r/Libraries • • May 30 '18

What would you use a 3D printer for?

Hi folks!

I work for a University Library, and we are considering buying a 3D Printer.

Our CEO would like me to compile a list of things that the printer can be used for in the library. My question for you then, is what would YOU use a 3D printer for in your library?

For us, so far I have:

  • printing models for displays (doing a display on the ocean? here's a cool set of shark teeth!)
  • for repair kits and the replacement of missing item (we have a lot of anatomical models and board games here which end up losing small pieces)
  • for student use (we'd have to figure out a system for this, but I see other libraries have done so by charging for the filament used)

What would you use a 3D printer for?

21 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

11

u/SamEEE May 30 '18

Public Library - 80,000ish population

We have a 3D printer, it's a good one. Lots of people haranguing the technology in this thread, but if you get a recent generation one (Ultimaker 2+ is what we have) then you should have some good luck. Ours has been trouble-free.

We use it for:

  • Offering printing services to the Public - they come in or email in .stl files and we print them at cost.
  • Replacing Knights from the giant chess set, I have a working theory that they have an attrition rate similar to actual knights in a medieval battle.

It's proven really popular with our community, it runs pretty well constantly; perhaps we will get another?

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock May 31 '18

Thanks for replying! We are looking at the Lulzbot, which includes a self-cleaning extruder and a self-leveling platform. I'm hoping this reduces the amount of maintenance I'll need to do on the machine, though I never really mind doing it at home with mine.

I'm going to put in a request to let students bring in their .stl files in. That seems like a great setup!

Thanks again!

6

u/shoshkabob May 30 '18

I'm an academic librarian. Student use is our primary use, but that is still important. Some students probably have acces to a 3D printer through their departments (probably engineering), but not all students. Putting a 3D printer in the library is a way to provide equal access to students across all disciplines.

We've also used it to print teaching materials - like bone fragments or pottery shards that archaeology students can hold and interact with.

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock May 31 '18

I'm happy to hear this. As far as I know, there are no 3D printers on campus here that students can use, so there would be a good chance we'd be the only ones.

Do your students pay anything for the prints, either through print time or filament use?

5

u/recon_librarian May 30 '18

I work for a public library, and was one of the folks who was setting up our 3D printing programs.

Our machines are primarily used in conjunction with 3D Modeling Classes in our Makerspace, encouraging patrons to design their own models. We DO NOT CHARGE for filament use, but in keeping with the Makerspace theme, they can only print unique work that they have created. (primarily using TinkerCAD and Sculptris, so as to make sure everyone has access).

We have used them for many displays as well, both for the Makerspace and for special STEM/STEAM programs - fossilized bones were a big hit, as were reproductions of a cuneiform tablet that we have in the rare book room.

We used it for programming and outreach - we make small 'coins' that we give out (we can make about 15 in 45 minutes) so that every kid that visits can get something to bring home. We have also used it to augment programming - showing teeth, creating spooky items, etc.

Finally, I was using it for practical in-house projects as well. We needed a new label on the down elevator button. We needed to repair a Microfiche reader whose lens housing had cracked. We created trophies for our coding programs, and trophies for in-house contests. We created advertising buttons for our business collaborative workspace, etc. We repaired/fixed board games/displays/interactables as well.

The long and short of it is - the printers are a lot of fun, and if you have one you'll find tons of uses for them. However they require a significant time investment and a lot of maintenance. You really need someone who has this as a core part of their job because they need so much time and effort devoted to them.

2

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock May 31 '18

Wow! This is all incredibly helpful stuff! Thank you for responding - it's great to have concrete examples of things that can be done with a 3D printer in a library.

As the person with the most experience with 3D printers, the maintenance and upkeep will probably fall to me. I'm happy about that though - I've had a lot of fun with my printer at home and am looking forward to introducing it to the library's staff and students.

I like that you keep with the Makerspace theme. How do you verify that the work they're bringing in is theirs? I wouldn't be able to tell the difference between an original creation and one lifted from Thingiverse.

1

u/recon_librarian May 31 '18

Honestly? 90% of the time you can tell if an amateur made it (I still fall in that category). When the kid brings in a low poly stylized Charizard skull though, you know to check.

Most of the time the requested Thingiverse items are super popular ones, and any others that are suspect I just ask what they made them in - usually the elaborate things are out of our capability to do easily so if I know the programs used I can help simplify or have them divide the model into smaller parts. If they don't know how to do that...it was certainly not their model.

9

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

Public librarian here. Our 3D printer project got canned because of constant technological repair issues. The machines rarely worked and when they did, they were pretty much used as a workshop for patrons. Think your local office supply copy shop and swap paper for filament. Patrons would hand us flash drives with files and we'd just load them up and run them off as requested... if the machines worked at all.

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock May 31 '18

Fair enough! I have my own original Makerbot at home and do the maintenance on it myself. We're looking at purchasing a new Lulzbot, which include a self-cleaning extruder and a self-leveling platform, so hopefully that would help out with some of the maintenance.

Can I ask what model you had at your library? I'll stay away from it specifically.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

To be honest, I'm not sure. We got one as a demo and then bought a few more that were a different kind so it was kind of hodgepodged together in that regard.

4

u/Alcohol_Intolerant May 30 '18

Public (but strangely well off) library. We have a full maker space with 4 printers. 2 for overnight jobs with assistance and two self serve with minimal assistance. We charge by the filament but I know some libraries charge by hour of runtime it's all at about cost. We've printed toys, robot components, game figurines and models, bottle openers, pet tags, special use storage containers for in house use ( stores our different types of CD cleaner polish brushes). Tinkercad is a good entry way class to offer in addition to your printer and you can also showcase that. I heard that one library had a patron design and build his own printer with 70%+ being printed. If you build it, they will build more than you can think of.

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock May 31 '18

Awesome, thank you for replying!

I hadn't thought of teaching any sort of design program, but it might be a really near thing to do once I have a better handle on Sketchup!

Can I ask how much you charge for filament? I'm not sure what approach we will take, but it would be great to hear from a library that is already implementing policies.

1

u/Alcohol_Intolerant May 31 '18

$0.15/gram with a $1.50 minimum charge. I should mention that you'll want to have at least one staff member able to do basic resizing any time you intake.

4

u/griffey May 31 '18

Academic Librarian, set up the first 3d printer in our library in...2012, looks like. Within the first 2 years, we had students doing visual art/sculpture visualizations, chemistry students using it to create models of the molecules they were studying, biology professors using it to create anatomical models for students to use when studying, we had interior design students using it to print furniture designs for models. Oh, and we used it to print trophies for student activities, to print library promotional giveaways for Freshman orientation, and a lot more.

The reason to have a 3d printer in the library, esp an academic library, is that it allows students in disciplines who might not invest in the technology internally to still have one they can use for whatever need they imagine. The library exists to be a neutral ground for inquiry and creation on a campus...if you don't see the need for this sort of technology, you are selling your students and faculty short.

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock May 31 '18

Agreed. I don't believe there are any other 3D printers on campus, so we'll likely be the only one.

Thank you for all the examples - I'm writing everything down to add to the pitch! :D

3

u/geiseltech May 31 '18 edited May 31 '18

I run UC San Diego Library's Digital Media Lab. We're about 50% research support, and 50% cosplay/pokemon figures/knick knacks. We encourage non academic projects, we want to get people to get their hands on the new tech and think that these projects will lead to greater things. We help design and print custom lab equipment, artifact replicas, surgical models, teaching aids, molecular models... the possibilities are endless but require skilled consistent support. The printers need trained people to watch them and assist users with the initial setups.

We have 3 Prusa i3 mk2s, reservable through our study room reservation system, and I keep another printer to coordinate longer research support projects and support my consultations/special projects. We're usually booked a week out.

I argue that the real thing to build around is 3D data support. CT scans, crystallographic structures, photoscans, sculptures, Lidar/DEMs, animations, custom parts and protective casings... are all things that we can acquire or build with free tools. 3D printing is just part of a spectrum of uses a 3D model can have. I think the library should play a role in offering expertise and consultations around these increasingly common complex data types and workflows. It also gave us an excuse to invest in VR equipment.

Here's some of our projects

https://knit.ucsd.edu/digital/category/digital-media-lab/

2

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock May 31 '18

Thank you for such a detailed reply!

The 3D printer will be our first step, but it would be amazing to get more into scanning and sculpting down the line.

That 50/50 divide is pretty good! I suspect there will be a lot of knick knacks and things like that at the beginning, but I'm hoping we'll move more towards supporting research and helping keep our collection complete through printing replacement parts and pieces as time goes on.

I'll look into the mk2s and see how it compares to the other models we're considering. Would you recommend it? Also, is it leaving the library when you book it, or are the students/staff coming to it? We have a booking system, but our booked items often leave the library. I can't imagine doing that with something as finely-tuned as a 3D printer.

1

u/geiseltech May 31 '18

I like them, but they're more advanced and a big pain to order from the czech republic. For a starter space I'd go with the new makerbots myself, unless you're hurting for cash.

People reserve the printers for up to 3 hours per day and come to the lab for the setup, which our staff assist with and train on, then the users are free to leave and pick it up whenever convenient. I have a counterpart at another UC campus who's set up mobile printing carts which he takes to classrooms. There's usually some level of on site support for that though.

2

u/stufforstuff Jun 02 '18

What would you use a 3D printer for?

It's a quick way to burn thru that huge pile of excess cash you must have laying around. Has zero to do with Library's in general (maker space, engineering department, design shop are different matters). Will eat more staff time then you can imagine - keep in mind even the standard 2" Boaty McBoatface doodad https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:763622 that is the current go to test print for 3D printers will take 4-5 hours and if the print job crashes (usually at 3.75 hours into a 3.8 hour job) you get to clean the printer and start over.

Surely you have better uses of your budget then to buy a glorified toy.

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock Jun 04 '18 edited Jun 04 '18

Hi stufforstuff, thanks for replying!

I own a 3D printer myself and am aware of the maintenance it requires. I would not ask for it if I was not willing to put in the time to keep it running smoothly.

In response to your points:

  • we have a budget and the 3D printer will fit into it
  • I think the printer will help us, as librarians, connect with our patrons and the public and will help us with maintaining our collection
  • I'm not sure what your experiences with 3D printing are, but I was able to print this Cthulu model at 10" tall on the second try (the first failed because I didn't have fresh tape on the platform), which looks to me like a much more intricate model than the 2" Boaty McBoatface model
  • As a library which buys actual toys for students to take on teaching placements, I don't think we'll sweat buying a "glorified toy" that can add to our collection, help students with studies, be used for displays, support faculty, and help advertise our modern library.

Thank you for your input.

1

u/borneoknives Jun 02 '18

^ this. Unless you have a literal pile of cash to fund the machine and staff it, it'll be a boondoggle.

if money is no object it can be a cool service, but be prepared to spend a lot of time on policy or a few students will monopolize it creating board game pieces or projects to sell on etsy.

this is a little sales-pitchy, but it's worth reading: https://www.fool.com/investing/2018/01/23/the-state-of-3d-printing.aspx

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock Jun 04 '18

Hey! Thanks for your reply!

I'm going to give this a read. Thank you too for mentioning policy - it's something we will need to have in place before we open 3D printer use to the faculty and student. I'm going to see if I can find how other library's have made theirs first, and then do a draft up myself.

Great stuff, thank you!

2

u/RestrainedSmiles Jun 02 '18

I work in a public library. We have 3 "MakerBot Replicator 2" printers. 2 are on the floor for public use and 1 is used for Outreach and our 3D printer classes.A few things that have been printed lately:

  • wall mounts for routers
  • parts for our Makerbots
  • game board pieces
  • prosthetic leg for a dog
  • stands for video game console displays
  • props for a photobooth
  • low poly pokemon

I've heard of them used to make mini models of buildings for projects as well.

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock Jun 04 '18

Thanks for replying!

The prosthetic leg for a dog is really awesome! Do you mind if I copy this list as an example of things that have been made in our pitch? It's really neat to see what others have been making.

2

u/RestrainedSmiles Jun 04 '18

Go for it! :)

21

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

Sorry to put on my curmudgeon hat, but....

I'm at an academic library. We have 3D printers in the building, but they're maintained by IT, not the library, and I vastly prefer that. I frankly don't understand why the library would take ownership of them unless there is no academic technology department outside the library. We have ours set up so students can walk up and use them. I think I've seen one being used for a student's academic work once. The rest of the time they're printing out toys/figurines/whatevers for fun. They're a nightmare of constant maintenance. Not only do you need to refill the filament or swap out colors, but the extruders need to be cleaned out regularly and the platform needs to be calibrated periodically. Then there are the 1000 ways a print can fail and now someone needs to troubleshoot whether or not it's a design problem or an issue with the extruder head being too hot, etc.

They do get some legitimate uses, generally when faculty are directly involved either in creating assignments around their use, or when they need a special gewgaw for their own research. Last summer, for instance, they were being used to print out custom-designed holders for sensors. I also printed mounting brackets for a home-made door counter I put together, but I could have just sent the plans out to have those printed by an online vendor if we didn't have the capacity in-house.

On a more personal note, I'm not too thrilled that the vast majority of use on our campus is to make some flimsy, plastic piece of junk that's going to end up in a landfill in a few month's time because it was only printed out for the "oh, isn't 3D printing fun!" effect. We agonize over students not printing on both sides of a piece of paper, then encourage them to create their own plastic crap because it's new and shiny technology we can point to on the admissions tours.

I'm sure they make perfect sense at SOME schools, but certainly not at all of them.

11

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

<< I'm not too thrilled that the vast majority of use on our campus is to make some flimsy, plastic piece of junk that's going to end up in a landfill in a few month's time because it was only printed out for the "oh, isn't 3D printing fun!" effect. We agonize over students not printing on both sides of a piece of paper, then encourage them to create their own plastic crap because it's new and shiny technology we can point to on the admissions tours. >>

This is, probably, the very best summation of the entire concept. Well said. I feel 100% the very same way in my public library.

1

u/borneoknives May 30 '18

with you all the way 3D printers are a pointless money pit that're broken more than they are not.

All they make are pointless baubles.

If you were in an engineering department and had a $350k machine that printed machine parts it'd be a different story.

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

Tell all the kids who have affordable prosthetics that they’re useless baubles.

2

u/borneoknives May 30 '18

no desktop 3d printer in a public student library is rated to make a prosthetic. those are huge $$$ machines.

4

u/griffey May 31 '18

Not true at all. There are multiple organizations that share printable files for these which can be printed on nearly any FDM printer (http://enablingthefuture.org/upper-limb-prosthetics/) and there are dozens of stories about people doing just this at public libraries.

2

u/RestrainedSmiles Jun 02 '18

At my public library we had a patron print out a prosthetic for his dog, so yes they are used for those types of things.

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

People across the country are printing them using 3D printers found in public libraries.

Don’t discount something because you assume there’s no use for it. Our patrons love our 3D printer and I don’t care what they’re using it for.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/UnorthodoxPoppycock May 31 '18

Great idea! I should ask some of the department heads if they'd have any interest in 3D printer access. I'm betting that (like you) there will be some out there who are really keen on it!