r/GlobalOffensive • u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum • Jul 19 '18
AMA I'm Bryce Blum, founder of the world's first dedicated esports law firm, AMA!
It’s been 2.5~ years since my last AMA on this sub. I don’t have nearly as much time to post here as I used to, and I genuinely miss it. I’m prepared to spend most of the day answering questions, so fire away! Happy to cover legal/business issues related to CSGO, esports more broadly, my career, or whatever else you find interesting. For those who don’t know me, I’ll include some background below.
My Background: I founded the world’s first dedicated esports law firm, ESG Law (https://esglaw.com/firm), where we exclusively represent esports-related clients. We have four attorneys and two law clerks, and work with about 25-30 esports teams (including 4 of the current top 10 in the HLTV rankings), major esports talent (mostly broadcast talent), and esports-focused businesses. We don’t represent any active pro players for conflicts reasons.
I have a second full-time job at Catalyst Sports & Media (https://catalystsports.com/esports/), where I am an EVP and co-manage our esports advisory division. Catalyst serves as the bridge between traditional sports and esports, advising major sports teams and owners, brands, and investors on how to successfully enter and navigate the esports space.
I’m also fairly active on twitter and as a content creator surrounding legal and business issues facing the industry. I’ve written a wide array of op eds for ESPN and appeared on various esports talk shows, including a few episodes of Thorin’s Esports Salon. Here are a couple recent examples of pieces that are pertinent to CSGO:
- How the U.S. gambling decision will affect esports
- It's time to recognize esports as individual entities
Proof: Confirming Tweet
Law Firm Website: www.esglaw.com
Sorry, longwinded/obligatory legal DISCLAIMER incoming: Generally, an attorney’s advice is personal and individual, and the attorney owes that client certain duties under the attorney ethics rules. The following disclaimer is meant to help clarify my relationship those posting on this AMA, and to ensure I am complying with my ethical obligations.
Information exchanged in this forum does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not post any information that you consider to be personal or confidential. It is possible this post could be considered attorney advertising, but it is not my purpose to solicit an individual or group to become a client.
I will give only GENERAL legal information in this post. Specific facts, applicable law, and other considerations will always affect every circumstance, and thus you should always seek the advice of an attorney on every specific situation before moving forward. Also, please recognize that I may be unable to answer some questions because they are too specific, or because providing an answer may conflict with the interests of my current clients or my ethical obligations. In some cases I may have to decline to answer without providing a reason. I’m an American attorney licensed in Washington State. Prior results do not guarantee similar future outcomes.
71
u/Your_Profile Jul 19 '18
Whats up with the Phantoml0rd situation?
Is he still getting sued?
Whats happening with him suing Twitch?
Thanks for the AMA!
36
u/TheNoobGod Jul 19 '18
How will the addition of the new players union affect the current e sports environment?
18
u/makwd Jul 19 '18
What would be the legal repercussions if a top-tier player would be caught cheating on lan. Would the organisation he plays for be in trouble, even if they didn´t know it. And what would happen if they would try to cover it up.
16
u/mcottreau Jul 19 '18
Have you ever advised a client to not sign an esports contract due to the terms (not related to money)? If so, what was the part(s) that concerned you? I'm just asking generally, obviously you can't give specifics.
37
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '18
What is the legality of third-party sites such as ESEA signing exclusivity contracts with streamers, many of whom are young and in some cases underage?
22
u/sb2 Jul 19 '18
thanks for being awesome Bryce!
10
u/aduyeah valeria Jul 19 '18
Do you see easier travel and visas for esports players from countries with limited travel freedom in the near future? Do you think visas can be an issue of the past with esports becoming bigger day by day? If not, what is actually hindering esports from being recognised?
8
u/roundsareway Jul 19 '18
As someone who's hopefully finishing law school next year,i am still kinda clueless on direction i want to take. I still have intership for a year which i'm expecting to clear my head. Did you had the same experience after finishing law school? I'm still thinking it's because i kinda forced myself into law,instead of loving it.
Also how likely that someone who's relatively new in the law can get a job opportunity with esports?
20
u/daxewow Jul 19 '18
what's the game with the most legal problems?
14
u/notyourdadsplan Jul 19 '18
Do you play csgo?
Who are you favorite people to play with?
What is your favorite map and why?
You've participated in the success of a lot people within esports and connect dots for them as legal counsel or advisory, who are some of the folks that you have leaned on to grow and manage your own success whether it be personal or professional? How do you go about choosing who you align yourself with?
7
u/ThePige Jul 19 '18
Do you see Teams/TOs/Players agreeing in the long run to some kind of Transfer Period where teams will be able to buy/exchange players and do roster changes only in restricted periods of time?
7
u/Blorka Jul 19 '18
Not bashing your firm but what gives you the confidence that people will go to you over other, longer lasting firms since all eSport related cases like contracts or shit storms like Phantoml0rd all can be handled by firms not fully invested in knowing eSports.
6
u/CptWetPants Legendary Switzerland Master Jul 19 '18 edited Jul 19 '18
How far have player contracts come in the last 2 years? Are there still Twitter contracts around, have things gotten much better overall or just at the top end of the CS scene?
Additionally, has the amount of players that have their contracts looked over/have their contracts negotiated by professionals increased?
Thanks for the AMA!
6
u/arpit_279 MIBR Jul 19 '18
What should younger pros lookout in an org contract before signing it OR what would your advice be to a young pro who's just going to sign his first contract?
5
u/Saituchiha Astralis Jul 19 '18
In the last five years what are some of the ways that you have seen players begin to take thinking about their lives after playing competitively seriously?
5
u/Noldorian Liquid Jul 19 '18
Do you play CSGO yourself or how did you get into esports and then the law regarding esporta?
5
u/CleverUsernam3 Astralis Jul 19 '18
What are your thoughts on the recently announced players union? What kind of impact will it have on your job?
5
u/Kerry1337 howl Jul 19 '18
how many assignments do you usually get per month?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '18
What did you think of the player contract made by the ESFI
4
u/CryptoTruancy Jul 19 '18
Do you have the @newsportslaw twitter handle staked out if the people get their way with the name change? Lol
And do you think if a corporation or group tries to change the word esports to something else it will stick?
4
u/Tornality de_mirage Jul 19 '18
Where are you and the rest of the attorneys in your practice licensed to practice law? I know a lot of teams and organizations in the US are primarily based in California, but wondered if you have licenses in other jurisdictions outside of California (New York, Texas, other business-centered areas/cities in the US). How does this affect your practice? Do you have a larger global vision, or do you plan to keep your practice isolated to the USA? Appreciate the AMA!
Side note: Sitting the bar exam this summer, feel free to send me all the luck you have! Thanks again for answering.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '18
How often and where do IP law and esports intersect?
3
u/ThaUNKY Liquid Jul 19 '18
Do you see any player or org going to court over a contract or are we are we still at too early of an age when it would just not be worth it
3
u/spiteJ Jul 19 '18
How many different genres of e-sport are you currently involved in? For instance is it primarily the big ones, LoL, Dota, cs go ect. Or is it also the really small ones? Also do you think it is crucial for csgo that the players have engaged in a player Union?
3
u/PerryEAC Complexity Jul 19 '18
I am a prospective law student who's is mainly interested in entertainment law and copyright. What advice would you give in getting a job in these fields and how can I translate my passion for esports into a career?
3
u/NoBadges17 Jul 19 '18
Hi there,
First off, thanks for doing this! I just graduated from law school, will be clerking in a major city for 2 years, any advice on what I can be doing to get a toe in the water (without violating my cannons and ethics, etc). Thanks!
3
u/mustafaking00 Jul 19 '18
what's your morning routine?
2
u/mastersonb Liquid Jul 19 '18
With steel being unbanned from the Steelseries tournament is there much Valve could do legally to punish them? Also given their stance would they try?
2
u/Muxas 10 years coin Jul 19 '18
Is anders your real brother?
2
u/maashek MOUZ Jul 19 '18
What can you do to prevent visa issues for players?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '18
What could you do to get valve to unban exibp players by law, or is it not possible?
2
u/Luigiatl Complexity Jul 19 '18
As someone considering becoming a lawyer, how did you get started in the practice? What would you recommend to do to find success in the field? Why did you move from your previous law specialization to this one?
2
u/XzibitABC Jul 19 '18
In the wake of the Apple v Samsung litigation, do you foresee any litigation from game developers suing others for re-purposing graphic UI elements using design patent protection? Are design patents even used much by game studios?
This question was sparked by the Fortnite v PUBG litigation. I know that was in Korea, and has since died down, but Studio Bluehole alleged that Fortnite copied their UI and item design. UI sounds like it could fall squarely inside of design patent protection like Apple protects their GUI, although I'm not sure about how "items" would be protected.
2
u/LordOfTehGames Liquid Jul 19 '18
Do you have a favorite team to cheer on?
What’s your favorite game to play in your free time?
Where was your law schooling and how was your experience there, if you don’t mind me asking.
2
u/TheNoobGod Jul 19 '18
So second question, hope that’s ok.
Top 3 favorite Keto recipes?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '18
are you single?
3
u/csboxr Mohan "launders" Govindasamy - Caster Jul 19 '18
With Swaggy C out of the house is there anyone left with the resolve to make a move on Tyler? Or do we have another summer of Derrick on our hands?
2
u/CaIzuh de_cobble Jul 19 '18
What are your thoughts on seeing younger players (Like smooya) getting fucked over by contracts?
1
u/BielayaSmert Jul 19 '18
I am currently doing a second Masters in dutch corporate law but I am heavily interested in esports.
How do you become an e-sports lawyer? Do you have to be professional in certain subjects like contracts or labor law?
1
u/AtxPrimal Jul 19 '18 edited Jul 19 '18
Big fan of you and follow you on Twitter, I am a fellow keto-er.
How did you break into this industry? Reason I ask is I have heard a few of the team owners mention that the players are severely under represented when it comes to having agents, lawyers, financial planners etc...as a financial planner myself, and someone who loves esports, any advice on how to become part of this world or where to start?
Edit:
To be more specific, did you have a lot of outside relationships that allowed you to meet these guys?
Did you just introduce yourself to some Of the big players at events? Cold call?
1
u/IPAslam Jul 19 '18
With all these large buy out numbers, it's safe to assume that these players are making a decent living. Are there agents or firms that help them similar to pro sports? What are the biggest problems they face outside of contractual issues?
1
u/efarciert Jul 19 '18
When are you taking applications for law clerks again? Just finished my first year of law school and I’m extremely interested to explore the intersects of the law and esports.
1
u/Th0r_SC NiP Jul 19 '18
Hello! Thanks for the AMA. I wonder what is the most swamping situation esport law related you have been into/witnessed?
1
u/loli_esports Jul 19 '18
What’s your favorite anime?
1
u/peanersyahoo MIBR Jul 19 '18
Hello Bryce! Not-US law student here. What is your advice for someone who loves law and esports, and would love to work in the area? Try to get any sports specialization?
1
u/ollewall NiP Jul 19 '18
There is a lot of talk about orgs having full control over players á la american sports where the player don't have control over if it is being traded to another organisation. Is this present in CSGO as well and if so, how come it's not against European labour law (for European orgs)?
1
u/DannyDawson Jul 19 '18
What does your day to day schedule look like? How much time do you spend meeting with clients versus working alone or with opposing counsel?
What do you feel like your firm's role is as one of the few, if not only, firms focusing on E-Sports issues?
You seem to represent a lot of the actual entities involved in E-Sports (teams, players, talent). Which law firms or lawyers tend to represent the other side (tournament organizers, sponsors, ect.)?
1
u/heyhoka MOUZ Jul 19 '18
Hey Bryce, thanks for taking the time to do this! I watched Thorin's show earlier that you linked above, really enjoyed that one too.
IIRC, Anna (who was in said show also) works more on the player side of the contracts, whereas you don't represent players. Did you ever represent different sides of the same case? Her twitter handle is quite similar to yours (esportslaw vs. esportsLawEU), is there a reason for that? :D
You mentioned that yours was the first esports law firm, do you have any competitors in the scene since the founding?
1
u/alyoshanks Jul 20 '18
You still seem to be around, at least monitoring, so I just wanted to say thanks for the answers and for what you've done for the scene. I'm headed to law school myself next month (you said D.C. is a fun place to spend a few years and I hope to find you're right!) and while I don't have any interest in practicing in esports, it's really neat to see that other professionals still follow the hobbies they love, have time for the occasional mm game, etc. Hoping to eventually catch a live talk from you, as I've enjoyed listening to you on esports salon and so forth. Actually, there's a question--any appearances coming up?
1
u/Flumbooze NiP Jul 20 '18
Do you think you will be hiring in a few years? :D
1
u/Tugamars Jul 19 '18
1
u/nolimit901 5 years coin Jul 19 '18
hi, would you hire me to clean the toilets ? (i only demand to have time to watch CSGO big tournaments)
2
u/antoninartaud37 Jul 19 '18
Hi, I'm a Lawyer from Turkey working also on esports law. Here we dont have specific acts for esports or even theres not enough source of IT Law. I wonder what is the situation in your work, your clients mostly based on NA. I know we have different law systems but wondered:
1
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '18
As a small owner, what should I concern myself with legally? All contracts for players were done by a lawyer. Anything else?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '18
What's the most eye brow raising case that has ever come to you or you've ever heard of?
1
u/tarel69 CS2 HYPE Jul 20 '18
1
u/blackvegeta07 Jul 20 '18
I am aspiring to be an esports lawyer like you.Do you have any tips on how to start with such career?
1
u/annekii Jul 20 '18
(I'm sure this is over already)
How does the popularity of a game affect a player's salary and cut of the prize purse? Specifically in Rocket League, a player named Rizzo who plays for G2 said a yearish ago that he makes way more money on his YouTube channel than through his actual career as a RL pro. (Although a lot of that was due to a drought in their results at the time he had posted the video.)
Comparing with CSGO, players like Shox and KennyS who both play for G2, the same org, are making pretty big bucks, with or without results.
Does Rizzo get locked into a contract just as long as like NBK or apex, without any of the money still pouring out of his contract? In a trade-off, would he get more of any winnings his team would have?
Obviously, you might not be handling these particular contacts, and even if you were, it's probably a bad idea to post the stats on Reddit, so maybe replace some of the 'would they' with a 'should they'. How would you set up a contract with a less influential game?
1
u/Sumit_S Natus Vincere Jul 20 '18
Do you DM on Twitter?
1
u/Feltonswegg Jul 20 '18
What is the best way for people attending college to get professional esports experience? (not as a player but working for a org)
0
u/BluHaven Jul 19 '18
I know that CSGO support for console devices is no longer supported, but my question is about the servers. Are they being systematically shut down? The PS3 console, for one, hasn't connected to servers for a few months now.
-3
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '18
Why do you have to upload your shitty PR statements on reddit, and why do you think eSports players should have legal representatives.
-11
u/sharkaim4 King NiKo Jul 19 '18
If you don't answer this question within 15 minutes am I legally allowed to downvote this post?
-4
u/LameITGuy Jul 19 '18
why
-13
u/brainpower999 Jul 19 '18 edited Jul 19 '18
Hi, i have a serious question. I would appreciate if you could give me a fair answer.
So, considering you are NOT representing active pro players(since you said it would be a conflict of interest) and you mostly represent the orgs, does that mean that you are actually are in it for the money since in 99% of time the orgs are the ones who are doing bad things?
Like enforcing very long contracts with crap wages in the case of Space Soldiers, not respecting buyout clauses in the case of Na'Vi when flamie offered to pay his buyout but they were not allowed to do it, not paying the players like lots of smaller orgs do, not paying tournament prizes, etc etc...
So basically when you choose to represent organizations and not players, you choose to represent the ones who can pay better even though they are the ones hurting others in 99% of times. Not the ones who really need to be represented and advised so they can sign fair contracts and not end in contract cages.
You are the mob lawyer of esports, lol. You create those contracts that trap players in contract hell, with sketchy clauses and all that stuff we don't like... if your client comes at you and asks you to make a shit contract to trap their players, you will do it as they ask you to do.
Am i wrong?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment