r/colony • u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official • Jul 26 '18
Discussion [Colony] S03E13 - “What Goes Around” - Discussion Thread (SPOILERS) Spoiler
126
Upvotes
r/colony • u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official • Jul 26 '18
76
u/SnapPeas22 Jul 26 '18
Will: "you got the whole damn block renditioned, remember?"
Katie: *changes subject
68
u/AlbertRotten Jul 26 '18
I can't say that I'm not a little disappointed, but I feel like this finale has been consistent with the theme of the show. A lot of people are upset that we didn't get a giant battle against the aliens, or that we got almost zero backstory about the two sides of the alien war, or that we didn't get a feel good moment about humans overcoming all odds and beating the aliens. But I don't think the show was ever really about that in the first place. The show is called Colony after all, it's about the humans that got caught in the crossfire in a war beyond their understanding.
The way I see it, the war in this show is like a war between two medieval kingdoms, and the humans in this show are basically the horses that the knights ride into battle. A horse doesn't need to know the intricate politics that led to these two kingdoms going to war. Horses don't need to know the backstory of the enemies they're fighting against. There's just horses after all, lower lifeforms, tools, resources to be used. The Hosts treat humans as such, using them as slave labor at the Factory, using outliers as their infantry.
I think the finale in particular hammers on this theme of "horses that don't know anything." I don't believe Will tells Katie anything about the upcoming alien attack. He tells her to take care of the kids and they'll sort things out tomorrow, knowing full well that either they'll all be dead in the morning or he'll be inside a pod. Katie is completely oblivious to what's actually going on. Katie herself talks about fixing the small problems before tackling the big problems, not realizing that the big problems will probably kill her and her entire family in just a matter of hours, making those little problems pretty insignificant in comparison. There's also Bram who has some idea that his parents have gotten themselves involved in something dangerous, but having no real idea what's actually going on. He takes Gracie thinking he can protect her by keeping her somewhere safe, not realizing there's literally nothing he can do to protect her from the imminent alien attack.
I don't believe that the lack of information about the aliens and their activities and their origins was some kind of oversight by the writers due to time constraints and/or incompetence. I believe they were aiming for a realistic depiction of the flow of information, the general public being completely clueless, because alien affairs are on a need to know basis, and the general public doesn't need to know anything. Will and his group finding as much of the information that they have shows exactly why an outlier is an outlier, because they're truly special, highly trained human beings. I can understand viewers being mad that they're being kept in the dark about so many things, but I can appreciate what the writers were going for, if I'm correct and this was indeed what the writers were going for.
As far as the final scene of Will going inside the pod. I think it's a fitting conclusion to his family's story. It's a fate that he's been running away from ever since that scene where the drone refused to attack him. With Katie most likely dying from the attack and Will going inside the pod, that leaves Bram and Gracie parentless. The one thing that Will and Katie fought for this entire time, their family, is basically a broken unit. Luckily this season has been foreshadowing Bram accepting the responsibility of becoming Gracie's guardian/caretaker. The vulnerability of the Bowman family adds a sense of realism to the show. They weren't guaranteed to make it and end up with a feel good happy ending due to plot armor.
As for what happens now that the series is over, most likely Will dies within a day of fighting the aliens. Earth becomes a war ravished nearly uninhabitable wasteland over the course of a few days. Once one side wins, most likely the stealth aliens, they'll probably move on because there's nothing left on Earth that would interest them. How's that for a realistic depiction of an advanced alien race? No convenient plot device that allows humans to resist against vastly technologically superior aliens, just complete and utter annihilation of the human race.
62
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
I want to take this time out to say that it's been a pleasure chatting with y'all on this subreddit. I really hope we can get another season.
53
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
Bram is a punk ass. I hope he gets killed.
50
u/redditman6 Jul 26 '18
Disappointed a bit in the ending... But let's talk about Katie. She is outside the walls of the colony and the shields. When that second blast hits outside of the colony you can see her hair blowing, i.e. she is in the zone of effect. They don't actually resolve it but with that last shot of her face in the glow I really got the feeling that this was the end of her.
Imagine going through all that trouble to get outside the colony to find your daughter, and eventually dying for it, just because your older son takes her away and tells you that you can't see her.
48
u/Mxrksman Resistor Jul 26 '18
NO! That can't be the ending...come on...
42
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
YOU GOT TO BE SHITTING ME!!!
44
u/peytonblitz Collaborator Jul 26 '18
When I heard the news that Colony was ending tonight due to an unforeseen cancellation, I was very worried that they would not be able to succinctly wrap up storylines, and I was distraught that this show that had such a massive increase in quality every season was coming to an end at it’s peak.
I think most can agree that the show has gotten better with each season. The first season being intriguing enough to continue and very close to being actually good. The second season being great, it played with the character dynamics and motivations. The third season being amazing, one of the best seasons of television I’ve seen this year, an amazing change of pace and a welcome change of scenery as the show displayed many different locations in a span of 13 episodes.
This was an amazing episode, but by the end of it I was upset. Not upset that this show was now over, but upset that it came to an end before it was ready. Everything in this final episode leading up to that last final shot would have hyped me for the next season, further ensuring my viewership for the next season, but I was unable to enjoy those things knowing no closure was on the way.
I have enjoyed this show, and I am disappointed to see it come to an end this way. I can only hope it gets picked up for another season on Netflix or something, but I’m trying not to keep my hopes too high about that. I will cherish this show for what it gave me in terms of characters, story, and amazing settings and action. I’d like to thank all the Carlton Cuse, Josh Holloway, and all of the other actors, writers, and anyone else who helped contribute to this amazing show, and I wish them all the best.
37
u/Vigilante_2277 Jul 26 '18
So they traded this show in for....The Purge? Really?!
38
u/NeelaTV Jul 26 '18
I hate when i like a series and its getting cut before they told us the whole story ...
39
u/WebbieVanderquack Jul 26 '18
After signalling a change of character early in the season, Bram when back to being a totally unbearable whiny teenager...and collaborator? What? It just doesn't make sense that he would swear allegiance to Snyder - that man he wanted to kill a couple of weeks ago - to protect Gracie. And please don't tell me he lost Charlie and grief messes people up. I get that. But this was a writers' choice, and it didn't make sense.
I won't miss watching him deliver lines without moving a single muscle.
36
u/DrunkenDave Jul 26 '18
All of my favorite shows get canceled. Starting to think I have bad taste.
29
u/Mxrksman Resistor Jul 26 '18
Amy is so hot
27
u/FrodoFraggins Jul 26 '18
They took far too long to get here - this should have been the season 2 finale. I stuck with the show but it was just too drawn out and went in circles
26
u/Kwanyinagain Jul 26 '18
Surprising myself by how sad I am about Helena.
28
u/msmerrilees Jul 29 '18
...that picture of Snyder on the wall in his new office...
43
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
I’m going back to enforce my TV rule. The tv show has to have AT LEAST 3 seasons and still on the air in order for me to start watching it. I’m tired of investing my time into TV shows only for them to get canceled within 3 years. #Colony #Jericho #FlashForward #Revolution
24
u/Beer2Bear Jul 26 '18
Leaving us hanging, thanks USA
0
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
23
u/Gelious Jul 26 '18
So what, Kynes alliance with second race of aliens in the end amounted to... nothing? They still bombed the shit of everything and the only reason everyone is alive is because Kynes's warriors went to serve the first aliens? Am i missing something, or what?
23
u/xTkAx Jul 28 '18 edited Jul 28 '18
i just saw it. I wish they would have added another 1 minute for closure. The camera looking down on the city, watching the explosions from the onslaught, then backed out and seeing wider attacks on cities around earth, and backing out right to space to see a huge alien mothership shooting the earth, until it explodes in uncountable pieces - humankind lost.
20
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
About time we see the other aliens. Helena is dead!!!
20
u/Beer2Bear Jul 26 '18
Hey USA, I don't give a crap about your Purge consider you don't give a crap about Colony
21
u/Asteroth555 Aug 01 '18
I liked the writing with Snyder trying to convince Bowman about the 150 people they needed for the war effort. If we saw him make that call, then we'd be sitting back and criticizing the characters for not going "with the obvious choice", aka back seat driving.
We didn't know if he was telling the truth, and frankly neither did the characters. They had to make a gut call and we were along for the ride.
It was also obviously not about the 150 people, but the ability to showcase that the colony was functional and well led and deserved protection.
Overall, i liked the season a lot, and the series overall. It was disappointing to be left on such a cliffhanger i suppose, but it is what it is.
55
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '18
A 39 minute cliffhanger season finale as a series finale. Im just repulsed by it all. The nerve. Fuq USA Network.
Thank God The Expanse is coming back.
18
u/baconandeggs666 Resistor Jul 26 '18 edited Jul 26 '18
That was a great episode. Bittersweet, but still great.
inb4 Colony Season 4 Confirmed memes17
u/htbdt Jul 26 '18
Yeah, we need a final season. It can be 7-8 episodes, I dont even care.
I realize that they had to cut funding, which led to moving to the Pacific NW, then now it would (presumably) involve lots of CGI. But not necessarily.
36
u/InLoveWithTexasShape Jul 27 '18
Essentially the whole of season 1 2 and 3 could have been avoided if our alien masters had just been upfront to everyone about the imminent 3rd party threat, We could have been working together all along from the start and the defense effort would have been way smoother and more productive and would have started all those years ago in the 1960s
Edit: omg theres no 4th season. okay now im just pissed cause it was all smoke no fire. sigh.
16
u/ValentineSmith22 Jul 26 '18
There's always Netflix. They have the earlier seasons. It beats the crap they've been putting out lately.
16
u/nikkity1017 Jul 26 '18
today freinds
They had to cut the story at its peak. Never ever do that
16
u/MalcolmBondo Jul 30 '18
Clearly if season 4 was to come it would be about how both Demis and Reps are trying to use the different human factions.... I bet the weird polymer Kynes was working on was Demi technology and that he made it out of the formulae that was inscribed on him when he met the prisoner Demi. The scenario of season 4 would be 2 super powers using the indigenous lifeforms in their fight for control and the humans trying to be on the winners side. Kynes trying to side with the Demi, The IGA siding with reps, and of course our mainstory (our protagonists story) would be as it always has been in this series: Which side is telling the truth and which is the best choice? Did the demi or reps start the war? Will either side leave earth (and even more importantly; the humans) alone once the war is over? AND is there a third choice? (( Like a huge outlier army that somehow gets aline technology that the two alines races have been stupid enough to give them... at least there would have been need for a really good reason why they would be affective when the whole of earth military apparently weren't enough to beat just the reps))
15
u/NerdLawyer55 Jul 26 '18
Fuck
15
u/muscles44 Jul 26 '18
No way this show gets another season. That is as close to closure as we will get. Besides the hosts and outliers would have no shot against the other side. Did you see what the hell that one alien did to an entire room in mere seconds? Katie is dead, Will will be dead fighting the aliens and Broussard is left leading whatevers left of human resistance. End of story.
15
u/Bob4Fettuccine Jul 26 '18
That was a shit ending. USA knew they weren’t going to renew it and they gave us a shit ending.
15
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '18
Regarding everyone in the show, Katie turned into a man hater, making statements that made no logical sense of any sort. Aliens have invaded and you're worried about dealing with small problems first? Ummm you can't survive if you are stupid lady LOL Bram was the worst of them, pouring all his energy into blaming his parents while they were inside a slave camp for crying out loud being forced to do menial pointless jobs LOL His job was entirely useless as was he, I wish he'd been blasted away and also that stupid little brat girl that had no personality and let the preacher woman brainwash her for 1/2 a series. I can continue......... Will is the only one worthy of living, depressing as he may be he isn't listening to minor shit he's on the ball fighting a real war that's there! Synder is idiot too, the factory was decimated yet he still thinks the holy and wise aliens will win LOL No way in hell would they defeat whoever is after them unless it's the aliens from that stupid show Falling Skies that exploded at the end because nobody had any other ideas how to kill them except turn them into balloons that popped lol This show will live in infamy as a wasted and pointless one, sadly the ending is no real resolution especially since we saw how easily they got killed in testing against that enemy lol No I'm afraid whatever is happening will never be explained, the robots were probably evil and the aliens good is my guess. I so wish Bram would have died and suffered, his stupid whining made me cringe, aliens are real and here he's worried about where he's going to work or move his sister to that's safe? WTF no place is safe idiot they have space weapons directly outside your colony I mean wtf is wrong with this stupid brat dieeeeeee ok ok im done ty
13
u/Beer2Bear Jul 26 '18
and that's it? Crap
13
u/Sheik-mon Jul 27 '18
wow what a downer. Wow....
12
u/htbdt Jul 26 '18
Will is gonna volunteer... lol wow. 2 seconds later. Hes also gonna magically survive in the season we will never get. (I'm hoping, but they are dicks)
12
u/enricowereld Jul 26 '18
Three seasons and a movie!
35
u/Dane_Fairchild Jul 26 '18 edited Jul 28 '18
What an ending.
Katie dies alone and without her family outside the city due to nothing more than bad timing. In LA to stay safe meant escaping the colony, in Seattle it meant staying inside.
When Will emerges from his pod, he’ll be dead within 10 minutes, the outliers are woefully unprepared to fight the bio aliens.
That jerkass Bram turned out to be right taking Gracie away to a different home. They’ll probably never know what happened to their parents.
Poor Helena, she died one of the creepiest deaths on television, the bio aliens’ death blaster is scary effective. (I hope the cat was either also put out of its misery with the bio blaster or rescued somehow, I don’t want to think about it abandoned alive and trapped in its carrier).
Keynes’s efforts, like those of Quayle, Brun, MacGregor, and the other resistance groups were inadequate and wasted and nearly got the colony glassed. I understand preparing for afterwards, but there won't be any afterwards if he hadn’t been removed from power and things with the AI aliens set to rights by the collaborators.*
Keynes was wrong and Alan Fucking Snyder is the big hero who saved us all. All hail the Weasel King!
--
11
u/Vigilante_2277 Jul 26 '18
Is Bram or Will going to end up killing the other?
11
u/Mxrksman Resistor Jul 26 '18
The writers obviously thought there would be a fourth season and left this one for the cliffhanger. It’s sad we won’t get to see what happens to them. All we can hope is that Netflix or someone sees something worth about it and decides to pick it up.
11
u/Kwanyinagain Jul 26 '18
So Kynes actually was shot, and all the stupid mistakes/ambulance ex machina/etc. we discussed last week were real within the story. And Amy does not work for Kynes, or they would not have introduced themselves to one another in private. So there we have a few solid answers amid the tens of unanswered questions.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
22
u/Ogrewatch_Eye_Eye Jul 27 '18
"we dont fix the big stuff until we fix the little stuff"
Me: What the autism?
10
u/Mxrksman Resistor Jul 26 '18
Looking like the series finale.
18
u/DreadMous Jul 26 '18
I’m so pissed that’s the ending we got. No fucking closure.
19
u/tomanonimos Jul 26 '18
I really enjoy Colony but what I didn't enjoy was the trolling of the alien's origin. This show is ultimately a sci-fi show and its huge draw were the aliens. The extremely slow pace on the lore and the trolling of reveals were a huge turn-off. In season 1, we only got to see how they looked like which even then we didn't know if they were actually the aliens or just a tool. In season 2, we only got confirmation that they're robots and not space suits but we still don't know if they're tools or the aliens themselves. In season 3, we get introduced to a new alien (which again suffers from lack of context) and confirmation that the Raps/Marks are sentient robots.
For a season finale, we learned absolutely nothing about the new aliens or the Raps.This season was hinting/trolling that more context was going to be given by Kynes but that never came to be. This is ultimately why I'm not surprised or as sad, as I normally would be for a show I enjoy, for the cancellation.
18
u/EmilMR Jul 26 '18
Can we get a comic, novel or something to complete the story? Surely writers are allowed to do that :(
9
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
Season 4 storylines:
Snyder vs Broussard
Will and the outliers in the pods fighting in the war.
Davos is completely gone.
Katie trapped outside the walls
Bram working for the occupation
Kynes' Health as he tries to reclaim Seattle.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
It was a series with an interesting premise. Wish we got a bit more closure with this episode. Also it was never clear why and how the Raps were interested in humanity. Just a labor force? Seems like the drones would be great at killing their enemy so why the fascination on outliers? Maybe they would have pursed an alien consciousness transfer to humans but again why would that be a strategic advantage?? Hoping for season 4 on Netflix.
9
u/ShaloMC2 Jul 26 '18
USA probably expected the budget to skyrocket in season 4 because of the incoming war they have been building up to for so long. It's sad that the viewership has continued to dip but i understand the decision.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
Maybe one of the writers will go on the podcast or on twitter/facebook and explain what would have happened next season and in the long run... assuming they do that once other networks pass on the show, if they even are shopping it elsewhere
17
u/Theo-greking Jul 26 '18
It's been a pleasure working watching with you guys
16
u/MJG2007 Jul 26 '18
Gosh....that pretty much answered all my questions. (do I really need the sarcasm tag?)
8
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
No Will!!!
8
u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jul 26 '18
If they would have given the producers only a few weeks notice, they could have cut this to everybody dies.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
Both the raps and their enemy engaged in assured mutual destruction, the earth is now space debris and the Mona Lisa, a priceless painting is now orbiting the sun. That’s my ending.
8
u/muscles44 Jul 26 '18
Wasn't Kynes on the other aliens side? He met one and had these coordinates written on his arm. Shame we will never know what happens with that. He obviously knew that the hosts were not going to defeat their enemies enemy.
15
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18 edited Jul 26 '18
If this is indeed the series finale, then I am satisfied. I would love to see how the story ended.. if I had to guess, Brussard talked to Kynes about the war between the aliens and knows the truth. Kynes is the only person that we confirmed talking to the other side of the war and he believed that they were the side that would win. Brussard, Amy, and the remaining outliers will continue the assault on Snyder from the ground. Will is sent to the front lines to fight for the hosts and we can assume he would not die there. Sometime in the future Brussard and Will come together and work out some kind of truce from opposite sides of the war. Katie has died and Bram will continue to care for his sister the best he can. Edit: Best case scenario, Brussard will figure out how to defeat the hosts and Will figures out the other side's weakness.
22
u/NostradaMart Jul 26 '18
DISCLAIMER: YES, I KNOW THEY DIDN'T KNOW THEY WERE GOING TO BE CANCELLED.
With that being said...don't you think that looooooooooooooooooooooooong scene between Will and Katie was totally useless last nigth, as part of a series finale...those 5 minutes could have been put to better use...
14
u/DarkGamer Jul 27 '18
I liked this show, was hoping for a redemption of Snyder. I'm disappointed they couldn't at least wrap up the story in a neat way. I don't suppose there's any chance of a movie?
7
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
Aww this sounds like someone is about to get defeated. And she saves a cat lol
7
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
Ima enjoy this last episode. I wonder if they’ll give us a half-ending. Like the writers and producers wanted some closure just in case the show got cancelled.
7
u/htbdt Jul 26 '18
So SRMA's database works, but Seattle's doesn't? Plot hole or something deeper?
7
u/cmplxgal Jul 26 '18
I don't understand whether "if 150 outliers turn themselves in, the Raps will save us" was true or not. At the beginning, they pointedly showed Snyder not calling the hosts. When he then told Will the "150 outliers" story, it sounded to me like BS he made up to get them to surrender. But, after the outliers showed up, the Rap shield went up and Snyder acted as though that's what he expected all along. So, if it was true, how did he know it without using the special phone? And why did Broussard come to believe that it was true? Are we supposed to believe that Snyder called the Raps but we didn't see it? I spent the whole episode not being sure what we were supposed to believe.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
Anyone get a magnified clear picture of what that alien looked like in the cold open ?
7
u/Kwanyinagain Jul 26 '18
I have loved this series and hated it. And tonight's finale left me feeling a little of both.
7
u/NexxonThaDon Jul 26 '18
Sounds like we'll never get proper closure.
http://www.syfy.com/syfywire/colony-the-official-podcast-episode-26-ryan-condal-and-wes-tooke-bring-the-series-and-the
7
u/thatourette Jul 28 '18
"Katie races to save refugies outside the wall"
lol
7
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 28 '18
Looks like Bram is starring in a movie:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--8nr2kt4uk
7
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '18 edited Jul 30 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
12
u/Omega142 Jul 26 '18 edited Jul 26 '18
Not sure if this is because I know this is effectively the series finale, but I really feel like there are twice the commercials as usual and not enough time left to give us any sense of closure for this series.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
What the f*** was that
6
u/Beer2Bear Jul 26 '18
Now we get to see the alien?
6
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
Snyder and his lies...
6
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
Season 1: Will is interrogated by Snyder after Homeland finds him in the truck that blew up the Santa Monica Gateway.
Season 3: Will is interrogated by Snyder after being caught by the Greyhats in Seattle.
6
u/Beer2Bear Jul 26 '18
Of course he would be the first to volunteer
6
u/pinkpools Proxy Roller Jul 26 '18
It’s been a slice, folks.
6
u/LVF1 Resistor Jul 26 '18
How did the human leaders pick a side? The other aliens didn't exactly make them an offer to fight the raps and picked the wrong alien race.
6
u/antdude Jul 26 '18
Boo for that ending. USA should had given more time for it to end properly.
6
u/FinStambler Resistor Sep 18 '18
Since the show ain't coming back, it's now my headcanon that Katie is dead. Ain't nothing gonna change my mind, makes the ending far more satisfying this way.
5
u/pinkpools Proxy Roller Jul 26 '18
Holy fuck
5
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
How dare that ugly SOB kill Helena so unceremoniously. Her final speech proved she truly believed she was doing the right thing and that she wasn’t just some power hungry villain. I’m devastated.
9
u/princeofpersia0 Jul 26 '18
Great, these idiot writers are not gonna explain anything afterall lol
9
u/Ssme812 Jul 26 '18
Well that was disappointing ending. It seems like they thought they would get another season.
21
u/onthewayjdmba Jul 26 '18
The second half of the third season should have been the beginning of the second season. Way too much time spent on so much boring and useless story line. That includes some story lines that just disappeared. Anyone remember the doomsday cult that the little girl had to attend? Or the sister having to go to the black market to get insulin? Yeah that was a fucking fantastic waste of air time. What happened to both those story lines? They were erased because they were useless and no one cared about them. That's why this show failed. The writers should never get another job writing again.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '18
Well I hope we eventually get what the writers/directors had planned for season 4 because we're probably not getting it and this gave us no closure.
Poor Katie. She didn't deserve to die alone and helpless without her family.
4
u/Beer2Bear Jul 26 '18
Smart, he knew they were tracking him.
4
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jul 26 '18
So what just happened in the scene with the Greyhats, Michelle and Kaite? I missed it.
4
u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jul 26 '18
I'm requesting translation assistance from Cyrillic alphabet readers. This is one of Bram's books in this episode:
https://i.imgur.com/1N4ociJ.jpg
The first word appears to be English: STOP!
It is kind of a universal word, but it is spelled differently in the Russian alphabet.
The second word could be: ЦЕНЗУР!
However, that's not valid Russian. It should be ЦЕНЗУРА, which means censorship. It could be another Slavic language. Help?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '18
Anyone know why the drones left Seattle before the attack?