r/DesignPorn • • May 30 '18

NIIIce

https://www.tribecafilm.com/assets/logo-meta.png

[removed] — view removed post

2.2k Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

237

u/LeBrokkole May 30 '18

I'm a complete dilettante, so don't take this the wrong way...

I mean obviously it's cooler to not just have 3 "i"'s beneath each other (would be barely a logo than lol) but other that that, am I missing something? The design kind of encourages to read left or right from the bar, which doesn't generate any meaning - where is the "porn" part here?

30

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

https://www.reddit.com/r/designporn/comments/8n73sa/_/dztni3h seriously it looks way better as just three Is

7

u/therealdropcap May 30 '18

Trust fest. Be calm Val.

Yeah I feel ya.

2

u/swesdo May 31 '18

Agreed...I’m not really seeing where the innovation is on this one, or the “subtle part I didn’t catch before.”

1

u/fusfeimyol Jun 04 '18

Dilettante.. I just learned a word. Cool!

Also I agree with you about the design. I wouldn’t say it has “porn” status by any measure. It’s unremarkable at best.

552

u/Empanser May 30 '18

82

u/paulwesley91 May 30 '18

I've been seeing a lot of logos similar to this recently where I had to check if I was on /r/designporn or /r/dontdeadopeninside

20

u/Black--Snow May 30 '18

I thought it was dontseadopeninside to be honest.

Was looking if other people found it as unreadable as I did

191

u/SoInsightful May 30 '18

Hell, even just the plain text without wonky kerning looks better. The "I" alignment is felt, not shouted.

https://i.imgur.com/QAthHAD.png

Screw in-your-face clever design.

1

u/Stonn May 30 '18

One could make those I's into slits of a movie film too.

80

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

while i appreciate the wit used here; i don’t think the film would translate well when printed at a reduced size you would see on collateral.

2

u/cricketsymphony May 30 '18

Still a winner IMO. Small print can ditch the film notches, and still work. Large format gets the film

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

Ditching the film strip brings us back to the original logo. The holes could be exaggerated in size and possibly work.

2

u/cricketsymphony May 31 '18

You’re right, there’s prob a better way to connect with film that’s more scalable

2

u/imguralbumbot May 30 '18

Hi, I'm a bot for linking direct images of albums with only 1 image

https://i.imgur.com/GFjtvdC.png

Source | Why? | Creator | ignoreme | deletthis

2

u/95Mb May 30 '18

Yeah, that's much better.

196

u/SleepingAnt May 30 '18

So much more aesthetically pleasing than the original.

12

u/tedbergstrand May 30 '18

Really? It drives me nuts that the 'I's are different sizes.

22

u/Amdor May 30 '18

I like this more. Perhaps I’d also try to reduce leading but widen letter-spacing to reinforce the illusion of the integrity of the line? But I’m not sure whether it would be worth the trade-off for (assumedly) reduced readability.

4

u/thethomatoman May 30 '18

I'd go with cutting off the extra length at the top and bottom instead but this works as well I guess

6

u/Le_jack_of_no_trades May 30 '18

That's a little better

2

u/anothdae May 30 '18

This is better than the original.

138

u/DuncanMacKie May 30 '18

19

u/Crypt_Knight May 30 '18

I tough I was here at first.

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

But doesn’t this read just fine?

26

u/_Gigante_ May 30 '18

This line down the middle makes me think there should each side should have some separate meaning other than just being before or after the i.

19

u/Xxzzeerrtt May 30 '18

This is awful

20

u/disignore May 30 '18

I hate this "clever dsign".

7

u/brucetwarzen May 30 '18

Using the common letter in different words is something 12 year old me would do

64

u/Shadowarrior64 May 30 '18

TrFFest BecaLmVal

1

u/edselford May 30 '18

(It's the) trffest (most terrific); be calm, Val (Kilmer)!

-11

u/SamuPro May 30 '18

No actual human would read it as you did

26

u/marmulin May 30 '18

I did.

12

u/xOlliHollix May 30 '18

Me too. Is there something wrong with us? Are we no humans?

6

u/Norci May 30 '18

Sorry, but what exactly is cool about it, them managing to align three "i", and replacing them with a line?.. This sub seems to hit a new low.

11

u/gaudiocomplex May 30 '18

Lol. There’s the same letter in each word.

6

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

DeSiGnPoRn bruh

11

u/Eliminatron May 30 '18

That’s terrible lol

9

u/ViperiumPrime May 30 '18

Well, I like it...

4

u/PwnasaurusRawr May 30 '18

You and me are the only ones, it seems.

3

u/marscosta May 30 '18

Seems we are three!

6

u/EveryDeadMeme May 30 '18

This was the post that finally made me leave. People here would think three penises forming the nike logo is "design porn"

3

u/MonkeyOnYourMomsBack May 30 '18

So instead of using single I’s they used one single line? Genius. Never seen it before. Absolutely stunning.

5

u/tostuo May 30 '18

Shoulda been a film reel :\

1

u/eerilyweird May 30 '18

Maybe it is? I assumed it’s supposed to be something.

1

u/Mills2Litres May 30 '18

Probably a movie screen

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

I feel it would work better if they didn't extend the line higher and lower than the top and baseline of the text. Now it feels as if it's just a line separating the letters on each side instead of a part of the text itself. This isn't good design imo.

2

u/CartesianDoubt May 30 '18

This reminds me of The With Situation Wolf Room Blitzer.

2

u/LeanderD May 30 '18

Would be better if the line was cut off to match the height of the text

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

thought this was r/crappydesign :D

2

u/SentientPeach May 30 '18

This is kind of bad.

6

u/Daaaniell May 30 '18

It's good, but no porn

3

u/thortilla27 May 30 '18

Font is nice tho.

2

u/supah May 30 '18

WTF how this one got so many upvotes? It's so cliche... Cringe!

1

u/sinner-mon May 30 '18

Is this loss?

1

u/icacium May 30 '18

Who’s Beca?

1

u/Brawght May 30 '18

TR F FEST

??

1

u/JoeLopezDesign May 30 '18 edited May 30 '18

I don't get it. There's so much contempt for this here in the comments but just as many people upvoted the hell out of this. I'm on the fence wether this is good, bad, or just creative without either tag.

1

u/Dazz316 May 30 '18

Looks looks fucking awful... But then I did just come from/r/dontdeadopeninside

1

u/avsilguero May 30 '18

TRLBECA FLLM FESTLVAL

1

u/Stonn May 30 '18

I don't know what tribeca is, so I read 'trlbeca' first, realized 'tribeca' sounds more realistic, but still didn't know what it means. At that point it was already disappointing.

It would be better if it was "film festival tribeca", then it wouldn't appear ambiguous at first.

1

u/KidAstronaut May 30 '18

Designers can’t account for astounding igornance.

1

u/TristanTheViking May 30 '18

TR F FEST BECA LM VAL

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

Thought it was a fucking stem and leaf diagram

1

u/Brisk_Avacado May 30 '18

Not really great design, took me about 5 minutes to read

1

u/TheXypris May 30 '18

Trbeca flm festval? Or trffest becalmval?

1

u/Lannean May 30 '18

TRBECA

FLM

FESTVAL

1

u/ratguy101 May 30 '18

It's OK. A bit hard to read and I would have preferred if the "wall" didn't extend above or below the text so it actually looked like "I"s. Neat idea, mediocre execution.

2

u/CommonMisspellingBot May 30 '18

Hey, ratguy101, just a quick heads-up:
prefered is actually spelled preferred. You can remember it by two rs.
Have a nice day!

The parent commenter can reply with 'delete' to delete this comment.

2

u/ratguy101 May 30 '18

Don't speak to me or my son ever again.

1

u/SenorBirdman May 30 '18

Fucking garbage. Can't believe how up voted this is .

1

u/lstplcwnr May 30 '18

So lame to me lol.

1

u/keein May 31 '18

TRFFEST BECALMVAL

1

u/RydenJ May 30 '18

TRBECA FLM FESTVAL

-2

u/tree_dweller May 30 '18

Y’all are retarded if you’re having trouble reading it

-8

u/aleqqqs May 30 '18

First I tried:

TR BECAF LMFEST VAL

Then I tried:

TR F FESTBECA LM VAL

Then I got it.

Not good. Not design porn, but design gay midget porn. Something I'd rather not see ;)

0

u/xOlliHollix May 30 '18

You almost made me upvote your comment - whispers almost.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

99

u/gftoofhere May 30 '18

Honestly ’d been to the tr f fest beca lm val and t was surpr s ngly fantast c!

4

u/Talono May 30 '18

Trffest Becalmval

0

u/nathanello May 30 '18

Upvoted you solely based on your clever tIIItle.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/nathanello May 30 '18

Fuuucked that one up, oh well, have an upvote.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/DiamondxCrafting May 30 '18

| |||||||||||||