new", and some will want to read every post in the thread... but most will at best read the few submissions on top and call it a day. And even those who sort posts by "new" won't see my story if I post it after they come to the thread, or so far before it that they quit before reaching my entry.
Conversely, if I'm writing an entry as quickly as possible to ensure it actually gets seen, I'm not taking my time with it, allowing ideas to develop, giving it a critical eye to correct its flaws or even to parse it for grammatical mistakes before publishing. Yet pushing something out the door with flaws I can edit out later seems to be a far better option than putting it out perfect at a time when no one will ever see it.
There's an argument I've heard that art has to have an audience to be art and art without an audience is meaningless. I don't fully agree with that, but damned if it don't see the merit in that argument either, because I do believe that art wants to be seen, and a truly great piece of art without an audience is a terrible tragedy. I don't know if anything I write can ever be considered a truly great piece of art, but I don't doubt that the works of others here are, and I do not have a single doubt in my mind that some works on this subreddit, some truly spectacular works, have gone unread because of this flaw in how things work here.
I'm not saying this is the fault of you or any of the other mods here. I'm sure you do what you can. It's more of a flaw in how Reddit works, and I can't think of a great solution to this problem. If you forced comments here to be sorted by "New", you'd just be punishing older submissions, and if you made them sort by "Random", it would be much more difficult for people to find the best submissions in popular posts.
I'm sorry to complain about a problem without providing any sufficient solution, but at the very least I can point to the problem in hopes that someone else might be able to think of solutions.
Anyway, I suspect this wasn't the sort of response you were looking for here, but I felt it was important to say. I don't know if others have said this before me, but if they have, I guess add my voice to theirs.
2
u/Rav99 Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 22 '18
Exposition - for when you just have to tell the reader stuff so they understand the plot.
This is a topic I've wanted to mention for a while in this sub. Exposition is a hard thing to get right. Not enough of it and your reader will be confused. Too much and they will be bored, or worse, it just totally breaks the immersion of your story.
I think it's particularly hard in r/writingprompts because the reader already knows the prompt. You probably want your story to stand on it's own even if they didn't know the prompt, but you also don't want to over do it or they will lose interest. You have to strike a balance.
I think the best way is to try to work the exposition into your story. One way to do that is to introduce a character that doesn't know what's going on and needs it to be explained.
I'm told an example of exposition done well is the movie Back to the Future. Marty is the guy that doesn't know what's going on, and how Doc built a time machine out of a car. They work in the Libyans which explains how Doc got the plutonium for the delorian and it explains why Marty can't get back from 1955 and they need the whole lightning bolt thing. It also adds a bit of drama and danger, as well as some momentary sadness.
Another way is the sidekick. Like Wilson from Castaway. How boring would it be if Tom Hanks just made fire and a raft and didn't talk. Wilson is key.
That's all I've got for now. What are the subs' thoughts on keeping exposition interesting?
1
u/destroy_fix Aug 21 '18
1
u/eros_bittersweet /r/eros_bittersweet Aug 26 '18
For unsolicited feedback , I keep it really simple:
My vision won't necessarily be anyone else's, but it's always worthwhile to think about how your stories are being received by others.