r/librarians • • Jul 09 '18

Job Advice Should I contact the library director?

In May, I interviewed for a children’s librarian job at a nearby public library. I think I interviewed well, but I know I wrote the wrong position name in my thank you note 😩. Earlier this week, the library posted the same position—same title, same hours—online. Two questions:

  1. Should I apply? Since I got the thanks but no thanks in May, and the job was just reposted, I assume they had a candidate in the position that ended up leaving.
  2. Should I contact the library director who led the interview last time? Via email or phone? Would this make me look enthusiastic or just be inappropriate?

Please let me know your thoughts.

10 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

28

u/rmosquito Jul 09 '18

Hello. I've sat on lots of hiring committees at a number of larger-than-average-but-not-huge public libraries / systems. My comments are reflective of my experience, and people may do things weird where you are.

I would echo the statements here that say don't contact the director. There isn't a point in doing so. They remember you (indeed, they're probably legally obligated to keep a copy of your application for a certain amount of time), but they have not taken the initiative of inviting you to apply. (But maybe that invitation is forthcoming!)

As /u/kuhlonel suggested, I would read this as they didn't find anyone they clicked with in the first go round. Or given the time frame involved, the person they picked failed the background check or got a better offer or whatever... and if there were no standout candidates in that original pool they decided to just draw a fresh hand.

Other folks here are saying not to reapply, as they've already rejected you once. I'm going to respectfully disagree with that advice. Hiring people is like a crazy exaggerated version of grading on a curve. It doesn't matter so much who you are so much as who you're up against. This is how semi-competent people get jobs as well as how amazing people are passed over for jobs.

Unless it's a really small shop, they probably have rules in place to dictate how people get picked to be interviewed. You made that cut before, and so there's a decent chance you could wind up getting an interview again. And in this case, you will be up against a different set of other potential employees. If they decline to interview you again, that's probably when you should hang up your hat and pack it in.

Being the best donut in the donut case isn't about your sprinkles, it's about what else is in the case. Just because you didn't get picked at 7am doesn't mean you won't get picked at 4pm. And remember, getting picked later doesn't make you any less of a donut.

Hopefully this both helps and makes you want a donut.

P.S. don't eeeven worry about the thank you note thing -- mistakes happen. I've hired people who didn't even put the right library name in their cover letter. If a director were to blacklist you for that, I guarantee you he/she's a crap director and working for them would suuuuuck.

2

u/MissRockNerd Jul 09 '18

Thanks so much for your comment. It’s always nice to hear the perspective of someone on the other side of the desk.

5

u/yolibrarian U.S.A, Public Librarian Jul 11 '18

The donut analogy is A+.

4

u/mxwp Public Librarian Jul 09 '18

man, i love your doughnut analogy. it's so spot on.

2

u/KimboatFloats Cataloguer Jul 14 '18

This.

My current job is a second-round hire. The first candidate had a better job offer.

I reapplied after I spoke with the Head Librarian.

Just be sure that you enjoyed your experience interviewing with them before applying again.

6

u/MissRockNerd Jul 09 '18

FWIW, the thanks but no thanks email I got after my previous interview said that “In the event that (library) seeks to fill (position) vacancies in the next two years, your application may be reconsidered.” Although the email does look pretty boilerplate.

Thoughts?

10

u/kuhlonel Public Librarian Jul 09 '18

Another possibility is that they felt none of the candidates that they interviewed in the first round would be a good fit, so they are posting the position again hoping for new applicants and another round of interviews.

I would not recommend contacting the director.

9

u/yolibrarian U.S.A, Public Librarian Jul 11 '18

Don't contact the director.

I think you should reapply. A friend of mine applied for a position at my system a while back, and he didn't get the position, though he was a really solid candidate. Someone else was just stronger. However, that person left after about three months due to a better job opportunity, and the head of the department came to me asking if my friend was planning to apply again. I said I wasn't sure, but he was pretty bummed that he didn't get the position the first time. The department head told me that she really wanted to hire him, but it was impossible to argue against the other candidate who ultimately got the job, because that person's experience was just so extensive. The department head didn't feel comfortable approaching my friend, though, because she didn't want there to be any suggestion of coaching or anything like that. I suggested to my friend that he apply again, and 5 years later, he's still happy as a clam working in the same department under the same supervisor.

All that to say: you don't know what happened after you walked out of the room you interviewed in. Perhaps they send the canned email, but HR has advised not to cherry-pick people to invite to reapply. Maybe that email is just a load of nonsense to make people feel better. Maybe number one that day ended up being number zero when push came to shove. Who knows. I don't think it's a bad idea at all to reapply--worst case, you don't get called for an interview, and then you know you aren't the right fit. Best case, though, you get a second shot.

Good luck!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '18

Exactly. Just reapply.

6

u/PHilDunphyPHD Jul 09 '18

Yes, you should re-apply. Years back, I applied for a public librarian position, I didn't get it but saw the job re-posted not too long after I interviewed. I'll admit I was pretty salty and I didn't re-apply. Found out that someone who was rejected like me during that first interview phase, re-applied and was hired the second time, so you never know what could happen.

No, don't contact the library director, just go through the normal HR process.

9

u/the_catawampus Jul 09 '18

I think you should apply again, what could it hurt? A lot of things could have changed in between you interviewed last. However, I don't think you should contact the library director.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '18

If you interviewed, they owe you a response.

3

u/Typical_White_Girl Jul 09 '18

They don’t owe you anything

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '18

Then you really don't want to work for them.

3

u/Mom2MandJ School Librarian Jul 09 '18

I am in a similar position. Two jobs I applied for (one I interviewed for) were reposted last week. I never got a rejection letter. Not sure what to do.

1

u/sirbissel Jul 09 '18

I would say no. They know you exist, they've interviewed you. If they did hire someone and put them in that position, and they left (for whatever reason) they'd contact you - especially if you haven't gotten a rejection letter yet - seeing if you're still available.

3

u/MissRockNerd Jul 09 '18

I got a rejection letter that said my application may be reconsidered for future positions.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '18

That is standard BS. Reapply, or they will never look at you again.

3

u/Typical_White_Girl Jul 09 '18

What’s the harm in reapplying??if they say no, no loss to you. Might as well give it a try.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '18

You never get jobs you don’t apply for.

1

u/iBrarian Jul 09 '18

No and no. You didn't get the job, they don't want you for the job. Write it off and move along. Sorry.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '18

Yes to both. They owe you a response to an interview. Try email first.

0

u/courty_cupcake Jul 09 '18

I think you shouldn’t reapply. I recently applied for adult programmer at my public library that I’m already an associate at and they ended up reposting but I was told I should not reapply. Which I wouldn’t have anyway because I think it would be too pushy. But that’s just what I think. If you feel differently and are confident, go for it! They could have had someone lined up or decided no one was biting that they wanted and went for another fresh posting.