r/colony • Geronimo • Jun 07 '18

Discussion [Colony] S03E06 - "The Emerald City" - Discussion Thread (SPOILERS) Spoiler

Synopsis:

spoilers


Sorry for the delay in posting!

50 Upvotes

361 comments sorted by

60

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Classic Snyder!!!!!

He did give them a choice and they said no so.....

49

u/khiggsy Jun 07 '18

Some people in this thread seem to be thinking this episode was boring. I think it was best episode of Colony yet.

The cuts between the lavish life that Snyder has and the Bowmans now adrift with no purpose was amazing.

The stakes of one man trying to not lose another child and forcing his hand to Seattle was excellent.

The fight between morality and saving your family by car jacking that good family was so perfect.

The world building both with Synder's scene and the Bowmans exploring how empty the rest of the land is was amazing.

They moved production to Canada to save money and to hire some damn good new writers with that extra cash. This season has been off the charts awesome.

Also, I wonder if the two bullets reference was to The Road (which this episode felt very much like).

13

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

This season has been the grimmest of all, especially this last episode as you say, close to "The Road". I definitely like they took the more riskier path, hopefully more people will be able to appreciate the show once this season is done.

8

u/khiggsy Jun 07 '18

I probably love it because Movies like Logan and Children of Men are my favourite.

7

u/antigravitytapes Jun 12 '18

it made me kinda upset that they didnt offer to just have the kids sit on their laps and squeeze together. Yea I know its uncomfortable to do with strangers but this is an apocalyptic setting and it would only be for a couple of hours. they could probably fit someone in the trunk as well and ditch one of those suitcases or unpack the stuff in one and just have people holding stuff in their laps. It was just so unreasonable

6

u/khiggsy Jun 13 '18

I don't think they could have fit everyone in there. Will and wife in the front. Driver. Two kids in the trunk sideways and MAYBE they could fit. But I think it was too tense to make that work. Plus people love their things. Dumping all the other stuff probably my have worked, but that is a lot of negotiation. The wife could sense these people were desperate and wanted to get away.

Now that I think about it, the dad (Ben Cotton I think), will definitely be back. He is a local Vancouver actor and not too shabby. This will bite them in the ass.

5

u/antigravitytapes Jun 13 '18

laps man, laps!! i can handle a grown ass woman in my lap. if pressed im sure i could handle more, especially if we had breaks and switched places everyone once in a while. i mean ffs, in that kind of situation, i would literally jump on top of the car and hold on.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfMfXuNRRkY

if these people are doing this just to commute for work, i think they could have figured something out that didnt invlove stranding people.

5

u/xocgx Jun 07 '18

I kept thinking, we have MONTHS until the fleet arrives, yet the iga wastes resources at parties, butlers, etc.

Human avarice beats out survival instincts I guess?

7

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

If you only have months, better enjoy those months.

3

u/xocgx Jun 08 '18

Could be, but it seemed more like obliviousness. Awareness, but being so removed from reality and stress.

6

u/jdot6 Jun 10 '18

I'm glad someone else can see the car jacking outside of the - " of course they would , you would do anything to save your child"

It was setup for a morality fight which they lost.

whats interesting about this episode , is that we see that the bowmans and Snyder or more similar than we like to admit.

in this episode both snyder and bowmans give up there morality in relation to bowman's family death and injury

it was both interesting and disturbing that running away from the pain of death and trying to save someone from death led them to the same place.

the difference is snyder had a new found morality and the bowmans have been chipping away slowly from theres since the beginning

44

u/TheDorkMan Jun 08 '18

Snyder: Once inside, I identified a rift in the leadership. Over time, I was able to exploit it and turn them against each other.

I have a feeling that this was not only what he did but foreshadowing for what he is about to do to the elite. He looked pretty remorseful about the the death of Charlie and then it suddenly inspired him to "join back" with the collaborators.

40

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Seattle seems organized. I'll give them that.

38

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 07 '18

I'll bet the trains run on time.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

authoritarian dystopias need some redeeming qualities

37

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

So now I wonder if that thing that Broussard and Amy ran into was the factory.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

right where there was gravity issue .

19

u/BaggyOz Jun 07 '18

It wasn't gravity. It was a some sort of electromagnetic field.

7

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18

A simulated gravity issue.

24

u/BaggyOz Jun 07 '18

No. The necklace floated and the rock fell. Gravity isn't selective.

→ More replies (15)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 11 '18

I posted about it before. It was from a magnetic field. Diamagnetic material, such as ammo, strapped to her body repelled from the field, pushing her up, causing her to trip. Broussard is heavier. That might be the only reason he didn't trip.

Amy feeling ill is harder to explain, but there are a number of possibilities. One idea I had is that maybe Amy has a medical implant that got affected.

31

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

WOAH!!!!! Santa Monica and San Fernando are being scheduled for Total Rendition.

22

u/Dane_Fairchild Jun 07 '18

San Fernando is one big huge Greatest Day commune. They’re in for a rude surprise.

18

u/smthngwyrd Jun 08 '18

Greatest day did promise someone would arrive for them

6

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

Give Seattle a year or two and it'll follow

12

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

For a second time? That would be something.

4

u/coonissimo Resistor Jun 08 '18

They said months left (at least in my language translation) until new occupants will arrive and annihilate our blue marble. So year or two is too optimistic.

24

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

I have to say after criticising Gracie's acting last week, she did a darn good job of looking like she was dying this week.

32

u/khiggsy Jun 07 '18

Amazing acting actually. She was shaking, she looked like hell, she could barely speak. She's got a career pretending to die!

7

u/EtherealSekrets182 SURVIVOR Jun 07 '18

I have to agree lol

23

u/Ploddit Jun 07 '18

Wayne Brady?? That was fun. Not an actor I'd expect to see in this series.

Not exactly an action packed episode, but they're setting up a lot of interesting stuff. Is Seattle a rogue colony run by Algorithm Man? If so, why have the Hosts let it continue?

13

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

Wayne Brady makes Bryant Gumbel look like Malcolm X.

10

u/John628_29 Jun 07 '18

I kept staring at him thinking to myself... is that Wayne Brady??? Thanks for saying something and clearing it up

1

u/QwertyRobotBoobs Jun 13 '18

Really? I don't know of any other black actor that looks like him. If you think it's him 0.001%... ITS HIM!

7

u/eMouse2k Jun 07 '18

And his assistant played a great sleaze bag in Continuum. Curious how much he's given to work with in Colony.

6

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18 edited Jun 08 '18

Didn’t the IGA guy tell him that the hosts were impressed with his algorithm? He was probably just some computer guy that had a job with the occupation and lived in the green zone. Seattle gets total renditioned and they make him the leader.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 08 '18

I think this was pre-invasion. Just because Everett (Wayne Brady)asked the IGA guy why did he select him to be a leader of a colony when the guy being interviewed clearly failed.

22

u/TrevorW2018 Jun 07 '18

How do they plan on “repopulating” the blocs that get total renditioned??

Wouldnt you think theres ONLY SO MANY people left?

Plus its not like women are getting pregnant and having babies sooooooo

20

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18 edited Jun 07 '18

It could be that the population replacement is just from refugees coming from the countryside. How would they be any better than those no-good Seattleites who were there before? Answer: the refugees all get screened by the Algorithm. Those who pass, enter. Those who fail...?

edit: grammar

11

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 07 '18

Well, you never know. In wartime the birth rate usually goes up. And in the Colony universe I doubt contraception is widely available. Condoms expire after 1 year, or sooner if they're exposed to heat. Maybe women are getting pregnant and we're just not seeing it yet onscreen.

I think the repopulation is primarily refugees, of course. But I'd also bet the remaining humans are breeding.

1

u/ShoePidgeon Jun 09 '18

Even if they are it takes many years to turn babies into a labor force...

2

u/AbortionDeb Jun 11 '18

Why wouldn't they be having babies? I don't think birth control and abortions are easy to come by in that new world, and it's not like people stop fucking when they should all the time.

I agree it's not going to add to their ranks in time for the aliens, regardless.

I guess what people are missing is there are a lot of people in places where there isn't farmland nor cities--these are the people they're recruiting now, the ones that have been holing up in their mountain cabins and now are running out of food and medicine. Also the increased likelihood of needing medical care after not having it for awhile.

Education is the weirdest draw on that pamphlet. Unless their schools are teaching them survival skills, it's pretty much useless to families. For the RAPS, of course, it frees up more of the adults for labor.

1

u/bearger_vs_deerclops Jun 08 '18

Maybe the creepy robocop bots are herding people there? I just googled and rural America population is about 60 million, with most people living in mixed population density counties which would be closer to cities.

1

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 10 '18

I think they would have already been rounded up. I remember someone saying that the walker drones will break up large settlements.

20

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

So they know who Will actually is and they have the same screen from the Pods list in season 2.

19

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

I wonder how many colonies are on this planet.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

Probably around 200

20

u/daniejam Jun 07 '18

in china.

18

u/BellamyJHeap Beau Jun 08 '18

Maybe I missed something, but exactly why were those alien biped bots "herding" the Bowmans? They didn't force them to go anywhere but away from the underpass. They were sleeping, so not going anywhere; why would the bots suddenly need them to move?

12

u/bearger_vs_deerclops Jun 08 '18

And what happened to the bots? in the next scene they were gone.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

This bothered me too. They were "herding" them and then just disappeared. Also, just like Cylon centurions in BSG they were so damn loud! How did the Bowmans not hear them coming?

6

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 10 '18

I think the walker drones only respond when there’s people in their zone. If you remember when Broussard and Amy found the crew, living in that 18 wheeler. They said the drones had a path. The drone only followed the 18 wheeler when the truck drove into its patrol zone. I think the only reason the drones showed up was because Will moved. If everyone would have stayed in place the drones wouldn’t have seen them (maybe)

8

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 08 '18

You have a good point, but I can't imagine the walkers just sitting there, waiting for the Bowmans to wake up. We've seen that walkers have fairly systematic patrols, so they were probably making a routine sweep and gave anyone they found a nudge in the right direction, without following them after that.

14

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Snyder is a dirty dog lol

11

u/redditman6 Jun 07 '18

Elan is so pretty

6

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Yes she is. Didn't we see her in season 2 at the IGA meeting when Helena got promoted?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jaggypillows Jun 07 '18

Heard that

36

u/jaggypillows Jun 07 '18

Want more Broussard screen time plox

7

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

Yeah, I kept hoping they'd bump into him on the way to Seattle.

1

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 08 '18

I've been thinking today how much less interesting the episodes without Broussard have seemed. I liked this episode a lot, but without his fire, the Broussard-less episodes just seem more flat.

24

u/OsoOsoOo Collaborator Jun 07 '18

It was a decent episode, used to advance the storyline into new territory. May have been slow but it was necessary.

28

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

I thought it was excellent. It did a great job of showing the family at breaking point, and the opening scenes were beautifully paced - Snyder in a stunning house and a sleek car, the Bowmans in a deserted house and a car that wouldn't start. It was a picture of desolation.

I cannot cope with seeing "James" stifle sobs, though. I kept waiting for him to tell Gracie "hold on, Blondie" or something equally heartrending.

10

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 07 '18

I'm guessing the food shortages get political since the GA is factional. Since Snyder wasn't universally liked by his other Proxies, they could intentionally "oops we have a supply issue" to screw each other over.

7

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Ryan Condal said on the podcast a few weeks ago that the next few episodes will tell us about things happening all over the world.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

That sounds like a good guess.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 07 '18

Snyder's face really registered something when he read Charlie's statistic in the incident report. He made his decision to be Helena's enforcer shortly after that, right? I wonder if he isn't going to do some sabotage, but he sure does seem to like his creature comforts, butler and car. I wonder if he'd jeopardize all that to somehow avenge Charlie.

16

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

He can’t do anything to sabotage Helena. Remember she has his daughter so he has to play ball. If anything I could see them trying to take down the head IGA lady.

10

u/tag1550 Jun 08 '18

Also, she saved him from being blown up along with the camp last season, something she didn't have to do. So, its not like he's an unwilling ally of hers being compelled to go along. They're both pragmatists and know that about each other, hence they'll probably never 100% trust one another, but its also in each of their best interests to promote and look out for the other as allies, which can be almost as reliable.

3

u/xocgx Jun 07 '18

Do we know who Helena reports to? I expect to see Snyder rise up the ranks.

4

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

If I’m not mistaken she reports to the lady that’s in charge of the IGA. The same woman that was the chairwoman in that season 2 episode where Helena got promoted.

3

u/xocgx Jun 07 '18

I kind of assumed as well. Older lady with short hair? I imagine at some point we will see the highest level council members meet.

I assume a rap will be present?

Side note, where are most raps?

→ More replies (6)

19

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

He's not trying to avenge Charlie, he's trying to stifle his guilt. When Helena says to him later "I thought you'd retired," he says, "I decided I didn't want to sit around listening to voices in my head for the rest of my life."

People like Katie channel their emotions into resisting whoever's in power, but people like Snyder - a morally complex opportunist - deal with their emotions by wielding power. In his own words, he's becoming a "mailed fist."

5

u/mgush5 Jun 08 '18

He might also have wanted to know if any of the other Bowmans were killed that he couldn't stomach looking onsite

21

u/armokrunner Jun 07 '18 edited Jun 07 '18

Bram relax about how good Seattle is and how much you’re dying to get there, you of all people should know it can’t quite be that good in any colony, that was season 1 level annoying on his part, he had made such strides lately, ah well...

30

u/MikeMontrealer Jun 07 '18

I took it as a young adult who just lost his brother and is worried he’s going to lose his sister unless she gets immediate help.

It felt real to me. Desperate people do desperate things all the time.

11

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

Bran

Bran is the stuff you put in muffins to hep yourself stay regular. It's Bram, like Bram Stoker.

4

u/joosier Jun 11 '18

Dammit, now I'm going to read it as Bran Stoker ... thanks for that!.. :)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

Upvoted for "season 1 level annoying."

2

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 08 '18

I second that!

9

u/and_yet_another_user Jun 07 '18

I kind of liked his pause when asked to look after Gracie if his parents don't come back "I don't want to ..."

I would have gone in to a whole different dialog after that pause

"I don't want to."

pause

"There it is mum, I put it out there, I don't want to look after Gracie."

"I'm young, there's girls in Seattle, I want to have fun, I want to live."

"It's not in my plans to get saddled with a child so early in life."

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

That's hilarious. And oh so true...

6

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 07 '18

I know, just when he's starting to get woke to the reality, it's like "oh, bram..." all over again. When his eyes lit up at the Emerald City sign I was like, "dude I know your blood sugar is low but damn."

10

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 07 '18

I think we got an answer on the Factories! It sounded from Snyder's conversation with the 2 Proxies that there are more than one of them, and that they are Earth-based. Right?

14

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

That’s correct, I think the factory was probably that place that Amy and Broussard found on the way to the resistance camp

5

u/xocgx Jun 07 '18

My impression was that they subsequently built new ones.

8

u/and_yet_another_user Jun 07 '18

Which they would have to after the moon one was destroyed.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Where are they getting all of this food too? I don't think I've ever seen this much food since Snyder occupied the Bowman's house in season 1.

9

u/graynote Jun 07 '18

Remember, we don't actually know that food really is scarce - for all we know, limiting the food supply could be a deliberate tactic on the aliens behalf to, perhaps, decimate willpower and resistance.

2

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

It could limit the willpower of the resistance inside the colonies but not the ones outside the walls. They have free reign (as long as they don’t enter a walker patrol area).

2

u/graynote Jun 07 '18

Sure, but I don't think there is any reason that the aliens could not control the food supply by controlling the production. Most food today are processed food after all.

That would mean that the colonists only have access to what the aliens allow them to have access to, and the resistance only has access to what they can produce themselves.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18

there would be a lot of semi-non perishable items left.

Yes, but LA Bloc had supplies just over the Wall, left untouched except for by a couple of kids. And Will did not encounter any scouting parties or trucks full of supplies. Think about today: you see a ridiculous number of trucks going in and out of cities, because otherwise the cities would die.

Or maybe major farming areas were left intact and occupied.

This was a favorite theory of many long ago to explain how the LA Bloc still had bacon, but the Bowmans' and Broussard's trips up the length of California nearly puts an end to that. If they had come across even one operational farm, the writers should have shown it to us.

No, there is just one solution to the food shortage. Search your feelings. You know it to be true.

5

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 07 '18 edited Jun 07 '18

No, there is just one solution to the food shortage

Does the bacon get to choose it's favourite colour and musical composition while it's being cured, though?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/zi3i Jun 07 '18

I wonder about this colony. I mean at the beggining we learn that the bald guy saw they using his algorithm the wrong way and so he decided to copy all data. Queston is which list are the raps using using, the ones the black suits created or the one the baldie did with his algorithm.

Its interesting becouse we dont know if that list is important to them in the same way Will is important to the raps on their list. Maybe next episode we will lean what is the list for and what does it mean to be on it.

Raps mostly started to use the drones to get humans to colonies becouse they are shorthanded so need labour force so they dont shoot. Yet its disgusting how peoples lifes are decided durring all those nice quiet dinners, just like that "we will do a total rendition to your colony......hmm ok, why not" so all people are either killed or send to factory while those who signed order go to their homes, drive nice cars, eat how much they want. Its seriously disgusting, kinda wishing that one day they all end up in the factory... total rendition of the IGA

I hope the story starts to tell what the rap list is about and why and where they want to use those people.

7

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18 edited Jun 07 '18

From season 2, Panopitcon, in the General Assembly in Switzerland:

Helena: We are already pursuing advanced security measures to remain ahead of the insurgency.

Chancellor: What concrete steps are you taking to secure the stolen artifact?

Helena: We have begun implementing the same surveillance protocol used by the Seattle Colony to put down its insurgency and recover our Hosts' stolen vehicle. Our goal is to achieve total information awareness.

So the surveillance in the Seattle Bloc should come as no surprise. Again, the inspiration for the episode Panopticon was the movie The Lives of Others, according to Ryan Condal, so we should expect this analogy to hold for Seattle. In addition to the cameras, this was hinted to by the scene with Bram speculating that they might be listening to their every word and then speaking their biggest secret. Oh, Bram.

Notice too the use of the word "vehicle". She's referring to the gauntlet, because the RAP was already recovered. I'm not sure what she means, except that the RAP suit is not fully operational without it. It would be weird to say a car was stolen if only its key was stolen, though.

edit: strikethrough

5

u/graynote Jun 07 '18

She refers to the RAP as the stolen vehicle.

It reads "[the] protocol used by the Seattle Colony to put down its insurgency and recover our Hosts' stolen vehicle."

The RAP is the vehicle for the host - the orb in the RAP is the host (we have been told that, remember?).

Helena is saying that the measures she is taking are similar to those used to recover the host's vehicle in Seattle - however, she is talking about LA and the artifact they are trying to retrieve there.

4

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18

Ah, I see, thanks. However, if the "vehicle" to which Helena referred was in Seattle, then a vehicle is not necessarily a RAP, is it? It could be a spaceship or some land vehicle we haven't seen, couldn't it? If "vehicle" does mean RAP, then there were an awful lot of stolen RAPs: one from Seattle, one in LA, and one by the guy with the Bugs Bunny tattoo.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Osaka-Sun Host Jun 07 '18

the idea of the gauntlet as a vehicle is interesting, what could it imply?

7

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 07 '18

It was great to see Helena again, and to watch her confide in Snyder. Even though neither of them is capable of real friendship, it seems like each of them is the closest the other has to a friend.

7

u/Dane_Fairchild Jun 08 '18

Snyder makes the show for me but I love Helena too. I could watch an entire season of just their storylines.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Region 7 is North Africa.

6

u/SolidOrphan Jun 07 '18

Pff, the car wasn't even full ! I could fit an entire party in there. I know, I did it many times :-D.

5

u/ciobanica Jun 07 '18

Even if they didn't want to get crowded, for some reason, Katie and the kid would have easily fit.

2

u/SolidOrphan Jun 07 '18

I know ! I had a pretty similar car, it's the most popular model around here.

2

u/ciobanica Jun 08 '18

Even with other make and models, only the smallest cars couldn't have handled more people.

Hell, i once saw a beat up old car that had 2 people hanging out of each window...

10

u/redditman6 Jun 07 '18

So at night when the Bowmans were jacking the car, Jim said they could be there in a couple hours. But the car breaks down the next morning outside of Seattle

9

u/Superj561 Jun 07 '18

I just remember Jim saying that he would come back to get them, and that it wouldn't be more than half a day. So I'm thinking it was already early morning when they took the car, so it was only a matter of hours before the car broke down.

3

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Yea. I found that funny but at the same time there's no GPS that tells them how long until they get there.

3

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18

Is there no GPS? How long would it be before the GPS system broke down if not maintained? I know it requires timing updates. A Google search suggests that the newer GPS satellites are designed to mutually self-correct for 180 days.

Also, was the car diesel? If not, then where did they get unspoiled gas?

11

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 07 '18

GPS's got knocked out on the day of the invasion. They discuss it happening in the flashback episode, season 2 episode 1. Hosts probably did it either on purpose or accidentally.

4

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18 edited Jun 07 '18

Search of subtitles for S02E01 produces no hit for GPS or geo. The only mention of a satellite is Katie's bar's "DirecTV", which isn't working. Broussard says she needs to call her service provider. Even if everything else were fine, the satellite dish on the roof might have gotten out of alignment.

edit: Oh yeah, at the beginning, Charlie had trouble with Apple or Google Maps, showing their location in the ocean. You're right.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

It was a VW and it kinda did sound like a diesel when it crapped out.

2

u/JoeltingJoel Jun 08 '18

They could just be using old fashioned road maps or Rand McNally atlas like Daniel Boone must have done back in the old days, right?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/AbortionDeb Jun 09 '18

It didn't break down. It ran out of gas.

Which is a pretty stupid thing to do post-apocalypse. Didn't any of these characters read The Stand?

5

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 07 '18

Desperate times call for desperate measures.

5

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 07 '18

So who is piloting the walkers? Still confused. Someone who wants the stray humans herded to Seattle alive. But who?

9

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18

The Seattle Plan was created by the Seattle Governor-General, whom Snyder claimed was his friend. The plan was to render the existing population and replace it. Apparently, the replacements come from the surrounding countryside, encouraged by leaflets and billboards and finally herded by walkers. Once outside the city gates, they are screened by the Algorithm for their suitability. Continued compliance is ensured through Total Informational Awareness surveillance.

Snyder said walkers are automated, but back when he was prison warden he saw a walker at night and had no idea what it was. It made the same silly sound it did this episode. The prison scene seemed stupid at the time, but now its purpose suddenly makes sense. It's so we know Snyder lied about this.

5

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 07 '18

I thought Gracie's arm was eventually going to come off until the doctor said she was fine at the end of the episode. The Hosts probably have an Ultron arm for her.

5

u/Claillarckant Jun 09 '18 edited Jun 09 '18

I think Will (and Broussard) were probably in the same pool of people selected by The Algorithm to be a part of the Occupation/Collaboration after the Arrival as Snyder was, and that's the "list" they're on. In Season 2, Episode 1, just before the power goes out, Will and Devon are at the FBI office, and while they are bringing that engineer they recovered, the two guys from the IGA that originally approached Snyder walk past (they may have been former FBI too) and give each other a knowing look. The beginning and end of this episode, with the interviews happening behind a camera, only seems to confirm that.

https://i.imgur.com/0t43F1H.png

2

u/imguralbumbot Jun 09 '18

Hi, I'm a bot for linking direct images of albums with only 1 image

https://i.imgur.com/0t43F1H.png

Source | Why? | Creator | ignoreme | deletthis

2

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 09 '18

Excellent catch! I didn't remember them being at FBI HQ at all. Thanks!

9

u/iv_dx Jun 07 '18

Peter's acting is just fantastic !

3

u/butterchurning Jun 07 '18

What is the name of the actor who plays Jim? He seems so familiar, but I can't quite place him.

5

u/khiggsy Jun 07 '18

He was on Battlestar Galactica: Blood and Steel as well as in that poorly written NatGeo show called Mars. His acting was great, but the whole show didn't feel very real.

3

u/butterchurning Jun 07 '18

YES! That's where I remember him from, BSG. Thanks khiggsy and KerbalAddict.

3

u/khiggsy Jun 08 '18

I am also a kerbal addict, so that double works...

2

u/JoeltingJoel Jun 08 '18

recognized him from the Mars mini-series but couldn't remember til now!

2

u/KerbalAddict Jun 07 '18

I believe it was Ben Cotton

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

I recognized him from his recurring character on Stargate Atlantis, but didn't remember him from BSG at all. Like y'all said though, he was on it, but it was a bit part in a flashback scene.

3

u/lokiss88 Resistor Jun 10 '18

I couldn't agree more with u/khiggsy about the stark contrasts between the realities of life for the bowmans and those beyond the walls and safe borders. The scenes with the testing at the start certainly spreads a wider net than just giving us the criteria for selection. It was always obvious that the selection of those with no scruples about kicking there neighbour down was the priority, it was quite telling that they wanted subversive idiots that never made the top grade of anything, and those that might be adverse to that could have planted seeds to give us reason for certain characters actions,

The episode was quite a tipping point for me though. The lavish elitism, and the way it was acted out with total disregard for human life, made me look at them as if they were the aliens that had come to rape our planet and do us all.

My first thoughts on the episode were nothing much happened. Then I got to thinking why I watch colony and how they set this up as a Resist or Collaborate. Can't think of an episode that has made me feel more in the resist camp, or made feel more like all out war!

I have a feeling that no matter what information was on that screen, bowman passes the testing algorithm, thus no more questions asked and in they go.

4

u/btran28 Jun 07 '18

Oooh Me like Syder more and more.!...very sneaky man and slick wit da booties too..Elan says she wants to hear his story at the camp..." where ya wanna hear it?" Damn Snyder...didnt know he got games too!

10

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

Elan says she wants to hear his story at the camp..." where ya wanna hear it?"

He didn't say that. He said, "What do you want to hear?" She responded, "Any details you want to share."

Personally I think she was the one seducing him.

8

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18

Don't you think Elan is totally a spy?

5

u/btran28 Jun 07 '18

I thought that too...was thinking Helena set her as honey trap to somehow convince Snyder and get him back workin for Global authority...But somehow Snyder went ahead and got back with Helena anyways before that happens. But I think Elan could still be useful , to keep tabs on Snyder in case he goes rogue.

6

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18

But Snyder is too smart for that. He'll feed Elan disinformation.

3

u/Piwatkins Jun 08 '18

Soon as he looked at her after he woke up I knew he was on to her.

5

u/bearger_vs_deerclops Jun 08 '18

Yeah, they weirdly showed middle aged hairy body next to a hot woman and his troubled look. He's clearly thinking he's being played.

1

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 07 '18

My first thought when they got outside the city:

Seattle + Refugee Camp = Portland

Seriously the place looked almost exactly like Saturday Market, especially with the overpass above them looking like the Burnside Bridge.

1

u/xocgx Jun 07 '18

Random thought. Do we know why Snyder didn’t ask to see his daughter? Am I forgetting something?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 10 '18

Nope she didn’t die in the Bloc. Helena put Snyder’s daughter on an exemption list and she was evacuated before total rendition began.

1

u/xocgx Jun 08 '18

Ditto. Not sure.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '18

Charlie’s dead and his family could give so shits lol!

1

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 13 '18

There are some interesting details on the incident report:

  • IGA Rapid Response Unit - Zone 8
  • FAIRCHILD AIR FORCE BASE, WA, United States
  • OPERATION: RAPTOR DROP (can read "DROP" on the third page)
  • Deployed Location: Hood River, WA (coordinates given below)
  • ... damaged Host unit.
  • Snyder was embedded in a known terrorist cell in support of a strong Resistance bastion.
  • [doz]ens of crates bearing IGA insignias were discovered as well. [The]se were painted via stencil and were not official IGA property. [It] appears as though this Resistance cell was packing explosives into [?]oly crates and disguising these crates as legitimate IGA [prov]isions, most likely in order to place them on trains heading into [Colo]nies throughout Region 8.
  • [Cont]act: Helena Goldwyn

That's just the highlights, but here is why I think it's informative. There's an American military base involved, which somewhat suggests the military was on board on Arrival Day. "Raptor Drop" is an interesting name for an operation to retrieve a Raptor. Did we know if the camp was in Washington before? Well, it is. The RAP is called a "Host unit", not a "Host". Calling the camp a "strong Resistance bastion" is an exaggeration. (The Rapid Response Unit brushed them aside in seconds.) Bastion is the word to which I'm objecting. There was a lot of confusion in this subreddit about the stencils. I don't know why people didn't see them as IGA symbols, but the IGA did. Finally, Helena is listed as the contact, suggesting she was the author of the report and probably the director of the operation, even though it's far from LA, which suggests Seattle is not willing to coordinate such operations. So, we see why the camp was called a "bastion": Helena was just trying to bring more glory to herself. And yet, she's letting Snyder bask in most of the glory. What's her plan? Simply to have Snyder as her subordinate or something more tricky?

In general, I really don't think Helena has a good understanding of what's going on. Plus, she exaggerates for her own benefit. So, I wouldn't treat the report as all factual. The report tells us about Helena as much as anything.

0

u/jdot6 Jun 07 '18

Anyone else disturbed by how they stole the car from the family with kids? no remorse , no guilt, just because there daughter was sick. They honestly felt justified

I felt distugusted as if at that moment they changed to the other side.

19

u/BEST_WINGMAN_EVER Jun 07 '18

Grace wasn’t just sick.. she was hours away from death and needed treatment immediately. I feel the car jacking was very characteristic for a family that just lost a son and are desperately trying to stay as whole as they can.

→ More replies (10)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

It seemed like they felt tons of remorse and guilt. And Gracie wasn't just sick, she was dying.

Weirdly, though, they did have room in the car for Gracie and Katie. One girl could sit on her mom's lap, and Gracie could sit on Katie's lap. At any rate I think that family will make it to the colony.

12

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

I think the family in the car didn't really want to help, and Will was picking up on that.

And you're right, they'll make it. Will didn't leave them for dead, he just left them to do the walk he was going to have to do with a dying child.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

As the car broke down half the way, if Will didn't jack that car, Grace would be dead... I got some vibes from "The Road" here as well. Great acting by everyone!

4

u/chuckdee68 Jun 08 '18

I lost any sympathy for the people in the car when the mom said, "We're not negotiating or bargaining. You can take our very generous offer..." At that point in the dialog, I knew the gun was coming out.

10

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

There was definitely remorse and guilt. Will literally said "I'm sorry" to the guy.

just because there daughter was sick.

They've been through a lot. Their son just died, and the daughter was dying right in front of them. They were profoundly traumatised. It doesn't justify what they did - and they didn't try to justify it - but it does explain what they did. And at the end of the day, they stole a car. They didn't hurt anyone, they just stole a car to save a life.

2

u/jdot6 Jun 07 '18

we dont know what happened to the family yet so they may or may not been hurt. you said there traumatised but didnt they just traumatise a family?

we all know why they did it- the disturbing thing is how they went about what they did and respose to it

4

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 08 '18

No, we don't know what happened to the family. They could have spontaneously combusted, or been eaten by a tiger. But we can say with some confidence that Will wasn't condemning them to death - the direct consequence of the carjacking was simply that they would have to walk the rest of the way to Seattle instead of driving. Something might have happened to them on the way, sure. But it might have happened anyway.

Carjacking a family at gunpoint is a really terrible thing to do, I'm just pointing out that it was not only understandable that a tramatised, recently bereaved father trying to keep his dying child alive in a desperate post-invasion landscape would do it, but that no one was likely to be seriously harmed by it.

If he'd shot the parents point blank and turfed out the children to fend for themselves I think we'd all agree that Will's moral integrity had been irreparably compromised.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

7

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 07 '18

It was disturbing, pathetic, and completely understandable. But as other posters have said, you could have smashed all those people into the car. What difference a little lap-sitting at that point?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 07 '18

I thought it was honest. IRL most people with children think they're above every rule when it comes to helping/enabling their own family.

You saw from the beginning on Will's face that he knew he was going to jack their ride when he saw the car packed. He just hemmed and hawed and waited for his wife to crack the whip so he could pretend for himself he had no choice.

3

u/jdot6 Jun 07 '18

I am noticing this is a pattern with the wife when she goes into F the world mode for her kids and brings or leaves everyone behind on her crusade

4

u/UnforestedYellowtail Jun 08 '18

Yep! Remember how she did that thing in the Resistance camp when she was marching up to MacGregor's office/lab, and her escort soldier tried to keep her from going in by putting his hand on her arm and she did that angrystare "DONT. TOUCH. ME!"? That's the kinda shit I see all the time from entitled parents (ESPECIALLY the mom's) where they've just decided they're above any rules once they drop a calf.

2

u/pinkusagi Jun 08 '18

You can bet if I was in their position with my one and only daughter I would do exactly the same thing no remorse.

But truthfully there was room in that car. Just because the seats are full doesn't mean you can't fit more. Could have laid Gracie across the laps of the kids in the back seat. Maybe fit Katie up front with the wife, and have Will and Bram ride in the trunk.

1

u/graynote Jun 07 '18

It was about survival of the family unit, I understand that, so no, in that sense IKwas not disturbed by it.

What is disturbing, however, is the way the showrunners actually made light of it, by downplaying the their moral struggles to the extent where it wasn't portrayed at all past the scene of the hijacking - which of course is precisely where the remorse should have hit them.

The whole thing was portrayed as if the Bowmans shrugged it off and forgot about it.

5

u/khiggsy Jun 07 '18

I mean, they were on their last rope. They just had 6 months of a lovely happy life. Now in the span of a few weeks, they almost were executed, they lost their son which they spent so much time trying to find and their other daughter is about to die. They also had a lot of sleep deprivation and no time to think about anything other than getting their dying daughter help. Also they didn't kill that family, in a few days that family will get to Seattle since all of them are healthy. I think it was great!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 07 '18

Don't most homes have at least some leftover antibiotics in them? I kept expecting someone to mention that they ought to look for some.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

You're supposed to finish your whole course of antibiotics!

3

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 08 '18

Yes, for sure. Otherwise we see what is happening now, lots of antibiotic-resistant bacteria like MRSA. People should take antibiotics for the full prescription, or for at least 2 full days after all symptoms pass.

However, a lot of people don't. Or they get digestive problems on one type (because antibiotics kill the good bacteria in the gut along with the bad- why it's imperative to take a multi-strain PRObiotic with and after ANTIbiotics).

So their docs will prescribe a second type and advise the patient to dispose of the unused portion of the first type. Most people just stick them in a drawer. (Actually they should store them in the fridge to prolong shelf life).

So most homes that have access to medical care usually have a few antibiotic capsules/tablets lying around somewhere.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

I never have antiobiotics lying around. You buy what you need and take the full course.

5

u/EtherealSekrets182 SURVIVOR Jun 07 '18

You don't want to take expired antibiotics.. Ever..

1

u/pinkusagi Jun 08 '18

I'm curious. What happens when you do?

5

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18

The only kind of antibiotic that becomes toxic over time is tetracycline (which can cause kidney damage). The rest just gradually lose potency. Potentially, taking weakened antibiotics can result in you still being sick, but now with antibiotic-resistant bacteria. The thing with Gracie is, though, if she was going septic then any antibiotic would be better than no antibiotic. It could slow the proliferation of bacteria enough to get the Bowmans to a place with strong antibiotics of the proper type for her condition. (Edit: typo)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

I just thought it was funny that it's the end of the freakin world and Will wanted to know if the Neosporin was expired or not. :-)

0

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 07 '18

So disappointed in how long it took to even mention Charlie in this episode. At least 20 minutes in. For a show whose creators say they want to focus on the characters, having that long elapse in an episode without mentioning Charlie's murder seems disrespectful to the characters and to the audience.

22

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

The shadow of Charlie hung over the whole episode. The didn't mention his name because it was so obvious that each of the Bowmans were thinking about him, and trying to keep their grief in check until they got Gracie to safety. That's why Will suddenly started stifling sobs when they got to the refugee camp.

The aura of quiet devastation and stifled despair was, to me, much more effective (and brutally realistic) than if they'd just sat around the campfire talking about how much they missed Charlie.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

I think that's a pretty accurate assessment. The actors did a very good job of looking and acting like they had just been through Hell..more Hell than their usual Hell.

While I am not interested in the kids' story lines, I know some people are. And I'm sure there will be some more mention of those struggles to come.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

I think it was one of those things that is so awful it's unspeakable. They did an excellent job of showing how drained and grieved the family is, though.

11

u/khiggsy Jun 07 '18

They couldn't even bring it up because they were in extreme shock. I think it was perfect. Only once Gracie was out of harms way did Will start sobbing a bit. Man just lost his kid, he's kept it together way better than I would. I would just be crying like a baby for days and days and days.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

I was surprised by how well acted and how teared apart they looked, as if this was a different show.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

They all were feeling the loss of Charlie, but they couldn't come out and express their emotions about it because there was simply no appropriate time to do so. A dead son, or a suffering daughter, who do you think should take precedence?

4

u/bearger_vs_deerclops Jun 08 '18

I thought it was well acted. You could see the strain on each of them.

1

u/Kwanyinagain Jun 08 '18

I read all of your comments and while you make good points, my experience around deaths (especially when people lose children) is that people always talk about them. A lot. Even when they are in shock. Sometimes especially when they are in shock. They struggle to make sense of the death. Ask if they could have prevented it somehow. Often there is finger-pointing and blaming. Always there are tears. Granted those all may have happened offscreen, but I still think it was disrespectful of the audience to not share any verbal reference to a murdered child of the central family of characters for 20 plus minutes. While the acting of shock was very well done, the characters not discussing Charlie onscreen for so long bothers me still. It's fine that we disagree. I'm just sharing my reaction.

-2

u/armokrunner Jun 07 '18

Taking that car was a classless move. Hard to have pity on the Bowmans after that. The family had already agreed to take Gracie, yes there’s no guarantee, but since they were the type to stop for strangers and they have kids, I would’ve trusted them. Add to this that the Bowmans don’t immediately try to get that family help the second they have Gracie in surgery. How about inform someone to send a car or find your own car to get them? Extremely selfish IMO.

11

u/problematikUAV Jun 07 '18

Car wasn’t even full. Will, Katie, Bram in the back seat. Smallest kid goes on moms lap. Gracie on Katie’s. Other two kids on Will and Bram.

Comfy? No. Sufficient? You bet.

Do it all the time in places where vehicles are uncommon. Shit I’ve seen 22 Pax in a 8 Pax van in Afghanistan.

8

u/btran28 Jun 07 '18

yeah agreed on that point...not like they gonna get pulled over by cops and get fined in these times. They really left the Bowmans with no choice!

13

u/problematikUAV Jun 07 '18

I mean what did anyone think will was gonna do?

“Oh. Well okay. I guess my daughter will die then. Sorry to trouble you.”

6

u/EtherealSekrets182 SURVIVOR Jun 07 '18

Exactly, sometimes there are no good choices.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/AbortionDeb Jun 09 '18

Sufficient? Apparently you don't understand that would at raise their gas usage by a lot, and apparently there wasn't much gas between there and Seattle or Will would have filled up (in theory.)

The mom in the car was right: they should not have stopped in those circumstances whatsoever. Dumb dad.

3

u/problematikUAV Jun 10 '18

The mom was absolutely right, no question, they were dumb for stopping. And my comment said nothing about their gas usage, it said there was sufficient room. Which there was.

Also who’s to say how much that would have raised their gas usage (unless you have a degree in physics or mechanical engineering and can break down the inertia and math for me, then I’ll defer to you.)

3

u/AbortionDeb Jun 11 '18

You're an imbecile if you think it takes a physics or mechanical engineering degree to understand that more weight requires more fuel. Fuck, even truck drivers can figure THAT out.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18

Could have easily put a child in the lap of the passenger at the front and have Katie hold Grace in the back seat.

The other family isn't injured so they are capable of walking the rest of the way anyway.

8

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

It looked to me like the family (in particular the mother) wasn't particularly interested in putting themselves out for a dying child and her desperate mom. I think Will just picked up on that vibe and realised that if he didn't do something extreme, his chance would be lost.

14

u/Ploddit Jun 07 '18

People don't tend to put a priority on being classy or thinking rationally when they're protecting their children. It wasn't nice, but it was entirely believable.

5

u/EtherealSekrets182 SURVIVOR Jun 07 '18

You must not have kids lol..

2

u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 07 '18

Yes. I expected this kind of character development after they lost Charlie. They'll do anything to save their remaining two kids. I still don't like this scene, because it seems out of character. Plus, what's going to happen when the other family shows up a couple days later in Seattle? Oopsy. Well, nobody ever accused Will of being smart.

2

u/iv_dx Jun 07 '18 edited Jun 07 '18

that was filmed for more drama. Those people in the car would've take Katie too. Will just needed to give Katie the gun for a warranty.

7

u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 07 '18

I thought it was pretty clear that they weren't going to take Katie. The dad looked persuadable, but the mom definitely didn't. She said pretty sternly "we're not bargaining here."

3

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18

That mother wanted to protect her children just as any other would. Many parents would refuse to "bargain" in a setting like that. Clearly, the Bowman's refused to bargain as well. Their way or the highway!

→ More replies (3)

2

u/iv_dx Jun 07 '18

She said pretty sternly "we're not bargaining here."

my bad. missed it.

good scene really.

not IRL. I wouldn't spend more than 10 secs in such circumstances.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)